Samsung Galaxy S5 vs HTC One (M8)

[@AndroidAuthority]

*HTC One (M8) vs Samsung Galaxy S5* Full comparison: goo.gl/tHuod8 Here’s our look at the HTC One (M8) vs Samsung Galaxy S5! By *****

[@robwisz8415]

FIRST. Before the troll posts start running amuck.

[@BillyJacobKandah]

In before the Samsung fanboys, Oops too late!  lol

[@MikeEmery]

Third baby!!!!! Lol

[@robwisz8415]

***** LOL, yep. And the HTC Fanboys! "blah, blah, blah, blah, blah... ask the internet.

[@ijazmohammed]

I'll start, Samsung sucks. :-P

[@Billy-e9x]

9:48 Lags?! On the Samsung Galaxy S5???

[@GuillaumeSerrurier]

huh it's touchwizz, what did you expect !

[@MrHippoda]

Yeah, both phone use the same CPU/GPU, but the S5 has a little bit higher clockrate (doesn't make it much faster). However, the S5 has an awful optimised OS and therefore, it starts to lag every now and then. Have the same issues with my Xperia S. Awful optimised= lag every now and then.

[@bramheesenarmwrestling]

dude Touchwiz sucks, Samsung should make it way less colorful.

[@zdawg3579]

That's not lag. The operating system isn't as "snappy" it isn't lag. I own the Galaxy s3 and after two years it's just now starting to lag, however, I'm getting the GS5 because although people hate on Touchwiz the S5 is a hell of a lot faster. Touchwiz actually works well, it just matters how much strain you put on the phone, but the S5 seems to have fixed that by trimming back features making it work better all around.

[@GuillaumeSerrurier]

Zachary Fox have you considered the nexus 5 or the moto G ?

[@venkypandu]

HTC One M8 for build quality .. Samsung Galaxy S5 for camera, waterproofing.. Sony Xperia Z2 for both ! :D

[@TnoBambino]

i have the HTC One M8, its all around great. Amazing sound quality, great display, beautiful and stylish build quality, very very fast processor and also a great camera. Just because it says 4 ultra pixels doesn't mean its bad, it takes very nice shots and takes the shots very quickly. The biggest wow factor to me about the phone is the battery life. As long as your not watching constant videos or listening to music through the boom speakers through the phone. it will last you for a very long time. Of course listening to music through the phones speakers will deplete the battery quicker in any phone, but having two beast speakers will definitely run it down quicker. i switched from the iPhone 5, to the galaxy S4 and then switched to the M8. The M8 is my favorite. I am looking forward to the HTC One's lineup coming in the upcoming years. They are great great phones. If i ever want to switch to Samsung's galaxy lineup, it'd have to be next years model, they barely changed ANYTHING on this S5. And if i ever switched back to Apple, they better make the screen much bigger, better battery life and also make the camera at least 16 mega pixels. The HTC One M8 is the best phone on the market right now, and if your going to complain about how bad the camera is, (which it isn't even bad). Go buy a cannon camera. Nobody will ever get a real photography type shot on a phone. HTC FOR THE WIN. M8>S5

[@breeze810]

I got the S5 on release and the plastic built doesn't bother me because 99.9% of the time I put otterbox cases on all of my phones...

[@ItzSofaKing]

lol otterbox

[@Spongegoose]

Chose the HTC One M8, and I'm loving it.

[@TheEverythingMan]

Gold M8 ! love my new phone ... the camera is not bad AT ALL . if people didnt know it was 4ultra pixel i bet alot of people wouldnt complain... its a placebo . yes the quality gets slightly grainy when zooming in but unless your taking pics and blowing them up for posters or picture frames (which why would you do that with a camera phone) it takes really clear pics. so far i have to say its the best phone ever made. the LG G3 and Nexus 6 might have something to say about that but they arent out yet so.. yeah ... love it

[@jawbonedoc]

Returned my M8. Got my s5. Today. Much happier with the s5

[@redgrafia]

I would get the M8 had it improved its camera. Its 4 ultra pix cam is a deal breaker. C'mon HTC. Camera is a selling point.

[@TerraRiley]

That's the detail I'm stuck on as well... So you're going to go with the s5?

[@redgrafia]

Terra Riley yes. S5 wins this time.

[@josetirado81]

i beg to differ. i don't care for the cameras. i look for performance, software and looks. The s5 looks somewhat ugly and unappealing. the htc m8 isn't plastic and looks amazing which is a big win also the front facing speakers and amazing audio is the selling point for me on the htc m8 since im a big fan of music. htc sense is also in my opinion is easier to use than touch wize. it pretty much all comes down to what you prefer in a phone. cameras are not that big of a selling point so htc doesn't bother with it to much.

[@redgrafia]

Jose Tirado then I guess it all boils down to user preference. Dont hold it against me if I consider cam quality as the main selling point because I love photography. S5's camera blows HTC's out of the water. Besides, performance wise, S5 is a beast. I dont really care about touchwiz or sense because im going to use a different launcher anyway, say Apex or Nova.

[@redgrafia]

Jose Tirado and the looks doesn't matter. I'd choose functionality over aesthetics. HTC might be beautifully designed but it's not as water resistant as S5. And besides, there are a lot of cases and other accessories for the S5 out there to solve that issue of design.

[@zeliph]

I can imagine the heart rate feature in the S5 would have devs take advantage of that sort of feature in such apps like a lie-detector, stress relieving app, or some kind of immersive horror game. Possibilities are endless with that cool feature.

[@RadSel8]

How many apps do you expect to be made ONLY for that one phone?

[@zeliph]

7 :]

[@aprilshowers3008]

Considering its the most popular android phone (by far) I'd expect a lot

[@Masterincommander]

HTC build quality, Samsung EVERYTHING else i like 16megapixels not 4 LOL

[@BlarshNarsh]

It's ultra pixels not mega, there is a difference. Ultra pixels let in more light and are bigger than megapixels

[@ProexProduction]

BlarshNarsh Yet the S5 still produces nicer photos...

[@aruanboggy]

"Samsung EVERYTHING else". :)) They're both Android smartphones that can do the same things and satisfy the average user. You are such a pansy.

[@danield6042]

BlarshNarsh Ultra pixels is just something that HTC likes to call. Yes they do take more light but it's still going to look ugly if you put it as a wallpaper on your laptop or just show it to someone on your smarrTV.

[@akku5786]

The only thing I personally like about the htc is the looks a speakers, other than that samsung wins (my opinion)

[@AnarchyRazerX]

HTC One M8: A Phone Michelangelo Would Envy....Work Of Art!

[@Seandude05]

Who's Michael Angelo? And why would he care?

[@bhagbir510]

Seandude05 omg nobody should answer this guys question. Lol

[@Seandude05]

bhagbir510 lol exactly

[@jazz3j3211]

Seandude05 * Michelangelo..

[@jazz3j3211]

Seandude05 * Michelangelo..

[@ameyak7771]

I'm definitely going with the HTC One M8

[@AqibQadeer]

can you do a three way comparison between gs5 and one m8 and xperia z2

[@22s22a]

I think people are really overhyping this metal built phone argument, why wouldn't you want the option to replace your battery with a removable back?? If your battery becomes damaged with a metal phone you can't simply switch it out. Also what would you do if your phone dies and your nowhere near a charger?? Its okay because atleast your phone will be metal and more likely to slip out of your hand and get damaged regardless. Thats what cases are for, you need one to protect you device!

[@Sean3RA]

You can carry a portable power pack that will charge any phone, not just the one. Metal phones are more resilient and break far less than plastic. It's not overhyped, it's been proven with basically every durability test ever. Both phones rate bad for slip though. I wish they had some kind of grip.

[@Nam3Iess]

Sean3RA Like bendgate right?

[@henchdan1]

Great unbiased review!

[@NigelKing94]

I got the HTC One M8 today. Here's why I chose it over the S5 (it was a tough choice): What's the #1 necessity in a phone? ACCESSIBILITY Samsung has wowed me with their extensive features. It shows me they really want a device that everyone can tailor to their specific needs. On the other hand, that can be very time consuming and a bit difficult to master. HTC took a totally opposite approach and designed a phone that is a bit more limited but everything is easy to access. From the settings to the camera, to the motion gestures. Samsung is a great device for those who want EVERYTHING out of their phone. You won't lose with that phone, but HTC won me over with their ease of access to what I want. Design nor sound really factored into my decision. And honestly, testing out the camera, it's really nice. HTC went for making sure you capture the shot, not necessarily the greatest shot. But let's be honest, both devices are better than iPhones and that's the real competition lol.

[@mellothecloud]

Your right #andriod

[@mirrorlessmemory]

Nice! You should make your own video review lol but your reasons are similar to mine. I got My too

[@Windoge11]

Oh my god......This the new rivalry now...

[@kiezpirat80]

Watched this on my m8, love it.

[@squirreldog1596]

Word.

[@Deveal2014]

I got the M8 & it's a beast. Very impressed with the device

[@Neno8403]

It's scary how many people continue to badly and ignorantly confuse "looks" with "build quality." For all you HTC fantards and iSheep, please let us know how you're enjoying the cheap plastic cases you all have to throw on your metal turds, to keep them from denting, scratching, and scuffing. Until an HTC One or iPhone can be regularly used without a case, the "build quality" goes to the durable polycarbonate plastics used on Samsung devices.

[@Rosalina102798]

Yep... Maybe?

[@Rosalina102798]

Performance-wide, the HTC One just barely beats the S5. However, I will admit that the S5 is one hell of a "fun" device to use.

[@1983Jacko]

Dude, I bet your S5 is in a case too, because I have news for you, the S5 scratches as well. And if you plan to resell it you better keep it in a case.

[@fxvc0911]

Khemistry Samsung fanboy detected! Pendejo !

[@Sensei_Leo]

Im an isheep because i have an iphone? that is quite cute and i dont have a case, i take care of my device good enough.

[@jamescrosser1958]

Your video was so beautifully detailed and in-depth this helped me alot with picking between these two! Thanx bud.

[@cristinayang0818]

Which one did you choose and why?

[@danield6042]

I would choose S5 over the HTC. In my particular case a better camera, fingerprint scanner, waterproof resistant, swappable battery, download booster, better multitasking will always win over a better build quality(i use a case anyway) simplicity (I would have stayed with iPhone), and better sound speakers(nothing to comment about that ).

[@18ncarbonara]

I absolutely agree. I might take a Iphone 5s over the M8 because of how simple it is. However, I could care less about simplicity and more about features.

[@adeizayusuf]

Beautiful review and comparison of both flagship , I've always been a fan of HTC but decided to go for the note 3 early this year and despite the 3gig ram I still experience the lag from the over bloated touchwiz. Writing this comment from my HTC ONE M8 and am loving it all the way. Sense is smooth n fast . If you are a serious user,I will advice you go for the M8.

[@TheMoises1213]

I'm a Galaxy fan but that HTC One M8 speakers are amazing but why the camera! A freaking beautiful phone with a suckish camera.

[@VJayzzzHD]

Same, everything looks very appealing in the m8 and I was just very skeptical about it being 4 megapixel. This video confirmed that the s5 is just better. I think a good upgrade from a S3. But that back cover of the M8 looks great but hey I can get a case for the S5.

[@TheMoises1213]

VJayzzzHD true i went from an s to an s3 to the s4 to the iPhone 5s. Now since I'm choosing another phone, I don't think the galaxy s5 is worth my time. I guess I'll choose the HTC One M8 and hold that down to see if the iphone 6 or the galaxy note 4 is better

[@graemeverelst8849]

The htc one doesn't have SUCH a bad camera, think of the iPhone 5

[@adeizayusuf]

TheMoises1213 good choice and u won't regret it.

[@adeizayusuf]

TheMoises1213 good choice and u won't regret it.

[@MsMonster128]

9:18 wait,whats that wtf lol what's the more accurate color the m8 or the s5?

[@warhawk4431]

This is one of the hardest choices ever. I love the style and simplicity of the One as well as its media capabilities, but I love the S5 for the camera and multitasking abilities. God dammit.

[@SilverHunkClover]

they are both good phones. Me too cant decide what to buy

[@muller_509]

Let me help you. CHOOSE THE M8!!!

[@SilverHunkClover]

why?

[@eliseimateiciuc6184]

Is funny cuz if you want to take picture at a pro level you will go for a nikon or so , the smartphones are suppose to give you an average camera than can take good shoots, how HTC does it,by the way.I recommand when you choose a phone chose it for every day experience not just for some silly features that your not going to use them after one week.

[@BryanXD09]

Well just think about it. Your not going to ALWAYS use the camera. And your not ALWAYS going to use the multiwindow feature. one thing you always will have to live with though is the hardware. And it's blatantly obvious that HTC has the superior design. Also an update in camera and the multiwindow feature is something HTC can add with a software update. The ugly design and terrible speakers of the Samsung can never change. I would say to go with the M8, I know I am.

[@teotsi21]

pause right at 0:35. Why the hell are these lines on top of the keys of the S5? They are completely anti-climatic.

[@15heartz]

S5

[@louied5343]

Does anyone know what game he is playing at 3:16??? Thanks!

[@dazvaz144]

duo camera over a standard 8mp camera or 13mp camera AND "black bar" keep it a second pick to the S5 (not to mention the non-removable battery). honestly, i'd rather have the M7 with OIS and a smaller overall frame. i know, i know, I KNOW! megapixels aren't everything, but being able to zoom and crop/edit larger megapixel photos makes a difference. and the S4 and S5 have killer cameras.

[@Big1unna]

Hi Android Authority I watch your videos every day Im 15 and i recently subscribed to your flip board news and i find your videos really informative keep it up.

[@iliksor]

Don't know why but I am just not a fan of Samsung, I think the s5 is ugly and the software isn't very appealing either to me. I would take the M8 any day, and can't understand why it's camera is copping such a beating, I have used it and though it looked far better than it had been credited

[@justtoogood78]

What is your opinion of sealed phones vs phones with removable and upgradeable batteries? I had a sealed phone for 2+ years and the battery would only hold a charge for about 4hrs towards the end I don't think I would ever buy another sealed phone for myself. ......thoughts?

[@MrPixelHelper]

I would still pick Samsung S5 over HTC (M8). I even like HTC more than Samsung though?

[@MetalGearKS]

Great review, very in depth and not biased at all, helped me make the choice between the two

[@MisbahAlKhadem]

I'd rather spend my money on a well engineered piece of hardware rather than a cheap of plastic. I had the One X, the One, and soon, am getting the One M8

[@Tweakey]

If you say so.

[@MagicalGalaxies112]

You''re saying a metal has well engineered piece of hardware while plastic is nothing.

[@thefeithfuly]

I'd rather spend my money for buy a great smartphone which has 16 mp camera , not just a fucking 4MP

[@michaelk487]

I just bought the HTC One how do I get the most of the video and camera

[@jazz3j3211]

I found the anti shake to be really useful and manual presets( play with manual settings according to your taste).

[@michaelk487]

Ok

[@jazz3j3211]

P.s. buy the ultimate shield wrap, it's comes with the camera lens cover for both main/duo sensor, carry microfiber cloth, camera Smudges easily.

[@Keiseru]

Set contrast and saturation to +0.5 or +1. Set sharpness to -1. Best video experience is 720p 60fps (FHD). Dont use anti-shake, you don't need it - since the camera takes less shaky photos than its rivals due to the bigger sensor (faster capture). In the auto mode set EV to -1 to make the picture seem normal instead of overexposed. That's about it. It's a great camera but the original settings suck. The only thing samsung beats it on is resolution after you've tuned it.

[@Putt-Putt]

For me, I'll take the M8. It beats out the S5 in every department (Speakers, Software, Build Quality, etc) except for the camera as the S5 performs better in that area but the camera on the M8's camera is not poor by any stretch of the imagination, its just a level lower than the S5.

[@MagicalGalaxies112]

Speakers isn't even a part of the comparison.And S5 wins M8 in the specs.Build quality,either it's metal or cheap plastic,there are pros and cons for both material,so it is a draw.Both devices are good in software.So overall,it's pretty much a draw between S5 and M8.

[@Putt-Putt]

MaskedGuy112 The specs are basically the same. Build quality is obviously where the M8 shines. At the same time, it's also based on preferences. Same as the software but Sense 6 is more towards simplicity and stock android so I'm guessing more people are aiming for that kind of experience IMO.

[@MagicalGalaxies112]

Panwagan Metal Pros:Build Quality,Durability,Feel Cons:Reception,Chipping,Temperature Plastic:Vice versa. But of course metal is obviously better than plastic.

[@azraphael6619]

I'm still confused which one to go for? I have the Galaxy S3 now and due for upgrade in August, I've found the S3 has poor build quality and lags heavily through most multitasking. I like the build of the M8, the screen, camera and battery on the Z2 and then there's the familiarity of the S5. Or do I just wait for the new nexus just to be disappointed by specs?

[@CrazyRoby81]

HTC Stainless Steel!!!!! Samsung fucked Plastic!!!! GOOOO HTC!!!!

[@VoodooMadMike41]

Fucked plastic that survives being ran over by a SUV and protecting the screen from cracking... Interesting, tell me more.

[@zoro2266]

Htc m8 sucks , fuckin on screen buttons, big ass chin only thing good about is metal that's fucking it! Samsung is the superior phone

[@Whatwhatwhat1]

I don't understand why people are so obsessed with metal back. Once they put a cover on, you can't even see or feel the back at all. Both devices are premium and you cannot go wrong with either one. It comes down to brand loyalty, personal preference, interchangeable battery, metal, camera and etc.

[@MagicalGalaxies112]

People are stubborn.Because of the metal back and not willing to put a case on their phone.

[@raydn23]

The S5 is just a hideous looking phone lol. Besides the camera I don't see why you'd choose it over the htc phone.

[@nirvanrungen]

hey...Android Authority, your voice sounds exactly like the one of the guy behind the XboxAhoy channel. Either you own the other channel or your voice sounds just like the other dude...either way it's awesome

[@mastika213]

really hard choice but the htc one camera just pushes me away.I would of bought htc one if it had a better camera but looks like i will place my order on samsung

[@umerchaudary2995]

Smoothness in software is something that can't be compromised.. So htc m8 is ahead in this battle..

[@JustVaguee]

I was going to upgrade my Samsung Galaxy S3 to the GS5 but i think i will wait for the LG G3.

[@JustVaguee]

Also the Oppo Find 7 and "Maybe" the iPhone 6.

[@cilopez155]

LG G3 good Choice

[@steevemccloud5841]

Take a look at the LG G Flex or the LG G Pro 2. They are two very good phones. I have the G Flex. I switched from iPhone to Android it I am very happy that I did with this phone. I suggest you take a look.

[@gnexus75]

Leo Tanzi LG makes some excellent handsets with superior hardware but what they lack in imo is design and a bit of build quality feel. Great phones nonetheless.

[@18ncarbonara]

I think the HTC One M8 can be seen as almost the "Iphone" of android, while the S5 sacrifices style and simplicity for features. I personally like the huge amount of features for the S5.

[@kiranmudnaney]

The more I see the m8, the more I feel like getting one.. Can't wait till it launches in India.. S5, just outta the race with that bandaid back cover n that horrible UI..

[@Juanchih]

Hey guys whats the game that he is playing at 3:21 ?

[@Eihabss]

Same question...

[@naeemmartin6164]

I'm gonna go for the HTC 1M8 because of build quality, sound & overall performance. The camera looks a bit better on the GS5 I won't lie, but at the end of the day the phone for you (no matter who you are) is the phone that requires things you'll be using on a daily basis & personal likes. This is the reality so just choose what "YOU" like & FUCK what people think. It's that simple :)

[@iAdrianT]

"the camera looks a bit better on the GS5" A bit? LOL

[@lukaskuipers7791]

+Mircea Marius well yea a bit.

[@LJImutan]

As a Mac user and an iOS user for 7 years, the HTC One M8 was the first Android to get me out of iOS... My friends and family do not know me anymore.

[@coke1011]

M8 is a far cry from it's predecessor, the M7. Don't be fooled by it's 90% aluminum construction or it's duo camera. First off, the camera on the phone can't even get the job done better than it's competition with TWO lenses; really? and the trade-off was OIS? Hell fuckin NO. & don't tell me I have to see this phone in person, because I have when I visited my local verizon store to see how it felt. FYI: it's slippery as hell. solution? wear a case. result? plastic or rubber. Ideal for a 'beautiful' phone? Not really. And why is the phone so awkwardly tall ? HTC hyped up this phone way more than it deserves; and it's pretty sad because they'd say anything to sway consumers in their struggle to survive against tech giants like apple or samsung. good luck to you HTC, but the m8 just isn't the answer.

[@theprophet1474]

So true

[@dcukic]

hahahah you just made my day! i laughed so hard! did you practice saying this comment in front of a mirror? hahahaha funny little kid thinks he insulted me. try again please

[@kulla3014]

Please can u tell me what is dual 4 camera in HTC One M8 ? I dont understand.

[@charlesverg2184]

This guy always kisses HTC's ass and always has something to complain about Galaxy:p The galaxy s5 has a way better camera, air gestures, multitasking apps in one screen, better durability, more colorful screen, and just so MANY MORE features, all the htc has is better design, speakers, and is a little faster, I mean that's great but few compared to the gs5.

[@ponketon]

Bla bla bla bla.....

[@sylinic6081]

Now please tell me, how many times did you actually USE the shit ton of features in S5? I don't see a point of having the heartbeat monitor in there, since most of the samsung users are 16 year old teenage girls who use the phone just for FB and selfies..

[@Urbansquealer]

Henry Kimmer ***** Many of the features are actually useful, and aren't as gimmicky as they were in the s4. Now... given that you limit those features to what the M8 has (which actually isn't removing very much), then you'll find that both of these phones are still virtually the same. So similar, in fact, that the last couple lines of Carlos Valenzuela's argument would actually stand true. I can't ever see when the speed would really matter though... but I would like to see the Samsung improve in that department. I'm just saying that it's not like you'll ever be skulking around, looking for some guy to be eyeballing your phone load up the camera .5 seconds behind his, only to cry about it later at night. Unless that kind of thing (a phone being faster) makes you orgasm in your sleep, then it shouldn't be something that blows one phone out of the water in comparison, or makes you choose one over the other. Design is also a bit of a sketchy argument. It's like saying that my metal door is better than your wooden door... They both do the same exact thing. The only difference, though, is that the change in material on a phone doesn't add to durability... Bottom line, it's up to you as a consumer. Do you like buttery smoothness, or cool features? Do you want better sound, or a better camera? There's really no reason either should be deemed "better" than the other...

[@sylinic6081]

Yeah, features, as if a lot of people actually use the heartbeat monitor, the finger print scanner is also a failure.

[@Urbansquealer]

***** Henry Kimmer Many of them are useful, though.. It's obvious that you two either don't know a lot of them, or are just saying that in hopes that people don't notice how good many of them are. (I'm not talking about gimmicky ones like the baby cry detector, or the heartbeat sensor.) And I don't have much trouble with the fingerprint scanner. It gets me to my home screen faster, and that's why I like it.

[@fifdude93]

I have the Samsung gear fit will it still be compatible with the M8 if I were to swap out my S4??

[@meAmong313]

Multitasking , camera , battery , better processor , better colours are features of samsung , while htc got good speakers with shit camera and less battery with non removable cover , Samsung wins

[@dimosk7389]

same processor. for some reason in US the M8 is 2,3 while in Europe its 2.5 fake colors from the S5, its like watching a cartoon camera of M8 is very good for what it is, a phone camera. and great for dark places. battery life is equal or better on the M8, but if you need more than 1 battery through the day, yes S5 will suit you better in the end, they are both equally fast, and its up to personal taste.

[@meAmong313]

dimos k stop lying and spreading disinformation s5 got better specs in america 2 it's processor is clocked at 2.5 ghz while htc's is 2.3 ghz s5 got 2800 mah batter while htc got 2600mah battery by the way galaxy s4 had 2600 mah battery last year galaxy s5 got 4times better camera than htc . but due to ultra pixels htc camera performs better in low light samsung got fingerprint scanner , heart rate monitor and thermometer . htc got nothing like that i probable will never use these things but i will still like to have these things just to show off. and yes amsung got amazing colours that punch you in the face .. dont like it ? ok then go into settings / display and change the mode of display to less saturation . done .. your phone's display is now ready to look as boring as htc's display enjoy your phone ;)

[@dimosk7389]

meAmong313 htc is clocked at 2.5 in Europe, i dont know why they do it 2,3 in US. S5 has more mAh battery because all this bloatware requires more battery. but in the end, htc lasts the same, or better because it doesnt have as much crap running in the background fingerprint and heart rate are useless on a phone, except for showoff. btw, its fingerprint scanner has already be hacked, so not much of a security boost there. if you like bloatware that lags your phone, then go for the S5 like most people will thanks to advertisement. if you want REAL quality on your device, light and fast OS and features that actually make a difference, like the boomsound, you get the ONE.

[@kfurjan]

And Samsung at least put something new in the GS5 (like fingerprint scener, heart rate sensor and IP67). What did HTC put new in M8? It is M7 with hardware upgrade.

[@meAmong313]

dimos k nah man when you need that clean fast and pure experience then you get nexus ... no bloody htc with 4 megapixels camera ? crap... 4 megapixel camera ? i can beleive this shit... my bloody 3 year old nokia x6 had better camera man... xperia 10 .... 3 years old phone had 8 megapixel at that time

[@vashawnbrown4258]

What phone do you have now

[@o0mrrobot0o26]

They're both slick phones. The S5 clearly has a better camera but the M8 has amazing speakers. I'm gonna hold out for the Note 4 because that's actually Samsung's flagship phone not the S5. Hopefully it will have a 2k screen to compete with the oppo find 7

[@msan108]

the note is a flagship but its not the main flagship.....Samsung still states is s series is its main flagship....the note was meant to compete for the attention a business/ phablet orientated erson......the s line is for the common mjority, everyday average consumer

[@o0mrrobot0o26]

techmaster that being said, I still prefer the Note line because that's where Samsung usually puts their high end chipsets in. The Note 3 came a little bit after the S4 and had the snapdragon 800 and 3 gigs of Ram to the S4's Snapdragon 600 and 2 gigs of ram. Not to mention pressure sensitive stylus support and 4k recording neither present on the S4. I'm a spec whore and business owner so it suits me better but everyone had their own preference.

[@msan108]

Ed Irizarry its due to the notes later release cycle that puts ahead of new chipsets, with the expectation of the latest cpu....however next year thats gonna change cause u have the snapdragon 808 and the 810 coming out and both are 64bit hexa core and octacore cpu configurations requiring 4 gigs of ram for top performance....so whether u get the s6 or note 5 it wouldn't matter because both chpsets are worlds beyond the 801/805

[@msan108]

***** Noooo.....For allot people its Camera>Speakers...Especially for those who use earbuds or headphones. Especially high end ones like Sony, Sanheiser, Bose, Harmon Kardon etc....I would say beats but they are just overpriced bull. Its personal preference and opinion not fact,

[@arealscorpio1]

Awesome review! I'm sticking with upgrading to the S5.

[@quadred4135]

I give up...... I am buying two phone :P

[@quadred4135]

well apparently i just bought an M8 and its awesome i aint going for S5 :)

[@ob882]

Bazaid Khan slippery?

[@quadred4135]

well this comment is long time ago but now i have the m8 its a pretty awesome phone

[@ob882]

so its not slippery?

[@quadred4135]

yeah it is quite slippery but i have a grip case on so its fine

[@LacedBacon]

I just upgraded from an Iphone 4s and the difference is huge, I really like the Galaxy it has a ton of cool features that I was not aware of before.

[@racea.t6531]

Ill go with the S5! 👍

[@aintnosaint93]

Android Authority ***** what is the game u play at 3:19? on HTC One M8

[@NeonMotion23]

getting my htc one m8 next week! selling my s3 soon

[@tashtean]

If i get problem with battery in htc then how i can get new battery while its non removable?

[@fastestman9977]

I want the HTC One M9

[@Just1nCredibl3]

Josh what is your preference? Just a curious question I want to hear reviewers opinion on why you chose yours.

[@bboyloco3]

There is obviously a clear winner here and I still don't know why people are denying it, The HTC M8 wins. The disgusting design of the s5 is the same old shit from last year mixed with the note 2 plus the really ugly bandaid back. The specs of the s5 can't make up for the ugliness. The HTC M8 is full of innovations, first from the design, the front speakers, and the dual camera. Even though the camera is 4 megapixels the dual camera is a innovation which other phones will soon adopt. So samsung fan boys stop being in such denial.

[@bboyloco3]

Roman Yelisyeyev the first everything is always not prefect, can you imagine having a 16 megapixels camera then another 4 megapixel on top for low light? Its an amazing innovation. Phones will adopt this dual camera.

[@Stvnrulz]

"The specs on the s5 can't make up for ugliness." Get a grip. Look up the spigen slim armor case in white. That takes a shit all over your overrated metal elephant phone.

[@Nam3Iess]

Tom jo I like how htc ditched the dual camera in the M9 XD

[@LeGeNdArYxx24l7]

I can tell you why the m8 is a lot better. First, the build quality is more appealing and comfortable. The headphone jack on the bottom and micro SD card slot are a nice touch. Next the FRONT facing speakers blow the s5's out of the water from my experience with both. The complete audio experience HTC has provided is the best on a mobile device! For the camera, the m8 suits what I use it for. The front facing camera is surprisingly great. The rear camera is simply better in all low-light pictures. The two-tone flash allows for more realistic shots. Having stereo microphones is way better than a mono microphone. Also, the UI and photo editor is more simple and really nice. Did I forget to mention the m8 has the fastest focus of any phone that I have ever used. Yes the s5 takes better daylight shots. There is more detail and contrast with bright lighting. They both are really exceptional cameras but I prefer HTC's approach. I upload photos on twitter and instagram and with the ufocus effect, the pics look really good. I cannot remember the last time I put a photo on my PC. Another aspect that is better is the software. Sense 6 is more snappy and responsive than touchwiz. I have yet to find a slowdown in Sense but with touchwiz I encountered lag with my magazine and switching between apps (mostly with games). The motion launch gestures are something that I use all the time. I use blinkfeed for my news consumption while my magazine is laggy at times. This comment was made to state why the HTC m8 is better than the Samsung Galaxy S5 and not to bash Samsung. I really do enjoy using both phones. Samsung has somethings going for it like it being water-resistant (I wish a lot more phones were), the download booster, removable battery even though I never had to swap batteries, the finger print scanner, and durability of the phone. What both phones are pretty much equal in are the battery life with enhancements to last longer and the displays of each phone. I can barely tell a difference between the two. If anyone is considering a new phone, the m8 should be the first one to look at.

[@Neno8403]

You know we're in the age of butt hurt fanboys when you have reviewers and Joe Schmoe's, complaining about actually HAVING features on your phone! Imagine buying a Mercedes and complaining that you had LED headlights, navigation, radar cruise control, blind spot monitoring, a moonroof, leather interior, a V12, and autonomous driving capabilities, compared to having none of those things on your Hyundai... oh, and the Hyundai also costs as much as the Mercedes, to boot! Where they do that at? Who complains about having features lol? Fantards, I swear! Don't understand why people are so upset the Samsung is better. Because it isn't made of dentable/scratchable metal??

[@davehugstrees]

Being overloaded with features and not having the hardware to keep up can result in lag during normal use, like you see on the S5. I would rather have a phone that does a few things well, rather than a lot of things poorly.

[@Forestamp2024]

davehugstrees Lag is not problem on s5,it is better then htc in all aspects,only thing that on htc is better are front speakers(but at the end i almost never use speakers,only for games,but for music iam using earphones and the other staff,if you want to use speakers in loud environment bunch of speakers wont help you),i wont say build material cause i like s5 material,and my phone is in cover!My opinion,that's why i will buy s5!

[@clintonova]

Interesting view Khemistry, re-reading your analogy to cars I believe your associating the S5 to a Mercedes with "all" the features and the M8 to a "Hyundai". If that is correct, I believe you to be mistaken in you analogy of the cars and the phones. There's a reason the phones are made of their materials, do you prefer plastic forks or knives or metals ones when you eat? :) And just fyi here's a little Hyundai fanboy info ya regarding the car analogy. www.autoguide.com/manufacturer/kia/2015-kia-k900-review-3760.html Kia is the sister company and it has all those features you mentiones and it does NOT cost as much as a Mercedes......jus sayin ;)

[@AtHomewithLucas]

I love your words my friend!! You said what I have always been thinking.

[@JoeMikeGent]

Anyone ever heard of phone cases? Lighter phones also help from shattering, you can KZbin search drop tests. Don't matter what its made of, a case completely changes the durability, and in Samsung's case the lighter material actually helps when combined with a case.

[@velkro16]

When it comes to cameras, S5 all the way. It has nothing to do with megapixels. It's just a better camera. More detail, color, quicker autofocus, more camera options, plus you can see what your HDR photos will look like before you take the picture. Build "material" preference is just that, a preference. There's no Samsung is STILL using plastic or HTC is STILL using metal, like someone has to "catch up". The build of the HTC is more attractive to me. The sound on the HTC sounds better than the S5. No refuting that. User interface is a matter of pure opinion. Flat and simplistic is only a modern design choice that has nothing to do with beauty but how modern designers believe it to be. Pick the interface that is most functional and useful to you. The build of the S5 is much more durable. Period. Water resistance should be a standard feature on every phone. I'd take that as a standard before I'd take front facing speakers. Nowadays, your phone gets wet, it's over. It shouldn't have to be that way. HTC wasted too much space on the front to stick their logo. They made the device even taller and put the button on the top. Bad idea. Battery on both sound like they've been good. Have to give it up to Samsung on the extra battery saving mode though, and removable battery is not a necessity but if you travel you'll find the quickest and most cost effective way is to have a fully charge spare. No expensive battery cases making your phone any fatter, no extra cables for external battery packs.

[@DavidAnthony]

I'm a pretty simple guy....so why i would care about "air gestures" or anybody else would is silly to me...for some ppl their phone is their life...for me it's a communication device....call text email pandora....that's it lol....i dont tweet or IG or Vine....so which phone calls people better? lol

[@DavidAnthony]

also if you are serious about taking pictures....BUY A CAMERA. People who are like oh it has a better camera make me laugh....it's a selfie...not a national geographic award winning photo....buy a Nikon.

[@The0gravity101]

***** it's quite clear that u like the HTC one M8 better. I'm not sure which to pick. A phone with a better camera takes better pictures which u can instantly upload them to most social networking sites which a camera can't do (unless u buy an overpriced smart camera). Air gesture also seem pretty pointless to me but it's a cool feature and looks like it has potential.

[@khyoon14]

***** I used to say that ALL THE TIME. You want a good photo buy a camera.

[@TheoriginalBigDaDDy]

Good video Josh keep up the good work.

[@TubinJust22]

Going with the m8, besides the fancy mega pixels and the 4k video. The m8 is a better device. Who is honestly gonna use the phone for professional photography?? Most users use the cell phones for social media/instagram and facebook. The m8 will get the job done. So pay for a better phone and not a better camera

[@robertrusso3268]

Agree!!

[@robertrusso3268]

Agree!!

[@MagicalGalaxies112]

People take their smartphones and capture special moment with their families and relatives,so the picture has to be good and sharp.

[@elisagarcia8555]

MaskedGuy112 for that you'll just buy a pro camera or digital camera, not use your smartphone. It's just a question of commodity and having all in one place, cause the trend these days is to pack a huge amount of different fonctions in one device. But sometimes you just have to realise that smartphones are for media, calling and texting basically. Photography is for cameras.

[@TubinJust22]

Lara Garrex completely agree

[@lordofwar1234]

What is that game you are playing at 3:15

[@mattfox14]

My S5 is coming tomorrow between 10:30am and 2:30pm yay ahha

[@mattfox14]

9535342h :D hope you enjoy it

[@JustVaguee]

9535342h Only thing i like about the iphone 5s is the camera. Enjoy your new phone ^_^

[@ErnestMarvinEsteban]

Enjoy the phone.

[@ErnestMarvinEsteban]

Enjoy the phone.

[@matthewfox4419]

9535342h Mine arrived about a hour ago I can say the camera is absolutely amazing, far greater than my iPhone 5 i'm upgrading from, also the back feels really nice pictures and videos don't do it justice, it's a really nice device.

[@FastFerrari82]

Android Authority I have the HTC EVO4G LTE which was made with an aluminum and plastic body. Being the M8 and possibly the soon to be released "M8 prime"(I think) made of metal, did you notice the phone getting hot? I use a lot of data and sometimes charge while on the phone. Any suggestions, thoughts? Comments? Thanks, nice vids btw.

[@CrispyyyK]

Wish the m8 had a better camera

[@Nam3Iess]

Burton Keys Yep, whoever came up with that fucking bright idea that a flagship should come with a shitty 4MP camera should be fired.

[@platinum_tears]

The camera is the only thing that I dont like in my m8. It was a very dumb idea

[@lukaskuipers7791]

if you want a good camera get a camera

[@lukaskuipers7791]

+Sheila Broflovski If you buy a camera the price of a phone is prolly gonna be hell of a lot better. You either like photography or don't give a shit about it. If you really need it get a camera. Unless you're really into photography the m8 camera will do just about enough.

[@lukaskuipers7791]

+Sheila Broflovski So what, if i can clearly see what's in the picture that's enough for a phone. If you care about taking beutifull pics please just buy a camera.

[@GregBergman]

Great comparison and review! I'm still hoping and waiting for a phone with an S5 camera, M8 speakers, and Droid Maxx battery!

[@TomsGotPowers]

Both great phones, both practically the same more or less. Samsung is really lacking on the design front though, any flagship phone in my mind (I know its been said) should have a metal casing.

[@Neno8403]

The ignorance is thick with you lol.

[@TomsGotPowers]

haha lol... how so?

[@STAR_GUARDIAN_V]

No they shouldn't, and I don't see why. I prefer a plastic construction.

[@TomsGotPowers]

Good for you.

[@Blackt0ast]

I like metal more but platic casing allows you to change batterys easily

[@UmarMunir94]

Everyone wants M8 with G S5 camera.

[@davidcoulter1637]

You guys talking about camera as if your photographers the m8 cam more than efficient. The m8 is the best operating device period. Go buy a cannon. I want the best smart phone not a dumb phone with a good cam

[@svtjon]

+David coulter gs5 is for performance, you have expandable sd and removable battery which allows for battery swapping plus the s5 is water resistance

[@svtjon]

Lukas Kuipers Do you have an s5? Because if you remove the back you have the removable battery, which when you take off/ gives you access to the sim card, and over the sim card slot is indeed the SD card slot. Overall, i cannot goto stock Software as i use Cyanogenmod 12.1. but my phone seemed Hella snappier then the htc one m8. Before you give shit to the S5, please do your research

[@lukaskuipers7791]

+taby448 well yea the it does have an SD, my bad. But i've seen both in action plenty and have concluded that there's no difference in performance. And I have already told you why the s5 is worse IMO.

[@svtjon]

Lukas Kuipers the s5s rear speaker is indeed shit, but the Nexus line isnt an option as i require SD storage for holding all my roms. and i have yet to find an SD card phone with the speaker on the front, the S5 camera is okay but of course thats what buying a camera is for. :p

[@lukaskuipers7791]

taby448 the fucking m8 has all yiu want

[@schlooonginator1227]

Just curious so checked this out. I am/was the owner of the acclaimed M7 and,at first, loved it. This was my first smartphone and I was really impressed with the technology and the capabilities of such a small device. Cell phones sure have advanced. However, my feelings changed when my camera caught the horrible purple bug that plagued this model. Basically, turned my camera into junk. Needless to say I was and still am pissed over that whole abortion. That a tech company could let such a massive mistake slip into production seemed ridiculous. I didn't like how it was handled either with HTC obviously trying to downplay the situation as hordes of customers began seeing this crop up. We were left among ourselves to figure out what to do with rumour and inuendo being the solution. Will there be a software update to fix it? Was it even software? Who really wants to send their phone off to get repaired and have to re install everything? Of course many, including me waited for another solution. Not to mention the horror stories of people being stonewalled by the service department with allegations of "water damage"(what I swear is just a manufacturer loop hole to void warranty) and being given a choice of paying hundreds or ridiculous shipping fees. Bottom line? That experiance made me hate HTC. Which is sad because I really liked the phone but the frustration seeing everyones great shots while mine were noisy pink bloody messes was infuriating. I couldn't even do a simple online sale post without having to go through another camera and a huge hassle transfering images etc to post a simple ad! The thought that this could be so easy had my damn camera work only ground salt into the wound. Fast forward to today and HTC was not even in contention(never will be) I am now the very happy owner of the best tech I have laid hands on the awesome LG V10! Now THIS is a smartphone. Its simply works and does so fast and with quality. Its just so intuitive and a multi task machine despite the fact I am no power user the second screen is so handy as I can quickly check the time w/o waking up, phone a friend w/o leaving a video, its so much more than a gimmick. The sound quality is what sold me to begin with having ESS Saber DAC and amp. There are stand alone DAPs that cost nearly the same. The camera is unbelievable, and I haven't even explored the manual options. The Q Slide thing again is brilliant and familiar windows style option...really smart software. This thing has so many features that I actually use its crazy.

[@Khhhaaalllee]

Like for m8

[@KnoPainVI]

Why do you make no mention of the front cameras in your videos? Just curious.

[@M.I.1947]

god help me i cant decide! :(

[@dirkgausmann9415]

Sony Xperia Z2... :)

[@Nydersty]

Best thing you can do is go try both in store ... look for a demo and play with them a couple minute , then you can make a decision afterward.

[@Ecu509]

Hey Android Authority Are you making a comparisons between the Sony Xperia Z2 and the Samsung Galaxy S5?

[@TheJunglekiller]

Does anyone know whether the new version of touchwiz will be coming to my GS4

[@imWristy]

I'm looking for a phone and i prefer to have 4g/LTE e decent camera and good recording for like on party's or something so i could record the music, what do you guys recommend from phone?

[@kova78]

Silver or Grey M8? I like the grey a bit more but I heard that it scratches a lot easier and is more slippery? I won't be using a case.

[@zhiarw]

dont care for slippery or scratches if u take care of it it wont get a scratch through i recommend gun metal color be cause of its texture .

[@TheBigAppleNYC]

Hands down... One M8 will be my next smartphone purchase. A couple more weeks and I will be a proud new M8 owner.

[@RiSo1988]

With such smooth metal and moist hands, Imagine dropping slippery M8 in your face while lying on bed! thats gonna hurt!!

[@djrajr]

Just curious but have you guys done any tests on the microphones that are built in for voice recognition and call quality between any smartphone? Now granted I know there will be a difference in which provider is being used for calls but just a thought. Still a good video.

[@abbasohn]

Just picked up the new htc one m8... What an awesome phone! The speakers will blow your mind!

[@Pattayaman999]

Excellent review!!! Hands down....S5 wins!!! Replaceable battery always wins for me.

[@LUISDAB3AST]

Po have a question, which one feels better? iPhone/iPods have a nice feel which is the only thing apple can give... Which one feels alike that?

[@baolitsky]

How do you get the phones you test?

[@LioSintra]

Why did you cut the Atuntu bechmark results?

[@haizhu9755]

I got my M8 today. I got a problem cuz the speakers are not impressing me. The quality is definitely good but the volume is not louder than my iPhone 5c. Just makes me wonder if something is wrong with my phone.plz help!

[@haizhu9755]

Jerizze S.C. really appreciate ur reply. Thank u