Samsung Watch5 PRO : Scientific Review!

🔴 General Amazon link*: geni.us/thequantifiedscientist
🔴 Galaxy Watch 5 Pro link*: geni.us/SamsungWatch5Pro
🟢 Instagram: / quantified_scientist
🟠 Shorts: / @smartwatchshorts
🔵 Newsletter: www.robterhorst.com
🟡 Twitter: @QuantifiedRob
* Affiliate (paid) links support the channel by earning me a commission on any sale, and it doesn't cost you any more! My opinions are completely my own, and this content is not sponsored.
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
👇 $30 off any new WHOOP membership, affiliate* (paid) link, supports the channel!👇
join.whoop.com/QuantifiedScie... ($30 off any new WHOOP membership)
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
👇Amazon Affiliate* (paid) links. Supports the channel, doesn't cost you any more!👇
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬BEST WATCHES▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
Whoop Strap 4.0: join.whoop.com/QuantifiedScie...
($30 off any new WHOOP membership)
General Amazon link: geni.us/thequantifiedscientist
Samsung Galaxy Watch 5: geni.us/SamsungWatch5
Huawei Watch Fit 2: geni.us/HuaweiWatchFit2
Huawei Watch GT3 Pro: geni.us/thequantifiedscientist
Huawei Watch GT Runner: geni.us/HuaweiWatchGtRunner
Huawei Watch GT 3: geni.us/Huawei_Watch_GT3
Apple Watch 7 41 mm: geni.us/AppleWatch7_41
Apple Watch 7 45 mm: geni.us/AppleWatch7
Apple Watch 6: geni.us/0gNGeO
Apple Watch SE: geni.us/Apple_Watch_SE_44
Garmin Fenix 7: geni.us/Garmin_Fenix_7
Garmin Venu 2: geni.us/Garmin_Venu_2
Garmin Instinct 2: geni.us/Garmin_Instinct_2
Polar H10: geni.us/hnXc
Polar OH1+: geni.us/D7bs5
Polar Verity Sense: geni.us/polarVeritySense
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
📸My Gear* (paid links, supports the channel and doesn’t cost you any more)📸
Camera body (main): geni.us/SonyA6600_body
Camera lense (main): geni.us/SigmaContemporary
Camera (B-roll): geni.us/CanonEosM50MarkII and geni.us/Sony_ZVE10
Light: geni.us/Godox_VL150
Softbox: geni.us/NiceFotoSoftbox
Light stand: geni.us/WalimexLightstand
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
Timestamps:
00:00 Intro
01:32 Most Important Background Info
04:03 Heart Rate Test Spinning
07:44 Heart Rate Test Cycling
10:25 Heart Rate Test Weight Lifting
13:36 Remarks on Battery Life
14:16 GPS Test
16:02 Sleep Stage Testing
21:28 Sleep Stage Test Overview
22:52 SpO2 Test
26:03 Is the Watch 5 Pro Worth It?
Intro: This is the brand new Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 Pro. And in this video we will take a first look at the heart rate accuracy, sleep tracking performance, GPS tracking and oxygen saturation measurements of this new watch from Samsung. In the last weeks, I already shared several videos in which I performed extensive tests on the standard version of the Galaxy Watch 5. However, many of you have been asking how the Pro version compares to the baseline model. So, in this video we will take a first look at the sports and health tracking performance of the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 Pro. And, honestly, the Watch 5 Pro definitely has some advantages over the normal Watch 5. However, if spending the extra money is actually worth it, is something you will have to decide for yourself, and I hope this video will help you make that decision.
Conclusions: In terms of sports and health tracking, I get the impression that the Galaxy Watch 5 Pro performs about the same as the normal Galaxy Watch 5, and as we saw in my other tests. This also means it is not performing that differently from the older Galaxy Watch 4. Now, future firmware updates might change this, because we have seen updates make major differences in the performance of the Galaxy Watch 4. Still, if you do not care about the battery life, the navigation features, or the different look of the Watch 5 Pro, you might as well get the much cheaper Watch 5 or even the Watch 4. However, if money is not an issue, I do quite like the look of the Watch 5 Pro, especially if you replace the strap with this brown one.
Now, let’s take a step back, and see if I would actually recommend the Watch 5 pro in general, or even the Watch 5 for that matter. Well, from a sports and health tracking perspective they are OKish watches, with good heart rate tracking for stationary cardio exercises, and the SpO2 sensor on the Watch 5 Pro also shows some promise. However, there are definitely better watches out there. I would mostly consider getting one of these watches if you also care about the smartwatch features themselves, and your focus is not mainly on sports and health. Therefore, based on my experience so far, overall I would give the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 Pro: 3.5 out of 5 stars.

[@TheQuantifiedScientist]

🔴 General Amazon link*: geni.us/thequantifiedscientist 🔴 Galaxy Watch 5 Pro link*: geni.us/SamsungWatch5Pro 🟢 Instagram: instagram.com/quantified_scientist/ 🟠 Shorts: studio.kzbin.info/door/cpARGzXNaC62UQWns2dh2Q 🔵 Newsletter: www.robterhorst.com 🟡 Twitter: @QuantifiedRob * Affiliate (paid) links support the channel by earning me a commission on any sale, and it doesn't cost you any more! My opinions are completely my own, and this content is not sponsored. ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬ 👇 $30 off any new WHOOP membership, affiliate* (paid) link, supports the channel!👇 join.whoop.com/QuantifiedScientist ($30 off any new WHOOP membership)

[@actual_random]

Everytime im about to buy a galaxy watch you shatter my dreams with your scientific reviews🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Kirubhas_Shankar]

I feel you😭😭😭😭

[@Elixyon]

Yes i feel you boys 😂

[@bigmaxcc]

😂🤣 already have my fold 4 now waiting GW5p black titanium

[@ljacobs357]

There is nothing wrong with the Watch 5. I compared it to the Apple Watch and the results were comparable.

[@giridhranpalani3139]

I feel you so much haha 😂😂😂

[@josephabiti9226]

THIS IS WHAT I CALL A REVIEW. Thanks very much for the time and effort. It is not only a review, it is educational as well.

[@ismathem]

Couldn't agree more

[@thefix-itguyreviewer8151]

Update From what I said before that if you want more accuracy turn the watch around on the back of your wrist give that a try Make sure it's tight. The watch band makes a difference!!! I got a wider watch band. A rugged Velcro hook and loop. The entire watch band is wider not just where it connects. IT MAKES A BIG DIFFERENCE IN ACCURACY FOR THE HEART RATE!! Maybe because the watch is very heavy when you don't have stability it may rock from side to side while you're exercising or lifting weights. The real issue is when you're moving around, boxing, lifting weights etc. The band keeps it stable and tight very little movement and rocking. Sometimes I wouldn't get good readings even with the blood oxygen measurements. It would work maybe 70% of the time. Same thing with the heart rate. NOW IT WORKS EVERY TIME!! EVEN THE BODY COMPOSITION WORKS BETTER!! I tighten it up when I'm working out. Then I undo the Velcro and loosen it up a little bit walking around normally. Still works great both ways. My findings were confirmed with the polar Hot rate monitor, and my FRONTIER X IN MY OPINION THE BEST HEART RATE LIVE ECG HEART STRAP MONITOR WITH INFORMATION YOU CAN'T GET FROM REGULAR HEART STRAPS ABOUT YOUR HEART GALAXY 5 WATCH PRO WAS PRETTY DEAD ON!! Peace out God bless!!

[@masterblockwarrior]

Appreciate the work that goes into these videos. Truly top tier informative content.

[@TheQuantifiedScientist]

Thanks so much! really appreciated, since it costs quite some time to make these videos 😀

[@rahulgoyal3287]

@@TheQuantifiedScientist please do amazfit bip 3 review

[@fist003]

@@TheQuantifiedScientist time well spent. Also great to see the production quality had also refined

[@maciejtekieli8268]

@@TheQuantifiedScientist hello, please look at my question above. I think someone is trying to impersonate you

[@AM-qv2ed]

Make sure that the heart rate on your watch is set on measure continuously to get more accurate readings because it's set on measure every 10 min by default

[@kentjoshuainoue5097]

Thank you! I appreciate the honesty and the time and effort you invested with this review. Hope to see more of this!

[@adrielhernandez6005]

This guy is… I can’t even describe it thank you very much, you are increíble, you and flossy carter are my 2 favorite channels in KZbin about technology, flossy with the earbuds and you with the watches ❤️

[@AllWeDoisWork]

Thank you for your amazing in depth videos! Always look forward to them!

[@gnarfle]

This agrees with what I've found trying various trackers. The Galaxy watch to me seems to be the best I've tried at detecting when you are awake. It most consistently records middle of the night and early awakenings and seems to fairly accurately detect when you fall asleep too. if you are most concerned with total sleep time and tracking insomnia, it seems quite good for that. However, sleep stage tracking seems to always have been quite bad and it tends to report a VERY low amount of deep sleep. For me personally I've stuck with the galaxy because generally tracking total sleep time and wake periods is my main concern and I put little faith in the sleep stage tracking.

[@thusby81]

Rob, congrats for u work, its amazing! Please make a TRex 2 full review.

[@frankyguitar1241]

Was waiting for it, thank you Rob

[@giuseppea.3073]

@The quantified scientist. It's a pleasure see your review. The unique way to comment correctly a product. Thanks for your time test and training

[@martinezeli13]

This was insanely helpful. Great video!

[@carrocertopb]

Amazing video. With so many details, this is the best analysis. Talking about review, you are The Man! Thank you to share your knowledge .

[@chyong6883]

Great review as always. Was wondering if you can review the blood pressure and ECG features of this watch.

[@vedprakashwagh]

Hey! I feel like you should revisit this watch once again because Samsung finally enabled the temperature sensor on this watch. I believe the temperature sensor was disabled when it was initially launched and they turned it on somewhere around April of this year. It should lead to very different results?

[@jim771212]

First of all, thanks for your sharing. You are very particular about experimental data. It is the first time to see such a sharing. It is really special. I think the battery increase of the galaxy watch 5 pro this time is a big improvement in the smart watch. In the past, the smart watch had a small battery, and various functions could hardly be fully turned on, so it was impossible to fully experience the convenience brought by the smart watch. But the watch 5 pro provides a larger battery, which not only increases the usage time, but you no longer need to worry about which function consumes power, and can fully experience the convenience of a smart watch.

[@omastria]

Amazing!!!! I liked a lot your type of analysis. This is a beautiful comparison. Who like science will fall in love with your videos. Thanks a lot! Greetings from Brazil

[@eliasbane3588]

You should show the average heart rate of each session as well. The watch(like all watches) undoubtedly loses some peaks on the hr but at least watch 4 catches the average hr very well. It's usually 3-5 beats off when I compare with the polar h10. You should consider this because the peaks don't last much during the session. The average heart rate is most important for ordinary people,like you and me. Of course, there is another conversation when we talk about pro athletes. I think it's much more important to examine the distance and the pace during running and generally the GPS. Watch 4 is not so good at it. Usually is shows 10"/per km slower than the polar, which is indeed significant.

[@Sinasi08]

This channel is a gem 💎 Dank u wel Rob 🎉

[@tylerhanson]

This is more than a review, this is an analysis, great work! Can't wait for my watch 5 pro gray to arrive 29 days 🥶

[@DrMIS1]

I've had a Galaxy Watch 5 pro now for a few months. I've been using Samsung watches since the first one came out, traded to the watch 3 for free as an add-on to my last Galaxy phone, then got the 5 pro for around $100 with a trade of my watch 3 when I upgraded that phone. I'm mainly concerned with its synchronization with my phone for calls and messages. They only health feature that really matters to me is heart rate, since I have bradycardia, so I like to keep track to make sure it doesn't go too low. I love the look of the 5 pro. I get 3-4 days out of the battery, and it's very sturdy. It's a little bulky, but I don't even really notice that. I do keep track of steps every day, but I'm not that concerned with the accuracy of any of the other health features other than out of general interest. For me, the integration with all my other Samsung devices and the low cost when purchased with my phone and tablet made it a better choice than any of the alternatives that work with Android. The Apple watches were never even a consideration since I've never owned Apple anything.

[@GadgetyMV]

Excellent covering the specs up front, and your experience with the battery autonomy. I believe this will make your channel appeal to even more people. Perhaps you could add an image of all the ratings you give for the features tested, and the overall score, since you quantify them all. Four days battery life, wow! Ouch for the sleep tracking, in particular the deep sleep stage which is the one I'm most interested in. This stage is better tracked by chance than by the 5 Pro, it seems. Unfortunately the Dreem 2 is no longer for sale for consumers. If you have a chance please consider testing the Sleep As Android app, which is a Wear OS compatible software, which could present an alternative for the Samsung (and other Wear) watches.

[@TheQuantifiedScientist]

Thanks for the compliment! I need to collect more data with the watch to make sure how good the sleep tracking is, but I think this is indeed a good first indication. Have a great day!😀

[@GadgetyMV]

@@TheQuantifiedScientist Thank you Rob! You too, and have a great night's sleep!

[@moodberry]

@@TheQuantifiedScientist I have been using the sleep app for some time, but the graph that shows my sleep stages on the phone health app is useless. I want to see the data in more detail, like you did in the video. So how did you get the sleep data from the watch into a useful graph like you showed us?

[@spaceghostctc5890]

The way he breaks down his findings is amazing

[@thedrunkengardener9367]

I love the accuracy and proficiency in the way you review these watches! I ordered the Galaxy watch 5 and abruptly returned it. I would love some input from you and the followers on your channel about advice to let my Samsung S21 Ultra connect to in my opinion a more attractive option the Huawei smart watch. I tried to connect my watch fit to my S21 Ultra and failed. I still find their design so much more attractive. And according to your hard work, so much more effective in health tracking. In your expert opinion is it even feasible to connect a Huawei watch to a Samsung phone in the United States? My watch fit original, connected to my mate 20x global version flawlessly. I never could get it to work with my S21 Ultra.

[@asianstudio7918]

I like your English pronunciation and the way, the speed you talk. My English is poor, but I can listen your every word clear.

[@SaltyMcSaltyPants]

Thank you so much ! Could you tell us the complete list of settings you use to get that battery life please?

[@VladimirChernik]

Thank you for your research! This is a real review vs marketing! Thank you!

[@harvgill76]

Amazing info. In the future, if you are able to measure vibration strength that would be mind blasting.

[@romxxii]

This is so helpful! I was almost dead-set on buying a Watch 5 pro, but from these reviews, I might just get a Watch 4, or even just an Apple Watch 7.

[@menifo4334]

Incredible review!!! I wish I listened to you and didn't make the mistake to buy the Amazfit GTR 3 PRO. Thanks!

[@cardwellmuvungani550]

I have a few questions on your methodology Do you reapeat your tests on each device to ensure reliability? Do you test devices on other device users to ensure - inter rater reliability? Skin tone is also a factor on these light based sensors. You are rating these devices against the Polar heart monitor. Where is the data to show that it is the gold standard of Heart rate measurements? Can this data be classified as scientific if it is measured on one person by one person?

[@nabiladnan4577]

are u planning to do the mi band 7 pro? btw, love your videos. really really helps with making a decision

[@TheHUhelps]

Hi Rob, Maybe it's been asked already, but what watches would you recommend? I'm looking at the Garmin Venu 2 right now. Greetings

[@cooluser23]

As I'm watching the video I'm hoping to see something on the BP monitoring. One thing I never seen any testing on is Rep counting for weight lifting with the accelerometer.

[@cristi.n]

A new huge update came to watch 5pro. It seems that HR tracking is grately improved. Maybe the sleep tracking is improved too. Can someone actually confirm the changes?

[@mridhulsivadas]

Love and appreciation from India. I really admire the work you put in to make content like this. Reviewers here in India do not even go for a 5k run with the watch and share the basic metrics in their reviews. Some commented here that they've changed their decision to buy this specific smart watch because they feel the sensors in this aren't good enough. My case is the opposite. Galaxy watches may not be the best fitness tracking devices out there, but it's really hard to find a smart watch that can match the other smart features that the galaxy watches offer. (Body Composition Measurement, for example) Besides that, I'm not an athlete fighting for gold medal in Olympics for my country ☺️ I'm more than happy with approximate values that are meaningful. Once again, congrats for making in-depth data mining like this. I'm now waiting for Onam (Local festival here in Kerala, India) bumper lottery results to check if my mom will get the first price, for her to buy this watch for me ☺️

[@immiteshk]

Exactly, approximate values are just fine. No other best overall choice for Android. I have ordered the 40mm one.

[@SharathLal]

If the sensors and overlying softeware is not accurate what is the purpose of buying an expensive Smart watch or band?

[@rodrigopierettimenezes5538]

Awesome video! We need more and more of this review! Just found your channel and subscribed. However, i wanted also this kind of review regarding the bioimpedance system of the watch 5 pro. Could you make it anytime? Thanks in advance!

[@HughesyTech]

May as well get a Suunto 7 if you can get it on sale. Still, very damning review of the Watch 5 Pro. Good on you for pointing out all the flaws out.

[@actorjay]

I just thought of this and BAM here it is. THANK YOU!

[@TheQuantifiedScientist]

Just for you ;-) !

[@actorjay]

I'll probably get it eventually anyway just because I already own a Samsung phone and this is still the best watch option available in the Galaxy ecosystem. It's a bit too thick for my taste, but the improved battery life is worth it for me. Cheers!

[@GK-qc5ry]

I hear Garmin and Fitbit have releases in September, can't wait to see those reviews QS!

[@Jarpaza]

Thank you for brutally honest video. I meant to get Samsung watch for training but now wiser :)

[@AdAm-cw3gi]

Love your stuff!

[@frayvidz]

hello.. would you do review on the accuracy of the blood pressure monitor feature as well? cheers! great video as always! :)

[@Peoplesuuck]

Thanks for a very in depth review. I have this watch and do enjoy it but certainly take the health metrics with a grain of salt. Helpful to point you in the right direction but absolutely a plus/minus to certain metrics. As shown in the video, one in particular is your oxygen saturation. Take the score that the watch gives you then add 1-2 and that will be more accurate. Just measured mine at total rest (healthy) and it gave 96%. Add two: 98%, ya that's about right for me.

[@hinhp803]

@ The Quantified Scientist - where can I purchase that cognac watch band? Great review! Thank you.

[@XdB1Gz7StR4C7]

Thank you so much! Great job! So many-many relevant informations to make better decisions ☝👍👌💪💪🤟✌👏👏👏

[@thevuong6706]

thank so much for this video!!!!!

[@Ben-op1kn]

great content! thank you. Can I ask where you got the leather strap for this device, please. (And your link to the strap)

[@mmafighter077]

Where did you purchase that leather watch band? Great video BTW.

[@AlexChIsk]

Great job, thank you!

[@Grr8jon]

I absolutely love your content! Sleep tracking is important for me. I will look into other devices (fitbit) for sleep tracking. Subscribing.

[@jameslopez3450]

I also have a z fold 4, galaxy watch 5 pro and love riding bicycles subscribed.

[@SINSosure]

Despite the inaccuracies, I bought this watch after seeing this video and some heavy consideration. The watch is able to do more than just fitness track. It is also customizable connecting to apps in the Play Store, which works well for me. Seems to me this is the best Android compatible option. Thank you for your extensive research!

[@jakubsmihula6412]

Hello, sorry for bothering but I'm considering buying Galaxy Watches 5 Pro. Are you satisfied with the purchase?

[@SINSosure]

@@jakubsmihula6412 I'm still satisfied with it. Although, it is a glorified reminder tracker to me now. But, it has allowed me to answer calls and text without the use of my phone. Since my phone is an older model, it won't let me use the camera function.

[@giridhranpalani3139]

Thanks for your videos Rob! Disappointed at the HR sensor for the weight training and hopefully this changes with software updates in the next month or so or I'm gonna wait for the Huawei GT4 Pro launch soon 😂. Looking forward to your next review! Cheers

[@seanlinehan1136]

It doesn’t. Ppl say “software updates” as a way to ease the cognitive dissonance in their mind, but there is almost NO company that has legitimately and RAPIDLY improved their product through updates. Samsung never added features. Google never fixed battery drain. Buy a product for how it is NOW, not for the pretend future ppl convince themselves will happen but never does

[@gz625]

It will never change. Look at GW4. They as bad as was when just came out 😹

[@thedarkness3080]

The Huawei watch gt 3 pro has just been released, it will take a while until the next one is released. The next one should be GT4.

[@giridhranpalani3139]

@@thedarkness3080 yeah I'm hoping within the next 6 months or so for the watch GT 4 pro as the rumours are that the GT 4 will be released this Sept.

[@giridhranpalani3139]

@@seanlinehan1136 that's true, sad but oh well. Was really looking forward to this watch as it would be great for my Samsung ecosystem. Guess I'm just disappointed

[@terenceleung1214]

Hi, Rob, your tests are amazing & eyes opener. Is it possible to do tests on Amazfit GTR 4 as it has upgraded its' Biotracker & GSP tracking ? Million thanks.🥰

[@salvocomplicazioni75]

Grazie per il tuo lavoro!

[@azanshuja8687]

Excellent Video! By the way, you should test it again atleast after 2 months. After that, it should be lot better due to updates

[@yildiraykomurcu]

Products of which companies do you have early access to test Rob ? Fitbit Sense 2 is announced. Will you be able to test it ? On paper, it is similar to Sense 1 which was terrible at heart rate tracking.

[@nealprice1813]

Would love to see you implement running for heart rate test.

[@megatronking1386]

Hi Rob, I know you don't take requests, but if you can, kindly try reviewing the newly launched Amazfit GTS 4 mini with Biotracker 3 PPG, with GTS/GTR 4 models with Biotracker 4 ppg, which claims to take 33% more readings as compared to Gen 3.

[@daniellecozine3360]

Would you be able to do some testing for smart watches and swim features?

[@michaw.6161]

Do you have link to this orange leather strap to the watch? It looks awesome!

[@BilotoS89]

Hey thanks for your detailed Videos! I think there are many improvements from firmware upgrades can you re-make an update for accuracy? I want to know because i want to use it for running and weight lifting workouts ,I know that the apple watch ultra is way more accurate but also the price is way more higher :( Also i have polar h10 so i can connect with spesific program for more accuracy

[@JasonPejsa]

Hello, I have a question. I am using the PolarH10 as a baseline. Comparing treadmill runs, yoga, and intense weightlifting between the whoop 4 (wrist) and the Watch 5 Pro, I am finding the Watch 5 Pro more accurate for the real time HR as well as post analysis ave and max HRs. I am using MAPMYRUN with the H10, the Whoop App, and the watch tracking apps. I display the H10 and Whoop on a split screen and compare to the watch display for real time HRs. The biggest trend is both the watch and whoop are slow to catch high HRs and if the HR drops quickly, the wrist devices miss the peak. For the exercise summary, the Watch 5 is consistently and considerably more accurate. I did receive a Watch Pro update about a month ago, prior to trying the whoop. Are you considering another Watch 5 pro test with most recent updates? Or is there something I am missing. Based on your charts, I was expecting the whoop to be much better than the results I am seeing. By the way, love your channel and it has been crucial for my decisions!

[@masterkinonc]

Thank you for great job

[@Shinangel]

THX for the video, what is this brown leather strap? Link please

[@donwoodward2615]

Best video ever on this smart watch

[@maciejtekieli8268]

Hello. Great video. A few days ago Amazfit showed new GTR 4. With ne HR and GPS sensors. In your previous test Amazfit did not measure HR well. Are you planning to test new devices from Amazfit?

[@janzupanzu]

I hope that you'll make a video about Fitbit Sense 2, too. It would be nice to compare Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 with Fitbit Sense 2.

[@TheQuantifiedScientist]

I hope to get it soon!

[@uh7123zz1azxcv]

Can you test the sleep tracking based on "Sleep as android" app and its agreement with EEG? Sleep as android has been in the market for years and I think it's (or should be) one of the more accurate tracking algorithms for wear OS watches

[@FrancoEC_]

when will you do the complete scientific review of the xiaomi band 7, it had updates and it seems that they did very well!

[@rosepritchard5203]

Could you please test & evaluate the Fitbit Versa line, maybe even the soon to be released version 4?

[@t_c5266]

Really seems like it's all about fit and variables like that. I'd love to see some tests with different band styles. Maybe try to isolate the variable by getting bands of the same circumference where you can choose more than just where the holes are pre placed. Something I've noticed about people who have an apple watch actually get skin irritation because it is pressed so hard into their wrist.

[@erlendkristiansen4664]

I really can't understand how that is the conclusion you've managed to draw from this.

[@t_c5266]

@@erlendkristiansen4664 it's called isolating variables. The scientific method. If they all had the same placement and pressure on the wrist, how would the results change? These devices work off of good contact with the skin and a band that isn't infinitely adjustable won't give the best contact. If you think they wouldn't, pause the video and inspect it for yourself.

[@arunvignesh7015]

@@erlendkristiansen4664 Most of these high end devices use similar sensors which leave the factory calibrated and tested. These are not camera sensors for different companies to have different interpretation of the values, they have to more or less them same. The compass in all our devices is going to point the same direction with reasonable accuracy if its of good quality no matter which company uses it. The large varienace in these tests of different high end watches might simply come down to fitment, user pattern and use of statistical tools without any statistical model which accounts for all these factors, and more importantly the lack of sample variety and numbers. But then if we try to do all these things then it becomes a laboratory test that the manufactures would have done anyway. But then lab tests are good for labs because in the wild these magic sensors won't do any magic, they just be becomes unreliable. We could go on and on about this but the bottom line is if these devices can measure with reasonable accuracy of say 80 percentage or something, that should be good enough if they are using the same senor that's available in the market. Only when one if these manufactures comes out with some revolutionary technology that's exclusive to them we can go into that high territory of accuracy and try comparing them.

[@arunvignesh7015]

Looks that way because the results seem too wild with the tag scientific on it. Like some man said numbers said out without mentioning their uncertainty is scientifically useless.

[@special2546]

Amazing videos. I Appriciate it a lot. Please extand your methode to other type of devices. Thank's a lot.

[@tupagalha]

Please make video on fossil smart and hybrid watches

[@Kameleonic]

Top quality as usual:)

[@manjitbhatia9909]

Excellent Video ... I just Return My Samsung Watch as It's not Accurate and Misleading ...when it comes to Health Monitoring don't take Chance.

[@your__daddyy]

Will you make an updated video for this watch ? It's been a year since you posted this video and the watch has received a lot of updates .

[@easamalik2095]

Thats a great band on Pro 5. Can you post the link for that please?

[@weekendwarrior8179]

Glad your keeping them honest

[@Ashlyn_O.]

Rob, can you please test out fitness watch call Maimo? Thanks.

[@mohamedelbanna6013]

Can you please post the link for the brown strap, i really like it. thank you

[@Scruffed]

Would've loved to see how it performs for swimmers!

[@AntagonisticAltruist]

I really hope software updates improve some of these results. I already ordered the watch, but some of these results are not stellar.

[@matteova3973]

Could you retest to see after 6 months update the possible changes in performance?

[@anirudhyeswanth4108]

I'm from India I'm an Android user bcz of you imade a decision to by Huawei gt3 pro thank you so much for your work

[@4thNebula]

I am researching all options for 24/7 data collection of fitness, spo2, and sleep data. I currently us a Fitbit Versa 2 and looking to upgrade. Seems the Oura Ring and Fitbit series the only gadgets for me due to the Samsung and Apple watches having such poor battery life. Not sure if the Apple Watch Ultra will be useable for >24 hrs at a time using all apps per day.

[@raghavchaudhary7769]

Hello man I love your videos. I noticed you haven't uploaded a video of Realme Watch 2 Pro despite it having the most accurate sleep tracking in budget watches. Please can you make it?

[@jucapini]

Can you do a review of this and other watches after some time? It would helpp to check if firmware updates actually have worked

[@gabbiesjoubert6197]

PLEASE DO A COMPLETE/ INDETH REVIEW OF THE HUAWEI GT3!!!🥺🥺🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@bc3395]

I really enjoyed your objective and intelligent review - as I have purchased a 5 pro in 2024, the price is much more affordable, esp in buying refurb from Amazon

[@joaoalves8486]

You have to test the new fitibits! I want to see the software development hehehe

[@yeterbeter83]

Thnx man

[@EA99999]

Any chance you can revisit this not that it's been out for a bit and likely has updates? thanks!

[@ShanePatrice]

Waiting for your review of the new Google/Fitbit watch released in Oct 22.

[@tc00ds]

Hi! what would you buy between galaxy watch 5 pro and huawei gt3 pro and why? Thx.

[@winsooohhh]

Great reviews! Unfortunately, i have no choice on buying watch with my galaxy phone. Hopefully, samsung will indeed... improve sensor accuracy by software update...

[@MrTANKASALA]

can u review the honor magic watch 2 as well?