Sad State of Organic Farming in India | Harpal Singh Grewal | Ravi Singh Choudhary |

[@arunksharma1230]

जैविक खेती को कैसे बढ़ाया जाए, इसपर एक सटीक चर्चा।हमारी परंपरागत खेती कितनी समृद्ध थी इसे जरूर सुनना चाहिए।

[@ShankarRatneshwaran]

This is such an important discussion! My God Ravi Singhji you are a hero !!!! God bless you!

[@MrRahul6464]

हरपाल जी को पुनः बुलाए। और २-३ विषय चुनकर उसी पर प्रसारणी करे।

[@mohansantwani811]

Grewal ji I fully support your thoughts for organic farming

[@sunilsharma6118]

खेती को लेकर गजब के विचार है श्री हरपाल सिंह ग्रेवाल जी के बहुत कम किसान बचे है जो इनकी जैसी सोच और समझ रखते है , यदि हम अभी भी नहीं जागे तो हमारी जमीनों को बंजर बनने से कोई नहीं रोक सकता ! सरकार को ऐसे व्यक्तियो से विचार विमर्श कर अपनी पॉलिसी तैयार करनी चाहिए।

[@divyasingh-hs3lh]

बहुत ही अच्छी चर्चा ग्रेवाल जी की

[@sanjaypatil-cx5dq]

बहुत अच्छी जानकारी मिल गयी है. धन्यवाद ग्रेवालजी. इतके बाद के व्हिडिओ भी हम देखना चाहेंगे.❤

[@arunksharma1230]

Must be listened by all the organic promoters and forwarded to policy makers .

[@Prajaktashimpi]

U mean policy makers do not know ??? Be it law or farming why do they act as aliens ???

[@AbhishekYadav-kj8oc]

A round of applause for these gentlemen. Both filled with knowledge and wisdom and have so much to share. Awaiting part 2.

[@balajiv8085]

Ravi Singh Choudhary ji has a lot of knowledge in the topic. So he is not asking Harpal ji to explain some basic terms and concepts (which the audience has no clue about, but both of them know). So the audience might be missing out on interesting and important details. We need several videos from both these men, to educate the public on a very important topic.

[@tejindersingh4154]

This guy is the interviewer.... secretly hoping to get credit

[@nisarggodhani2919]

Absolutely right Sirf marketing term me bol rahe hai jisse sab kuch pata na chal paye agar sab bol diya to koi inke pass nahi jayega isse achha hai ki Gujrat ke Rajyapal ne book likhi hai ya unke karyakram hai modiji ke sath vo dekh lo Prakrutik kheti ke bare me vo sabse badhiya hai chemical ke bina aisi kheti hogi

[@AvtarSingh-zr6qc]

Judicious use of five elements of life; 1) Bhoomi(soil) 2) Agni(sunlight), 3) Gagan (space) 4) Wayu (air) 5) Neer (water) BhaGWAN in agriculture is the way out to 1) sustain food and nutritional security 2) mitigate and adapt climate change and 3) use critical natural resources (water, energy and land) sustainably.

[@yagyabhushansharma1008]

सुन्दर चर्चा।

[@shripadvyawahare]

Very knowledgeable video... thank you. We are also working in organic farming and encouraging chemical farmer to convert into organic farming.

[@shantanain6174]

PM has a great knowledge of Organic farming. His next 5 years will definitely see a turn towards Organic Farming

[@Mojo-vu4hr]

yes but no one has balls to stop purchase of fertilisers and chemicals! NO1

[@HimanshuKumar-uh5um]

pm 10 saal se ghanta bajye or 5 saal bhi bajayenge.

[@sumeetpandey6521]

​@@HimanshuKumar-uh5um 10 saal pehle organic farm land kitna ttha awwr aabhi kitna hai ???

[@hardeepSingh-um1nm]

Past study has proved with evidence that our current PM can talk good, do Hindu-Muslim only. He is face cover of corporate.

[@anuragg-p8k]

@@hardeepSingh-um1nmyou are blinded by nafrat so all vivek is gone

[@PrincipalUncle]

Exlnt right and True Thanks.

[@hardayaldawra1458]

Highly knowledgeable, informative and helpful

[@GPJhala]

किसी को भी दोष मत दे। आज पॉपुलेशन चार गुनी हो गए हैं। जमीन 40% कम हो गई है क्योंकि शहरीकरण हो गया है। सही हल एक ही है वस्ती कम करने के लिए कड़ा से कड़ा कानून होना चाहिए।

[@OrganicFarmer123]

who told you that land has decreased have you ever visited any village. all village people encroached forest area by deforesting.

[@dayaprahlad6951]

Government should walk the talk and promote natural farming. Stop supporting Corporates

[@rashtra-first]

Thankyou for bringing this entirely new information and personality to us. I never heard about all this.

[@AvtarSingh-zr6qc]

Naturalization and Concept of crop biodiversity in agriculture is the best way to solve all the agri-based problems of the society; financial,nutritional and environmental.

[@ashokverma7501]

मोदीजी, कड़ा निर्णय यहां भी चाहिए। ग्रेवाल जी की सुन लीजिए

[@fnmfnm2896]

Great content...pls do more sessions on vedic kheti even more and in bite size for youngsters to take advantage of such knowledge.

[@kaushalyafarms5055]

Amazing discussion

[@alokkumarkerketta8834]

Nice talk thanks to sangam talks

[@ashokverma7501]

Grewal ji and Dr Vandana Shiva should meet sometime

[@parnanetra]

Nice interview

[@rahul_bali]

transformative talk

[@hilmikato169]

Brilliant discussion ❤

[@rajeshkamath3350]

I wish all the best to the scientists for sooner achievement of the goal.

[@jitenderbhadu5140]

Make a series on each topic with Sardar Harpal Singh without interruption dear anchor

[@sudhirabhange5086]

Want to listen more from Harpal ji

[@TmTNaturalFarming]

Hatts of You sir!!! Great points. Should have more constructive and longer discussion

[@hasmukhchouhan2822]

Very good information

[@JatinderKumar-bc7he]

Very Valuable inputs

[@arfaabbas]

beAuTiFuL 💜

[@nishakushwaha120]

Bahut achchha discussion. Please is vishay per ak series banaiye.

[@SispalChhirang]

Grawal ji you aregreat

[@sriniwassharma952]

Agree with Mr Grewal Ji that Ayush and Agriculture Should be CoordinatedDeptt. Secondly Budget forOrganic Agri Resesrch be priority of Agri Univercities ICAR. Governor of Gujrat Sh Devvart Ji have rich experience may be listen onAgriculture

[@assassincreed1238]

If India didn’t do land ceiling we would have bigger farms with better technology instead we need msp to fund all the marginal farmers

[@JagadguruSvamiVegananda]

Why do you call your nation by the name given to it by the British (from the PERSIAN word “Hindustan”)?☝️ What’s wrong with its PROPER name (Bhārata)? 🇮🇳

[@rickypulikal]

​@@JagadguruSvamiVegananda That's what you want to talk about. Not the sorry state of the most important thing for human survival in country??? Food....

[@JagadguruSvamiVegananda]

@@rickypulikal Did you know that in ancient Bhārata (India), a person who consumed ANY type of animal was known as a “Chandāla” (dog-eater) and was not even included in mainstream society, but was an outcast?🥩 So when a DOG-EATER such as yourself presumes to judge and instruct a member of the Holy Priesthood (The World Teacher Himself, in my particular case), it is rather amusing (and, of course, totally evil).👿 Bless You Always, Mr. DOG-EATING beta-male! 😇 P. S. I conditionally apologize if you’re a strict VEGAN, Sinful Slave. 🌱

[@PragA-p1u]

One side effect would be mono culture. Its not good

[@Mojo-vu4hr]

ITS ALL PLAN OF UN and SYSTEMS of this NATION FARMERS ARE MOBILISED towards CITIES BY PLAN AND PROGRAMME

[@pinda.tambard]

Sir harpal singh ji app apna KZbin channel officially launch karo

[@spidy402]

Question for gentlemen, how the common Indian citizen become a farmer and start organic farming

[@UmeshKumarthunikipati]

Need English subtitles We from. Telugu states want to know the topic intended Please add English subtitles

[@sanjayjogdand9102]

सर कृषिपाराशर ग्रंथ पढना चाहिये!❤️🌹

[@healthspace4936]

Adha information hai, farming has to be done sustainably. Sustainable doesn't mean organic, it means using variable rate application that yields food rich in nutrients and it's with balance with the soil ecology (improving carbon levels and maintaining it, using precise nutrition schedule and protection )

[@sharathkurudi]

Sustainable farming is the way out. In that method one must not give nutrition to soil from outside.

[@kulwantsandhu9047]

Good discussion

[@GPJhala]

पंजाब के किसानों को अस्सी सालो से सबसे अधिक पानी मिला है । सबसे अधिक महत्व मिला है। लेकिन अगर थोड़ा सा पानी राजस्थान को मिले तो ज्यादा बेहतर परिणाम मिलेंगे। राजस्थान के लोग ज्यादा मेहनती है।

[@Hindus_Nation]

कृपया इन्हे फिर से बुलाएँ।

[@prasungaurav416]

Need a better anchor to interview Grewal Ji

[@rschoudhary108]

Even I thought that, then subject expertise was required to bring the discussion within the framwork.

[@rabindra9830]

But ravi singh Chowdhury also has deep understanding regarding natural farming, he may not familiar with this task.

[@Hindus_Nation]

This is for general discussion for general public, not necessarily for the farmers. Ravi Singh Chaudhryji is an expert.

[@nikhilthakur7317]

Prasung, tu ne kyun nahi kar liya?

[@geekmails]

He keeps interrupting.

[@dr.iqbalmustafa1493]

More videos with Grewal ji

[@RawanaTiger]

Fact is India right now is a grain surplus country that ends all the debate. If Grewal ji can adopt a village and increase production or match it with non organic then farmers will take it up automatically. There is no need for center's intervention.

[@RamanSharma89]

kash hamari sarkaar jaage aur ispe kuchh kaam kare. abhi jo Natural farming ko promote kiya ja raha hai wo ek achha step hai lekin wo bhi sahi tarike se nahin chal raha hai.

[@manishadate9840]

देसी सब्जियोंकी quality seeds कहा मिलेगी?

[@Ramarao-dq8mf]

Punjab me suru hua e curruption. Green revolution nam pe.. E zahar kerala nahi pahuncha malum. Ek conference me kerala prof ham ko GM varieties ke bare me classes liya tha.jab pucha krela me kyo nahi e sab..haske bola..aap mughe west ka agent bhi bolenge. Bas suno, apka marzi badme..

[@bawa6776]

Os time desh Bukha mar raha tha.

[@kamalgupta5954]

How and from where we can buy authentic organic food?

[@saurabhrai5461]

Nowhere

[@paraslath4464]

Very knowledgeable

[@ArminMistry-i7t]

Rajiv Dixitji ke You Tube video me' organic farming kaisi karni chahiye uskaa sab description hai

[@atmakrishna85]

What's the organic replacement for Potassium, please suggest

[@sharathkurudi]

Please read books by Fukuoka, or by Subhash Palekar. Sustainable Farming methods increases the health of the soil.

[@sanjayjogdand9102]

कृषिपाराशर ग्रंथ पढो

[@girirajlavti2488]

who to test fruit and vegetables organic

[@abrahamchacko6822]

SPNFarming is a way out

[@HimanshuKumar-uh5um]

we need laws right to recall health minister , jury court , right to recall chief minister.

[@ybrengade802]

sir we have to use scientifical, commercial, economical, environmental farming like multilayer hydroponics farming with fish farming for vegetable, water should be stored underground as possible as quantity to avoid evaporation, ground water recharge though rain water and filter waste water.

[@mamasingh67]

Same for indian spices full of chemicals. Uk and Australia looking to ban them .

[@Hindus_Nation]

Oh! Please give some more info. on this.

[@atmakrishna85]

I, produce Chemical Pesticides free Cardamom.

[@nishakushwaha120]

Sir,GMO SEED PER VIDEO BANAIYE

[@tejasvi18joshi]

GMO should be banned

[@Truth684]

Vandana Shiva Rajiv Dixit Davender Balhara Sanjeev Sharma Sunil Sharma#jsm Bhartiya Pariwar Channel

[@maahirajput5823]

Harpal Singh grewAl ji ka KZbin channel he kya?

[@srivathsaacharya7903]

Bhai no hate but uncle ji ka knowledge hai par une cross questions Karo to make it more attractive. Ap ak or person jo agricultureke basis janta ho

[@15-FF]

❤❤❤

[@neeleshkumardubey7407]

आप लोगो ने श्री सुभाष पालेकर जी का नाम नहीं लिया

[@kamlaarora5640]

Chemical seeped intense crop instantly washed loaded vehicles reach mandi so what can be done.

[@ripudamansingh4854]

Brother please tell the address of Mr harpal Singh Grewal so that we can meet him personally..🙏🙏

[@NativeVsColonial]

What happened to Sri Lanka after they tried for “Organic Farming”?

[@rschoudhary108]

This is just war of narratives. Banning chemical is not Organic farming

[@Hindus_Nation]

That was the problem, "they only tried", they only banned chemicals and didn't have any action plan for organic farming, so they failed. We Indians do have several techniques for organic farming.

[@pardeepdotasara8161]

हरपाल सिंह सर से संपर्क करना है

[@ravirana2021]

Bhai n acha business suru kiya h .

[@nfak105]

Why is he(anchor) deviating grewal sir from the main topic?

[@rajeshmalik5254]

Mehangaayi aasmaan choo rahi hai, aur inhe organic chahiye...mai kisaan hoon aur dabaa ke potash, dap, urea, pesticides, fungicide daalta hoon aur aage bhi daalta rahunga...mere paas koi dusra option nahin hai...agar ye chemicals daalne ke baad jyada production hote huwe bhi kisaano ki haalat kharaab hai toh socho organic farming ke Kum production se kya haal hoga humara? Sirf bakchodi pelne se kuch nhi hoga...kisaano ko iss desh ke log ubharne he nahin Dena chahte...apna hakk maangte he deshdrohi kah deti hai sarkar aur unke chele.

[@HarpalGrewal-o9c]

Grow organic for your family atleast. Start thinking about future of(JAT’S) coming generations health.

[@rajeshmalik5254]

@@HarpalGrewal-o9c Karta hoon apne 500 gaj ke plot mein, sirf family ke liye...guava, chickoo, jaamun, mango, papaya, lemon ke ped bhi hain ussi plot mein...sabzi mein lockey, tori, bhindi, baingann, tomato, green chilli lagaa rakhe hain..seasonal sabzi botaa hoon...kheto mein possible nahin hai jab tak mere chaaro taraf ke khet maalik fertilizer daalenge tab tak tubewell ke paani mein bhi uska asar jaayega aur khet overflow hone se direct mere khet mein bhi maal masala aa jaayega...plot isolated hai, kheto se door gaon mein...issliye plot mein karta hoon..

[@jigsaw2281]

Agriculture expert chaiye tha naki book likhne wala history culture p

[@pushpendraverma8463]

लोग अपने और खेत दोनों के लिए दवाई (जहर) खरीदना चाहते हैं😂😂😂 Agriculture is just a business for them! Government also don't want to loose its profit and control.😂😂😂

[@poojagupta2588]

जय श्री राम

[@NitishYadav-lb7zc]

Only 15 k views 💔

[@rahulgolikeri1187]

👌👍🙏

[@yatribaxi1307]

Very immature interviewer , not prepared, unaware of agriculture and discussing details of farming ...there is no order , for farmers this will not be helpful

[@rschoudhary108]

This was for policy makers sir. Not for farmers.

[@divyasingh-hs3lh]

ग्रेवाल जी कोई प्रशिक्षण कराते हैं क्या, अगर कराते हैं तो कब

[@yawninggap2328]

They need to switch to Biodynamic farming then things will improve.

[@ShivamGangwar-it7is]

Tcbt के बारे में क्या बिचार है

[@rajendrarathodofficial6142]

જય આયુર્વેદ

[@-PramodMehta]

India me tho fertilizers consumption per haters abi b bouth kam hai.

[@sivafzzy4181]

English sub title

[@namanpal123]

Why is the anchor grinning at every scentence . Please call him again and create a structure of the interview beforehand . Go through every issue pointwise and not haphazardly.

[@Prosperity_krishna]

Bhai please don't ruin it make a organic expert anchor

[@vikramraina5414]

Put a better anchor to interview ...

[@deepsalame6549]

#tcbt kheti

[@sudiptahalder241]

Copied techniques

[@KrishiMandirOrganics]

But how to do it ? Bhai Kya nahi ho raha hai Vo to suna Per karein kya ? Ghanti prakash kapoor ky kaha vo pata hi chala Make a vdo on ayurvedic kheti forget Wht is not happening we would love to draw from ur knowledge

[@nvspraneeth901]

Sad state because it gives sad outputs

[@mayanksinghfartiyal5290]

I feel awkward just looking at the anchor, bhai jab nahi pata toh chup raho na aur pro ko bolne do

[@kamaljain7661]

Chup reh ke bhi interview ho saktaa hai baahi 😢

[@letsfight9472]

🫡

[@-PramodMehta]

Host ko jyda kuch knowledge nhi hai keti ke baare me bas quest k influence me gardan hila rhe hai...

[@रामबीरबैनीवाल]

Host ruined everything...... could have been a grat podcast

[@rschoudhary108]

Could you give me the feedback. I want to improve. This was my first experience as a host.

[@OrganicFarmer123]

​@@rschoudhary108you should have cross- questioned him. It seems that you are not prepared well with questions. there are lot fause given by interviewee you didn't fill that gaps by cross questioning him you just kept noding and grinning which is not expected by the audience.

[@vanshmaggo7749]

Ye jaat khatrio ki zameen lekr baitha hain soot boot main. Nanak ji ne kaha tha drop your surnames ans use only singh and kaur, why he is using chaudhary??

[@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL]

Khatri never owned any land apart from British grants they were shudra letter writers and small shopkeepers. Guru Nanak ji never asked for SinghKaur surname it was by Guru Gobind ji for those becoming Khalsa. Never asked to remove your titles or tribal surnames

[@vanshmaggo7749]

@@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL how can be shudras more white and fair skinned than so educated and civilized dark skinned jats who don't know how to read and write. And for your information if you think jats owned land than you are wrong, whoever was the ruler of that area owned the land, jaats were just people who used to farm and look out for crops, and they didn't even owned the crops cause it was property of the raj. Status of jats were same as today's biharis who works on other lands

[@Ramarao-dq8mf]

Kisne banaya policies, kisne govt ko sath diya..Punjab se nasha har jagha pahuncha.kyo nahi thukraya green revolutionko...

[@anandtiwary2869]

Policies were made by Congress to get more votes than Akali Dal