संवाद # 103: Pushyamitra Shunga, Indo-Greeks & dark period of Indian history |

[@varunkhugshal9049]

Great podcast, ability of guest to give multiple sources and multiple explanation is great. More we go back in time, more history becomes less of facts and more of stories.

[@sumitdutta7043]

That's what I liked the most

[@zhanepal969]

barahman apne app mahraj keshe bolegaa .ohh barahmn xetrya sastar pakray . barahmn kam Shikhan hay chalna xetrya ko hi Mubarak ho magera achhe chalna ann chay orna taygi population jada ho chuka hai

[@anmoldarjee3162]

​@@zhanepal969bhai English main bol Hindi samajh nhi aya tera

[@AbhinavKumar-rt7le]

​@@zhanepal969pahela to jab koi apna dharam bhul jata hai too use apna karm yaad dilwana brahaman ka karm hota hai aur second thing uske vansaj fir se aa rahe hai bharat to muslim se bachaane ke liye kyuki pahele to kashtriye apna dharam nahi bhule the isliye nahi aaye the but abb aa rahe hai.

[@samayturki]

Loving this series of podcasts with Jay.

[@saurabh6747]

Most relevant podcasts ever listen, kudos to VAAD, other podcasters were only focused on superficial things as they didn't even know about the subject that their host was talking about. One request - Pls invite Dr Abhijit Chavada.

[@namansrivastav2008]

Chavda is ridiculous . Very right leaning with no knowledge

[@alani3992]

Yes that Chavda has no research or papers published. Just calls himself and his opinion 'expert' lol.

[@Kkkushwah7905]

यश वर्धन भाई बहुत ईमानदारी से बात कहते है। ऐसे ही सच्चाई के साथ बने रहना।

[@anuragprakash5386]

Pushyamitra Shunga was a great King who saved Bharat / sanatan dharma .

[@ashokpanda8805]

Right

[@aa_572]

Jay vardhan is no nonsense historian. Grt podcast as always.

[@theanalyst1367]

When I saw the notification of this video I was just amazed and surprised because I was eagerly waiting for another video of jayvardhan .

[@sanjaysaini9879]

This series with Jay has been excellent and very informative.

[@dogged_unexpected6664]

Hail Pushyamitra shung 🔥

[@mahanirvaantantra]

Hail the brahmin king who restored dharma and protected bharat from malechhas ❤️

[@tonmoy1549]

@parmeshwari Purano me Boddho ke purvach ko dharm manne wale Asur kaha gaya hai.

[@mahanirvaantantra]

@@Rakshita442 te saala koi fake id bheemta hai 😂😂😂😂😂

[@economicsadda7376]

@@Rakshita442 madam abhi podcast mein bataya pushyamitra shunga ko bhuddo se nafrat nahi thi aapki imagination pushyamitra shunga ko villan banane ki

[@kanishkkumar5431]

@@mahanirvaantantra tu bhi harami sanghi lag rha h

[@tarunyadav7026]

this podcast is bahut hi accha ,very good for knowing our past and also for competitive exams revision ,loved it

[@Learner21]

Please continue bringing Jay. Delight to listen to his nonopinioned history.

[@hotfun07]

This is a beautiful series ❤ So much to learn.

[@bharatbhushanmanitripathi2095]

महान पुष्यमित्र शुंग के समय ही भारत को सोने की चिड़िया कहा गया।

[@reelandvlogs]

क्या भारत अखण्ड था उनके टाइम में अगर नहीं था तो सोने की चिड़िया कहा से हुवा कुछ भी

[@ZuhaibAhmad-hr3wc]

I have been watching your history podcast from Swat valley, Pakistan. We see various Buddhists coming from around the world to visit the Buddhist remains of the past as we do have them in abundance. We also have the remains of the kushan empire, and an Italian archeologist has been doing the excavations of the sites here for more than 20 years. Swat valley was part of the Ghandara region. Plz I would really like to watch a podcast particularly focused on the history of our valley and the region.

[@TheROI-republicOFindia]

Relegion? You are mslim thankyou 😊

[@ZuhaibAhmad-hr3wc]

@@TheROI-republicOFindia yes, I'm Muslim. Why did you ask me my religion?

[@SAGARji495]

The local buddhist of sindh help arab invader Mohammad ibn qasim against raja dahir Source - Chachnama

[@PoonamMohite-db8bj]

Sir, Hindus and Brahmans were Slaves under Muslim Mughal Empire.

[@Tech_burner-c8g]

​@@PoonamMohite-db8bj Buddhist were literally finished under their rule

[@witchilich]

Arabic sources will ofcourse paint it as if they had local support. Since Buddhism is gone, now lets pretend Buddhist were supporting Arabs.

[@walterwhiteeee]

Chachnana isn't a contemporary source

[@rahulparewa6535]

& Birbal was chokidar Akbar & a bhrmanis try to kill shivaji maharaj form back..what about ur thoughts on this? Jo bhr s aaye h sbne Bharat ko he toda h

[@no-one3296]

Mere vichar mey to Pushyamitra shung ne kuch galat nahi kiya apne raja Brihadratt ko maar ke kyuki jab Malechh Bharat ki dharti par bar bar akraman kar rahe thay tab bhi ye bhoddh raja Ahinsa ki mala jap raha tha. Pushyamitra senapati thay aur ek Brahman bhi thay unhone matrabhumi ki raksha ke liye humare Sanatan Dharma ke "Dharm Hinsa tataiv cha" ke sidhant ko apnaya na ki khud Raja ban ne ke liye. Isliye jab tak ve jeevit rahe kabhi Raja ki upadhi khud ko nahi di. Naman hai aise rashtra bhakt veer ko. Agar wo na hote to Bhuddh dharam ki ye self defeating ahinsa ki neeti Bharat mey vyapak roop se feil jaati aur hum aage chal kar muslim akrantao se ladd kar apna dharam bhi nahi bacha paate aur Bharat aaj ek muslim rashtra ban gaya hota.

[@kanishkkumar5431]

Achha...kya hi mazzak h.. Saale rajputo ko vajeh se bharat ghulam bna ... saare khud me ldte rhte the.....aur mughlo ko support kiya .....asal me tm sanghis ke vajeh se bharat ghulam bna . Jab tak budhh the bharat me ek bhi invaders successful nhi hue

[@malharj]

You have to become strong to protect You're motherland nonviolence never gives you the happiness

[@ParthMusic]

PushyaMitra Shung Amar rahein. ♥️♥️♥️

[@amitsingh131193]

Are Chachaa Thambha thambha !! Ap sahi ho maratho ne bhi kuch nahi Kiya Tha isliye Pesvane kaman Sambhali thi.. ap sahi hoo😅 jahil insan ..

[@debangadas8669]

desh bachane wala islie ourote ke lie ladkor mori

[@JaagUthaHaivaan]

Found your channel few days back. Very comprhensive and enlightening podcasts. On the same lines of interplay of Hinduism and history, would love to see some discussion on how Hinduism, its philosophy and iconography spread in South east Asia and even East Asia without any violence, the influence of Cholas, Pallavas etc in this regard.

[@sumitaggarwal6653]

History is itself a teacher from which we can learn many things.🧐🙏🙏👍

[@voldebean6055]

We cannot learn from history we are the history.

[@bhuvanc4992]

The last Iranian ruling dynasty also called themselves Pahlav. The king who was deposed in 1979 was Shah Muhammad Reza Pahlavi.

[@siddave549]

Buddhism is a great religion and Gautam Buddha was one of India's greatest religious leaders and philosophers but unfortunately reality is Buddhism made us weak and that is why we failed to defend our country when we were invaded. Even Mauryan empire fell apart because Ashoka simply lost his mind and reversed the original expansionist policy followers by earlier Mauryan Emperors.

[@rahultiwari-dx8qo]

That's a nonsense excuse Asoka was a Buddhist even before kalinga war he didn't renounce being a warrior ..the empire simply tell apart after his death because it was such a huge empire almost equal to size of empire under aurangzeb that it was impossible to administer and keep control of such a vast land

[@siddave549]

@@rahultiwari-dx8qo i am blaming his pacifist policies . Yes it is true he was a kind of a buddhist before kalinga war. Renouncing of war was a bad idea.

[@chitragatha-anshudeepdhusi5752]

Buddha was not a great philosopher. He was an alien warlord who was sent into our glorious history, by the use of time machine. Aurangzeb and Hitler appointed him to weaken Hindu Empire by his illusionistic arts of psyco terrorism, and Buddha was getting a salary of ₹ 20 per annum by Atal Bihari Vajpayee Ji on the instructions of Queen Elizabeth. Buddha also owned a BMW M5 by investing in RCM business plans. All the so called bhikkhus like Ananda, etc were actually the members of RCM business network, who were joined below Buddha. Buddha also had attacked maxico and Egypt with ten thousand charioteers and 12 lakh infantry. Buddha killed 70000000000000000000000000 human beings within half an hour by his own sword, in the battle of Waterloo. This was the real reality of Buddha.

[@extraordinarygamer937]

@@chitragatha-anshudeepdhusi5752 so a Muslim is disguising itself now

[@chitragatha-anshudeepdhusi5752]

@@extraordinarygamer937 Muslim never need to disguise, it's always animation that needs to be continued by the essence of humanity of reproduction of understanding of captainship of heroism, under the banner of peculiarisation. Jai Mata di just rock,💋💋💋💋

[@nishanktiwari1998]

Pushyamitra Shunga ko zabardasti hi villain banaya jaata hai...

[@vishnumeena2976]

History me Inka milta to kuch he nhi jabardasti ghusaoge to dhkke hi milenge

[@vishnumeena2976]

Dhanadev ke shilalekh me kya likha he maharaj

[@vishnumeena2976]

Me tumse puch rha hu ki tumne kya pda dnadev abhilekh me

[@vishnumeena2976]

Kis Bhasa me he lipi konsi he

[@vishnumeena2976]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/p327qo2eq7iXsKM

[@omcarterios]

बौद्धों ने भारत को बहुत कुछ ऐसा दिया है जिस पर हम गर्व कर सकते है। संस्कृत की प्राचीनता संदिग्ध है। पाली, प्राकृत और मागधी के धातु (root words) से संस्कारित हो कर संस्कृत बनी है। इसलिए इन भाषाओं में बहुत ज्यादा अंतर भी नही है।

[@abhishek894]

Thanks

[@ShivamKumarDas-sh3yb]

The way Jay bhaiya feel happiness while describing history ❤

[@lbmallya]

Please read Six Golden epochs of Indian history by Veer Vinayak Damodar Savarkar. He has written a great deal about Pushyamitra Agnimitra and Medhtithi.

[@Eff_off-x21]

Sure👍

[@rajkamalpatpingua2524]

Sorryvarkar😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@rahultiwari-dx8qo]

Suarworker was not a historian he had propogated genocide and killing of muslims and rape as means of restoring dharma such bastaed cannot be taken seriously

[@shivam00668]

​@@rajkamalpatpingua2524 जैसे अशफाक उल्ला खान ???? 🤔😂 कम से कम सावरकर ने गांधी की तरह अंग्रेजो से हथियार नही मांगे जर्मन के कत्लेआम के लिए 😂

[@utkarshchannel8]

😂 😂 😂 😂 😂 😂 😂 😂 😂 Kuch bhi

[@akj616]

History somewhere is also an interpretation of our ancient texts and events .

[@chitragatha-anshudeepdhusi5752]

इससे प्रमाणित होता है कि न तो पुष्यमित्र शुंग ने बौद्ध भिक्षुओं का कोई बड़ा संहार किया था। और न ही वह कोई बड़े राजा थे।

[@बाबाभारतीय]

शांतिप्रिय बोद्ध धर्म से ब्राह्मण लोगो का धंदा बंद हो गया था इसलीये ब्राह्मण लोगो ने चाल चल कर बोद्ध भिकू का कतलेआम किया जाण से मारा ब्राह्मण धोकेबाज हे

[@milindrokde7233]

जब अहिंसा अतिरेक होकर राज्य धोके मे आ जाता है। तब उस अहिंसाकी हिंसा करनी पडती है।

[@PradeepKumar-nk7vm]

Galat pushyamitra shung Ek Bodh Raja tha Kyunki Hamen Jo Sapoot Milte Hain usmein unhone Bodh Bihar ko theek karaya aur naye baudh Vihar banaen lekin Hamen Ek bhi Aisa Saboot Nahin Milta ki unhone mandir ka Nirman Kiya ya Hindu mandir moortiyon ka Nirman Kiya

[@Strellinhindii]

Bhimte sidhe sidhe party banakar election jeet nahi paa rahe isliye SC,ST,OBC,MINORITY, GANV, GARIB, MAJDOOR,KISAN JAISE Nare lagakar hinduon ke khilaf jahar ugalta hai

[@श्रीमंत_बाजीराव_पेशवा]

😂😂😂😂​@@PradeepKumar-nk7vm

[@shakeelabhatta467]

Always Best Episode 👏👏

[@rohanroynameless]

पुष्यमित्र शुङ्ग 🚩

[@badarpurschool9618]

Addicted to this podcast

[@piyushsonone7]

Great series

[@ranand089]

so well-researched...this guy is so well read

[@atharvanaikwadi7539]

Thanks for making this podcast 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@kartheeque]

Sanskrit and Prakrit should be seen as different registers of the same language, like a literary and spoken variety of the same language. It is like, when someone writes a book or gives a formal speech, they use formal hindi, but while talking commonly, they may have colloquial usages. The person won't see them as two different languages, but rather as two different registers to be used in different circumstances. Sanskrit was probably limited to scholarly, literary and educational circles, and the prakrit form for inscriptions etc.

[@tonmoy1549]

Prakrit falls under MIA(Middle Indo-Aryan) languages.

[@prasanthbodlapati3543]

what you said is true. Prakriti vs vikriti e.g. dharma vs dhamma

[@darkprince2490]

@@tonmoy1549 stop believing everything vomited out by gora

[@SodiumSyndicate]

@@tonmoy1549 There is nothing called Indo-Aryan or Aryan anything. These are Nazi ideas.

[@rishavkumar1250]

@@baagi2187 lol 😂

[@bharat7917]

Buddhist texts are full of exaggerations on the "persecutions" carried out by non-Buddhist kings on Buddhists.

[@Strellinhindii]

Specially in translated books 😮😮

[@rahulparewa6535]

So es Geeta kitabe bhgwn m likh di? Itni calamity aaj or y kitabe bch gye dinosaurs mar gye or kitabe bch wah bc😂

[@Strellinhindii]

@@rahulparewa6535 मित्र आपको यह ज्ञान होना चाहिए कि यह सभी ग्रंथ मनुष्यों ने अपने स्मृति में कंठस्थ किए थे और उन्हीं के वंशावली को आज ब्राम्हण के नाम से जाना और धर्म को मिटाने की इच्छा रखने वाले लोगों द्वारा घृणित रूप मे प्रस्तुत किया जाता है

[@theghostwhowalks2097]

Quoting Romila Thaper and I left the podcast.

[@tonmoy1549]

Why?

[@mahanirvaantantra]

This is called living in an echo chamber bro. Romila Thapar is a communist historian but she is an authority on the field and she is a vidushi. She interprets history with a marxist pov.

[@theghostwhowalks2097]

@@mahanirvaantantra history is not an opinion but representation of facts which her ilk did not know they have been poisoning Indian History with paid fiction.

[@sumitdutta7043]

I alao don't like her But again its the marxist lense of viewing and speaker gives you all the alterante options not like one, so behave like a mature person and listen to it.

[@aa_572]

Gobar minded detected.

[@abhaykanth5577]

Dhanybad ❤😂

[@bhuvanmaravi750]

अखण्ड भारत केवल मौर्य साम्राज्य ही था। हथियार छोड़ने के बाद केवल सम्राट असोक ही हैं जिन्होंने साम्राज्य का विस्तार बिना हथियार के किया।🇮🇳

[@itsmedude4965]

Oh acha...5bc se 5000 BC tk kya sare jnpdh thy....Abe ..dng s pdh leftist ka etas pdhkr bonk rha h

[@Pratigyaa382]

​@@itsmedude4965कोई पढ़े या न पढ़े पर तेरी भाषा तुझे अनपढ़ से भी गैर गुजरा बता रही है।😊

[@reelandvlogs]

बिलकुल पुष्यमित्र ने है यूनानी लोगों को बुलाया था ओर मौर्य वंश का नाश किया अशोक के राज शाशन में उनकी हिम्मत नहीं हुयी और उनके पुत्र हत्या करके खुद राजा बना और ब्राह्मण वाद किया और फिर जातीवाद किया तब से और आज तक ये सब चलरा है

[@reelandvlogs]

जो ये भाई ज्ञान देरा है पुष्यमित्र का वो पूरा ग़लत है बिलकुल ग़लत

[@PrashantE4]

चार बार बोल चुके हो ,कि गलत है ......अगर इतनी समझ है ,तो बताओ ,क्या गलत है !!!!!आप का रवैया समझदारों वाला नही है ....बस चलती गाड़ी को रोकने वाला ही है ।​@@reelandvlogs

[@rj-hd6hy]

Awesome as always 👍

[@Rahul_Aryan_6594]

Buddhists made our boundary weaker that's why shiks have to originate..for the defence 😢

[@witchilich]

bullshit

[@bijayahamal1668]

Then later Hindu made boundaries weaker that’s why British captured India later?

[@lipun1531]

​@@bijayahamal1668then hindu wake up and give india independence

[@ranjanchaudhery8479]

Arihant bhai keep inviting this guy... Awesome episode

[@nitink15]

यवन, श्वेत हुण, कृष्ण हुण, शक, कुशाण इनके बाद म्लेंछ भारत आये।

[@kavitasharma4257]

सब अपने पूर्वज की जय बोलते

[@बाबाभारतीय]

सभी गांडू थे साले

[@indianatlarge]

This session took me back to my school days in TN, where I studied in cbse medium, research is all about af-pak for most part which is not part of present day political india

[@arya229]

Im Watching from patliputra. 😮

[@biomind]

Kushm dhavj

[@bharatperiwal9720]

amazing . Do keep doing ur work

[@vishalgupta50]

Jai pushyamitra shunga

[@SANCHIT18OCT]

Much awaited Well done👍

[@Playerone1287]

We are enjoying Jay's podcasts because they are full of information unlike biased opinions like Wikipedia historians like Abhijit chawda

[@debalinamukherjee7197]

woh bhi sehi bolte hai esa nehi woh koi galat bolte hai

[@arkadeepchanda9524]

​@@debalinamukherjee7197 thik bolecho

[@Nationalist04]

Bhencho koi b Chu Xavier likh k ulte seedhe comment karta rehta hai aajkal

[@shubh4268]

Oooo god his video is sooooooooooooo much of relevance ... For me especially as a History Honours student

[@general9064]

Lol, i learn vedic jyotish and brihat samhita could be hallucinating then lol because many concepts of vedic astrology are absent in western or yavana astrology, but there is a mention of a few techniques we got from them which we acknowledge them and even phaladeepika mentions it. The navgrahas are mentioned in vedas, which are easy older than any yavana. Also, we have so many concepts which are just not present in any western astrology concepts...

[@mailnitish7]

Detailed description by guest is awesome 👍.

[@AbcDef-gw4dg]

Not mentioning time is a ancient tradition Mantra and Kaal are kept secret.😊😊

[@rubyashraf]

Wat do you mean

[@tonmoy1549]

@@rubyashraf He means that his worthless ancestors were so high on themselves that they didn't even care to mention the time period of an event.

[@rk8604]

Wonderful podcast

[@rhythmkhandelwal2940]

Pushyamitra Shunga, the name which is burning bhimtas and neo buddhiheen tists asses to this day and giving them nightmares😂😂😂

[@aarren2]

your father jaywardhan is still child to read history....he believes in purana as a source of history...

[@rhythmkhandelwal2940]

@@aarren2 I don't even know who he is 😂😂 neither do I care

[@hindkisaanmunch7501]

​@aarren2 Abey Anpad he raho ge tabhi tumhe sabse niche rakha gaya hai nahi toh aadmi aadmi me koi bhed nahi hai per gadhe ko bhi gahr se bahar he banadha jata hai Ander nahi.

[@veryrarecoinhusssain4373]

Baba sahab ambedkar bo naam hai jisse aryo ke jalte he nahi fat jati hai

[@rhythmkhandelwal2940]

@@veryrarecoinhusssain4373 Lol 😂 Booba Saheb ko kon seriously leta hai 😂😂 Mota Bhim

[@sleepEasy2]

history has always been less about the facts from the grounds more about what you can imagine.

[@debadityapurkyastha1777]

Great knowledge

[@ishaanrohmetra3447]

heliodorus pillar vasudev The Heliodorus Pillar is a stone column that was erected in Vidisha, India, during the 2nd century BCE by Heliodorus, a Greek ambassador of the Indo-Greek king Antialcidas. The pillar bears an inscription in Brahmi script which identifies Heliodorus as a devotee of the god Vasudeva, who is identified as an incarnation of Lord Krishna. The inscription on the pillar reads: "This Garuda-standard of Vasudeva (Vishnu), the god of gods, was erected here by the Bhagavata Heliodoros, the son of Dion, a man of Taxila, sent by the Great Greek (Yona) king Antialkidas, as ambassador to King Kasiputra Bhagabhadra, the Savior son of the princess from Benares, in the fourteenth year of his reign." The mention of Vasudeva as an incarnation of Lord Krishna is significant, as it indicates that the worship of Lord Krishna had spread beyond the confines of traditional Hinduism and had been adopted by Greek ambassadors and other foreigners. The inscription on the pillar also provides valuable information about the cultural and religious exchanges that took place between India and Greece during the Hellenistic period.

[@KamleshPednekar-zt6dp]

Bhot se historians he jo pushyamitra ko boddho ka dushman mante he leki wo ye baat bhul jate he ki agar wo dushman hote to nalanda aur takshila khilji ke ane ke pahile hi nasta kar dete wo ye baat bhul jate he ki acharya chanayak jo ek brahmin he unho ne bhi dhananda ko marne keliye chandra gupta maurya ko tayar kiya tha taki wo greek raja ko bharat mein akraman karne keliye rok sake wo hi chandragupta jo samrat ashoka ke purvaj the jinhone akhand Bharat ka nirman kiya tha agar pushya Mitra shunga na hote to samarat ashok ka ankhand bharat greek rajao ke karan invade ho jata

[@Qwerty0007]

Bhimate aur Buddhu Bhikku abhi bhi Samrat Pushyamitra Shung ke naam se thartharate hai 😂

[@MarathaHistoryBuff]

You are doing a great job...

[@speedstar6140]

In this whole arguement I see a lot of influence of western theologies. I see too much focus on the era between 300 BC - 200 AD and too less on focus on the era before 300 BC. They are differentiating between Greeks, Scythians at the timeline being discussed, however they fail to showcase the commonality between the different cultural interactions......I was also expecting some reference of the Dashrajan War from Rig-Veda!

[@sarveshbahulekar2187]

Jai vardhan singh bhaiyya zindabad🚩

[@rvd597]

@jay vardhan sir... Why don't you have podcast in Hindi.. I listen your podcast regularly I feel you are stronger in Hindi language

[@aa_572]

He has a hindi KZbin channel

[@lalluchettan]

He reaches an international audience with English

[@rvd597]

@@aa_572 Can you please share the name Or link

[@rvd597]

@@lalluchettan Agree with you but sometimes some meanings get diatorted

[@lalluchettan]

@RVD Can you give just two examples?

[@reynolddsouza4357]

'What is perhaps especially valuable about The Buddha and the Sahibs is Allen's gentle reminder of exactly how and why Buddhism died out in the land of its birth. Every child in India knows that when the Muslims first came to India that they desecrated temples and smashed idols. But what is conveniently forgotten is that during the Hindu revival at the end of the first millennium AD, many Hindu rulers had behaved in a similar fashion to the Buddhists." Fri 27 Sep 2002 19.43 WD The Guardian Deceit has come a full circle.

[@bijayagarwal6326]

Marxist ke alawa tumhare pass koi reference nahi Hai kya hamare desh me koi aur historian paida nahi hua Jo aahi history india ke Bata sake

[@randomturd1415]

Independence ke baad Marxists ka dominance badh gya(nehru socialist tha isiliye) Independence ke pehle bahut type ke historians the

[@commentpatroller-wf6yo]

Kaan khol ke suno bhai

[@unmuktyatree8200]

i wish we can have map and time line prested and stamp all the time on the screen...Great talk

[@amitbhau]

भिमटे :-अशोक के समय एक भी ब्राम्हण नहीं था. पुषयमित्र शुन्ग नामक ब्राम्हण ने आसमान से टपक कर अशोक के पोते का वध कर अशोक मौर्या साम्राज्य का अंत कर दिया 😂

[@akitodaisuke6532]

रामटे - विक्रमादित्य ने युरोप तक साम्राज्य फैलाया मक्का ही मक्केश्वर है जय हो लन्ढाधीपती शिवटे रामटे की 😂🤣

[@Bharat21vats]

​@@akitodaisuke6532 hathi ke oolad विक्रमादित्य pe ज्ञान दे गे 😂😂

[@akitodaisuke6532]

@@Bharat21vats ramtu jara proof toh dena tera chikramaditya ka🤭🤭

[@Bharat21vats]

@@akitodaisuke6532 उज्जैन आओ कभी

[@akitodaisuke6532]

@@Bharat21vats bevdey ramto ka ujjain 🤮.

[@AnilKumar-bv8uv]

इन लोगो के बात चीत में मान रहे की संस्कृति की उत्पत्ति पाली प्राकृत के बाद की है।

[@pn3874]

The history teacher we need

[@Niteshkumarnitesh-rr5rp]

Good jankari ser ji

[@KetanJayade]

jay has his own interpretations we respect that but they doesnt seems to be anywhere near reality

[@rishavkumar1250]

What he says is based upon research ,go and start your own channel pajeet

[@rubyashraf]

Please say clearly

[@psk5849]

Yup a historian phd scholar is far away from reality and someone with whatsap chap knowledge is close to reality

[@devanshu6335]

One of the best podcast..but note for interviewer that please don't drag questions for too long it is wasting time.

[@vickydonor5922]

Ye hamesha Romila thapar, Irfan Habib ko quote karta rahta hai..iske pahle wale videos me bhi dekha hai. Aur Romila, Irfan ka point of view to sabko maloom hi hai.

[@pushkarraj5673]

kp jayaswal ko bhi kiya hai bhai, aankh khol ke dekha kar video

[@kanishkkumar5431]

@@pushkarraj5673 sab sale apni ideology ke hisab se history change kr rhe h

[@aryanpandey8105]

​@@kanishkkumar5431 tum bhi history change kar rahe ho

[@kanishkkumar5431]

@@aryanpandey8105 kya change kiya maine. . Ye sanghi aur madarchhap ek hi jamaat ke lag rhe h

[@krmusic3523]

मेरे हिसाब से उस समय के कोई राजा एक देश के लिए नहीं लड़ रहे थे, सभी अपने अपने राज्य को बढ़ाने के लिए लड़ रहे थे।

[@nav19ty]

ये जो महान historian है | ये अपनी बुद्धि इस्तमाल करते है या नहीं? या इन्होने ये कहा उन्होंने वो कहा पर ही आश्रित है?? "रोमिला थापर ने कहा की भारत ने जो अंकतरिक्ष क्षेत्र मे जो जानकारी हांसिल की वो हूणों की देंन थी" पहली बात to ये की हम रोमिला थापर को historian नहीं मानते होंगी वो विद्वान् लिखी होंगी उन्होंने कई पुस्तके और होंगी अपने समय मे फेमस लेकिन वो महिला एक नंबर की मार्क्सवादी कम्युनिस्ट है उससे हम साक्ष्ययों के आधार पर एक निकष्पक्ष इतिहास लिखने की उम्मीद नहीं करते और एक बात मुझे ये समझ नहीं आती ये सभी आक्रमणकारी हिंदुस्तान आकर ही कैसे इतने विद्वान् हो जाते है | जबकि इनके ओरिजिन प्लेसेस पर अइसा कुछ नहीं होता हूण अंतरिक्ष के ज्ञान के माहिर हो गये मुग़ल स्थापत्य कला के एक्सपर्ट हो गये 🤦 मुगलो ने हमें तहजीब सिखाई वो लोग जो लूट की चाहत मे दुसरो पर आक्रमण करके अपना पेट पालते थे महिलाओ बच्चो को गुलाम बनाते थे ऐसे historian द्वारा उनको हमें तहजीब सीखाने वाला बताया जाता है दिन लद गये अब मार्कसीस्ट historians के

[@kavitasharma4257]

इनके जुल्म तो ये मानते ही नही सारे हिन्दू के। आप निष्पक्ष कैसे सोच सकते सभी अपने पूर्वजों को चाहते शक के वंशज शक को हूंण हूंण का यवन यवन का कुषाण मुसलमान ईसाई ।

[@Saddas992]

कभी गया भी है जहाँ से वो आये थे, तुम्हारी तहज़ीब,संस्कृति और अस्थापत्य कला जो सनातनी बताते हो उसमे अभी तक लोटा ले कर खेतो में जाने की ही संस्कृति थी जो इक्कीसवीं सदी में भी शौचालय नहीं दे पाये या ये कहो की वो उनकी तहज़ीब में खेतोँ की मेढ़ पर ही हगना हो वो अपने को बहुत ही तहज़ीब याफ़्ता या सुसंस्कृत संस्कारी थे जिन्हे शौचालय बनाने का भी ज्ञान नहीं था वो स्थापत्य कला में माहिर थे 😊🤭

[@PrashantE4]

​@@Saddas992....तो फिर " वो " जहाँ से आए थे ..वहाँ कौन से स्थापत्य और तहज़ीब के झंडे गाड़े हैं ???? मुगले आज़म देख कर अपनी अकल मत झाड़ो .....

[@Saddas992]

@@PrashantE4 अबे व्हाट्सएप्प यूनिवर्सिटी के झंडू प्रोडक्ट, अब बिलकुल सिद्ध हो गया की बस फिल्मों के ज्ञान और व्हाट्सएप्प ज्ञान के इलावा तुम लोगों के पास है क्या तुमने किताबों से कुछ पढ़ा कौन कहाँ का था उसने वहा क्या किया उनके पूर्वज कौन थे उनका योगदान क्या था. तुम मुग़लों के बात करते हो क्या तुझे पता भी है वो कहाँ से आये थे उनके पूर्वज कौन थे, वो जहाँ से आये थे वहाँ जब pm जाते हैं तो वहाँ से दिल्ली तक कॉरिडोर बनवाने की बात करते हैं. तुम जहाँ से पढ़ के निकले हो उन्हें अपनी ही उत्पत्ति का पता नहीं कहाँ से है नहीं मालूम, फ़िल्में न देख चेले विषगुरु के,कुछ पढ़ लिख तब बात करना।

[@pukhrajmansion8445]

Great 👍 👌

[@vedicarya7]

What? He said Manu was between 1st century BCE to 1 century AD but how he's mentioned in Mahabharata many times? Idk about other smritis but kindly do more research about Manu

[@randomturd1415]

I think it means the kanu smriti reached its final form during that era, because of its emphasis on mlecchas(which became populous in India only during that period)

[@wayne7594Vruce]

Mahabharat saara ek time Pr compile nhi hua hai , Mahabharat mai kafi time Tak compilations add hue hain

[@satyajit2007]

Sorry to say the kharabela part is wrong . There are more information this person is unaware of .

[@commentpatroller-wf6yo]

Like?

[@witchilich]

@@commentpatroller-wf6yo read the latest comment by me in this video. I compiled the other mentions and references for kharavela and mahameghavahana. Also, the article by The Hindu, "A confederacy of Tamil kings ". You may have to use Wayback Machine as there is a paywall now.

[@raginisingh2251]

V. Knowledgeable video

[@SenapatiM96]

Matlab Pushyamitra Sunga bina zyada kuch kare hi gaali/tareef khaa rahe.

[@kanishkkumar5431]

Same like ashoka..... Its all about ideology Bharamn supporting Pushyamitra .because of cast .... Wo budhhist ka narsanhaar kiya tha it's It's a fact

[@utkarsh144]

Shunga period mai kai sare great religious, scientific, literary works likhe gaye the, Pinani, Kalidas, Arunabh ko unka contemporary the. It was a great time for Hindu religion.

[@utkarsh144]

​@@kanishkkumar5431 Lol jis Samudragupt ka naam laga rakha h username mai uske bare mai pata bhi h kuch? Lol. Usko bhi chemta bana do

[@kanishkkumar5431]

@@utkarsh144 mai tmhari sanghi nhi hu islye samudragupta naam r kha h......tm log saale jaahil radical hindu kal ko apne baap ko bhi gaali doge jab wo congress ko vote dega .... Ashoka ko badnaam kar ke tmlog khud ki hi badnaami kar rhe ho saath me hinduism ki bhi

[@kanishkkumar5431]

@@Rakshita442 ashoka ka khud ka inscription ye khta h ki wo secular tha sabhi religion pe ... Barabar caves aaj bhi h jo ashoka ne ajivikas ko diya tha .... Tm sanghis saale apni aukat pe aa rhe ho. ..jhuti history propagate kr ke Ashokavadan me ashoka ka chitran sahi lag rha h lekin ussi book ka Pushyamitra Shunga shhi nhi lga Iss doglapan ki wajeh se hindus har jageh pele gye

[@ronny383]

Very addicting 🙏

[@amittripathi5068]

One like for Abhijit Chavada sir.

[@reelandvlogs]

आपका जो ज्ञान है वो ग़लत है माफ़ी चाहते है पर ग़लत है

[@seikiro3462]

Haa bhai tu ek archeologist hai phds hai jo tere information me bharosa kre😂

[@AjayPandey-ft2mu]

अश्वमेध यज्ञ होता है श्रीमान जी

[@tonmoy1549]

Same thing.

[@FromPlanetZX]

@@tonmoy1549 yahi sab choti baat, in jaise historian pe bharosa nhi hone deti.

[@tonmoy1549]

@Animesh Why are you guys so annoying? Ashwamedha 'yagya' and Ashwamedha 'sacrifice' literally mean the same thing.

[@shailpatel6987]

Please continue with this series. It is very informative

[@roopeshs4528]

पुष्यमित्र शगुन तो बौद्ध राजा थे.... ये हिंदू बिंदू कहा से आया 😂😂😂

[@rochakhindi5919]

😂😂😂 to kaise boudh stup toda aur boudh ko kaise mare । Arop to naba boudh aur bhimte lagate hai । bichare pushyamitra sung ko kyu badnam kar rahe ho 😂😂😂

[@Ereeee05]

Shagun bc😂

[@AbhishekBalagaon]

really insightful podcast, But I have a doubt, why do in podcasts like this there is no map shown (I know there is one at 7:37) or kept while discussing like a teacher keeps while giving a lecture, which will be better for viewers to visualise as not all are aware with geographical terms, apart from this really loved the way Jay explains things with proper refs.

[@ReddyAlwaysReady]

Bharatiya Ithihasa after Mahabharatha Mahabharata 3100 BC Bhrihadhtra Dynasty 3100-2100 BC Buddhas actual date is 1850 BCE Maurya 1600-1500 BC Shatavahanas is 800-300 BC Gupta is 300-80 BCE Vikramaditya 57 BC Bhoja 300 AD Vijayanagar 660-1660 AD These are the TRUE dates

[@tonmoy1549]

Lmfao.

[@rajeevkamra9120]

Source?

[@ReddyAlwaysReady]

@@rajeevkamra9120 look at the Kali year that most calendars universally use in India, that will itself give your the year of Mahabharat War. If your not satisfied with that then there are numerous inscriptions which have inscribed the Kali date and Saka or VIkrama date of the inscription. If you date back the number of Kali years, then it will give you 3100 BC as start of Kali yuga. Not just inscriptions, most Hindu calendars give you the Kali year, we have been counting these years thousands of years it didn’t just start a 1000 years ago. It has been written down that Maurya rule started 1500 years after Kali Yuga, so you get 1600 BC for Maurya. Btw, There is no proof at all that Megestanes visited Chandraputa Maurya because it is written that he visited Xandrames, but there is no guantee that is Maurya and not some other King with first name Chandra, there are many Emperors in History with name Chandra, there are two Chandraguptas one in Gupta and Maurya itself. Equating Xandrames to Maurya is pure guess work done by William Jones, and that formed as the Sheet anchor at 323 BC of Western telling of Indian history that all future and past events are based on.

[@tonmoy1549]

@Vamsi Kallen Maurya Empire's advent doesn't correspond to the fall of the first Babylonian dynasty.

[@randomturd1415]

Buddha's date is 600BCish, stop projecting your hindu wet dreams into history

[@harshoful]

Sir आप शानदार काम कर रहे है।

[@PoonamMohite-db8bj]

Hail Great Buddhist Emperors Bimbisar, Ajatshatru, Kalashok, Ashoka, Menander, Kanishka 🙏

[@SAGARji495]

Sister Buddhist are responsible for ahimsa The local buddhist of Sindh helped Mohammad ibn qasim against Raja dahir Plz see facts sister Don't have for hate Brahmins and kshatriya kings 😊 We hindus don't believe in jatiwaad today we believe in unity of hindus and Buddhist but some jai bheem jai meem people don't like the unity

[@बाबाभारतीय]

@@SAGARji495 ब्राह्मण बेमाण धोकेबाज थे जो बोद्ध धर्म का नुकसान किया नालंदा जलाई

[@aproudjagannathbhaktkaling6054]

Buddhist bane isiliye to khatam ho gaye 😅

[@shauryapratapsingh4893]

Waiting for ep4

[@drsanjaykumar3448]

खुद के भी देवताओं को यहां लेकर आए थे जो आज भी यहां पूजे जाते हैं

[@Strellinhindii]

जैसे अम्बेडकर 😢

[@blackmoon655]

Rajput king British ke gulam tha india ka asli gadar rajput hai.

[@Pratigyaa382]

पीछे कुछ भी रहा हो,पर कितने लोग है जो आज के सच को जानना चाहते हैं,और उसे सुधारना चाहते हैं। जिसमे प्रमुख है,जातिवाद,बेरोजगारी,भूखमरी,गरीबी।क्या सोचते है सब इसके बारे में।

[@MOHIT836]

Ye jnu waale sab ek hi tarah hote hain

[@sumitdutta7043]

Dude even Jaishankar waa from jnu. Best thing avout him is that he is giving you multiple versions not like left snd right's single version

[@kanishkkumar5431]

@@sumitdutta7043 this host looks sanghi. ... Bhraminical ideology ko promote kiya jaa rha h.... ab kal ko ram rahim ko bhi glorify krega

[@sumitdutta7043]

​@@kanishkkumar5431 ramrahim koi bhi glorify nhi skta uske apne anuyaio k alawa.

[@kanishkkumar5431]

@@sumitdutta7043 this radical sanghi can do anything . Agar mahaan samrat ashoka ko abuse kar skte h toh ramrahem lo bhi apna baap bna skte h

[@kanishkkumar5431]

@@sumitdutta7043 pratik borade is a prime example of radical sanghi. ...jo review krta h ...aur asaram bapu ka chela h

[@ashishpatel350]

great work

[@hichcock7364]

पुष्यमित्र यह बौध्द मौर्य राजा ही था, ब्रह्मण किसीभी ताकतवर को अपना बाप बनानेसे नही चुकते, अनेक गपोड ग्रन्थ लिखकर कन्फुजन बनाते है. फर्जी परशुराम को बनाकर क्षत्रिय को मरवाया उसी तरहा पुष्यमित्र को बौद्ध धर्म विनाशक बताया, ईन गपोड ब्रह्मण कागजपे ही मर्दानगी दिखाते है.

[@hichcock7364]

@@jkayush पिछवाडे मे मिरची लगी क्या

[@karanshukla2966]

@@hichcock7364 वह बेटे दूसरो को ज्ञान देने से पहले खुद मे झाँक लो पुष्यमित्र को पहले गालियाँ दी वामपंथियो भीम वादियों ने और आज उसको बौद्ध बताकर बाप भी बना लिया कहाँ से लाते हो ये दोगलापन और ये पुष्यामित्र तुम्हारा बाप कब से बन गया 😂😂😂🤣🤣

[@ashishlohani7683]

Abe lodu tere baudhh granth or bhikshu ne hi pushyamitra ko brahman or baudhh birodhi bataya hai

[@omgomg3002]

Buddhu is a big gandu.

[@hichcock7364]

@@omgomg3002 तुम जैसे सन्नाटुन्नी को पिछवाडे मे अंधाकुटिल साप लेने की निंजा टेक्निक पुरानी है

[@kingsahab3741]

Quality content ❤❤

[@sumangaldhurandhar5268]

ब्राम्ही लिपी मे कृष्ण लिखा नहीं जा सकता हैं...क्यो गापोडी गप बाताए जा रहे हो...?? संस्कृत भाषा मुगल कालीन हैं उसे क्यो प्राचीन बताते हो...!!

[@karanshukla2966]

जर्नी को कम देखा करो और थोड़ा क्रॉस वेरीफाई भी किया करो भाषा लिपि का ज्ञान ना हो , सनातन समीक्षा चैनल पर आ जाना सारा भाषा लिपि का भूत उतर जाएगा😂😂😂

[@sumangaldhurandhar5268]

@@karanshukla2966 जातक समीक्षा वाले दोनो बंदे सबसे बडे गपोडि लाल हैं ... मैं किसी को देखता नहीं हू...बल्की सबको दिखाता हू....! तुम मे थोडी समझ हैं हो तो आ ओ मेरे कू छ प्रश्र्नो के जवाब दो...? बुध अगर काल्पनिक हैं तो फिर टणाटण वाले भुस्वाहजी कहते हैं की बुध के समय ब्राह्माण थे ... यह कैसे संभव हैं या तो ...बुध एक मिथस हैं या तो ...बुध एक वास्तविक हैं...?? मेरी ओर से उंको यह पूछ लो...बुध कल्पना हैं तो उस समय ब्राह्माण कैसे हकीकत हैं...??

[@karanshukla2966]

@@sumangaldhurandhar5268 , यहां अरगुमेंट तुम लोगों के लिए है क्योंकि हर चीज में तुम्हें अभिलेख ही प्रमाण चाहिए होता है तो अभिलेख की प्रमाण के आधार पर तो बुद्ध काल्पनिक ही हुए तो तुम्हारी भाषा में उनको जवाब देना रही बात ब्राह्मणों की पुष्यमित्र शुंग के अभिलेखों को पढ़ लेना वहां पर अश्वमेध यज्ञ और अन्य यज्ञों का उल्लेख आता है यज्ञ को कराने वाले बुद्धिस्ट तो थे नहीं वह तो किसी ब्राह्मण मैं ही संपन्न कराएं होंगे

[@randomturd1415]

Kyunki brahmi lipi me prakrit likha jata tha jisme kisna किसना uccharan(pronounce) krte hai Paida hi ulte hue the ya baad me sir ke bal gire?

[@sumangaldhurandhar5268]

@@Rakshita442 क्या आप मानते है की हिंदू शब्द 1000 साल से पुराणा हैं हिंदू शब्द संस्कृत से आया हैं क्या राम,कृष्ण,कौरव,पांडव ने अपने को हिंदू माना हैं...??? इतना ही नहीं शिवाजी ने तक स्वयं को हिंदू लिखा नहीं है तो इन गपोडि के क्या कहने...! आप क्या मानते हैं इस पर सवाल होना चाहिए न की आप के धर्म ग्रंथ मे क्या लिख रखा हैं..! जातको की बात आपके समझ से बाहर की बात है एक तरफ से भुसवाहजी जाटको की सिरीज चला कर बौद्ध धर्म का प्रचार प्रसार ही कर रहे है... हमारी ऊंसे भूत दया वादी संवेदना हैं. 2bc पूर्व भारत मे बौद्ध धर्म अस्तित्व मे था तभीं तो उसके पुरत्तविक सबुत मिल रहे हैं...आप का क्या है ...?? आप का एक सिंगल ढेळा भी मिळता नहीं है बौद्ध धर्म के ग्रंथ को प ढकर ही आपके बाबूजी को समझना पडता हैं इतिहास मे वेद ,रामायण महाभारत उपनिषद् मनुस्मृती,पुराण का एक सिंगल ढेला भी नहीं मिला है न भविष्य मे मिल्ने की संभावना हैं. आज भी राष्ट्र के ध्वज मे ,राष्ट्र मुद्रा मे,संविधान मे ऐसे कई संकेत चिन्ह हैं जी बौद्ध धर्म को प्रेसेंट करते हैं...! संविधान के किस आर्टिकल मे हिडणू धर्म के तत्व ,नियमन का उद्गम दिखाई पडता है... बता सकते हैं आप...??

[@santoshdeshpande4742]

जयवर्धन जी, पातंजलि नही, पतंजलि कहना चाहिए। सकल नही, शाकल कहना चाहिए -- सियालकोट के लिए ।