Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis | Language and Thought in Urdu/Hindi | Linguistic Determinism and Relativity

Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis | Language and Thought in Urdu/Hindi | Sociolinguistics | Linguistic Determinism and Linguistic Relativity
Language and Thought:
There are three different claims about the relationship of language and thought.
Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis:
It is named after two American Linguists based on; Linguistic Determinism and Linguistic Relativity
#sapir #whorf #linguisticrelativity #linguisticdeterminism #languageandthought #sociolinguistics

[@Yash_rajput14]

Apki vedio se concept Crystal clear hogya .... Thanks sir..

[@fazluddin6903]

I presume, that without language very limited thought is possible .But when thought is channelized through language obviously then language influences the way we think because it enlarges our canvas and gives an extensive approach of the world. 1) If a child is brought up in an isolation with out any language he/she can at least express their pain, pleasure, likes and dislikes. 2) A person with limited understanding of a language has not made any discovery or innovation bkz language is limited that's thinking capacity too.

[@waseemhussain299]

Worth knowledgeable keep sharing 💞

[@bashirahmad3887]

I think thought is primary and it is the thought/brain that affects our language structures. If we have a weak brain or non-working brain or damaged brain we won't be able to think talk or create any theory or philosophy. Yes only thought is not important language has it role in looking and explaining the eorlx view but that too under the directions oc thought.

[@seemabalhara3398]

Claim 3 is correct

[@ZilleHuma-lf7dk]

I was seeking for the main difference between Linguistic determinism and Linguistic relativity. You nailed it bro....❤

[@saidayaz7160]

I think language and thoughts both are similar important because we speaks whatever we thinks and we thinks whatever we listen from other through language

[@ShakeelAhmed-eh4fy]

Well explained easy to understand.

[@Talash-Editor]

Well explanation.. From Pakistan 🇵🇰

[@hyderzurain5382]

An amazing description sir 👌

[@maazahmad7285]

i think language relativity hi thek hai hmari scoh pe asr andaz hoti b language q k hm without language zyada authentic ni soch skty language convey krti h hmari thoughts ko ya language se hi hme sochny ka moqa milta hai not completely but mostly

[@yourlanguagetutor4610]

You have arrived at nice conclusion

[@muhanmmadhxn1166]

Very good explain Thank you Soo much sir

[@rabiaiqbal8374]

Good work ...keep it up,👍

[@amritanand9126]

It was very good explanation. It clears my doubt. Thank you so much from India 🇮🇳.

[@yourlanguagetutor4610]

Your Welcome dear neighbor ❤️

[@usmansani7316]

I watched it some time ago nd thought I will watch again in exam time nd today I searched it many times it was coming at first but I thought there was no man just notes nd on title there was someone so I ignore it nd check all other videos 😂😊🙂

[@alinanoor2108]

Thank you for your efforts sir

[@Dhanaksikandar]

I think thought and language both are important but your thoughts influence your language for example if there is a glass of water which is half filled some people says half filled glass of water some says half empty so it's your cognitive processes who helps you to progenitor of language.

[@saniamalik4426]

your explaining method in urdu was very good and easily understandable. I am easily understand this topic beacuse you exlpained in urdu. Good🥰🥰

[@bismaali2119]

And I really like your videos

[@nomikhan8495]

You deserve million subs

[@hadiqaarshad4218]

Great effort 👏👏

[@khadijakhan8555]

Good lecture

[@saifurrehman7670]

Well done

[@Sujalchaudhary004]

I think claim 2 is correct because language is not the only thing which determines the way we think sometimes certains things happen in our life any trauma or incident also shapes the way we think....🤔

[@zahoorkhan7644]

You have explained very well.Please make more vidoes on sociolinguistics topics.

[@yourlanguagetutor4610]

We have already made videos on the topics of Sociolinguistics Check out our playlist Sociolinguistics: kzbin.info/aero/PL8ZmByG4Cx6pWcgjc9PPlQ4hbk-pw56aA

[@psychojennie8959]

Acha prhaya but ye subject bht boring hai I love literature only 👍

[@zainullahkhan3574]

Thanks alot

[@kingsukbagchi6479]

Very good analysis from India

[@TechnicalAdviceAky]

I think language determine our thoughts For example,if we will put some people of same languages in one and then put other group of same language in another place and gave them a task to do for coming out of that place.then we will see both will think according to their experinces and experince is based on your language

[@adeelaazeemmazeem1337]

Wonderful lecture sir 👍

[@rehmanacademy3431]

Very good 👍. Sir ye question be bta dain plz What revolution corpus has brought about in the field of linguistics?

[@khadizameem1655]

I am Bangali, from Bangladesh 🇧🇩..I can understand hindi a little bit... But I can understand your lecture sir❤️....thank you sir

[@yourlanguagetutor4610]

Your welcome ❤️

[@bismaali2119]

You are doing great

[@SirJamshed.]

You have explain very well sir😊

[@Sabirali-uo7mm]

Got the actual concept here on your channel❤ You are doing very well, keep sharing the concepts love😊

[@anilsharma-ub8xx]

A perfect lecture

[@muhanmmadhxn1166]

May Allah bless you

[@yourlanguagetutor4610]

Ameen

[@funnyvideos-vl9qo]

2nd claim I think more suitable

[@aqsabano3956]

Helpful lecture ❣️

[@jawadabdullah2552]

Very nice

[@sadafuon2437]

Keep it up bro!👍Very Weldon.💫

[@zukhrafmalik4511]

Amazing

[@relaxationworld267]

Thank you a Million

[@RDPGroup-tb4hm]

Thanking you ❤

[@sibghasarwar2662]

It's very helpful

[@mobeenbi1077]

Bhai detail mn George yule book ki glossary discuss kr dy

[@mohsinkhanmk3440]

It's good

[@hassannawaz7884]

make video on the topic of prague school

[@asadullahshaheenofficial2135]

Thank you so much Sir 💓

[@anonymous-f7t]

Please make a video on ideation, referential, and behavioral theory in semantics

[@yourlanguagetutor4610]

sure

[@mutahhartoorvlogs6219]

Give the conclusion of this lecture, finally! Plzz

[@ravijoshi9931]

Sir correct your pronunciation of determined..Many people are watching you and learn from you so please take care.Teaching was good. No doubt about it. 🙏

[@funwithsabaoon891]

MashaAllah 💖

[@liaquatalibaloch2994]

🌹🌹🌹

[@sabasaba1587]

👍👍👍

[@ShaperiyGul]

Excellent ❤

[@zuhaibjaan951]

According to my thinking first one is better because what we think its base upon language if there is no language how can we think!?

[@khan.339]

In my point of view, where there is no language,there are no thoughts.Without language, thoughts are nothing

[@faryalkarim9598]

If I say that 'naya Pakistan ' was something that determines our thoughts ... So it would serve as language determinism and if I quote the example of language relativity as a crying child and it's adherence to his mother ... So are these examples satisfying ?

[@yourlanguagetutor4610]

Watch the video again You will get your answer

[@Slimshady209]

Explained very well and in a simple way which could be understood by anyone... Thanks for saving my mind getting confused ... Keep up the good work .. love from india🙏

[@naureennazar7139]

could you please make a video on background of London school , general ideas and Neo Firthian Linguist.

[@noorchaudhry1348]

Amazing 😍

[@rehmanacademy3431]

Plz jaldi bta dain .ya video bna dain .paper h .mphill ka

[@arishaaemon4004]

I think first claim is true.

[@SimranKaur_2024]

Shukriya sir

[@itvworldwide9470]

Sir linguistics determinism 2 claim p pora ata ha na k 1st claim p But apne opposite btaya

[@yourlanguagetutor4610]

Opposite nhi bataya Watch again

[@amjadhussainhussain4500]

Nice

[@minaelkhan572]

Great work sir 👍👍

[@IfraIqbal-im6lh]

1 think 3rd one

[@Islamicgems592]

Good ❤❤❤❤

[@saifurrehman7670]

💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖

[@rehmanacademy3431]

2nd question What are the research potential associated with corpus?

[@yourlanguagetutor4610]

Sir we will upload this stuff very soon But it may some time because many demanded videos are already in queue Stay tuned! Thank you

[@fishfarmermirzapur4188]

Hello sir , can you provide me the notes of wave model theory of historical linguistics

[@faryalkarim9598]

Sir I have a question here ... If many philosophers or linguists favours language relativity then why it is still considered as a weak version ? And can you put some examples for both of the principles ?

[@hopenotoutandbepositive3331]

necessary to clarify that the words "strong" and "weak" are not related to the strength of the scholarly argumentation, but rather to the degree to which language is assumed to influence our thought and behaviour.

[@hopenotoutandbepositive3331]

Bridging walo kuch samj nahi ata

[@yourlanguagetutor4610]

The strong or weak version of this hypothesis is not determined by the people. It is just a relationship of language and thought driven from the works of Edward Sapir and Benjamin Whorf, with one strong and other weak claim. Now others have rejected the stronger claim of hypothesis but weaker one is accepted till today.

[@hopenotoutandbepositive3331]

Sir can you give some examples on which bases the strong version of hypothesis

[@faryalkarim9598]

@@hopenotoutandbepositive3331 samjh Nhi a rha is Liye tu poch rhy hain s

[@abhilekhbagade2233]

😮😮😮😮 thanks sir

[@Tayyaba-Zahid]

Super

[@Aaaaacc130]

What is the app of this white board animation? Anyone?

[@shaikhiram6398]

2

[@Ayesha-eg2jl]

👍

[@maazahmad7285]

or ye sign language b ho skti h feelings sb kch ni hoti

[@yomilala8929]

Is this English? Because i can't understand most of the video

[@yourlanguagetutor4610]

This video is created in English, Urdu and Hindi

[@wierdoo8469]

(Language and worldview) ye topic

[@hammamgalalhadial-hamed7070]

Please, answer if this true or false, i have a test today, is this hypthesis indicate that, if two persons speak tow different languages, will see the world differently?

[@yourlanguagetutor4610]

Yes But their linguistic region also plays a part

[@pleasurablethings5185]

I think language influences the way we think.

[@itvworldwide9470]

Muhammad Amjad

[@madhushreemaity3856]

Claim 1 is correct

[@ezzahikram5668]

well explained