Sarokaar - Existence of God Vs Science

Does God really exist? Watch the talk and listen to the arguments for and against the claim of God's existence.
Guests: Gauhar Raza (Chief Scientist NISCAIR) ; Swami Sarvanand Saraswati (VC, Bharti Shri Peetham) ; Chandrakant Devtale (Author and Poet) ; Amitabh Pandey (Scientist) ; Swami Balendu (Blogger)
Anchor: Amrita Rai

[@praveshr.ranjan4760]

मैं आज ये वीडियो देख रहा हूं यह science की देन है, न कि God की, i'm proud to be an atheist

[@krishandas1972]

Aur ye dekhane wala God h

[@jeetparmar9]

@@krishandas1972 😂😂 Aur bhagwan ko banane vale hum hai

[@jeetparmar9]

I am also proud to be athist 🔥

[@Ankushkumar-lr4ci]

🔥🔥🔥❤️

[@jeetparmar9]

@VAIBHAV MISHRA i am not hindu🙄🙄 Ghatiya dharma

[@pradeepsiinghal7517]

मुझे भगवान में बहुत ही आस्था और विश्वास था लेकिन सन् 2020 में जब मैं हर तरह से हार गया तो मुझे एहसास हुआ कि मैंने गल्त जगह से आशा की

[@dharmeshkumarpareekpareek5902]

आपके प्रारब्ध कर्मो के कारण आप हार गए दोष भगवान को दे दिया

[@Me_rimjhim]

@@dharmeshkumarpareekpareek5902 he is right 🤨

[@Me_rimjhim]

Yes brother... Bhagwaan nhi hote ☺☺

[@hashimalam8720]

😂😂😂😂

[@hashimalam8720]

@@dharmeshkumarpareekpareek5902 भगवान का होने का सबूत दो 😂😂😂

[@VinodVerma-gx4le]

बहुत अच्छी चर्चा हुई । बहुत ही अच्छा विषय रखा गया । आस्तिकता एवं नास्तिकता चलती ही रहेगी । मेरे हिसाब से यह सत्य है कि ईश्वर नहीं होता है और यदि ईश्वर को हम मानते हैं अर्थात ईश्वर का नाम रखा गया है तो वह प्रकृति है । प्रकृति ही ईश्वर है । प्रकृति ही भगवान है और प्रकृति का संचालन विज्ञानिक तरीके से निश्चित नियमों के साथ होता है और यह नियम सभी प्राकृतिक हैं । प्रकृति का वास्तविक स्वरूप नहीं है । यह एक आदृश्य हो सकती है और प्रकृति में विभिन्न प्रकार के भौतिक पदार्थ हैं । वही ईश्वर का स्वरूप हो जाते है । इसलिए भगवान अर्थात प्रकृति का कोई स्वरूप नहीं है वह निराकार है । किंतु भौतिक पदार्थों के माध्यम से वह आकार के रूप में भी है। यह भी सत्य है कि मनुष्य ने ईश्वर को काल्पनिक रूप से गड़ा है।

[@kishorushir1333]

SIR apne bahut achhi bat kahi lekin prakurti ko bhee bhgwan samjana aur usko dhanda banana ye bat puri traha se galat he kivaki prakriti me koi bhav (sense) nahi hota matlab uski puja karna aur usko gali dena ye dono bate murkhta he hum sirf uske prati moun raha sakate he jaise ki thathgat GAUTAM BUDDHA rahe

[@lordbuddhaphilosophy1930]

@@kishorushir1333 good very good आप का कहना उचित है तथागत बुद्ध की बात बिल्कुल सही है लोगों को वहीं पहुंचता है

[@krishnak.4070]

@@lordbuddhaphilosophy1930 to Swami Vivekananda galat the kya

[@vinodpandeyg1389]

जब कोई व्यक्ति हॉस्पिटल में ट्रीटमेंट के दौरान मर जाता हैडॉक्टरों की देख रेख में वह तो सब साइंस तो क्यो मर जाता है वह और आदमी मरता क्यो है और खोज करने वाले वैज्ञानिक भी मर गए इसका मतलब मरना नही चाहिए था उसको पर में ये कहना चाहता अगर विज्ञान से जीने में आसानी हो गयी है और वह सब कुछ नही है अगर किसी का पैर कट जाए तो क्या विज्ञान उसका उसी तरह का पैर दे सकता है नही इसलिए विज्ञान भी पूरी तरह से सफल नही है और ये सब मशीनरी नही थी तब भी मनुष्य जिंदगी जी रहा था और अब भी जी रहा है

[@targetneet6060]

Right bhai , god is nothing , god is only nature .

[@mohammadakramali1466]

Religion's source are: Trust me bro. Science Source: years of reasearch using scientific methods.

[@20-aman]

🤟🤟

[@itsanewday5219]

Do u agree with those scientists agaobst ur islam?

[@gauravsahota6564]

Yup buddy💯💯💯

[@narayanparbrahma5241]

There is a man who has fallen ill, he has to be cured, research says it is a virus. This is creation, God is doing it, science says no, it is big bang, reason for bigbang, searching.....

[@BEST_AUTO_SALE]

Are u a exmuslim

[@energeticlion6673]

The epic debate by RSTV I consider myself as lucky to watch such intellectual video

[@Me_rimjhim]

Yes☺

[@chandrakantalenka4204]

Golden days were there before 2014

[@Saurabh98760]

ALL THESE GATHERED HERE ARE NOBODY IN FRONT OF SWAMI VIVEKANANDA....GO READ VIVEKANANDA..

[@masabakhan9136]

I am proud atheist 😀

[@agriculturist3448]

Astaghfirullah... Sister study about islam...

[@himansh1239]

Bro i think you should study science😂

[@agriculturist3448]

@@shivanshrajpandey2534 😂😂 ha bhai... Baat krna seekh le btw

[@arunakumarsethi3509]

Eithiest mahapurash nahi bane sakte.

[@arunakumarsethi3509]

Veda is science,veda is not blind

[@mandhojmagar3615]

I am an atheist. I agree with the intellectuals. And I believe in Science. You can not convince fools.

[@Samir20112]

Acha bhai pehla bandar kaun tha uski photo hai ? Vigyan ke pass andho ko sury prakash nahi dikh sakta ab tum ab vigyani apne khud ke bal se nai prithvi (Mangal grah ka use nahi) apne khud ke matrial se naya prithvi grah kab bana rahe hai

[@kalyanikedar2590]

Evolution is right. Science have fossils, traces and many more proof.

[@buttercup2991]

@@Samir20112 pehla bandar ka photo kaise milega tab camera thodi tha...bandar ek din mei nahi bana matlab evolution nam ki bhi kuch chiz hei😂 haan par scientist ne fossils se uska structure habit cranial capacity zaroor bata diya hei..google p dekh le

[@Samir20112]

@@buttercup2991 le accha akal ki andhi to bhagwan raste main chalta koi vigyan ni hai photo lade ya bat karle wah re doglo jab khud ke pass jawab na ho to ghatiya word use karo yahi sikhati hai science acha waisa hi dikhta hoga uska kya praman hai kuch bhi photo video dikhao kya hua jab khud ki bari main to pathhar ko fossils bol do hum kyun mane aise myths ko

[@buttercup2991]

@@Samir20112 accha thik hei😂

[@funtimedude3085]

११ साल पुराना, इस era में तो ये दम संसद TV में नहीं है

[@nandkishordongre7018]

विद्वान पत्रकार महोदया द्वारा सटीक वैज्ञानिक तर्को से सभी विचारकों को सम्हालते हुए अपनी कुशलता का ,अपनी धैर्यता का जो परिचय दिया वह क़ाबिले तारीफ है।

[@ekwastvikbhartiya1375]

ऐसे डिबेट हर रोज होने चाहिए इनसे जागरूकता अभियान चलेगा और लोग god और धर्म जैसे सड़ी हुई चीजों के नाम पर लड़ेंगे नहीं

[@AdityaSingh-lxp]

Ji aap shi bole 🙏🇮🇳,Tabhi log jagruk honge, 😊,,, kyuki ajj kll god ke piche apna pura jivan ke aadha time'issi me barbaad krr rhe hai 😢🥺🥺

[@Sarcastic_view]

Are ham bhi naastik hai, par Jo log apna palha badalte rehte hai unse kaun Jeet payega...jaha galti pade vaha ye astik vale bol dete hai ye nahi ye vo nahi vo...par bhagvaan itna hi achha hai, to scientisto ko bomb banane me kamyab ho na hone deta...😂😂😂

[@hemrajkumar4754]

कभी दुनिया की भुखमरी, गरीबी, कुपोषण, भ्रष्टाचार इत्यादि के बारे में सोचना एक दिन धीरे धीरे ईश्वर पर से विश्वास कम होते होते एक दिन सच्चाई पता चल जायेगा!

[@sciencelover7972]

Bilkul👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[@omshankarchoubey4664]

Ghar mein baithe rahoge to bhookhmari to aayegi hi na

[@hemrajkumar4754]

@@omshankarchoubey4664 बात विलकुल सही है! भारत देश के साथ साथ विश्व के लगभग सभी देशों में भूखमरी है! क्या आपके और आपके भगवान के पास कोई एसा मंत्र या यज्ञ है जिससे इस विपदा से निजात मिल जाए!

[@omshankarchoubey4664]

@@hemrajkumar4754 sabdon se mt khlo

[@hemrajkumar4754]

@@omshankarchoubey4664 शब्दों से ना खेलो! क्या कुछ गलत कह दिया क्या❓

[@catplayscatalan956]

Very nice and rational debate. It was a pleasure to listen to these people. Nowadays I can't believe any news channel showing anything else than Hindu-Muslim debates.

[@RajveerSingh-wb5or]

Einsteins god letter said "the word God for me is nothing but the expression and product of human weakness" His god letter sold in 2.8 million dollars .

[@chiragsharma5624]

Einstein believe in god so do Newton go to Wikimedia never spread reumer

[@RajveerSingh-wb5or]

@@chiragsharma5624 read his god letter and then come again.

[@chiragsharma5624]

@@RajveerSingh-wb5or it is written for cristion god he believes in god is Spinoza (may be i don't spell it right)

[@RajveerSingh-wb5or]

@@chiragsharma5624 correct i agreed

[@chiragsharma5624]

@@RajveerSingh-wb5or and Newton belive in Bible also

[@M.S.H.E.Trust6445]

Love science and technology Proud of science ,without science our life (incomplete)can't imagine (run) in every step

[@khalidismail2682]

Jb science nhi thi tb zada skoon tha

[@Saurabh98760]

ALL THESE GATHERED HERE ARE NOBODY IN FRONT OF SWAMI VIVEKANANDA....GO READ VIVEKANANDA..

[@deadshot128]

@@khalidismail2682 khuch bhii

[@khalidismail2682]

@@Saurabh98760 yes i red not special

[@Psartz]

​@@khalidismail2682you were not there witness it . human doing big wars before science

[@starprince6341]

I used to be an atheist. But after reading Richard Dawkins, Bhagat Singh, Periyar i am an atheist out and out.

[@anupbhau91]

नास्तिक बनो " इंसान " बनो, बहोत " स्कोप " है इसमे

[@languageofpraiseeng]

hello, Mr. Nastik give me the solution to today's problem that the world is going through?

[@Samir20112]

Vigyan bhai Mangal main kitne log hai kyunki kuch chaman landure vigyani o ne managl main Pani dhundha hai kuch ne waha koi jivit alian dhundha hai per sabit nahi ho paya ? Matalab chodu banne ka trika Stephen Hawking sala khud to ungli bhi nahi hila paya aur big bang ki theory ka gyan jad raha tha

[@himanshusagar5257]

@@languageofpraiseeng यह बात तो एक धार्मिक ही बता सकता है उसी के धर्म ग्रंथों में लिखी होंगी यह सब चीजें नास्तिकों से क्या पूछ रहे हैं उसकी तो रिसर्च अभी चल रही है वह तुम्हारी तरह सीधे सीधे कोई चीजों को मान नहीं लेता पहले वह सर्च करता है फिर जाकर किसी धारणा पर पहुंचता है धर्म विश्वास पर खड़ा हुआ है जिस दिन विचार पर खड़ा हो जाएगा तो ज्यादा दिन तक धर्म रह नहीं सकता

[@SunilSingh-qc8sb]

Laura scope hai

[@anupbhau91]

@@SunilSingh-qc8sb kisme hai Land bhkti mai

[@Kumaarr101]

I was bigger theist in family but now I am bigger atheist in my family

[@HarshalMahalle1005]

there are more than 75 crore aetheists .... i am feeling good now..that m one of them.. :)

[@shivamgupta7757]

Ohh...u are too one of those fools...

[@saurabh32able]

It will not make your life easy I used to be an atheist now an agnostic I find that atheist and theist both r believer and lier ,side of same coin

[@manassehdesai5298]

My dear, lt is eternal truth that there is God. Pls read Bible, bible says, foolish said in his heart that there is no God, so those do not believe in God they are foolish. The whole universe is proof of of God. Also that majority are correct.

[@optimusprime5199]

@@manassehdesai5298 Lol, Bible is most corrupted book. Full of scientific mistakes. How come universe is proof of God?

[@optimusprime5199]

@@saurabh32able Though I am an agnostic too but i didn't get it, how come atheist are believers and liars?

[@praveenkhande2944]

विज्ञान ही सत्य है धर्म ने तो मानवजाति का विनाश ही किया है

[@voyageSBlogs]

विज्ञान सही है इन्सानियत होती तो ऊच नीच जात पात भेद भाव नहीं होता

[@P.K-lc6dg]

ऊच नीच,भेदभाव धर्म द्वारा संचालित मान्यताएं हैं,विज्ञान तो केवल सत्य प्रकाशित करने का काम करता है |

[@ANILKUMAR-ky2zj]

@@P.K-lc6dga

[@UPSC_DREAM-391.]

@@P.K-lc6dg yes

[@parmachandyadav2066]

@@none272 अरे , बीएसडी के गाली क्यों दे रहा बे ,

[@Pktrader-kg4fy]

-महर्षि वाल्मीकि ने रामायण लिखा और बाबा साहेब ने संविधान दोनों ही दलित थे फिर वो कौन से मूर्ख लोग हैं जो संविधान मानते हैं पर रामायण नहीं

[@anileshkushwaha5115]

काश प्रति दिन धार्मिक कार्यक्रमो कि जगह ऐसे ही तार्किक कार्यक्रम आयोजित किए गए जिससे भ्रतियो को दूर करने में सफल हो कर नेक इंसान बन सकें

[@vbmaurya1296]

Bhagwan kalpnik hai

[@arjitsingh5357]

जय विज्ञान जय संविधान जय भारत 🇮🇳 🙏 🌺

[@dharmeshkumarpareekpareek5902]

सर आप अगर विज्ञान को जानते हो तो ईश्वर को भी मान सकते थे आप वेदों को नहीं जानते है अच्छे से स्टडी करो फिर बात करो

[@dharmeshkumarpareekpareek5902]

संविधान के पहले पेज पर है राम लिखा हुआ है क्या वो गलत है

[@manpreetsingh7005]

अगर ईश्वर का अस्तित्व नहीं होता तो हम इस चीज पर बहस भी नहीं कर रहे होते। 🙏

[@MohammedIrfan-qw1wk]

In pagalon ko Ranchi me hona chahye dharam ke waja se mar kat hota hai to 1st aur 2nd world War dharam ki waja se nahi hua aur karodon log mare gaye aur 3rd World war bhi dharam ke waja se3 nahi hoga aur pura pirthivi ka the end hoja jaye ga due to scintific culture

[@SpectreGR396]

@@MohammedIrfan-qw1wk yes Nature is god and believing in god is not bad but believing in religious reject love

[@debasismandal4105]

Gohor Raza 👏🏻👏🏻

[@Amitkumar-sb8cv]

Aaj kal aese interview kyo nahi hote😢😢😢😢😢

[@Bhartiyakrantikarisena]

धर्म व भगवान के नाम पर पेट के पूजारियों ,पादरियों, कथावचकों,पाठियों, मोलवियों, आदि धर्म के ठेकेदारों की दूकानदारी व उसी दूकानदारी से इनका पेट पलता है और ऐशो आराम की जिदंगी जीते है ,,व भोली भाली जनता को बेवकूफ बना रखा है ,,,,,,इन्कलाब जिन्दाबाद ,,कडवा सत्य

[@himanshusekharnag308]

Right

[@arunrajak7987]

Aap sahi bol rhe ho bhai

[@varya6855]

10000.... % right ❤️

[@Bhartiyakrantikarisena]

धन्यवाद जी

[@Bhartiyakrantikarisena]

धन्यवाद जी

[@TRISHIKH1910]

इंसान हर चीज विज्ञान की दी हुई उपयोग करते है तो फ़िर क्यों विज्ञान कि बजाय 99% पॉपुलेशन भगवान की पूजा करती है?

[@websites3502]

Because people are afraid of how society if they don't agree with their beliefs system normal people want to go with flow Eg : in India if someone argues that God does not exist in a country where 98% of people are religious then his life could be in danger Other main thing is lack of education I am from nepal and my parents are Hindu and I view myself as atheist only in digital world because when I go out side and see that 99% of my country is religious and I lies in 1% then me arguing with other that I don't believe what 99% believes put me in danger

[@souravjha9985]

विज्ञान क्या है ???

[@akarshittiwari5730]

Kyoki wo manna nahi chahte

[@s.kumarmehra4321]

Hii

[@alokjohal]

Par vigyaan to ek sanskrit ka shab hai... Aur sanskrit vedic language hai... Aur vedon me vigyan dhabh sanskrit me likha hai... Baby science aur God me behans kar... Science is not written in ny religious text.. But vigyaan is written in vedas.. So vigyaan is a part of sanatana vedic dharma🚩🙏

[@BijendraKumar-lu1cv]

Kisi maulvi ko bhi bula lete,thode dange dekh lete

[@shivanirajput722]

Hehe

[@ramshresthgope]

🤣😂🤣😂

[@deepakghaytadak764]

मवलैवी आया नहीं होगा?

[@rehanaparvin9945]

🤪

[@vijaypalsingh1347]

श्रृष्टि का श्रृष्टि कर्ता कोई भी नहीं है। धर्म के नाम पर धर्म के ठेकेदार अपनी अपनी दुकानें चला रहे हैं। जय विज्ञान जय भारत जय संविधान।

[@Samir20112]

Bhai corona hai savidhan dikhao corona bhago chua chut ka savidhan ne mana kiya hai ab sab savidhan ke hisab se chua chut nahi karni chahiye lekin kyun kar rahe ho

[@dhrubaandsonsconstruction4581]

Are bhai jai sambhidhaan kyu yaar

[@dharmikanand8199]

सातवें आसमान पर रन्डीखाना चलाने वाले दल्ला के बारे में भी कुछ बोल

[@yugamkukreja5681]

Agr profe krdiya ki bhagwan h to challenge h terkooo m proofe kr sakta hu bhagwan h

[@BhagatSingh-lq6kr]

Chalange hai mera tuje

[@ketanchaudhary6323]

1 theist against 4 INTELLECTUALS Great intellectualism

[@nextlevel7322]

in world 750 million atheist against 7 billion intellectuals , great intellectualism

[@ketanchaudhary6323]

@@nextlevel7322 but they are not at any official debate as in this case where these INTELLECTUAL are trying to prove something in a way called Heckling. When in Debate, follow the rules of debate by keeping Equal opponents and then you are eligible to be called intellectual at least, keeping aside who's right or wrong.

[@seizedboy4834]

No bro its 5 that dumb anchor is also his against

[@Namanchauhan2164]

Likhne koi likh sakta

[@sujk671]

@@ketanchaudhary6323 absolutely right , it's like they have invited theist to show the majority in the forum. But unfortunately , person from audience destroyed all these so called INTELLECTUAL panelists 🤣🤣 and then we saw that how they got frustrated

[@devranjan68]

Swami Balendu ne 100 baat ki 1 baat kahi hai👌...aastikon se tark mat kijiye...tark ka scope science mein hota hai, religion mein nai.. period.

[@logicalbhakt4483]

Sanatan dharma tark pe hi chalta he. Ved me khud likha he ke jab tak me aapke tark pe khara na utru tab tak mujpe vishwas mat kijiye

[@jeetparmar9]

@@logicalbhakt4483 kaha likha hai bhai Jara hame bhi batao 😂😂

[@EverydayLifeandScience]

@@jeetparmar9 You are right, fact is that we have no written record of what was originally said in the Vedas, it was all transmitted orally and much was added and subtracted before it was all penned just a few centuries back. Moreover, during ancient times, knowledge and learning was limited.

[@mangalhembrom190]

Usliye to bekoof bante ho dharam ke naam par

[@agnosticatheist7699]

@@EverydayLifeandScience aisa kuch nahi hai bhai chaye jo bhi bolo mein dono ko hi maanta hu vigyan vigyan hai aur god vigyan se bhi upar jisko samjha nahi jaa sakta

[@PankajKumar-ek3ot]

बहुत सही चर्चा हो रही है ऐसी ही चर्चाएं होनी चाहिए मीडिया में ज्ञान विज्ञान के लिए उत्तम सर्वोत्तम है और यह सही भी है!

[@Ankushkumar-lr4ci]

Bhai ye sab charcha congress ki time ki hai Ab ye sab nhi hota hai Ab to aur dharmik conference krte hai

[@physiotherapy9128]

"Dharm and science" is very helpful book 📚 written by wahiduddine Khan

[@itsanewday5219]

Any topic about islam on that book?

[@BhagatSingh-gr6rp]

@@itsanewday5219 dharm mai islam bhi ata hai gawar 🌚

[@Shandilyanuj1008]

@@BhagatSingh-gr6rp chutiye dharm means duty hota hai na ki religion

[@IEE-nc3jc]

They called it "goddamn particle" but publisher of the book thought that it was outrageous and can cause controversy and he changed it to god particle , but what astonishes me is that the moderator was not aware of this fact , they have not done proper research before organizing the debate

[@Anshvloger123]

higgs boson ko pehle goddamn particle naam dene ki soch thii magar god ko dhyaan me rakhke hi isse god particle naam diya gaya

[@akscs373]

@@Anshvloger123 toh yh particlegod k existence ka pramaan h waah...mtlb mujhe toh fir westerners ko follow kr lena chahiye.....

[@सूफ़ीध्यानश्री]

ई बाबा तो ईश्वर को लेकर कोई एक राय रख ही नहीं रहे....कभी बॉडी, कभी आस्था, कभी प्रसन्नता का नाम दे रहे हैं☺☺☺

[@madhusoodanprasad2248]

😅😀😀😀😀😀

[@gurmannsingh9548]

Bhai sab dhram jhute hai... Science sahi hai...

[@varya6855]

Right

[@mahatmacharya]

कोई एक राय है ही नहीं क्यूंकि 'ईश्वर' एक मनगढंत वस्तु है! कारक परिणाम इस संसार का प्राकृतिक भौतिक सत्य है विज्ञान और बुद्धिवाद सही मार्ग है बिना किसी संदेह

[@honeysingh-jd8mp]

Kyuki ye baba bhagwan ko sirf manta h janta nhi h

[@vinodmathur6999]

Yahi kalyug Hai sahab Krishna ji ki ye baat Gita mai varnan Hai Jai shrii Krishna 🙏🙏

[@jonikumar8755]

Na hi koi satyug h or or nahi kalyug Ye sb dharm ke thekedaro ka hi purpganda h

[@anshpreetsingh3476]

Vinod mathur chutiye tujhe kaise pata tere bhagwan asli hai tu dhek kar aya tha ?

[@skprenzhania2723]

Anpad yug ko sat yug kaha h Q k pap kisi k pas itni Budhi nhi thi ki vo sahi aur galt prr sawal krta...aaj pda likh vyakti janta h ki kya kese hota h isi ko kalyug kaha h scientific yug ko kalyug ......

[@VGnationalist]

भैंस के आगे बीन बजाने से, भैंस नागिन नहीं बन जाएगी,

[@ketankr7526]

haha

[@dhrubaandsonsconstruction4581]

Kehena ka matlb kya he

[@aniljaiswal2090]

Every religion teach don't kill anyone 'However religion is the only thing here is responsible behind almost All the killings' 💯 Harsh reality 🙏

[@nikhildeshmukh6851]

Soo damn true

[@pappulalkumhar4431]

मै भी ईश्वर पर बहुत विश्वास करता था परंतु जब मेरे पुत्र का निधन हो गया तब से ईश्वर से विश्वास ही उठ गया है और अब मैं नास्तिक हूं

[@ravishankarmishraenglishho466]

Debate must be organised among scientists and Shankaracharya

[@souravjha9985]

सही कहा

[@ramakantnishad235]

Jisko chot lage o hospital me jata hai na ki mandiro me

[@rodixff9271]

Yes brother

[@radheyjaiswal6066]

Koi dhrm nhi h Sirph logo KO darate h sale😀😀

[@kuchnakuchzururmilygakuchn2155]

Bolkul right

[@ajeetkumar540]

Ishwar ek aisi shakti h jisako kewal feel kiya ja sakta h aap unhi energies ka prayog karke har kaam kar rhe h

[@ratri6110]

I am a pantheist. I believe that universe and nature is God. I don't believe in Big Boss type of God.👍

[@gtgamerhumanoid7187]

Can be true....god is not like something they show in tv....its just a universe

[@vidyanandbapat8032]

But that's how the word God us used in common parlance. Pantheists and deists twist the definition of the word so as to fit to their narrative.

[@Ankit1543]

is pakhandi pandit ne ek bhi sawal ka sai se answer ni dia

[@suhanapandey1778]

Ankit Saroha पण्डित जवाब नहीं देते,

[@wantedkoda1744]

@@suhanapandey1778 bas pakhand karte hai

[@user-KDS994]

Bhag sale Arbi

[@dr_dangerrr]

@@wantedkoda1744 exactly😂

[@technicalboys8513]

@@suhanapandey1778 kyunki vo laude hotte hai😁😂😂

[@tayaji4452]

I like this debate From Florida, USA May 18, 2020.

[@sciencelover7972]

U liked this debate 1 year before.

[@carramboardlover938]

Apko nobel prize milega😄

[@pradeepgautam706]

One of the best debate on the existence of God.

[@skullcrawler18]

Atheist or theists?

[@explorewithsunny2890]

Jo yeh sochte hain ke science bhi believe karti hain bhagwan mein, unko yeh nahi pta ke 98 percent scientist big bang or charles darwin ki evolution ki theory ko maante hai. Doosri baat Albert Einstein ne kabhi nahi kaha ke woh god mein believe krte hai, unhone yahi kaha ke woh agnostic hai, woh poore vishwas ke saath nahi keh sakte ke universe ko koi bnane wala hai ya nahi hai. Iska matlab yah nahi ke woh bhagwan mein vishwas karte the.

[@anitashrivastava8175]

Toh usne nahi kaha ki bhagwan hai ​@ghost27611

[@Ishtsharma534]

There was a time when rajya sabha tv conducted thoughtful discussions

[@ankitdixit9719]

True

[@ankitchaudhary9192]

"It's better to have a question that can't be answered than to have a answer that can't be questioned."

[@meena9049]

Bohot hi shandar charcha ...ese discussion or laiye channel pr

[@Rehan_Yafai]

I think audience are more intellectual than the guests.

[@Ruchi553]

Religion -- trust me bro ,i am messenger of God. Science -- research and analyse then accept or reject both options is in your hand .

[@gopalakrishnasn5311]

Half baked knowledge of participants. And, the anchor could not take the debate in right direction. Simply stated, sheer waste of time.

[@honeysingh-jd8mp]

Anchor doesn't even know anything

[@anearthian625]

It was the time of Christopher Hitchens , George Carlin , Richard Dawkins , Javed Akhtar , Issac Asimov and many many others . Aajkal kahin aise debate hote h kya ?

[@sanskarilaunda9454]

Science is reality.... Not today but tomorrow..... it is reality 🙂

[@Jinata1]

17:50 जो देश जितने कट्टर h वो उतने ही बदहाल है The line is true Ex - Pakistan

[@9246189242]

True is outside, which is invisible, when will it become truth, when the witness like you say something about true, it is truth, your experience. Starting point is invisible, from where you are standing, that place is comma, from where you see towards the starting point, which is not a false to be crashed it out, from the comma point, your future point starts but you never know the end point. Your future point is no the end point, from there your end point is another, certain point to accept.

[@imransiddique8794]

One thing you must have noticed in this secular Debate, No one has mentioned Quran, Sharia, Prophet and Allah.

[@ishanabhavsar]

Yeah. Sure ... average non Muslims could mention those words.. quran sharia prophet and allah.. and not be sacred of having Sar Tan se Juda !!

[@dreamworldhg.243]

Positive deabete 👍🏻👍🏻🙏🙏🙏 aisa deabet hona chahiye samay samay pr 👍🏻🙏 science + Nutural pawer complimentary to each other.👍🏻👍🏻🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@gangaparshad738]

ज्वाला देवी में वैज्ञानिकों विधि द्वारा ही बनाया गया होगा वह दीपक क्योंकि उसका खोज करने के लिए वहां के पंडित पुजारी वैज्ञानिकों को जाने नहीं देंगे आस्था का विषय कह कर के हल्ला मचाएंगे

[@kishorrai6855]

धर्म पाखण्ड , बिज्ञान सतय खोज सिद्द लगा मेरेको , भगवान् सिर्फ शब्द है ईसका मतलब जो भी लगा सक्ा है धार्मिक गुरूलोग

[@Ratwara-m9q]

काश मैं इस debate में मौजूद होता मेरे पास इन सभी सवालों का सटीक उत्तर है जिसे कोई काट नहीं सकता ।

[@poojaprince5405]

Really are u thiest or atheist

[@KUMAR786NAREN]

Missing this type of debate these days. :(

[@rajveerkanojiya2985]

God doesn't exist that's the bottom line cause stone cold Steve Austin said so

[@kumarsah474]

आस्तिको का बहुमत होने के कारण इस डिवेट में जीत हासिल कर ली है।

[@dhrubaandsonsconstruction4581]

Ok to tum kya ho

[@chakradharhadke4063]

LET'S NOT MEASURE GOD DUE TO MAJORITY BUT ON BASIS OF FACTS.

[@ex009adityarajsingh2]

Bahumat me bhed chalte hai samajhdar log evidence aur rationalist mind se chalte hai aur asliyat me to nastik hi contribute karte hai ya jo log rational hai

[@LearnWithAlok101]

Pakistan m aise debate ho to mar peet ho jayegi 😂😂

[@prahaladvishwakarma5001]

जब समझ दिमाग से बाहर की हो जाती है, तब हम ईश्वर या भगवान के नाम से दिमाग को भ्रमित कर आगे बढ़ जाते हैं और इसको आस्था बता देते हैं। जब विज्ञान द्वारा समझ आती है तो वही भ्रमित भगवान और आस्था की कोरी कल्पना रफूचक्कर हो जाती है।

[@agnosticatheist7699]

PROUD TO BE AN ATHEIST❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@sharadbhaisoni9286]

परमात्मा, ईश्वर,गोड़ ये तर्क से साबित नही होता ,जो लोग अपने अपने ईश्वर परमात्मा को मानते है श्रध्धा,आस्था है उसके लिए है 100 प्रतिशत है और जो नही मानते इसके लिए नही है ,सतयुग मे भी नही मानने वाले थे तब ये असुर कहलाते थे और आज सायद खुद वो लोग खुद को नास्तिक कहते है। नास्तिक होना कोई बुरी बात नही है लेकिन नास्तिक होकर भी इन्सान बनकर रहे तो वो दूसरोंके लिए भगवान,ईश्वर ही है।

[@optimusprime5199]

Yeh kahoo naa ki astha ki baat hai, saboot koi nhi.

[@vishwajeettiwary8456]

@@optimusprime5199 Bhai aaap ek faaal bno do plz bnao Pura natural wla bna do ar Mera soul aap lo ar apna soul hmko de do de skte ho

[@shriramsakhalkar-blissyog2744]

It is not that you think that is why you are there, but you think only because you are there. You can doubt everything but not yourself. So knowing yourself is spirituality and not any religion. Knowing the Self is experiencing the God.

[@sahebraothorat142]

जहां आस्था खड़ी होती है मतलब मतलब दिमाग़ की किंमत वहाँ झींरो होती है !

[@vkscience245]

Would enjoy more if there were the representator of all religions 😂😂😂

[@akashiyer1305]

All have guts to devare with Hindu only

[@H_Amin]

Gowhar Raza sb aap aastik haen nastik nahin jo pakhand men vishwas rakhta hae wah nastik hae jo vigyan or prakirtik Ko manta hae wah aastik hae❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉.

[@स्टीफनहाकिंग्स]

मुझे ईस्वर से इतनी नफरत हैं कि आइनस्टिन जो कहता था की ईस्वर नाम की चीज हैं तो मैं आइनस्टिन से भी नफरत करता हूं ।मेरा आदर्श सिफ स्टिफन होकिंग्स हैं जो ईस्वर नाम के प्राणी को सिरे से नकारता था।

[@subtv1440]

जब आप खुद को नही जानते ।ईश्वर को केसे जानोगे।

[@Amit_Raaz]

मैं आज देख रहा हु। मैं नास्तिक ही सही था❤

[@balkarsandhu1317]

Bhagwaan was imagination of fool persons. These persons try to make fool and exploit feelings of innocent persons.

[@arupkumarjena5178]

ALLAH.. BHAGBAN..JESUS... All of these are just imaginary characters created by our ancestors...just for "Aal izz well" support . A born-blind have to believe whatever we tell him... because he is helpless ... But we are worse ...we are holding smartphones...we know about science..technology...inventions..evolution...universe etc . But we are still believing in that God which doesn't even exist and arguing in support of his existence

[@kabirmalik8703]

Actually, Atheist Means Realistic. Based On Logic, Rationality, Proven Things.

[@fatehsidhu8035]

There is no God... All religions are just business nothing else

[@rinkubabbar2916]

Paji tuse sardar hoo kr aise kh rahe ho..kyu paji

[@burhanwayne404]

Can you plz ans my some questions where food come from how food help our body nd yea how this universe is so perfectly running.

[@pradyumnabanerjee3333]

@@burhanwayne404 Universe is NOT perfectly running. It is full of randomness. And we need food for living because we need energy to survive, and we have more than a trillion mitochondrias for that.

[@burhanwayne404]

@@pradyumnabanerjee3333 but where food came from im Confused

[@burhanwayne404]

@@pradyumnabanerjee3333 look how perfect it is we sleep in night nd work in day

[@TheTrueLifestyle]

Mai na science na religion ko manta hu.. Mai sirf insaaniyat aor Dil se kaam karta hu aor khud ka God pe kya experience hai usko yaad karke rakhta hu. God is personal matter. Vivekananda said.

[@Haraex]

Science koi Maan ne ki cheej nahin hai

[@sheikhfarid6798]

Excellent discussion!

[@bijaysubba5642]

Radhey Radhey 🙏🙏🙏

[@jeffbezoskerishtedar2140]

😛😛😛😛

[@dutiramgogoi8500]

🤣😂

[@truelyworldfact5670]

Radhe Radhe❤🙏⛳⛳

[@anupbhau91]

सबसे ज्यादा "ओलिम्पिक मैं मेडल" " नास्तिको " के देश लाते है ।

[@none272]

और सबसे ज्यादा डिप्रेसनकी मेडिसिनभी नास्तिकोके देश हि खाती है । सबसे ज्यादा ड्रग्स भि नास्तिको के देशकि जनता हि खाती है। और सडकपे हर 1 km पे सबसे ज्यादा पुलिस भि नास्तिकोके देशमे हि रख्ने पड्ते है वर्ना नास्तिक लुटपाट मर्डर सुरु कर्देते है लेकिन इन्डिया नेपाल जैसे आस्तिकोके देशमे हरेक 10 km के वाद एक police station होति है वौर वहापर भि सिर्फ दो चार बन्दे हि होते है और सिर्फ एक अकेला पुलिस हातमे लाठी पकडकर सडकपे duty कररहा होरा है। सालो नास्तिको सम्झा करो बातको 😂😂।

[@anupbhau91]

World happyness index Mai Bharat 145 ve sthan pe hai .

[@investing563]

@@none272 और जानकारी बढ़ाओ

[@samraatparmar3335]

Abe chutiye 33 cror bhagwan hai police ki Kya jarurat

[@RahulSharma-xb4ob]

Nastika koi desh nahi hai .

[@Akkshat]

Ek Question hai ki Aaj se 1000 years pehle jb kisi bhi scientists ne kisi bhi force ya laws ki khoj nhi ki thi to kya usse pehle wo forces ya energies apna kaam krte tha? Iska answer nhi to shayad ho nhi skta lekin agar haa to us time ye sab to rules the hi nhi, us time ke bhi log debate krte to yahi kehte ki aisa kuch hota hi nhi...

[@rajeev227979]

इश्वर वादी की आंखें सत्य देखना नहीं चाहती वो अपनी आस्था विश्वास को सही साबित करने की जिद करते हैं

[@satishkumartiwary7246]

वैज्ञानिक सत्य भी बदलता रहता है ।

[@neerajverma4208]

Badlta nhi improve hota hai

[@vijayparadkar1284]

Cosmic mind created dream type structure and perceived by Senses of living beings.

[@vijaypalsingh1347]

शोषण का नाम ही ईश्वर, अल्लाह, खुदा,भगवान, ऊपरवाला है।

[@rajuchauhnrajuchauhnon3896]

Science is great

[@angnosti-baba333]

Bagvan ka shukr hai me atheist hu 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@RaviKumar-ne8yn]

मुझे भगवान से डर नहीं लगता मुझे भगवान को मानने वालों से डर लगता है।

[@asmitdahule2390]

Kisine notice Kiya jo bhi bhagwan ko nhi manane Wale he vo sb dr dr ke ya naraji se bat kr rahe the lekin only one person having always smile on his face that's the proof

[@servantofKRISHNAforever]

Saint people are satisfied in life !

[@preetgautam8216]

Koi positivity nahi darr k liye jaate Hain .God name ki koi cheez nahi h na koi murti bolti.

[@rodixff9271]

Yuppp

[@akshaygupta4606]

Bilkul sahi

[@theprincechandrayan]

Pandit Ji fans Gaye....

[@akshaygupta4606]

I have the proof that cannot be challenged in the entire universe. First of all, the sun is the only and ultimate source of energy. Green plants trap this energy during photosynthesis and thereafter it is transferred to different organisms through food chain. During birth, a baby needs huge amount of energy in order to become alive, which is transferred from the mother to its baby during childbirth and if it is not transferred due to any complications then the baby dies. In mammals like us the baby's development takes place inside its mother's womb and the baby is connected to her mother's body so that the energy can very easily be transferred. Even the hens sit on eggs to transfer the energy. Amoeba divides into two and budding happens in Hydra. These physical contacts help to transfer the energy. Sperms and ovum also have that energy and they are like microorganisms. After birth we maintain the level of the soul(energy) throughout our life by taking food everyday. Whenever we work hard and don't eat anything, we feel weak because our soul(energy) decreases, and if we continue to avoid food for longer periods we would die because we require this energy. This energy doesn't have any sense, thoughts or personality on its own and is unable to think or decide what is good or what is bad. If someone is sleeping(means his brain is in coma) and at the same time if someone else aims his head with a pistol, revolver or gun without making a noise, the person will not wake up to protect himself. Why doesn't his soul(energy) tells him to wake up and protect himself. The answer is that this energy cannot see anything, think, decide or give instructions. Why a person who is in coma in a hospital doesn't wake up? though his soul(energy) is still inside his body. Why sometimes some people lose their memory and even don't remember their own names? though the soul(energy) is still inside. Why some people are born mentally disabled? though the soul(energy) is still inside. I have seen some dying people, even my mom when I was only 13 years old, who couldn't even recognize their family, though the soul(energy) was still inside their bodies. We are able to think anything, we behave good or bad, we do good and bad things, we recognize our family and friends just due to our healthy brain and not due to this soul(energy). Our personality is the product of our brain and not of our soul(energy). A person becomes good or bad only because of what he learns during his/her development years and all these good or bad knowledge is absorbed in our brain and not in our soul(energy), which ultimately decides whether the person will be good or bad. When the brain is in coma or if a person is mentally disabled then this soul(energy) cannot give instructions on its own. Our special organs such as heart, lungs, stomach, kidneys, liver, pancreas and all the other components of our body keep this soul(energy) trapped inside our body (just like a bulb) as long as they are healthy and when any of these special organs fails or is destroyed due to an accident, wounds or old age, then our soul( energy) is forcefully released out of our body and we die and that energy cannot come back to our body, because after death our blood, cells, tissues and everything starts to decompose or destroy. After death this soul(energy) is again transferred into something else. Therefore this soul(energy) which is unable to think, decide or give instructions, only gives us life. It doesn't have any kind of sense or idea and doesn't become a Ghost or Angel, and thus these two things doesn't exist at all. Most of the things which is written in all the different types of ancient books are absolutely fake, lie and untrue. The universe, stars, galaxies, planets and every matter came into existence due to the big bang and now scientists have found many evidences of our expanding universe. All organisms have been evolved from the organic matters. Nobody has created us at all. Thankfully science and scientific books haven't contributed for Riots, Hatred, Genocide, Superstition and dividing people into different factions(groups). Nobody can count how many people have been killed in these 5000 years because of those non scientific books which don't encourage different communities to live together happily and peacefully instead each of them encourage its community to dominate and convert the other. Throughout the history they tried to destroy each other. Science has produced destructive nuclear weapons and also used them once but thankfully since that time they are under the control of Laws, Constitution, logical minds and not under the control of Religion. Those ancient books don't focus on Equality, Liberty, Fraternity, Justice, Moral Values and General Laws which are common and essential for every person and equally applicable to everyone and on which all the people can agree upon without any conflict, instead these ancient novels present unscientific and impossible events and stories which cannot be true at any cost. ((It is a bane that humanity is divided into different communities due to those ancient books and Each one tries to Assert its Supremacy over the others which is the only reason for Riots, Discrimination, Persecution and Genocide all the time in different places of the world)). Those ancient novels are destroying humanity which is okay for everyone, but humans don't want to destroy the sources of Superstition, Hatred, Persecution, Discrimination. Each ancient novel asserts is supremacy over the other which is causing only harm to the humanity. The greatest book in this world is only and only the Constitution of India which is a uniting force and promotes Harmony, Fraternity, Justice, Liberty and Equality. It protects us from Unjust and Tyranny. Thankfully our country is governed by a Constitution and not by any Religion that's why we have peace. These Religions are not same at all therefore nobody can think about replacing the Constitution with any Religion.

[@rahulmahakud3067]

Mujhe lagta hai k spirituality ko janne ki koshis karna chahiye kyun ki spirichuality aur science alag hokar bhi ek hai acience bahr ki duniya k bare main batati hai aur spirituality ek insn ko khud ke bare main janne ki paddhati hi

[@hirdeysingh1971]

Dhan guru nanak sahib g..mharaj...Which says without true guru u cant get enlightenment.waheguru g

[@hirdeysingh1971]

@@atheismpromoter may lord enlighten you with truth of light, by his wisdom, through his mesengers.

[@kumaritripti4737]

The man in the audience was epic

[@adityaanand1453]

आपने एक आस्तिक और इतने सारे नास्तिक बहुत नाइंसाफ़ी है।

[@mineshkumar1787]

आस्तिक लोग डर में नही आये डिबेट करने क्योंकि आते तो बुरी तरह फंस जाते वो

[@none272]

@@mineshkumar1787 यैसा तुम्हे लगता है । क्युकी तुम्हारी पास यित्नी बुद्धि अभि तक नहि है कि तुम जानसको परमात्माकी exact meaning क्या है। यिसिलिय तुम्हे यैसा लग्ता है कि इतिहाससे आजतक जित्ने भि बुद्ध पुरुस हुय है वह सबने परमात्माकी परिभाषा बताया है लेकिन तुम्हे समझ आय कहाँ आतिहै। ? तुम्हे तो उपर दाडिवाला या फिर धनुसवाला या फिर क्रशवाला कोहि शक्तिशाली जिवको परमात्मा है केकर सिखाया गया हैना? खुद यिसका मतलब पता कर्लो यित्नी बुद्दि तुम्हारी पास हे हि नहि। परमात्माका मतलब समझनेके लिय ध्यान , और प्रखर बुद्दिमता चाहिय लेकिन य सान्सारिक दैनिक जिवनवाली बाते तो जो कोहि भि समझलेता है। तुम्हे इश्वरकी परिभासा नहि पता तो क्या सभी लोगोको भि नहि पता क्या? बाकी सब अनपढ है? तुम्हे एसा लगता है? क्यु ऐसा लगता है बे?

[@studentchannel9302]

Bhut sandaar debate hai thank you this channel

[@realart1007]

yeh discusion bacho ke lable ki hai

[@JoginderSingh-fe2lo]

Sir aap hi apne bde hone ka prnaam de dijiye

[@SatyamShivamSundaram29]

निपट मूर्ख इकट्ठे होकर रो पीट रहें है !!! ये अज्ञान के वशीभूत होकर नहीं जानते अपना खुद का ईश्वरीय स्वरूप।। हर कोई अपनी धारणा बनाए बैठा है।।

[@onehappythought2562]

I'm nastik !! Maine kuch log aaisebhi dekhe hai Jo eshwar ki narajgi k dar k mare pujapath karte hai Nastik hu kehnekeliye bhi himmat honi chahiye.

[@shreeadityapurifiedwateren6382]

Mujhe Nahi lagta ki log darr ki wajah se bhagwan ki puja-archana karte hai mai sahmat hu ki kuch logo ki aesi maansikta hoti hai par sabhi ki nahi vo unka dridh vishvaas hai unke paramatma ke prati aur mai garv se kehta hu mai aastik hu........aastik hu.......aastik hu.......

[@akshaygupta4606]

I respect you