Making up God? Hashim Vs Atheists | Old is Gold | Speakers Corner

[@scdawah]

*LIKE the video it helps us reach more people!* Support us & become a Patreon- www.patreon.com/Scdawah PayPal - www.paypal.me/ScdawahChannel GoFundMe - www.gofundme.com/f/scdawahchannel

[@yussofross1417]

Brother, what is the minimum for the Go Fund me? I kept pressing but it just won't go through

[@scdawah]

Hmm I think possibly $5 unsure Akhi , on Patreon you can support us for as little as $1 a month , GoFundMe we are unsure

[@yussofross1417]

@@scdawah I kept pressing enter with 5, 6,7,8 pounds but it just didn't go through. Nevermind, I'll go to the Patreon instead. Thanks, brother.

[@scdawah]

Hmm we will look into this thanks brother , and jazak Allah Khair for your support on Patreon

[@HarrisVanRensselaer]

Uuuuwyqwtytytwwwywuoryywwwwwrwwywwwwwy

[@Neon790]

When Hashim says "Really?" You know you about to learn something or have your ignorance exposed.

[@rasydanidan5397]

If im hashim's oppenent, when i heard the "really?".....my confidence will be deteriorating

[@TheJavaSync]

really?

[@ajhammer1701]

A beautiful dialogue this was. No lies, no hate, no one being disingenuous.... honest individuals. May Allah guide us all.

[@ibrahimconteh8442]

Hashim is just strengthening my so called scientific belief about God.

[@shamsia_rahimi8717]

Hashim is one of the most talented and intelligent person in hyde park ❤❤❤

[@shamsia_rahimi8717]

@@SpeakersCornerAnalysed It is clear from your jealousy that you are so incompetent that you understand my sentence correctly np😂😂

[@shamsia_rahimi8717]

@@SpeakersCornerAnalysed You are disgusting people who ruin your day and night for hating Muslims ٫You deceive people with your fake videos and spend your life with hates.......... Alhamdulillah for (Islam) by believing the only one Creator of the world, we have a very calm life and a very comfortable mind. no hate no conspiracy

[@ayaankhan4316]

No its Hatun...

[@313dimz]

Speakers Corner Analysed : lol.. then ur standar lower than animals.. 😂

[@313dimz]

Speakers Corner Analysed : I am still a child but able to distinguish between humans and animals namely consciousness. But instead you admit that you are an animal ... lol

[@Gojo_8]

Hashim explained it so well mashallah! He is one of the best out there Alhamdoullilah

[@aaaabbbbccc123]

Brilliant. Prob one of the best vids uploaded by SCDawah. A healthy debate from all angles. Mashallah! Good job br Hashim.

[@geo-yq4ed]

i agree 100%

[@iqrafatima2031]

The whole conversation was concluded in 4 minutes when he talked about consiousness😎

[@andiginobili4403]

right,,,,😀😀

[@ghulamsarwar687]

Absolutely 🤣🤣 started off smug and arrogant but within 2 minutes Hashim humbled this fool

[@jsaiyed1738]

That was the nail in the coffin.

[@Keynotes13]

Actually no, bunch of special pleading, his creator just existed with no evidence

[@jochemlambers]

@@ghulamsarwar687 his argument is so weak, though: "if you say there is consciousness, you have to believe there is God." "It looks designed, so there must be intelligent design." This discussion could have been ended by asking:"does the quran say the earth was created before the planets and the stars?" - Yes. "That's not possible" - Agree to disagree "Ok, Goodbye!"

[@ahmedayoub9177]

That man was really stretching his mind may allah guide him.

[@flylord42]

There is no Allah, if you think there is, prove it.

[@ahmedayoub9177]

If you say i don't believe allah, that is acceptable and logical. But when you make statement like there is no god or allah then you should prove to us. For example i make claim that there is no caw on the moon. And when people ask me can you prove that i will not say i don't have reasons to believe that but i will say caw needs oxygen and other elements and they are not available on moon. "There is no allah" Can you prove to us please.

[@flylord42]

@@ahmedayoub9177 I agree the burden of proof is the one making the claim. Isn't it easier for you to prove Allah or should you concede there is no Allah? I have no belief in Allah, or any God thing. And don't have to burden of proof to prove a negative, that is a logical falacey in the first place. Being the logical person you claim you are, you should already know this. So why do you ask me stupid questions?

[@ahmedayoub9177]

@@flylord42 as usual that is what i expected. So first, my point is you can't say there is no allah as long as you can't disprove it. Secondly because the universe is a system (components working together) and system shows design and design shows basically intelligence. That is a basic answer for the existence of intelligent(God). Car, plane or artificial intelligence are products of intelligence. Just like that i say the human body for example is a product of higher intelligence.

[@flylord42]

@Hilman Shaharuddin Now your just being a coward. Come back to reality and stop falling for confirmation bias over the course of your life.

[@callmemak8489]

Probably the best, the most interesting discussions I’ve watched from Hashim

[@ghulamsarwar687]

Agree

[@TruthSeeker574]

A LITTLE KNOWLEDGE OF SCIENCE MAKES YOU AN ATHEIST. IN-DEPTH KNOWLEDGE OF SCIENCE MAKES YOU A BELIEVER IN GOD. (Albert Einstein)

[@umaryes4473]

@@SpeakersCornerAnalysed Alex, stop.

[@amirmohammed2932]

Gunther Vincent, most all scientists are theists, including Albert Einstein, scientists being atheists is something relatively new.

[@amirmohammed2932]

You do understand that they are essentially the same thing right? They both believe that God created everything. And why could a scientist not be a theist, do you also know that most all scientists were theists? For thousands of years, science has never contradicted religion, and to this day, it doesn’t, so tell me, what has changed?

[@amirmohammed2932]

Gunther Vincent, so why is one any more likely than the rest? If you say that theists have no evidence for a god, couldn’t you argue the same with a deist? It doesn’t make sense for a scientist to believe in one more than the other, as according to them, both have no “evidence” to support themselves. Why would you then say that most scientists are deists? That doesn’t make any sense.

[@amirmohammed2932]

That wasn’t the point. Earlier, you had said that “maybe a scientist could be a theist, certainly not a deist” which doesn’t make sense since both believe in something which according to you, has no “evidence” this shows that you are either ignorant of what you say, or are just biased against theists.

[@f8rk9n]

This 1 hour discussion is in my opinion more than enough to accept the existance of an intelligent designer and even to accept that Islam is the right Faith. SubhanAllah.

[@f8rk9n]

@oscarcr80 I mean in my opinion it is very easy to find the true religion out, if we only consider the 5 world religions. In Judeism you can only be a real jew, if you are born this way. Why would God only let jews go to paradise, if nobody can decide to be born as a jew. So that's against God's mercy. In Hinduism they create God with their own hands, which is of course a contradiction. You cannot create God and sorry if i have to say that, but otherwise i could also consider an excrement as God, EuzuBillah. What is this, like srsly. Buddhism is not really a religion, but philosophy. So that is out as well. And Christianity does not make any sense, God is not divided in 3 different person and 1 in total. That is also a contradiction. The Trinity came up 350 years after the preachings of Jesus. This system is nowhere in the bible, not even the concept of trinity is there. And also there is a lot of pornography in the bible, which shows that human beings have put these verses into the bible manually. So the only world religion left is actually Islam, that's how fast it goes. But I as a muslim respect all other religions of course. We have no space for racism in our society.

[@FullyAutomaticAddict410]

@@f8rk9n Nicely explained!👍🏾

[@AsixA6]

You need to work on your critical thinking skills.

[@f8rk9n]

@@AsixA6 Maybe you are right, or maybe you just need to understand what i am talking about.

[@AsixA6]

@@f8rk9n Maybe I'm just right and you don't know what you're talking about.

[@SISIABBAS]

I believe that if someone is truly open hearted to new knowledge and is curious about God, he will find Him. But you need to be open to understanding a way other than your own.

[@rz5214]

@@SpeakersCornerAnalysed Prof yourself do you exist of. We are talking to chemical substances?

[@elyasomar7117]

I am from Afghanistan so I was born a Muslim but used my brain not my Hart to believe in Allah sister

[@TheSlaveOfAllah1992]

What evidence Do you have that the past doesnt exist 😂

[@flylord42]

God isn't findable. Being open does nothing for finding something that is not there. It's clearly simple.

[@hali8580]

@@SpeakersCornerAnalysed so if I show you 10 professors who teach in universities from all around the world in non Muslim countries, will you accept they have accepted Islam after reading the Koran (the fact that you spelt it like this tells me your level of knowledge on this subject matter) and submitting to the truth of it's signs. Or are they just dumb people, as you suggest we are??

[@Emily-dc1wq]

One of the best SC vids i've seen! Love it.

[@AbrarManzoor]

I truly appreciate the patience of daiees like brother hashim bcoz stubborn people dont even accept they are concious when it comes to their ....i dont know ...only they could tell

[@flylord42]

I don't appreciate the dishonest conversation. It's idiocy.

[@AbrarManzoor]

@@flylord42 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 i dont bother about people who didnt even admit their concioudness

[@AsixA6]

@xaviesta John barnes What 'religion' is the supposed "diehard religious atheist" supposedly a member of? (Please say atheism so I can make you look stupid)

[@Cruelsport347]

subhan Allah , my brother Hashim nailed it with every point. I can see it made every one of them start to think differently and made them ponder. Brother Hashim has delivered in my opinion, now it is up to them to take away the lessons and start reading. May Allah bless you brother Hashim and may he protect you and your family, Aameen.

[@dodosback]

MashAllah one of the quickest hours of my life. Brother Hashim may Allah reward you and bless you for the work you put in. Hashim had a response and answer that ALWAYS made sense packed and loaded. Wallahi even when looking at this objectively and sincerely you will come to the conclusion La illaha il Allah, Muhammad rasool Allah.

[@dodosback]

@Salmaan UK He watched the entire video then comes to the comment section all worried and chaotic inside because he knows Hashim's points weren't refuted so he comes to the comment section to lie and act like Hashim made no points. Like you said there is no way for science to observe the human consciousness.

[@shafieemohddaut1244]

I have to admit this is a very good discussion. It makes me increasingly fear to the creator.Jzkk brother Hashim.

[@capecoastalart]

MashaAllah Hashiem. Your points were outstanding. Welldone.. May Allah reward you.

[@hassanomar7750]

Br. Hashim may God increase this tactics for you to expel the denials.

[@danibrown4294]

Loved every second of this video. Love from Australia.

[@101ferinaslam3]

Are u a Muslim bro?

[@AyubKhan-md4km]

Even the electron, protons etc that move within an atom have a specific order field in which they move around in the orbit of an atom

[@flylord42]

Our conscience requires the existence of a body. Without a body, there is no conscience. It's the dishonesty of the conversation that makes it silly. He is a trained apologist debating an atheist with dishonest views.

[@alexojideagu]

Neutron stars have no order

[@skrill3770]

@@flylord42 how do you know without a body there is no consciousness. You can't bring a dead man back and ask was he conscious while he was dead..

[@indrananayakkara7104]

@@flylord42 spot on . You are absolutely correct. There is no mind without matter. I would go little bit further and say also there is no matter without mind .

[@Miniondeals]

you are right bro, The solar system is made by the intelligent designer(Allah)(God), As the Iphone System is made by apple, size doesn't matter, if i make an iphone as big as the universe the question who designed this system will still be asked.

[@Apollo05]

Loved how respectful this conversation was. The guys seemed to really come around the Hashim’s ideas

[@nikeren7786]

This is one of the best discussion. Salute brother hashim

[@abramjeylani2462]

Calmness articulated Straight to point and humble gesture. This brother is just ☄️

[@vicbros08]

i just want to know how brother Hashim has the patience to spend time for all these people. Please teach me how to be that patience, like really patience! Respect.

[@tweyartweyar2063]

Insha'Allah these two gentlemen will embrace Islam one day. Subhana Allah.

[@AbrarManzoor]

Brother Hashim is a legend...

[@shade20082003]

😂😂😂😂cracks me up ‘ your no different than a rock ‘ And ‘ you have more to worry about other than magical dragons ‘

[@saffu87]

One of the best conversations in Hyde Park. I saved this video for future reference. Your great Hashim!

[@saisant100]

1000 likes to brother Hashim. May Allah bless you and your Family.

[@badlishahshabudin9339]

Masya Allah, I just love Hashim's killer line, "Shall I tell you why?" 😁

[@predatorL89]

May God guide both these guys James and peters and bring them to Islam the ONLY TRUE RELIGION! Peace✌

[@AsixA6]

Got any evidence it's true?

[@frifan217]

@@AsixA6 it said nowadays modern science, where 1400 years ago it is imposibel for a man who doesn't know about reading and writing.

[@frifan217]

@@AsixA6 black hole, pulsar, gravitational waves, big bang, iron, biology, botany, zoology, math, etc etc

[@frifan217]

@@AsixA6 in Quran

[@frifan217]

@@AsixA6 time dilation, moon and sun has their own orbit

[@MohammedImran-tj4gt]

Alhamdulillah one of the best explanations, may Allah reward you Bro Hashim

[@sohaibjamal711]

These are good guys who are trying to learn 👍👍. Also Hashim is amazing ☺️

[@ibrahimconteh8442]

For me this is the best video about God. gives me thumbs up cuz I luv the rationale behind everything Hashim said

[@AsixA6]

You're very easily impressed.

[@frankamodeo3640]

@@AsixA6 Say What?

[@AsixA6]

@@frankamodeo3640 What part of my comment do you need clarification of?

[@frankamodeo3640]

@@AsixA6 You say that because you don't me,it's the opposite, It is very difficult to impressed me.

[@AsixA6]

@@frankamodeo3640 AGAIN, what part of my comment do you need clarification of?

[@suhailinayat5120]

Very nice discussion!

[@rekaletaqsegak7660]

This is good conversation. Both are open heart and look sincere.

[@bsono3718]

one of the best of what I have heard from Brother Hashim

[@AsixA6]

Really?! That was just sad.

[@2peki189]

sometimes i step back to take an unbiased approach to the debate..... without fail the muslim always wins.

[@AsixA6]

_"sometimes i step back to take an unbiased approach to the debate"_ Ahahahaha!!! Yeah, sure you do.

[@haxseen]

May Allah s.t guide you to sttaight path

[@locrian0]

I swear to Allah brother i like to believe that im open minded but i wanna hear one good argument from atheists

[@AsixA6]

@@locrian0 No problem. The evidence supposed ‘god’ things don’t exist, is the complete lack of evidence I’d EXPECT if they do exist. Absence of evidence is evidence of absence when evidence is expected. When someone claims something exists, I definitely EXPECT evidence that it does.

[@313dimz]

@@AsixA6 : "something comes from nothing (aka no God)".. poor atheists.. Yeahhh.. an atheist is d most moron people in d face of d earth.. 🤣

[@yvryvryvr73]

Solid discussion and refutation by Br Hashim!

[@ahmedhanif911]

That was deep and respectable how it should be, may Allah guide them

[@hmgrraarrpffrzz9763]

Allah or skepticism.

[@ahmedhanif911]

@@hmgrraarrpffrzz9763 to me it seemed as though they were both leaning towards the theory of Something created something and their is a first cause and not everything comes from nothing. You may have skepticism about this theory but watching the video it seems their doubt has lessened as it's the only logical and sane explanation that makes sense.

[@hmgrraarrpffrzz9763]

@@ahmedhanif911 Well, but there are more options. 1) The universe had a beginning and it was a being that created the universe on purpose (like the deity you worship or a different deity or somebody else). 2) The universe had a beginning but it was not a deity but rather a natural cause. 3) The universe had a beginning without a cause. 4) The universe has always existed. 5) It is a different answer we can not even think of yet, because we don't know enough about the nature of the universe. As far as I know, there is no good verifiable evidence that any of those answers is true. So "right now, we do not know", seems to be the most truthful.

[@ahmedhanif911]

@@hmgrraarrpffrzz9763 The evidence is there to say we do know how it started, it's the Qur'an, the last Prophet pbuh and his sayings. The Qur'an foretold many things and has many miracles, the people at the time of Muhammed just accused him of being a magician or sorcerer, this just shows us that some people regardless of evidence will never come to believe for example the prophets uncle, it was said in the Qur'an he will be in the hell fire with his wife and he will never become a Muslim, so all he had to do was become a muslim and that would counter the whole word of god and destroy the Qur'an but God knew he was too stubborn he knows the future he is all knowing and wise and that his uncle would never convert, that is another miracle one of many to prove the word is true and the last Prophet pbuh is rightly guided.

[@hmgrraarrpffrzz9763]

@@ahmedhanif911 Does the Qur'an also provide evidence that Allah created the universe?

[@Addakhel]

May Allah bless Br. Hashem and the brothers of the SCDawah channel for this great content.

[@jahangirshinwari3334]

I just wanna say Alhamdulillah

[@muslimmas4321]

Subhanallah... Bro Hasyim elaborate everything n its make sense to those who inteligence thinking... Tq bro hasyim for the knowledgeable sharing...

[@sxnib5050]

I made a comment on older videos disrespecting hashim strategy as i found him cocky and i want to openly apologise for my comment and hope allah forgives me and grants hashim ease. I will go delete it now .

[@rahim4416]

I believe that if brother hashim sees your present comment, he will surely forgive you cause that is what islam teaches us to do. Inshaallah.

[@313dimz]

great bro.. 👍

[@sxnib5050]

abdul rahim inshallah if i see him at the park i will apologise.

[@FullyAutomaticAddict410]

@@sxnib5050 Righteous 💪🏾

[@lr4uuk]

Beautiful Hashim, people arnt open to except truth, feels like they didnt expect a person who believes in God to talk in their language and make sense.

[@lr4uuk]

36:00 , majority of videos i watched is always because of this, is their some form of discrimination or is it they expect someone who believes in a creator to be backwards?

[@EDINTOWN]

This man is blessed by the intelligent designer. I get his argument!

[@borntohodl2965]

Best and nice discussion

[@nasirupvita4063]

Maasha Allah, hashim make every thing crystal clear.

[@yusrontanzihan5261]

Masha Allah, very good argument from Hasyim.... Barakallah

[@gilgameshlfx7006]

Asking "Who made God?", "Where God came from?", is bunch of silly question because it's bunch questions under the assumption that God bound by time and space. A starting point is within time and space. God is there before the existence of time and space.

[@AsixA6]

That's called a claim. You need to actually evidence your claim.

[@gilgameshlfx7006]

@@AsixA6 Evidence? So you need evidence that consciousness exist too? You obviously one of those that measure speed of light with a thermometer. "God" isn't "God" if He did not create time/space. Therefore He isn't bound by it.

[@AsixA6]

@@gilgameshlfx7006 _"Evidence?"_ Yes, evidence. _"So you need evidence that consciousness exist too?"_ I have evidence that consciousness exists. _"You obviously one of those that measure speed of light with a thermometer."_ You're obviously running from evidencing your claim.

[@gilgameshlfx7006]

@@AsixA6 Okay, show me evidence that consciousness exist.

[@AsixA6]

@@gilgameshlfx7006 Oops!! You forgot to evidence your claim. Gee, what a surprise. The fact that you responded to me is evidence of consciousness. Now, how about you evidence your ridiculous claim?......cricket, cricket, cricket.....didn't think so. You'll undoubtedly just argue incessantly about the evidence I pointed out for consciousness.

[@ibrahimconteh8442]

Hashim is very very very intelligent. One of his kind. Everything he is saying is very logical, you cannot deny it.

[@AsixA6]

_"you cannot deny it."_ Yes, I can.

[@aimanbabahmed7449]

@@AsixA6 and then u live in delusion. Congratz

[@AsixA6]

@@aimanbabahmed7449 No, Captain Projection, people that think everything Hashim said is logical, are delusional. Congrats.

[@aimanbabahmed7449]

@@AsixA6 why is that. Explain.

[@AsixA6]

@@aimanbabahmed7449 WTF? Because not everything he said is logical, you delusional magic believer.

[@fasttorquedrifter91]

And when harm touches you upon the sea, those that you call upon vanish from you except Him (Allah Alone). But when He brings you safe to land, you turn away (from Him)And man is ever ungrateful." Al-Israa, verse 67....when death is near they will certainly call to Allah to save them yet arrogance blinds them.

[@BosniannMuslim]

Thats a beautiful Verse

[@ryanmwanza5439]

La ilaha ill'Allah !!! ☝🏾

[@mubeenmoosa429]

I love this video. Hashim is the best. May Allah reward him.

[@axd2312]

Am i the only one whose blood boils seeing these Atheists not understand a simple thing? I don't know how these brothers have so much Patience

[@axd2312]

@@ibra1616 yes! This is Exactly what they do! They know the truth but not believing in it gives them mental relaxation to do whatever they want to do.

[@AsixA6]

@@axd2312 How long ago was your insanity diagnosed?

[@isam3l3]

very cool convo, i like how it seems these brothers in humanity reason. thanks and jAK Akhi Hashim for speaking and alhamdillah for allowing us the knowledge

[@peacebeuntoyou8934]

36:49 "I'm not going to steal it from you..." Meaning 'I have no valid response'. Weak.

[@curious413]

Lol 😂

[@rashidmamadiev6386]

Truly great discussion and reasoning! Well done Hashim!

[@ndhikaatube]

Powerful discussion, powerful dawah

[@tarek399]

Abdullah ibn Amr reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said: إِنَّ الْمُقْسِطِينَ عِنْدَ اللَّهِ عَلَى مَنَابِرَ مِنْ نُورٍ عَنْ يَمِينِ الرَّحْمَنِ عَزَّ وَجَلَّ وَكِلْتَا يَدَيْهِ يَمِينٌ الَّذِينَ يَعْدِلُونَ فِي حُكْمِهِمْ وَأَهْلِيهِمْ وَمَا وَلُوا Verily, those who were just will be in the presence of Allah upon pulpits of light, near the right hand of the Merciful, the Exalted, and both of his sides are honorable. They are those who practiced justice in their judgments and with their families and in all that they did. Source: Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 4493, Grade: Sahih

[@KaMasno]

Assalamualaikum Brothers and Sisters... Nice and smart talk by Brother Hashim with logical points raised... Alhamdulillah... ALLAHUAKBAR... Allahumma Aamiiin. Thanks for sharing.

[@madinati7775]

I suggest after every discussion with anyone give him a short information about Islam like brother shamsi do cause these people are misleading.

[@stephen271]

This was a great discussion

[@quranrecitationsandmemoriz1474]

Brothers and sisters, I invite you to 💜 touching Quran recitations.

[@rajayar4237]

He did not even mention islam till asked. I was shocked. very impressed.

[@Dawahdude0]

I testify that nothing worthy of worship but Allah. And I testify that Muhammad is the last Messenger and servant of Allah. أَشْهَدُ أَنْ لاَ إِلَهَ إِلاَّ اللَّهُ أَشْهَدُ أَنْ لاَ إِلَهَ إِلاَّ اللَّهُ أَشْهَدُ أَنَّ مُحَمَّدًا رَسُولُ اللَّهِ Ash Hadu An La Ilaha IllAllah Wa Ashadu An Na Muhammadan Abduhu Wa Rasuluh.

[@ikhsanikhsan2721]

MasyaAllah I love this conversation !

[@doctr7147]

You gotta have a few screws missing if you believe there is no creator

[@theoskeptomai2535]

Have you ever personally witnessed any phenomenon (object, event, substance, entity, process, system, or being) to have been created _ex nihilo_ - that is instantaneously popped into existence by the sole volition of a god?

[@amirmohammed2932]

Theo Skeptomai, this is a logical fallacy as the same argument could be applied to hide who believe the opposite. Have you ever experienced a phenomenon in which anything popped into existence from nothing? You see, it can be applied to anyone

[@theoskeptomai2535]

@@amirmohammed2932 The is not the opposite you fucking idiot. Nothing POPS INTO EXISTENCE. It was a fucking 'yes' or 'no' question and you avoided answering it. Why is that? I ALWAYS answer question directed to me. I am so tired of fucking cowards like you. What was preventing from answering a direct (and non-leading question) that only required a yes or no response?

[@amirmohammed2932]

Theo Skeptomai, maybe if you didn’t get so emotional when someone pointed out a logical fallacy in your incredibly weak argument. Compose yourself, you might be able to learn something. The answer to the question you asked me is the same as the answer to the question which I asked you, as they are in essence, the same question. And so you did just dodge my question, which in effect, would have answered your question. And according to most atheists, the universe did pop into existence, as that is the entire point of atheism, there was no creator. Use your intellect, not your emotions.

[@doctr7147]

@@theoskeptomai2535 yes I have ..but that didn't make me start to believe ..I already believed in the first place. .

[@kashmirilion8524]

Brilliant brother the way you have explain to these thick atheist

[@frifan217]

The jaket guy is thinking about sense, insyaaAllah Allah will guide him

[@Abeer-Essa]

One of the best discussions.

[@christopherwells3426]

Billions and billions of years of evolution so has Evolution stopped? When did it begin and when did it end. And what is your evidence.

[@dota2blendezt686]

Spot on

[@theoskeptomai2535]

Evolution never for an instance ceases. Evolution is the pertual process of change over time. Every phenomena is in transition at any given instant. Otherwise we would not be able to detect any phenomena.

[@christopherwells3426]

@@theoskeptomai2535 just remember evolution is a theory after life began. Why don't you tell me how the gases from millions of years ago formed Life as we know it LOL why don't you tell me how we popped into existence LOL why don't you tell me how we came into being from nothing LOL why don't you tell me how we crawled out of the ocean LOL why don't you tell me how there are still monkeys why have they not evolved yet are they just slow like you? Evolution it's not adaptation. We have evolved in the sense of adapting to the environment over the millions of years. It's not the same thing as once you were a monkey then you became a man. I know I know it was just one big cosmological accident. Yeah yeah yeah.

[@theoskeptomai2535]

@@christopherwells3426 Is evolution described as change that occurs over time? Yes or no.

[@theoskeptomai2535]

@@christopherwells3426 How did you come to the conclusion that "we popped into existence?" Have you ever personally witnessed any phenomenon (object, event, substance, entity, process, system, or being) to have been created _ex nihilo_ - that is instantaneously popped into existence by the sole volition of a deity? Yes or no?

[@afzalhussain605]

Very patiently discussing Hashim 👌🏼

[@mohamedmylastnameisibrahim1606]

11:38 Ohhh nooo here comes the dajjal 😂

[@مزوزعبداللطيف]

Brother Hashim Allah swt has gifted you with wisdom and beautiful preaching.so that you explain to peaple his right path.good job Allah blesse you

[@basitali3679]

ALMIGHTY ALLAH GIVES HIDYAT TO ALL NON BELIEVERS AND ALSO US MUSLIMS THAT WE PRACTICE ISLAM IN OUR LIVES

[@pbuh8352]

Just wow im mind blowed this man hashim mashallah Ty for this video it was educational very much

[@falagar1929]

hashim... may Allah(cc) gives you health, wealth and a peaceful life with your family... we love you..

[@Muslimman570]

Very fruit full discussion may Allah guide them

[@agsaay]

Naaa. It is so simple. They want to deny the existence of God to live a guilt free life.

[@aumyousefnasser9359]

Mashallah I love the ways in which sentence you explanation. May bless you.

[@robertomalone3222]

Mashallah brother Hashim, may Allah bless you, great dialogue.

[@MuslimKing-1]

May Allah be with u brother hashim... salute to and your work and knowledge.. .. may Allah be with us and strength us inshallah

[@cristiandinut5729]

Ma shaa Allah.... beautiful

[@joeygio5015]

I have been making the same argument Brother Hashim was making at 52:42. If I’m wrong and there is no god or afterlife then when I die I lose nothing. But, if someone who discounts the existence of God and the afterlife is wrong when they die, the consequences are much more dire.

[@mohamedsekiro876]

Very nice and lovely conversation, they both looked searching for the truth, may Allah guide them and enlighten them

[@peacebeuntoyou8934]

Except the third guy, he had nothing fruitful to add.

[@mohamedsekiro876]

Yeah, I was only talking about Peter and James

[@peacebeuntoyou8934]

@@mohamedsekiro876 Yeah, not the guy with the pink tie though.

[@terrelvivi1043]

I love these videos. What baffles me is how someone has a belief, but when that belief is tested by asking the most simplest question they won’t answer it. Accept the possibility that you could be wrong or misinformed. Imagine going your entire life not believing in anything due to the lack of scientific evidence and ending up in hell for eternity.

[@AsixA6]

WTF? I believe lots of things. I just don't believe the asinine claim that supposed 'god' thingys exist. _"Accept the possibility that you could be wrong or misinformed."_ Yes, please do accept the possibility that YOU could be wrong or misinformed. _"Imagine going your entire life not believing in anything due to the lack of scientific evidence and ending up in hell for eternity."_ Imagine going your entire life believing in fairy tales with a complete lack of evidence. That would be insane!

[@terrelvivi1043]

jwkivy the whole point of the comment was him not answering a simple question. I absolutely accept the fact that I could be wrong or misinformed and that’s with anything not just Allah but, until someone or something is brought to my attention with facts that contradicts what I believe, I will continue with my beliefs. That last sentence just shows me how little research you’ve actually done to support the claim of a “Fairy Tale.” I’m not forcing myself to be a Muslim or live my life in the manner that I do so if I die and none of this was true, I would be completely happy with my life. Let me ask you a question. Is there anything you believe that cannot be proved by science?

[@AsixA6]

@@terrelvivi1043 _”...until someone or something is brought to my attention...”_ *...you’ll keep believing something you have zero evidence of being true. That’s bad reasoning.* _”Is there anything you believe that cannot be proved by science?”_ *First, science doesn’t ‘prove’ anything. Second, I never claimed only science can ‘prove’(evidence) things so, your question is nonsensical.*

[@terrelvivi1043]

@@AsixA6 long time no hear buddy. First, what do you accept as evidence? There’s plenty of evidence for Allah and I can give you some. So, let me know what you accept as evidence. Second, okay science doesn’t prove anything but it can confirm.

[@AsixA6]

@@terrelvivi1043 Yeah, YT didn't notify me of your previous reply. What I accept as evidence is the available body of facts or information indicating whether a belief or proposition is true or valid. _"There’s plenty of evidence for Allah and I can give you some."_ *Then stop running from do so and just present it!* Science doesn't 'confirm' anything either.

[@Zeeshanijaz844]

Wow. What a beautiful discussion. One thing that a lot of people fail to mention is the purpose behind all of this. Behind the creation of universe, uncountable species and humans. The main and primary purpose for us to be here is that before creating consciousness, no one knew God. It's been said in Quran by Allah, that i was a hidden treasure and i decided to be known. This is where the mystery is solved for those who think. You see if we did not have consiousness, we wouldn't know that we exist. So for Allah to be known to someone and especially, to be known out of free will, a journey and brainstorming, Allah had to give us some sort of free will and consciousness. That's the reason, we can question if God exists. The fact that we are able to "question" God is in itself a miracle and something that should blow our minds with wonder. So we question and seek. Some become successful and fulfull their primary purpose and some are passed on to the afterlife, where they see what they have missed. For example, if i have made a robot and it's name is James. I spend 10 years with James and he helps me with cleaning and stuff. I have fallen in love with James and i wish that James knew who i am and who James is. So one day, i give him some sort of artificial intelligence or consciousness. James will then know, first of all that he exists himself and then he'll look at me and ask who are you. In this example, James is us the humans and the creator is Allah. As soon as you realise this, the journey starts.

[@isthisshabab4561]

this guy James and Peter they seem so sincere. Maybe Allah guide them. Ameen

[@rahim4416]

I believe with all my heart from the reaction of peter and especially james at the end of their discussion with brother hashim, they will pick the The Holy Quraan and with guidance of The Creator will someday accept that it came from The Creator and eventually fulfills the commands of the The Creator for mankind. Inshaallah.

[@walidaitaissa6196]

@Gunther Vincent why would he need to give an evidence ? It's just a point of view fam 😂😂

[@mahashalgam9480]

جزاكم الله خير

[@mohdalinz7226]

I Love Hashim..he was always precise to the point that in the opposite wants

[@fa-en4mn]

عيد مبارك علينا وعليكم الله يوفقك ويسعدك ويبارك فيك جهود موقفه.

[@erdogan70]

MASHALLAH brother Hashim

[@proficiency7751]

The issue of an originator was concluded.. Ie: A originator, An initial Cause, it was necessary from then to discuss the qualities, it MUST possess in depth. A Will/Intent, Knowledge & Mercy, so as to further conclude in accepting a unwilling position of being under the influence of a GOVERNING CREATIONAL LAW ie: The need for sleep, sustenance companionship inclusive of Humans and animals alike. The earth's dependency on the Sun etc. Also an acknowledgement of having non awareness of one's personal life span... to whom you'd be born from.. your ethnicity/geographical locality at birth or death. (سَیَقُولُونَ لِلَّهِۚ قُلۡ أَفَلَا تَذَكَّرُونَ) [سورة المؤمنون 85]

[@kakalam6004]

To know is merely a mental activity, as evidence can be information that is logically consistent and cannot be falsified.

I like Hashim. He knows what he is talking about. Hashim should be debating the bigger fish in the market.

[@amani2283]

May Allah bless you brother Hashim

[@e.e121]

So many Christians appear sincere and claim to be open minded. The moment they are offered a Quran, they pause to think. What are they considering? If I am open minded about something, I would grab the knowledge with both hands...