Schubert: Complete Piano Sonatas

[@BrilliantClassics]

Thank you for watching, let us know your favourite Schubert piano sonata. And don't forget to like the video and subscribe! Tracklist: Klára Würtz (piano): Franz Schubert: Piano Sonata in B-Flat Major, Op. posth., D. 960: 0:00:00 I. Allegro moderato 0:21:38 II. Andante sostenuto 0:31:20 III. Scherzo, allegro vivace con delicatezza 0:35:20 IV. Allegro, ma non troppo Piano Sonata in B Major, Op. Posth. 147, D. 575: 0:43:51 I. Allegro, ma non troppo 0:51:11 II. Andante 0:56:41 III. Scherzo, allegretto 1:01:34 IV. Allegro giusto 1:06:26 “Lebensstürme”, allegro for piano 4 hands in A Minor, D. 968 Frank van de Laar (piano): Piano Sonata in A Major, D. 959: 1:18:06 I. Allegro 1:35:54 II. Andantino 1:44:38 III. Scherzo, allegro vivace 1:49:44 IV. Rondo, allegretto Piano Sonata in E Minor, D. 566: 2:02:58 I. Moderato 2:09:06 II. Allegretto 2:17:04 III. Scherzo, allegro vivace 2:22:21 IV. Rondo, allegretto Folke Nauta (piano): Piano Sonata in C Minor, D. 958: 2:28:46 I. Allegro 2:40:00 II. Adagio 2:47:21 III. Menuetto, allegro 2:50:48 IV. Allegro 6 Moments Musicaux, D. 780: 2:59:55 I. Moderato in C Major 3:05:30 II. Andantino in A-Flat Major 3:11:43 III. Allegretto moderato in F Minor 3:13:51 IV. Moderato in C-Sharp Minor 3:19:18 V. Allegro vivace in F Minor 3:21:35 VI. Allegretto in A-Flat Major Frank van de Laar (piano): Piano Sonata in D Major, Op. 53, D. 850 “Gasteiner”: 3:30:02 I. Allegro vivace 3:38:58 II. Con moto 3:52:57 III. Scherzo, allegro vivace 4:02:36 IV. Rondo, allegro moderato Piano Sonata in C Major, D. 840 “Relique”: 4:11:52 I. Moderato 4:25:54 II. Andante Piano Sonata in A-Flat Major, D. 557: 4:35:39 I. Allegro moderato 4:39:22 II. Andante 4:43:10 III. Allegro David Kuyken (piano): Piano Sonata in A Minor, Op. 143, D. 784: 4:49:54 I. Allegro giusto 5:02:28 II. Andante 5:07:07 III. Allegro vivace Piano Sonata in G Major, Op. 78, D. 894: 5:12:25 I. Molto moderato e cantabile 5:30:35 II. Andante 5:38:45 III. Menuetto, allegro moderato 5:43:08 IV. Allegretto Klára Würtz (piano): Piano Sonata in A Minor, D. 537: 5:52:09 I. Allegro ma non troppo 6:02:51 II. Allegretto, quasi andantino 6:11:27 III. Allegro vivace Piano Sonata in A Major, Op. 120, D. 664: 6:15:52 I. Allegro moderato 6:26:57 II. Andante 6:32:09 III. Allegro Pieter van Winkel (piano): Drei Klavierstücke (Impromptus aus dem Nachlass), D. 946: 6:39:38 I. Allegro molto in E-Flat Minor 6:52:48 II. Allegretto in E-Flat Major 7:03:43 III. Allegro in C Major Bart van Oort (fortepiano): Piano Sonata in A Minor, Op. 42, D. 845: 7:09:26 I. Moderato 7:21:06 II. Andante, poco mosso 7:33:43 III. Scherzo, allegro vivace 7:42:07 IV. Rondo, allegro vivace Piano Sonata in E Major, D. 459: 7:47:51 I. Allegro moderato 7:54:40 II. Scherzo, allegro 7:59:37 III. Adagio 8:05:57 IV. Scherzo con trio 8:09:01 V. Allegro patetico Alwin Bär (piano): Piano Sonata in F-Sharp Minor, D. 570/571: 8:15:49 I. Allegro (finished by Alwin Bär) 8:23:20 II. Scherzo, allegro vivace 8:26:24 III. Allegro moderato (finished by Alwin Bär) Piano Sonata in C Major, D. 613: 8:33:06 I. Moderato (finished by Alwin Bär) 8:41:26 II. Without tempo indication (finished by Alwin Bär) Piano Sonata in F Minor, D. 625: 8:49:30 I. Allegro (finished by Alwin Bär) 8:58:35 II. Scherzo, allegretto 9:02:15 III. Allegro 9:09:04 Sonata Movement in C-Sharp Minor, D. 655 (finished by Alwin Bär) 9:13:30 Ungarische Melodie, D. 817 Zwei Scherzi, D. 593: 9:17:48 I. Scherzo in B-Flat Major 9:21:56 II. Scherzo in D-Flat Major Tamara Rumiantsev (piano): Piano Sonata in E Major, D. 157: 9:27:22 I. Allegro ma non troppo 9:32:42 II. Andante 9:38:37 III. Menuetto, allegro vivace Piano Sonata in C Major, D. 279: 9:42:24 I. Allegro moderato 9:49:05 II. Andante 9:54:26 III. Menuetto, allegro vivace 9:57:34 IV. Allegretto Piano Sonata in E-Flat Major, D. 568: 10:04:44 I. Allegro moderato 10:11:11 II. Andante molto 10:16:40 III. Menuetto, allegretto 10:20:20 IV. Allegro moderato 10:28:04 Fantasie in C Minor, D. 2 e 10:35:14 Allegretto in C Minor, D. 915 10:39:34 Scherzo, D. 593 in B-Flat Major Martijn van den Hoek (piano): Impromptus, Op. 90: 10:43:32 No. 1 in C Minor. Allegro molto moderato 10:52:59 No. 2 in E-Flat Major. Allegro 10:57:17 No. 3 in G-Flat Major. Andante 11:02:55 No. 4 in A-Flat Major. Allegretto Impromptus, Op. 142: 11:10:52 No. 1 in F Minor. Allegro moderato 11:23:41 No. 2 in A-Flat Major. Allegretto 11:31:35 No. 3 in B-Flat Major. Andante mit Varationen (Rosamunde) 11:43:12 No. 4 in F Minor. Allegro vivace Fantasie in C Major, Op. 15, D. 760 “Wanderer Fantasie”: 11:49:54 I. Allegro con fuoco 11:55:59 II. Adagio 12:03:10 III. Scherzo, presto 12:07:59 IV. Allegro 12:11:29 Deutsche Tänze / German Dances: Op. 18: No. 1 12:12:39 Deutsche Tänze / German Dances: Op. 9: No. 3 12:13:37 Deutsche Tänze / German Dances: Op. 18: No. 4 12:14:22 Deutsche Tänze / German Dances: Op. 9: No. 5 12:14:52 Deutsche Tänze / German Dances: Op. 9: No. 6 12:15:26 Deutsche Tänze / German Dances: Op. 9: No. 2 12 Wiener Deutsche Tänze, D. 128: 12:16:17 No. 1 12:17:19 No. 2 12:18:36 No. 3 12:19:58 No. 4 12:20:57 No. 5 12:21:42 No. 6 12:22:48 No. 7 12:23:50 No. 8 12:24:43 No. 9 12:25:25 No. 10 12:26:46 No. 11 12:27:36 No. 12 12:28:29 German Dance and Ecossaise, D.643 12:29:19 German Dance, D. 722 2 Deutsche Tänze, D. 769 12:30:04 No. 1 12:31:18 No. 2 16 Deutsche Tänze, Op. 33, D. 783 12:32:06 No. 1 12:32:59 No. 2 12:33:52 No. 3 12:34:26 No. 4 12:35:01 No. 5 12:35:37 No. 6 12:36:12 No. 7 12:37:07 No. 8 12:37:41 No. 9 12:38:06 No. 10 12:39:13 No. 11 12:39:44 No. 12 12:40:16 No. 13 12:40:50 No. 14 12:41:27 No. 15 12:42:04 No. 16 Deutsche Tänze, D. 820 12:42:43 No. 1 12:45:07 No. 2 Deutsche Tänze, D. 970 12:48:51 No. 1 12:50:12 No. 2 12:50:39 No. 3 12:51:21 No. 4 12:51:56 No. 5 3 Deutsche Tänze, D. 971 12:52:36 No. 1 12:53:12 No. 2 12:53:51 No. 3 3 Deutsche Tänze, D. 972 12:54:52 No. 1 12:55:27 No. 2 12:56:15 No. 3 3 Deutsche Tänze, D. 973 12:56:52 No. 1 12:57:43 No. 2 12:58:47 No. 3 2 Deutsche Tänze, D. 974 12:59:55 No. 1 13:00:29 No. 2 13:01:10 German Dance, D.975

[@stefanomadrau3683]

664😙

[@godless1456]

العزف على الكمان احسن من البيانو

[@stefanomadrau3683]

@@godless1456 Muciti

[@alexandredlougoch8076]

Aa

[@marcosabeldomingues3071]

1

[@zuzannawisniewska4464]

The older I get, the more I appreciate Franz Schubert..Schubert is the best ..

[@autobusowyawanturnik9410]

how old are you?

[@autobusowyawanturnik9410]

are you into classical music?

[@a.duncan6791]

I want to live in a world without noise. I'm happy with piano songs and the wind in the trees.

[@gabrielsoutopiano]

Só no Céu! Compartilho de teu pensamento. O barulho não faz bem, o Bem não faz barulho. O mundo é muito barulhento!

[@shin-i-chikozima]

This masterpiece will quench and moisturize the dryness of the soul, and evoke comfortable feelings and nostalgic feelings

[@jeffsmith1798]

It amazes me that in such a short stay on this earth, Schubert created so much beauty.

[@MJballer97]

That was his purpose I guess

[@educatorsnake]

It was an austrian, that's why.

[@matthewpoplawski8740]

Jeff Smith, see,also, Mozart,Chopin, and, the Schumanns.✌✌✌✌

[@Populous3Tutorials]

@@educatorsnake true, just like hitler, they come to earth only for a while but do great things

[@davidgarione2206]

@@Populous3Tutorials You're being sarcastic, I suppose.

[@Sandrine-uv7qn]

I read in a biography of Schubert that he was in love with a simple young lady, not very pretty but gentle, a singer, but he could never marry her because he was not rich enough. She waited for him a long while until she could not wait any longer.. I found this story sad sure but very romantic too ...

[@yaufmannadezhda.]

Ой, как же Вы мне угодили! Как же я обожаю Шуберта! Завтра утром буду собираться к выходу и включу эту музыку! Как же я люблю интернет! Сколько здесь волшебной музыки!

[@micael5805]

I am listening to Schubert while I see the ruins of the Ukrainian cities that your country destroyed

[@pineapplelofi3236]

As I begin this day, help me to remember that I belong to you. Guide my spirit through your wisdom so that I do not stumble or falter as I walk in your path. Amen.

[@peacefullness-8823]

You belong to me. There, happy?

[@shin-i-chikozima]

There are the universal things and the immortal things in this world. It is masterpieces of Schubert

[@外山貴康-b2w]

クララ　ワルツさんの演奏で14時間に及ぶシューベルトのピアノソナタを聴いております。ピアノの響きが私の心を癒してくれます。ひとつひとつ音がくっきりと表現されています。自然なピアノの響きに魅力を感じました。ありがとうございます。この様な大曲をじっくり聴くのが私の好みです。次回のプログラムを期待しております。ありがとうごさいます。

[@catherinejones9396]

Days and days of beautiful music. I had no idea that Schubert wrote so many sonatas in his tragically short life. What I have heard so far tells me this is a musical tour that will be well worth the while embarking on. Thank you yet again Brilliant Classics. You never fail me in expanding my musical journey. At 81, that has been happening since I was 3 and started experimenting at playing piano. My hands and shoulders no longer allow me that pleasure, but my ears and brain still carry my curiosity on. There is a great deal to enjoy in today's classical type musical world and exciting young artists and composers to be amazed at. Then there are the immortals, like Schubert. This recording is one of your best piano ones to date, and the artists who have played here appear to be very insightful and talented. Thank you so much. By the way did the Jussen brothers play the Lebenssturme?

[@BrilliantClassics]

Dear Catherine, Klára Würtz is the pianist who plays the Lebensstürme!

[@luisdiazlopez3712]

Claudio Arrau said that Schubert's sonatas are the last challenge of a pianist.

[@hannawagenknecht6378]

Diese Art, Musik zu machen,ist mit die Schönste,mit anderen Worten,ich bewundere Schubert so sehr und sage , Dankeschön 😌❤️

[@musicamedieval516]

Thank you for sharing this beautiful FREE ENERGY. God Bless Everyone 🙏

[@rafaelac7617]

Heerlijk, 13 uur Schubert onafgebroken, kom je de hele dag mee door!

[@Roman_Politykin]

Вы не работаете?

[@trevorj4707]

Does it just not blow your mind to know that these seriously awesome artists who lived many many years ago are known for music that ultimately accumulates to only a few hours' worth of work in the end? The amount of effort it took is seldom ever taken into account.

[@MirjaRiihimaki]

Schubert had never the home of his own and still he made such a marvellous music for us to listen!!

[@billtomson5791]

Schubert never ceases to amaze me, perplex me, excite me, sadden me and fill me with wonder all at once. I listen to his chamber and piano music like Sherlock Holmes on the trail of Professor Moriarty.

[@piengiess]

Elementary, old chap. Listen to the 'footsteps' ..........

[@myrnakosse3347]

Schubert always hits me immediately, especially the D 960 Sonata. Thank you for sharing his immense work for Piano. I will always be grateful!

[@Andersdenkende]

He is at the end.... usually things intensify then. Quality and intensity....before he dies

[@notaire2]

What a nice compilation of all the piano sonatas composed by Schubert together with other small but beautiful masterpieces! All the pianists are excellent and highly intelligent. Thank you for the elaborate upload with the highest possible sound quality!

[@edwardnah6739]

Schubert shows Eternal beauties in these piano works over the Universe.

[@juanramonbertran2910]

Que maravilla poder disfrutar a Schubert y a otros grandes. Gracias youtube y su gente, que no todo son algoritmos. Son mi cable a tierra!!!!

[@vivacepianostudio]

Thank you so very much! I love all the composers’ music but Schubert touches my heart like no one else. His beauty and spirit overwhelms me. I will spend many happy hours listening.

[@fulviopolce9785]

Meravigliosa raccolta ,stupendo inserimento che esalta le migliori qualità pianistiche di Schubert. Un grazie con affetto.

[@shainacamous9180]

Shubert is a composer very famous in the world and he belong at the classic century. This performance is very good. Shubert pieces talk with human and explain feels and interiors and exteriors of human. Bc it is very couriousement. I love shubert bc of his talent and his sens that shows to everyone. Thx a lot .

[@miguelarriagada5765]

Crecí escuchando las sonatas de piano de Shubert que tocaba mi padre en el piano de la casa, son todas hermosas, evocadoras y llenas de la magia de lo imprevisto

[@steveegallo3384]

MIGUEL ARRIAGADA -- De acuerdísimo......BRAVO desde Acapulco!

[@timfinn3395]

The Wanderer Fantasie is up there for me as one of the 'great' piano works. If I want a relaxing and melodical Sonata there are so many, but I always lean towards the immensely satisfying D-Major D850. I really enjoyed playng the Moments Musicaux in my youth.

[@paulwhetstone0473]

Ahhhhhhhhh, so nice to hear the warm and lively tones of Schubert’s piano music. I particularly enjoyed the 6 Moments Musicaux.

[@류순열-h6i]

아름다운 피아노 연주곡 잘 들었습니다~감사합니다~🎵🎹🌿🍀☘🌹🌹☘🍀🌿❤❤수고 많으셨습니다~🍮

[@tomradford7174]

So very pleased with Schubert!

[@rsjmd]

Wurtz's 960 is marvelous. Thanks.

[@markknego7658]

Lovely! I'm new to classical music and I'm happy I found him.

[@fransmeersman2334]

Many thanks for this marvelous upload of Schubert's heavenly piano sonatas, and also very interesting with several great performers !

[@raacher]

Qué interpretación tan bella. Gracias Klàra por tanta belleza, klaridad, espiritualidad. Que placer escuchar esta sonata del gran Schubert. Schubert por siempre esparciendo tu primavera eterna tu canto eterno para deleite de nosotros los mortales. Vive vive vive deidad amada ….

[@HB-MrCatLover]

Thank you so much for sharing this amazing musical moment. I love the piano sonata in D Major, Op. 53, D. 850 “Gasteiner”.

[@stephanebelizaire3627]

Great Music Forever !

[@gabrielmny]

Practically all of Schubert's piano music, brought together in one great video! A musical wealth! Thank you Brilliant 🎼

[@miamichel4586]

I adore Shubert piano sonatas!

[@tomwalker6756]

Glorious music. I wonder what incredible works he would have produced if he lived longer than his 32 years?

[@OrestesMourao-jh8xs]

Vou escutando por etapas, muito agradecido, gosto muito das Sonatas, de todos eles.

[@MrSEMYRAN]

All of the sonatas are heavenly. Thank you so much!!

[@gustavodelagnolo7062]

It's a very generous your initative that of sharing this wonderful collection. God bless you!

[@janwillemfolkers8115]

Goedemiddag, erg veel dank voor het opladen van deze schitterende muziek. Good afternoon, many thanks for uploading this beautiful music👌🙏

[@marthaaceves5181]

Estoy escuchando las sonatas de Schubert bellísima interpretación. Muchas gracias ❤️

[@rodolfoschossig9226]

Majestosa música, traz muita paz. Muito obrigado

[@antonioprisposolamela9355]

Gracias por regalarlos esta música tan de este mundo, que parece del otro.

[@ethansadberry6069]

I am really starting to become a huge Schubert fan

[@billtomson5791]

Welcome to a very fine club. The Trout Quintet got me "hooked" in the '80s.

[@Delectatio]

This is mesmerizing! Thank you so much🙂!

[@akanda50]

Thank you brilliant classics for another epic upload! You are beautifully consistent in doing this !

[@mishadeschreider8267]

Beautiful interpretation

[@joaoantonio-md9jz]

Aliás o período entre 4h50’ e 6h da obra uau!! Gênio é pouco para shubert.

[@pierrefoul5960]

Thank you Franz

[@adamweilergurarye5422]

thank you so much for this upload

[@TheRealCarolin]

estaba escuchando esto mientras hacía otras cosas, pero la música, cuando es buena, entra como sea. Gracias, Schubert es maravilloso

[@dimakurochkin4066]

Я рад возможности прослушать все сонаты Шуберта, которые я очень люблю ❤😂😅

Faz muito tempo que eu queria ouvir Schubert obrigada

[@Taka-Musics-Labo]

Thank you so much for posting this great video, like as an encyclopedia of Schubert's piano works..

[@aliciabarrigaaedo8675]

Gracias por este regalo tan hermoso. Excelente compañía en horas de trabajo

[@jackarcher7495]

These are very fine performances of this wonderful music. If this were the only recording of Schubert sonatas you had in your collection, it would perfectly suffice.

[@pietervoogt]

I always love this part... 1:14:30

[@knownfact4905]

Beautiful -- especially having the next 13 hours of listening all set out for me.

[@peace13216]

Thank you for the great job.. Brilliant classics 💕

[@elianeh_777]

Bravo!!!! Estupendo!!!! Thank you from Brazil!!!!

[@focomarin2515]

Excelente y sublime!

[@aboelsaudeldessuky4844]

thanks a lot for uploading

[@stlouisix3]

Brilliant classical music⛵

[@Tijaxtolan]

I still can’t understand why Schubert’s hasn’t as many recordings of his symphonies and sonatas as Beethoven

[@akanda50]

I agree! After Decades of listening, I feel like he is in the same league as Beethoven and Mozart.

[@canman5060]

Maybe some think Schubert's symphonies and sonatas are imitation of Beethoven.

[@canman5060]

Much less recordings for Beethoven's secretary and student Federnand Ries.

[@Tijaxtolan]

@@canman5060 he's good too

[@Jorgereflexivo]

Schubert didn't know counterpoint!

[@CabezasDePescado]

Thank you for sharing this

[@MatiShemoeloff]

Thank you! I will include Stanislav Ricther interpatation of Shubert's sonata.

[@luisdiazlopez3712]

Saviatoslav Richter's is one of the best D 960 version.

[@lnw1515]

Maravilhosas interpretações! Muito grato pela divulgação.

[@gerardocoluccini1751]

Franz Schubert was one of the greatest composers of all time. His life was not easy. Schubert enormous talent was not recognized during his short life (only 31 years) and, to survive, he could only count on the help of a few friends, who often spent the evenings with him, when he used to play his works at the piano, often with the presence of a singer (his famous lieder). He wasn't lucky in love either. He fell in love, reciprocated, with an opera singer, but her father opposed the marriage, since Franz was poor and without a stable job. He left us a legacy of inestimable value: his works, most of which were saved from oblivion thanks to Robert Schumann, who found the scores in his house in Vienna, thrown into a dumpster by his brothers. A detail: Schubert, unlike most composers, did not use the piano to compose; simply, he wrote on the score, as we would write a letter (before computers!). Thank you, Franz. God gave you gifts of inestimable value, which you transformed, for us mere mortals, into simulacra of Beauty.

[@2002jorgeparr]

Awesome 😎 THANK YOU SOOOOOO MUCH!!!!!!!!!

[@fikretsokmen9812]

Müthiş bir birikim dinle dinle bitmez. Teşekkür ederim.🎶🙏❤

[@juanjimenez2707]

Increible!!!!

[@felipekerdolicalaca5763]

Greetings. I would like to know what painting is that on the cover of the video. I confess that I fell in love with this image.

[@StormWarningMom]

Just discovered your channel...I'm working through this playlist as I work during my day. Thank you, you've earned my sub. :)

[@xl000]

A grand master like him You wouldn't tell the differenc if he was just hitting random keys on the piano with jus a slight sense of harmonics impromptu means improvised

[@von_winkelmann5648]

Thanks you for this 🙂

[@steveegallo3384]

Tamara Rumiantsev RUUUUULES! BRAVA from Acapulco!

[@steveegallo3384]

@steveegallo3384 -- I was wrong....They ALL Ruuuuule.....Still BRAVI TUTTI......from Acapulco!

[@IvanGreindl]

Thanks for this marvelous sharing...🙂

[@shanubag6785]

Can't believe it's finally here 👁️👄👁️

[@Tijaxtolan]

Same, so many recordings of Beethoven’s but Schubert’s get really overlooked

[@Beatsbasteln]

Wow das sind echt ne Menge Sonaten

[@remidemetz5964]

I love the video Just one thing: The sonata in e flat major is missing

[@SamuraiKidMusic]

very nice very nice

[@MenelionFR]

That was massive! Thank you so much!

[@militaryandemergencyservic3286]

Here is my home-made pastiche of 17 of Schubert's greatest final piano works - kzbin.info/aero/PLYUhuuvIrJm0Z7vc1Olxvs1cOLMfuSo4I

[@darabanottotibor8463]

Gyönyörű!

[@wrdna58]

Many lesser-known gems here, like the Ungarische Melodie, D. 817, which seems to come from the world of the moments musicaux

[@manuelp8671]

Merveilleux...

[@kevanspencer444]

I seek etwrnal rest in the ipening of the bb sonata. That pedal point is heavenly

[@tomasziwanowski5539]

I complete ❤piano sonatas👍👍

[@scratsch4564]

Muito Bom!

[@guyfawkes999]

11:43:12 No. 4 in F Minor. Allegro vivace

[@hjeffrey668]

很棒喔👍👍

[@zvezdinki7998]

Just all ❤

[@poimandres]

What is this painting? It is beautiful.-

[@marcjohnson8423]

How long do I have to wait till I find out if this will be interrupted by an ad?

[@patrascualexandru8990]

This music is indiscret

[@bonisubev4281]

❤️

[@Rene-uz3eb]

just realized that composers have been locked into this system of 12 half tones and keyboards to have range and play chords, resulting in these approximations to the true intervals. Just had the idea that maybe most of dissonant chord theory might be actually just approximations to momentary transpositions to other keys. Bears exploring. Indeed, checked this on arabesque Debussy, the dissonance is when he overlaps two different keys implicitly

[@Bring_the_book]

Definitely not. That idea is why 20th and 21st century music went wrong.

[@Rene-uz3eb]

@@Bring_the_book I've done some more research since. Dissonant chords aren't dissonant they are two (rarely 3) keys played at the same time. Given that every interesting piece of music involves at least implicit temporary modulations to different keys, I wonder how it would sound if instead of on a 12 tone it would be played in just intonations. I suspect better when moving scales and chords, however I'm not sure about when two keys are played at the same time. Probably still better: the obvious way to derive a scale would be taking the first, third and fifth of each pure chord and choose the remaining scale tones from either scale depending on which one the melody emphasizes. Although usually one key is dominant, otherwise it does sound too dissonant, so either the third or fifth is omitted from the other. Maybe those newly derived scales sound interesting. It could also be they sound off and that you'd have to choose one just scale (of two) only, for the melody.

[@Bring_the_book]

@@Rene-uz3eb Interesting. I wasn't familiar with that. Is that where the emphasis on the pentatonic scale in many late Romantic composers arise?

[@Rene-uz3eb]

@@Bring_the_book I think so

[@gammafoxlore2981]

The issue with that train of thought... is that before the 20th century, composers were not conceptualizing music in a chord by chord fashion. Rather, chords were a result of counterpoint. Another issue lays withing the fact that it wasn't until pretty late into the 19th century that equal temperament became the standard for keyboards. Modern musical analysis, while interesting... is wholly inadequate for understanding pre-20th century music.

[@danilomarquesdasilvasilva4445]

Show!

[@RuinRoxanneWolf]

Good