What's happening with sadhguru right now? And what we can learn from it

[@scienceisdope]

Support me at: Buymeacoffee: buymeacoffee.com/scienceisdope Patreon: www.patreon.com/scienceisdope_ YT Membership: kzbin.info/door/g--ENXdDpXh5LyLigolg2gjoin UPI: scienceisdope@icici (QR Code available on www.scienceisdope.com/support )

[@harshgarg1448]

just a addendum from a believer in the enlightenment As an ultimate goal of human existence The thing with enlightenment as you have rightly pointed out is that no one knows exactly what it is even Buddha or shankracharya refused to elaborate because acc to them it can only be experienced and it is highly subjective. Having said that unfalsifiability is also the realm of science , most theory that tries to prove a physical phenomena postulates theorm that is then proven by various experiments i.e, unfalsifiability is just that, one is free to choose between believing or not believing it. For example there is a theorm that there are no odd perfect numbers but it is unfalisfiable , most people will argue that theorm is correct since we have not find any such number yet, but that doesn't mean one has to believe in a particular version since the answer is in the limbo( dog with two tails is a stupid example, and mischatacterize what unfalsifiability means). This is doubly difficult in case of enlightenment and spiritual because of it being a highly subjective experience, and given people often confuse some coincidence or a simple brain activity as spiritual experience. The thing with spirituality is that it is a highly subjective and personal experience, (and I am frankly not interested in converting you to my way) hence you can't do scientific inquiry into it. All I can say that it works for me. And in that point I will say your self-sabotage is insensitive statement comes from a lack of empathy and ignorance believing yours is the only right way to live the life. The best advice one can give to a person looking for spiritual person is be highly suspicious of everything (most importantly what you experience, as you yourself are the easiest person to be fooled). Coming onto jaggi vasudeva aka sadguru , I personally see him as a man with some interesting ideas(some far-fetched ) and gift for speech , who uses his clout to run his spiritual business enpire . I don't see anything wrong with it as long as it doesn't hurt its participants and society in general. This particular case especially will only bolster his image because in no way we can prove he is on the wrong, and if you have been reading news paper you would know the political enmity between sadguru and current political establishment in TN( that have been the in the background for some years). Ignoring politics from this equation gives an incomplete picture of the whole scenario, as to why TN police acted swiftly and SC needed to intervene in this case just days after the order of Madras HC

[@LordSousukeaizen]

Sadhguru is a wise man who helped save my life many times with his advice and herbs. Godbless you Sadhguru 🙏❤.....

[@praveendsouze]

@@LordSousukeaizen "SC stays Madras HC order for probe into Isha Foundation, transfers case to itself"

[@ckashish5561]

Huge fan of your work man! By the way Acharya Prashant talks a lot about Enlightenment/Mukti/Moksh, so what's your take in it?

[@pr42806]

Brother please a change your voice and pronounce a little bit, to make us understand what you are saying exactly. Sometimes I’m not able to understand your words. I am regular viewer. Thanks

[@teja7976]

Wait, the guy who never shaves his beard has made women shave their head?

[@Curious_Citizen0]

🤣that's the comment which should be pinned!!!!

[@bhashkarverma2738]

ohh 😂 😂bro nailed it 😂 😂

[@reenapalav8000]

😂 good one

[@rvind000]

The other option is indeed to let it grow fully, but then they will have to spend their energies in managing hair. If they simply don't care, they will look like Akka mahadevi or Adiyogi himself. Which might bring unnecessesary attention from society.

[@shivangssinha1915]

🤣🤣🤣🥲

[@oogaboogacute]

I love how Pranav has become more soft-spoken and mature when discussing religion. Instead of putting himself above those who believe without questioning, he respectfully engages with them. He politely counters their views without being a hater, showing kindness towards people who are often just innocent in their beliefs. Great job, Pranav, and yes Science is Dope!

[@MaheeshaAdelina]

Seems like he has taken inspirations from how GMOSkeptic approaches these topics, love to see this I think more youtubers, and people, should take this approach

[@RamMohammadJosephKaur]

He is just anti sanatan dharma

[@daanush468]

Yeah, almost unsubscribed because of how arrogant he used to sound. Glad he's maturing.

[@TamalRayMahapatra]

​@@RamMohammadJosephKaur Okay Modiji, if you say so...

[@oogaboogacute]

@@RamMohammadJosephKaur not really he maybe supporting left wing ideology like in his last videos but no he's pretty neutral which is really hard to see nowadays also all his religion videos are factual and no hate in it.

[@ksheer]

back with Jaggi bashing! wheres my popcorn?

[@darknx]

i ate it

[@ibrav7979]

​@@darknx dw we have more 🍿🍿🍿

[@Shiva-05]

Someone is going to take this comment too far _😅_

[@shashankkumargupta8477]

😂

[@abhinabdas1092]

Atheist scoundrels having guilty pleasure in their own ignorance

[@nandishnan5680]

The guy who claims to have the knowledge to cure all chronic ailments runs to the best of the best modern medical faculties to get himself cured. This alone is enough proof to learn what to believe in and what not to. What those daughters are doing might be their choice, the question they should ask themselves is what mukthi, moksha, or enlightenment they would achieve ignoring their aged parents. One needs to take care of their aged parents, enlightenment can be attained later also, if at all it exists, parents won't be there later.

[@Fantomstranger]

True

[@smarathe301]

2 thumbs up

[@Namish-yv9mz]

Correct. Although it is their personal matter, but since it is about religion, I must say that they are actually ignoring their dharma or dharm or duty towards their parents What kind of moksh is this

[@ayushshukla9904]

A grown adult is not someone's slave even if they are parents. You can't force them to live with you mate it's called kidnapping LOL. Jai Gurudev.

[@Yogeshlu4]

​@@Namish-yv9mzwhat about ram who left Sita? Or budha who left his wife and father?????? What about them Even Krishna who left Radha ??? What about thr responsibility??

[@loneranterism]

Please stop referring to that charlatan as "Sadhguru"!! ...just call him by his normal name..Jaggi Vasudev

[@yogisguide321]

It’s not even jaggi it’s jagdish

[@vimaladevishanmugam5943]

I prefer calling him 'liar' Both are supremely accurate.

[@Namish-yv9mz]

He's not a guru at all tbh

[@AbdullahPunctureWale-BePgCxx]

He should be called Taggi... not Jaggi.

[@AbdullahPunctureWale-BePgCxx]

​@@yogisguide321😮

[@Truth_Jc007]

Sadhguru ❌️ Jaggi Vasudev ✅️

[@lahari-1509]

I don't understand why he lets him call Sadhguru no great guru since called himself guru

[@suppiahbeerangan9550]

​@@lahari-1509 Only fake Guru's will ask his followers to call him Guruji, Sathguru etc. In fact this guy a Sad Guru.

[@shivangssinha1915]

@@suppiahbeerangan9550 making lives of other people sad as well.

[@stevewhite6241]

Jaggi

[@anchitbose4151]

Not a sadhguru fan but deciding to become a monk or not a monk is an entirely personal choice. It's like saying pranav is brainwashing people to be athiest and anti hinduism.

[@curiosity_fan]

Bro, the problem is not that a person wants to choose a monk life or not. The problem is Sadhguru's, a self proclaimed godman, Isha Foundation is linked to this whole saga which is as always something to be very suspicious. If you're not aware of Sadhguru's shady businesses under name of goodwill ashrams and all then check out some of some old videos in this channel, you would know.

[@anchitbose4151]

@@curiosity_fan first of all you can't say xyz is evil bcos I don't like them. Yes sadhguru says plenty of bs things like most religious people do but that doesn't mean we will rob people of the freedom to religion.

[@curiosity_fan]

@@anchitbose4151 Read my original comments again bro. I said that a person wanting or not wanting to choose a monk life is not a problem. The fact that Sadhguru is involved in the whole scenario makes it highly suspicious. Don't underestimate someone's ability to brainwash when he already has disillusioned many, many vulnerable public and continues to do so.

[@Yogeshlu4]

​@@curiosity_fanbro which case ? You heard what the chief justice of India said today ???

[@Yogeshlu4]

​@@curiosity_fana shity asss people and chanel like this won't comment on mass conversation by Christian missionaries

[@sandytatham3592]

Lots of parents in the West also lose their children to cult-like groups, eg. Scientology.

[@max-cs9ko]

Those cults are nowhere near to followers of Indian Godmen

[@Peacewithin97]

Science works on evidence not on faith thats the difference Thats why countries where science is taken more seriously then religion are ruling the world right now

[@Fantomstranger]

Less prevalent than India though

[@athulkrishna9114]

@@Peacewithin97 bro i don't think scientology has anything with science (edit- sorry you probably are not talking about scientology,but scientology is a cult)

[@Someone-mf1tz]

the biggest is xtianity it endures for over 2000+ yrs an apocalyptic cult that failed yet many still worshipping an immaginary jew who isnt even attested from his own community

[@shivangssinha1915]

I also ran behind enlightenment then I became an Atheist😂.

[@KindlePrime]

I think Most of us has same story 🎉😅

[@abhinabdas1092]

😂 coz u all failed to get it

[@RamanSingh-zo5hf]

​@@abhinabdas1092you talking like you achieved it

[@shruti._111_sings]

So did I 😂

[@ryepepper]

​@@abhinabdas1092 what did you get? 🔔?😂

[@abhisheknaik909]

I have his small potrait of him at home, most of them think I follow him for his spiritual talks but I am impressed that how he fooled half of the world. It's like modern day Pablo Escobar 😂😂😂

[@MischiefL0ki]

Bro wtf, at first when i read i thought that you must have it because of parents or family member💀

[@BruteZ7957]

this time you are off the mark, you have some great inherent biases in the arguments Pranav. 4:49 You start with a base assumtption that doing what they did is self sabotage. I disagree, at worst you can call it an unconventional choice that you don't understand. what authority do you have to pass moral judgment on their chosen way to live? for the rest of the video you claim that they're there to attain enlightenment and enlightenment doesn't provably exist and thus they're in a scam. a. how can you speak to their motivations of being there? b. Enlightenment doesn't need to be scientifically provable for it to be valid or for it to be not a scam. Let's say it's a mental model that allows people to be in peace. You can't prove efficacies or even existence of such concepts. Peace, love, grief, resilience should all also be then scams because one can't measure them scientifically in a person. Hope you don't fall prey to the very phenomena that you some times criticise some people for; leaving critical thinking aside just because you've an echo chamber which agrees with you.

[@Kr1sh_108]

He is speaking about (and for) the two Women without knowing a thing about them. He also makes a lot of subjective, seemingly biased statements that aren’t objectively valid, or cannot be objectively proven. I agree with the points you’re making.

[@jugaljoshi1061]

Well said, agree

[@shivabhinavvenkatasubraman3209]

Couldn't agree more.

[@prashanthn9887]

So true, this guy Pranav just coz he has read a bit or knows certain english words and his undeniable hatred towards Sadguru and trying his best at every chance to put him down, he has no valid arguments, no facts and no rights to judge anyone on any levels, he seems like a 10 year old who has got pissed with an uncle next door and going around giving false claims. I am no Sadguru fan but this guy's audacity to talk this bullshit with this kind of delutional confidence makes me think i am not that dumb when compared to people like Pranav

[@7Riishhii]

When I was in high school I had just watched the film LUCY and thought enlightenment means a stage where people can harness 100% energy of their brain. They can teleport, they can see futures, they can time travel and can do all supernatural things😂😂. Sorry Young Me! 🤧

[@abc-pw5ff]

That is actually enlightenment according to buddism i think. Cause budda became one with the universe. I don't believe it so my knowledge might be lacking

[@beyondjaggery7480]

NO ENLIGHTENMWNT IS SOME FORM OF NON EGO

[@sarihaddu]

@@abc-pw5ff There is no such thing as becoming one with universe. What does it even mean? Not having any kind of EGo is enlightenment according to some.

[@sindhura1341]

In non ego No Mind State all powers will arise. You are universe 🌬️

[@Dattatreya-pm4lq]

@@7Riishhii Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds ...

[@AMITKUMAR-jx8vk]

Where was baba ji ka enlightenment when he lied down in Apollo hospital few months back.

[@Kr1sh_108]

You are drifting into psychological patterns. Exactly like sadhguru followers and religious people do. That’s hypocritical and kinda ironic. Science is objective and not subjective. 1. when did he claim enlightenment. 2. why would it safe him from a deadly disease, he’s a normal mortal human being? Or did he claim enlightened people are immortal or can’t get sick? That’d be funny.

[@scienceDon]

​@@Kr1sh_108he claims healing power. You get to see his claims.

[@AMITKUMAR-jx8vk]

@@Kr1sh_108 he claims that he cured his own fracture within hours of meditation.

[@AMITKUMAR-jx8vk]

@@Kr1sh_108 moreover I don't think he ever embraced modern medical science.

[@sonalisingh2049]

Even his stint in hospital was promoted/marketed

[@arnavthescientist1149]

I try to show these videos to my mother and elder sister but they just avoid watching as they are big fans of Sadhguru and don't want to be challenged.

[@Fantomstranger]

I can relate

[@whykoks]

Don't try to convince your family members about their beliefs, it's counterproductive. It's not worth your efforts, let them live with their beliefs. Relationships are more important.

[@jeevansagar-dh3bi]

Don't worry, just wait for sometime, even you will start realising what Sadhguru is saying. Not just elder people, millions of young people all over the world have realised in a short span of time, it's so fortunate that young people in this generation are turning towards spirituality and realising the truth. Truth is undeniable, cannot change by a logical argument, just because humans cannot prove something scientifically it doesn't mean it does not exist in the universe. Humans are very recent happening, earth is billions of years old and the creation in any way doesn't fit into any logical statement or scientific proof that could be made by us. Even legendary achievers like Steve jobs, Virat Kohli, Ambani etc etc. have realised that there is something beyond in our life other than our mere intellect. One thing is for sure , Yoga is the solution for all the problems that exist right now in this world. Ps: I am a 23 years old and I am not an isha volunteer.

[@arnavthescientist1149]

@@whykoks yes I know. I love them to bits regardless of their beliefs.

[@EvilEye-rw6cx]

@@whykoks What if their beliefs are harmful to them or to others? What if their beliefs cause them to do toxic things?

[@maildrpritishukla]

What's the harm ? Daughters being away ? That happens all the time . Daughters go abroad , they are not allowed by in-laws ... . I dont get the point of parents . There is no such legal responsibility on children

[@budding4708]

There is no legal responsibility but is there not a moral responsibility

[@chitrapillai130]

When she is married off and send her parents to old age it's fine...when she wants her way in life then it's a crime...toxic parents also🙄

[@srijitatripathi92]

yup, that's true but they do send some money to their parents back home in India....or at least most of them do I believe, intsted of completely abandoning them to live on their own and visit them more often than not.

[@sayantrivedi]

He said it clearly that this is not something illegal, adults can have their own choices even if brainwashed. Then actually he focused mostly on how enlightenment itself is fake. It is like I know you are stupid but I respect your right to be stupid and boast of it publicly.

[@AnnieRegret]

Depends on the childood right?​@budding4708

[@VipulNavadiya]

Happy to see so many atheists coming forward and rising voice. Always with you.

[@abhinabdas1092]

Go to France weirdos

[@sb-bw4lp]

Sorry after 40 year there will ve no atheist you know reason because there will be no pagan sorry for bad English 😂

[@rvind000]

Raising voice againt Bramhachariya?

[@amitsingh46483]

Dude I was on the way of being atheist and then Encountered " Titu Singh reincarnation documentary" . There are many more such documenatries of reincarnation. I am finding it very hard to deny the facts shown in the video by any logical or scientific reasoning. I have started to believe that may there are things which science is yet to discover. Maybe there is a "Aatma". See if you can clear my doubts after watching those documentaries or give me any logical reasoning.

[@RimuruTempest007]

To be honest, agnostism makes much more sense than atheism.....

[@Arun-nt4kv]

They are in isha bcos they are happy and peaceful. It is the case with all who are in isha. They are not waiting for enlightenment. They never said that they wanted enlightenment

[@subrat9734]

One man crippled the entire missionary ecosystem in the state

[@naughtyboy1500]

seriously , the so called missionaris in india is almost to zero and we have cow protectors and cow right winger 99% in india , btw can you tell me why this ONE man and like his devotees like to be in only in CHRSITIAN WESTERN COUNTRIES rather try to spend their 'enlightenment' to AFRICA, ISLAMIC COUNTIRES ??

[@manojoy6913]

And gave illusionary gobarsystem 😅

[@maheshrathod204]

Yeah bro 😂😂😂 bullas and Mera yashu yashu entire ecosystem is shivering 🥶🥶🥶😂😂😂 from 1 man

[@maheshrathod204]

Yeah bro 😂😂😂 bullas and Mera yashu yashu entire ecosystem is shivering 🥶🥶🥶😂😂😂 from 1 man

[@samirloke6225]

@@manojoy6913 Far better than your masters' & fathers' abrahamic system. dont worry keep showing your bravery against hindus, it all goes fuss infront of Islam.

[@Kaala112]

At this point, Pranav is making a living out of Sadhguru.😂

[@arunenquiry]

In Kerala, we call this ഇല നക്കിപ്പട്ടിയുടെ കിറി നക്കിപ്പട്ടി (ila nakki pattiyude kiri nakki patti). Dog who licks the cheeks of the dog who licks at leftovers.

[@manojoy6913]

What about making money from your idiocracy by sad gullu.

[@Ganesh-ey8zp]

His life depends on Sadhguru 😂🙏

[@echooscar5241]

Pranav I'm no fan of the Jaggi nor am I religious. But people have the right to choose whatever life they want whether it is to join the clergy or the infantry or do extreme sports... At the best what the parents can do is sue the daughters for an allowance anything else is stealing their agency.

[@digitalbath6057]

Person who is not loyal to culture or nation is not to be trusted. I hate religious folks too but sadhguru hasn't said anything hateful. Ive heard him we always had culture of disagreement and dialogue. This concentrated hate I feel is towards Hindus as people. I don't think people should complain if something happens to them

[@SudarshanV-m]

Everyone has their choice to be what they want to be but brainwashing them to commit harm on other people or making them to donate all their property to charity owned by them is the problem. Where this enlightenment all becomes bull shit

[@echooscar5241]

@@digitalbath6057 hate begets hate. By collectively hating a group you are justifying the hatred Saghis, Zionists and other extremists express towards whoever.

[@echooscar5241]

@@SudarshanV-m does that mean all people are not equal and some votes should have more weigh than others?

[@leelavasu5985]

Whether Sadhguru s teachings are transforming his devotees/ followers into being kind, loving, compassionate people can be seen how they treat their parents and family. If detachment happens towards parents and family/families then definitely something is wrong in Sadhguru s teachings. As a devotee s transformation towards isolation to achieve self peace in selfish gains. Our culture teaches, MATTA, PITHA, GURU, DEIVAM. So it points to brainwashing for selfish gains.....

[@jayprakashnair2499]

As an agnostic, I was wondering why spirituality has to pass a Scientific method test? Clearly, Spirituality and Science do not belong to the same stream of thought. They are also not converse to each other - Since they pursue 2, very wildly, unrelated outcomes, they are not even comparable with each other. Given that this is the case, Pranav, why would you apply Falsifiable/Unfalsifiable methods/questions to spiritual beliefs? I don't see spirituality demanding that a scientific finding should follow some rules of divinity or spiritualism. What do you think?

[@punyonobing5371]

Because religious/spiritual people prove their beliefs by providing evidence such as their beliefs goes hand in hand with science .Such as they will claim - All things which are found in Science were already written there in their religious/ spiritual books.

[@noir2967]

​@@punyonobing5371exactly! Believing in it is one thing; claiming it is supported by evidence is another

[@verxux5432]

Indeed, Spirituality is more metaphysical as it deals with more abstract concepts but when the preachers make baseless claims and use pseudoscience as a scapegoat to counter criticism, it is only fair to refute their claims using scientific method

[@PABITRABADHUK]

Hitchen's razor: If something is asserted without proof, it can be refuted without proof.

[@AnirimaGhosh]

I don’t think any human being who charges 1.5 L to 3 L for a bike ride with him is an enlightened one spiritually. The only enlightened thing he has is business sense 😂😂😂. Ignoring your aging parents and searching for a mirage is not gonna bring any enlightenment of what so ever. 😊

[@consciouschapters8396]

Where do you cook up these stories from ?

[@trashpanda2842]

She didn't cook this up. You can do your own research. He even sells his feet picture for 3k. Okay, touching the feet of your guru is important for many. But selling it at such a high price?? Not good! If spirituality was so important to him then he would at least sell it for a reasonable price. He's just a capitalist who knows how to fool gullible people and earn money. ​@@consciouschapters8396

[@TonySoprano-oo8wd]

​@@consciouschapters8396 says the guy who believes in flying monkey 😂

[@RaviShankar-ki2kh]

People getting addicted to Love, Social Media, Porn is normal. Some people may see suffering in the above things. More people see suffering in being Austere. When we talk free will, both choices should be given equal respect.

[@learnenglishwithvicky2451]

Not a follower of Sadhguru but enlightenment is a real thing. However, enlightenment cannot be proved or demonstrated. It is a subjective realization of your own real nature. It is that background awaress which is prior to all thought and bodily sensations. Your body keeps changing throughout your life. Your thoughts also keep changing. But there is something that never changes. That's who you really are. Experiencially knowing that is enlightenment. Nothing changes. You don't become super intelligent. You don't gain any superpowers or anything or that sort. 😂 However, you don't have to leave your life and denounce all worldy pleasures and become a monk or something. Although, I suppose that serves as a great facilitator. But, like I said, it's not compulsory. I am a great fan of your work Pranav! I really appreciate that you're bringing scientific temperament to the country. However, not everything these so-called gurus say is bullshit. I suggest you take on a bigger perspective on life to understand what enlightenment is. Much love and respect ❤

[@shivabhinavvenkatasubraman3209]

❤

[@AKENOXTRM]

That sounds a lot like self realisation or may be self actualisation.

[@noelrodrigues8179]

Well I feel enlightenment means just being self aware which is something that most adults r, u can literally close your eyes and focus on the noises around u, I don't see anything enlightened about it. It's just u focusing on your own consciousness making u feel special only for being a conscious being in the universe, so I don't understand how it's enlightenment but I do understand y would u feel special for simply existing For me getting a physics degree Or a phd is more enlightenment bcz atleast u r much closer to the reality of the universe than an average layman who just feels special for simply existing and calling that enlightenment.

[@STVolgs825]

Pls define enlightenment.

[@beyondjaggery7480]

atheist and theist both are believers prove me wrong

[@dipikasharma]

​@@casualgambit674 That's okay. I never had high expectations from a follower of this channel. Leaching off of the scientific method... Know nothing about it.

[@benjamindsouza6736]

I grew up being very skeptical & critical about almost everything Indian, particularly the spiritual & medical stuff. But having been wracked with a host of life threatening ailments ranging from cancer to suicidal depression, that were the result of decades of an unhealthy lifestyle that included serious addictions to dangerous chemicals, I was out of utter desperation compelled to turn to therapies/healing modalities such as yoga/pranayama/meditation & ayurveda as there was nothing modern medical science could do for an extreme case like mine. Today, at sixty one, I have been free of all the ailments for well over two decades & not only enjoy robust physical health but am naturally in an elevated state of mind that does not require any stimulants/intoxicants whatsoever.....& above all I have discovered right within myself the eternal peace & joy that nothing in the external world could give me! I feel very sad for all those who out of sheer ignorance keep criticizing our rich Indian heritage even as they keep wallowing in the material realm in the futile & exhausting search for lasting peace & happiness in material pursuits & temporal thrills!!

[@vigneshmv47]

I hope maximum number of people read this. RELIGION is just a BELIEF system. ATHEISM means disbelief in GOD. Atheists BELIEVE that there is no God, because to KNOW that there is no God, they need to have proofs. So ATHEISM is also another RELIGION (Belief System). People just switch between the belief systems saying one is wrong and the other is right. According to me ENLIGHTENMENT is to stop listening to what people say about things that we don't know for sure and start seeking the answers for our questions on our own.

[@raktimamchiforthe4thtime445]

They don't KNOW god doesn't exist, they are merely not satisfied by the reasoning, argument, proofs provided by theist. I don't see why they need proof of god's non existance because it impossible it prove a negative. It's not hard to understand don't respond if you don't have anything coherent to say. And your definition of enlightenment is not accurate in current sphere of the world, that's not how the word is used in context to Sadhguru situation

[@coreyanderson3288]

I agree with @raki's comment. Also, given that religion is defined as "the belief in and worship of a superhuman power or powers, especially a God or gods", atheism is definitely not a religion. Not sure why you think it is.

[@44shree26]

Disbelief is not the same as belief. Gotya was murdered in a house. Ramu and Shamu were present in the house at that time. Gotya's sister BELIEVES Ramu killed Gotya. The Police don't BELIEVE that Ramu Killed Gotya. So do the police BELIEVE Ramu is innocent? Not believing is not same as believing the opposite. I don't know how to simplify further. Atheist just can't BELIEVE in things without proof OR sufficient evidence.

[@rvind000]

@@coreyanderson3288 One belives, other disbelives. One can't make knowleadge out of existantial reality, one can only experince it in more profound way by enhancing their perception.

[@stevewhite6241]

Religion isn't just a belief for its followers.

[@vgg6273]

I dont care about enlightenment..I know many phyciaststrists suggest to practice yoga to help recover anxiety and depressions..yoga is good and its beneficial in many ways..rather than saying its enlightenment tool better to promote it as a healthy life style habit

[@pavithrachandra7225]

Even after meditating for years he couldn't stop bleeding in his brain but still promises to cure all kind off chronic illness in his ashram!

[@sanjaya870]

I believe in proper reasoning and science but I have some issues with this video. 1) While acknowledging the girls are adults and have their own free choices to make, you do not hold back in associating their stance to self-sabotage and the influence of Jaggu's teaching about enlightenment. People have different family dynamics, different personalities, different motivations and ideas on how to lead their lives: some are rebels, some just wish to be part of a tribe they find themselves comfortable with. Heck they might not even agree with everything Jaggu tells them. Yet they might be happy being part of that tribe. 2) The dog example is a weird one. Science also tells us about mutation, that could probably cause a dog to have two tails.

[@manjukasoysa3901]

He's mixing and Science and logic without really understanding the implications

[@Ronit109]

Buddy.. do inner engineering, practice it as it’s guided and then come talking abt sadhguru. (just give it an unbiased experiment! what’s in that?) science u know?

[@deepakpeethani3695]

The funny part is that this kind of malice police action is exclusive to Hindu organizations; heinous crimes from other religious organizations will vanish in thin air or be backed by the government. The police raid seems to be akin to Udainidi Stalin's 'ERADICATING SANATANA DHARMA' statement in action rather than a crime-fighting action.

[@banklootful]

The fellow is a criminal. He has built the whole place in a green zone

[@rvind000]

@@banklootful Prove it in court then. Even Madras High court doesn't mind questioning him.

[@TonySoprano-oo8wd]

Yes saaar chindu victim saaar

[@StubbySquid-1]

lol.. I’m a doctor. Followed inner engineering course. Yes, I’m brain washes to spend 20 min a day doing mediation 😂 as far as I’m concerned, NO ONE during my time there said science is wrong.

[@Ronit109]

He ain’t a scientist. he’s a dhruv rathee puppy

[@mentalhealth8777]

Comment section show how senseless people can be,taste it and talk but please 🙊 until you taste it

[@DrSANJEEV]

We need to ponder a bit deeper as to why so many of us want to escape social life and live in a delusion of enlightenment or monkhood... Have we failed as a system that daughters feel the need to escape from their duty of taking care of their ailing parents...

[@omegatronousgalacticus7750]

The Professor and his wife should will all their property and everything they own to charity. I would like to see the outcome of this move after the news breaks to the daughters. Every religion promises a perpetual truth which is actually always a lie, and which is then perpetually denied to the followers

[@brevitygreaves2321]

They could also legally disown their daughters. That would pre-empt any inheritance claims from that direction. Otherwise the will could be legally challenged.

[@keeya_ks]

Funny how those who criticise sadhguru will never question Christian nuns living a life of celibacy and marrying Jesus or monks but love to mock anything Hindu for views, also if you mock spirituality and enlightenment but can never answer if they can prove there isnt a creator of this universe or anything outside the proof of science even scientists are more honest than this narcissistic atheist who believe it’s their duty to mock anyone with a belief preferably Hindu belief

[@shahidkap9544]

Hehee true

[@stevewhite6241]

You will also find those comments in Christian related videos. Just not here. You can't walk into an Apple store and see people bring in Samsung for repair.

[@shahidkap9544]

@stevewhite6241 send me Christian related vid of him

[@stevewhite6241]

@@shahidkap9544 no surprise why you missed my point.

[@amaljose1704]

Simple logic, population in India Christians- 2.3% Muslims - 14% HINDUS- 80%. Obviously 80% of the time Hindus will be in discussion.

[@asa7813]

So every doctor's children should be doctors n monk's children should be monks like varna system .. Wow what an insight. Nobody should have their personal choice.

[@niyathasr9]

I hold an unbiased stand here, but I've seen parents who have married off their daughters / sons ,who have been in the US or Ireland, making 6 figure salary who don't come home for years, leaving their old parents / surviving parent alone here. How is this different

[@sudiptochowdhury9059]

@scienceisdope so enlightenment means self realisation, a realisation that one is not the body mind .

[@sudiptochowdhury9059]

Aren't we already conditioned by the society? Aren't we already believing so many things which are not true? Pls learn about Advaita vedanta, non duality, pls.

[@raunaqueiquebal7088]

Why do most people believe you can not enlightenment unless you are unmarried.

[@Morjaane_1]

It's her choice.

[@KindlePrime]

​@@Morjaane_1 but she is brainwashed so how you know her choice is right for her life

[@KindlePrime]

​@@Morjaane_1 brainwashing because they give wrong information about her own existence. Information that Jaggi himself don't know wrong or right

[@rvind000]

@@raunaqueiquebal7088 it's not about marriage, it's about commitment.

[@namrathakn9772]

Pranav are those AI images that you're using in between cuts? And if they are can i ask you the reason you're using them?

[@KC_Tripathy]

1st thing is, those two daughters are highly qualified, so its very unlikely that they will be brainwashed... Second thing is, one of them is married and later lost her husband and now a widow..so she can easily compare the two aspects of life and choose which is better for her, ascetic or worldly life.. 3rdly, those arguing for the pity of their parents, were acting like a mute spectator and great advocate for the self realisation of Hadiya, a hindu women married to a Muslim men against her parents will in Kerala...

[@ParthTyagi23]

There have been so many saints in India and other parts of the world. Even in the recent times. They have demonstrated saintly mystical powers. You can google where did Steve Jobs visit in India. Enlightenment is an actual phenomenon. You need to study more.

[@Namish-yv9mz]

even as an agnostic, I do believe there is such a thing as enlightenment. It is not supernatural or godly Buddha, Mahavir, Guru Nanak, Vivekanand and Jesus were not just casually hanging around I'm sure

[@benjamindsouza6736]

Pranav is speaking out of utter ignorance!!!

[@benjamindsouza6736]

Pranav is speaking out of utter ignorance!!!

[@arkmail9542]

With your video I for interested in Sadhguru

[@georgekyle165]

The daughters are adults and they choose their life as you said. Wtf is brainwashing? Sadhguru never urged anyone. If we go to ashram we can choose what we do there. We can attend stuff, eat for free and just leave. What they choose is a path. A lifestyle. That's it.

[@Kr1sh_108]

Precisely right!

[@manojoy6913]

You mean he pushed his daughter into narak 😂

[@AlokKumar-zy7ul]

Pranav is a very rational thinking guy and I also love his content about our human brain and thinking. Challenging spiritual beliefs is like playing with fire and he has guts that I respect to give people new perspective about life

[@anilvundavalli1383]

Did Buddha prove his enlightenment to you? Why are you conveniently taking sides? You need to first work on your awareness and consciousness,so that you will know how stupid your limited perception is. Just by bashing some one makes you feel superior,enlightenment is far far away from you Enlightenment is doper!!

[@gamexstreams1731]

I used to have a friend in the previous colony i lived and i spent 2 years discussing about spiritualism and other interesting insights about life and society which actually sharpened my intelelct and helped me stand out in college. But i didnt realise that being too spiritual actually made people find me more annoying, short-tempered and anxious all the time since all these spiritual 'obligations' were too much for me to handle. Even the guy who taught me all this was a semi-hermit - didnt eat non-veg, one meal, slept at 8:30, walked and talked like a robot. All was fine and all but DAMN he was such an A$$hole. He always argued and got defensive to every little thing and would basically mind-r**e you and make u feel guilty at the end of every conversation. A Master of Gaslighting. And he would say outrageous things like 'I owe nothing to my parents' or 'all the crimes in society need to persist cuz they teach "something" to people 😮 and he also manipulated me to leave my job with that "Money is root of all evil" BS. Basically turned Me from an energetic, optimistic, funny guy to a cynical, bitter a-hole who was 'Lost'. I always wanted to write stories for my novel and other ideas. Guess who drained all the motivation to do it ? ... You guessed right. My advice for anyone reading this is : If you come across someone who says stuff 'Paramatma, abandoning parents, leaving your job, desires' etc ? Run or tell them to F off. Cuz these people are mere brainwashed a-holes.

[@anuragnathyal5889]

Firstly why are you assuming that these women are living a life of suffering? 🤷🏻‍♂️ Happiness is so subjective and if you ever encounter sanyasies in Isha there isn't a moment of agitation and frustration in them . Well you can argue about it. But if you genuinely observe them they are much happier then an average person that's for sure. Secondly about enlightenment , is there evidence of that ? Yes there is a lot of evidence but evidence in terms of experience not in terms of material. Just like a person with eyes can never tell some blind person how the experience of seeing is no matter how much ever we may argue. But evidence here is experiences that we get by doing Sadhana or certain types of meditation. You can argue that it's placebo , you can argue that it's imagination, you can argue that it's power of suggestion and it's all imaginary. But we are very aware of all these things. Infact that's why no one is told what they will experience during meditation as they will start imagining that. But just because someone says he is experiencing something should we believe them ? No ! But when you yourself do sadhana and have these experiences then you will have no doubt about it. The difference between physical sciences and spritual sciences is that the evidence in physical sciences is mass in nature. But the evidence in spritual sciences is individual in nature. 🤷🏻‍♂️ It's like if I have eyes and someone doesn't. Seeing is true for me alone I can't share my experience with someone blind. But if he also gets eyes he can know for certain how seeing works. Spirituality is just like that till we don't become capable of experiencing non physical it's just a belief and can be untrue but when we experience something non physical it's as clear as day. The most concrete evidence spirituality has is individual in nature just like a person with sight can't share his experience with the blind. Experience is the only evidence.

[@CSATPrepchannel]

Can you tell us your understanding of the world 'enlightenment'?

[@this-abledtheextravertedhe5299]

I adore my Sadhguru 🥰🙏🥰

[@kabiramalhar2189]

Great insights, also sidenote but your lighting and production has improved so much Pranav!

[@AparnaPSown]

What is the problem if a woman choose to live without marriage...Indian parents never change

[@scienceisdope]

Hey I agree with you

[@andreamessiasgomes7118]

​@@scienceisdope Sir please make a video on Harry Sahota and also this KZbin channel called Hindu Lifestyle. He's a westindian guy who lives in Canada.

[@SnehPandyaPersonalChannel]

I wish to point out one thing. From 3:20 to 3:43 the message is not clear due to impetuous speaking, I fear it may spread wrong messages to people. Although this is just an example, I have observed this many times in your videos. Please take care of it. Thank you.

[@shreyanshmankar3052]

Never heard this man before ; but after this i would love to know his thoughts on acharya Prashant

[@kaypee9187]

Sir, we have a tradition of people leaving the parents to become a Sanyasi, this practice is called as renouncing the word. A sanyasi loses his caste, his material possessions as well as his worldly liabilities. When such a person dies he is not cremated but buried in an unmarked grave. Having renounced the world is irreversible and a akin to death. A person who forsakes his family in this manner causes immense grief to his parents. A person who influences another to take sanyas without performing the appropriate ceremony of celibacy can be equated to causing a form of death without the loss of life. The father of such a celibate person is struck with grief and great emotional pain. Though, there are no laws prohibiting such a practice, the act is close to abetting suicide and deserves to be punished.

[@hello2k225]

I have said this before. I’ll say it again. Sadhguru has occult powers, whether you believe it or not. I have a clear and constant inner experience (from Sadhguru’s Shambhavi initiation) of something beyond my body and mind that exists within me. As usual, people only care to listen to what they believe as possible. If they believe something as impossible or illogical, they don’t care even if one is speaking the truth.

[@sujitwarrier4857]

@@hello2k225 lol

[@RohitVerma1289]

Just illusion

[@v8706]

Bro i just wasted my 3500 k in shambhavi maha mudra course which is called inner engineering and its a scam people beware its a freaking scam that guy is just going to brain wash you and manipulate you into joining his cult so called isha foundation and after this they are going to fully manipulate you inti buying is things courses feeet pics 😅 lol . And about shambhavi maha mudra its an old practice in hath yoga which you can also learn on youtube and practice it sadh guru s cult just brainwashes people and market old yoga practices in their own they even created their own goddess lol .

[@TonySoprano-oo8wd]

Gaumutra logic 😂

[@VENOM-tx6gp]

I love how this whole process of attaining enlightenment requires you to void all desires and duties of life. While this whole idea of attaining enlightenment is a desire itself

[@benjamindsouza6736]

It does not require you to avoid all desires & duties, although you're free to go to a Himalayan cave for deeper experiences.

[@VENOM-tx6gp]

@@benjamindsouza6736 1:16 if it's not required, why did they do it?

[@Rahul-hn1iq]

Brother's channel is surviving because of Jaggi.😂😂

[@abhinabdas1092]

Sadhguru not Jaggi

[@nk-hv1jj]

​@@abhinabdas1092Ahem. He's no God. The only entity who deserves that kind of respect is the One above , not a GODDAMN mortal

[@rvind000]

@@nk-hv1jj Sadhguru means one who has grown from within. If you can get mukti on your own, then I guess you're fine anyway.

[@v8706]

@@nk-hv1jjtruee and this jaggi is saying that he is the avatar of shiva lol

[@nishajaihindajain9192]

If SPIRITUALITY is water , Religion is thr container. Without container hiw will you comsume water

[@gopalks6437]

Both are scams.

[@Banditxam4]

Man people are disliking his videos but he's right

[@bumdum8798]

There are 0 dislikes as of right now

[@astro8833]

​@bumdum8798 14 now

[@astro8833]

​@@bumdum8798 14 now

[@ducxi]

14 dislikes only wut u talkin bout

[@Namish-yv9mz]

How are you even able to see the number of dislikes ? it doesn't show on my device

[@kiranram1689]

My point is when Jaggi, the so called "SPIRITUAL GURU" can marry, get his daughter married and can live in LUXURY, how can he can ask his sishyas to tonsure their heads, cut off their bonds with parents etc? Without his teachings why should they? As a true well-wisher ( if he is really one) he should ask them to lead a normal life, as he himself is doing.

[@jamta69]

But the court can still do 2 thing 1)a psych evaluation and blood test,if they fail the test ,they can charge isha foundation or make then go counselling or something. 2) also even if 1st test fail they can still be sue for elderly negligence.

[@Yogeshlu4]

Supreme court ne kyo nai kiya bhai ??

[@SmallusDicckus]

Some people think free will doesn't exist, cough*atheists*cough 😅😅😅

[@Arch009]

@@SmallusDicckus I mean, existence of free will is a philosophical debate... but I am sure most atheists are the ones who would want the most freedom for the individual cause, brdr it's ur damn life! Do as you please! A religion would advocate for rules (some strict like islam some relaxed but still)...

[@jamta69]

​@@SmallusDicckusPsychlogicological manipulations and use of therapeutic agents can induce effects on brain,which is why real hypnosis exists (not the coin thing,if u want read about it)​ and also for ppl having psychological trauma,stress,mental issue, or preexisting hardcore religious belief have predisposition to join cult. This is why a cult is more dangerous than other religious bodies because the free will is non-existent. And the baddest ones are one formed upon ideas of larger religions like sadhguru and baba for hinduism,lot of western cult are based on christianity and islamist terrorists organization are an offshoot of cultist format.

[@jamta69]

​@@Yogeshlu4psychological evaluation

[@dharmayogaashram979]

I am enlightened and so are you. In varying degrees, we all experience innerlight (and darkness) and the feeling of lightness (and depression). En-light-(we are) ment to be but the darkness is also important. Choosing a single or married life is simply ones personal choice. Both are good and have no relevance on ones in light expriences. No fan of JV he is a huckster, but can not agree with all your opinions on religion but appreciate so much of your wisdom and debunking frauds.

[@KindlePrime]

Buddha's enlightenment is purely rational. He did not believe in any soul; his enlightenment was intellectual. He did not say anything about God or the soul - people created stories after his death. He was a rational man, not a supernatural being.

[@deadalpeca8099]

So Sadhguru claims to be enlightened, and claims that enlightenment cures you of all physical and mental ailments, but then when he has a medical emergency he runs to the best of the best doctors. Hmmmmm

[@binary3i]

God = Unicorns = Dragons

[@Fantomstranger]

= dimensions

[@harjasx]

​@@Fantomstranger=cosmos

[@unknown-c9x]

=dogmas

[@smarathe301]

= subtle way

[@rvind000]

It can be anything in your imagination, until you experience it.

[@TheCanyonhiker]

You can’t prove it. You cannot disprove it. So, leave it alone. It’s not your field of expertise. So this video falls into the category of useless chatter about nothing.

[@rvind000]

Most people do basic sadhana, that's good enough for living well. If one wants to do other kinds of things with their system, then Bramhachariya is the way.

[@sonalisingh2049]

Most of these cults do this. 'Brainwash' , 'Indoctrination' are the words I use. But when you question these followers, they become ultra-defensive, taking offence to these terms. I have umpteen examples in my personal life. The cult/guru/philosophy becomes all-important, family takes a backseat. Spouses, kids become low priority. Often followers become obsessive, their houses are like showcases for the cult memorabilia/merchandise. Look around. They make people spend money....loads of it. OBSERVE those who're linked to cults. When the time comes, representatives of these cults wash their hands off family disputes saying, "Its their (follower's) wish if they want to follow/part with their property/bank balance, we havent asked/influenced them." Or , "Its your family matter to sort." Personal experience #Brahmkumaris #Isha Old people are convenient to convert. They're anyways looking for 'meaningful' things to fill their time, and own peoperties/bank balances to 'donate' which are willed to these cults, not to the rightful heirs.

[@harjasx]

but dont you think without religions human unification could have been tough? We needed a common belief that in this case is god to unify the humamity?

[@vimaladevishanmugam5943]

The comman belief I agree for is *Truth, Honesty and integrity.* Those alone are enough. Pseudo science should not be our 'only mode of unification' We need better things, NOW. Also just look at all the religious divide happening these days, it's pretty obvious that religion doesn't help in global unity, rather we need better philosophies, NOW.

[@logeswaran1823]

It does more separation than unification

[@carnage2834]

Lol... Religion has done more separation than any other things ever could.

[@rvind000]

Existantially we are already one. All this yoga, tantra, yantra etc. that were woven with the Dharmic cultures around the world were essentially about pushing us one step closer to being with the truth.

[@GauravSingh-fw2xf]

06:25 You are talking in pseudoscience basis of assessment where everything is boiled down to material world , conducted trials to measure success rate . Enlightenment is never about material world. But I will indulge anyway , most people can't even sit with quite mind without meditation for 10 mins without thoughts invoking deep emotions even when person is alone. Enlightenment is always personal and continuous process not point in time thing. Conflating it with material special powers is even bizaare!!!! Not letting your thoughts of past have an influence on your current emotions is a super power

[@N0Xa880iUL]

Great video

[@subhendugiri5018]

If we are aware of how ineffective Judiciary is, scope of exploitation it has and how ambiguous the role of advocate is, we will take recent development lightly. Why he is doing this to daughter of others when/why he couldn't do same for own daughter, this can be gossiping not argument. Context should be what is the crime involved and evidence? For 'lesson to be learned', big Q is, who should or will take the lesson? 1.4k likers or (16k viewers-1.4k likers)? I find many comments where people expect Pranav to be soft-spoken, neutral, mature, balanced while speaking on religion... Now, for such comment owner and likers of such comment, what lesson can be enough? When a man can transform huge number of so-called educated cum well-dressed people to just puppet cum idiot, how can we forget/ignore skill of that man? Skill + financial back up by rich cum elite class. Brainwash? So? Any unidirectional talk can be considered as attempt of brainwashing. Shall we expect rational behavior or argument from religious people? Why? If he/she is rational, he/she won't be religious. Being religious is the result or effect, not cause. Attempt to feed the 'enlightenment' capsule to any unemployed and frustrated youth who has to take care of his/her family, you will get good reception! 10:32, even in 2024 if we accept nonexistent entity (god) without seeking for proof of existence, what lesson would be enough? Here comes the role of education which needs to be revisited.

[@subhadippal7889]

Please also talk about the Bangladeshi muslim too

[@tpb1006]

why, you dont want to listen to the truth of Hindus

[@TonySoprano-oo8wd]

They impregnated your mata?

[@anandchoure1343]

Legally it's okay, morally it's not okay, religious and culturally it's okay and rationally it's STUPID कानूनी तौर पर यह ठीक है, नैतिक रूप से यह ठीक नहीं है, धार्मिक और सांस्कृतिक रूप से यह ठीक है और तर्कसंगत रूप से यह मूर्खतापूर्ण है

[@2856Rohit]

What is sadguru’s fault in all this can anyone explain?

[@scienceisdope]

No direct fault. He's just exploiting a system and culture that takes advantage of people's unquestioned beliefs.

[@2856Rohit]

@@scienceisdope yes you are right but brainwashing should not be used here Brainwashing which effects other is a serious concern like you see in radical groups but if someone is thinking about himself it can be wrong or right it should not be considered brainwashing. That was my only concern pranav.

[@KindlePrime]

​@@2856Rohit offcourse they brainwash them by giving wrong information about their existence

[@jnanakshatriya668]

@@2856Rohit yeah with his logic, we can also conclude what he is doing on youtube is also kind of brainwashing. lol

[@2856Rohit]

@@jnanakshatriya668 Yes brainwashing starts from childhood when you believed everything what had been said to you. But adults are mature enough to judge what is wrong what is right their actions may look wrong to you thats your thought process like in this case these two daughters are almost 40 and if they find some peace in something let them be why put morality on them they are not taking care of parents.

[@MsRickkick]

Ignorance is the biggest drug in the world. Feed people with misinformation and keep them ignorant so they are in a state of delusion. For ignorant people anything they don't know feels like magic.

[@user-wj5lw1rn5p]

Everyone lives in ignorance. If we were all caring or the actual receiving end then we would have either been dead or silent due to fear or on battlefield. We simply don't care because it doesn't affect us as much as those who are always outcasted.

[@nishajaihindajain9192]

BINARY THINKING is not good . Making someone Numero ONE or making them zero is wrong . Let's not degrade Sadhguru so much .

[@PakistaniKitaabghar]

Hi brother Dr Zakir in Pakistan many people are waiting for him to make a video.

[@tusharbalpande8723]

u may consider ISIS n ISHA with same level of brain washing.then ..hope u understand the difference in objectives of both these org..

[@TonySoprano-oo8wd]

One are brave warrior and other drink gaumutra 😅😂

[@adityaiyer3250]

Any allegations have not been proved . Period

[@nishajaihindajain9192]

This happened with Gandhi . This happened with Nehru . This happened with Osho . This is happening with Sadhguru . It's hightime we should Stop defaming visionaries .

[@gopalks6437]

Don’t compare Osho and jaggi or sadhguru.

[@2967_]

Osho was a sex cult leader. There is documentation of that.

[@susanjohn5167]

Don't compare Gandhi with Jaggi

[@KindlePrime]

Bro write Gandhi, Nehru and Jaggi in same comment 🤡

[@rvind000]

@@KindlePrime Agreed anything is better than agreeing to partition & giving an worst kind of nightmare to millions of people. And then doing hunger protest to give money to Pakistan when they've taken over Kashmir.

[@oogaboogacute]

I mean, religions are not bad at all. It's just part of evolution-like, we all evolved, so our intuitions led us to start asking questions about our own existence. Random rulers started talking, and people believed them because they were already worshiping alphas (the strongest mentally, genetically, and physically), like their kings. The main problem with religions is that they are narrow in their thinking, encouraging people to work without asking intuitive questions. This can confuse us and even lead to depression-I know because I suffered from it. Religions made sense at the time because there were famines and diseases that needed solving. So yeah, it's not really about God, but more like a placebo effect. For example, someone survives a disease and credits God because they don’t want to sound crazy. Then they create stories about how God saved their life when they were about to die. What I’m trying to say is, religion isn’t bad, but in some areas, it’s doing more harm than good. I don’t think we should eliminate religion altogether because I know that’s not going to happen anytime soon. But we should eliminate things like misogyny and hatred, and make religion more personal. No matter how modern a religion is, it can’t keep up with society-like boomers trying to keep up with Gen Z, lol (I know, not a great example, but you get what I mean-I’m not a lecturer, anyway). Now, about me: I’m biased, yes, but not in the way you might think. I don’t support illegal immigration, but I do support UCC, and I’m a big fan of Polish parliament speaker Dominik Tarczynski. He puts his country’s people first, and we need that in our system. I also believe India isn’t ready for hardcore liberalism like LGBT rights and other woke stuff. But Indians need to be patriotic and support their people, like Pranav is doing. I know he’s not only targeting Indians, but he’s showing a positive side of India, and I’m really proud of him for that. Unlike Dhruv Rathee and Gaurav Thakur, who seem to do it for clout and money, Pranav is the best. Also, Pranav is getting more factual. He even made a separate channel just for science to separate factual content from religion-based biases. Yes, he’s biased because he supports minority groups, but that’s not wrong-most of us should support minorities. I think Pranav should be more popular in the West, as he’s like those yogis and babas but more of an intuitive scienced based counter version from India (and no, I’m not desperate for white people’s validation). This could even help reduce racism against us, which we still face-people ignoring our intellect just because of our looks. Look at Japan, Korea, and even China; they’ve countered most racism by developing their people’s mindsets, making them seem strong, technologically advanced, socially disciplined, and safe. Great job, Pranav! And science is dope. I never write comments this big, but you always make us proud. I don’t just support you, I’ll always stand by you.

[@nandakishore588]

u have an interesting perspective on religion . regarding "But we should eliminate things like misogyny and hatred, and make religion more personal. No matter how modern a religion is, it can’t keep up with society" - buddha already did this 2,500 years ago. he saw that even highly educated and sophisticated people are not free of hatred -that is why he has dedicated an entire section of the dhammapada to the 3 defilements of the mind ( hatred or aversion being one of them) and that is why, he recommended that compassion should be the foundation of buddhism. of course, any religion can only be as good as its followers.

[@oogaboogacute]

@@nandakishore588 True

[@rvind000]

Bramhachariya is not religious, it's about willingly not sticking to anything or running after petty pleasures. One simply does whats needed. Atleast internally everyone should be like that.

[@rahuljig1731]

Funny thing is people who have a bad lifestyle are always ready to criticize people who are having a healthy lifestyle 😂😂😂😂

[@yogi30051972]

Just like sadhguru criticising others!

[@gtranandgtr9544]

Hi Bro How are you ? Long time no see .. Keep posting videos . I ❤ all your posts

[@shreyass7527]

pranav when there are no views: lets bring sadhguru back

[@krishnayogi]

what is enlightenment? enlightenment is the realization that you are not this body or mind but the all-pervasive consciousness, the super consciousness that is responsible for the creation maintenance and destruction of everything in the known universe and unknown beyond

[@krishnayogi]

the discussion about enlightenment is probably the most important one of our life because it aims to turn around our idea of self itself , the core identity that we all posses. its the biggest issues entire human life struggles from the very beginning of human history , the greatest challenge that's give to us

[@gharaanaa6587]

The day scienceisdobe makes a video bashing Jaggi should be declared a public holiday.

[@നെട്ടൂരാൻ_ഒഫീഷ്യൽ]

Can we us this same brainwashed analogy for Islamic Hijaab choices??

[@dem0_o14]

@@നെട്ടൂരാൻ_ഒഫീഷ്യൽ its already there go and watch it offended tanatani

[@sb-bw4lp]

​@@നെട്ടൂരാൻ_ഒഫീഷ്യൽno he cant he nows what will happen with him if he do that thing 😂

[@harshgarg1448]

This comment is Just a rewrite of reply to pinned comment, if you have read that please kindly ignore it . Just a addendum from a believer in the enlightenment As an ultimate goal of human existence The thing with enlightenment as you have rightly pointed out is that no one knows exactly what it is even Buddha or shankracharya refused to elaborate because acc to them it can only be experienced and it is highly subjective. Having said that unfalsifiability is also the realm of science , most theory that tries to prove a physical phenomena postulates theorm that is then proven by various experiments i.e, unfalsifiability is just that, one is free to choose between believing or not believing it. For example there is a theorm that there are no odd perfect numbers but it is unfalisfiable , most people will argue that theorm is correct since we have not find any such number yet, but that doesn't mean one has to believe in a particular version since the answer is in the limbo( dog with two tails is a stupid example, and mischatacterize what unfalsifiability means). This is doubly difficult in case of enlightenment and spiritual because of it being a highly subjective experience, and given people often confuse some coincidence or a simple brain activity as spiritual experience. The thing with spirituality is that it is a highly subjective and personal experience, (and I am frankly not interested in converting you to my way) hence you can't do scientific inquiry into it. All I can say that it works for me. And in that point I will say your self-sabotage is insensitive statement comes from a lack of empathy and ignorance believing yours is the only right way to live the life. The best advice one can give to a person looking for spiritual person is be highly suspicious of everything (most importantly what you experience, as you yourself are the easiest person to be fooled). Coming onto jaggi vasudeva aka sadguru , I personally see him as a man with some interesting ideas(some far-fetched ) and gift for speech , who uses his clout to run his spiritual business enpire . I don't see anything wrong with it as long as it doesn't hurt its participants and society in general. This particular case especially will only bolster his image because in no way we can prove he is on the wrong, and if you have been reading news paper you would know the political enmity between sadguru and current political establishment in TN( that have been the in the background for some years). Ignoring politics from this equation gives an incomplete picture of the whole scenario, as to why TN police acted swiftly and SC needed to intervene in this case just days after the order of Madras HC

[@Rexorazor]

All these Baba log say that "if you do this this and this, you will get these super powers", why can't these baba log demonstrate what kind of super powers they got after doing "That, that and that"? Stop believing this crap, yikes.

[@user-je1hi6jy1i]

I feel really pity for you because of your delusion and ignorance. May god bless you to have a understand deeper understanding of the things and the world.

[@Kr1sh_108]

You’re absolutely right, I agree.

[@yashagar4443]

Impeccable

[@penacle7]

Sadguru follower is will smith , when sadguru wasn’t able to help him to contain his anger with Chris rock what more do you expect him to deliver. Sadguru like others is nothing but a person pretending to be a spiritual guru .what kind of person would make an asharam in the route of elephants they been using fr decades and then putting high voltage wires to prevent the elephants and how many must been killed or badly hurt.

[@siddharthjoshi6811]

A debate with Bhargava Joshi aka Project Satyaloka

[@pablochocobargaviria]

Here with popcorn 😜

[@harshashow7105]

Millions of people find fulfillment through religion. Even if we think what they believe might not be real, we cannot deny the benefits of people finding satisfaction and purpose in it. As long as it doesn't hurt others, religions are one of the best inventions for human mental health imo.