Aryabhata: A True Gem of Indian Mathematics and Astronomy

[@abhilashhn269]

I feel sad for you though. As I watched your other videos, you have truly made an attempt to debunk the pseudoscience in India. And you have actually taken a nonaggressive and humble approach to do so, unlike the other science speakers such as Richard Dawkins who do not show a glimpse of empathy in shredding it into pieces. Unfortunately, given the political climate in India, people mistook you for someone who they think is attacking their heritage. And I think that is why you had to make this video to explain our true heritage to us. We Indians want to feel good about our background and culture, but in that hurry, we blind ourselves to anyone who might be exploiting that particular weakness itself. I have a message for Indians who are reading this: Don't ever underestimate the Indian contribution to science. It is easy to do so when the science news and awards are dominated by European scientists. You should be reading about Indian scientists not just to feel proud as an Indian, but to be grateful for their efforts in bringing that pride to you.

[@scienceisdope]

I think I should pin your comment bro. You understand my position perfectly

[@abhilashhn269]

@@scienceisdope On a side note: I suggest keeping the nonaggressive and humble approach, it is very much needed in this political climate.

[@ashutoshmishra2439]

@@abhilashhn269 I think sometime aggressive criticism works , buddy. I was transformed from a bigot to somewhat rational after someone trolled me.

[@V-for-Vendetta01]

@@ashutoshmishra2439 you are correct. i was also transformed after my positions were challenged brutally. but this kind of stuff doesn't help the vast majority of people- they choose to use the "he isn't even civil while putting forth his arguments!" position.

[@KejriwalBhakt]

You know you contradicted yourself in second para. Its like: be proud of your culture and contributions but ONLY THE WAY I WANT. Indians be it you or me likes our ego to be pampered. This is the result of years of slavery under Islamic and British rule. You tend to seek some sort of validation. Their a subtle inferiority complex among us. Ex: Covaxin was mocked by us Indians and we wanted covishield. And Covaxin was mocked not by illiterate but the intelligentsia of India. When our best brains acts like mental slaves, your expectation of few not having and aggressive outburst is ignorance. The political climate of india in past encouraged the mockery of Indian heritage and the political climate now is just opposite. We never had a sane middle path.

[@Abdulkalam-xv3mj]

I genuinely wish that Aryabhatta's works should have been reached all over India, But sadly due to drawbacks of the limited resources (non-existence of paper , manuscripts, palm leaves), We couldn't get the one of the masterpieces of ancient India

[@amishbhat3560]

I know, right. I was mind blown when i saw the values of sine and pi discovered by a mathematician of 5th century. Wow

[@ArghyadeepPal]

Many of the ancient works and books were destroyed when Nalanda University was torched by Bakhtiyar Khilji

[@Abdulkalam-xv3mj]

@@ArghyadeepPalyes ,it was dark days of Indian literature history

[@Abdulkalam-xv3mj]

@@ArghyadeepPal but, was Nalanda University the only hub of Indian literature ?🤔 I mean Aryabhatta's works ,

[@ArghyadeepPal]

@@Abdulkalam-xv3mj Takshashila University was also there but it was older than Nalanda. There might have been other places where ancient Indian works and books were stored but they were lost and destroyed over time and as a result of invasions.

[@sriramgovardhanam]

Aryabhata deserves his own video about all the great works he did in detail. True Legend 🙌🏻

[@nachiketsharma4507]

bhaskaracharya was another OG of Indian mathematics, who describes formulas of mathematics and also talks about his daughter in a beautiful, poetic fashion in his book Lilavati

[@abhilashhn269]

I was searching for videos on pseudoscience, and that is how I found your channel. It is so great to see an Indian channel dedicated to science. This is such a new breeze since all other science channels of India are dedicated to competitive exams. You have gained a loyal subscriber, keep up the good work.

[@scienceisdope]

Thanks a lot man. Really refreshing to hear this! Please share my content so more people may find it☺️

[@scienceisdope]

Also I'll be doing a livestream today evening at 6pm. Join if you can!

[@rohitpise6929]

​@@scienceisdopeplease make video on acharya sushruta

[@Nikhikniranjan]

I am from the birthplace of aryabhatta patliputra . We are proud of him ❤️ .he also tought in nalanda university which was the best university of that time in the world

[@rationalist542]

Aryabhatta died in patliputra. His birthplace is near andra or maharashtra

[@ekkshashas4014]

Nalanda was a Buddhist learning University so was he a Buddhist ? Is there any proof of his existence apart from Sanskrit literature?

[@anamelessmonster]

Then why greek historians never mentioned his name?

[@mohanadasa2268]

@@ekkshashas4014 I think some Buddhist text (which is also, apparently in Sanskrit) mentions about Āryabhaṭṭa as a Brahmana Mathematician studying at Nalanda

[@Akm12297]

​@ekkshashas4014 studying in nalanda doesn't make him buddhist. Nalanda was buddhist majority university but people from different religion study there.

[@divyanshveer1087]

This channel is deeply underrated Its hell of a job to separate the real claims about indian culture from the false claims about the indian culture Most people always have a conformation bias in favour or against the scientific knowledge in ancient india U deserve a hell lot of subscribers

[@scienceisdope]

Thanks a lot bro! You can help by sharing with people who might appreciate this kind of content :)

[@siddhantmishra3598]

This ^

[@Ramesh-ps7yn]

Very underrated channel !! True gem channel really !!👏👏🔥😱 U r genuine man !!!! 🙌

[@abhisheksing8379]

Thanks for showing the actual work of Aryabhatta. Right knowledge needs to be propagated.

[@scienceisdope]

I agree bro. Please share if you found it helpful 😊

[@nachiketsharma4507]

I took a small course about the history of mathematics in India in college. Indian acharyas developed binary number system to study combinations in music and poetry (Laghu and Guru instead of 1 and 0) moreover, permutations and combinations were computed as means of developing medicinal mixtures from natural ingredients. Trigonometry was used in design and construction of hawan-kunds, and temples. I was really surprised to see how many things like series for irrational numbers(pi, e), faster-converging series, areas, binary numbers, square roots, cube roots, permutations and combinations, trigonometry, limits were developed in India independently from the published works of famous european mathematicians (most of these were studied earlier by Indians, while some of these were researched in europe earlier. ) What is taught in schools as 'indo-arabic' number system is purely Indian but accepted and used by arabic scholars. It is truly disappointing how little we know about the culture of science and mathematics in pre-colonial India. (another fact is that scholars from even 5th-6th century sometimes did not mention proofs and rote learning was practiced in India since the vedic times )

[@worldnews1545]

I went through 1000s of math books top notch books gave credit to India as early as 1810 they said everything math originated from India shocked to see advanced math already fully in use in our nation thousands of years ago .. these colonial mind Set people will never understand the greatness and depth of Vedas. Unfortuantely even I had to learn the greatness of our of heritage our vedas from western scientists and mathematicians... later indian nuclear scientist and an old Shiva temple helped me understand things I'm lucky to be born in our nation... Om namah shivaya..

[@Sandesh98147]

This is such an amazing piece. Great work!

[@scienceisdope]

Thanks a lot! Please share so that it reaches more people :)

[@satyasrikanth1588]

Your videos are wonderful.. Hope you reach a million... Need more such videos... This is not just education... It is enlightenment

[@kaushikevani]

I'm truly awed at the extent of knowledge our ancient mathematicians and scientists had. Its sad that people now are more concerned about ancient Indian pseudoscience BS instead of genuine Indian geniuses like these.

[@ecofactsbynewforester3744]

It's amazing to know about this great man.. thanks for making this video about Aryabhatta and his mathematical discoveries....

[@vy9076]

Moon reflecting light of sun is well known in sanskrit literature. The oldest mention I know is in sundarakanda of valmiki ramayan where ravan s palace is described

[@vishalahuja2136]

write chapter no n verse no.

[@vy9076]

@@vishalahuja2136 read exodus, numbers 34

[@tattvamashi]

Yajur veda Chapter 23 Verse number 10 “Moon doesn’t has it’s own light, But sun gives it light”

[@XtenstialKrysis]

@@tattvamashi cite the source

[@rmy5445]

@@XtenstialKrysis buy yourself kindle edition

[@vivekvijaykumar43]

Pranav, brilliant video as usual. Why is this not taught in math class?

[@scienceisdope]

Thanks a lot Vivek :) probably because of our western system of education. I think a few generations from now, credit will come to Aryabhata

[@jackyjack9660]

Are you kidding because in my school these things about Indian scientist and mathematicians like aryabhat, bhramgupta, bhaskara,ramanuja. etc are taught in junior classes. We used to get charts of Indian scientists and mathematicians in lower classes.

[@smellymomo]

Because it's not Math's job to teach you history of maths. But some historical fact boxes do exist in Math NCERT textbooks though.

[@JohnDoe19991]

What are you claiming is not taught? Is it that Aryabhatta is not mentioned in math book or is it that he was not mentioned in History book . Because I am pretty sure he is mentioned in every Indian history book which deals with his time period. In math one will not be mentioned unless name is associated with any formula like Pythagoras theorem, Euler's Identity, Taylor series . No such thing as Aryabhatta theorem or number exists that finds popular use in contemporary mathematics like Ramanujan number .

[@linxuser897]

cuz it's a math class, not a history class

[@astrogalaxytraveler]

Pretty shock to see, that you also acknowledge India's achievements.

[@nandanbhardwaj8464]

Rationalists know very well ancient India's contribution to science, math and astronomy, philosophy and architecture. Its the pseudo science , brahmastra is nuclear weapon proof that we find ridiculous. Also Gods and Demi Gods had brahmastra. Humans did not - so ancient Indians did not have nuclear tech - fark samjhe? May be Arabs invented hman flight separately with flying carpets also - ? hahaha

[@chad807]

Aaj suraj shayad west se nikla hai

[@NicolaTesla36928]

Aryabhatta wrote his findings at the age of 23 Einstein published his papers in his 20-25s Werner Heisenberg published his work in his 20s ... And may more scientist established this much in their early age. I don't know what I must be doing, even with this much technological advancements I wouldn't be able to 😢

[@dksdmusic]

Dude please talk more about the system Aryabhatta used to denote numbers. I’d love to hear more about it. Thanks mate.

[@purnabhishek]

9:36 I have issue with the wording you used. "He has a remarkable understanding of how it was not things in sky that was in motion but the earth that was in motion". It gives off a misconstrued notion that Aryabhatta knew about heliocentric theory long before Copernicus, which is not true. If you read aryabhatia, you can immediately see that's not the case. He still followed the geocentric theory of cycles and epicycles, which was the standard at those times. But where his theory differed from conventional geocentricism is that the earth rotates (not revolves but rotates). That itself was pretty revolutionary for its times. To conclude, Aryabhatta was proponent of rotating earth geocentricism, not heliocentricism.

[@ArghyadeepPal]

Any detailed source to read up on this?

[@smellymomo]

@@ArghyadeepPal I would love to too. Really interesting stuff

[@pmishraofficial]

9:11 - Did anyone notice the question? (bottom right)

[@colonelradec5422]

Yeah, he asked us to notice the error. The error was the claim that stars also reflect the light of the sun 😊.

[@anoopkvpoduval]

Essense and other scientific channels typically lack videos that recognizes what is genuine. Hats off to Pranav filling that gap of unbiased positivity. Now, what's lacking in this video is how disconnected Aryabhatas discoveries were from the religious ritualistic ways of Vedic community. Especially when the Sadgurus of today try hard to claim religious credit on all these ancient scientific achievements

[@ks20234]

The story of how jya became sine was interesting. I knew there was some link but the fact that it was due to jaib translated as sinus was something quite interesting. I wanted to share one other point. I study jyotish i.e. Astrology as per Hindu traditions. Now it's quite implicit in our studies that Moon reflects the light of Sun. I can't really quote a shloka, I will try to find a reference though. The concept in jyotish is that Sun represents the soul, Atman, hence the consciousness while Moon represents mind, Manas. Mind doesn't have its own light. Light is only in the Atman and that is reflected by Moon. So this is quite implicitly understood. Also one area which most modern Indians don't research into are our Puranas. They are an encyclopaedia of knowledge. I have read Maths in Narada Purana. Now the historians, who I believe always like to date our scriptures later than what it must have been date the principal 18 Puranas to the early centuries CE. The oldest Puranas were supposed to have been composed in BCE. I haven't seen your videos debunking Vedic maths. But if the question is - are the ideas from Vedas themselves. You got to understand that in our traditions the Puranas are basically supposed to explain the philosophies in the Vedas through examples so that the common man can understand. So the Puranas are an extension of Vedas. The other two encyclopaediacal Puranas are the Agni Purana and Garuda Purana. The time scales like that of Yuga, Manvantara are given in many Puranas.

[@politeleaf7827]

Everything is great but why do you speak in 0.5x speed 😒 feels like I'm in a meditation retreat 😂

[@scienceisdope]

Haha! I've got this feedback before. I've tried to increase speed but I subconsciously go back to that same flow xD I guess I'll gradually change

[@ksrinivas1729]

😀

[@roshantopno1253]

You are doing a great work. 👍Given the current situation of Indian politics this is what we need. Understanding real Science vs psuedoscience.

[@scienceisdope]

Thanks man 😊 share my videos if you liked them

[@ishankashyap3350]

The Argumentative Indian by Nobel prize winning economist Amartya Sen wonderfully describes the intellectual tradition of India, including the works of Aryabhatta, Brahmagupta and also many other philosophers. The idea that the West is logical and the East only reliigious is not true, Indians and Chinese have a long tradition of debate and argumentation, the different schools of Hindu philosophy have very rigorous systems of their own. Unfortunately questioning and debating is considered a "dilution of our traditions" today.... But this has been true in all cultures throughout time ig, Sen also describes how Aryabhatta was chastised for his methods, but he fearlessly openly used and promoted them. But Brahmagupta was more cautious and hid his real methods in many cases, just like Copernicus, Galileo etc faced chastisement. Lovely book

[@jackyjack9660]

At 9:30 sir I would like to correct you that nothing in universe is at absolute rest so you can say the stars were too in motion and the earth too basically it's relative motion according to aryabhat.

[@scienceisdope]

Yes bro :) I don't think I've implied that stars were completely stationary. Anyway I've discussed stars in detail in my video on "Indian Astrology" do check it out

[@jackyjack9660]

@@scienceisdope my bad anyways video was detailed enough to make me understand the view of aryabhat. Peace:,-)

[@samyakchhajed]

There is no proof of the existence of Aryabhatta, let alone the belief that he gave any scientific knowledge.

[@chad807]

Do you want a photo/video of him?

[@samyakchhajed]

@VC's Computer Club Give one

[@theVoid-V]

​@@samyakchhajed I didnt Understand, Are you Saying he is A Fictional Chracter?

[@Nobodylihshdheuhdhd]

Bro give up singing U can never be one

[@RockTrand-fn3le]

You have, your grandfathers, grandfather photo yes or no

[@arundeepthpadmanabhan1372]

Great job Pranav. Waiting for more contents 👍

[@scienceisdope]

Thank you :) please share so that I may reach more people

[@arnavpandey3823]

There have many great Indian mathematicians. Consider making videos on brahmagupta and the Kerala school of mathematics and astronomy.

[@swagatochatterjee7104]

Actually, many of his discoveries were also made by mathematicians such as Aristarchus. I guess it isn't fair to claim he was a genius because he discovered stuff no one did. But he was a genius because he rediscovered many of these with his own novelty. However, there was definitely a knowledge transfer that happened between Indians and Greeks, and much of that might have been compiled by him. I guess we should take everything ancient with Stigler's law of eponymy, but he indeed did a great service to Mathematics in India.

[@AbhayKumarsingh-rn2nn]

I think you have a wrong thought process

[@glkglkglkglk9193]

@@AbhayKumarsingh-rn2nn might as well added why you think so

[@ishankashyap3350]

No intellectual tradition in the world is isolated from the rest. We made our own work, but we also took a lot from the West, modified it, improved it and also made our own inventions and discoveries. The translation of Sanskrit, Greek and Latin texts into Arabic and Persian led to the Golden Age of Islam, where they improved on our work and also added their own discoveries. All of this was finally translated back into Latin were they again made innovations and their own discoveries, during the Renaissance. I think a fault in our hiistory education is that we talk about kings and queens and wars. If we instead teach kids about how ideas developed across the world, we would realise that the various civilisations are not rivals who plunder and fight and steal (those things are primarily done by kings and queens, not ordinary people) but that we are all co-existing with each other's help and building on each others' work. The Argumentative Indian by Amartya Sen wonderfully describes this dynamic, particularly the comradery between Indian and Arab mathematicians, scientists and philosophers in the middle ages

[@AmanKumar-de1kc]

@@ishankashyap3350 Wonderfully put. Comments such as yours make my day and remind me that wisdom can come from all sorts of places (including KZbin comments)

[@anmolt3840051]

In Aryabhatta's time, they didn't have journals they look up for doing literature review. So Aryabhatta would have rediscovered a lot of the known stuff from first principles.

[@adithyanthrithallor6559]

Why are your channel is so underrated?

[@scienceisdope]

One of the many mysteries of the world I guess 😅 You can help by sharing my videos :)

[@adithyanthrithallor6559]

@@scienceisdope I will

[@aldritchvarghese]

Good video mate. I am sure those people bragging about indian heritage and stuffs dont know about what exactly Aryabatta said or did.Or the likes of him. They just want to be proud of all the other insignificant fantacy stories existed in India and stories told by godmen like Sadguru

[@scienceisdope]

Yup. And people get butthurt when they're told that those fantasy stories are false

[@shoonya_study]

I like this type of content so much more than those exposing psuedoscience bullshits, those are fun but this is beautiful. The way aryabhatta explains the value of PI was euphoric.

[@KING-hc2qq]

U dont know about ancient most advanced archetecture like dwaraka 9700 years ago

[@shubhamverma798]

please do live stream or detailed video on Aryabhata concepts in details. And great work !!! this is really more of like satisfying videos😌. your work on this remind me of Project Shivoham Channel.(you both are really great and legit knowledge source) and thanks for Rao, S. Balachandra; recommendation..

[@scienceisdope]

I did. Just see my channel

[@swagatochatterjee7104]

Live Stream! Live Stream! Live Stream! Or actually, upload a video. I am damn sure many people would be thrilled to learn about Aryabhatta's number system.

[@harshmudgil4140]

I believe, if people who invented the system of Ayurveda, were alive today they would have been the biggest promotors of the modern medicine. I believe, people who started Ayurveda, started it with a scientific aptitude, with a genuine interest in making the human body better. But, unfortunately over time, this practice converted into a dogma and further practitioners lost the genuine interest in treating the human body.

[@abhishalsharma1628]

How can we know exactly about his birth year as we are not sure of what certain value does a yuga hold as mentioned by yourself in Hanuman Chalisa video

[@amitav1129]

Can you pls suggest the best book on Aryabhatiya? There are many interpretation. It'll be helpful if you could suggest a particular book to understand the complete body of work of Aryabhatta

[@sourav3958]

The thing we can learn from our ancestors and gurus is to explore the complexities of the world, not just be sitting duck and beating our chest for our tradition. Our rituals were to explore and seek not to trust blindly. In that manner we(Indians) should be pursuing science.

[@akashkece]

haha so he can be from all parts of India even so far Kerala but can not be from Bihar. Amazing

[@phygyan8334]

Awesome video bro. Nicely researched content...... Beautiful flow. Loved the video 😃 Will love to see the live stream.

[@scienceisdope]

Thanks a lot man 😊 At my release frequency, I better be doing some research right? 😂

[@phygyan8334]

@@scienceisdope exactly😇

[@amishbhat3560]

@@scienceisdope haha

[@aniketmahapatra8985]

Great video.. this makes you totally unbiased✨

[@amritangshusvlog7781]

here is the prblm the ceo of pseudoscience sudhansu trivedi uses this verses and some verses of ved and gita(similar to some moderns cientific theories) to prove that sanatan dharma is completely scientific

[@pearlmistry6120]

The video was very informative. I'm currently working on Aryabhata's contribution in astronomy's research and your video definitely helped me. Thanks. Thou if you have more info, can you pls tell me where I can find it.

[@rishiranavat5987]

You should start podcast, Like beer biceps but keeping the "inner peace" and " spiritual" shit out. Just talk about practical and realistic topics and people. Sorry I am an atheist , can't help my language

[@waltersike]

Atheist ho....kaafi religious books padhke iss conclusion pe aaye honge. Respect

[@nandanbhardwaj8464]

@@waltersike its fine to want science and history podcasts on ancient India. I personally find value in ancient spiritual practices also. No need to forcefully mix the two. SUsruta proves ancient Indian expertise in surgery. Not replacing head of Ganesh story. aayi baat samjhmein?

[@neerajvashisht1230]

B. L. van der Waerden is the person who suggested an underlying heliocentric model for Aryabhata’s calculations, but this has been rebutted. One of such articles is Review: A Lost Monument of Indian Astronomy by N. Swerdlow, which is also cited in the Wikipedia article. Swerdlow goes into detail questioning both the astronomical basis for van der Waerden’s claims but also his historical accounts. Considering the fact that Indian astronomers who came later and cited Aryabhata directly make no mention of a heliocentric system either, the reasonable conclusion is that Aryabhata had a geocentric model with the one important difference that he included the rotation of earth.

[@scienceisdope]

Aryabhata's model was not heliocentric. It was epicyclic :) I didn't explain that in the video because I would have had to explain that and make the video longer :)

[@neerajvashisht1230]

@@scienceisdope In the video I felt like you referred it as heliocentric . Also, I think you should have mentioned mistakes in aryabhatiya as well...

[@puravbhutta7237]

Aryabhatta did hypothesize that the movement of the sun, the moon and the stars were caused by the rotation of the earth, however he could not figure out that the movements of the planets were centered around the sun. He proposed an epicyclic model of the planets with earth as the point of reference. Also his theory of a rotating earth was not accepted by most indian astronomers except a few like Bhaskara 1.

[@scienceisdope]

@@neerajvashisht1230 I think maybe you didn't watch that part but around 10 minutes, I highlight a mistake that Aryabhata made. Not the one you mentioned, though

[@scienceisdope]

@@puravbhutta7237 yup , most later commentaries were very critical of Aryabhata

[@safeera8740]

@scienceisdope who invented/discovered 'Zero', if it wasn't Aryabhatta?

[@HimanshuShuklaURL]

Really awesome, dude. Didn’t know so much about Aryabhatta. Do the live thing... I am curious.

[@scienceisdope]

Thanks man. Will do bro :)

[@gouravsaha6037]

Supporting people like Akash Banerjee clearly shows your hinduphobia . Creatures like Akash are politicians under the garb of a youtuber who support jihad and communism.

[@scienceisdope]

@@gouravsaha6037 Haha who toldyouI support Akash Bannerjee?

[@gouravsaha6037]

@@scienceisdope that's Himanshu Shukla

[@sethu8992]

Good explanation...It's really helpful👍👍

[@Ashok99883]

Thanks for providing such indepth information

[@rohithraghavendra7143]

Thanks!

[@scienceisdope]

Thank you!

[@shashwatsharma5211]

10:05 Nowhere in that shloka is the word "Star" mentioned. I have checked every translation of star in sanskrutam and I did not find it used in that shloka. Tell me science expert, how you translated the shloka and found stars mentioned in it. Are you using someone else's translation and trying to find out the mistake cause maybe you can't read sanskrutam? If you can't translate whatever is written yourself and are believing what someone else translated, which may be true maybe not, no evidence of it; your credibility for everything you said in the video, becomes somewhat difficult to accept as true.

[@HariChera]

Exactly bro

[@alpaciandecatre4385]

He is not preaching religion to not make mistakes. Making mistakes is how u learn science. No way does it discredit him

[@HariChera]

@@alpaciandecatre4385 but didn't it misrepresent aryabhatta?

[@NN94887]

And how you can say, particular translation by a particular person Is right , bcz even Vedas too have 100s of translation in hindi bcz no one agree with one translation bcz to hide many things . And now some people even start calling word "milawat" in scriptures by Britishers or Mughals bcz now the hypocrisy written in those scriptures are now open to public , so start manipulating translation and facts and started removing bad verses of those scriptures , so these things show , who would probably misinterpreting things deliberately may be ।

[@HariChera]

@@NN94887 wtf bro 😂 that isn't veda. That is a simple shloka written in classical sanskrit. Vedas are hard to understand because vedic sanskrit is a little different from classical sanskrit.

[@JayantRaut]

*"By the theorem of Aryabhata"* Look at the sentence, ❤️

[@LORDGULSHAN]

How did you predict, you are gonna hit 1k on Friday??

[@scienceisdope]

I actually hit 1000 on Sunday bro

[@chirichkilipaaripresents]

do the 💓aryabatta number system

[@Saj00724]

What a great man he was 😍

[@ronitrajput3934]

I want to see that live stream.

[@jacoby619]

+1

[@ashwinvk4124]

me too

[@krishna3305]

Awesome video... interested in live stream

[@justsomeguywithoutamustach6432]

This is maths ASMR

[@victormaxwellpeters9771]

Where can you find original manuscript of Aryabhattya??

[@Greenslides]

very arranged explanation...Nice flow! Keep going..

[@scienceisdope]

Thanks a lot bro!!

[@shashidharhegde2815]

Please do such analysis of other Indian scientists as well!!

[@scienceisdope]

Of course, my friend :) Share it if you liked it 😊

[@divyanshveer1087]

I hope i can trust ur content cause ive shared ur videos on my instagram story 😅

[@scienceisdope]

I spend a lot of time researching bro :) Also tag me on instagram, I'll repost :) @thepranavrk

[@storytellinghub48]

I wish if we could explore our religion more and understand it's true meaning because what you see is really different from what it really is

[@puneetmaheshwari]

Wow thanks for explaining

[@kanishkshettytheredhawk3033]

Dude!Please make a video on Kautilya and the Arthashastra.🙏

[@KK-un5vt]

Do you the theory where people corrupt information purposely so that people believe in the wrong knowledge?

[@sanjeevvijay1]

Love u brother ur an amazing son of india❤

[@jackyjack9660]

Please do make a video on ramanuja the genius of mathematics. And the ancient aliens TV show portray him as being who got knowledge from aliens. Damm they can't even accept that Indians can be genius too. Curse you history TV.

[@scienceisdope]

Haha... Ramanujan I'm definitely doing :)

[@jackyjack9660]

@@scienceisdope glad to hear.(◍•ᴗ•◍)❤

[@prem9185]

Check out Tibees on KZbin. She has done on ramanuja

[@jackyjack9660]

@@prem9185 I had seen her many videos including one which was on ramanuja. But I want to this man viewpoint because he does research in detailed way and his videos are very detailed.

[@superbuddy2493]

Alien is a common slang type in the western .it doesn't literally mean that😂..just like you say messi has superhuman powers and Cristiano relies on hardwork..in reality both do hard work.

[@nayana6505]

Please make a video about nalanda university

[@harshsiddhapura6894]

Please make channel in hindi so that people can understand easily .your content is great by the way

[@jurrasicgrant2307]

India has had some of the oldest and a very long Materialist and scientific tradition which was very deliberately wiped out by the orthodox and idealist schools of thought. Look up the work by Debiprasad Chattopadhyay on ancient and medieval materialist traditions from India.

[@Ragnar638]

We want live stream in detail about Aryabhattas works

[@rajm1706]

About brahmagupta,shankaracharya these are also scientists

[@soumalyadas1123]

9:11 some parts are ever day and ever night due to the way the axis of the earth is tilted....

[@mananaron8469]

Link for the livestream where he talked about how Aryabhata used sanskrit symbols?.;?

[@jokerjackass8461]

These things really helps u to understand the subject (math). Can u prepare a course(brief or whatever u like) on historical systems(like one u have described of Aryabhatt) of mathematics. Bcz that can really help u to admire our current mathematical system and in understanding "what mathematics is" (like ur video on what science is gives lots of insight on how we get true information/conclusions from observation) . I m not forcing u bt just expressing my wish 👍 N sry for mudering the English 😂😂 Love ur work❤️👍

[@scienceisdope]

Thanks man :) I'd love to do those videos. But it takes time and effort. Which I'll be able to give when my videos start getting a lot of traffic. So please help me grow by sharing :)

[@shraddhalipane4031]

Your video at 6 mins says Aryabhatta used sanskrit alphabets...? I am confused, is there sanskrit script?..

[@duluozah]

Yah ,There is...

[@standingaloneofficial]

Good One Brother !! Keep It Up

[@mindudorjeenaksang3014]

There is no tradition of debate in hindu tradition..only the brahmins were allowed to read or so to say study..

[@nandanbhardwaj8464]

science and religion must be separate. Modi ji said Indians practiced plastic surgery because Ganesha's head was replaced. I would rather say that Susruta invented surgery, his book is the earliest discussing in detail. This is the differnce between a proud Indian rationalist and a bhakt

[@diehardernxgt2161]

The problem is, ganesh is mote popular than susruta, so politicians will mention the dieties/people that are more popular.

[@vipulsharma3751]

Letters of sanskrit alphabets, do a live stream.

[@sarathlala.k6835]

One channel "project shivoham" telling so many things related to science mixing with ancient India is that true?

[@sarathlala.k6835]

@Science is Dope please reply

[@rayzard3687]

He is true

[@aniruddha3431]

Ya I have watched it. Incredible

[@sahilnaik3079]

A true legend!!

[@shubhamchandel3524]

Can you make a video on Sanskrit and what makes it different from other languages and if it is the ancient language of our culture or it is also derived from some other language...??

[@shubhamchandel3524]

@@osculocentric What??

[@Tomevone]

What do you have to say about the science of aryan invasion/migration theory

[@KING-hc2qq]

Mahaveera charya who tell speed of light

[@akhileshpandey7503]

bro please put subtitles in all of your video,

[@sivaprasad3126]

Play it in 1.75x or 2x. He is really very slow.

[@onlyhumanity6148]

China has high influence of India's ancient Buddhist traditions. Still they give credit to India for Bodhi dharma. Whatever they got from India, they clearly give credit. That's the greatness of China. While Arabs who had learned somethings from India never gave credit.

[@codenamevisage]

"Giving and not giving credit" lets see how you came to this conclusion.

[@khosrowanushirwan7591]

Arabs or Muslims to be precise gave credits to India

[@md.shaghilsubhani.1639]

Read some books bro u found??

[@Xenor999]

What did they learn from India?.Arab or middle East is far more older than India . Sumerian Persians etc were the people who influenced indian culture and traditions as the people first migrating to India were from these locations .so if anything middle East influenced India more than vice versa.

[@onlyhumanity6148]

@@Xenor999 Talk with the facts. The Indian temples are more than 1000 years older which are still the marvels of architect. The universities like Nalanda, Vikramsila, Takshhasila used to be in India. While if you look at arab, they dont had so much profound things. The only invention of Arab is Islam which is the cause of trouble and wars in many countries. Buddha, mahabir,kabir are the gems of India whose impact on the overall world is very high. The numerical system Hindu-Arabic system was also invented in India.concept of infinity and zero was also prevailed in India since ancient times. Probably you may be Indian or Pakistanis. But having biassed feelings towards Arab is surprising. You follow the religion of Arab, that doesnt mean they were your ancestors and you have right to take credits of Arab.

[@shivaram1355]

can u talk about medical topics ?lifestyle n food myth like that bro?

[@ekkshashas4014]

Is there any actual proof of existence of Aryabhatta as a Hindu/Brahmin man apart from Sanskrit literature?

[@KING-hc2qq]

In vedic period we indians know earth is round in vedic period u want proof

[@diptyprakashswain1121]

Bruhh because destroy of books

[@DineshKumar-ut4ph]

Yes please provide😂😂😂

[@diptyprakashswain1121]

@@DineshKumar-ut4ph bruh just search

[@KING-hc2qq]

Aghastya samhita

[@sanjayprasadsrivastava5875]

He was from India only.

[@venkateshprabhu7027]

Sir, please find the information 🙏👍 Dr Carl Sagan and Dr Richard Dawkins and their Wikipedia and videos. Thank you sir.

[@vaibhavkrupakar240]

Can you make a video on kerala school of mathematics and Madhava of samagrama, I guarantee no pseudoscience

[@awesomevideo5525]

Can you talk about Dasgupta

[@arjun5j]

6:05 you could have just explained how 10 comes after 9 - nothing complicated