Scratchin Melodii Old vs NEW (2023 update)

[@RJNRGYT]

Which song had the biggest change in your opinion?

[@starry_miku_mikan_tadc_ds]

Cream Cheese Icing

[@britishperson1]

easily cream cheese icing

[@himitsusonzai4396]

Cream Cheese Icing.

[@bloopy4344]

Cream cheese icing!

[@reythe9]

cream cheese lcing

[@grinchyskellington]

i like the new versions of the songs. seems like they fixed the tuning. specially melodii, they sound more expressive.

[@RJNRGYT]

Cream Cheese Icing got a huge update and in Grease Poppin Melodi doesn't sound like she has no personality anymore

[@skydoesstuff7129]

@@RJNRGYTI don’t like djs new vocals

[@RJNRGYT]

Same​@@skydoesstuff7129

[@RJNRGYT]

​@@skydoesstuff7129in the old the music kind of stops for the intense dj but in the new it keeps going

[@bobuxman1434]

And the voices, they no longer sound so much like a vocaloid, besides fixing melodii's voice in grease poppin'

[@Bytezor8]

With the new voices it’s clear their focus was consistency and clarity A lot of vocals are now a lot clearer, and Melodii got practically overhauled, a lot of her vocals are far less electronic sounding and now has a consistent voice amongst all songs (for an example of what I mean by consistency listen to how different her voice is in the old version of Grease Poppin compared to the rest of the game)

[@jteam_]

to be fair im pretty sure with the old version of grease poppin', the point was that melodii sounded like an old TTS voice from the 90s

[@jamieberryb]

melodii is not a girl pal 😭

[@rainbowspongebob]

@@jamieberrybisn’t she non-binary or smth

[@alexexists3108]

​@@rainbowspongebobthey use to use all pronouns but recently LJ retconned it to exclusively They/Them

[@posadassustersicknijaibdej8409]

She looks like a girl tho

[@kyubeyz_7062]

The new cream cheese icing is marginally better than the original imo but it suffers from the issue of not being a very good tutorial song compared to the original.

[@mint_marigold1229]

I definitely see that now that you pointed it out. Since the songs are made with vocaloids the lines could easily be simplified if need be, and the UI could also do with some sort of signifier that it's changing from blue to pink or vice versa. I love new Cream Cheese Icing, it's a bop, but it absolutely might be a bit tricky for beginners.

[@breadbug323]

i always complain on how the tutorial prepares you for not much and the 1st song isnt very beginner friendly. If i had to say, nami.wav is the easier then cream cheese icing and it kinda annoys me. I got my friend to play it and she couldn’t get past cci 😭😭

[@ashyofficial23]

@@kyubeyz_7062 it suffers from the issue of not being as catchy as the original

[@Raddish-IS-Radd]

​@@breadbug323honestly Nami's song works much better a first song because it's tempo is slower and is a much better way to learn how to free style.

[@crow231]

cream cheese ain’t a tutorial song

[@justinsketchesNG626]

For some reason, whenever i see older and earlyer versions of indie games like this and fnf, it gives me nostalgia and makes me feel old

[@benykenyrben1029]

Saaame

[@UNSTABLEOTTERRRKindacraz-xi8fj]

It really does

[@elm625]

Mhm! Im just a kid but it makes me feel old ESPECIALLY GAMES THAT CAME OUT WHEN I EXISTED AND I SAW THE OLD AND NEW VERSIONS COME OUT ;-;

[@mystic_sand]

Yeah, it gives me nostalgia even if it's a game that i didn't played then.

[@caramelcwossont]

I like the new versions now. It’s clearer and seems more expressive Tho I did prefer the old version for Stir and Mix, but that just may be me being used to how the voices in the old one sound since it sounds odd in the new version.

[@Probably_a_Puffer]

Yeah it might be the new tuning. The old tuning (IMO) was more in rhythm, but I can’t judge, I am no expert, nor do I know jack shit about music. lol.

[@bakedbeans3739]

i really like the improved version. Firstly Cream Cheese Icing being like the original but having a lot more playing instead of the three just staring. The overhauled Vocaloids are nicer, sounding way more smooth and clear, more appealing to the ears. and then the lighting is noticeably more bright in Grease Poppin'. And i also noticed the "Take a Breather" camera angle was changed to view the outside instead of the corner. Overall the updated version is just a lot better.

[@francyisanid1ot106]

Hot take: Melodii's new vocals sounds way better than the old one

[@owenrace9746]

Hot take: i agree

[@Calypso-The-Kitsune]

It sounds soooo much better in grease poppin. And i love them in the new songs

[@mimikyubutitsactualyhornet]

Do people actually disagree with this

[@kotshadow]

There are these moments where I prefer Jamtine's old voice over her new one, the most notable being at 3:49, but theyre both good in different ways

[@mimikyubutitsactualyhornet]

Jamtine is the only character that sounds worse now imo

[@madden8021]

The day when we get actual Singers "that's not only Nami" to be on par like Parappa is the day where it'll be complete.

[@blokos_]

vocaloid voices are intentional

[@ВладимирПахроменко]

that's what makes Nami unique, and also fits how all the normal songs are vocaloid, but digital-themed song is voiced by a human

[@JayZ69000]

​@@blokos_It sounds bad though, Human voiced songs have more expressiveness. Using non-human tools like that is no good, atleast humans can still sing and sound better.

[@blokos_]

@@JayZ69000 i said theyre intentional. "bad" decision != "should be replaced"

[@VenomousAshes]

​@@JayZ69000Womp womp

[@YourFoxFriendYT]

I noticed the creator seems to base the difficulty based off how they play and not how players would. You can see the switch to support used to have a warning and it seems the levels have gotten harder which is really bad especially in the case of cream cheese icing which is insane for a first level and this comes from someone who has played rhythm games in the past and have gotten my friend who can beat the hardest modes with cool mode on Parappa 2 but took 10 tries at cream cheese icing.

[@manIhatethisuser]

I knew it was gonna be too hard for the first level back when the trailer released for it (which made me think it would be harder to fail, I was wrong)

[@breadbug323]

it took so long to finish cci that i gave up and freeplayed. Then low and behold, I could play nami.wav and stir and mix way better then cci? Math isnt mathing rn

[@j_mushroom2358]

Love the new animations, they make it a bit less awkward in my opinion. I don’t know why, but I have this weird dilemma about Cream Cheese Icing. I feel it’s better but it weirdly doesn’t feel like an introduction/tutorial anymore.

[@TempestKrimps]

really good comparison video, easy to see all the changes! i love the polish that is going into this game, nami.wav looks way more dynamic, bit sad they got rid of the guitar in grease poppin though

[@shilohlambrecht2594]

You can definitely understand melodii better in the new one, but the old one will always slap

[@Loopimay]

I'm so sad that they changed the vocals for Melodii in "Grease Poppin'," I really thought that their old voice fit the style of the song a lot better. I guess people were bothered that they couldn't understand the lyrics? Maybe it's just because I listen to Jack Stauber, but that never bothered me. Oh well.

[@ashyofficial23]

@@Loopimay it didn't even sound like her prior to the update

[@Thevr235]

The old version didn’t sound too clear so they did some bug fixes in the 2023 update. I hope they add the 2024 update.

[@PellerN64]

2:09 they actually fixed the hair clipping through the headphones oversight ? ?

[@Imsuperawesome9998]

im really happy that they only tuned the voices for stir and mix because it all ready really good

[@Pixel_Blue11]

I like old one it gives me nostalgia

[@Neil-rl4lk]

3:23 THERES TWO OF THEM SINGING

[@kuribirdie]

the improvement is crazy, they're really making this game the best it can be

[@luismiguelcaballerojordan4784]

The first song changed a lot in a good way, i also love the burger level new version, melodii voice is more normal compared to the weird old version

[@DuskZiOXofficial]

I feel kind of sad because I seem to be the only person that prefers the old cream cheese icing version, the song just sounds more unique than the new version idk it just sounds nicer to me, but I really like the new animations in the rest of the songs

[@RJNRGYT]

The Old one was like more of a tutorial song exept for the Hey dj I gotta admit part

[@OmegaSean]

The old one is not only repetitive, but just generally bad to listen to

[@jakejayingee]

I agree

[@lucuzlol]

I know this sounds weird, but hear me out.. The old Cream Cheese Icing sounds amazing imo

[@Yun_denn]

I don't really prefer one over the other but I'll definitely miss the old version of Cream Cheese Icing.

[@notreallya_gamer653]

I never noticed just how different the new cream cheese icing is

[@GoonManGuy]

The only song that I think should’ve kept Melodii’s old voice is Grease Poppin. The more robotic tone meshes better with McWave.

[@StarrySkyyyy]

I like almost all the redone animations better! ...except Nami's. Hers are the only visuals I actually prefer in the old version

[@thatnoorr]

i miss the old jamtine song because the new one sounds off

[@m31l_]

fr tho her new vocals sound really weird the old one was so much better to me

[@horsiesys]

It's because the vocals are less robotic lmao

[@Starvaze]

Dear Va for jamtime: with all honesty. You did your best. Jamtime new voice works well in some places. But Ai Ai Ai everything sounds out of sinc especially the "StiIIIrr" part. The old one sounded more natural. But hey this is a demo after all. Things a scheduled to change anyways

[@hhoneymead]

the VA is actually a vocaloid! i'm not sure if it's cyber diva or ruby (they both have similar tones) but in this update she sounds a lot better tuned imo

[@Starvaze]

@@hhoneymead oh. Ok *Disappears*

[@The-Ghost-King]

Cream Cheese Icing had such a big change.

[@CatmcgameYT]

I think the old one is much better in some songs, like the first song we tried in the juice and our first rivals.

[@Ganglesondeck_vr]

I like 4:15 to 4:22 of stir and mix

[@starry_miku_mikan_tadc_ds]

I DONT think Nami.wav got any updates, just melodii’s voice is different And I’m talking about the sounds

[@sloft-70]

They changed a lot of the background and camera angles

[@user-od6ur7nl5k]

Listening to the new songs is like torture listening to the old songs is like spotify

[@15_heidune72]

So apparently, 2cada did the new tuning, which explains the massive jump in clarity.

[@skydoesstuff7129]

I feel like they made butter mans moves smoother

[@rhen017]

The old one is banger

[@DeniseJones-tl6dc]

I like how the new update fixes everything like the voices especially melodii's

[@bibletwastaken]

The new one has like.. a red filter over it? It's not super noticeable but its there

[@MarzFromMars]

nah i think the colors are just more vibrant

[@Real_Cinnamoroll]

2:07 was my favorite change in nami.wav

[@Lemonade_505]

The new one seems a bit more clear and cool.

[@emilianohakrama8055]

4:46 WHY IS NAMI ON THE CEILING-

[@katiepedroza9457]

I love the old one and the new one too

[@GlitchythePumpkin]

I kinda miss the olld waves of the water break down the tension

[@johnbaggilon-ws7nu]

Older ☠️ 3:58 4:02 4:06

[@ItsFerdiNah]

Nice job! I'm planning on doing my own comparison too

[@user-od6ur7nl5k]

Simplicity is the king of all art

[@ASTR0_BEARZ]

Unpopular opinion but i rly liked old cream cheese icing

[@NebulaNectar385]

Damn I like new so it give me vibes

[@ZyrusRodriguez-d1f]

bruh they made the first song so hard now

[@Meebboi]

Melodii sorta sounds the te same dosent she

[@EmotionalSupportDemon69]

1st : new is definitely a great upgrade both song and graphics Edit: euh on second thought, djs old voice is more favourable in the old version 2nd: i don't think the song has changed much or at all maybe? I like alot of the graphic additions but there are parts of the old one that are a little better idea-wise for graphics 3rd: OH GOD WHAT DID THEY DO TO HER VOICE OH GOD HELP ME OH GOD MY SKIN IS BURNING ... Graphic improvement good(isthebuttersingle) 4th: hear me out... Smash... Oh right and uhm good uhm stuff yes sure

[@breadbug323]

funny groovy burger man funky guy dude haha funny funky anyway yeah i agree. i liked jamtimes new vocals but the “aAAAH!” felt off to me 😭😭 still prefer the og because its iconic

[@Illuminator99]

lets all be honest, 1 song has changed a lot.

[@glitchydorime]

IMO, dj's new voice for Cream and Cheese is so much worse than his old voice, doesn't fit with the tune of the song or with any of the other characters Hope they fix him

[@itsnathan9131]

his voice in supastar tennis sounds good

[@breadbug323]

I didnt see much problem with it until i heard the comparison. It hit me like a train but I began to not care much.

[@reythe9]

I liked the other songs in the new update but they remove the freestyle in the boss level

[@RJNRGYT]

Apparently the free style didn't work for the new score so they had to take it out to Make it work for the new score thing (it will come back though)

[@reythe9]

@@RJNRGYT ok and you replied like 10 mins ago

[@maddiemcnugget1076]

dang my burger won't be in 3D

[@dylanzlol7293]

The new version feels more parappa-like imo idk

[@UdinAnggi29]

i miss old jamtime sound

[@MalayPhilipIndo]

I like the new version bc melodii’s voice is higher instead sounding like an ai

[@cinthyajulissalopezmejia4342]

i dont know but this new version sound utau and the old version sounds clean

[@PonyHorsePlays]

I prefer the old cream cheese icing music better

[@Rain-og6uw]

Old Nami wav was good😢but new too

[@MasonMorto]

The game is more... pinkish? I love it

[@Peppapogiscringe]

I love the new one!

[@Quicknori]

I like the older version.

[@rainbowspongebob]

The new one is so much better

[@Mastercheif5332_Gaming]

The new version of grease poppin melodii singing is way better than the old

[@MalayPhilipIndo]

Bruh the song of “Nami.wav” it doesn’t even sound like you switched songs cuz they are the same song lol

[@itbh5753]

Gives me parapa the rapa vibes

[@birdiehasafuntime]

Nami sounds the same Bc she isn't a vocaloid

[@radicalboy_777]

Oh cool

[@fanoverdell]

I don't care what everyone thinks... The old visuals of NAMI wav were better... the new sprites are not bad but... They give her a more real human look, but I don't like it... Because, you know... All other characters are still cartoon characters.

[@Realzeyahere]

well jamtime sound new at the new update

[@auildomessinah7746]

vs nami...THE BEST THEN THE NEW

[@Missnurse-u9x]

I love old

[@omerabdalla7427]

Got ×2 That Sweet ×2 Magic💀

[@mphomateagane7745]

The new one is better than the old one

[@jorgienathanael]

i think the song of stir and mix is sound same

[@blank2255]

Old Nami.Wav visual vibes were better

[@Hamburger-st5go]

Why does the old one sound like FNF!?!?!?!

[@Superastroid]

Both melody voice is kinda bad i want a very meduim voice the new ones too low and the old ones too high

[@Superastroid]

I mean jamitine

[@Superastroid]

Too

[@user-od6ur7nl5k]

I like the original stir and mix song cuz jamtine's voice sounds better new jamtine sounds to inoccent

[@LightningYuuki]

old is like FNF

[@briahriehle5767]

HI

[@Lunsheath]

Might be an unpopular opinion but a actually kinda prefer the original cinnabay & cheesecake song

[@SCORPIOGG52]

😜😜 gor that ee po

[@Silly_robert]

The old one sounds robotic

[@Thevr235]

Did I just hear Melody say take the L

[@RJNRGYT]

Where

[@noobi_epico911]

butter

[@notbigshot7662]

In my bias opinion 1 new better 2 tied 3 old better 4 old better

[@bucodjodjodjovic3253]

Old version of HEY DJ I GOTTA ADMIT THE KIDS GOT STYLE AND BARS TO SPIT is better

[@verktum]

For people that like old better 👇

[@notnok5595]

2:32 4:02

[@Superastroid]

Creadits to dingo dnc

[@Vizedar]

the dj for the old was better

[@samanthadeady457]

Honestly i hate the new Jamtine. She sounds more "mommy-like"

[@Rain-og6uw]

New 👍

[@Astr0oo29]

Not very popular opinion: some songs weren't very good with the new update

[@LauraRobles-c4o]

DID MELODII SAID PEE PEE

[@red_kot_blyat1274]

old stir and mix and grease poppin sounds better than his new version

[@Кет_Рыжуляк]

Dingo dnc

[@karlamoreno3154]

Quitando lo racista son más ne---💀