Seandainya aku jadi murid sekolah Hogwarts [Rose All Day x Harry Potter Makeup Review]

[@trisha6670]

Senior yang sering tinggal kelas 😂😂😂. Tidak heran kak Shal awet muda karena jokesnya juga mantap mantap 👍🏼

[@sisapirili]

Sesungguhnya aku terhibur dg transisi ka shal.. awkward but natural. Love it haha

[@ea1065]

You’re giving me Luna Lovegood vibes indeed 👀💙

[@bluebyme6129]

"Penderitaan kita sama seimbang" -shallow stuff ( june 2022)

[@miftahuljannahilyas4544]

Omg kak shal I love how your make up is getting more and more natural karena emang ini yang aku cari! Makanya ga heran aku selalu nungguin video baru di channel kaka. Semangat terus ngontennya ya~

[@jeybishinta]

Kombinasi yang ku sukaaaa bgttt Aku Ravenclaw dan in Love with Hermione, ditambah suka produk Rose All Day. And tadaaaaa, mereka collab (?) seneng nya 🥹🫶🏻

[@arach4459]

They had the chance to name the shades after HP spells or at least HP related but nah🤷

[@shufih]

Agreee! Also I wish packaging lipbalm warna gelap juga kaya kardusnya, bukan putih :(

[@ATHIYASDFGHJKL]

bener bgt cuma tempel logo doang. mengecewakan.

[@hannamariapardosi4174]

AKU SELALU SUKA KAMUU KARENA KAMU SELALU MASUKIN KOMEDIIII 😭😭😭😭 BTW MAKASIH YA KAKKK

[@miftairma4727]

Akhirnya review ini yg ditunggu" banget buat pncinta hp, kmrin mau beli msih ragu nunggu direview kak shal dulu

[@titilasmariasaing846]

Serius umur 30thnan? Ga pake make up umur nya kelihatan 25/26thn pake make up kelihatan 22thn , awet muda sekali Kaka ini 😭 sukses selalu kak

[@ilovemyself7991]

Kalau di aku sih sebenernya emang produknya bagus tapi ga se wah itu "in terms of quality". Lip balm ya oke cuma masih banyak yg lain that performs much better, eyeshadow juga warnanya kek udah basic bgt dan mostly udah pada punya warna itu. Tapi kalau emang suka bgt sm HP ya gas aja buat koleksi. Sayang banget nih di aku yg masuknya slytherin warnanya sangat tidak ada yg melambangkan kita wkwkwkwk. I expect that they are at least have this one color that would represent each houses on the pallette but I guess we wouldn't get it in this collection 🙃

[@ilovemyself7991]

Ugh idk I actually kinda disappointed though not gonna lie. Kek it's a big collaboration right? I mean it's HP so why don't you try to give it all? Itu jujurnya lebih ke HP Gryffindor collection bcs all of the colors scream gryffindor for me. I expect that would be at least some yellow shimmer, black, metallic blue and true metallic green. It's not cheap so yeah idk if I am actually satisfied or not

[@shallowstuff3911]

Thank you so muchy for your point of view. I was actually scared that the products would perform less than their other launches, cause that's what most brands do when they collaborate with other brands, it's all about money grab, but when I tested the eyeshadow palette, the mattes were pigmented (except for Sheer), the shimmers were creamy, it is a good quality eyeshadow palette. Is it the best of all time? Idk. Will I use up more than half of the shades? Absolutely. Ofc the top row was pretty basic, but that is exactly what I look for from an eyeshadow palette. Some basic earthy colors and some creamy shimmers. But yesss I definitely agree that there should've been more colors representing each house.

[@ilovemyself7991]

@@shallowstuff3911 yeah I can't help but compare them to other HP collaboration like Barry M and Ulta. I am not going to say this one is the worst in terms of quality but I got to say it is in terms of creativity. Even the shade names in Barry M and Ulta pallete would remind you of a character or even spell in HP apalagi warnanya ya. The quality is good though, just too bad it's all scream gryffindor collection for me (yes me as a slytherin being salty karna jangankan di prioritaskan, dimasukkin aja engga wkwkwkwk).

[@putrinuriffa]

as a slytherin, i couldnt agree more. aku potterhead yg masih waras. liat produk ini ga gelap mata karena jujur keliatannya biasa aja dan emang kurang merepresentasikan asrama2 di hogwarts. sayang aja padahal udah nyangkutin nama harry potter and i know is not that easy. i would appreciate more if theres something new and interesting as it would be in this collaboration

[@ilovemyself7991]

@@putrinuriffa exactly, tbh I expect something unusual too like a black or dark green lipstick that represent ST, blue and yellow eyeliner for other houses. I mean it's more like "Gryffindor Collection" rather than HP collaboration. Ibarat bikin kolab Power Puff Girls tapi shadenya bertemakan pink semua atau kolab sm Avengers tapi shadenya merah semua wkwkwk

[@yoiminnn]

Bener2 #oot tp Ada yg nonton Manifest ga sih? Kakak mirip bgt sm Dokter Saanvi ya ampun! Pantes dr pertama liat kok muka kk kek pernah liat gt.. baru keinget skrg 😌

[@ceuceuelma]

Mana ada siswa tinggal kelas kaak, kakak lebih kayak Hermione yang akhirnya balik lagi ke Hogwarts ambil kelas 7 dan nyelesain ujian NEWT biar bisa lolos jadi calon Ministry of Magic 😂👍🏻 Edit: aku jg Thunderbird kak 😽 klo Hogwarts nya Hufflepuff pride😤💛

[@alenitaputri6943]

pas awal launching di ig i like OMGG THIS IS SO CUTEE :') like yang harus belii harus belii gituu , aku slytherin but in love with hermione

[@destriinayah5928]

sukaa bangett, natural bgtt 😍

[@pradnyapratiwi2447]

Kk coba review bedak Maybelline Fit Me 12-Hour Oil Control dong kak, kira" kakak cocoknya shade apa😁

[@jinsoulee]

you're so effortlessly funny😭😭

[@MeltyNisa9626]

You’re give me a Luna Lovegood vibes💙💙💙

[@alia_babo]

Aku juga Potterhead (I'm a Ravenclaw at Hogwarts and Horned Serpent at Ilvermorny) tapi karena aku gak terlalu suka pake makeup jadi aku gatau collab yang ini. Jujur jadi kepengen gara-gara ini HP related wkwkwk Tapi nama shades-nya kurang kreatif dan kayak gak on theme gitu. Kayak bisa buat tema lain selain HP. Kurang iconic hehe😂 Tapi kayaknya aku mungkin bakal beli lip products-nya karena aku suka tinted lip balms.

[@unpretty.journey]

Aku jg Potterhead dan mikir yg sama dgn kamu. Tp dugaanku kenapa nama2nya ga iconic, karena nama2 yg terkait dgn HP itu ada trademarknya masing2, secara masing2 kata2 itu kan kreasinya JK Rowling ya. Jadi kalau mereka mau pake kata2 yg ada di dunia HP, bisa jadi masing2 barang ntar makin mahal harganya. Just my opinion 😊

[@alia_babo]

@@unpretty.journey kayaknya kalo nama tokoh-tokohnya atau hal-hal yang cuma ada di universe HP (kayak quidditch, horcrux, Ravenclaw, patronus, nama mantra kayak expelliarmus, dll.) iyalah trademark, tapi kan kalopun ternyata gabisa pake yg trademark, bisa pake yg lain yg masih tetep on theme. Misal yg warnanya kemerahan itu "dragon heartstring", atau kalo ada warna ijo itu "bottled fame", atau bahkan kata-kata yg generik (relative to the HP universe) kayak "witchcraft", dll. Gatau ya ngerasa kayak agak asal-asalan aja bikinnya kayak collab Mac X The Sims 4

[@unpretty.journey]

@@alia_babo iya aku setuju dgn yg kamu blg gitu. Aku jg cuma share my thoughts aja dan ga bermaksud berdebat apalagi belain RADC yg mungkin agak kurang kreatif dalam penamaan shade2nya 😊

[@alia_babo]

@@unpretty.journey kenapa ini dibilang berdebat 😑 Gue cuma kasih gambaran gimana colab ini seharusnya bisa lebih baik dan justru nerusin poin lu

[@unpretty.journey]

@@alia_babo haha ya sudah.. Cuma mgkn agak kaget dgn kata2 kamu ketika bilang 'iyalah' soalnya agak kasar ketika dibaca. Dan jg emoji 😑 ke org yg dikenal jg agak rude imo.. Kita kan sama2 pecinta HP dan intinya merasakan yg sama dgn collab ini yg agak underwhelming 😔

[@renipurnamasari0448]

Pliis.. Umur 30 tapi kayak anak 18 tahun ya ampun :((((.. Kiyowoooo

[@chikayulia2408]

Ka cobain madame gie perfect velvet spf 30 two way cake dong

[@miekremesgemez7022]

Bikin review luxcrime foundi balm dong.

[@harumicha]

Mine is Ravenclaw too 💙

[@tirtasilalahi3175]

blushnya pake apa??? lucuu bangettttt warnanya

[@tsamaraghinahsalsabilahw8942]

masih nunggu paket lipblamku Dan makin ga sabar abis liat inii T^T

[@shallowstuff3911]

Lip balm-nya favoritkuuu, ini aku lg pakai sekarang warna Velvet Crimson.

[@kamilazizar]

"Senior yang sering tinggal kelas akan beranjak" + ekspresi lempeng Kak Shall Humorkuuuuuuuu 😂😂😂

[@mariamarianadolorosanogo5059]

Kak, minta skin care rutin utk matanya donk. Makasih

[@unpretty.journey]

Aku sama banget dgn Shall soal lip balm, jaraangg bgt nemu yg warnanya campuran, pdhl yg campuran itu yg lebih cocok di bibir & skin tone aku. Tapi kalo secara feel lip balmnya gmn, Shall? Apakah ada rasa mintnya, atau vanillanya, atau apa pun? Trs apakah dia balmy yg slippery gitu, apa ya cuma kyk lipstick creamy pada umumnya? Makasih sebelumnya. Btw, niat bgt makeup dan outfitnya hehe. Kamu masih mending ga naik kelas, aku masih nunggu surat undanganku dianter sama owl smp skrg :")

[@shallowstuff3911]

Feel-nya balmy, nggak ada rasa ya. Kalau balm-nya sendiri ada yg mirip2 gitu juga, yg aku suka warnanya he he.

[@unpretty.journey]

@@shallowstuff3911 okee thank you for answering my question 🙏🏻😊

[@deviverina6215]

Review lotion vaseline gluta hyaa dong kak aku penasaran bangett

[@chotto.matcha7871]

Hufflepuff here 💛

[@mulyani_1505]

Kakak senior yang sering tinggal kelas, saya mau di ospek oleh kakak dong~ 🙏 Di tunggu di asrama Slytherin ya kak 😄

[@ghinakhairunnisa353]

kak ijin req, review cuhsion bnb dong, lagi rame katanya setahan itu produknya tp bingung nentuin shade nya

[@MeltyNisa9626]

Up, dan sekalian liptint sma lip cream nya

[@desiwidya5756]

Cantik kaliiiii 🥺

[@aliazen2790]

Kak Review Lipstik maybelline matte donggg🥲

[@Dayutrim]

You look like Cinta lauraaa

[@molla3007]

Terima kasih atas ilmunya, Senior yang sering tinggal kelas uwu Sangat menghibur uwu

[@annahulliyyatuljannah2242]

Kak, please terbaik dan terburuk Sada 🥺

[@MeltyNisa9626]

Up

[@meaningfulchococone1834]

Kak.. di video ini pakai concealer apa?

[@czevans]

wahhh kak shallow sumatera nya dimana

[@hannymardiah]

HOORAY APDET!

[@fatikasari5901]

kak, you are so so so soooo cuuute ❤

[@zahranafisa8757]

Kita Sama² Ravenclaw kak toss 👊🏻

[@JuliTube91]

Hehe cutie

[@ekayolanda9872]

kakk pkk colr correcting merk ap ? spill dung

[@anggrainistory]

Gak keliatan 30 tahun 😭😭, next bikin make up kaya Wednesday wkwkkw

[@creatorbonjok3462]

hadir

[@kakagerma1855]

kedua setelahsekian😉😊

[@florentina4290]

Hi ka Shallow. Thank you yaaa udh direview!:") Btw may I know what concealer do u use??? Thank you!!

[@bluebyme6129]

She use blp peach concealer as a corrector and esqa toffee concealer

[@florentina4290]

@@bluebyme6129 haiii kak makasih banyak informasinya!!❤️

[@khadijahmachdar2855]

I am a Slytherin girl yay🤟🏼

[@adetyaika8822]

aku mau transisi apa ngga ya ? wkwkwk kocak,

[@adeodry7566]

Kak Shallow maaf nanya nama skin tonenya apa ya?

[@adeodry7566]

Soalx warna kulitku agak mirip kak Shallow tpi aku gk tau namanya apa 😅

[@runiunge7575]

"aku minta maaf, aku tidak peduli...." Bloody hell 😂

[@oceansripple]

Kak, maaf agak kepo dan gak nyambung. Tapi MBTI kakak apa kalo boleh tau? Hehe

[@Nana-gi4dg]

Haloo

[@riskiamelia7074]

Kak mau request makeup ala Taylor Swift dong. Pingin banget liat kak shal makeup seperti Taylor Swift sepertinya bakal cocok.

[@MeltyNisa9626]

Up

[@MeltyNisa9626]

Karena Taylor Swift itu identik dengan lipstik merah

[@riskiamelia7074]

@@MeltyNisa9626 iyaa, apalagi kalau kak shal bisa makeup kayak video clip blank space pasti cantik, dan cocok juga karena bentuk wajah hampir sama

[@hajimarkl8155]

Yaaaay

[@augustthesummer]

I'm slytherin,

[@dancelikeumathurman8092]

Did I hear a 'hegwid' or am I tripping

[@ekaputriwijaya7806]

mbk etik bukan ya .. ? mirip bgt soalnya ? udh lama saya mencari org .

[@lellianggraeni4220]

Halo ka , boleh cek email kaka?

[@jeybishinta]

Kombinasi yang ku sukaaaa bgttt Aku Ravenclaw dan in Love with Hermione, ditambah suka produk Rose All Day. And tadaaaaa, mereka collab (?) seneng nya 🥹🫶🏻