Secret VS T-ara - 시크릿 VS 티아라, KMF 2012

[@Jerry-cl2qq]

두 그룹 다 그룹으로컨디션 최악일 때.. 시크릿은 교통사고로 징거 활동 빠지고, 활동 비상 걸려서 결국 컴백 몇 주만에 어쩔 수 없이 활동 마무리했었고, 티아라는 왕따 사건으로 온갖 악플세례에 악재란 악재 다 겹쳤을 때. 진짜 눈물 머금고 활동한 두 팀이 이렇게 붙었네,,

[@vghhjjjj]

여초가 다 박살냈네 그러고 보니

[@annajuly5967]

티아라 저때 욕 ㅈㄴ 먹었었지..

[@정현영-u1j]

징거파트 일부러뺀건가요?저 시기 화영이 일을 고의적 전국민 티아라 안티시절

[@jisuw2747]

​@@annajuly5967 류화영도 류화영이지만 지연이니 기존에 있던 애들이 SNS에다 그 유명한 의지드립으로 어그로 끌어서 더 욕을 사서 먹었던 시기였죠... 시크릿은 언급 된 것처럼 징거 사고나서 빠져있던 상태였고...

[@Bbbbyyg]

@@vghhjjjj갈대같은 한국남자들이 3세대로 갈아탄거랑 전효성 밤길 무섭다고 맞말한걸에 열폭하는 남초문제ㅋ

[@잭바우어-l4b]

카......저때가 그립다.....말 그대로 걸그룹시대....걸그룹대전쟁......음악방송 자체가 다 레전드였는데....

[@littlerabbit3535]

Back then T-Ara's music beats is so unique that makes them recognizable, Secret one of the most underrated Group that is so talented

[@raeyni]

secret was popular but ts ent. messed up

[@남프듀를봐서는왜하필]

와 진짜 미쳤나 봐... 2012년 노래 대부분 다 하루에도 수십번 듣고 그랬는데 벌써 5년이나 지났어

[@산유-i8p]

@@올라이너인생 ㄷㄷ

[@l2o1818]

이제는8년

[@Jerry-cl2qq]

내년이면 10년 되는 노래들이라닠ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 진짜 신기하네;;;

[@wf9188]

12년 😢

[@배대승-j6g]

티아라..가만 보니 순전히 라이브로만 하네...ㅎㄷㄷㄷ

[@진효재-t8m]

저때 립씽했어봐, 또 얼마나 까였을지 휴...

[@유성현-z2v]

@@진효재-t8m 티잘알....

[@user-el7nu5ro8h]

다른영상에 7초 찐따남은 너무 충격이었다 대놓고..

[@율눌]

퀸덤이 날 여기까지 끌고왔다...

[@faridseman9997]

2024 Who still Listen this Legendary K-pop Songs❤

[@LostGhost-n8u]

Yo hoy 03-11-24 a las 19:47h

[@설향-z1g]

티아라는 초반 여자들이 야유회온 분위기 춤도 신나고 노래도 너무 신나서 절로 즐겁다

[@euyontake710]

Secret talk that은 진짜 명곡인데 사고 아니었으면 무대 많고 좋았을텐데

[@skylarnovak6432]

When it comes to remixes T-ara are the best and no group can compare.

[@narabrio4225]

Skylar Novak yeah

[@정다희-g8z]

Secret언니들 목소리 넘 좋네요.교통사고만 아니었으면 1위 몇번 했는데 아쉽 ㅠ

[@jyjin.26]

와..송지은이랑 지연 진짜이쁘다...

[@빼시-v2r]

송지은: 귀한 비주얼 메보 지연: 윰프로디테와 함께 2세대 대표 미친 비주얼센터

[@흔연-x8o]

큐리랑 효민은 진짜 클럽 많이 다닌듯한 바이브다 ㅋㅋ 특히 큐리 찰떡임

[@너구리-l5l]

티아라 탑찍던시절 그립다 6인 완전체다시한번 나오길

[@vfree100]

T-ara queens. The best Korean group

[@이동화-g4r]

2012년도 티아라 전성시대이면서 힘들었던 시기였다고 생각합니다 ㅠㅠ 힘내세요 티아라

[@수방-t1n]

와 이거 본방으로 봤었을 때 톡뎃 노래 넘 좋다고 생각 하고 계속 찾아 들었는데 벌써 몇년 전이야...추억이다

[@vanhong1317]

i am queen's, but i respect both, pls don't say bad any one.

[@권예빈-y1p]

이때 티아라 응원 장난 아니네여 ㅎㅎㅎ 근데 순전 진짜 라이브다!! 와.... 근데 춤격하게 추는데 그래도 잘하네여^^

[@황예지-f7j]

티이라사랑해💛

[@cocoblanc4197]

6:54 큐리도 라이브 ...댄스 추는 와중에 저정도면 괜찮은데... 시크릿도 티아라 다들 라이브 미쳤다ㄷㄷㄷ 게다가 티아라는 소속사가 불화설 사태 이후로 일본 등 해외활동으로 저 무대 준비할 시간이 많지 않았을텐데..

[@acmilanv66]

뭐가괜찮노

[@philippevanbeck2140]

People who are bashing Secret by saying they looked dead and boring need to UNDERSTAND this performance was just few days after they were involved in a major car accident, in which Hyosung and Hana suffered from severely injuries, and Hana was still at the hospital for this performance. Just after recovered from her injuries, Hyosung came back to the agency and the three girls had to recreate the choreo in just two or three days because of the absence of Hana. During this live, they were tired, still shocked because of the accident, and stressed for Hana, but they still did quite well. Be understanding please. They don't deserve what people says. (sorry for my bad english...)

[@vuloan3691]

Himson Li agree

[@yanivshemtov9430]

i actually really enjoyed from the dark theme and i had no idea that it happened to them, i just thought that they are really good in acting and that this is what they planned to do

[@sonnykim83]

Thanks for your information. This story makes me feel sad and this one must be one of Secret's legendary performances!

[@ierasyahirah5068]

Gwen Leeane they did awesome.. happy to been their fan.. 😍😍💕💕💕

[@ericcoen8894]

Gwen Leeane what you mentioned is only the reason, but we are talking about the result. The result is the performance itself. The performance is dead and boring. This is the FACT.

[@decieloupamaybay5597]

People vote for secret because of the bullying issue for t-ara, but if you go beyond it and just listen to their music, t-ara will really stand out, I admit that t-ara is my bias but it doesn't mean i'm supporting them because they are my bias, just listen to their music, from liea to sexy love, you could really see and feel their love for music. But anyways secret and t-ara are really the best, we'll just keep on supporting them!

[@kkom.jin.]

솔직히 옛날 가요대전 가요대축제 가요대제전 마마 이런거 진짜 개꿀잼이었는데ㅋㅋㅋㅋ드라마틱블루 미스틱화이트 같은거

[@tkayee1710]

Jeon Boram Lee Qri Park Soyeon Ham Eunjung Park Hyomin Park Jiyeon … T-ARA GO! I prefer tis^^ All my angels , All my LoVE ^^

[@RikoJAmado]

Boram is best bias.

[@sallychiu2560]

T-ara remix song !!!!!! all performance is number one T-ara fighting!!!!!!!!

[@johnaecha7372]

T-ara is the best whether they performed their songs in remix, but their performance is very good and very polish .. also secret is good but T-ARA FOR ME IS THE BEST.. T-ARA FIGHTING!

[@이어너-t4f]

두그룹다 각자 스타일이 있음.지금도 비슷한 그룹들 없잖.티아라 롤리폴리나 시크릿 마돈나 샤보같은 스탈

[@brandenjrmidshly1095]

티아라 2곡에다 2곡 모두 춤이 저렇게 빡센데 쌩라이브하네 ㄷㄷ 진짜 괜히 시대를 풍미한게 아니다 물건은 물건이야...

[@yrg3ueuei]

효민 음색 대박... 진짜 라이브 잘한다 흔들림도없고 음색도 장난아님

[@icedtea8085]

Two of my favorite groups are going against each other. Their songs really lift my mood up, especially T-ara's. They were so lively that put you in a fun mood. Secret's was so unique and mysterious (I'm sad Hana couldn't come though).

[@jasmint4224]

t-ara is the best and i love eunjung

[@user-rg5fc3qf8r]

기억난다 , 이때 시크릿 교통사고 나서 뉴스 나오고 , 징거 활동 못 하고 ..

[@성이름-s2z5l]

티아라는 저밑까지 추락하고... 둘다 2012이후로 하락세... 그나마 시크릿은 유후까지는 흥했지

[@brunonoogajaku]

시크릿 최고의 전성기 = 징거 빠진 3인 체제

[@Jerry-cl2qq]

@@brunonoogajaku 무슨소리세욥. 징거가 빠졌는데 어떻게 최고 전성기임..

[@nokfogus.7001]

Secret ♥♡

[@sonjh4248]

Secret: Choreography ☆☆☆ Singing☆☆☆☆ T-ara: Choreography ☆☆☆☆ Singing ☆☆☆ Reason: T-ara had more up beat and had a lot of dancing. Secret had a low tempo song with did not have a lot of fast or complicated move (shuffling, jumping, running around) so they could concentrate on singing while t-ara had to dance fast because of the intro

[@sonjh4248]

Oh and about the fanchant. T-ara has a clubish sound that would work well with a fanchant (also tradition of t-ara even if the song is a ballad) but Secret's song was sad and wouldn't really work with a fanchant. Just my opinion^^

[@dmj2691]

i love how t-ara mixed their songs!!! so great for clubbing or partying

[@timetolovetimetolove2346]

멋있다 우리 티아라 라이브도 너무 잘하고 최고다

[@baekhyunpapi6178]

T-ara. They will always be the QUEENS! See what I did their no, okay.

[@ciciakro9813]

T-ara no1

[@벅벅-s3l]

대결이고 뭐고 그냥 그룹 조합이 미쳤는데

[@sheio852]

T-ara is the " BEST" ❤

[@huyruadh90tv]

The music is so good, the choreography is too nice, the members are all singing or dancing. Tara is a colorful group that is not boring, each song is a dance with a different style. Tara is number 1

[@라면과자소금]

둘다 잘하는데 노랜 내취향은 톡댓이네요.멤버도 한명 빠져서 셋인데도 라이브 하는거보니 확실히 이당시 4인조들이 실력 괴물들이긴하네 secret화이팅

[@lv-queens6742]

Miss T-Ara 2018

[@marz2]

t-ara is always my favourite

[@anonymousdevildog1406]

I can't score this one, because I'm bias and I love the T's . T-ARA is my favorite girl group of all time. I'm American so I don't care about all that scandal stuff Koreans keep up. I'll always love T-ARA.

[@DrMRChef1165]

Amen brother. Tara is a great art group with plenty of great songs to commemorate

[@garyshum1754]

I agree with you...T-ara is the best...

[@DuyKhanh-oc7br]

yeah

[@CalinKun07]

+1775 Someone with a normal mind, thank god.

[@tonym5866]

Right on bro, I am from Canada and I dont give a damn about that scandal. T-ara is the best !!!

[@sinnerz4221]

Best K-pop music era, not only did they look good they could actually put a good song together.

[@hyuuugeta]

T-ara Fighting!

[@스키스키-r2d]

두 그룹 다 대체불가능한 그룹들이 지

[@blibblib595]

i love t-ara and secret and i can't choose between them

[@blibblib595]

OK :)

[@mynameisniceguy9535]

Love that fanchant!! T-ara..! T-ara..! 😃😄 Well LEGENDS ARE THE BEST SO RESPECT TO SECRET AND T-ARA ❤👍 FIGHTING!!

[@EJ-ss5bh]

Oh My God teary eyes imagining that this happens during scandal issue the fanchant was superb... all out.... Queens always support s T-ara, for better for worse, for richer for poorer, in sickness and in health, to love and to cherish, till death us do part,

[@세영-n3p]

이때가 그립다 걸그룹 지금처럼 많을때도 아니엇다 실력도뛰어났다 최고 전성기다~👍👍👍

[@nurhazirahsofiahbintisahar2785]

Secret performance is so perfect 😢

[@noblesseh1529]

역시 라이브실력은 시크릿 송지은이 모두 발라버리는군요..

[@ikmalhrs]

T-ARA....FIGHTING!

[@manushehli1077]

T-ara !!!!!!!!

[@JRHHH]

I like T-ara's performance more it was nice and fun and really different from original song really good remix

[@hienngoc1313]

Lelfwqv mnywruigeqjefybhuhwwjjkjonwwvbegweruure b nkiubjlkeiueqwhjuyh p Teuggjh885😯😬oytrpu Ey

[@dvonk46]

이때 영상들을 보면서 혹자들은 이때 그룹들이 더 나았다고 추억하는데 나는 그보다도 불현듯 걱정이 앞선다. 특히 여기 12 대제전 나왔던 걸그룹들 하나같이 결말이 너무 안타까웠어서... 지금 3세대 그룹들도 내년부터 재계약러쉬인데 그들만큼은 그룹활동을 이어가든 정리하든 모쪼록 해피엔딩으로 이어지길 바람...

[@안성준-d6e]

티아라, 시크릿 존예

[@xxxiamjsservn]

Back in the days when Areum was still a member of T-ARA.

[@joenbjerregaard7816]

yes she looks so cute

[@alyssamariequia2842]

I wished before that it should be just Areum who is added. I love Areum. Maybe T-ARA will be still active if their company did not add Hwayoung.

[@ZitaQueens]

t-ara best remix ever . i need a full version seriously

[@FBI_EEUUSA]

Did you get it?

[@kirktv6600]

did u get it (2)

[@kimminjiutopia]

lol

[@asmawatibintiasmali1798]

Lol

[@gh0stdem0n666]

Lol

[@Jbgold.u]

Jiyeon so pretty♡♡

[@ryuu6503]

いつまでもt-ara のことが大好きです❤️

[@amberlim69]

T-ARA still the BEST !Love their songs and dance and people can never be competed with

[@АватариякланАврора]

T-ara the best in the world!!!!!!

[@Exo카이-k1j]

티아라♥

[@alle2538]

개인적으로 이런 컨텐츠 너무 재밋었는데ㅜㅠㅜ 요즘에도 했으면 좋겠다

[@sucun1319]

티아라 사랑해💖💖💖👍👍👍👍👍

[@LinhNguyen-xu1yf]

OMG fanchant during T-ARA performance in this big event ...

[@jasminefrench7197]

It’s been few years ago but i still remember that secret got into a car accident few days before this performance. I like talk that i think it’s one of their best title track and i see no problem with their performance despite their condition at that time.

[@이어너-t4f]

두그룹다 졸라 이뻐

[@사저욕설.안수경은굥]

최고로 노래좋고 열심히 하는 두 그룹을 붙여놨네. 실력이나 인지도나 그룹컨셉 노래.. 뭐 하나 빠지지않던 그룹들. 인기 많았지만, 그들에게 합당한 인기를 생각하면.. 반의반도 못가졌지

[@venduuh_]

T-ARA IS THE BEST!

[@Arriss3]

Secret had an amazing performance and T-ara rocked the stage yet again! =D Both groups have such amazing skill in dancing and singing!

[@jeondino9504]

Who's still watching this in 2018? T-ara slayed it 😍 I miss the golden age if T-ara 😌

[@sitisolehah1603]

티아라 모든 최고의

[@Dongkh74]

둘을 비교 하는 댓글 많은데..저당시 씨크릿이 신곡내면 히트 못하면 어떻하지 하는 불안감이 있었고..티아라 신곡 내면..이거 또 메가 히트구만 하는 느낌이 있었지.. 솔직히 난 씨크릿 아이 원츄 백 부터 좋게 봐서 노래 즐겨 들었는데..티아라에 비빌 수준은 아니지.

[@t-arafan2409]

T-ara 's the best girl - group for me

[@lirium248]

Secret and T-ara are the best

[@Jbgold.u]

T-ara jjang!!!!

[@nurulanis3786]

i Like T-ara So Good!!

[@미나리-v7u]

와 저땐 송지은 별로 안보엿는데 지나고 나니까 송지은 목소리 얼굴 너무 이쁘다 ...

[@enrike1197]

T-ara :3 !! Winner !!

[@MOLI798]

T-ARA IS THE BEST >

[@amnotcarriebradshaw]

It seems like not many knew how much worse the accident that Secret got involved in just a few weeks before this performance. From the witnesses stories, if Hana actually suffered from broken ribs and heavy bruising, I would guess it is bad. Plus, getting involved in a car crash is traumatic. Especially considering the car actually tumbled a few times.

[@derlanger1939]

Fatin Said Did not know about that, it's amazing that the three other girls were able to pull off such a great performance in this context.

[@raineeable]

T-ara my idol always.Stay pretty my dear T-ara.Luv u always.T-ara Fighting!!!Queens Fighting!!!

[@hangphung1270]

SECRET!! I love them ! They own the stage ;3

[@blibblib595]

I think the reason why t-ara win this performance is because of the support of their fans .If u can read the banner that their fans holding it had a Sweet treasure logo and it was the fanbase of t-ara in japan they booked a flight just to watch and support t-ara and give them a loud fanchant

[@chhivlingduong7958]

speed and t-ara is the bad group ever

[@blibblib595]

yeah the very talented speed CCM FAMILY is the best

[@MinestoDKL]

Queen Faiie Not CCM family...just their artists are talented and good...but the company itself sucks so bad that if you were to look up the word "Suck" ccm is the definition. Even Davichi left them, the crap they did to Seeya, even handling the issue behind T-ara..bad management and just bad people in that company. The worst place to be.

[@blibblib595]

i think you don't know that Davichi are back in CCM

[@MinestoDKL]

Queen Faiie holy...shitake...CCM must've paid them good money. But it's only for one last album(?)..after that Davichi is still unsure. Still stand by my opinion of CCM being a sucky a** company.

[@juniorlouback3330]

T-ARA FOREVER!

[@넘넘-e7c]

와.. 한선화 진짜 예쁘다...

[@camilleshiii5880]

SECRET and T-ARA WE NEED YOU. COME BACK TO US 😭😭😭

[@Jbgold.u]

T-ara Jiyeon i love you♡

[@VerdiNuvole]

Queen's were so close to the scene, fan chants

[@victoorvs]

BAAM! The original shuffling queens! T-ara 💖👑

[@joypomacastro]

Secret is the best

[@산타도도벽있다]

티아라 완전체 노래 듣고싶다

[@Jbgold.u]

T-ara is the best!!!

[@xSooyoungx3]

T-ara :3

[@큭크루-g5v]

04:53 이부분 소연 무대중 레전드임 계쏙돌려보게됨