'Secular India' But 'Communal Law' | Is The Places Of Worship Act 'Secular'? | India Upfront

In this episode of India Upfront, Rahul Shivshankar will be discussing the outrage over the 1991 Worship Act. The Centre has been ordered by the Supreme Court to state its position on whether the Ram Janmabhoomi case's Constitution Bench has already decided the Places of Worship Act of 1991's legality. Rahul Shivshankar asks Congress' Lokesh Jindal what was the thought behind the introduction of such an Act. 'The govt aimed to provide positive safeguards to the minorities & keep India's secular fabric intact,' Mr. Jindal says. "I believe each party has legal right to seek repartitions of its property & it won't amount to hotheadedness", says Sai Deepak. 'Secularism is the most abused English word as far as Indian discourse is concerned,' he adds. Tune in for a full discussion.
#supremecourt #englishnews #worshipact
Times Now - Times Now News channel examines news with in-depth analysis. We provide much more than the latest news and breaking news of the day. Times Network houses upscale television channels.
Times Network takes the lead with its ground-breaking innovation and disruption of a new content category. The Times Network channels, which have a global footprint in 100 countries, inform, entertain, and engage viewers of all ages with fascinating and intriguing content, news, and information.
Subscribe to our channel - bit.ly/Subscri...
Check out our website: www.timesnowne...
Times Now News App : bit.ly/3AD5qqN
Connect with us on our social media handles:
Facebook: / timesnow
Twitter: / timesnow
Instagram: / timesnow
Subscribe to our other network channels:
Times Now Navbharat: bit.ly/Subscri...
Zoom: bit.ly/Subscri...
Mirror Now: bit.ly/Subscri...
ET Now: bit.ly/Subscri...
TN+: bit.ly/Subscri...
Pushed via Slike

[@chettiarsbc6592]

J Sai Deepak is a man on a mission 🙏🙏🙏

[@BLUERAY1611]

Secularism my foot. Word "Secularism" and "Constitution" are frequently misused by certain community for their nefarious anti-India agenda.

[@SumanRoy.official]

Why people appease Islamist? I never understood it, what benefit has it provided over the years? can someone please explain

[@indianmilitary]

It benefits congress in India and other pseudo secular/woke political parties around the world ultimately benefitting globalists for their new world order. So, they use minority religions (depending on the country), judiciary, media, pseudo secular political parties, dalits, africans, gays/lesbians, feminists, animal rights, NGOs and even central banks ( like RBI) for going against a country's majority tradition/religion/nationalism/economy/family values etc

[@kanhaiyapareek6928]

They appease to get votes in bulk

[@babulalsuryakantsharma]

India was not Secular Since Baapu launched Khilafat movement .. Baapu Chacha didn't utter a word during Direct Action by Jinnah... Chacha didn't listen to Dr Ambedkarji's Solution of Exchange of population... Chacha favoured MPLB ...& 370 .. & Special status to Peacefuls.. Vande Matram Jai Maa Bhavani Har Har Mahadev

[@radhakrishnanmenon8045]

The two scoundrels were farsighted . They saw a big vote bank in the Fanatics to be in power and indeed remained in power for 54 years and they didn't waste the opportunity but deeply entrenched with every conceivable Institution named after the Father, Daughter and Grandchildren. Every scholarship, medal instituted in the families name.

[@babulalsuryakantsharma]

@@radhakrishnanmenon8045 Bro Radha Krishnaji, You're absolutely right...101% True... But being Sanathani Hindus let's not label the 2 leaders by abusive words ( SC******).. Let's accept an another side of the truth... Yours as well as mine grands/ great grands Selected/ Elected them...We believe in Karma ... It was our ancestors Sin & We are paying it. Anyway, thanks for the kind reply.. Let's try to correct our mindset & get United irrespective of Caste Language State etc etc. Ram Krishna Shiv bless you... With best wishes, regards... Wish you Coming up very happy Deepawali... Vande Matram Jai Maa Bhavani Har Har Mahadev

[@Dharmicaction]

@@radhakrishnanmenon8045 Gandhi was imported by East India company agents to delay Indian independence by 25 to 35 yr in the name of ahimsa Their motive was a separate JEWISH state called Israel through world wars I and II. Gandhi recruited thousands of Indian soldiers for both wars. So much for his ahimsa.

[@crypton_8l87]

@@babulalsuryakantsharma So what if our grandparents voted them? Are you your grandparent? Grow a spine.

[@neelmoradiya1389]

Don't forget moplah genocide

[@ekvishwaas6347]

Due to partition in1947, the Hindu community lost vast land as well as many places of worship (eg. Sharada Peeta) to Pak. The Hindu community should have been compensated by giving an option to reclaim all the demolished temples in India. But what happened? Pak given to muslims, the land of muslims migrated to pak also given to muslims and the disputed temples within India are also given to muslims by denying Hindus any rights to reclaim those temples! This is called secularism!

[@ajitnadgouda6079]

If India were a "Hindu" country, then it would have made some sense to bring in a law for protection of minority Non-Hindu community. But bringing in the law protecting minority in a secular country is clearly depriving the majority from their fundamental rights. Only Nehru can do this. Nobody else.

[@crypton_8l87]

Very true!! I'm sure this basic logic has escaped those Khangressis and even BJP has become left of centre now.

[@vlogvisionaries294]

जय महाकाल🔱🕉🙏 हर हर महादेव 🚩🚩🚩

[@upadhyayrathiraj1518]

Did the Hindus commit a crime by being a majority community in India? Why should they be punished?

[@_prash]

That maadarjaat Lokesh Jindal said "positive discrimination against Hindus" should be upheld, what the fck he is smoking.

[@msr5296]

I disagree with sai deepak although I admire him, ram janma bhumi would never have been solved if swamy ji had not invoked basic structure of fundamental right to worship cuz the title dispute was there for 8 yrs,so swamiji is right if he is asking for exceptions,at least he always delivers not blabers.

[@Xoyasal57]

Shariat law please 🙏🏼 Kodis included , not selective sharia

[@gappauch]

Obviously It's not

[@skpatel433]

This is postion of Hindu.....in..there own country....😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀all can play with Hindu like foot ball......🧐🧐🧐🧐

[@yuvarudra6602]

finally a fool left. 😂

[@anitashukla742]

Congress 👎🏻shame on them

[@sumam9961]

Foreign me bejke aya hai congress bahuth time hogaya no shame

[@ggsyep6509]

Sai Deepak and DR.Rizwan Ahmed are great in any debates

[@Adiyogi2024]

It’s communal law… government aggression on temples , taking over all have incomes…

[@indianmilitary]

State governments which benefit from most temples are non-BJP governments, especially in the south.

[@Sumit-zm7ks]

Jai Sai deepak bang on!

[@hiteshkumarmeher7265]

Why only to only two temples....why not all

[@indianmilitary]

Locations where 2 temples are present itself sacred for different reasons (both historical and scientific). Dr Swami is looking at historical significance.

[@_prash]

@@indianmilitary but for us every place where our temples were is sacred, why only limit for Ram janmabhoomi and 1,2 other temples why not every other temples that is being questioned.

[@prembedi2551]

It's really shame on all of us and all our governments who made us and our future generations victim of this humiliation by making India secular country. I hate our first leaders during independance who're directly are under charge who made us suffering of terrorism. Why? Why Hindus are disgraced in their own motherland, it's horrific, isn't it? Do leaders feel responsible and have an answer for it? Can we ever relieved of it?

[@gavuryponniah8688]

Don't trust the Modi government. Delaying , dragging their feet, not changing laws, delaying, and as with so many other related issues Modi government is not supporting HINDUS. This is disappointing, frustrating, annoying, and does not give any hope. Sai DEEPAK-ji and lawyer Mr. Vengadesh also do not have faith in this Modi government when it comes to HINDUS.

[@indianmilitary]

First, they must remove government control of temples. Second, amend the 1991 act. Third pass UCC. But we have to vote for them for next 20 yr with full majority. Then only they can confirm that Hindus are voting for the welfare of Hindu community/tradition. If Hindus vote like fools like in the last 60 yr, why should BJP worry about most HINDUS who vote for more hedonism, greed and gluttony and demand for "development" "tax breaks"?

[@sakuntalanagesan1745]

What about Prof. Anand Ranganathan, does he have faith in Modi Govt?

[@sasikumarn5786]

@@sakuntalanagesan1745 For the first time, for the sake of Hindus I want Modi to lose in 2024. First notice I put on him is how he stops Chandrachud from coronation as CJI, who is the ruler of present day India.

[@gavuryponniah8688]

Most of us have faith in Modi government. It is only his support for Hindus that is in doubt. At the moment there is absolutely no choice but the BJP.💖🇮🇳

[@arnipskumar3245]

If not for Modi, imagine the plight of the majority Hindus in India ..we as citizens need to fight as well. A PM can do only do much...he cannot dictate to judiciary, executive, legislature etc...will not happen in a Democracy...albiet a weak one like ours 😭

[@sanjaypriyadarshi]

The point here is what is stand of central Govt we don’t know . They are taking time .. if an act is wrong it has to amended .. central Govt should present its views and why delays only they knows

[@indianmilitary]

They are verifying how it benefits them "electorally"

[@TrulyIndianThoughts]

Law should be amended and stop govt land occupy

[@sm9214]

Secularism Defined: "As far the Hindus they are answerable and liable as regards discriminations - the date of commencement starts 5000 yrs ago. Only for minorities it starts from 1947". In other words: Hindus should forget all that were upstaged and launched against them before 1947. Minorities can recall anything before 1947. Only the Hindus should be Tolerant. Minorities need not be. All can walk thru all streets except those streets where minorities are in majority. Minorities can close their streets. Set timings for police authorities to "interview them" with prior permission from Jamad. Wow. What a Great Democracy Nehruvian India is!!! That is the Beauty of our Secularism. Long live secularism.

[@ajeetm372]

when any aera gera mulla can just getaway by questioning the proof of Where Ram was born. What's the point of talking about secularism 😒

[@R.kandaswamy]

Most Muslims have same mentality. Only Muslims have religious rights, no other faiths have right to their religion.

[@premjibhimji5858]

Jai Sai deepak bang on

[@arnipskumar3245]

We in Bharath need people like Rizwan, Sai D and Rahul ..name a few...these are the true Hindustani who will protect and preserve Bharath's unique legacy, history, infrastructure inc temples and way of life...these Ab faiths have come in survived and proliferated...now claiming Bharath as their only - despite having 190 out of 193 independent countries in the world as Muslim or Christian only. Hindus must fight till death for Bharath and Ram rajya...for only then will the other two outside relegions, survive in Bharath...because otherwise.....these two relegions/ideologies will fight unto death...and convert/destroy all before them. 🙏

[@radhakrishnanmenon8045]

I couldn't find the word "Secularism" anywhere in the world but in a cupboard in Ananda Bhawan.

[@reemaz209]

Intension of govt of the day inacted the Act in question should be questioned & inaction of present day govt of the day also.

[@drrmdebnath8356]

Pack up secularism of Indira Gandhi and return it to grandson Ruhul Gandhi .....😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@SN-xo3vv]

I sincerely hope after listening to Quereshi and such people you should realisevhow communal they are. If anyone argues for a Hindu cause you are automatically communal. But if anybody argues for Islam they are secular. By the way if you say you need proof of Rams and Krishnas birth and existence then we can also demand the same of you

[@panimeda245]

Every Hindu place should be taken back. WAQF board should be dissolved and govt should take care of the Islamic places if worship and all other entities.

[@BlackandWhite10]

Complex situation to reclaim all the temples which are demolished by Muslim regime in India. But step should be scraping the act of religious places.

[@rajjena9053]

I am of the opinion that sai argument is always to the point he makes you feel good.

[@upadhyayrathiraj1518]

What's the proof that his Muhammad was even born?

[@Nero6570]

Shame on Congress😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡

[@Useruytrw]

Danish Quereshi has 3 FIR against him

[@nikeshyadav6063]

Scrap places of worship act

[@ivychua4091]

J Sai Deepak 🪔🧡🧡🪔🪔🧡🧡🪔🪔

[@Ramarao-dq8mf]

Jindal .. Bobby....how can he not support congress law.

[@malinipachaiyappan8598]

I seriously started hating the word secular that too in our constitution.the more I hear it adds to the fire.. Modi government should be given thumping majority so that it can be removed from constitution.

[@Ramarao-dq8mf]

This is lokesh....haha

[@achoorivenkatreddy5199]

KHANGRESS MURDABAD