Selling the Gibson R4 ... Can Eastman SB56 replace it? - My P90 Les Paul Dilemma

[@nunomc2815]

I get home and see a video of someone I admire for the passion he transmits, the humility, the excellent taste in music when he plays, and the sympathy he has towards his subscribers. What a great way to end a stressful week at work.

[@theguitaristas]

😊🙏

[@nunomc2815]

@@theguitaristas🙏😊

[@catmandoodoo7903]

Best guitar channel on YouTooob

[@theguitaristas]

@@catmandoodoo7903 😊😊🙏

[@robpolk4469]

My fav channel too.

[@ihnchaser10]

Well having never owned a Gibson I can’t even imagine letting one go. I’m not overly enthralled by Gibson guitars, I love the shapes and history and have respect for the company. But epiphones have filled my desire to own something close to a gibson. But I understand the relationship or lack thereof with certain guitars, I have a couple that just sit in their case pretty much untouched since I bought them. But I’m too sentimental to trade or sell them. Anyways, love this channel and the content. I work graveyard shifts and coming home to watch these is quite relaxing and enjoyable! Thanks for sharing your guitars and riffs and keep up the good work!

[@rickflippin1]

We are definitely kindred spirits i have 3 les Paul’s i just cant sell

[@NintenDub]

Not every guitar needs to be kept.or object for that matter. It feels good to let stuff go knowing other stuff comes. Instead of pack ratting it all

[@handlebarmoustache7047]

Gibsons can be great, but like all guitars you have to find the right one. I’ve had 4 Gibsons (Les Paul’s, SG’s, ES335) and the midtown will stay with me forever… my Eastman T59 I sold because o didn’t like the feel, even though it sounded great. Horses for courses!

[@MattBaker-zd8nq]

I can’t sell my Les Paul I waited to long to get it

[@gbbruno596]

I think that R4 is a very very special guitar. It sounds better than the Eastman and it has a clarity which is amazing. I hope you will repurchase it someday as the two of you get along quite well

[@alexander_td]

I have almost pulled a trigger on an Eastman antique varnish a couple of weeks ago, and you were a big influence for that decision, Colin! :) But then I thought about it once more: will I still want my dream Gibson R8 afterwards? Absolutely! Probably not the next week or month, but still.. And with the current price for a varnish series being 2550 Euros in Germany I am already half way there. As someone has well put it in a different video: "I always thought it was too expensive to pay 5000$ for a guitar, so I'd spent a 15 000$ on cheaper guitars over the last decade instead of buying THE one." So I've put my money in an envelope and I think I know what I'll get me for Christmas hehe. I guess at these price points - above 2 grand - it's not about playability or quality anymore - it's about fulfilling your dreams.

[@chrisforever1255]

Agree!

[@Winstonrodney6989]

I have a nice r8. It was supposed to be a plain top but has nice flaming in it. I got lucky with that because I ordered it sight unseen. I was a little bummed about how thick the neck was and wondered if I should have gone with an r9 instead for another grand or so but now I’m used to it and love it immensely! I try not to be a guitar snob, and these days I mostly buy cheap guitars and fix them up but sometimes nothing compares to the real deal. Good luck on getting yours when you get around to it. You won’t be disappointed. In the meantime my next nice guitar is going to be an Eastman 335 style. At this point in life I’m done spending Gibson level money on stuff.

[@chrisforever1255]

@@Winstonrodney6989 Yes - I love my 58 thick neck! For the 335 take a look at the Maybach, too! I´m lucky enough to own a Gibson ES 335 Dot from 1986 - a dream of a guitar! Have fun!

[@Winstonrodney6989]

@@chrisforever1255 thanks, I’ll check it out.

[@bigmikeyz0071]

Can’t go wrong with a Eastman or Maybach but getting Maybach’s in the states is a bit harder. But I love my Eastman

[@ChrisJones-ht9zn]

I think the Eastman has the looks. Loving that colour. It’s so easy to have regrets, especially when hearing things side by side. The Eastman sounds different definitely but I can hear that it has more sustain. I think that you will love that Eastman once the Gibson has gone. I think it sounds great. I’ve got 3 strats that I’m forever comparing. I have got into the habit of putting guitars away, as it’s too distracting having them out together. No two guitars sound the same, they react differently to pedals and eq and need to be approached differently in terms of where you have the volume and tone pots positioned. That Eastman is one seriously nice guitar so stop whinging 😂

[@jamesdalgleish9389]

This and That Pedal Show are the only channels I press the like button before I even watch the video…….🎸

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers James! 😊🙏

[@CBGypsy03]

I have personally sold all my gibsons and still own 2 eastman guitars. They felt and sounded better in every way. I also own a fancy collings I30lc with 2 p90s, spent years saving for a collings. The eastman quality and feel is up there with that I30lc. The collings has something special though :)

[@georgeargon5113]

There's something so very special about owning a well made top-of-line guitar.

[@mortonwilson795]

Hi Colin, great to see you doing a comparison between 2 top level guitars, esp. given your history with the R9. They are clearly both beautiful instruments and I think it's great that you have let go of the Gibson to a new home. Sitting here in HK what I do respect most about all this this is that at no point did you bring the "USA vs China' made thing. Before I went pro I worked in the biggest music shop in Wellington, NZ in the early 70s, when I was 18 / 19 and I learnt a lot about guitars - I was a star salesman. My boss used to take me out the Gibson import agent to get first look at what came in and I would pick the best for the shop and tell the boss of the import company which ones to send back to America (one bass had a banana neck that was hilarious). We are guitar players and, despite politics and/or prejudice, IMHO it comes down to the instrument. I have lived in HK for 40 years and worked with musicians throughout Asia and met people who make instruments - they just love doing what they do no matter of the politics of the country. We benefit from their love of music and craft. All that said - I think it's cool that you let go of the Gibson and, personally, as a guy who used to have to set up guitars in the shop, I do applaud Eastman for doing the Tailpiece + Bridge thing - I am not a fan of single wraparound tailpiece / bridge combos because intonation can be a problem. Hope this not contraversial (delete if so). Enjoy the Eastman - I'm hoping I can try a few out in the next few weeks!

[@russellzauner]

Next up: Peerless.

[@andrewhouse3246]

The Eman is top shelf, it doesn't have to play or sound better to be amazing. I thought it was well matched. And dare I say..easier on the eyes. The real question is how it feels? Cuz it sounds as good. If it feels great, no regrets...light years more value..

[@johnny.musician]

Col, you are a bloody treasure. And for those that read comments, if you’re not on his ‘private’ channel you should be…the value added from his input and that of we forum members is terrific…like being in a gang, as Joe Strummer would say. Cheers mate, you’ve made a good decision.

[@mknewlan67]

Wow that R4 was way better unplugged. Edit, after listening to the sound demo the Gibson just has a beautiful tone. I absolutely love Lollar pickups but there’s just something in that R4 sound I can’t put my finger on.

[@sidestyle05]

You may not have recognized it yet, but it's clear to me having binged a lot of your videos together in a short period of time: you're no longer a Gibson guy; you are now officially an "Eastman guy." And with good reason--their awesome instruments!

[@michellewilson8845]

For me, if i already had the r4 i would not swap that for the Eastman as the difference for me was minimal. If i did not own either i would go for the Eastman i think they deserve a chance as the quality/price ratio is better. IMO

[@Winstonrodney6989]

This is a rational reply. Unless you need the money holding onto an actual Gibson reissue makes more sense. That said I see a couple Eastmans in my future. And why not when I can get two for the price of a Gibson and have some change left over.

[@Dan-gn2xo]

I have 3 Eastman guitars. I also have a bunch of Gibsons. The eastmans are just better. Sorry Gibson you need to step up your game.

[@Winstonrodney6989]

@@Dan-gn2xo can’t wait to finally get to try one myself. Got to get my money situation sorted first though. Two big holes in my collection are a semi hollow and something with p-90’s

[@anthonymoore1705]

i think the more you play the eastman the more you will like it, like you said its brand new so needs playing in, plus i'm glad you got a good deal on it, i've never seen them at £1999 before, usually around the £1700 price range, so well done on that,

[@carlosdeno]

Both beautiful high end guitars and for me the Gibson just nicks it, the colour and obviously it’s heritage. The Eastman looks like it has an ebony fret board. If the Gibson had that it would in my opinion look amazing. Great video as always Colin, thank you and enjoy the weekend! 🤘

[@TonefulPraise]

Just picked up the SB56 and love it. A well made instrument that can more than hold its own to the American giants.

[@nathanbouton6700]

Hearing the Eastman unplugged told me everything. Smoother, more rich, more sustain. The tone knob and volume knob rolled in some spectacular tones plugged in.

[@oak3076]

Two beautiful guitars. Personally, I much prefer the warmth of the rosewood fretboard. The sound difference is irrelevant, because they both sound fantastic, just a little different. Thanks for the invite to ride along with you.

[@robinfawcett7973]

Amazing how your playing sounds so much better on the Gibbo mate... I find that with different guitars - they seem to give out more than you put in. Been trying to bond with an Epi 335 for a year but it's just not happening and it's going... Have a great weekend.

[@jeremymiller6933]

Hey Colin. The differences are so miniscule that even if I had a preference of one over the other, it would not matter which one I was playing as far as the sound coming through the amp. I think a lot of people overlook the amplifier and effects. If you have a really good quality amp and effects, the more expensive guitar's natural sound vs another lesser expensive guitar's natural sound are usually lost in the mix. Enjoy your new guitar, both of you!

[@QuantumGamingUploads]

The Eastman sounded beautiful. I think I like it more than the Gibson R4.

[@stephanematis]

Happy St Paddies everyone. I am sitting here, fetched my SSB56 that weighs 8 pounds 5.7 oz and strumming happily along. Guitars are such a lovely reminder that life is good and prosperous, bringing along a great soundtrack. Reminders that life can be enjoyed with some introspection without OCD. Sláinte!

[@christopherwatkins9729]

G'Day Colin... Yes... The Eastman SB56 is a "Keeper"... Made up my mind in your "Playout-Exit"... and... You are no slouch in your playing abilities ! Wish I was as good ! If you ever get the chance to play a... Stagg L400-TS ... (LP) do so... The pick-ups are Stagg Brand (?) and I am not jealous of anyone else, with my own... (Made in Belgium)... When I bought it the third fret was 'sharp'... a quick file down fixed that and the "Not-For-Sale" sign is up ! I play through a 'Blues Junior'... Cheers 🤠

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers man! 😁👍

[@TimB335]

Another great video, I was in Forsyth’s in Manchester a couple of weeks back, I actually went in to try some Eastmans after watching your reviews of them! Forsyth’s is a great shop with a really good selection of guitars - definitely worth a visit if anyone is in Manchester 👍

[@GNeuman]

I bought a Vox AC15 from them years ago. One of the last music stores in Manchester. Can't believe they've all virtually gone. Any Mancs on here remember A1 Music on Oxford Road? Great review, Colin.

[@cosmicdog62]

Always look forward to Friday to see what Colin’s going to do next. Thanks Colin!

[@jamescurtissmith]

As of late autumn last year, mine is a Gibsonless household. Can't say I regret anything. So many great guitars out there, and we can't own them all. Great stuff, as always! Cheers! 🎶

[@cgavin1]

You did the right thing 100%. I'm with Uncle Larry when it comes to gear. Enjoy it. Appreciate it. Sell it on. I've only ever regretted selling one amplifier in 50 years. I only have one guitar that is "forever". Everything else comes and goes. I think its honestly healthy to move things on down the line and look for the next new insight or inspiration. I honestly believe that life is about experiencing things not accumulating stuff. When you sigh your last breath, you won't regret the money you "wasted" on new experiences, only the experiences you never got to have..

[@theguitaristas]

😎👍👍

[@estevang.4693]

You are so great at what you do! I really enjoy your videos so much!! Much love from Cali

[@AussieEnglishPodcast]

You're a legend, Colin. Found your channel a while back and have been binging the videos since. Went into a local store today and tried an Eastman SB59/v which blew me away... glad to see it seems to have done the same for you too (as well as the rest of their line). Think I might be adding one to the collection soon... damn you sir! :D thanks, mate!

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers man glad you found us! 😁👍

[@FiredrakeCult]

Another great video! There's something for everyone out there that's for sure. Eastman SB59 would be my holy grail guitar, don't care much about Gibson. I have my other holy grail which is a yamaha revstar. Best time in history to be a guitar player i think, we are spoilt for choice

[@frantisca]

A while ago, I missed the sale of an R4 by a hair... Came just a bit too late. Found a Gene Baker B3 SL Wood instead: tunomatic, Lollar '50s wind, beautiful resonant and light. I have no regrets and haven't looked back. As I can hear, you're getting inspired by the Eastman as well. You will probably make the buyer of your R4 a happy one and I don't think you'll regret it. Enjoy ! Cheers

[@tim2468]

I have had that exact Eastman for months now-and it's a brilliant guitar. Great playing btw!

[@sixbladeknife44]

My R8 brings out my best playing, but it’s hard to quantify why…as you alluded to Colin, just something about it. It also happens to be 8.3 Lbs. I’m hearing more of the prototypical Gibson upper mids with the R4, the Eastman sounds a bit more low mids focused to me. They both sound great, but I don’t know that one is a substitute for the other. Good stuff, thanks Colin! ✌️

[@henninghesse9910]

The Eastman looks just great, I prefer it much more over the R4. But, if I may say, you never sounded so relaxed on any guitar you showed us on your channel than with that Les Paul.

[@henryhartley9993]

Nice one Colin, difficult decision but the right one I think, you already have your holy grail guitar and let's face it the Eastman sounds just as good as the R4, to my ears anyway...

[@victoresarey4036]

The green comes from copper flakes in the paint that was used back then. Oxidation turns it green with time

[@voiceofexperience]

"Our guitar journey." Love that, Col. That's how I feel too. Cheers!

[@The9thChord]

In all my years, I've never seen an R4 in person. However, I've had my Eastman SB56 for 3 years, and I play it every day still. Best fat neck, Best P90s, and light, resonant, quality treated wood. It does Bloomfield, Freddie King, and Sean Costello perfectly. I only wish it had a pickgaurd, fret nibs, and old growth mahogany like a Gibson, but I'll never part with it. It's become my sound. Hope you experienced some of what I did. Nice channel, your passion for fine instruments shows! MJ

[@coffeerocker1429]

Stoked I saved this to enjoy. I'll start this comment by saying this felt like a conversation which I've come to realise is why I love your content so much Colin, yes we chat in the forums as I'm member of the Guitaristas TV channel but watching the videos always feels like to me as if we are having a video chat and I greatly appreciate that experience. So thank you. I will preface this by stating I am a Gibson stargazer. I love looking at Gibson guitars but I now equally love looking at Eastman guitars I've just discovered That Eastman made a SB59 limited black with Seymour Duncan pearly gate pick ups so I've gone from perving on a Gibson classic to perving on the Eastman and being honest I prefer playing Eastman guitars. Regarding your R4 I think your comment was telling about the headstock. It wasn't about the brand for you anymore it was about the feel and all of us on our journeys come to that enlightenment I hope. Cheers again mate, see you next week. G

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Glenn! 😎👍

[@humstrumbangtwang]

I forgot what I was talking about…….I think that’s why I watch? Your playing on the end of the video with the Eastman was your most fluid yet, so it must be a keeper. I was going to say something about going for a pint or something but I’ve forgotten……

[@marcop1587]

Holy smoke isn't your content absolutely stellar? I've spent yesterday afternoon listening to your episodes on these japanese Les Pauls while I was making sushi (🍣 lol) as I've been considering getting one myself instead of the "real thing" which would save me a pretty penny... I've put my eyes on a stunning looking Tokai ULS132GT (Gold Top + P90s) and an equally beautiful 1977 Greco EG500 with a cherry Burst flamed maple top (both made in Japan) and I was wondering your opinion about those... I also wanted to thank you for this content you make, I absolutely love the time you put into these hour long videos and the fact that you take your time, please never change! Might not be much but I just subbed btw ❤ (If we were neighbours I'd totally let you review my 1965 Galanti Grand Prix and 1961 Eko 400 V2 in Gold Metal Flake finish, the spaghetti western machine! 😂)

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers man thanks for the kind words and sub! 😁👍 that Tokai sounds great and a 77 Greco will be a thing of beauty!! 🙌

[@braddietzmusic2429]

For me, any LP or LP Style guitar (PRS notwithstanding) doesn’t look quite right without a pickguard.

[@JS-gp3xd]

Never be a prisoner past decisions, They are just a lesson, not a life sentence. Both those guitars sound great to me.

[@chriss2452]

You're an excellent salesman for Eastman guitars

[@theguitaristas]

In my experience they deserve shouting about 👍

[@eikerau1672]

Hi Colin, thanks for all your great videos, I enjoy the content, your humour and your playing style very much. Another thing I really love about your videos is the fantastic production quality: the different cameras (foot cam! great!), the lighting, the inspiring studio environment. This all together creates a relaxing atmosphere which I thoroughly enjoy. Many thanks for your efforts and the great inspiration!

[@theguitaristas]

⭐️Thanks Eike that’s really appreciated 😊🙏 I enjoy messing around with guitars and making films so am living the dream! 😆👍👍

[@marksanders2784]

It's not a fab Friday unless there's a Guitaristas video! Great stuff Colin, really enjoy your channel and you can see the work that goes into it 👍 But please cover up that cherry red SG on the wall over your left shoulder.. it keeps looking at me! 😍

[@russellzauner]

Can't go wrong with Eastman - it's a matter of personal preference at this level, and preferences do change over time, I think. The only LP analogue I don't see a lot of people trying out is FGN's Neo-Classic series - which I guess they don't get sued for anymore, because FGN USA is showing them (FGN USA site has a limited selection of the larger model base FGN makes). I have an Expert Flame, which is a lot like a LP but more like the Knaggs/Huber variants - a bit more carve, a more stylized lower horn, but essentially maple cap on mahogany body with mahogany neck in an HH config, but it's got the single vol/single tone two knobber Ibanez style config where the Neo-Classic tracks with the LP config with a 4 knob control scheme.

[@mikepj1025]

I have a room full of guitars that I SHOULD sell and or part with. I just keep finding reasons to keep them. Why is it so hard to let them go? But i will say this, when I walk in that room and see them looking back at me, i have a smile ear to ear.

[@stevebrusseau3301]

I love my Gibson with a wraptail bridge and the intonation is perfect and I don't think i will ever sell it it's my favorite guitar because it plays so easy and sounds so good.

[@davessparetime83]

You need to top wrap the Eastman tail piece. Lower it too for the correct string angle.

[@scozz6139]

I prefer the Gibson, it sounded more open and dynamic to me than the Eastman, not even close, but I'm listening to it through KZbin, I'm not in the room. soooo,. I enjoy your videos very much, you're more of a working mans' guitarist I think, and I like that! Your videos aren't overproduced like so many are these days, yours are raw, informative, funny, very entertaining, and relatable! I just want to mention to you that DC Resistance is not a very good way to measure a pickups output, while it might be a factor it is a small one, and lots of folks make this mistake. The things that really determine the output of a pickup are,... number of winds, magnet material and strength, and type of wire material. Those are the main factors in pickup output. Using Dimarzio just as a reference, (because they use a number to rate the output of their pickups). The higher the number the hotter the pickup, for instance,... .... A Dimarzio AT-1 is a medium output pickup, (320), and it's DC resistance is, 16.50k,... on the other hand a Dimarzio Super Distortion is a high output pickup, (425), and it's DC resistance is, 13.68. The difference between the nitro finishes is just the number of coats used I believe. I don't know how many coats either guitar has, but I'm betting the Gibson has a lot more than the Eastman has.

[@georgeargon5113]

Gibson's marketing strategy is not to sell the steak but to sell the sizzle. Quality control issues persist. But there's a magic to owning and playing a Gibson. The brand makes most musicians think their heirs to a legacy. As an owner of an Eastman and a Gibson, I can state unequivocally, that Eastman's quality control is second to none. A buyer would have to look to a Murphy Lab Custom Shop to find something of similar quality for thousands of dollars/euros/pounds more.

[@jamesmgreen15]

Some of a guitar's delight is in its imperfect nature often times. The Gibson 54 set-up maybe personified that, but the Eastman is very worthy. I'm watching your super outro playing as I type.

[@iaamusic1121]

Both lovely guitars. I prefer the look of the Eastman over the Gibson, and sound wise the Gibson probably pips the Eastman,but that might just be the Eastman needing a bit of settling…..Or I’m not blind to the headstock as much as I like to think I am! 😊 thanks Colin.

[@ces69]

I can’t stand the “Fat” lower bout of the Eastmans, no matter how good it’s supposed to be…Sorry!🤷🏻‍♂️ To me it looks like someone gave a description of a Les Paul to the CNC programmer over the phone!

[@howardyoung4185]

I watched this twice because i enjoyed it so much. You have put your money where your mouth is here and it was obviously a tough call-the right one though I think on balance. For me your playing is way more fluid on the Eastman and im sure you will use it more than the R4 (and never have to replace the tuners). Well done -great vid-thanks

[@briananderson2749]

Hi Colin, That neck pick up on the Eastman.................Wow............

[@carlospenna]

Hi Colin, I completely understand your dilemma, I've been through the same in the past, but if it's for a good cause... Congratulations on your sincerity!!! 👏👏👏👏

[@Po1itica11yNcorrect]

I got very lucky! My Gibson Les Paul Standard 50's with P90's weighs in at 8.2 lbs. My Classic is almost 10 lbs. I doubt I'll ever sell the Standard because I don't think I'd ever find another that light.

[@mikeaustin4138]

Bought a '71 SG new and it had both a nylon nut and nylon saddles on the bridge. I replaced the bridge with a Schaller with stainless steel saddles and the difference was spectacular.

[@orsongarnsey3705]

Love your format, thank you. In the outro, I thought the Eastman sounded spectacular in the middle and neck positions, well done. The Gibson sounded nice in every position.

[@baabaabaa2293]

I'm after the Eastman SC55/v... everywhere in Australia is sold out!! The goldtop is gonna sound great once she's played in, it'll open up... it already sings!

[@roberte03915]

Epic play-out jam (and now I want one of those SB56/N-GDs). Thank goodness I ran across this, otherwise there would have been pitchforks and torches this week!

[@Po1itica11yNcorrect]

Usually what I do is say I'm going to sell a guitar, buy its replacement before selling the other one, then end up keeping them both.

[@Rick_Cleland]

[@jonathanhudak2059]

Lolol!

[@pinkiewerewolf]

The great thing about being subscribed here and a member on your VHX channel is getting to hear you play and talk guitars twice a week. 😊 The R-4 is the stuff legends are made of, it’s perfection. I understand your thoughts on passing it on. I’m going through similar thoughts with several of my motorcycles. I’ve decided to let two, maybe three of them go and maybe snatch up a Royal Enfield for a good price. The Eastman sounds awesome, just a bit different than the R-4. In your hands the Eastman will become it’s own legend. Have an awesome time playing the SB56, Ill look forward to hearing you play it in future videos! Steve, you’ve got a legendary guitar coming your way!

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Pinkie, that's interesting about the bikes... are you looking at the new RE Super Meteor 650 by any chance??

[@pinkiewerewolf]

@@theguitaristas I am interested in the Super Meteor 650. I’ve seen some early reviews from UK content creators and it is impressive. I like the quality materials used in the bike. The style is spot on as well. The Classic 350 has piqued my interest for a while but the smaller size engine is prohibitive in my area as I I need to use freeways for pretty good distance to get to the more scenic enjoyable roads.

[@theguitaristas]

@@pinkiewerewolf I'll go post a picture on plane trains and automobiles on the guitaristas forum now...😉

[@pinkiewerewolf]

@@theguitaristas I’m headed over! 👍

[@pinkiewerewolf]

@@theguitaristas I’m Jealous! 👍🤩

[@T0neXIII]

You know my choice already, but I agree with everything you said today. I'm glad this is your pickle and not mine. My ear says the Gibby makes your play style sound like an artist because all those between the lines noises that come out and expose the real core of your output... the Easty sounds very nice especially sometimes...like when you really dig in... however the compressed sort of tone squishes the nuances it seems and that would lend to hearing your licks in a different light.... like competitive or open to criticism rather than enjoying an artist.

[@edlicari3909]

Obviously both stellar guitars but that Eastman just does it for me. Another great video as usual mate!!! 👍

[@stephenkennaway9326]

Hi Colin I think the answer to this is if you were buying one of these new today which one would you buy, my guess is the eastman its far to good for the price. cheers Steve.

[@williamarthurfenton1496]

As someone who's favourite guitar overall are Les Pauls, that classic gold top p90 is one I'd hang on to. For me Gold Top is my favourite finish, p90s are just wonderful for so many styles, and it being a Les Paul. It's pretty much the pinnacle of guitars as far as I'm concerned. Can't afford one, and for some inexplicable reason Epiphone don't do one. So I've got my eye on one of those new Gretsch Jets with similar p90s and a chunky one piece bridge and tail-- it's the closest I can get for under £600. They also come in some really nice colours so you might be interested to take a look. The model is G5210-P90. The one in Fairlane Blue is gorgeous, and it doesn't have the stupid Bigsby. Speaking of P90s my latest guitar is a Casino Coupe, which has a smaller body just like the 339 and most usefully it has far better access to the top of the fretboard-- one thing that I really don't like about the full sized Casino is the neck is too deeply buried into the body.

[@ces69]

You should check out the Burny RLG60P, it’s their Goldtop Les Paul with P90’s and would be within your budget! It’s one of the 2 Burny I have, it’s a great guitar and quite an accurate Les Paul copy! (More so than Epiphone’s!)

[@jacobshred67]

great video brother as always , usually the horn on other brands single cuts turns me off … the eastman one doesn’t look to bad tho

[@Blues-man.]

Very interesting and informative review, The Eastman guitar looks to be a very well made piece. Thanks for sharing your expertise.

[@octaviomesquita4592]

Hi Colin, great review! I think you were able to send the message that both guitars are great. We all would buy and keep as many guitars as possible if there we’re not any issues associated in doing that. Gibsons are expensive and not perfect, but they sound great, feel great and look amazing. I had a chance to play an Eastman T486 at a shop and was so impressed with its quality. Thanks for sharing your journey with us!

[@christopherclarke3022]

When I chose a guitar it because of the feel and comfort. Sound is important but that can often remedied if there are issues but feel and comfort not so easily. I have 4 Gibson LPs there is something about the feel to them that I haven't found in any other guitars I own US and Mexican fender Strats s& Teles and they are lovely a Gretch and a Peavey Tracer, a old 1970s Nippon made Tele copy and a 2010 squire affinity strat as well but again there is something about the feel and cut shall see say about the Gibson LP that just feels like home. I have a number a Fender basses and Yamaha and others basses but that another story. Thanks for the clip hopefully you wont miss the Gibson to much. Cheers.

[@michaelmassoff]

Hi Colon, somebody needs a beer. I own the Eastman antique varnish, love it. Have owned Gibson Les Paul Custom and Standard. Eastman does not disappoint. If money were not an issue though...

[@larryduttry9400]

You definitely open up on these two guitars. The Gibson does have a very slight “edge” for sound but the Eastman is a brand new instrument that hasn’t had any play or aging on it.. I always feel that has a bit to do with it. That Eastman is no slouch and I think given some playing time and a little bit of aging so to speak it will be a phenomenal (already is) instrument. Excellent video!

[@victorbeebe8372]

Aloha and Mahalo Colin! The stop tail piece is part of the looked for feature that's on the 54. Eastman is always nice. The cutaway is kind of big.

[@johnwatkins677]

I have worked on an Eastman guitar it was the double cut junior model and the issue the owner had was the wrap over bridge posts were starting to lean forwards and the guitar wouldn't stay in tune ! The issue was although the guitar is made out of mahogany it is a softer mahogany hence the bridge posts leaning forward ! Even the modern Gibson guitars no longer use Honduran mahogany and there have been videos on KZbin where some one took out a tuner and the wood were the screw was came out like powder ! As we know there are different grades of all woods and to build a guitar to a price point means using less expensive woods ! It's a shame with the Eastman because they use top grade fittings and pickups. I removed the tuners on the Eastman and once I removed the tuner there was a lot of wood dust behind the tuner just like the Gibson Video I saw ! The tuning problem was because some of the screw were loose on the machine heads also the ageing gunk that was used made the tuning sticky so I cleaned the tuner post and polished them and all is well and the guy who owns the guitar is really happy and I must admit it is now a really nice guitar. In reality for a guitar of this price you shouldn't have these issues but I have seen this on vintage guitars as well. I would keep the Gibson after all you paid for it and the residuals will be better . How about checking out the PRS SE McCarty 594 Single Cut !

[@chasiebabe]

Great review again, thanks Colin. I had a Les Paul classic goldtop with P90s which I regret letting go as I do with all my past guitars

[@pkflash2004]

Colin. I don't know where to start. Firstly, great video mate. Everything about it was top notch. Told a story and the ending felt a bit sad ....... like saying goodbye to someone you'll never see again, and the playing at the end summed it up beautifully. I like the idea of Eastman guitars and I'm currently thinking of getting a hollow body with p90's and a bigsby, like a Casino. Anyway, from the souunds in the vid I prefer the Gibson. I don't dislike the Eastman but for what I like the Gibson sounds more unique, maybe because its brighter. It probably is the lightness of the wood along with the wrapover bridge/ tailpiece. Your playing sounded inspired on the outro, both on the Gibson and the Eastman. I think moving on from the Gibson with the idea of buying more guitars to review for the channel makes perfect sense so fair play mate!

[@pttrent123]

I have wanted a P90 guitar for a while. My preference on the sound in your video was the Gibson, that is a great guitar. If I was going to choose which one to buy, I would get the Eastman. I am even considering an Epiphone Les Paul Special or a Revstar. I love my Eastman SB59, so I have confidence that the other things Eastman make will be good quality.

[@matthewcollis-long5233]

If I might humbly request a tangential foray into Ernie Ball Music Man guitars? I’d love to see what you think of the Valentine & St Vincent signature models amongst others. Great show. Thanks for making it. ❤

[@moosey62]

I got a Vintage V100 goldie with Wilkinson P90's. Sounds and feels nice. And weighs a ton with a B5 Bigsby!

[@AudioNaut93]

I like the color & finish on the Eastman better. In a mix, good luck telling these guitars apart. They’re both fantastic instruments but being that I own an Eastman I’m partial to favor it. I know how good they are regardless of county of origin. If Eastman ever discontinues making the SB series guitars their value will skyrocket.

[@shoulderoforion8067]

Hey Colin. Really enjoy all your informative and in depth demos and shoot outs, thank you for taking the time. This video brought out the therapist in me (I am not a therapist!). Here is what I heard you say: 1) I love Les Pauls but I don't enjoy playing Les Pauls. 2) The Gibson sounds and feels better than the Eastman. 3) I want to love the Eastman but I know I will end up selling it. My opinion was that the Gibson was better in every respect. It has the right shape and name so it looks cooler but also sounds and feels better. Yours is also very lightweight and that makes it a special one in most players' eyes. However, please let it go and don't try to replicate a guitar you hardly played anyway. You won't miss something you never used (unless it is for investment purposes). The Eastman was essential to understand your Les Paul journey but not a keeper. Life is short. On to the Teles...

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks I think that has helped!… please send me your bill to Gibson Brands inc, Nashville, TN 🤣👍

[@Mark254-TX]

Both brands make great guitars and these two were both great examples of what each company is capable of... in this video, for me, it came down to the pickups... the Gibson pickups presented each notes fundamental with greater clarity and had all that swirling harmonic content around the fundamental... Lollar makes great pickups, but not every set is great... and that happens to any pup builder from time to time... this particular set fell short for me... each notes fundamental got lost as the notes were just too gritty sounding, no swirling harmonics ... the pickups sway this for me, the win goes to the Gibson this time... :-) Great content Colin... as always, well done !!

[@paulsworld2]

Great Video Colin I have trouble selling any guitar I own never mind a Gibson R8. You will enjoy the Eastman but that R8 will always be calling you back.

[@jkf9167]

Great playing. I actually think I prefer the gibson here, but not by much. This is kind of thing where you reach the limits of A/B listening.

[@barrycole]

I would be tempted to run the strings through the body like a Tele, on the Eastman. This would optimize the design of the tailbridge.

[@PerpetuallyTiredMusician]

It's Friday, it's Colin, it's the best yt show around. I am immune to Les Paul "gas" no matter the brand. The shape does not push my "magic" button. That said if you read this and you are single cutaway/LP style enjoyer I hope you have found your "the one", it's the worst when you finally figure out what it is you look for and you set out to look for it and you can't seem to find it. Add Gibson pricing to that search... Just Oof... I do not envy anyone going through that. Peace and have a fabulous weekend

[@markfahey3921]

The P90's would be great for playing Stones songs!

[@johncooper16]

As I said in your SB59/v video, I have the limited edition Antique Varnish SB56 (#2 of 40) that weighs in at 8 lb 2 oz. It's a ridiculously good guitar that I never plan to part with. I also have a T386 Eastman 335alike, which is great, but is getting a pickup swap soon (Monty's PAFs). Great video, as always.

[@bradyazell]

I'm sad that you let the R4 go. I don't know that I could have. I love my 2019 50's Standard with the P-90s. I can't see ever selling that. It will quite possibly be in the coffin with me. Or the urn. 😄 Princeton 65 again. That is one great amp!

[@rumataguitar]

You said it right. There is something about the R4. It is more vintage sounding, and that is my thing.

[@billdehey1300]

Thanks for looking under the pups on the Eastman. I have that same one. F$%%#kin' love it. Great sustain The Gibson grolls like nothing else. It's unique even though it just a single cut. The Eastman holds close to the Gibson. It has a different, awesome tone.

[@jonathanhudak2059]

Colin what a terrific comparison between these two! They both sounded pretty close in my opinion but overall I like the Gibson better. I'm sure it was hard to part with but the Eastman seems like it will fit the bill. Great playing as well!

[@nellayema2455]

I think that your head says you made the right choice, but your heart says that you didn't! I like them both, and agree with your decision from a business standpoint for freeing up $$ for channel. That said, I think you'll end up with another Gibson someday. Rock on, sir!

[@jeffcooper3433]

You should start mentioning the headstock angle, i.e. 17° or 14°

[@grindhouseglitch]

Eastmans are good guitars that quality-wise sit in between Gibson USA and Gibson Custom. I don't think I would ever buy an Eastman again, though - I just prefer the sound and feel of Gibson Customs.

[@eertje01]

8.3 pounds is a nice weight for a les paul, but even too heavy for me. I like my guitars to weigh 6.5 - 7.5 pounds. I have an epiphone les paul that's weighs 7 pounds! Its one from the Muse series. Great guitar 🎸

[@thecaveofthedead]

I'm almost in the reverse situation. I'm going to flog my '84 Deluxe to get a '54. But I want some stuff you can't get from Gibson so I'm hopefully going to get my local guy (who's built a good few '59 replicas) in Cape Town build me a '54. But apart from the colour and a few other details that goldtop of yours is nearly perfect - especially with the weight. That's one thing I'll be certain to get if I have the LP built is a weight very similar to yours. So yeah. A lightweight '54 really is my holy grail. I just hate that from Gibson you can (a) basically only get them custom shop at vast expense and (b) they're almost all gold - which I can't stand on an LP. One thing I'm seriously thinking about in a custom-made '54 is putting Fishman Fluence P90s. Big range of tones (including a telecaster tone to make the guitar super-versatile) and no hum. So if you ever fancy buying a set and reviewing them, I'd love to see that.

[@ChrisNash-ee5xk]

Particularly epic playing this week. Brilliant.

[@theguitaristas]

😊🙏