SEPTEMBER 2024 MACY’S BEAUTY BOX UNBOXING: I Gave the Wrong Spoilers But I Ain’t Mad About It! 😀

[@lisasmith7]

I got mine yesterday. It was very nice. Have a wonderful week ❌️ ⭕️

[@SherSharesBeauty]

It was a good one! You have a great week as well!

[@missmandaa]

oh this month was so good!! so many good brands!! I would be so happy to get the ABH, Mac and Elemis :)

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Yesss! I thought it was fabulous! 👏

[@PureLottie]

The orange bag is perfect for fall! You’re right, I feel orange/pumpkin is more October for you guys! Mask - meh. Elemis - yay! Love Elemis Ohh I can’t wait to hear your thoughts on the lash primer!! Perfumes! Nice! Serum - meh haha ABH brow gel, how tiny is it 🤣🤣 I got one once as well and had to giggle at how tiny it is😂

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Isn’t it cute?! A baby abh lol. Yea they had me all kinds of turned around on this bag. But it definitely turned out great lol

[@tammy0507]

well shoot my MAC primer was a deluxe sample… oh well enough to try it I guess. 😂 TAM

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Oh no! I wonder why they give full size to some but not others! 🤔

[@tammy0507]

@@SherSharesBeauty not sure I’ve seen other channels where they also got samples as well. A confusing month for sure not going to complain i’ve been getting the box for over a year and this is the first hmmm moment i’ve had. better than many other out there for sure.

[@jeannie2532]

Mine was a deluxe size as well. Not sure why some got full size … lucky you 😊

[@brendasantiago9901]

Lucky you received full size primer, I got sample. Weird that they did that. So really some of us didn’t receive a full size item this month. Box was ok .

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Yea that is so odd. I’m wondering why too. Many confusing things going on this month.

[@LivinLargewithLCruu]

maybe october will be more about deeper reds & blacks n things? I feel like september could still be pumpkins for sure!

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Hmm maybe but I don’t feel like the October one was more Halloween than the others either. 😂 I’m still confused lol

[@lindak1768]

You was lucky to get a full size primer. I got a sample. I was happy with my box though.

[@SherSharesBeauty]

That’s what I’m hearing. I wonder why they gave full sizes to some and not others. But I think it was still a great box too:)

[@twnkletoes5233]

I got a sample size also.

[@mandismith3010]

This box is much better than last month. I think the Phantom fragrance is for men. I hope so, I gave it to my son…😊. Loved the Fame one too!

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Ohhh that makes sense. Since I didn’t study the spoilers for this one, I didn’t get to check the details on everything first and you’re right, now that I think on it. I think it is for men. 😂

[@loribreitbarth2215]

Nice box. Love your earrings ❤. Thanks for sharing

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Aw thanks! Yes such a good one this time:)

[@alisharoberts2178]

My Mac primer was deluxe size

[@SherSharesBeauty]

So odd. I’m wondering why I got full size but I sure am not mad about it lol

[@jeannie2532]

Lol, Phantom is for men. One womens fragrance and one for men 😂 also my Mac primer was a deluxe sample 🙁. TFS

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Ha ha that makes so much more sense now. You’re right, gosh, since I didn’t get to do the spoilers, I didn’t check those kind of details first. 😂 and awww it’s so weird how they gave some full size primer but not others:(

[@sylviascosasparacompartir1868]

I got mine yesterday and I love it❤❤ Would love to get the full size mascara That is my favorite eye product in general 😊.. love your videos

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Yay, yes I loved it & thanks:) I still don’t know why some got the full size and others didn’t. But great box still:)

[@MellaYellow]

Hi Sher I just posted mine and I like the other perfume best! I called Macy's again about my missing August box and they couldn't figure it out so I will take my $15 to Ulta! Great box!

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Oh no! Well hey that’ll be a nice $15 to spend lol. Do which perfume did you like? The Fame or the Phantom?

[@MellaYellow]

@@SherSharesBeauty The vanilla lavender orange blossom

[@AnnKray-t3n]

I loved this box! I use these products for travel ❤

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Perfect for travel. Great idea!

[@SanayaDiamonds]

I just started working at macys the people there seem nice and welcoming , that bag is pretty , Ouu u got the Mac mascara I needa try that

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Oh nice!! Congrats on the job! What a great place to work. Hope you get lots of good shopping perks! 👏

[@SanayaDiamonds]

@@SherSharesBeautythank you

[@bekkifromwisconsin]

The Elemis balm works great to remove my dark eye makeup

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Yes Elemis makeup balms are the best! 👏

[@katerynadyer1387]

I used a Mac primer before it's excellent!

[@SherSharesBeauty]

@@katerynadyer1387 oh yay! Cant wait to try it! The Mac mascara is my fave so I hope I love the primer too!

[@katerynadyer1387]

@@SherSharesBeauty agreed, that's my top picks!

[@melissamccall1182]

I got my box yesterday, and I'm very happy! I like this makeup bag gift much better than the Kylie bag (my zipper didn't open and close). Love getting perfume samples and anything Elemis!

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Yes agree! So good! 👏 aw I loved the look of that Kylie bag but my zipper was wonky too:(

[@sherryhenley3327]

Hey there..thanks❤ I got this box a few days ago..I was not impressed😂

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Ha ha really? I loved it! 😂 but that’s okay. Do you like October’s box better?

[@aleishabudgetbeauty]

At least they have something theme wise that makes sense like pumpkins

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Yea I like the theme, just thought it was fitting for October and they presented the spoilers so confusing. We were all lost lol

[@aleishabudgetbeauty]

Robot guy 😂😂😂

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Ha ha, the perfume girl here is probably not pleased with my references 😜😂

[@aleishabudgetbeauty]

Shout out to Andre! Needs to be a tshirt 😂

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Ha ha! That’d be great! He’ll become a meme! 😂

[@TenajNikki]

That does sound like a wonderful box 😅

[@SherSharesBeauty]

I thought it was fantastic! :)

[@GhosstRyder]

The box is really good this month. I am considering buying it.

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Yes it was so good right? Now that we know what’s probably for October, those are looking good too:)

[@diciehamrick2359]

How much is Macy's box?

[@SherSharesBeauty]

@@diciehamrick2359 it’s $15 per month:)

[@amymiller5860]

Did anyone get a full size primer? Wonder if the full size was just for PR. But i tried the primer today with the mascara we got a few months ago and I'm impressed and i usually dislike anything that isn't thrive and lancome. That helps with my meh feeling. I'm sure my daughter in law will like the perfume so that makes it okay 👍

[@SherSharesBeauty]

This box actually isn’t PR. I pay for this one with my own money, so unless my new friend Andre at Macy’s hooked me up, it was random as a customer item lol. 😂 So odd. I wonder why too. Wonder if they ran out out of samples and gave others full size instead? 🤔

[@HonesTeaBeauTea]

So you were correct about the Macys beauty box. I ordered FOR the Kylie!! They confirmed Id get the Kylie via phone. It literally said on their site if I ordered by Aug 15th id get it. But at checkout it said my 1st box would be Sept. They told me the Kylie box was Sept! I knew my daughter would like it. I had a bad feeling and called to confirm. They were not correct. You have every reason to be confused. It lit said it on their site... I have a screenshot! Im so sorry if I confused you at all. It was my first time getting the box. Thankfully my daughter loves travel perfumes to try high end ones. I am very happy with the bag, the elemis & the mac lash primer. The eye mask is cool too. Well worth the money in my opinion & ill share it with my daughter ♡ uhm my mac lash primer is travel size!!!!! My son has the full size robot calogne from when I had GQ box and had access to buy a mens scent box. I was all over it. He loves it. I love the packaging. My first macys, im very happy with it. Im glad I signed up.

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Oh no! Well I’m really glad you loved the box! I thought it was a great box too but just sorry that you didn’t get the Kylie when that is what you signed up for. It was definitely so confusing. I think Macy’s did not have their act together at all lol. And even the fact that some folks got the full size lash primer and others didn’t. But it was such a good box that I’m not complaining too much lol

[@susankhouri9590]

Looking forward to next month; this one was a “meh” for me. Not much bang for the buck

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Aw it’s interesting to hear everyone’s take on it. Glad you are linking October’s prospects better:)

[@michelezeigler6167]

I was disappointed with this box.

[@SherSharesBeauty]

It’s interesting to hear everyone’s take on it. It really is about what you’re into. Hope you like October’s better:)