Music Producer Vs. AI Beatmaker: Can you hear the difference?

Get ready for the ultimate sonic showdown in "Music Producer vs AI: Can You Hear the Difference?" 🎵🤖 Join us on a musical rollercoaster where a talented producer battles it out with the futuristic beats of AI. Will your ears be able to spot the human touch, or will AI's musical magic leave you guessing? Tune in for laughs, surprises, and a whole lot of toe-tapping! 🕺💃 Don't miss out - it's time to find out if your groove radar can outsmart the machines!
Shoutout to Shadow Emblem for helping out. Stay tuned for his upcoming music!
Shoutout to the reactors:
/ jaylongo_
/ aftahill
/ llusionmusic
/ luvandreas
/ prod.by.iiinfinite
GET MY BEAT MAKING COURSE: www.prolevelbeats.com/special...
Samples and kits for purchase here: www.simonservida.com
Use this code to sign up to Distrokid with 7% OFF!
distrokid.com/vip/servida
Use code "SERVIDA" to get 10% off DRIP!
dripplugin.com/
USE CODE "servida" to get 10% off a shortcut mousepad!
www.insideaudio.net/en/websho...
Disclosure: There are some affiliate links above and I may receive commissions for purchases made through links in this post, but these are all products I highly recommend. I won't put anything on this page that I haven't verified and/or personally used.
FOLLOW ME ON SPOTIFY!!
open.spotify.com/artist/49K0C...
FOR COLLABORATIONS EMAIL ME AT
[e-mail]
Follow Me On:
Instagram: @simonservidaMusic
Twitter: @ServidaMusic
Second Channel: / @servidastream8250
Soundcloud: / simonservida
Discord: / discord
www.simonservida.com
Go follow my editors @mira.wav @mdosik
#flstudio #beatmaking #Musicproducer

[@LLusion]

idk why i was so serious listening to all these 😂 didn’t want to hate on someone by accident lol everyone had so much fun with this tho this was dope. appreciate you Simon!

[@shadowemblem.]

I'm glad that you took it seriously. Otherwise how would guess which was mine and what was the ai's?

[@prodbynoizey]

it isnt hating if it’s just bad. people should realise this. It’s just stating facts/(constructive) criticism. Not hating. Hating would be if you didn’t like the beat because it was made by someone you don’t like.

[@shadowemblem.]

@@prodbynoizey well said.

[@goofyahhshark6969]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/sHTPmmOjhdp2b7c banger

[@k6i771]

pop A soundin like a tutorial video 💀

[@shadowemblem.]

I'm just glad I could do better than it.

[@kashcot]

man what are yall talkin about bro

[@nothingtoseehere309]

I can already hear the Indian guy telling me how to fix my phone 💀

[@DrFumiya]

When pop ain’t popping 💀

[@chroniamusic]

@@nothingtoseehere309 LMAO

[@supremeskunk]

Respect on the beginners mentality

[@shadowemblem.]

Thanks man.

[@CivilianApplications]

He doesn't realize that he has no chance for a commercial career anymore. Hope dies last. Nice hobby, ok, but you will only get a tiny fraction of the jobs from in the niche market of people how want to pay a premium for handmade music - by a beginning producer with mediocre quality at best.

[@actuallymarcos8606]

@@CivilianApplications bs

[@actuallymarcos8606]

Big respect to the beginner! Music is not just "math" a computer can't have feelings like humans, it will never be the same as an human. An AI can never do something like Kanye West has done for music.

[@shadowemblem.]

@@actuallymarcos8606 Thanks man. But he does bring up valid points. My relatives say the same thing so I'm use to it.

[@shadowemblem.]

Loved being apart of this video. Thank you to all the producers who guessed the beats.

[@ServidaMusic]

Thanks for participating!

[@officialgymbo]

ur gonna make it one day trust

[@shadowemblem.]

@@officialgymbo thanks man

[@olgasyulyukov6470]

Good job! You are going to go far.

[@shadowemblem.]

@@olgasyulyukov6470 I appreciate it.

[@ProdbyIIInfinite]

Dude this video is incredible, thank you for having me on bro!

[@shadowemblem.]

Thank you for guessing which where mine.

[@the_blind_hearing6]

Love your work bro. I was pleasantly surprised to see you feature in this

[@ProdbyIIInfinite]

@@shadowemblem.what’s your instagram?

[@ProdbyIIInfinite]

@@the_blind_hearing6thank you!

[@danieljohn4014]

Lowkey that little speech at the end was needed bc of AI anxiety

[@shadowemblem.]

Thanks man.

[@danieljohn4014]

@@shadowemblem. why are you thanking me thank simon 😂

[@shadowemblem.]

@@danieljohn4014 I was part of it. Kinda of

[@frostmadethis]

the fact that trap c was ai is genuinely INSANE 😭

[@karlord3274]

fr bro i was 100 percent sure that was simon

[@madebyjo_l]

@@karlord3274nah I knew A was simon cause it just sounds like him but I thought the beginner was just yknow.. a beginner whose main focus is trap that’s why the other genres weren‘t that great

[@aquabuffet]

@@madebyjo_l yerp u can tell immediately by the sound choice that it's simon

[@MylesSquared]

that melody went hard af 😂

[@CurtisGabrielMusic]

To be fair, Trap isn't exactly rocket science 😂 Once you get the right drum sounds and an distorted 808, figure out that its the same rhythms that are pretty much the same in most tracks then its pretty much done! AI can get to that stage quicker than a novice.

[@olgasyulyukov6470]

The beginner producer is my son, I am so proud of him.

[@alr2157]

👍

[@shadowemblem.]

Mom.😂 oh my lord.

[@virulan5714]

He's got a good head on his shoulders. I may be in the minority but I actually really liked what he made. He's got a great start and I think he'll make something great if he keeps at it

[@shadowemblem.]

@@virulan5714 Thank you

[@cescimes]

​@@shadowemblem. i agree with virulan, i actually liked the direction you were trying to take the rnb one, the lead melody i guess could be spaced out a bit; also dont be afraid to eq the heck out of everything haha, just basically carve out frequency niches for different sounds

[@LuvAndreas]

I’m just happy to see my dog making an appearance in the video😌😂… thank you for having me, this was dope!

[@shadowemblem.]

Thanks for guessing. Love your dog by the way.

[@joebob007]

10:47 was beautifully said. Keep going man you have a great mentality

[@shadowemblem.]

Thanks man.

[@thezanke]

Bro, that sound at 10:23 was uncalled for... Had me alt+tabbin' so fast.

[@YABSGlobel]

I feel like an order for AI to take over is if people stop engaging with other people in studios,just in the studio having fun and joking around while making a good beat is what brings us together, I don’t see ai doing that in the future🤷🏾‍♂️ but money talks so

[@Reeceline]

I really like that you didn't skirt the issue in this video. How honest your question was with the beginner producer too. He has a great mindset about it. One aspect that wasn't covered here is that humans will always have one edge over AI and that is experimentation. Ai will always be limited to trends at its core, whereas humans will always have personal expression and experimentation in the mix. Great video 👏

[@DizzySantino]

"ey, how you doing? It's Drizzy Drake. Y'all seen my video the other day?" 💀🤣🤣🤣

[@Nicenigel14]

I love the beginner's takeaway at the end. Keep it up my man 🔥🔥🔥

[@shadowemblem.]

Thank you

[@SamFocused]

The Drake at the beginning 😂😂😂 Love the honest Conversation at the End!!! Great Video and Good Job Judges 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

[@shadowemblem.]

Thanks man

[@tomschroder7182]

Your video are so crazy good, i‘ve been watching all of your videos since i began producing in 2019 and you and Kyle just made my journey as beat maker and producer ever since. Thank you for that.

[@27thdimensionmusic]

“Drawing apples is my passion” B a n a n a

[@ServidaMusic]

I’m working on it

[@27thdimensionmusic]

@@ServidaMusic I believe in you

[@shadowemblem.]

At least it looked good.

[@27thdimensionmusic]

@@shadowemblem. good point 😂

[@nikobellic7462]

@@ServidaMusic that joke was A+

[@C.J.F.H]

I need that R&B B to be uploaded as a full beat right now

[@guilhermechristiano8335]

Your way to compose and make beats inspired me to find my way and how i should like to sound, today imma beatmaker hows produces for a couple artists in my block, and also a rapper. Your channel always was like my classroom to this digital art kinda thing. You are awsome Simon, i hope u know your content is essencial for the comuunity, thanks alot.

[@sdottwal]

R&B B I need it on Spotify

[@SoundRelaxus]

Brother !! In my opinion. You should never stop creating music. Your Dedication and Passion are something AI can never understand or match. Keep doing what you do. So I and others. Can keep being a fan. God Bless You My Brother !! Your Friend: Patrick Ginn

[@Ritorikal]

Definitely interesting to see how everything is progressing. My stance has been that AI can continue to do whatever it's doing, I'm gonna continue to do whatever I'm doing, and the consumer will continue to enjoy whatever they enjoy. At the end of the day, if ya fecks with me, ya fecks with me!

[@amenetaka2419]

Real

[@tainguyen-bp3if]

Aint gonnna be like that in the future tho,we might fucked

[@MilayaAfroLofi]

That was fun to watch. Was quite tricky to identify the AI songs 😅.

[@kemmii]

i loved this video! great concept; and that r&b beat was nastyyy 🔥

[@kemmii]

“TRAP A” TOO 🔥

[@sagiyosefisking]

Final message was all I needed ❤

[@thomass9457]

As AIs essentially stitch together fragments of existing works to create "original" beats, images, stories and other creations one might say that it engages in a form of digital alchemy that transforms the raw materials of human creativity into something new. This process, raises critical questions which demand to be answered especially whether or not artists have the right to receive fair compensation for those tracks which could never have been generated had their worke not contributed to the AI's training, however indirectly. I posit that a model must be instituted enforce fair use where AI is concerned in order to ensure that where every AI-generated piece, whether a sound, track, or image, incurs a fractional cost to be deposited into a fund dedicated to distributing earnings to artists wherever they may be deserved, acknowledging their indirect contribution to the creation process, financially and however else otherwise. There also exists other alternative solutions one of which ammounts to the obfuscation of ones works from the prying, unwelcome eyes of AI. Visual artists are already pioneering technologies such as these to shield their works from crawlers used to feed AI models which distorts images in such a way that confuses machine learning algorithms and renders the works protected by this technology as unusable noise. This technique suggests that there exists a possible solution for other mediums, one which promises to safeguard one's intellectual property artistic and otherwise across all mediums from unauthorized AI consumption. The challenge then remains to craft a mechanism-either through collective action or regulatory intervention-that will ensure artists are credited and compensated for their work's role in training AI.

[@djdeadly246]

well said. Fully agreed 💯

[@DamonHodgesOfficialPagePlus]

This was dope!! keep them coming the world is watching and understanding.. fire

[@PVPnb]

Yo, i know that beginner! he was a friend in my band, good to see him do more music! also, dont stop front flipping, that was awesome when you did it, Daniel!

[@shadowemblem.]

It was front flipping.

[@PVPnb]

@@shadowemblem. Lmao that's right, mb, I still have the video haha

[@widepeepohappy1969]

no beginner should ever be ashamed of being ranked lower than an AI, especially if they're, as stated, a beginner. of course AI is gonna be better, it has so much to go off of because they're an AI.

[@shadowemblem.]

Thanks man I appreciate the support as the beginner.

[@prodbynasir]

Bro showed and said apple and drew a banana.

[@danieljohn4014]

LITERALLY AHAHAHAAHAHA

[@eventuelleon748]

i laughed so hard at his lmaooo

[@Flairis]

youtube emoji going brazy

[@nenadilic381]

Hello everyone, I've watched a couple of videos now and I really like the content!! Also I have to mention I really like the approach and all the things you cover. It is really amazing how thorough you interact with others while analyzing their experience and feelings.

[@jamilanwary5793]

Big Up to Shadow Emblem! What you said was beautiful.

[@JAKSN-youtube]

Always with the amazing videos. This is a subject I know can be difficult to understand but I feel you did a great job

[@rene7211]

The fact that you used the Pop Ai Beat as background music

[@GilgameschUruk]

That‘s exactly what it‘s good for😂

[@CivilianApplications]

@@GilgameschUruk Good enuf is the exact problem. Yeah, clients will pay a premium of premium stuff. That's about 2 ot 5% of the market. The rest is in "good enough", especially if you thing about the costs, and how easy it is to generate another. Another. Another in seconds until it fits. Like klicking random outfit button for you character until random is nice enough.

[@cadenmcclure1520]

Superb quality video. Keep it going Simon!

[@cpoxkaizer3651]

I was waiting for this video long time

[@obertinsky]

unseen video with various location in ongoing time flow. awesome video edition and everything included. Tha!

[@gimoon0125]

Ice cream truck type beat💀💀💀💀

[@Darko1.0]

Bruh that R&B B beat is ridiculousss, I need to hear the full thing.

[@wealthmaterialized]

Thanks for doing this!

[@amandanoir.]

I love the message in the end of the video, as a beginner music producer it's really concerning that I spend this much time and money to do something AI do so easily, so I got emotional with that message :)

[@polardaking]

I love how you can just tell Simon's beat apart 😅

[@16studios27]

I love how I saw a banana even though I was expecting an apple

[@cavindsouza14]

man came with sickest drip of the decade in his service lets gooo!!!

[@prodnaki]

yeah simon, keep moving those knobs beatboy😫😈

[@juliekovich-recordingartist]

This was so cool to do!

[@octaneuro]

havent watched the video yet, but the best way to make sure your not replaced, is to make music so good and different, that no one can recreate it even if they try. im trying to learn to do this ever since i learnt about this AI stuff. and if your reading this, you should learn aswell ofcourse, this really applies best if you're an artist, and not a producer.

[@iamkelz6047]

That outro always gets me 😂😂

[@mrjustingreen1]

Simon, I've been watching your videos for a long while now. I'm STUCK with FL Studio Mobile so I beg of you, please sir, I am but a humble and poor beat curator whom only has his phone to make music. Seeing videos using the mobile app makes me feel like I still have hope. What you make in an hour I haven't even come close to yet. I used to have FL Studio 11 a looooonnnngggg time ago and my laptop broke so I stopped. Bought it on my phone several years ago but just this week I opened it back up and making the attempt to get back into it. I want to see how nice I can make something into by exclusively using my phone for EVERYTHING. Love your videos too, thank you for all the encouraging and helpful insight! (I wrote all that, A.I. didnt) 🤜🤛

[@tomschlaiss5735]

Interesting video and concept, cheers from Germany

[@Maesdy01]

You deserve million subscribe.i've been following you for years

[@prodjoshhh]

It’s a good day when Simon uploads

[@drehsaxysmusic9940]

God bless you for your last statement... Creating music is all about what and how you feel (mood) and that makes the difference mehn. Music is an ART!

[@jusmi3724]

I actually got all of them correct lol, very cool concept 👍 trap A goes crazy

[@johnheroprestillo]

this is not just a video, this is a effin research that i can use for academic purposes

[@artpinsof5836]

The KZbinr gives it away with his glitch signature, and all three of his beats

[@ProdByOblivion]

Huge respect for the beginner bro. Like he said in the video, it's nothing to be ashamed of. You can almost think of the AI's level of making beats as its experience. It took the AI millions of songs to create that garbage POP A and it only took you this long to make POP B, that's a huge difference. The human element still matters a ton, even if the AI is technically better it's only because it's "Heard" more songs, it can't make anything with feeling or passion

[@bechari1709]

Pop A lives rent free in my head😂

[@idealyrafidinarivo]

R&B B was dope af 🙌🙌

[@PaschalNere]

What program do you suggest I should use to make beats?

[@iWoodbeatZ]

cant lie i love how you said you love drawing apples and drew a banana lol, great video sir

[@foxkab3616]

i knew your style your sound selection so it was easy to me

[@koalamusik]

Love that drawing of an apple

[@idk-how_to_name-myself]

The beginner is so confident im jealous

[@shadowemblem.]

Thank you, I kind of made the beats kind of bad to make it harder for the producers to guess who was who.

[@miyoturcovic7804]

This video is very inspirational and more of a heads up.

[@TaekLuutzen]

The name Shadow Emblem is fya

[@shadowemblem.]

Thanks man

[@rhniqb]

need full session of rnb b🔥🔥

[@1dealace]

The drums go soft...but in a good way😂😂

[@orlock20]

AI can generate lyrics, sing, generate instrumentation and then a human-AI program can refine it. That can steal a lot of work. For instance, the "film" industry could use AI generated music for scenes while commercials and video game music can be completely AI generated.

[@DJURBANBG]

making music is about having fun, it was and it always have to be. Problem occurs when you start to look too serious on producing music, especially for money

[@michael-johnnoviski849]

perfect timing simon i just got salmonella this morning and was looking for some beat videos to watch

[@davesisti7083]

Using the AI's medicine commercial beat for the beginner's feel-good speech is vile

[@erickauthenticmusic]

Now we know drawing Apples is Simon 's passion & what he was born to do 🤣 @11:27

[@karlord3274]

bro i was so sure that trap c was simon. i was so shocked to find out it was ai

[@prod.bydocnificent]

11:36 yeah we're f@*k*d 😂😂😂

[@rickdickullis4486]

I want R&B B. So smooth 🫠

[@ekuniverse1]

Bro you should've used SoundRaw AI those beats are absolutely fire.

[@ty.sakimusic]

What's crazy is... we're watching AI learn how to make music like a "brand new producer" learn how to make music in real time. We clowning today, but in a short amount of time we're going to be saying "Oh shit, this thing is fire"

[@parkermogensen642]

Bro W amazing vids keep it up

[@valanci.official]

glad i found your yt again

[@ayimadomi]

I (we) need that RnB B That's crazyyyy

[@BobTheMisu]

Simon servida's beats are standing out so much you just know its his

[@itsJustJayMusic]

I honestly could pick the RnB and Pop Simon Beats, but the trap was confusing to me, I couldn't pick which belonged to whom.

[@UZ-Said]

5:23 Someone help me please find this RnB Chords what packaging is this in? 🙏🙏🙏

[@Vin_Dre]

Whoah..things just got reeeeeaaaal interesting

[@TheRussianGenius]

shout out to aftahill, love the artist!

[@lukayz1363]

we need a video on RnB B

[@LazaMan101]

These are my guesses as im watching Pop A was AI ✅ Pop B was Noobie Producer ✅ Pop C was Servida ✅ R&B A was Noobie ❌ R&B B was Servida ✅ R&B C was AI ❌ Trap A was Servida ✅ Trap B was Noobie ✅ Trap C was AI ✅ AI music has very little in terms of creative direction. Weird things that you'd hear someone like FLYLO do would only be an accident if AI were to do it. Thats part of why I got R&B wrong, that initial knock was pretty interesting, and it made me feel like it was an organic choice by a human. I could tell which one was the expert reliably. The noobie didnt know what he was doing at all for the R&B, no disrespect, but thats what made me feel like it was AI. I didnt particularly like the noobies tracks, nor the AI. I could get down with the tracks made by Servida. So what I take away, a good producer won't be easily beaten by AI. But noobies will have a difficult time competing with the soon to come hordes of AI producers. I can only hope that DJ's dont start performing live sets with AI music.

[@cavindsouza14]

bro's flexing his points at this point😂😂😂😂

[@TURBOMIKEIFY]

Bruh! How did I bob my head at 145BPM before I even heard it!? 😮

[@ninjabeano3190]

Simon please show how you made Pop C, I want to make something like this

[@limes_I]

Can you upload snippers of all the bests in high quality so we can listen to them ourselfs?

[@eyeview3765]

Trap A...Trap B and Trap C...its like giving a tour of hoods in Chicago 😂

[@ProdGingey]

is there a link for ur discord. the one in the description doesnt work

[@ajaennix]

A fuckin Masterpiece yo Much Love OG !!!!!!!!

[@krabzlezinto]

new challenge: simon draws an apple using a mouse in photoshop

[@zenrichmond0126]

Ice cream truck type beat fr! 🔥

[@shadowemblem.]

Thank you, its my favorite out of the 3.

[@parkermogensen642]

I find it funny how I could instantly know whose was whose lol

[@CcokeS]

SIMON!!!!! I NEEEED you to teach us how to do Brazilian PHONK!

[@MrDrummerboi999]

*pop A plays* “ask your doctor about adalimumab” 😭😭