Philosopher Shocked by Muslim Answers - M.Ali - Speaker's Corner

[@sadeekahsaban162]

This guy is not ignorant but very arrogant. May Allah soften his heart and guide him.

[@hnia0]

someone that laughs and don't understand basic concepts is both ignorant and arrogant. Bushanallah Ali has lots of patience

[@M.Moadeli123]

I didn't pick up on arrogance. He would've taken offence often but let stayed humble imo

[@IncognitoTrap]

If he’s a philosopher I’m a brain surgeon. The astronomical level of patience one has to have with such humans is mind boggling.

[@PegimampooS]

This guy is not ignorant at all. He clearly knows what's brother Ali was talking about. He just playing dumb because he can't argue with Ali's points. And obviously Ali know this too..

[@rio-diamante]

He played dumb, because he was... Ali realised this...

[@nihilist4184]

Ali is an expert on Muslim laws because he is avidly reading the Quran constantly but that doesn't make him an expert on life outside the quarans interpretation.

[@greenbananas12378]

@@nihilist4184 your name says enough…. Of course in order to argue for something, you need to know the opposition. He has studied “life outside the Quran’s interpretation” and so have many who revert to Islam.

[@nihilist4184]

@@greenbananas12378 so if you were window shopping other religions before that why on earth would you buy the one with pedophilia?

[@khazuki6795]

Yup.

[@viaiflahati6754]

MasyaAllah.. I pray that the child in my womb right now will have the same intelegent, knowledge beyond age, patient, and eloquent like you brother m.ali ameen 🤲🏻

[@2FreePalestineFreeYourself]

Ameen

[@hookahzone5600]

Ameen

[@ahmednasrulla4766]

Aameen. What a beautiful thing to say

[@monke6157]

Inshallah your child will be very handsome/beautiful, inshallah he will do good, and inshallah he will make others' smile like Muhammad ali. Ameen

[@ahmedhussain496]

Ameen

[@akays1991]

He claimed that he is a philosopher, but what I see here seems like he is struggling to follow a philosophical talk. But for him to show the interest is still a good sign. May Allah guide him...

[@mikeyo116]

I think there is a language issue every now and then As well

[@tajolariffin6021]

i dont believe he's a philosopher..his level of thinking is like primary school student, not mocking, just stating the fact based on my observation..its either that, or he's just playing dumb

[@zokashi9887]

@@tajolariffin6021 yeah 😂. But i don't think hes first language English! He might be from Europe!

[@ronaldpraja9992]

he's also not being genuine, it's like hearing but not really hearing.

[@zokashi9887]

@@ronaldpraja9992 yeah i noticed that, and then Mohammed talking to him to give him point but that doesn't matter anymore when he is ignoring no matter what point you're making it won't do anything cuz he is in hes "philosophical thoughts"

[@antinonsense]

I love how this brother is so calm and calming to others.

[@AbdullahAlMamun-iv7er]

Knowledge makes you humble, Ignorance make you arrogant

[@KingWolfdz]

Yes, Masha'allah

[@didierleonard7125]

@@AbdullahAlMamun-iv7er Yeah… that why Islam boys are so arrogant …. Do you think any god, any intelligent Supra being , so potent entity need you to say : @ allah is the greatest « ? This is completely nonsense. Hat is the ridiculous of all religions. It s like me king of earth waiting for ants to shock their mandibles for me. Totally stupid. And if you think that is truth and wisdom , well, you really need to learn … maybe from true philosophers… I said philosophers, not what your not so called « scholars « . Because they are not even these…

[@gelarman]

his laugh is so comforting

[@saadaden7769]

@@AbdullahAlMamun-iv7er nice quote

[@nidaa3233]

He is so well spoken. I can listen him all day long. Brother Ali, congratulations.

[@salimsawandi9829]

i would liked if he asked him : the orange you have is eeating you or you are eating it? the answer would be gold xD

[@aliamouzasakaluran5399]

I'm just ordinary person, with little knowledge, but watching this philosopher it makes me realize I'm more logical and intelligent! 🤣🤣🤣

[@dom879]

It's really no laughing matter, knowledge belongs to Allah. The difference in knowledge between you and him, is by permission of Allah swt. Not by your own doing, or his.

[@aliamouzasakaluran5399]

@@dom879 I'm not talking about me and Allah subhanahu wataala, I'm talking about me and the philosopher.

[@dom879]

@@aliamouzasakaluran5399 yes, read my comment again. The difference between you and him (the philosopher), is by permission of Allah swt...

[@aliamouzasakaluran5399]

@@dom879 yes and that's why I laugh about it its because I'm not seriously says I'm intelligent....

[@nooamystery2470]

​@@aliamouzasakaluran5399 you have 'Aql عقل', something more then being smart and intelligent.

[@alsalman007tube]

I want to have the intellect and communication skills of Mohammed Ali.. May Allah bless us all with such skill sets

[@omarmuhammed5960]

Brother, It's not about intelligence, it's because Allah gave us the absolute only truth and there is no one can compete against the real truth all you need to do is learning what Allah taught us and seeking help from him

[@SOLOQ_withAPE]

my aunt just revert just now she's from cali masyaallah

[@justiceglenn3869]

Mashallah brother may Allah bless your aunt and grant her happiness in both the dunya and the afterlife ❤️

[@nislam16]

Alhamdu Lillah wish her all the best

[@bahriboy]

Mashallah

[@abdalmalk_kasem]

الله اكبر

[@juanortiz-zq8ot]

I enjoy and can't get enough of brother Ali videos. Thanks for sharing 👍

[@randomness8819]

brother juan are there any tips you can give when making dawah with my latino and hispanic brothers in humanity? what things you recommend to focus on?

[@hoomanAdnan]

Same here

[@spag5296]

@@randomness8819 You can take inspiration from your favourite dawah speakers. Break down their attributes and ways of teaching into small parts, and study it so you can implement them in your dawah teachings. For example, Mohammed Ali has a very calming approach to dawah. He does not shout, he is humble, he makes the conversation humorous, and he is very knowledgeable and delivers his words in a way that is easy to understand. Now you can try to implement these for yourself when you are spreading dawah, keeping mindful of them, and slowly you will have these attributes yourself

[@shhaba6519]

One of the best speakers to ever speak at speakers corner. Amazingly knowledge on a wide range of subjects especially religion. He has more knowledge on the bible and the teachings of Jesus than the Christian preachers at speakers corner including Bob and hatun the Christian hate preachers...

[@esahg5421]

maasha Allah that young man giving dawah Allah elevate him according to your will inshaAllah

[@AbdullahAlMamun-iv7er]

Brother Mohammed is soothing

[@housse51]

The Messenger of Allah salallahualayhi wasallam received the Qur'an starting from 40 years of age.. just the mere fact that He taught and recited and at the same time memorized the entire Qur'aan is already a miracle.

[@aimanbabahmed7449]

@@AA123TD i believe angel jibriel would come each ramadan and check on the prohpets pbuh recitation of the quran

[@salvatorezagra864]

How is it a miracle when there are so many things proven to be false in it? Is it a miracle that it has fooled so many stupid people? That may be the only miracle

[@aimanbabahmed7449]

@@salvatorezagra864 like what? Name one thing?

[@salvatorezagra864]

@@aimanbabahmed7449 you want to start with the quran's idea of the trinity? Or how about the idea the quran mentions 3 daughters of allah who are in Surah 53 and are pagan idols. Or Uncle Mo splitting the moon in 1/2....or having a flying horse with the head of a man with rainbow wings? Or claiming Jesus Christ spoke as an infant or Jesus Christ wasn't crucified, or water shot out of Uncle Mo's fingers or just blew into clay pigeons which came alive....or Jesus turned water in milk...of the god of islam is the Jew/Christian God...or Mohammed was mentioned in the Bible as anything but a false prophet A SATAN...need more?

[@salvatorezagra864]

@@aimanbabahmed7449 there is no Jibrel...only Gabriel

[@julianrogers8608]

Muhammad ali is the best at speakers corner so respectful and humble some others have to big of an ego and try to belittle instead of teach

[@mikunat2012]

This „philosopher“ just doesn‘t want to believe. He understands the arguments and by his facial expressions you can see that he knows that those are very good arguments but he‘s just too ignorant to acknowledge it. Sad..

[@esahg5421]

lol that is the look of a white man defeated. he will be back

[@Sami-bs1go]

The ego brother

[@AntonioRodrigues-cc2fw]

Pussislam.

[@PoesieIslamique]

wAllahi its sad that you can see he's choosing to follow his ego

[@IFootballSkiller]

His ego

[@ich9499]

He wants to disagree with everything for no reason....

[@TheFaro2011]

The hearts are blind. Not the eyes

[@proboxer8916]

Just wasting time

[@nghaider]

The level of Intelligence is evident. Our Brother Muhammad is well grounded and meticulous in applying knowledge.

[@zurinaismail8001]

I like how he is humble enough to say he doesnt know when he doesnt know..on almost everything. Mohammad's patience is beyond measure ... Like a father talking to his 5 yo child.

[@spiritzen]

The immense patience you need with someone who thinks they’re clever but reveal their shallow world view and lack of logic with every sentence. I would have walked away lol.

[@ocearbhaill3894]

I assume you’re referring to the guy on the right who can’t understand a basic point..

[@bulidrians2182]

@@ocearbhaill3894 🐍

[@ocearbhaill3894]

@@bulidrians2182 what?

[@omara1055]

@@ocearbhaill3894 your assumptions are incorrect. Of course 🤦‍♂️

[@ocearbhaill3894]

@@omara1055 Assumptions? Name one…

[@ahmadzubairazimi9599]

Calling this man a Philosopher is a slap on the face of philosophers.

[@warakanda7356]

SubhanAllah Alhamdulillah Walailahaillallah Huwallahuakhbar May Allah SWT guide those who reverted to Islam, to the true teaching of Islam and being an obedient Muslim, will grant them and all the Ummah with a place in Jannah. Aamiin🌙🕌🤲💕

[@papcheikhou]

Quran is for those aware of their intelligence and willing to use it…

[@mahaadel633]

Thanks a lot Watching these debates , made me appreciate more growing up as a Muslim ,,,, an extra blessing from Allah , u were avoided the hassle of questioning the religion u were born into ( if u ever would) , and deciding the right path , also , being an Egyptian speaking Arabic of course , i don't have a problem understanding the essential teachings and practice of Islam. In short as an Arab , i figure we have a smooth ride going through what Allah decreed , and reasoning with each phase as we grow up 😊 May Allah bless us and guides us all ❤

[@Gio23.]

الله يعافينا ، الحمدلله على نعمه الإسلام

[@muhammadtabish1821]

MUHAMMAD ALI is superb

[@shaiderayaz3988]

Salaam Muhammed may Allah keep u happy always and give u more knowledge which u can give people,as their lifestyle will be better by having Allah closer to their broken hearts like mine.I love watching u and hearing yor words.Take care Khudahafiz.

[@thecatch4648]

I like how he challenges without having a counterargument 😅

[@TL-el2bt]

I praise your patience with people who are trying so hard not to think logically or even to acknowledge basic information, seriously, with some people they will always stay blind to the truth, May Allah Tallah give them hidayat.

[@RashidpakAlb2]

He is a philosopher without knowledge. JazakAllah khair brother Ali

[@beast-master2094]

May Allah guide him and us, ameen

[@laraib827]

MashaAllah TabarakAllah SubhanaAllah Br Muhammed Ali your Dawah is so unique. Alhamdulillah your doing awesome works. May ALLAH SWT Bless you Abundantly brother. Aameen Another excellent video, JazakAllah khairun Brother...

[@Sami-bs1go]

The truth is the truth whatever you accept it or no , but if you don’t accept it go and look for you self .

[@mahmoodhuda8411]

I see two gentlemen having a cheerful conversation. May Allah guide him

[@AliKhan-yx1dy]

May Allah guide him Ameen May Allah guide us all Ameen

[@nosxtreme03]

If someone recorded me having a logical argument with my wife, it would look like this. :-)

[@AbdullahAlMamun-iv7er]

Lol brother 🤣🤣🤣. I know

[@hayatm8351]

Epic

[@mohammadalaminkhalifa1510]

Brah 😂😂😂

[@Dr.SarraOk00]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@ubuntuafrique5802]

😂😂

[@amiiina8769]

I would say that we muslims, shoked by this philosopher 😃

[@shhaba6519]

So much compelling evidence to prove Islam is true religion for all of us and Allah is the true one and only creator of everything and prophet Muhammad is the last messenger. All the evidence talked about is is enough for someone seeking the truth and ready to worship his creator... anyone seeking the truth who is willing to learn and study Islam who has a clean heart and free from misconceptions will revert to Islam because its the truth and there is enough truth for one to accept Islam

[@srnp0007]

So much compelling evidence to prove Islam is true religion for all ......." Please share Those Evidences With Me

[@zaidhussain9123]

​@@srnp0007did you watch the video?

[@srnp0007]

@@zaidhussain9123 :- No I Don't Watch Videos . I Am Always Interested To Have Dialog Discussion With Muslims . I Try To Help Them To See The Truth .

[@hellobaby6661]

Such healthy faith based debates should be promoted in all cosmopolitan cities. Doing so, people can better understand each others faith and then make an informed decision whether they are on the straight path or they have recourse to correct themselves.

[@abdulrechima8904]

Muslim - It’s obligatory to give 2.5% of your wealth as zakat if your rich. Philosopher - Why not 3.5% percent Wallahi he killed me man 😂😂😂😂

[@kinetic3971]

Hilarious

[@everseeking60]

I like this guy....he is genuinely interested and really listening. May he be guided. Amazing dawah❤

[@samaiyagiryan1789]

Good job brother Ali. May Allah reward you!

[@Imhameed92]

Even as he hesitantly agrees with the points because he’s cornered, he’s saying it arrogantly. Subhanallah.

[@budakamerika]

He is so dense…. 🤦🏻‍♀️ respect to MoAli for that amazing patience 🫡

[@moustache2842]

Thense

[@TheBurnttea]

Brother Muhammad's patience is REALLY beyond me! May Allah bless him greatly. Ameen. "They have hearts with which they do not understand, they have eyes with which they do not see, and they have ears with which they do not hear. Those are like livestock; rather, they are more astray. It is they who are the heedless.".

[@Hussain-zu1gl]

I would love to have brother m. Ali as my teacher! What a good spoken man

[@noviabdi2095]

this brother needs history lesson, brother ali, hehehe---may Allah always with us

[@asadjahmed]

@@jettyharrison4377 it took you 300 years to figure out what your history is. Wake up. You can't even explain the fundamentals of your faith.

[@erfaanisaacs2699]

@@jettyharrison4377 Bart Ehrman became an atheist and has left Christianity because he didn't believe Jesus was God. Bart Ehrman himself exposes all the contradictions in the Bible as well as in the manuscripts. Btw, where did you get 6800 years from? Jesus only walked the earth about 2022 years ago. Are you a new breed of Christians?

[@juliaabusaad1861]

Amazing Dawah💞

[@iennot]

"So which of the favours of your Lord would you deny?"

[@slaveofthealmighty]

The problem with this guy is he wants more. He wants the Quran to have every single information in it in order to fit the narrative that everybody should be perfect, peace etc. He gave the ruling of zakat and immediately said ‘why not 3.5%’… it’s not use, my patience would have run thin ages ago

[@Luna-on2sx]

Even if it did, he'd still find something to not fit his narrative cause that's how people react when they see the truth & its already too late for them. I honestly feel bad for the guy.

[@slaveofthealmighty]

@@Luna-on2sx what are you talking about?

[@katiaarmy4336]

Well he said he can Do his work without contradiction but I don't think I heard of his name means he's not a big deal and even he compares himself to god that is embarrassing I mean how he even get to be a philosopher with such a low sence of logic.

[@intihayati]

this form of arguments belong to the hipocrites only

[@wasifhasani1087]

Excellent discussion by brother Ali

[@amortalbeing]

Masha Allah, I have a suggestion, it'd be great if you also share what you are showing the people there so we all get to have those stats as well

[@grandemarguerite9502]

The only thing more dangerous than ignorance is arrogance.

[@adilsoomar1742]

Slms love watching you ... Continue the good work inshaAllah... Inspired Alhumdulilah

[@ahmedadawy1238]

May Allah bless you Mohammed for your effort

[@kemarin2237]

Indonesia was colonized by the Dutch who came with three missions: Gold, Glory and Gospel. And it last for 350 years. And no Muslim country invade and colonize Indonesia ever. Despite that, Indonesia is the largest Muslim majority (over 80% of the population) with hundreds millions Muslims. And even today, there are still many Church missionaries in many part of Indonesia doing their things with very little success. Indonesians are not Arabs, we are exposed to those Missionaries who always try to bribe us with "charities" like noodles, rice, etc but we simply choose Islam is the right way. But recently there are new movement from the munafikun who try to pitting Muslims here. Those liberals who infiltrate Islam and for now successfully control one of Islamic organization (Nahdlatul Ulama) supported by the corrupted current liberal regime. But it only makes the Muslims here especially the young parents even become more closer to Islam. Just like what happened when the Dutch colonized us. Because Islam is the right way.

[@abdulrokib5583]

Please upload part 2 of rhis video. Masha-Allah interesting conversation.

[@truth-be-told]

Surprisingly many people who think they are smart actually when put to logical test..the curtain falls 🤔

[@hoomanAdnan]

Dead end 🤣

[@kinetic3971]

A lot of atheists mainly the ones that are obsessed with god and are combative are pseudo-intellectuals.

[@BabaGoku-j7e]

by ALLAH! these westerners make me feel that I am very smart.

[@2212funkyfresh]

Homie was speechless with conversation rate 😅

[@Fatoumamouddj]

Brother M.Ali you have more patience then I would.

[@WellnessGraphy]

💢KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK ALI 💢MAY ALLAH HELP AND BLESS YOU AND MAKE YOU BETTER EACH DAY 💢

[@moustache2842]

Macha Allah brother Mohamed Ali

[@nmkzf]

Islam does not seek quantity in number of muslims, but looks for v.high morale Quality of its followers.

[@TheFaro2011]

Both. Numbers and quality. Can't deny haqq due to quality

[@nmkzf]

@@TheFaro2011 Quran stresses Taqwa Ihsan and Eilm Fiqh Truth......Eyman . Quran condemn the majority and praises the few.

[@Leenaesraa99]

May Allah guide him...to not be arrogant

[@youcefbzgr6664]

When you see people like this, you understand why God chose Arabs for Islam

[@AbuMusaAlBurtughaalii]

I'd like to know the study the brother was looking at about conversion rates and where i can find it please. BarrakAllahu feekum

[@TheLegendaryLeader1]

watching these makes you realize how people shut off their brains and get defensive when they don't want to accept something, @ 30:00 he starts arguing about something as basic as contradictions

[@oliviermeurou3663]

Assalamu alaikum brother, Could you provide reference for the Hadith that talk about oil. I was not able to find it. Jzk

[@klaw1425]

Masha Allah

[@itsmeyamenah2804]

O Allah, send our salutations to our Prophet Muhammad to his companions martyrs pbuh....your mercy to mankind and jinnkind...O Prophet, you have done it..There is no worthy of praises and worship except Allah, Muhammad pbuh is his messenger

[@SubmittedtoAllah]

Quran also mentioned Sun and star moves. Which is recent discovered.

[@fedouamansouri3318]

Mohammed Ali's knowledge and argumentation skills are just amazing! That said, the title of this video is misleading: the guy wasn't shocked or even impressed. It is clear that he wasn't ready for this conversation or something. He had a clear resistance to what Ali had to say. I wish he was given more time to formulate his own ideas, so that Ali would build personalized counter-arguments, and the so-called "philosopher" would grow more receptive and engaged.

[@nadahindi2680]

This guy is so arrogant may Allah reward this brother for his patience

[@lesleybaker9625]

I believe that splitting off moon is most scientific ayat in the quran.

[@bluyetiinc7553]

This was observed as far away as in India. You can read it in their textx.

[@familyfun4341]

Mashallah amazing conversation

[@skgalaxy2]

He's intelligent but he is just arguing for the sake of arguing not wanting to admit or accept the truth. Mohammad is great and bringing him back to the point of the conversation. May allah guide him to the truth

[@adamburman2337]

اللهم وفقه وتقبله برحمتك يا ارحم الراحمين

[@younesel]

I wonder how long the actual conversation was, because of the sudden end. Looking back at the title, this man was as described. When he realised he couldn’t win the discussion, his attitude changed. I hope this conversation left him things to wonder about.

[@smcptrsa]

Im in South Africa 🇿🇦 and we have more Christians than Muslims but everyone here lives side by side, most people here have Muslims and Christians in their family.

[@kinetic3971]

Alhamdullilah!

[@killingabbdoos]

That's because christians are taught to love even their enemy, unlike the religion of the devil.

[@smcptrsa]

@@killingabbdoos and what religion is the religion of the devil?

[@fsheik1127]

@@killingabbdooslol you are very ignorant about Islam. We love and respect Jesus we know he is not God. Muslims live in peace and in parallel with everyone else.

[@fsheik1127]

@@killingabbdoosand we are also taught to respect the people of the book. Which are the jews and Christians so not sure what you talking about! Maybe learn more about us instead of believing everything you are told! Do your own research

[@Imhameed92]

Every time Muhammad proves the truth of the Quran he increases in arrogance and says it’s not a big deal. Then his body language starts to change from hand down to crossed arms because he’s pacifying himself and closing off.

[@thephantomterence9211]

I think there is a communication barrier - the philosopher doesn’t understand half the things he is hearing because English is not his first language

[@Shahidtalkstv]

Where is the next part please

[@humzdon4life]

Mohammed ali looking fresh with the trim

[@linaanisyabila4198]

From Indonesia support you chennel bro

[@pkasb90]

The dark ages nothing was coming from Europe.

[@pad8941]

Why you cut the video in the middle of the discussion? We can hear more about this conversation

[@L4AH4N1889]

Worshipping Allah taala in Arabic is عبادة which is derived from ﻋﺒﺪ i,e, paving and polishing as in paving the road and polish it so much so that it can be polished to a higher degree that it resemble a mirror which reflects the image of Allah taala Allah has created us upon i,e His attributes. Man can be merciful just like Allah taala is merciful and generous just like Allah is generous to a degree … etc. That is the philosophy of worshipping Allah taala عيادة الله تبارك وتعالى in a nutshell.

[@testing-je7yz]

I haven't watched all of yet, but the Quran does say that when the Prophets came to the people they said we follow what our four fathers followed. Likewise, every child is born upon truth but it's society that stirs them away from the right away.

[@jamilquintero2160]

Is there a part 2?

[@thrilled2bits]

For a philosopher, he's not a deep thinker, very superficial... Must be the language or the prejudice/bias mentality that is anchoring his thoughts...

[@canonogic]

He answers the poverty question, then gets asked "why not 3 and a half" these people aint serious

[@slimanipdr]

MA Allah bless you brother Mohammed.

[@saral9817]

my gran and her family and our area converted to islam through dawah, they wer catholic before

[@sazzadahmed2297]

Alhumdulliah. Assalmu-Alaikum wa Rahamtullahi wa Baraktuh

[@saral9817]

@@sazzadahmed2297 wa aliykum asalam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu

[@TheAmoun10]

This video had many ads ( inappropriate ones )

[@fatmaaldegham861]

ترجمة من فضلكم وجزاك الله خير

[@mawar_kasturi]

I mainly like to watch civil discussions about these topics.. I mistakenly thought that this guy would have a decent attitude. May Allah give you more patience brother.

[@yakiramiro]

does the video have part 2

[@niloferkhan5275]

Allah has certainly blessed bro.Ali with patience and knowledge.This so called philosopher is lacking brain power and I do not time that kind of patience to tolerate idiots