Shadow of the Erdtree - The REAL New Hardest Boss in Game Is... - DLC Difficulty Ranking Elden Ring!

1000s of deaths later which new boss is ACTUALLY the hardest? Enjoy!
Support us on Patreon: bit.ly/1FUac4S
Hunters Three Channel Shop: huntersthree.store/
Discord Community: / discord
Monster Hunter can wait for now as we delve into Elden Ring and its Elden Ring gameplay with this Elden Ring guide and Elden Ring tips tricks and Elden Ring location and Elden Ring bosses and Elden Ring location how to and Elden Ring best weapon Elden Ring dex int str arcane faith build Elden Ring best build Elden Ring update patch Elden Ring DLC Shadow of the Erdtree DLC Shadow of the Erdtree gameplay release date trailer bosses weapon boss Elden Ring Shadow of the Erdtree gameplay Miquella Messmer the impaler new bosses boss weapon incantation sorcery spell magic story lore Shadow of the Erdtree new weapon ash ashes of war Elden Ring Shadow of the Erdtree new weapon gameplay Shadow of the Erdtree Dueling Shields Throwing Blade Weapons Reverse-grip swords light greatswords perfume bottles beast claws heavy katana hand-to-hand hand to hand dryleaf arts all new weapon weapons Shadow of the Erdtree new player guide starter difficulty location best build Shadow of the Erdtree Best Weapon weapon build hardest boss bosses difficulty difficult dlc hard ranking ranked messmer radahn!
00:00 Intro
0:43 11th Hardest
1:34 10th Hardest
2:58 9th Hardest
3:49 8th Hardest
4:51 7th Hardest
5:49 6th Hardest
7:01 5th Hardest
8:07 4th Hardest
9:34 3rd Hardest
10:49 2nd Hardest
11:51 Hardest Boss
13:51 Final Thoughts
#eldenring #shadowoftheerdtree #shadowoftheerdtreebestboss #guide #shadowoftheerdtreehardestboss #bossranking #radahn #bestbuild #boss #bosses #shadowoftherdtreebestbuild #build #promisedconsortradahn
Subscribe (bit.ly/1hTCETC) for more gaming content and read the description to fulfil your dreams!
Incredible thumbnail art by Lighght: / llighght
For exclusives, fun times and general shenanigans follow me on:
Twitter: / ragegamingvideo
Facebook: / ragegamingvideos
More life changing links!
Steam Group: steamcommunity.com/groups/Rage...
Stream: / ragegamingvideos
Reddit: / ragegaming
Email: [e-mail]
T-Shirts: www.redbubble.com/people/rageg...
I'm Josh with Cotton and Hollow. We make funny things, we make useful things and we end up in many improbable situations. If you've got this far in the description you are an intrepid explorer of boxes and I approve you as a comrade in curiosity. So join me on this adventure as we make multitudes of majorly magnificent videos as we be excessively modest and have a good time! Thanks for watching and reading, give yourself a cookie.

[@DeathsInverse]

I don't want to admit how many times that scadutree avatar murdered me 😔

[@AkrabSouls]

Same lol, especially as a pure melee build

[@-thebatman-]

Blasphemous slays it

[@Dr_Acula_MD]

I buried it in its own fertilizer. Rest in doodoo you floral bastard 🌻

[@CXIIIPHER]

As a lvl 250 bleed melee build I absolutely died numerous times to that damn flower

[@petronetto]

He's very, veeeery week to fire, once you figure out that he's a walk in the park, if you hit him in the head (flower?!) you almost one-shot the phase one. Also, every every phase he opens for a critical, if you get the crit the next phase starts with less HP

[@dantecoal7584]

Putrescent Knight wasn't super difficult for me, but I think that's because I saw him, then saw his weapon, and went "Oh, that's Orphan of Kos with a horse" and fought him like I'd fight Orphan. Can 100% see why someone would think he's too difficult, or even a BS boss, seeing as he's got a lot in common with one of the other "hardest" FromSoft bosses ever made.

[@joshuawallen8112]

Good to know I am not the only one who reacted to seeing it with "Cos! Who convinced you to let your baby visit us again?!"

[@liam6550]

I haven't beaten bloodborne yet, but I found the putrescent knight quite fun once I realized his move where he separates from his horse had 2 thing to make it reasonable to dodge 1: when he spins, he moves forwards, so dodging under him means that he'll consistently whiff that attack 2: his horse always spawns visible to the camera and always follows his spin. What make is difficult to dodge is the fact that the knight is onscreen as well, making it difficult to change focus

[@MrUnrelevant]

Radahn’s 2nd phase is crazy

[@unhappycore4608]

I just got to it and I literally have never wondered “what the fk I’m supposed to do about this” so much before in my life

[@dylanostermiller4533]

Bayle and Gaius and Radahn were the absolute hardest bosses for me I died so many times fighting them. It’s always interesting and part of why I love Elden Ring and Dark Souls to see what bosses people had a hard time against personally I didn’t struggle against the Divine Beast or Renalla or the Knight of Putrescence but some people had really hard times with those ones and it’s cool that the game can go so differently for everyone.

[@zackfaircc5624]

i feel like gaius is probably very weapon dependant. I was using colossal swords and i literally just got on torrent and went in a mount v mount battle vs him and it was super easy, but I can see that fight being much harder if you dont have good reach for the fight.

[@rendereduseful1005]

Honorable mention: Ancient Dragon Senessax. He/She heard about what we did to Lanessax

[@rikisalim6438]

Scadutree avatar and bayle killed me a lot more than malenia ever was.

[@duncanalexander4241]

It sounds like you were rusty, same lol

[@grayhat_9x]

malenia killed me more times than all dlc bosses combined (except Radahn). Recency bias doing wonders

[@jevan1247]

@@grayhat_9x Not recency bias if it is the truth. Malenia was less difficult for me than Radahn, Bayle and Gaius.

[@TFTiago]

For me on a ng+4, no summon, melee build: 1. Promised Consort Radahn 2. Bayle the Dread 3. Rellana, Twin Moon Knight 4. Messmer the Impaler 5. Divine Beast Dancing Lion 6. Commander Gaius 7. Putrescent Knight 8. Metyr, Mother of Fingers 9. Midra, Lord of Frenzied Flame 10. Romina, Saint of the Bud 11. Scadutree Avatar

[@animefreak2910]

atleast someone put rellana above messmer

[@shizu4073]

@@animefreak2910 rellana was easy compared to messmer

[@animefreak2910]

@@shizu4073 naah for me messmer was easier than her but yeah messmer was better boss I could say he was the best boss in the DLC .

[@David-zx6bx]

finally a more accurate tier list instead of it being made by someone 'fighting' the bosses using mimic

[@jameslough6329]

This is literally my exact list too lol

[@dallaspag3663]

Midra being easy is wild! Died to him more than messmer

[@standcontractdelta8120]

I ended up cheesing midra with mimic tear after about 15 tries because I was sick of having to go through phase 1 of the fight over and over.

[@dallaspag3663]

@MitsuyaChan yeah I beat messmer like 30 and midra like 40. I was using a very slow build tho with no shield. Was playing hard mode.

[@dallaspag3663]

@@standcontractdelta8120 yeah same. Thought it was a sick fight tho

[@jevan1247]

@@standcontractdelta8120 Summons aren't cheese. Cheese refers to unfair exploitation of game mechanics

[@Loepfe7]

Won't even let me summon ​@@standcontractdelta8120

[@Tosheii]

So many helpful videos pushed out for this DLC!!! Thank you and I hope you two have enough rest!!!

[@Kratosx23]

It is hilarious to me, personally, that the Putrescent Knight is at #2. I have *literally no idea* what he does, because I just buffed myself with a bunch of damage boosters, ran at him and Ancient Dragon Lightning Striked him to death with one cast. 😂

[@DillanJ]

he is very weak to holy damage. I spammed wave of gold and it died

[@DeathsInverse]

Yeah he wasn't really difficult at all

[@joshuatang3898]

Wtf that was the fastest Scadu tree avatar I’ve seen, that was like 3 hits to the head and his 1st phase was over

[@standcontractdelta8120]

To dodge Gaias charge, use crucible feather talisman. To dodge his phase transition AOE, run away with torrent.

[@charliehustle3539]

I defeated him 1st try somehow. I was able to dodge the charge by dodging into him.

[@duncanalexander4241]

Messmer was the easiest boss in the game for me. I 4 shot him on my second try. I feel like I played a different game than everyone, I only really used dragon communion spells and I did use npc summons. But the hippo and the guy on the pig killed me significantly more. Granted I think my tree lvls were higher compared to most people's at that point, I had lvl 9. The hardest boss for the hole dlc for me was Bayle the Dread, followed by the final dlc boss. Bayle definitely killed me over 100 times..... CURRRRRSE YOU BAYYYLE!

[@Azg4l0R1]

My tactic for Radahn was only leave Thorns and ancient rancor memorized and use mimic tear, also use stagger tear in flask. In the fight if you have aggro, you panic roll, when the mimic gets aggro you cast rancor hoping to stagger, when you get aggro again you pray the mimic will use thorns and do a lot of dmg or stagger him. Do not forget to equip the talisman that boosts healing flask, it really helps

[@D00MTR33]

Seeing my beloved longhorn doing only 2k damage with its AoW to a big beefy boy like Bayle makes me sad. They gutted the poor thing into oblivion.

[@dragaidurango5762]

My reaction to gaius. "How the fuck do I fight back when there's a dam pig in my face?!" 5 great shield soldiers and a life steal apparently.

[@jevan1247]

Best summons in the gaaaamme lowkey

[@Corion2121]

Next time I’ll use the lance and enhance it to poison, and then imma poke the hell out of Radahn with it!

[@mr_peach7704]

Commander Gaius is a GREAT fight for player summoning. Keys are getting out into the center of that huge arena and away from the walls and light rolling. And watching out for that super rapid dash attack of his.

[@blacgoat8916]

All the bosses are hard until you Google their weaknesses. The final boss and Gaius was my hardest fights. I didn't really beat the final boss I cheese with perfume bottles.

[@patricklodge1576]

U beat him then

[@Asriel_Cypher]

I don't see that has anything related to Cheesing. You beat him, with a powerful build that was considered out of tune. It was in the game.

[@CatGravityWell]

I wouldn’t call using a weapon the game gives you cheese, but you do you. Still, you don’t always have to Google the weakness. Most bosses I figured out the weakness for by checking the messages placed by the fog gate.

[@Vile_Oreo]

As someone who used dual bleed whips through the DLC, Scadutree avatar gave me the most trouble. Turns out a plant that can't bleed and takes reduced damage from whips on anything but its head was particularly troubling for that build.

[@jman9838]

Big ghost flame dragon in the coast is such a douche 😂

[@luisemoralesfalcon4716]

The blasted Commander Gaius and his prancing boar, I will admit Rellana is a thorn as well Mesmer (ran by mistake to his room not yet beaten) and Raddhan (not yet reached the zone) but, f--- that man pig duo. Is there a Boss on the big temple that he is on the way? The Finger boss is annoying and the Count is a cheese in of itself. Romina (scorpion/centipede/human) is also highly annoying. Putrecents Knigh (Great Fissure) is maddening. Dying Silunflower, just attack the head, which the boss makes it easy for all players. Dancing Lion Beast is a bother. Bayle is hard but fair when you see it's pattern and have patience for a tanky boss. The Knights held in the tombs (West, East and South) have been annoying with East and West the hardest of the 4 so far. The Golems are easy if you throw a pot inside them. Tree Sentinels are a blessing, the Gaol bosses have each a nice trick to them, with Lamenter being special. Midra is scary but fair. The only thing hard about NPC and Field bosses is how they have a lot of HP and can happen when you aren't ready (Bear Duo). Again, thank you From Software for those two Tree Sentinels.

[@CallistoBeloved]

i took forever for the sunflower, but divine beast dancing lion i beat in 3 attempts with like lvl 2 scadutree blesssing and bleed build

[@luisemoralesfalcon4716]

@CallistoBeloved I took out the Divine Dancing Lion in my first attempt, we killed each other but the game registered it as a win and I am not complaining. The other Dancing Beast gave me a bit of an issue but, then I cheese it with ranged weapons and killed the Deathblight toads it thre to me.

[@TheGreatGoddessFreya]

I absolutely love Romina's design, and I loved the fight. But yeah, if she was buffed by about 50% I think I'd love it even more. Making her that easy when the Sunflower was 3 phases is criminal.

[@QuantaleDingleDangle]

You know what's crazy, there are only 4 necessary bosses. Messmer, romina, needle knight leda gank boss if you want to count it, and the last boss

[@MrWolf123]

Bayle is by far my favourite souls boss ever. The dialogue of the summon and then his second phase where he unleashes literal nukes had me locked in. I beat him in about half an hour.

[@ruikiri]

The only bosses i really had some trouble with was bayle and the final boss... i cant believe scadutree avatar isnt the first one on this list xb

[@brentramsten249]

when i first fought the divine beast i had 7 scadu tree fragments and killed it in 10 charged glintsone blades (one tasliman damage increase, no lusats/magic damage buff). i was deeply confused when people told me the fight was hard

[@dantecoal7584]

Divine Dancing Lion is cheese time for Magic. One of a few fights this DLC where the ability to stay at range trivializes so much of the fight. Struggled with him for a min on my Unga Bunga build until I swapped to a duel Blood Stars build and destroyed him, but my pure caster build made it look easier than a bird warrior, lol

[@toxic2yrold]

My personal ranking using a Dex/Faith Fire Build 1.) Promised Consort Radahn 2.) Rellana Twin Moon Knight 3.) Mesmer the Impaler 4.) Bayle the Dread 5.) Commander Gaius 6.) Divine Beast Dancing Lion 7.) Metyr Mother of Fingers 8.) Midra Lord of Frenzied Flame 9.) Scadutree Avatar 10.) Romina Saint of the Bud 11.) Putrescent Knight (He died too quickly on my play through, he’s super squishy)

[@TheRegret]

i haven't seen hollow talk about it yet but miquella's broken rune from the scadutree avatar fight, removes the grab debuff so you can be grabbed again and not die.

[@tonydillinger2553]

I got grabbed by Miquella and nothing happened, wasn't sure if it was from frenzied flame or bug.

[@TheMetalCaveman]

Normally I play big Unga Bunga 2-handed colossal weapon, but I played a bunch of the DLC with fingerprint shield paired with anvil on a stick, found Rellana to be one of the easiest fights, never even got to see her 2 moons lol Spelldrake + 3, the new shield talisman and the base shield talisman with dragon greatshield let you block pretty much everything, and staying close lets you punish her with some big hits. Though patience is still needed. The Putrescent Knight was also not that bad IMO, but that was because after seeing all the "holy required ahead" messages I prepared the black steel greathammer with sacred infusion and prayerful strike AoW, it absolutely melts that dude. Even Radahn wasn't bad once I used the lance sword (the one you get from Gaius) and fingerprint shield, with the incantation that reduces holy damage, biggest issue with that fight was the Holy Nuke of Antioch, that thing killed me several times and just felt like the cheapest thing ever, got him to a sliver of health several times and eventually summoned help, there I learned running to the sides of the arena is the best way to deal with the nuke, you can block it if you keep your back to the wall, still need some descent stats and holy protection though. Hardest for me was the Divine Beast, easily the hardest boss in all the DLC imo, got to it with a low blessing level still with my build from the base game, no new stuff, got killed way too many times thanks to the camera, it was just a really frustrating fight for me. Overall, this DLC made me fall in love with big shields lol

[@tjmincemeat]

This list is pretty similar to mine. Main differences are I have Putrescent night much lower, Bayle much higher (at #3) and Messmer slightly higher at #2. I also have Meyter below Midras but they’re pretty even. Everything else is where I have it on mine.

[@Sleepysnorlax1]

Gaius just ticked me off. He just steam rolls you. I died 3-4 times just trying to start the fight. Once I finally just ran like crazy at the start of the fight, I was able to beat him 1-2 tries.

[@CloserToCairo]

what are your stats for the fire knight shortsword? that damage is crazy

[@Asriel_Cypher]

As a Faith Ranged Caster build, I had the most trouble with Midra the most. As he forces you to go Melee range. All of my spells often miss. I can't use Giants' Flameball. The Lightning will just miss. I didn't use the Miquella Holy spells. So I just beat him up using Melee at the end. I really wanted to use the Incantations but I can't. So I had to resort to just hitting him till he's down.

[@redviper5s150]

Not gonna lie, I died several times in my first few runs at Bayle because I was mesmerized by his move set

[@user-jd3br8il2g]

I completely mopped the floor with Rellana my first playthrough. Bayle is a blast to fight though.

[@tayshaunpatton4165]

Nah that horse coming from behind me while I’m looking at the skeleton was od

[@DanKing-tv9ze]

I had nightmares of Commander Gaius and Raddhan.

[@Grandeur023]

Holy crap lol… I just now am realizing how much more damage I had to do on NG+4 at level 150… that’s genuinely crazy 😂

[@moneymaker-fl2fc]

The no-cap ranking is: 1. Promised Consort Radahn 2. Bayle the Dread 3. Messmer the Impaler 4. Commander Gaius 5. Rellana, Twin Moon Knight 6. Metyr, Mother of Fingers 7. Scadutree Avatar 8. Putrescent Knight 9. Romina, Saint of the Bud 10. Midra, Lord of Frenzied Flame 11. Divine Beast Dancing Lion

[@HarryBondInc]

The Dancing Lion was way harder than Malenia IMHO. Radahn was the hardest souls boss I have ever faced. Was really satisfying to beat him though

[@hellixdiscord7041]

Final boss in nullified by ANY decent shield. Doesn't even have to be an amazing one. I see him as much easier than people claim, since shields don't nullify Mesmer, Rellana, Midra or Bayle to the extent that they nullify him.

[@hunterjax1]

I dont think ive ever seen a 1 minute ago upload. But hey. Comment for algorithm ensued.

[@sofaking4779]

I have helped many people as a summon to these fights. TBH, the number of people that die to the Mesmer grab attack from full to dead is by far the #1 cause for "Host has died". Radahn has the most deaths by random attacks for sure. The Bayle fight wins for "most likely to take up 10 minutes only for the host to die".

[@alexpaul4144]

I didn’t know giuas had a phase change…he charged my mimic an got stuck on the wall an i just thorns him 🤣

[@NicholasAdamsDPM]

Gaius was my hardest followed close by Radahn. Gaius would instantly rush at me and kill me in 3 seconds upon entering the room. This would happen 2 out of 3 attempts so learning him was almost impossible. Its the only boss I have ever cheesed just to get done with it.

[@Bakedbeans87]

Big sunflower meet burn o flame with two giant seals

[@codybaggett9741]

A solid build, adequate scadutree fragments, NPC summons, Spirit Ashes, knowledge of boss weaknesses, and experience of the base game is plenty preparation to make all but the last boss plenty doable. Like many others I was expecting Malenia level bosses left and right, but that just wasn't the case. For reference, I'm using a RL200 CQ Tank with pure strength damage and I just don't have to break a sweat. It was harder for me to get past Mohg than most of the DLC bosses.

[@AKmumu]

Midra was so easy for me he didn't have time to do any of his moves

[@petronetto]

For me Bayle comes right before Radahn, and before Bayle, Commander Gaius, but this is because I primary play melee, and these guys are an absolutely nightmare because of the long combos then they simply jump 3km always from you , and think: "Ah! Maybe I should heal!" and you try to heal and they are up to your neck in a split of a second with 30 seconds combo

[@jettblade]

I agree with all the positions however I hate the final boss. If the entire DLC is telling you be patient and wait for openings then this boss is a complete lie because there are no openings and as far as I can tell no way to create openings, which every other boss has a way. I can't tell you how many times I died because I had zero stamina from trying to evade the ridiculous chain combos. Literally the only reason why I was able to beat that boss was because some kind stranger was able to draw its attention long enough for me to actually be able to attack. The only time I felt the final boss was fair was when the RNG was nice and made them walk at me rather then the lightspeed dash or throw out the 52 attack chain combo. There is also the complete BS random light beams that I absolutely hate. Nothing like getting hit and knocked back from a light beam from an attack not even pointed at you. Honestly the only thing that needs to change is a little less aggression and a way to create an opening. It would be really nice to actually be able to make attacks at this boss rather than run away the entire fight.

[@shadowcyberdemon8776]

Rellana killed me more than any other boss, found her incredibly frustrating

[@TheBatosai]

I beat Bayle at level 9 in the DLC with a mage it took about 12 to 15 trys. My list of top 5 would go: #5 Giaus #4 First dungeon enemy guy #3 Bayle #2 Rellena most deaths and time #1 Radhan. But after 4 tires, I cheese him to death in 5 more with my Hello Kitty perfume attack

[@86lanzo]

Hornsent warriors are no joke the toughest enemies in the game for me

[@rodrigoleon5812]

I think i died 2 times to dancing lion my first playtbrough and 1 time my second. He reminds me of the ulcerated tree spirit weird movements and hitboxes but managable if you learn the wiggle and trivial once you find the dead spots. Messmer sadly only killed me 3 times i just learned his moveset quickly and well its intuitive i loved his fight and wish i could've dont in longer. Rellana destroyed me full stop even on my 2nd playthrough just ruined me.

[@britonsky115]

Hardest for me, after Radahn, was Rellana... Goddamn that woman has no stamina bar

[@Not____Applicable]

I defeated Messmer on my fourth try but Midra took me days.

[@GodofMelon420]

Bayle did beat my ass the most but radahn is going to take that position soon

[@oneups8192]

Top 5 for - 1 Radhan- 2 Mesmer- 3 Bale- 4 Gaius-5 avatar

[@ArmoredChocoboLPs]

"Messmer punishes roll spamming" *video shows you roll spamming and it works*

[@Ratt611]

Bois its not if u can kill the boss, its if u can kill the boss with style. 😮

[@dmaxcustom]

After finishing all the bosses, my main issue is that I find really hard to see what's going on. The bosses throw a lot of sh*t on your face and to me, at least, is really hard to react. Eventually you either over power, or learn the move set, or find the weakness, or cheese. But never felt I was naturally learning to fight them.

[@blubeard6914]

Personally I’d switch the dancing lion with the skeleton knight thing.

[@content5272]

I still think the lion at 5 is crazy

[@lucacosta9354]

Putrescent knight wasn’t really a big challenge for me. It took me like 6 tries once I learned its weak to lightning damage moves. Radahn and Mesmer were the real pain in the butt. For Radahn I played with the stone shield which I just hate to play with. But this fucker has just too many strong move sets which are impossible to dodge even with 60+ vigor and endurance with almost max scadutree blessings

[@loganberkheimer1857]

Romina misses half of her attacks all on her own, I'm on ng+2 and have yet to die to her

[@Howardone]

Putresent knight melted against lighting spear, as did the mother of fingers.

[@liam6550]

Their arenas are in water which probably explains the extra lightning damage

[@iMightBeCrazy]

I had more trouble with Midra than meytr or the sunflower or Rellana. Bayle was harder than Mesmer as well

[@kimcruz1305]

Everybody is listing the top weapons and yet no one put morg sacred spear w the bloodboon ritual, it been my go to since I got it from morg then DLC, I know it has a slow wind up but if the boss is distracted by the mimic or floating in the air, full 3 burst take 80% of health of the boss, plus I beat Melania with it in 2 try

[@CatGravityWell]

Weirdly for me, the bosses were super hard (except Romina) until I dunked all over the old mad dude. I guess he stole my Wretch Luck when I entered the DLC and I had to clap his withered cheeks to get it back.

[@animefreak2910]

rellana is way harder than Messmer , he gives many chances to punish him but she is always doing something . I literally used 4-5 perfect charged attacks on messmer but on her not even a single .

[@jevan1247]

How are Bayle and Rellana below Divine Beast????????????????? The Lion fight definitely took less time to learn than any other Rememberance fight in the game. Lion prolly took me 3 tries, where Rellana was at least 10, and I left Bayle alone for most of the game after 20+ tries.

[@tonydillinger2553]

the boss that gave me most trouble was bayle

[@saintseya4469]

Well i spent dunn how many tries trying to defeat the last boss, i killed most of the list (not all, since i never killed the fire dragon, or the tree, i left something for after ending the game, to have an excuse to play it more) in a few tries, but the last boss, took me more tries than all the other bosses combined by far >< . Second phase destroyed me everytime

[@PhoenixInferno]

I heavily disagree with the putrescent knight he isn’t that hard to know his moves and radahns second phase is bullshit by the amount of follow up light attacks and how hard it is to see radhn himself by that’s just my experience

[@Loepfe7]

Fuck this I beat Bayle easily and Midra is giving me all sorts of problems

[@jeremysanders8766]

Godwyn or Miquella would’ve been better than the repeat of Radahn

[@samurai_panda]

Messmer is so weak it’s disappointing. I expected Malenia 2.0, but got Morgot 1.5. On my first play though I killed him first try and didn’t even get to see his whole move set. Rellana, Dancing Lion and Midra are so much stronger

[@Enenra138]

Many are in the opposite boat. I killed Rellana after a small handful of attempts, and did Dancing Beast in my first attempt, but Messmer? I had to take a break, simply because he was consistently wrecking me shortly after finding him.

[@vijaybm9305]

It really depends on what order you fight the bosses. If you try to kill messmer right after rellana with like 7/8 scadutree blessing, he's going to be more tough than most bosses except the final one. I fought him early and struggled. On my alt character, I fought him at the end and he felt like morgott 2.0.

[@LostboyUk]

Every boss is the same difficulty with the builds in this video.

[@maran947]

I don´t like the fact that Radahns light staggers, it doesn´t feel good at all you get hit by the afterlight and you are done you get hit by a chain of 20 hits I dont feel like it is 100 percent fair, his first phase is great except one move that is a bit questionable but the second phase how is that fair difficulty I dont get it which boss then doesnt have fair difficulty? Dont get me wrong but I feel like it is a bit overtuned with the stagger and aggression the rest is great

[@craftymagpie3182]

Putrescent Knight bugged out for me and froze at his spawn point. No way to get out of his pit once in combat so had to hit him repeatedly in the hope it triggered his pathing. Spoiler- it did not and he just went down like a sack of mouldering spuds. Will try him again properly another game.

[@Sky92on]

Personally I'd rank Gaius at number 2, but agreed on the rest!

[@cez010]

For me Bayle was hardest, other bosses can either be tanked with a shield or just with high bleed builds, heck radahn with a tank setup was probably easiest than most here

[@ZeroGs2232]

so many of the bosses in this DLC are way to big and make them just melt to ancient dragon lighting its both funny and sad, the hippos even the mandatory one was just dead in seconds

[@Git_Gud_Scrub]

Ok time to Help Fellow Tarnish Tank The final boss.

[@jaybruce6974]

It’s got to be Radhan. But I don’t think any of them compare to what melania is/was

[@techdeth]

So far the the first solitary knight was my hardest lol, just gotta kill the chaosdude, bayle, and radahn and i think im done ,

[@JCOolx]

bayle was like ten times harder than the lion

[@genHawkeye]

i personally would rank Midra higher but that's only because my first kill i just...wasn't playing against him properly lol- looking back now im like "oh yeah...i could have done X or Y during that fight and wrecked him. Weirdly enough Messmer for me wasn't...that hard? Took me about...8 tries to get him down but compared to some of the other bosses he didn't FEEL that difficult (but i went into his fight expecting something like Malenia so maybe that's why?) 100% agree on the top 2, fuck the putrescent knight or whatever the fuck he is called.

[@MrShinoTheBugman]

I personally put baeyl at #2. but otherwise pretty similar opinion to your placements. (though I personally found putrescent very easy. only 3 deaths on him the lowest of any of the bosses other than the flower who I one shot)

[@Warkill94]

bro dane's parry💀

[@kouyang9393]

I'm not going to lie, i try to solo this, but it was hard for me cause if i did not kill them fast enough, they gang up on me. The big guy give me the hardest time with those Rot Pot i scare 1 of them give me rot asap.

[@ruikiri]

Malenia is definitely harder than radahn... radahns moveset is not hard, but theres some bullshit in there that will piss you off, like the double slash into cross and the clones clipping your character.. not to mention the "visual spectacle"..

[@joshcummings8567]

I hate big beast/ monster bosses most of the time. I wish they would keep it mostly humanoid bosses. And a few big monstrosity every now and then

[@uknoimjoker]

The first time i fought messmer it was a horrible experience my frame rate dropped and fell through the map on my second playthrough of the dlc i beat him first try it was a fun fight. With that being said rahdan is very disappointing to me as the final boss it should have been Godwyn after seeing it was rahdan i honestly i felt like turning my ps5 off and going to sleep it honestly felt like a waste on my time only saving grace it had was having dude jump on his back but i doubt ill even fight him on my second playthrough i dont see the point just to be disappointed more because it should have been godwyn not a boss ive fought 10 times already

[@chasegaetze4507]

That putrid knight is cancer. Just super annoying always creating distance. Literally never stop chasing him around the entire arena just for him to run again

[@artemis1734]

putrescent ranked as 2nd hardest boss is a crime, get any holy weapon and the guy will be dead in 20 seconds with decent rng, and his moveset is really simple so finding opportunities to punish is very easy.

[@arkcantoscreampsnpc7274]

Final boss is the only boss I think is genuinely unfair at times, the rest are fine to me To say it’s not is just fanboying and I say that as a player with 6000+ hours across the games His moveset is fine sure but the holy chains following each attack are bullshit that from added simply because he’s an easy boss without them. Ask yourself this, if he didn’t have the holy laser chains would he be harder then messmer? The answer is no And that means his difficulty is entirely based on one gimmick, a shit gimmick at that that doesn’t feel good to fight, and I say that having beat him 2 times legit 1v1 for ego and a third with bleed thorns gimmick

[@Bass_n_barbells]

1. Radahn 2. Bayle 3. Messmer 4. Gaius The rest are cake

[@GodofMelon420]

Radahn is my bayle