Best wishes to u and your loves one. Someone from Singapore 🇸🇬
@何慧敏-v6t Жыл бұрын
@@klloh5012 謝謝
@milanvenngai2 ай бұрын
多謝您😢。
@正呀正呀2 жыл бұрын
每次聽這歌,我就想起母親。母親婚姻失敗後,就把我當作是向父親報復的工具,多年來都情緒勒索我。小時候我聽Shall We Talk ,我幻想,可以把這歌送給母親,她可會知道我心底想法,停止傷害我?我有想過,和家人說出想法,是否可換來體諒和停止傷害?答案是不會的。我的家庭沒有溝通這回事,所以我選擇不說了,任她傷害我,我能做的就是避開,避開她那些傷人的說話。多年後再聽 Shall We Talk,陳奕迅的歌聲多了點的力量,大概將力量帶給每位希望溝通的朋友。力量我收到了,但我的家庭仍然是沒有溝通這回事。#沉默令我聽得見葉兒聲聲降 還是感謝夕爺,陳奕迅和陳輝陽,還有各位製作這首歌的幕後工作人員。
以心理輔導其中一治療方法 - 內在家庭系統(Internal Family Systems)看這個MV,我們內在都有受傷、脆弱、想不通的部份(3:43),我們起初或會想去逃避這些部份帶來的傷痛情緒(1:01),但如果我們有勇氣去接受而不帶批判去面對自己的部份,很多心理問題就可以透過這種溫柔迎刃而解(2:37)。透過訓練去了解自己內在的不同部份,能夠在外在世界產生更大同理心和好好聆聽表面上和你有很多差異的人(3:53)。 對MV純粹很個人的意會:波點人和那些貼在面上的波點象徵我們如何放大自己的缺點和不足,那些I'm not good enough的思想; 注視蝴蝶的人可能很想achieve某些事情(蝴蝶可以是思想上覺得很難達到但很想得到的目標:金錢、愛情、過去美好的時光、健康、或是療癒本身),他的futility很能表達抑鬱症的powerlessness; 差點跳下深淵的人表達有自殺傾向的部份,自殺除了是一般人眼中的想不開,更是心中的傷痛痛得不能忍受,用來保護自己免受傷痛的心理機制。重點是我們如何面對自己的負面情緒,有些人會視之為洪水猛獸,有些人會用各種addiction去掩蓋這些聲音。 最後,踏出第一步尋求專業既治療師/醫生/社工係好難,但願意尋求人地幫助、講出自己心聲既人其實係好有勇氣。
@chingfucc4 жыл бұрын
我覺得波點人似係講緊草間彌生點樣同精神病共處
@smallcaplamb4 жыл бұрын
多謝你的見解!
@litkashing2 күн бұрын
波點人應該係bipolar, 個蝴蝶男仔似係schizophrenia
@kwongwinnie45674 жыл бұрын
聽左廿年,呢個簡直係得救版
@acevictory35874 жыл бұрын
+10000
@jordanchan88814 жыл бұрын
其實Eason 真係比唱歌事業耽誤既演員....MV入面每個表情都好細膩
@myaoeo3 жыл бұрын
eason係mv中段開始,表情都好溫暖
@chihinng14194 жыл бұрын
一開始用左Debussy既月光做前奏 到最後又加入Beethoven既月光奏鳴曲做伴奏 配合返Shall We Talk歌詞既 明月光 依個編曲真係用心良苦
@農婦-v4o4 жыл бұрын
what's more, original title of "Clair de Lune" is " Promenade Sentimentale" (sentimental walk), really fits the whole thing. Well done!
@ilovedogswinnivi39512 жыл бұрын
"明月光,爲何又照地堂?“
@Night3HLC4 жыл бұрын
好彩仲見到林夕個名,而唔係佚名
@lamsirius_92724 жыл бұрын
大陸apps都寫林夕啦
@askad74 жыл бұрын
Ideas are bullet proof.
@m_123_4 жыл бұрын
Lam Sirius_ 你唔知上電視變左佚名咩
@sparta07194 жыл бұрын
還好在台灣沒看過。。。,BTW, i really like this new arrangement
多謝Eason、林夕、陳輝陽。 重新演繹Shall we talk,聽完好感動,一首比心靈飲既心靈雞湯,好治癒。 多謝Eason送上心靈安慰比每位香港人。
@gocheunggo1523 Жыл бұрын
Shall we talk是一首破格嘅流行曲,开始時好平淡然後慢慢一層又一層遞進激情卻又能回復和諧的編曲世界,林夕嘅詞當然注入了無限生命,eason厚實温暖嘅聲線表面似唸書嘅唱法影响了其後多卑好多歌曲在創作時都想倣效这首歌的模式但當然强差人意,男歌手鄧健弘,吴浩康唱过的歌有不少想倣效shall we talk这種類似童謠感覺的旋律,唱者不需要很好的唱功,聽起來個個好似唸書一樣去唱歌,甚至維持十幾年都出現一大堆新人唱嘅歌都好像在唸書数白欖聽者沉悶,幸好shall we talk嘅製作團隊沒有被这歌嘅成功冲昏頭腦,eason继續与音樂人共同努力去探索流行曲嘅其他可能性,开拓聽者嘅"耳"介,表表者是"人啊人",教人有種靈魂出竅嘅感覺,好利害!如要形客呢首歌,那就好像入戲院睇4D電影一樣,"心"歷其境
Eason +夕阳组合,当年颁奖典礼的常客,也是香港乐坛的黄金年代,可惜现在再也见不到了。Eason也很少和陈辉阳合作了,最近的一首是"相信你的人",但陈辉阳是编曲,不是作曲。希望能再次见到你们合作新歌(或者新专辑,更好)。"Shall we dance, shall we talk",和"The line up" 绝对经典啊。
@ivaniverson594 жыл бұрын
字正腔圓 咬字感情滿分!
@LeoCheongK4 жыл бұрын
"鈴聲可以寧(ning4)靜" 都係發左懶音(ling4)
@Ogroenland3 жыл бұрын
@@LeoCheongK 有諗過佢係咪突登咁發個音
@charleskwok10183 жыл бұрын
三種情緒病,我身邊都有人有。睇完好心痛,熱淚盈眶,一路湧出,原來當事人如此辛苦
@milkofcity4 жыл бұрын
睇完兩集eason幫港台拍嘅關注精神病患者節目,再嚟睇MV。覺得首歌係2020再推,特別有意義
@123LYT1234 жыл бұрын
E神好嘢,成熟了的聲線,堅定的唱腔,歌再編,歷練過,多年過後,另有一番回味。你和我也是!
@eddiecheung78244 жыл бұрын
拍得非常好及有意思的MV,Eason從新演释得非常有感情!加上夕爺!陳輝掦!絕對是難以再見的组合!
@ntonyoo4 жыл бұрын
睇到眼濕濕,MV拍得太太太好了,歌當然也是一流
@heihiiii19154 жыл бұрын
林夕依個名值得一直一直被記住
@amberberber-LJI3 жыл бұрын
陳奕迅 - Shall We Talk 明月光 為何又照地堂 ming yut gwong wai ho yau jiu dei tong radiant moonlight, why do you shine on the earthly paradise again? 寧願在公園躲藏 不想喝湯 ning yun joi gung yun do chong bat seung ho ttong I would rather hide in the park, I dont want to eat 任由目光 留在漫畫一角 yam yau muk gwong lau joi maan wa yat gok allowing my gaze to remain on the corner of a comic 為何望母親一眼就如罰留堂 wai ho mong mo chan yat ngaan jau yu fat lau tong why does looking at my mother seem like a punishment? 孩童只盼望歡樂 大人只知道期望 haai tung ji paan mong fun lok daai yan jek ji dou kei mong children only hope for fun, adults only know of the future 為何都不大懂得努力體恤對方 wai ho dou bat daai dung dak nou lik tai seut deui fong why don't we comprehend the need to work harder to sympathize with each another? 大門外有蟋蟀 迴響卻如同幻覺 daai mun ngoi yau sik seut wui heung keuk yu tung waan gok there is a cricket outside the door, the echoes are like an illusion Shall we talk Shall we talk Shall we talk Shall we talk 就當重新手拖手去上學堂 jau dong chung san sau to sau heui seung hok tong let's start over and walk hand-in-hand to school 陪我講 陪我講出我們最後何以生疏 pui ngo gong pui ngo gong cheut ngo mun jeui hau ho yi saang so talk to me, talk to me or we will become estranged 誰怕講 誰會可悲得過孤獨探戈 seui pa gong seui wui ho bei dak gwo gu duk taam gwo who's afraid of talking? who falls into sadness by the lonely Tango? 難得 可以同座 何以 要忌諱赤裸 naan dak ho yi tung jo ho yi yiu gei wai chek lo it's hard for us to get together, why do we avoid baring ourselves? 如果心聲真有療效 誰怕暴露更多 yug wo sam sing jan yau liu haau seui pa bou lou gang do if the sound of the heart really heals us, who would fear more to reveal? 你別怕我 nei bit pa ngo you must not fear me 螢幕發光 無論什麼都看 ying mok faat gwong mou leun sam mo dou hon the TV screen radiates light regardless of what's on, I'll watch anyway 情人在分手邊緣只敢喝湯 ching yan joi fan sau bin yun ji gam ho ttong lovers on the brink of breakup only dare to have meal 若沉默似金 還談什麼戀愛 yeuk cham mak chi gam waan taam sam mo lyun ngoi if silence is golden, how can we talk about love 寧願在發聲機器面前笑著忙 ning yun joi faat sing gei hei min chin siu jeuk mong it would be rather be standing before the speakers with smile 차라리 스피커 앞에서 웃고 있는 게 낫겠지요 成人只寄望收穫 情人只聽見承諾 sing yan ji gei mong sau wok ching yan ji ting gin sing nok adults only hope for success, lovers only hear promises 為何都不大懂得努力珍惜對方 wai ho dou bat daai dung dak nou lik jan sik deui fong why don't we comprehend the need to work harder to cherish each another? 螳螂面對蟋蟀 迴響也如同幻覺 tong long min deui sik seut wui heung ya yu tung waan gok the cricket confronting praying mantis, the echoes are like an illusion Shall we talk Shall we talk Shall we talk Shall we talk 就算牙關開始打震 別說謊 jau syun nga gwaan hoi chi da jan bit syut fong even if your jaw is tremblling, don't tell a lie 陪我講 陪我親身正視眼淚誰跌得多 pui ngo gong pui ngo chan san jing si ngaan leui seui dit dak do talk to me, talk to me to face more tears that have fallen than from anyone else 無法講 除非彼此已失去了能力觸摸 mou faat gong cheui fei bei chi yi sat heui liu nang lik juk mo if we already have lost the ability communicate, there is no way we can talk 鈴聲 可以寧靜 難過 卻避不過 ling sing ho yi ning jing naang wo keuk bei bat gwo the sound of a bell can be serene, yet you can't avoid feeling bad 如果沉默太沉重 別要輕輕帶過 yu gwo cham mak taai cham chung bit yiu hing hing daai gwo if the silence weighs on you too heavily, don't take it too lightly 明月光 為何未照地堂 ming yut gwong wai ho mei jiu dei tong radiant moonlight, why do you shine on the earthly paradise again? 孩兒在公司很忙 不需喝湯 haai yi joi gung si han mong bat seui ho ttong children busy at work don't need to have meal And shall we talk 斜陽白趕一趟 And shall we talk che yeung baak gon yat tong And shall we talk, the setting sun rushed in vain 沉默令我聽得見葉兒聲聲降 cham mak ling ngo ting dak gin yip yi sing sing gong the silence let me hear the sound of falling leaves 擷取自ericabaek.blogspot.com/2015/11/eason-chan-shall-we-talk.html?m=1
@@zangg89 看來你真的沒有聽出20年前的分別在哪裡。 20年前的速度比這個快很多。就只是說這一點,同一個歌詞,同一個曲調,但不同的伴奏,帶出來的訊息量可是差別甚大。你自己找回2001年的時候的Shall We Talk,你不難發現2020年的版本沉重非常多,那就可以看到你回應的人的意思是否有差了。
@cookiehui33504 жыл бұрын
睇完RTHK Eason主持既節目返來再聽呢個新版,感覺好完滿!
@aw54204 жыл бұрын
+1 多謝港台
@ThingOneTwoThree14 жыл бұрын
谢谢Eason, 辉阳和林夕这最佳组合,请再合作。
@sisidai4 жыл бұрын
重制版好评!这首歌真的太催泪了!几乎每次听都泪目!真的太戳心了!
@RB-zk2vo4 жыл бұрын
真係估唔到會重繹經典 仲係新mv
@jeffjeff03294 жыл бұрын
呢個編曲,好有置諸死地而後生嘅感覺,衝破中間嘅障礙終於黎到最尾黎明出現。最後3個字聲聲降好正
@kit934488053 жыл бұрын
每當唔開心嘅時候都要聽Shall We Talk
@marief.t12634 жыл бұрын
❤️❤️Eason !!! 支持重新演繹所有金曲🥰🥰
@chauyinpik4 жыл бұрын
重新編曲加上新嘅唱法,好正 好感動👍👍👍
@kangpocheung4 жыл бұрын
很有意思的編曲! 想問問大家點理解 TRE LUNE MMXIX? TRE 係三嘅意思 LUNE 係月亮 歌入面有DEBUSSY CLAIR DE LUNE,亦有BEETHOVEN 嘅MOONLIGHT SONATA 第三個LUNE係邊到?係咪陳生嘅"明月光"? MMXIX 又係點解?2019? 香港人的情緒真的很差很差,要變得健康 除了每個人更留意自己的情緒外, 社會也要改變吧,每天營營役役,追目標,追樓價,追成績,問題不只是個人,是日積月累的社會問題 這幾年,身心靈最健康的時候不是儲到錢去日本,是看見人鏈的治癒,看見獅子山發光的剎那 或者公義能被彰顯才令大家更能好好哋溝通!
The Ribbon girl suffers from Depression. The darkness she stares into can represent her stormy past as well as her disrupted network of Neurons. As she is about to fall into the well, Eason ties knots along the ribbon as a sign of acknowledging her "emotional knots" and to shorten the distance to her. When Eason finally gets close to her, the defensive walls and constructs collapse. The dress also becomes perfect to signify her rising out of the depressive episode and overcoming the suicidal intent. The Man with the trapped butterfly is Schizophrenic. He is also trapped in a mirror-imaged world. The butterfly is the man's soul and is confined within a delusional box. He also sees hallucinations of various insects and beasts. The messy hair and beard are signs of self-neglect and poor self-care. Eason helps to set free the butterfly by showing alternative insights. The mirror-image ceiling then disappears and the man's soul is also set free. The girl who draws red circles has Bipolar Affective Disorder. Her world is dominated by 2 colours, which represent Manic and Depressive episodes. When Eason draws the blue circle, all the circles in the room start bubbling and coalesced into unity, signifying a resolved Bipolar condition.
@carinmanfong4 жыл бұрын
your explanation touched my heart :) thanks!
@EstherYuen4 жыл бұрын
Such a beautiful explanation! Thank you.
@unijade4 жыл бұрын
As someone suffering from bipolar disorder I could pick up the idea behind the first girl instantly.
Listen to yr inner voice, care about yrself. Listen to others, care about the others. We human being are all the same -- Oneness. 2020 is a difficult year, let's get through it together. Blessings to everyone.