Shayari Aur Filmi Shayari | Irshad Kamil & Manoj Muntashir with Naghma Sahar | Jashn-e-Adab 2017

"Shayari Aur Filmi Shayari"
Irshad Kamil & Manoj Muntashir in conversation with Naghma Sahar at Jashn-e-Adab 2017 Phase-2, IGNCA, New Delhi
This channel is the official channel of Jashn-e-Adab Foundation, known for its literary activities celebrating Art, Culture & Literature in Hindi and Urdu across the world right from 2012.
Connect with us :
Facebook : / jashneadab
Twitter : / jashneadab
Instagram : / jashneadab_foundation
#irshadkamil #manojmuntashir #naghmasahar #jashneadab

[@thewholeworld5341]

मनोज सर की सादगी और कलम बेहतरीन है इरसाद जी की तरफ से ये इन्टरव्यू से ज्यादा डिबेट लग रहा है मनोज सर का हर गीत दिल छू लेने वाला होता है 🌹🌹🌹🌹

[@sanjaykumartewary8497]

इरशाद कामिल बेशक बड़े गीतकार हैं पर इस इंटरव्यू में हुए एक तंग दिल इंसान नजर आते हैं। मनोज मुंतशिर ने बहुत बड़ा दिल दिखाया है। वे एक बेहतरीन गीतकार के साथ-साथ बेहतरीन भी इंसान हैं ।

[@prabhabisht4686]

Sahi.kaha hai

[@shabbarshaikh5537]

Correct har baat me wo irshad Bhai keh rahe they

[@gauravbasraiyya7771]

Aaj ek baar manoj muntashir ka time line aur youtube channel dekho To pata chalega gi irshad sahi the

[@mbhu18]

Sachchi baat chubhti hi hai kyuki usme point hota hai. Irshad sahi sahi saaf aur khari baat karte hain. Manoj ji buttering karne wala insaan hai, samjhautabaaz hai aur copycat bhi hai!

[@pankajdubey4845]

It's true

[@sagarsawarkar]

Irshad Kamil is pure class! Mai ye, mai vo, mera gaana, mujhe dekho wali baat hi nahi hai. Like he said, unke geet hi unki pehchaan hai.

[@moleculeclasses]

Manoj sir salute you for teri mitti song 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@parrymianiwala]

manoj sir......love u......kya down to earth aadmi hai....saari dunia ko pdh kr agr sehmsheelta nhi aayi to kya pdha....aur manoj sir ne sabit kr diya....🙏🙏🙏

[@mixingtalks6286]

Banavati h

[@im.amritvani]

दोनों ही अद्भुत प्रतिभा के धनी हैं, मुझे इन दोनो के गाने बहुत अच्छे लगते है।👍

[@ajitchauhan2487]

Manoj is very soft spoken and down to earth

[@hirakjoy4575]

both of them are my favorite lyricist 😍

[@a2lovers380]

Pool

[@dev8761]

Me too Bhai

[@amrit5679]

Amitabh Bhattacharya

[@DESTINY-of1fo]

Bahot sukoon mila dono ko sun ke Thank you

[@rajsingh__477]

मनोज मुंतशिर भैया सरल व्यक्तित्व के धनी हैं। ❤️ देवरिया, यूपी

[@rameshwarsharma2812]

Highly intellectual and literary discussion.Unheard in film industry in recent times. Congratulations organizers. Wonders truck to listen Irshad sahib and Manoj, Sir. More literary than literary festivals. Hats off to participants.

[@nimmis133]

Manoj is the best human being and lyric writer

[@YAYAVARANHAD]

कामिल से ये उम्मीद नहीँ थी....... मनोज सर कमाल है आप

[@ef9929]

Tum idiot ho

[@pankajdubey4845]

You are right

[@naveenbhardwaj3063]

Kaisi ummid bandhu ???

[@himanshu8785]

इरशाद कामिल सर, मनोज मुंतशिर सर से थोड़ा ख़फ़ा-ख़फ़ा दिख रहे हैं, सिर्फ़ मुझे ऐसा लग रहा है या आपको भी लग रहा है?

[@Principle.]

Mujhe bhi lag raha hai dost

[@amanizad3907]

Khafa hona lazim he

[@srikantlamba7892]

Haan bhai lag to raha h par wajah kya h ?

[@himanshu8785]

@@amanizad3907 भाई लेकिन ऐसा क्यों कि ख़फ़ा होना लाज़िमी है? एक शायर को इस तरह भरी महफ़िल में ऐसा बर्ताव नही करना चाहिये जो कि सामने वाला उन्हें बड़ा कह रहा है और उन्हें इज़्ज़त भी दे रहा है, ख़ैर अपना अपना व्यक्तिगत मसला होगा मगर ऐसा नही होना चाहिये था...अफ़सोस!

[@chinmayraut2515]

Ha. Mujhe bhi yahi laga. Irshad Sir bohot hee professional aur punctual hai. Aur ek interview mein Irshad Saab ne ye bhi kaha tha, ki agar koi dusra lyricist unke movie mein koi gaana likhe, to unhe ye pasand nahi aata. Shayad Manoj Sir ke deri se aane se, aur iss professionality ke karan shayad wo khafa ho sakte hai.

[@naveenbhardwaj3063]

कामिल साहब को समझने के लिए एक अच्छी सोच और अकल की ज़रूरत है जनाब ।

[@VishalKumar-et2by]

Irshad can't be compared..He is the Gem....

[@ritasingh2193]

This is really really nice of Manoj ...He is great great person .👍👌💐💐💐.

[@syedjafferimam5789]

The best part is these 2 are the 2 of best people to talk about this after Javed Akhtar. Really enjoyed the session 👌👌

[@nawalkishorkayal7328]

Kis manhoos KO Yaad kiya

[@naveenbhardwaj3063]

आप एक सफ़ल लेखक और कवि के साथ साथ बेहतरीन और एक उलझा हुआ इंसान भी हैं, जो की एक कवि होने के नज़रिए से सबसे अहम बात है ।

[@kunalsharma8670]

उलझा या सुलझा?

[@prasantasarkar1214]

Kaisa yea ishq hai ajab sa risk hai Pehli bar Irshad Kamil ka naam suna Teri Mitti sunkar pehli bar Manoj Muntashir ka naam suna

[@pratikmedhane8843]

Hats off... Manoj sir, You are big inspiration🖤

[@yashmalik4907]

I too am inspired by Manoj Muntshir

[@SUNIL-wy7zp]

Are you still inspired by him 🤔🤔

[@sscricketcom2040]

गाने में अपना नाम गीतऋषि गोपालदास नीरज जी ने भी इस्तेमाल किया है। O meri sharmili में... नीरज नैनों वाले... 😍

[@jayakjazbaat1310]

देखना ज़रा अखबार में मेरा भी नाम आया होगा। मैं कल उसके काम आऊं, इसलिए वो मेरे काम आया होगा। और कारोबारी तो यूं ही बदनाम है । शहंशाह तो और ही हैं, जहां से पैगा़म आया होगा। @jayakjazbaat

[@subha6976]

Love you both my best poets of this era

[@deepakkumarjoshi8568]

23 minutes me kamil sir ne jo baat khi, true lines... I googled for kunfaya thousands times.... Then I knew about kamil sahab..

[@SunilVerma-te6mc]

Aanad bakshi sab the great lyricist of bollywood 3500 song

[@neelimanajare9473]

Very nice

[@anitajha9962]

मनोज मुंतशिर जी कितने कूल हैं । और वो इशराद को कितना महत्व दें रहें हैं । पर इरशाद कामिल थोड़ा घमंड सा दिखा रहे हैं। मनोज मुंतशिर की बात ही अलग है। Love you 💖💖💖🙏🙏

[@rupeshmaravi2167]

भाई इरशाद कामिल मनोज मुंताशिर से सीनियर है

[@GurdeepSingh-yz9oy]

उनका स्वभाव ऐसा ही है, किसी भी इंटरव्यू में देख लो, घमंड नहीं है।

[@amangurjar4305]

Manoj se bada political koi ni he ..Irshad ji is jamm

[@Way4shorts]

Manoj ji ek behtareen experiment karten hain jo aaz ke kisi writer me nahi hai

[@aakashdubey5567]

मनोज सर कि वजह से इरशाद भाई आपको देखने का मौका मिला,,,, और आप उन्हीं से जले भूने जा रहे हैं,,,,

[@sarthakchouhanyoutube25]

Abe beta irshad Kamil ko janta hai unki sirf Rockstar aur Aashiqui 2 Manoj ke Carrer khatam kar degi

[@mukeshgeophy]

Irsad Kamil should learn to be competitive but he is arrogant. He don’t know how to behave publicly. I have noticed that whatever Manoji Muntashir is saying, Irshad is trying to count. I know the depth and range of Mr Manoj Muntashir Ji and he is very down to earth.

[@gullukhan4561]

Bro irsad kamil sir is introvert man he is not arrogent

[@varuns6407]

@@gullukhan4561 correct

[@parijat95]

Irshadi kamil mic tak nahi dena chahte manoj ko. Manoj irshad bhai kah kar kai baar unse kuch puchte hai lekin irshad was blank.

[@jayajain8882]

Esa kuch nhi h bhaii

[@rashideepudubey2714]

Sorry bt arrogent nhi bol sakte, इन्सान का व्यक्तित्व परिस्थितियों पर निर्भर करता है, परिस्थितियों की आंच ज्यादा लगे तो इन्सान सख्त हो ही जाता है.

[@sunilsharma-xi7fj]

इरशाद कामिल जी एक छोटा इंसान बड़ा शायर नहीं हो सकता इसलिए आज आप बड़े नहीं हैं| मनोज जी आप भविष्य हैं देश का|

[@sarthakchouhanyoutube25]

Hn ab dekh Zara controversy ke baad manoj ki

[@anitajha9962]

मनोज मुंतशिर जी आपको सुनने के बाद किसी को सुनना मुझे तो अच्छा नहीं लगता ।,💖💖💖💝

[@kamalmishra9043]

IRSHADJI APKI SOCH BAHUT ACHHI ISMEN SACHHAI HAI

[@heartbeat7720]

Dono alag tarah k sayaar hai, issiliye samajh bhi alag hai. Healthy discussion hai. Accha lagta do sayaar Ko ek sath dekh k.

[@rishiraaj.580]

90s - Best Period Of Music Industry. Melodious Songs 🎵🎸👌

[@hetalbenpatel442]

👎इरशाद तुमने भले ही सब कुछ सीख लिया हो पर अहंकार को नहीं भूल पाए|मनोज मुंतसिर तुम महान हो|👍

[@hetalbenpatel442]

Right

[@sharwankori218]

This comment didn't age well 😂

[@dr.mohitmajhi2191]

ये इरशाद कामिल इतने एटीट्यूड में क्यों है भाई , कब्ज है क्या।

[@singermp1755]

😂😂😂😂

[@uniquepoetry9500]

Bro vo ye bol Raha hai janni aapke andar TELENT hai to KHUDKE haaton SE apne SAPNO ko pura karo Dusron KE upar NAI, SAMJHA na samjh insan ,🤣

[@sarthakchouhanyoutube25]

Kyuki unhe pata hai woh No 1 hai Salim Javed me bhi atitude tha kyuki unhe pata tha ki woh no 1 hai aur Sahir Ludhianvi me toh sabse zyada tha kyuki woh no 1 hai aur sirf galat ko Sahi kare ko atitude nhi khete

[@shaikhfarheen4933]

Ye hota bade aor asli admi hone ka fark, wo apni tarif khudse nahi krwata jaise k manoj kr rahe hai, yaha sabko irshad sahab jealous aor arrogant lag rahe hai magar kisi ne unki sadgi aor khud ko aam samjhne ka hunar nahi dekha he is a legend koi kuch bhi kahe unki soch tak pohchna bhi mushkil hai kisi k liye 🙌🙌🙌

[@dilkibaate4394]

Tum log hamesha mazhabi hi rahoge.....kattrwaadiyo

[@sarthakchouhanyoutube25]

True Bhai

[@ashudwi8958]

Bhai log, Mujhe lagta hai dono ka apna-apna way of talking hai, but both r legends 4 all of us in this golden era.

[@kiranshekar2744]

Such great anchoring and guests are gold

[@PrashantKumar-po6se]

Manoj Shukla 💘💘💘

[@sanjaysblc]

How we find difference between two persons. They are great. They have their own style. Accept them.

[@SUNIL-wy7zp]

Irshad sahab is a great man He is not like the Hindu extremist manoj . I am proud to be his fan ☺️

[@vipinpandey5630]

Manoj sir continue ,big support from Pratapgarh ,, where you loved urdu very first time

[@koushikmalik9130]

Bhoat shukriyea apka is program ka

[@ayaanbadnaam8806]

Teacher and student this is simple words jb do kalma sath hote h kuch aise hi talented milte hai dekhne ko🙏❤️👍

[@Suprat0555]

Manoj Ji You have earned my respect. I will always be waiting for new compilation. I wouldn't bother Kamil. Apna acharan sudharo paghile.

[@mikethebeastaman459]

Anand Bakshi is the best of all writters.....right from the 60s to 2002 the proper transition....he has given the greatest classical song and he has given the best 90s song.... it's not easy for a writer to change his style by changing the taste of music of listener.....proud to be fan of Anand Bakshi jee....

[@bkmusicrecords1927]

Anand bakshi is the real king of bollywood ,100 percent

[@narenderdhawan4208]

Both of my favorites lyrics writers.

[@bm19411]

I love Irshad kamil for introducing grace and quality to Punjabi poetry in film songs.

[@mukulsahu1104]

'महक गयी है ये खुशबू... महका तेरा जो है ये आँचल फूलों की तू है रानी या फिर है कोई सन्दल -इरशाद कामिल (फ़िल्म- I 'आई') किस - किसने सुना है

[@krishanyadav5112]

Personally speaking manoj ji is at his best. and irshad is carrying is attitude. But dil se yr irshad deserves this attitude. 🙏

[@pradeepsaxena32]

Bahot ummda

[@SurajSharma-nq2tp]

Manoj sir aap great hai Love from Siddhartha nagar♥️

[@jeeshannabi827]

Unacademy mujhe I. A. S nhi bnna... plz interrupt mt kro video mein...

[@dilipshanker8726]

100 va like krne vala 😊 And both are my favorite 😍

[@GujjuPromotionalComedy]

37:26 Manoj Bhai YoYo Honey Singh, Badshah Har gaane me apna naam daalte hain 😂😂😂😂😂 Jokes part bt Irshaad bhai aap dil pe kyu le rahe ho sb cheez

[@ashachauhan91]

Kamil to ek jala bhu a admi lagta hai. Manoj is very polite and gengtl man.

[@ashachauhan91]

Kamil pagal aur jealous admi hai. Manoj is polite and gentle man hain

[@jayajain8882]

@emraan hashmi true🤣🤣🤣

[@montychauhan4493]

गोपाल दास नीरज जी ने भी एक गीत में अपना नाम लिखा था।।।ओ नीरज नैंना आ जरा....

[@nikhilpurohit1433]

Two of my most favs 👏🙂

[@panchalkalpesh3883]

Kunaal Verma is missing bro..

[@pratyushshukla7503]

Manoj muntashir, Irshad Kamil, amitabh bhattacharya, kumar, kunal verma, Rashmi Verag, आज के बेस्ट lryicst हैं

[@nikhilpurohit1433]

Yes these all are 👌👏

[@sandeepgade8567]

Really I don't understand why Irshad Kamil Showing so much attitude while Manoj is very down-to-earth and really well-spoken.

[@VishalKumar-et2by]

Because He is 10 times higher than MANOJ...

[@sandiip21]

@@VishalKumar-et2by it is not everst climbing competition how is going higher. It is way of interaction with people. Read and follow Buddha teaching.

[@sarthakchouhanyoutube25]

Because he is Sahir Ludhianvi of our generation

[@roboticduniya1731]

Manoj- gaane 3-4 minute me bhi likhe jaa sakte h, Irshad- ek gaane ki ek line likhne me 4 din lgte h 🤣🤣🤣

[@pankajgiri6939]

Kamil ji manoj ji ki har baat ko counter karne ki koshish kar rahe hain. Shayad unhe manoj ji me apna bahut bada competitor mil gya hai🤨🤔

[@sarthakchouhanyoutube25]

Kyuki woh gano ko jee ke likhte hai aur manoj as a work likhte hai

[@pahadiInsaan]

बातें समझ सको तो,,दिल में कामिल ,,,👍

[@AnkitG12]

A lot to learn from these legend ❤️🙏.

[@YousufKhan-lx3bb]

Manoj bhai good

[@rajkumartiwari6396]

Wow awesome

[@tanvirqazi9226]

Manoj bhai aap bahot divane ho shayaro ke

[@SAVE_CONSTITUTION_DEMOCRACY]

DONO KO PYAR OR MUHABBAT MERI TARAF SE.. 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

[@jyotirmayeesahoo2539]

Me like ki hun aur dekhrahi hun ye video sirf Manoj sir keliye.. ek sache dil insaan hai ye .. aur sache dil insaan apne self respect pe jyada dhyan dete hain.. Irshad kamil ji k bate kuchh naraj kar rahi hai mujhe.. wo khuddari self respect nahi dikhi mujhe unki batonme.

[@shivamupadhyay142]

Manoj sir great

[@yaadeinwithanju7355]

You guys are legends..

[@yaseenbawazeer3025]

Both are awsome

[@upendrabajpai6175]

Manoj sir love you❤️❤️💓💓💓

[@daksharya8798]

36:45 'ये महकती हुई ग़ज़ल 'मख़दूम' जैसे सहरा में रात फूलों की' frm movie bazaar

[@chetansinghmandavi8580]

Irshad Bhai is best lyricist

[@reelserealeducation3541]

रहूंगा मैं अभी कुछ और जिंदा, अभी तो दर्द मेरा मुख़्तसर है!

[@JOBSURE]

Bahut experience mila mujhe

[@KulvinderSingh-pm7cr]

Irshad has the depth, Manoj is trying to impress people.

[@_13vipanbir]

Tow legend's Irshad and Manoj Sir

[@steekteam1150]

Both legends

[@mannse8137]

Of course they are two of the bests and my favourites But manoj sir is a great orator and speaker as well Kaamil sir is a great writer I really love his writings

[@gauravbasraiyya7771]

Irshad kamil sahi hai aaj jab ye manoj ka time line aur youtube channel dekha to laga

[@HUMSAFAR_SSC]

यहां कॉमेंट सेक्शन में काफी लोगो को इरशाद कामिल एक तंग मिजाज इंसान और कइयो ने तो उन्हे इर्ष्यालु तक बताया है ।।पर जो शायर सच्चा होता है उसे बस सच कहना होता है बिना ये सोचे की सामने वाला क्या सोचेगा

[@sarthakchouhanyoutube25]

Trye

[@SAVE_CONSTITUTION_DEMOCRACY]

Great Legends ♥

[@mohammedjabbar9312]

آج میرے یار کی شادی ھے میرا یار بنا ھے دلہا اور پھول کھلے ھیں دل کے یہ نغمے شادی بیاہ میں گائے جاتے ھیں۔ ان مئں ادب بھی ھے۔

[@user-xx1jj5km8q]

Unka lyrics shakeel badhyuni hai

[@anmol5777]

maza aa gya waah👍

[@raghvendratiwari6304]

Irshad is the honest lyric writer.

[@ramandeepsingh7026]

To all the people who are saying that Irshad ji is angry with muntashir... Thats not true... Its basically two different school of thoughts. One considers himself greatest of the all time (Muntashir) while the other man is so humble and he doesn't takes his success to the mind... Jio Irshad bhai❤

[@sarthakchouhanyoutube25]

Right

[@Dharam.bhai.poetry]

Love this poetry...

[@hkusin3]

मनोज जी को जितना सुनो उतना ही फैन होते जाते आ

[@anandpandey1137]

Like only for Manoj muntasir 👍

[@Aryan-bw3jk]

Before watching full video, I read comments about the anger Ness of Irshad Sir.. But after watching whole video, sorry, I didn't find any thing like this This is his way of talking. I've seen his almost every interview and the way he talks is this.. He takes a question to the next level of thinking. He is not having any problem with MANOJ sir. So pls don't say that he is rude to manoj Muntashir sir Both are brilliant and great Lyricist. ❤️

[@waseemsiddique6800]

bhai chutiye har jagah hnn

[@fullvillagefood1299]

aapke najariya ko slaam dost

[@sarthakchouhanyoutube25]

True'

[@chakreshsingh]

इरशाद कामिल ने कोई disrespect नहीं की मनोज की । वो एक philosophy या फ़लसफ़े की बात जहाँ कर रहे हैं वो सही बात है। hit गाने लिख देना एक बात है पहले के शायरों जैसा लिखना एक और बात है।

[@sarthakchouhanyoutube25]

Hn right

[@jyotiprakashjena7320]

Manoj muntasir ki gane Kano ko acche lagte hain Kamil ke gane Dil me utarte hain

[@sarthakchouhanyoutube25]

Sahi baat

[@sabirajamal2615]

Beautiful program thank u very much

[@sandeshpawar2002]

Irshad Bhai, aapne jit liya!!

[@amazinghammad614]

Manoj bhai aap ki narmi ne aapko r bada bana diya

[@anm1190]

Very happy to see this programme.

[@hariomkumar4510]

my favourite manoj sir

[@2sidesfun516]

Irshad and Manoj sir apke gane sunke hi ye interview dekhne par majboor hogaya...irshad sir apki urdu...lajawab

[@naveenbhardwaj3063]

सैल्यूट है आपको इरशाद सर

[@devendersharma3080]

Irshad Kamil is great writer