Shaykh Hamza Yusuf - Was Abu Talib Uncle of Prophet Muhammad(peace be upon him) Muslim ?

[@xtremeownage2]

Hazrat Abu Talib (Rad) is Muslim.

[@Maf99_]

xtremeownage2 I believe that as well brother, he definitely had the qualities of a Muslim and very much loved the Prophet. Personally I don’t believe he’s in hell, he is saved.

[@sheriefelsayad5578]

Mahfuz Ahmed The Prophet himself said in a hadith that Abu Talib is in hellfire. So you are going against the saying of the Prophet? Arrogance

[@Maf99_]

Sherief Elsayad where does the Prophet say this brother and what arrogance? No one is being arrogant at all. In my eyes I wouldn’t dare to say that one of his most beloved relatives that he himself loved is in hell because we don’t know that. Please show me where the Prophet said this and I will accept.

[@julianramsay4681]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bYLYopRufJx1atE

[@go10965videos]

@@sheriefelsayad5578 There is a legitimate difference of opinion on Abu Talib being a muslim or not,

[@mohamudhassan5196]

If the prophet did not hear the shahada then Allah could have informed him as he informed the death and Islam of king of Ethiopia

[@sheriefelsayad5578]

Answer is No. Very easy

[@go10965videos]

There is a legitimate difference of opinion on Abu Talib being a muslim or not,

[@thefeachaz]

Subhan Allah, what is this man saying??? You know, things like this even if you believe it you shouldn't go around spreading it because the proof is against you not with you. You don't accept ahad hadeeth in aqeedah based on what exactly??? So many situations even in life will be ahad narrations. So if I told my daughter to tell her mother don't cook dinner tonight because I'm bring home food, and her mom says "I will not accept this from you until it's mutawatir (I tell many people and my daughter, her brothers and sisters all have to say it first), is this logical? This is really nonsense and very dangerous nonsense at that, subhan Allah. Honestly it's better for the Muslims and Shaykh Hamza if you take this down because it's not good. Did Imam Muslim believe this? Did Imam Bukhari believe this? If they did then why did they include these ahadeeth in their books? Not to mention Allah said clearly in the Qur'an that you don't guide those whom you love to the Prophet Muhammad PBUH.

[@ماتياسالحنفي]

When it comes to aqeedah there has to be mutawatir in order for it to without no doubt true, then if people dont follow it they can commit kufr or be from ahlul bidah, but there is only that when it comes to aqeedah, if we have a saheeh hadith wich is ahad and the hadith is talking about some legal ruling when it comes to prayer, then we act according to the hadith, but when it comes to aqeedah it has to be without a doubt.

[@aunthegeek5788]

Don't be over-smart.