She Held a Goodbye Party For Her Boyfriend Before Killing Him | THE CASE OF JOE CINQUE

[@lizzynunez4906]

I think all those people that attended the dinners should have at least been expelled from school and been barred from ever becoming lawyers. They all contributed in his death by not saying anything to law enforcement or to Joe.

[@megragottkakasfej]

Well they will become good lawyers with that keeping secret skills...

[@lauriejohnstone8217]

I’m not surprised the people who went to these parties were law students. After all they have to start being immoral to be ready for their law practices.

[@celestialsylvia]

It definitely doesn’t bode well for their futures in interpreting law and criminal intent

[@kokoa385]

FR!

[@jarredv7447]

AGREED!!!!! Just ridiculous. Literally, common sense is NOT common

[@shellymarie216]

Hi Bella, My sister disappeared in 1999. It took me over 13 years to find out what happened to her. Her name is Sherry Leighty. It would be great if you could tell her story because her killer will be up for parole again next year. Feel free to reach out to me for any information. Thank you for your time. ~Shelly

[@nutyyyy]

That's truly awful, I'm so sorry for your loss. Hopefully her killer never gets out.

[@suck.it.6254]

I’m sorry for ur loss :(

[@anastasiyakuznetsov6628]

Oh noo! I would love Bella to cover it so people are aware

[@shellymarie216]

@@anastasiyakuznetsov6628 thank you, so would I.

[@kikichelo7449]

❤️❤️❤️Bella❤️❤️❤️

[@agrelic]

her getting a criminology degree and writing a thesis on murdering her boyfriend is so upsetting. it feels like she’s laughing in joe and his families face??

[@YesIlikebananasSo]

it's so repulsive... what an awful b!tch

[@LuzMaria95]

appalling

[@LifewithAlelee]

She should have never been allowed to graduate.

[@marmedello]

Kind of like those murderers who write books on their crimes and make big money off of their crimes. I think this kind of books should be illegal. And she got an award for writing about how she killed a nice guy

[@irgendwoaunid4048]

The fact that she didn't want him to move on and find someone else after her suicide but she gets to do that now is INFURIATING.

[@cme7527]

I don't even have the words for it.... it's so disgusting

[@empuwm]

Her new boyfriend is crazy in love with her he defends her. Lowkey i want a man loyal like that😂but i would never murder anyone

[@propogandalf]

​@@empuwmYou want someone to cosign your insanity? No. You need someone to call you out on your BS and get you help when necessary

[@marmedello]

It is. Even worse when you realize the whole suicide thing was a lie. She never overdosed herself, despite months of research of how much is needed to do that

[@YanetSmiley]

She was someone very jealous and it looks like she was very obsessed with Joe and hated the idea of him moving on be with someone who wasn't her

[@amaradominica]

Is there a petition for a retrial because this entire case needs to be looked at again. This is apparent injustice

[@jamesdean258]

That’s Double Jeopardy, you idiot!

[@rina-xs7sz]

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@maddieannrox]

Would this fall under double jeopardy?

[@punkieenunez3319]

I don’t think they can it would be total double jeopardy

[@thatvalensteingirl]

They'd have to file new charges to avoid double jeopardy.

[@BellaJames]

This judge needs to be reprimanded.

[@Alex7q9v]

This judge needs to be jailed!

[@leidylopez9531]

This case is so chilling. 2 years for murder?! Only 2?! The poor man went out of his way for this woman, even moved 5 hours away from his home to be with her! This is so insane to me! There was absolutely no justice for Joe and I truly feel for his parents and brother. May he Rest In Peace.

[@silentobserver3017]

How can he even rest in peace? I wish he haunts those evil creatures to death.

[@sharonpaterson788]

WTF

[@toedygarcia4504]

i just wonder what the judge was thinking giving only 2 years?Is justice served,I dont think so?

[@sdefuite5477]

Omg I haven’t finished watching but decided to read some comments. 2 years for murder? This has to be a mistake or something. If not why wasn’t there a re-trial?

[@sumapilkington4914]

Seriously you can't trust anybody there's so many .murders out there family and all she's so disgusting and very evil evil person

[@jorjalines4569]

Is there a petition or something to get this case back to court ? This is insane, how is she walking free?

[@nicoled1882]

I agree. This judge needs to go as well.

[@_ksm00]

wouldnt this technically be double jeopardy??

[@CindyLouWho77]

@@_ksm00Australia criminal law does have a recent caveat to double jeopardy. If substantial evidence has been discovered (such as advancements in DNA testing procedures, for instance), the prosecution can try a defendant a second time for the same crime. Technically, I suppose, the girlfriend (I don’t know how to spell her name nor do I think it bears repeating) could be charged for murder again since the judge found her not guilty by reason of diminished capacity, but attempting to bring new, substantive evidence that she faked diminished capacity, that she was of sound mind at the time of the murder, would be near impossible. Since a judge made the initial determination, it carries more gravitas. Also, she has “crazy bitch” eyebrows. It would be difficult to convince anyone that a person who does that to her face is anything but cuckoo bird. I don’t believe in karma - it’s another human construct that puts chaos into some type of order - but I wish for her the same life she allowed Joe.

[@deararia134]

Maybe.

[@elisabetecristina6188]

I sign the petition for justice for Joe! Where I sign? For who live in Sidney I have a diabolical 💡 idea: one of you all can make a report against anu singh to tell the police she did death threats against your boyfriends! Its our words against her words!

[@samiharowe4625]

I’m just at a loss for words on this one. They basically got away with murder and living their lives. I am terrified especially since Madhavi is allegedly living in close proximity to my family. They need to be locked away for good!

[@willdiesel8431]

She wasn't ever shown...so how can you be sure?

[@sngray11]

There was NO justice in this case! This is so f***ed up. Everyone failed him. All of the people that knew about Anu’s plan to end Joe’s life and didn’t say or do anything. And the lack of sentences handed out to Anu and her friend is mind-boggling. Neither of them should have been allowed to obtain a law degree after committing murder. And harsher sentences should have been given to those involved. 💔

[@amyshew1151]

Think - they too could become asinine judges .

[@fly2292]

Who cares. He's a MAN. Ew. Plus I'm a lesbian. As I should be

[@margaretcundall9637]

These people are complicit to the murder of this man ' and they all belong in jail ...and this despicable piece of 💩...she may have been beautiful on the outside ' but she sure as hell wasn't on the inside...

[@crispyone2564]

@@margaretcundall9637 did you see her tho? 40:19. No one with eyebrows like that can be trusted

[@margaretcundall9637]

@@crispyone2564 I didn't see her eyebrows at first' until it showed a close up of her face...and yes i agree' they are weird just like her...

[@stellamary204]

This one always blows my mind. Why did not ONE person say ANYTHING even if it was a "joke" why would no one mention it to him. I don't know who I despise more, Anu or the bystanders.

[@samih5916]

I would despise both of them, they're both disgusting for causing this to happen.

[@ms.shineray]

We all have to be careful with the jokes som e people tell, because narcissistic people will tell you whatever they think is the true and will call it a joke and that is the way they start to deteriorate your self worth

[@EienOfDark]

The only thing I can think of is, if they truly believed he was not in danger, they 1) therefore had no reason to say anything 2) might've thought he already knew, if Anu was regularly "like that".

[@stellamary204]

@@EienOfDark I get what you are saying but let's say they thought he knew. I'd contact either of the parents, talk to the uni counsellor try and seek help for them. Or let's say I thought she was "just like that" , one of them if they truly didn't know would be like "Joe, your girls doing the most again. What's with the "goodbye party/parties"?" .

[@JMac-27]

Are you kidding me, you answered your own question. How could these people all dismiss psychotic homicidal ideation, um...they are law students. They don't have a conscience they're all sociopaths by design. You cannot be a lawyer and have a conscience or empathy. Quite literally she couldn't have been surrounded by a more ideal crowd of apathetic people for her to express her psychopathy to.

[@sanjanasuresh5565]

This is so sick. It looks like Anu and their mutual friends betrayed Joe. He didn't deserve his unfortunate fate. The fact that she is out of prison boils my blood. It's sad that people stay in abusive relationship.

[@--leilani--]

I understand not taking an attention-seeking person seriously. But the least anyone could've done was check if he was aware of the situation. Like why the party was being thrown... that is genuinely so frustrating

[@stellamary204]

Exactly! Even just a "light hearted comment" to him like " Joe , Anu is so extra with this goodbye party thing" . I'm sure he would have asked what they meant . I wonder where all the "party " guests are now.

[@--leilani--]

@@stellamary204 Yes! Exaaaactly. I wonder too.I hope not in law, but with the way things seem to work out...

[@marielamiranda3066]

Yes!!! Twice 😠

[@jenn.9868]

Crazy that not one person so much as even just mentioned it to him even if they thought it was a 'joke'. This happens so much and it is extremely frustrating.

[@pearlsof5534]

I actually think Anu told everyone to keep it a secret from Joe- she told them joe shouldn’t know why the party was held so they all did just that

[@Sarah-sk4ie]

As a parent, seeing Joe’s mom talk about having to bury the boy she birthed, raised, and loved was heartbreaking. I pray that they find some peace and somehow are able to heal after this horrible event.

[@anabaird3835]

Yep- We mom's always think: "That could've been my baby boy". This is just too much.

[@ImaCountryGirl]

But they do have another son. It seemed like in this story, he just dropped off the radar and disappeared. I hope the other son is able to find some peace, even though the parents have been sentenced to hell for the rest of their lives. Judging by their grief, I don't think they will ever draw another breath that is not filled with pain and thoughts of their murdered son. How do they live when their son's life was only worth two years? I would be tempted to hunt that girl down. I wonder how many years her life would be worth? I shouldn't have read this tonight, now my heart is full of revenge and anger and the futility of it all. I wonder if I'll be able to even sleep tonight. (USA East Coast area) Don't pay any heed to the ramblings of an old woman. Excellent job of bringing this story to us! I love your accent.

[@starlingswallow]

Me too😢 horrible.

[@lovingmayberry307]

Joe's dad, Nino, died in 2017. RIP Joe and Nino. 🙏💙

[@cjhawkins420]

Death by hanging

[@fernandanemr7361]

she not only knew, but she actually helped. she even gave the money to buy the drug, which at least here in brazil is also a crime. if you buy someone the murder weapon knowing it is a murder weapon, that is a crime here

[@Person01234]

Everyone who attended those parties should be slapped with some sort of conspiracy charge. If you knowingly attend like 3 murder parties, at that point you are in on it.

[@celestialsylvia]

Not 1 party but 3!!!! 3 times you saw her talking about her plans and they did nothing smh

[@notnalaysia9710]

LITERALLY

[@deejai1173]

Right. Conspiring to commit murder

[@samih5916]

This case is so outraging, not just at what Singh did to Joe and her friend buying the drugs for her to use on Joe but also the fact that all the other law students knew what she is going to do to him and didn't even bother to warn Joe about it and they're just as bad and guilty as her. Also the fact that Singh only received 2 years in prison as well as leaving to go to university in Sydney and awarded that doctorate award is just an insult and a slap in the face to not just Joe but also his family too.

[@PoojaS17]

Slap to justice

[@pearlsof5534]

Ashamed to justice- in fact there was no justice at all in the case The civilians could have done a better job by beating her up

[@miyuryuu7260]

They treat human life is nothing n life goes on. Imagine a future law in Australia in the hand of those people. So scary

[@ZaZa-nm6sw]

Lord help all her patients.

[@madamnetworkit]

Women need to stop borrowing MURDER THY PARTNER from their boy counterparts 🙃

[@katiewilson5587]

when you said the sentence, I cried. there are hardly any cases I cry over. this is just so heartbreaking

[@seasea1648]

for the first time in my life im ashamed to say that im a law student. this is sickening! may Joe's soul rest in peace and may karma hit hard everyone who was a part of the whole conspiracy

[@hudaahezz]

It's truly disgusting. I wanted so badly to throw up when I read about this case. It's just a shame knowing that he could have been alive if the law students took this serious!

[@frankboff1260]

Probably won’t be the last though….

[@missurielleshakirthesiren-3866]

Well as a Law Student you should know they are not part of the conspiracy. because they didn’t do any of the planning or take any of the steps of the Murder.

[@SerenityChaos1975]

@@missurielleshakirthesiren-3866 knowing about a crime and not reporting it is a crime

[@woodswizdomytvlog2025]

@@SerenityChaos1975 very yes to that

[@sfspurri]

This judge had to be paid off, right?! That is absolutely asinine. Sometimes it still blows my mind that there are people in my country who are serving life sentences on non-violent, minor drug charges. Meanwhile, murderers in other countries are out on the streets again, sometimes even given the protection of a new name and/or identity, and don’t even require constant follow up to make sure they haven’t gone off the rails again.

[@BAW47]

Excellent point. The judge could have very well been paid off. Infuriating

[@amyshew1151]

Judges are lawyers first : Seems like he would’ve acted like all the law students who knew what was coming .

[@tima1520]

A lot of it depends on the case made by the two parties, she probably had a good defence lawyer, the judge can only know what is presented to them

[@sfspurri]

@@tima1520 I mean, I can’t imagine what the defense would have to say in defense of this that couldn’t possibly be corroborated. He wasn’t abusive whatsoever and she was deliberately seeking out information to fool people into thinking she was mentally ill. It feels much more likely that her wealthy parents bribed the judge and that’s why they chose to have the judge decide the case vs a jury.

[@please_im_a_staaar]

I do agree on the follow up thing. Mandatory therapy sessions in jail AND after jail at least once a week/two weeks. And if they don't show up, they can be sent to jail again. But also there is this thing that ppl think criminals of violent crimes aren't able to change which is a way to stigmatize mental illness or generally look at ppl as "naturally evil" thus incurable. Anyway, our current legal system in most of the world is shit cause we don't change the reasons, the root of WHY ppl become violent criminals: mental issues, questionable societal beliefs, financial struggle etc and instead we treat symptoms of these issues.... the criminals, by either executing them or throwing them in jail for life. Which does not have any effect on crime rates. Rates do not decrease because your country's criminals all have life sentences or are on the death row.

[@melaniebrie1556]

Your energy is very calming and I love your makeup

[@breeana2879]

So much for being “depressed”!! Now she is living her best life after she thought she was going to end her life. Nothing screams attention seeker more than that woman and I hope she ends up getting the long term karma that she deserves. She deserves no happiness and she deserves to not know what happiness even feels like. May her life be full of consequences of her own actions. I wish nothing but the worst for her.

[@celestialsylvia]

I know that depression can make people self-centered but she’s straight up malicious. She definitely has something more serious in her brain

[@pearlsof5534]

Exactly! Instead of killing herself at the time she now lives her best life as a result of it- by writing books and graduating- tell me where does this show she even remotely wanted to kill her self or is mentally incapable to have murdered?? She is living the high life and rolling! I too really hope Karma gets her

[@itsbedtimebitch]

lmaooo well said

[@AnaMartinez-cy9fe]

Agreed.

[@fly2292]

Who cares. He's a MAN. Ew. Plus I'm a lesbian. As I should be

[@sarahe3421]

This is so sickening all around. The judge, the bystanders, her friends, but most importantly her. She refused psychiatric help but when the time came she used psychiatric problems to her benefit. Disgusting

[@charaznable8072]

Only 2 years??? Can't his family sue her for wrongful death at least or is that not a thing in Australia?

[@Tryp-j9d]

Can’t they talk to “Vito” about this…”situation?”

[@withoutwings3293]

It’s absolutely infuriating that she got a degree in Criminology and to go on and live a full life after murdering a man in such a calculated manner. An absolute joke. I feel so much for Joe’s family, justice was not served and anyone that was involved with acquitting his murderer should be ashamed.

[@zanderisamazing5043]

Ikr, she didn't want that for him so why should she get it

[@michellep1555]

even more annoying is that. criminal get to study and get a degree for free. meanwhile hardworking people have to pay for it.

[@Cinnyb052785]

Absolutely ridiculous

[@LoLyaNa13]

The outcome is absurd!! She and the other girl now have partners???? Who would want to be around them????

[@mojo2679]

Yep and let’s be honest they are mingers. Why Joe was with that hideous hag in the first place is beyond me.

[@SweetLikeTcakes]

This case is insane. Everyone failed Joe. He didn’t deserve that. And he was about to leave. I really feel for his parents.

[@Pikachuuuu0000]

I'm from India and for the first time I'm feeling ashamed that someone from Indian origin behaved like this. May his soul rest in peace.

[@donnasulja6038]

There’s bad people from all countries, it’s not your shame to feel. 🙏

[@Pikachuuuu0000]

@@donnasulja6038 thankyou. You're very kind ❤️

[@gthoj8867]

Yep. This is maddening. Can't someone look at this case again? This family deserves justice. Joe deserves justice.

[@rossvegas1346]

Probably not. Double jeopardy would be an issue I think.

[@chewchew66]

Unfortunately you can't charge and judge someone for a crime twice one of the principles of most modern judicial systems. There are cases that should be exemptions. But the law is the law. I totally agree he was faild and he deserves justice. Real justice. I feel no pitty for that "lady", doing drugs is a choice (a poor one nevertheless, but still a choice).

[@chellymac16]

@@chewchew66 but isnt Double Jeopardy an american law? Wouldn't it be fine in australia? I dont know, just asking.

[@hoolydooly5799]

@@chewchew66 No DBL jeopardy in Australia.

[@ddivincenzo1194]

@@rossvegas1346 This may not apply to Australia. That is one of the faults of the American legal system.

[@nityanair3720]

I just hate the fact that they both are living their life normally after killing him. It's so frustrating and unfair

[@ednab.9001]

My heart goes to the family, more the parents…. I know exactly what their pain feels like and I just can’t with this whole video. She told the story with a lot of compassion but I’m so overwhelmed by saddens.

[@cuteladybug8622]

Everybody talks about how intelligent (book smart) Anu Singh is, but her real skill is her ability to manipulate people. She gives the phrase "master manipulator" a whole new meaning. Poor Joe didn't stand a chance against her. Joe, from what I've read, didn't have a lot experience with woman; which made him easy pickings for Anu. I'm American and this case has stayed with me ever since I first heard about it years ago. I've also read the book by Helen Garner. If this crime had occurred in the U.S, Anu Singh would be doing 15 years in prison MINIMUM due to calculated nature of the crime. Anu Singh murdered Joe Cinque, and then the Australian justice system let her off with a slap on the wrist.

[@styles_1031]

I thought her name was anure that accent is annoying af😒 very sad what happened to jur tho smh

[@charaznable8072]

It seems she only really truly manipulated Joe, it's really not hard to manipulate someone who is already in love with you.

[@themoderngamer3335]

u acting like the american justice system is better than australia's is laughable.

[@cuteladybug8622]

​​​​​​@@themoderngamer3335 Are you saying that it's ok that Anu served just FOUR YEARS for what she did to Joe? By the way, I never said the American justice system is better or perfect. I just said I think she would've gotten a more fitting sentence based on the fact that the murder was not a crime of passion, but rather a devious, well-planned crime. The fact that she'd been telling people for months that she wanted to kill Joe, speaks to this; and that would've been taken into account when sentencing her had the crime occurred in the U.S. It's like Australian justice system chose to completely ignore the fact that Anu Singh planned the murder down to the smallest detail. It's for this reason that (I think) she received the shockingly light sentence for what she did under the Australian system. I still think the Australian justice system failed Joe Cinque and his family, but that's just my opinion.

[@ohwellwhateverr]

Helps that she’s brown and her victim was white. She can play the race card and the judge/media will eat it up.

[@lisasophii2613]

Netflix needs to make a documentary about this case and then they roll up the case again and that woman gets what she deserves!!!! Unbelievable how crazy this case is and they all got along with this! She is truly the devil in person

[@sniperfoxxx6543]

Unfortunately she can't, it's called double jeopardy..

[@sniperfoxxx6543]

Actually I take that back, double jeporady is only for the US.. Im unsure how it would work in AUS but sure would be nice to actually get him and his family some justice.

[@sofija6997]

@@sniperfoxxx6543 We also have the double jeopardy principle for criminal cases in Australia.

[@sniperfoxxx6543]

@@sofija6997 that really sucks for the family.. No justice served

[@codeXenigma]

@@sniperfoxxx6543 Court of public option can be more productive. If everyone around her knows what she is capable of that is her karma

[@emilywillis9912]

God this is so awful.. The pain she caused Joe's family is inconceivable. How disgusting that those law students knew and said nothing. Not a single person had enough of a heart to speak up.

[@binderkim]

Omg his poor parents!! You can see the devastation on their faces whenever they talk about their son. It's heartbreaking!! 💔 what an awful, unjust case! Absolutely disgusting!!

[@misstigerlilly7353]

The judge should be fired !

[@unknownhumanbeing7935]

I'm usually not a vindictive person, but if someone killed my son and got only two years, I would make sure once they got out of jail their life would be a living hell.

[@SAM-sr3fo]

I hear you on that one. Only in my scenario that person's life would cease to exist except in the depth of hell the moment they would be released from jail. There are no words for this case. All I can wonder is, "Was or Is her family wealthy?" If the answer is yes, then perhaps I will have confirmed my speculation.

[@Anna-vl8qc]

Yes!You and me both.

[@1greenMitsi]

ru sure youre not a vindictive person

[@NatzTalk]

This💛

[@michellemanuel1949]

Facts!!

[@michellejoubert3412]

I've never heard of this case before. It really is horrible! I can't believe what i'm hearing!!! 😡😡😡

[@alexg9924]

the fact that there were so many people aware of all of this and he still died. unbelievable.

[@ellielevine2038]

This case is infuriating. How could NONE of the people who knew what was being planned do anything about it?

[@karinam4115]

Cause they must be evil too, psycopaths

[@fridahndungenzaumi6591]

My question too.?? So sad

[@xxxthatgirlxxx]

this happens so much, groups of people make terrible decisions, everyone thinks they are a passive bystander. because of this psychological phenomenon i actually make sure to take initiative in a group.

[@suzannenichols6900]

It never fails to amaze me how many of these murder/suicide plots end up with the murderer deciding that suicide is just too painful or scary or they just don't want to do it. I say if you're in a murder/suicide plot, FOR ONCE, think of yourself FIRST and take YOURSELF out.

[@nataliegreene4510]

A psychological phenomenon that still shocks me to my core: Bystander Effect- The more people involved/witnesses the LESS LIKELY they are to report because they think someone else will/why no one else has. If you hear, see something SAY SOMETHING: Better to be a misunderstanding and safe then to later realize you could have saved someone’s life.

[@lizellebisschoff808]

The clip of his dad’s emotional display when his mother said “we didn’t want him to go there” is just heart breaking…. As a mom of two boys myself I can’t even imagine what they went through 😔

[@breannaneville4332]

This case is bananas! Love your earrings girl ❤️

[@mattlarew2100]

Every single person at those "dinner parties" should have been charged as accessories. Disgusting case of human immorality and group psychology. Super sad for Joe and his family.....obviously.

[@bre1836]

I've heard this case before and it has lived rent free in my mind ever since. I study Psychology and Criminology with the hopes of doing a masters in Criminal Psychology--it's my passion to understand criminals motives etc but not a single part of this case makes sense to me. I don't know why it happened, nor why nobody tried to intervene its the most nonsensical thing I've ever heard. Genuinely terrifying.

[@celestialsylvia]

Yeah that part was crazy to me. How could every single friend stand by and watch?

[@enuphsayd9746]

This was a wildly, insane epic luck. Talk about "stars well aligned." Crazy indeed. This is literally gods' theatre.

[@gemini1404]

Because they are indians.

[@monicanath4859]

@@gemini1404o my goodness!!

[@Lucy-ie8qw]

💔That was truly heart breaking. Thank you for such a detailed video. Poor Joe.. and yet again the criminal gets a great life. It’s sickening.

[@theIaurenshow]

Joe seemed like an amazing, smart, caring man. He should still be here.

[@taytayqueen7024]

Off topic but I actually love how natural your lighting is, like it goes dark in the middle and you don’t care. It really adds to the sitting in a room listening to your friend tell you a story feel.

[@ladylazarus35]

I thought it was my phone lol

[@SacredArcana]

yes & the sweet doggy snoozing in the back!! so precious

[@euniceqsmith]

Yes! So true

[@rina-xs7sz]

yes, I love how it changes!

[@monicanath4859]

@@ladylazarus35same here 😂

[@alsmith9853]

This case highlights three major issues in the Australian legal system. 1. The useless mental health services 2. The pathetic sentences handed to killers. 3. The lawyers look after their own.

[@jobione3620]

I hope all the people involved wake up every morning remembering how responsible they are for Joes death and consider how useless they are. Condolences to his family my thoughts are with you 💙

[@suzannenichols6900]

They should be tried as accomplices in his murder. They all knew about it; one guy was supplying drugs for it. And she should have been tried for premeditated murder and put away for Life..

[@michelehenne2477]

@@suzannenichols6900 I agree!

[@alsmith9853]

They won't care though, they're narcissist sociopath types by the sound of it

[@margaretmartine9430]

They should be barred from practicing law for life!

[@cassiem7252]

Genuinely not one person saying a THING to Joe is infuriating. That’s just wrong.

[@hightimecrime]

How on Earth is she free?? But this was a great coverage of this case.

[@namantikaraj]

Every law person in this case is delusional and shamefully insane, even the judge. These are the person who fight, represent and judge a real act for justice in a court room. Seriously, in a crystal clear case, where evidences were present, where murderer accepted the crime, this was the final sentence ? 2 year imprisonment ??? Mental health is indeed a real awful issue, but it shouldn't be a way out in a case where someone *perfectly fine* died. WOW.

[@prachibansal6670]

Delusional and shamefully insane...indeed SPECIALLY the JUDGE!! IF JUDGES LIKE HIM EXIST THEN GOODBYE JUSTICE!!

[@LizDaWiz]

SO ABSOLUTELY UNBELIEVABLE /? 2 year imprisonment ??? 👹👹👹👹

[@namantikaraj]

@@prachibansal6670 totally goodbye to justice. At least in Joe's life, there was no episode of justice.

[@AspireGMD]

Literally worse than any other case I've seen and I binge tf out of true crime.

[@Michelle617tate]

Agree 😠 😭

[@ShaynaReneeStyle]

I AM SOOOOOO CONFUSED..... How could she basically get away with all of this..... People get crazy sentences for less.... like the truck driver whose whole life is ruined for an accident on the road that he didn't pre plan or attempt! this is crazy someone need to bring her back.... how dare they....

[@rooder7777]

Rich people can afford the top lawyers while the poor cannot. That is what the "justice" system is all about!

[@sabrinarene_97]

This!!!! I think about his case all the time, his life legit is being ruined for a horrible accident. And this woman premeditated and meticulously planned for months & nobody else who covered for her paid for it either. It’s infuriating

[@sabrinarene_97]

@@labradoriteatheart I think I’m thinking of a different story than what you are

[@shelbygarcia2038]

It's Australia

[@crystalrosas6052]

@@sabrinarene_97 yea

[@janinazcameraroll]

hi bella! i used to watch you religiously a few years ago. i'm rediscovering you know with the crime cases. youtube had stopped recommending you :( turnin on notifcations so i don't miss future videos. sending love to you from america

[@danielmante8075]

There is another one who is like her ,she is called anna solves.

[@jupitergonewild4933]

Bella the true crime content you post helps me get through my busy long workdays it's one of the many highlights of my week! This is such a deeply sad and heartbreaking case Joe and his family deserved so much better!

[@kaylajara2208]

me right now listening to the video while working

[@TriciaMaria]

I couldn’t agree more. These true crime posts keep me going too and it’s why I also share true crime too. The research and learning about law and also becoming aware of the friends and families involved makes me feel connected…I’m right there with you!

[@sindhujaramakrishnan9693]

This case is frustrating. I can’t believe no one thought of alerting the authorities

[@samphillips9109]

Hi Bella. I have just subbed to your channel and love the way you told this dreadful story! This was so tragic and this woman who took away this poor man's life, and indeed his parents lives, should have been put away for life! Purely premeditated!

[@raphaelabravo3852]

This case is INSANE. When you think it can’t get worse, it does. I feel very sorry for joe’s family!

[@rachaelmantoszko]

I'm so glad you covered this case, my mum Robyn was one of the witnesses a couple years before I was born! She was studying social work at ACU at the time which is another Canberra university and she knew Anu, I think they were just acquaintances. She testified in court for Anu's solo trial about a really weird conversation they had in passing where Anu was saying she was having strange violent feelings/urges. So my mum asked if she meant she wanted to hurt animals or something? Then I think that was the end of their conversation, you can read about this in the book. She didn't know Joe or anything else that was going on. So strange of Anu to just mention things like this to my mum who was just this random other student who didn't even go to that university, they weren't even good friends at all and it was just out of the blue. (*I'll see if I can ask mum more about this and edit this comment if there's anything else*) This is the most infuriating case and so devastating for Joe's family and friends, absolutely tragic.

[@coralburriss3546]

This must have taken you a lot of time to put together and I appreciate your hard work.Subscribed! ! What a shame. I used to work on mental health with a forensic hospital. I had many interactions with people who had committed heinous crimes and were found NCR (not criminally responsible) and remanded to the state psychiatric ward. I worked with people that were arrested for crimes ranging from sleeping on a park bench to child murder. The BIG thing they had in common was they could not have pre meditated the crime due to their mental health. Now, this woman was clearly psychotic during this relationship but she did show an abundant amount of pre meditation. Sad to say, Joe would still be alive if people recognized and treated mental health with more care. She was sick, however, this does not excuse her actions. Now her friend and those who knew she was sick and planning to murder her boyfriend.....I can't even see any rational explanation for that. Another take on this event. Mental health is so precious, protect it. You can LEGIT become another person when suffering psychosis. Not excusing any behavior in this story but just a reason.

[@Ind-Voice]

Wait, she had diminished responsibility when she killed a person but has the brain capacity to write a thesis? What? This case is too painful to comprehend. Is she hiding in the US practicing? Good God, help us all!

[@crystalhoskins8155]

I have to say at least her parents were trying to seek help even though they were not aware of the extent of danger she imposed. But as far as everyone else, what the actual hell! The judge should be ashamed. Clearly bragged about her ability to get out of it and both of their knowledge of law should've been taken into account. I'd be angry as hell. No parent should bury their child. I imagine those verdicts were just as hard to take as his loss... Tragic all the way around. How are any of these people practicing law???

[@rooder7777]

Her parents knew she was nuts.

[@crystalhoskins8155]

@@rooder7777 Yes and no. A mental illness does not necessarily equate insanity. When you have the ability to plan for months on end you may still be mentally ill but not insane. Someone who is insane also don't have the ability to realize that. However a mentally ill person can question their sanity. That ability to question is what differentiates the two. But anyhow the point I was making is her parents saw her struggle with the mental illness and tried to get her help. Had they been told by her what she was telling everyone else they could have had her admitted on an emergency basis. They didn't have that knowledge. So therefore they couldn't. Often in these cases the parents look the other way...

[@rooder7777]

@@crystalhoskins8155 they did look the other way and because they are rich got them both off. Anu and Madavi should be in prison for life or have the death penalty for taking a life. Instead they could be living next door. These are premeditated murders. This really sucks. Parents have a lot to be ashamed about in Indian society or any for that matter.

[@DVelez-wz3fe]

@@rooder7777 They’d have to look behind their shoulders for the rest of their lives if that were my child!

[@haileyparsons3844]

Normally I would say no they didn’t, but in they case, I’m suprised that they did try to help her, and did a lot. Like getting her treatment even before it got to the point where she murdered Joe.

[@aprince4u]

Outrageous. That judge should be removed

[@jadepaula]

your hard work and research for these videos is so appreciated bella!!

[@TriciaMaria]

I love the detail she puts in her videos haha but I also love researching for true crime content (hooray for being a geek!)

[@celestialsylvia]

These kinds of videos take FOREVER to research and edit and she always does so well! I also love her camera quality

[@aliciadavie991]

I just wanna give Joe's parents a big hug, they seem like the most lovely people and so did Joe. How some people end up on death row for crimes they didn't commit and this chick only got two years for something so cold blooded seriously baffles and infuriates me wow

[@ChelseaRaeAnderson]

Thank you SO MUCH for sharing his story!!! I just discovered you and I’m so glad I did.

[@laurenwojo]

This is my worst fear as a mother. Truly awful and heartbreaking. If he were my son, justice would be served, like I would be waiting at the prison gates for her to walk out.. that’s all I’m saying.

[@leighannfowler9687]

“Need a ride?”

[@lasagnewolf]

So you can show her your nice garden that you built in the backyard?

[@DK-ex7bt]

Absolutely agree with you!!!!

[@mircat28]

And if you had other children you’d go to prison for murder and traumatize them????

[@fjones]

Lauren...we hear you loud and clear. Many wouldn't agree with you. Many of us would. Justice would be served one way or another....👍😌👍

[@olga5739]

Outrageous! When you said we would be angry after listening to this, I thought: come on, we've seen so much in all the true crime cases, it can't be worse. But it was. It f*****g was!!! I hope Joe rests in peace, and may Anu never know a moment of contentment in her life and not a sliver of calm. May she have the life she dserves.

[@MySnowhawk]

It’s also weird that they allowed her to be off so late got maybe the judge likes her!!

[@gsin311]

I think the narrator has some biases in this case or maybe you think that judges and the judicial system is full of incompetent people. There is a reason why the sentence was light

[@MySnowhawk]

@@gsin311 you do say! Tell us the reason!

[@monicanath4859]

Amen

[@AspireGMD]

@@gsin311 Yeah and that reason is a total collapse of the justice system.

[@shirleybaiza8713]

Those ninja turtle earrings are EVERYTHING!!!

[@hannahmkb]

i’ve been angry at so many cases with various disappointing outcomes, but this one is in the top five for me now. i cannot believe how they both virtually got away with this wtf…joe and his loved ones deserved real justice!!!

[@misssamartypants]

Thank you Bella for highlighting this case. I know this is vindictive, but I hope this draws undue attention in this woman’s life to where she is never successful or happy. I hope this follows her forever, she is never forgiven, she never gets a good job or has friends and her own life is made miserable by a public that won’t forget……

[@amandaleighplans]

I sincerely hope that too. I wonder where she’s at today - I hope she’s miserable. This is sick.

[@amyshew1151]

She should be tagged .

[@lasagnewolf]

I hope someone takes her out.

[@catherineervin2630]

Carve a big M on her forehead for murderer.

[@TheScarletAlchemist]

One of the worst parts about this case is that most (if not all) of the people who knew and went to the parties probably became lawyers. They all should've gotten at least conspiracy charges.

[@tea9893]

I dont get it how, when a specific person has been telling you several times now, for months, "oh I'm killing my bf tonight btw" "oh I just spent $500+ on heroine and pills to kill my bf" you dont get weirded out and actually get worried and question everything. YOU are a law student ffs. I dont get how no one even tried to warn the poor guy besides that one person who still didn't at the end. Truly unbelievable and insane. How is that attention seeking cmon that's way past it.

[@chaoswitch1974]

what I don't understand is why she paid $500 for a gram. it should have been $50. if you've never done heroin, $25 worth can kill you easily.

[@tea9893]

@@chaoswitch1974 she got ripped off probably idkk

[@chloebelle4526]

Infuriating!! That judge was either senile, paid off or taken in by this monster's "charm". He needed to be removed from the bench. My heart breaks for this family.

[@courtneyleigh-anneunderwoo2255]

This case is absolutely devastating. EVERYONE let that man down by keeping silent.

[@jihanemesbah3397]

Her friend makes me sick, what an awful person

[@TriniMonstera]

And I wonder what kind of life she lives now.

[@hudaahezz]

@@TriniMonstera same.

[@nadinejacob6845]

I cant believe you’re covering this case!! I work in the entertainment industry and someone at my work literally ran in the same friend circles with Joe at ANU when this happened… they helped in making a movie about it called “Joe Cinque’s Consolation” crazy case and very sad…

[@monicanath4859]

O really? This would feel doubly sad for you then.

[@davebunnell1105]

You poor thing, I cannot imagine your terror.

[@CindyEdwards-g7r]

That’s what is wrong with society, judges making these kinds of decisions. The criminal is the victim and the victim is the one to suffer along with family members. Utterly pathetic.

[@silentobserver3017]

They should keep investigating to see if there’s any “accidental” deaths around her. I have a strong feeling that Joe wasn’t the only one & there’s no way she could stop the ‘urge’ after walking out unscathed. 🤔🧐

[@soniag4516]

I was thinking of that. Could she have become a mental health therapist in USA? There is an Indian woman on KZbin, she is in her 40s - 50 who resembles this murderer.

[@silentobserver3017]

@@soniag4516 What?? Nooo 😱😱.. Do share the link if you happen to have any extra info. 😉👇

[@monicanath4859]

Right!

[@AspireGMD]

Even if they found out she murdered 2 other people they would just give her 2 months in daycare and call it a day so it doesn't really matter.

[@silentobserver3017]

@@AspireGMD 😶😓

[@Leosandoval-pd6di]

Rip Joe. This lunatic failed him, her friends failed him, and the judge failed him. I have a feeling that this girl will be featured again in a different episode

[@styles_1031]

Rip jur

[@steelmuncher]

The amount of opportunities that had arisen where so many different people could have stopped this is absolutely maddening. I can’t fathom hearing something like that; joke or not, and not saying anything to the person. It’s just absolutely unbelievable, like, incomprehensible.

[@maribelbermudez3025]

This is insane! My heart goes out to Joe's parents. Depression doesn't cause someone to kill someone else. I can't believe this happened. The judge should be put to death. Unbelievable. But I strongly believe in karma. Her day will come. And her friend?! Geez! She completely got off, changed her name and has a family. Life can be so unfair sometimes. But her day will come, too. RIP Joe......

[@gloriasimiyu5082]

A

[@maribelbermudez3025]

@@gloriasimiyu5082 ??

[@gloriasimiyu5082]

Sorry Maribel, this was a butt dial type of situation.

[@maribelbermudez3025]

@@gloriasimiyu5082 lol. it's ok. i thought it was a code of some sort. lol

[@sunflower-gj7jk]

Truely disgusting! How could so many people fail him?! How can those two women just be allowed to ho on with their lives like they didn't murder someone!? 😡

[@celestialsylvia]

It’s so disheartening!!!

[@MilleBaxter]

The fact it was judge only trial makes it even worse that they let them just murder someone and basically walk free.

[@EmiliaMarques]

I can usually stomach gruesome crime scene details with ease but this case truly made me feel sick… the fact that so many people knew what was coming and did nothing is just outrageous! This poor man and family … his mom said it best.. she really seems like the devil

[@conigliana]

everyone with that kind of eyebrows is clinically insane. also all of the people that went to "last dinner" things are accomplices and should have never been given a chance to practice anything remotely similar to law.

[@silentobserver3017]

That eyebrows.. I literally had the same thing in mind!! 🙊

[@LuigiCp30]

It's the psychopath's eyebrow

[@israamo9604]

This is just so heart breaking! So sad to see such a broken justice system

[@greenkodak]

I used to watch you in 2019 and i’ve just been so busy with life and im so glad that i’ve come across your videos again and to see how far you’ve come, you 110% deserve it 😁

[@No-sv6mu]

This is terrifying on so many levels. I know a guy I went to highschool with who served more time for driving on a suspended license (got sentenced to 3 years after the 3rd offense). Unreal

[@kingkohli4952]

But he is a MAN and most importantly not a lawer. This is one of the so-called ” male privilege ” that lot of women complain about

[@tituscollins892]

This is the most painfully saddest story I've ever heard. Everyone in this was damaged I pray for Joe and his parents

[@OhRaez]

This aggravates me beyond an imaginable point. Knowing justice is not served for millions, and we protect the criminals more than the victims is disgusting. This really is a STRONG point for the death penalty, law reform, and a better vetting process for judges in our system. The fact there is no justice for the family is tragic.

[@elifayhan2480]

There should never be a death penalty

[@rooder7777]

I agree Anu and Madavi should have got the death penalty but that doesn't exist in Australia, sadly.

[@OhRaez]

@@elifayhan2480 You know what, I've believed that for many years myself. But people like this particular case honestly deserve it. After the evidence is 100% covered and confirmed, she could be sentenced to that for all I care. I'm sick of seeing extremely evil individuals consuming resources for years, and being allowed to experience the gift of living another day, while the victims die a torturous death and their family is broken forever. We let a successful man with a potentially great contribution to soceity die, and a psycho killer get off scott free for killing him. Add to that, the justice system failed to deliver any form of justice. It often doesn't in certain matters as this, and killers abuse the "insanity" plea to get off free with barely any accountability.

[@oh-6613]

The state should never have the power to murder anyone

[@OhRaez]

@@oh-6613 The libertarian in me agrees, but after hearing such a disgusting and barbaric case as this, if she was given the death sentence I wouldn't bat an eye

[@sadgurlzluvbunniez]

Something similar recently happened to my brother. The woman and man responsible are not in jail, but the police are still investigating trying to gather enough evidence to hopefully charge them both. This was really difficult to listen to, but thank you for covering this case.

[@jazziemin]

so sorry you’re going through that. don’t worry they will find the evidence and you will find your peace of mind 💗

[@monicanath4859]

O my goodness! I am so sorry to hear this! May justice prevail!

[@davebunnell1105]

You poor thing, I can't imagine the terror you felt.

[@MacT4972]

46:47 She looks hard and much older than she is. Her spirit shines ugliness; evil! This case is INFURIATING! Rest In Peace, Joe & May God give his family strength.

[@gdeane922]

What is even more terrifying about this is that a Canberra and ACU is where a lot of of Australians politicians come from. That all these law students did nothing and then went on to join into law in our political capital is honestly so scary. How do we know these people won't join politics one day or haven't already. I'm studying law and ethics is a pretty big deal

[@evaxoxo6864]

Everyone that knew what she was planning should have been held accountable for Joes murder!!! Absolutely ridiculous sentencing she should have gotten at least 30+ years with no possibility of parol

[@tinamarlow506]

I agree!!! They should’ve been accessories to the crime. Especially her friend (Midharvey?) This world is coming unhinged…

[@morecm3322]

Joe's poor parents. My heart goes out to you. A lovely young man taken away. So so sad.

[@tommiegnosis]

I have severe anxiety, insomnia, and depression and borderline traits and have never ever in my life attempted to kill another person nor have I wanted to. That argument is bs and if her mental health caused this then she should not be around other people at all, period.

[@danarigdon1591]

A trip to a prison in China or Turkey might whip her into shape

[@ellssuzanne7224]

This case is genuinely infuriating. The anger and heartbreak Joe’s parents must feel has to be crippling. I listen to a lot of true crime and this is probably the most unjust case I've heard. So incredibly unfair. Anu Singh deserves life in prison without the possibility of parole. Everyone else who was complicit or helped with his murder should have been charged too.

[@jayjo77144]

My heart goes out to the family 💔 Sincere condolences to everyone that loved Joe Anu is clearly conniving i cannot wrap my mind around this case T.y. For covering his story He sounds like he was a wonderful human

[@KatMerriam75]

WTF?? I thought the US justice system was broken but this takes the cake!! Who is this judge?? They need to be taken off the bench. Omg I am pissed cant imagine how Joes parents feel

[@amyshew1151]

Likely everyone involved may have been charged as they were in on the planning therefore as guilty as the one who did it.

[@tgrice601]

I wouldn’t be shocked if the judge was at 1 of these parties at this point this is just sad!!

[@tgrice601]

But also I don’t think the justice system in the US would’ve even did this even tho it is definitely bad but damn I think with all this evidence I think the ppl here would’ve did their job

[@elinalukaziak693]

Her family obviously paid them off. Deport them all 😡