FINALLY REACTING TO Preacher's Daughter by Ethel Cain *it hurts* │ Part 1 (FIRST Interpretations)

[@Orlandoflrd]

TIMESTAMPS 🪔🏚🍂 0:46 FAMILY TREE (INTRO) 5:11 AMERICAN TEENAGER 11:44 HOUSE IN NEBRASKA 22:01 WESTERN NIGHTS 29:07 FAMILY TREE 34:36 HARD TIMES

[@nickimozaj4600]

Omg thank you

[@Pqrplex]

This comment helps explain the lore: Ethel Cain is from Shady Grove Alabama and is the daughter of Joseph (the preacher) and Vera. The album takes place in 1991 when Ethel is 20, and her dad died 10 years before the events of the album. The man she's singing about in House in Nebraska is named Willoughby Tucker, who was her highschool love (as she says in the song), but they broke up because of Ethel's actions/behavior. The house isn't actually in Nebraska, but an abandoned house that they would imagine was there. Hayden said that the song was inspired by an abandoned house she used to drive past off the highway south of Quitman, Georgia which she’d daydream about constantly. Western Nights is about another man named Logan Phelps, who is a criminal and in the lore later dies in a police shootout. Her father was also abusive to her, as shown in Family Tree and Hard Times. She then runs away to Texas where, in Thoroughfare, she meets Isaiah Abram. While it seems like a happy song, there's a missing poster Hayden made that says Ethel was last seen being forced into a black truck, so Ethel could be an unreliable narrator. Then in Gibson Girl, they've reached California and Isaiah has began pimping her out and giving her drugs. Ptolemaea is her hallucinating. August Underground and Televangelism is her dying (from being killed by Isaiah) and her soul going to heaven, respectively. Hayden has said they're kind of two parts of the same song, with AU being Ethel's physical death and TV being more of her spiritual death. Televangelism is also improvised! SBF is her reflecting on her life after she's died and thinking about how she still finds comfort in the church even though she hasn't had the best experience with it. And finally, in Stranger's, Isaiah eats a piece of her body which then poisons him. Then the slower part at the end is her talking to her mom :) Her next project is an EP of the b-sides of this album that will focus on Ethel's teenage years and her relationship with Willoughby:) one of the songs will be 20 mins. then her next two albums after that will focus on Ethel's mom, and then her paternal grandmother making it a trilogy. she also plans to write 3 books (of which she's currently writing the first) and make 3 movies. (This was a copy of a comment i saw somewhere else but cant remember the og so sorry creds to them!!)

[@sherthetruth]

Glad to return. I was overwhelmed by the length so I decided it would be easier to break into two parts. Part 2 will be here this week. I want to say tomorrow but I know myself. Miss you all!

[@VenusAsAFormerBoy]

Two parts was a great decision, not only is the album long but it's also sooo dense. There's so much to talk about!

[@aguapanelaconcloro3169]

You can react to marina and the diamonds(also)MARINA now,especially ELECTRA HEART,please❤

[@TGPgrxy]

Love the video! ❤❤❤

[@Krustenkaese92]

seeing people realize what this album actually is about will never get old haha

[@evandersolis5528]

The mattress is dirty in ‘House in Nebraska’ because the house isn’t actually in Nebraska, it’s an abandoned house, they just fantasized about the house being in another state

[@usermay6607]

That prolonged ":O" after you read the meaning behind "Hard Times"... so true

[@headinthewall]

HELP I WAS SO IMMERSED IN THIS AND THEN 33:29 HAPPENED AND I CANT BREATH THAT CAUGHT ME SO OFF GUARD

[@ortigozaseb]

Fr

[@laffydaffy222]

breaking down to House in Nebraska is SO real 😭

[@badmiracle]

crying during the back half of house in nebraska is so real. the stripped down repetition of “i feel so alone out here….” is so heartbreaking lmao i get misty eyed just thinking about it.

[@mr.perezident9381]

I personally think the line about the soldier in AT could go either way tbh, in the sense of it being a callous dismissal of a veteran’s suicide due to ptsd, reflecting how mental health issues like depression is stigmatized as a product of laziness or weakness, that those who do struggle with trauma like Ethel or the veteran are expected to just pull themselves up by their bootstraps and simply work harder to overcome their hardships.

[@sloaneshi]

Hard Times has gotten me through so much. Easily top 3 of the album for me. So gut wrenching but so incredibly cathartic.

[@Melekinh]

The “The neighbor’s brother came home in a box, but he wanted to go so maybe it was his fault” line isn’t referring to unaliving yourself, but to him choosing to join the army and dying overseas. That’s what she meant by “Another red heart taken by the American dream.” It criticizes the blind faith many young Americans put in their country. edit: My bad, I saw you already caught it immediately after commenting 😅

[@sherthetruth]

Haha I completely missed the plot first listen I was editing and thinking I’m so off 😫

[@darksideofthemoon8034]

Skin is glowing and that face card never declines mama. Love your takes and interpretations.🤎

[@shadyjoanneboots]

When I first heard and read the line "Please don't love how I need you" I thought it was a misheard lyric cause I didn't think it made sense initially, but my interpretation now is that she means "Please don't take advantage of how much I need you", like she's worried that he knows the effect he has on her and would therefore ab*se his power over her, due to how dependent she is of him. At least that's one way you can interpret that line

[@VenusAsAFormerBoy]

Just finished the video and can't wait for part 2, ending on Hard Times hurts so bad 😭. I'm glad you've decided to look into the meanings of the songs, though! While I love hearing your interpretations, this album is just overflowing with so much storytelling that a lot of people don't pick up on first listen

[@66GreenDragon66]

FINALLYYY Thank you so much Sher!! Love your reactions and interpretations of the lyrics

[@lukavojinovic7246]

Golden Age and Carpet bed are a must too!

[@eyeorigins77]

this album is so HEAVY

[@restinte]

i am SO happy to see you check out this album. everything about this project is so raw and real and even painful, but cathartic at the same time. it's alot! i don't know much about music but i know that ethel cain is someone very special. very excited to see part 2, i love your reactions and interpretations! thank you for the compassion and respect you give to the projects you check out.

[@ttwolleftffeet]

i’m not a complete expert on the albums lore but i’ve come to find out that house in Nebraska is a song portraying ethel cains first love, with it being pure and innocent. They found each other in their small, tight-nit, religious town and only could find understanding and solace within one another. on the edge of their town they found an abandoned building that they would turn into their escape. (hence the dirty mattress) they pretended that it was a house far away from their hometown in the middle of nebraska. they dreamt that once they grew older they’d turn this dream into a reality but it never happened. it hurts more knowing that the “house in nebraska” was only ever a concept that two lovers used to cope and it hurts even more to know that ethel cain still considers it home even though it was never real.

[@Buffaloreplaced]

YAAAAAAA Ethel Cain so excited to hear your thoughts. It’s a very intense album and I hope you’re okay after listening to it 😭😭😭

[@theunitedkingdom]

i’m really touched by this first half reaction! i feel like watching your videos i almost never feel the need to skip through because your analyses are so concise, compelling, and charismatic. excited for the next one and hoping your ring light feels less feisty next time.

[@headinthewall]

Just finished watching and I’m so excited for part 2 it’s gonna hit you like a TRAIN ON A TRACK

[@Pqrplex]

SO excited to see ur reaction to this masterpiece of an album. So much story telling and hidden meaning its literally endless and beautiful and open to interpretation but also so well thought out and personal and detailed and clever. Amazing writing. She is a one of a kind talent for sure.

[@meganwhite1352]

This whole album should be played as one long music video. I know Beyoncé and Lana did this with Lemonade and Tropico but…. There truly is nothing like this. There’s something about early 90’s satanic panic in the gothic deep south tying religion and reality and intertwining good vs evil. This whole album is a story. A very dark, story.

[@iy3274]

Love your videos so much! I have some requests for you :) 1.) Shiver by Jónsi. Jónsi is the lead singer of an Icelandic post-rock band formed in ‘94 called Sigur Rós. They are known for their ethereal sounds and angelic vocals. On “Shiver” Jónsi partners with A.G. Cook (PC Music Founder , Charli XCX + SOPHIE collaborator) and creates one of the most immersive, personal, simultaneously freezing and blistering listening experiences I have ever had! 2.) Desire, I Want to Turn Into You by Caroline Polachek. I love your review of her album “Pang”. Where Pang feels like a fairy tale wrapped in winds and waters, Desire, I Want to Turn Into You feels like ancient myth encased in earth and fire. I recommend listening to the deluxe version as the additional tracks contain a lot of poetry / spoken word, and just generally expand the universe of this album. 3.) Fountain Baby by Amaarae. Amaarae is a Ghanaian-American singer-songwriter. She makes futuristic Afropop and is a sonic sorceress in her own right. This album is a lush, kaleidoscopic waterfall. The album is swirling with themes of passion, the dark and light sides of abundance, and the consequences of pining for glory. I love your videos and hope you have time to listen to these albums even if you’re not able to review them!

[@LifeOfJakoby54]

hey! love this video this is honestly one of my favorite albums of all time and love to hear ppl talking about it bc it’s super complex and dark but also so beautiful and well done

[@m_milos]

oh my god!! so ready for this

[@lajoiasensational]

THE QUEEN IS BACK YALL

[@matt_jmurphy]

yayy so happy to see you sit down with this album

[@chichi5779]

Mama this was so amazing!!! When will we be getting part 2? I have to see you reacting to some of my favourite tracks on the backend of this album

[@jakobandersen3944]

This album is so good. Another album from last year, that I think you’d really enjoy is The Record by Boygenius.

[@heavensfavorit333]

I´M SO HAPPY YOU´RE BACK OMG

[@Thig2000]

I WANTED TO SEE YOU REACT TO HER FOR SO LONG IM SO EXCITED THANK YOU !!!!

[@iDownUnder]

Ahh I’m so excited to see you analyzing this album!! I just started the video but it’s one of my favorite albums this decade and I am READY!

[@nottrigonometry]

the queen is BACKKKK!!!! YUHHHH LOVE YOU SO MUCH

[@Cyceris]

So excited to see you react to this body of work !

[@eduardojefferson8736]

sher you're so special i love watching your reactions

[@rojurr]

queen reacting to a queen

[@nemintheorbit9976]

omggg i love your reaction and your take on this albumm love you girllll

[@nathangrimes4071]

THANK YOU QUEEN

[@welcometodmitrysworld]

Youre finally back and reacting to Ethel too 😍

[@headinthewall]

Was literally about to go to sleep but now I NEED to watch this

[@lukavojinovic7246]

Omg finally, Family Tree (intro) changed me forever, definitely my favorite ❤

[@AustinAshburn]

ONE OF MY FAVORITE ALBUMS!!!

[@simounnn3591]

OMGGGGG!! im so excited for this i love you!!

[@cybergloc]

PERFECT TIMINGGGG

[@spiralysts]

OH WE WONNN SO HARDDDD

[@Freezerbride5]

Omg I’ve been waiting for this I’ve recently discovered this album and love also love your reaction 😄❤️

[@anakin8132]

OMGGGGG This is the best day of my life

[@punkstarsx]

We need part two now! haha

[@babashart8574]

33:29 HAS ME CRYINGG😭😭

[@downhere5413]

omg i cannot wait for the next part!!!

[@dxntonio]

CANT WAIT FOR PART 2

[@HeirHypnos]

18:08 this time it is about a breakup yes- (every time i listen to this album i cry so you’re not alone lol)

[@UncleThuggy]

Omggg I’m so excited to see you react to this album

[@diubatte]

Oh baee, I hope you're doing great! You're very especial. 🫴🏾💗

[@odlyb5338]

hard timessssd hits soooo harddd

[@westcoast2114]

omg thank you for this, we ve been waiting for this!!!

[@DioJeans]

I’m so excited for another Ethel Cain reaction! Just watching the video now, subscribing to see part two

[@johndavidpisigan8816]

OMGGG I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS!

[@chetanveersidhu753]

This video made my day❤

[@ayoru3323]

yay great reaction, love your videos!

[@davidd.666]

In American Teenager when she refers to the neighbor coming home in a box is probably reference to the wars is Iraq and/or Afghanistan

[@marinacarmelle317]

Yay!! Please check out Stick Season by Noah Kahan, it’s an amazing body of work!!! It’s discussion around mental health and post-pandemic world is unreal.

[@dayt0nam3th]

i haven't been well since the first time i heard hard times and its been almost two years

[@evandersolis5528]

33:29 I GOT SO SCARED LMAOOOO

[@inmyfeelings9]

I WASN'T EXPECTING THIS OMG I'M SO HAPPY

[@shadyjoanneboots]

I clicked as FAST AS I COULD

[@randychavez1979]

Can't wait to watch ❤❤❤

[@CharlieKarate]

So happy to have you back!! I love your reactions to Lana Del Ray, please go back and react to Paradise and Born to Die; I think you’d really enjoy those! Thank you for all your content!

[@iguessssssillmakeayoutubec1642]

This was great.

[@badboy4k8]

You should react to Noah Kahan's Stick Season! Since you loved Folklore by Taylor Swift, you'll definitely love this one as well.

[@sorayawashere]

Thanks 🙏

[@predohenr]

you should give a chance to the record by boygenius!!! i think you'd really like it!!

[@ineedacigarette1688]

Natural Born Losers by Nicole Dollanganger must be next

[@thegayben]

praying

[@dxntonio]

YESSSSSS

[@alexdunn9029]

I'd love for you to listen to Jubilee by Japanese Breakfast at some point! Her song In Hell makes me cry every single time I hear it

[@starlitrug3575]

YESSS

[@JulietMHorner]

❤

[@girlheav3n]

I interpreted “The neighbor’s brother came home in a box-But he wanted to go so, maybe it was his fault” as unaliving as well.

[@oiergarciaaoiz7195]

has youre opinion changed on ocean boulevard? in my experience it has grow so much on me, that album is fucking insane

[@chadstchad]

♥️✨

[@tylapi]

OMGGG YESSS

[@19sopp_5]

i really wanna see your reaction to bewitched by laufey 💗💗

[@gothhy]

I would love to hear you react to King Krule😇

[@aguapanelaconcloro3169]

You can react to marina and the diamonds(also)MARINA now,especially ELECTRA HEART,please❤

[@andrew01016]

yay

[@thewhisper4269]

i always thought for American Teenager, shes talking about military with the Neighbor's Brother + Long Cold War

[@alexandrareuter327]

Yeah, I'm pretty sure that's what Ethel means. As far as I'm aware 'to come home in a box' always means to die and be shipped back home. Soldiers dying in war seems the most obvious example. I thought it fits into the religious theme of the song because lots of Christian families and communities are all about 'Christian values' (pro life, etc.) but are simultaneously supportive of the military and are proud to "serve their country". Lots of young men get fed a glorified image of joining the military and then end up traumatised or come home in a box. And when I continued the video I realised Sher clearly thought the same. 😄

[@indyvision]

pls someone do a timecodes