SHINee moments with no heterosexual explanations part 2

[@AnnaWatermelonLovesJonghyun]

edit: i think i may have indirectly misled some of you. the clip with the old lady is a popular meme that i edited. in the original clip she was reacting to a Shakira MV. it was wrong of me to assume everyone was familiar with the meme and i hope you aren't too disappointed that FBE didn't actually react to SHINee's reunion. also the clip that appears for like 2 seconds had to be cut due to copyright :/

[@MeAmLoveU]

i just want to point out even though the vid is for fun alot of the subs are alittle off but i guess we cant help it because the language difference is alot :

[@AnnaWatermelonLovesJonghyun]

@@MeAmLoveU where?

[@cryinglaughingemoji1741]

That video is a meme but the video on it have the Same Energy with the original anyway lmao

[@yacobeinauan9533]

But even if people weren’t familiar with it its still normal to use memes

[@moonchild8249]

"his lyrics are often pretty gay" SENT ME INTO SPACE OMFG

[@she5786]

Hail his creation 😇

[@WhatASillyLady]

“Jonghyun in general” -lol BYE because that’s so accurate

[@marchymeow4584]

Gotta stan 💎

[@yaoibabe]

It really is 😂

[@itsjiminsnonexistentjams1221]

Honestly 😂

[@grethi8110]

period! lmfaooooooooooo I love him so much

[@WhatASillyLady]

@@hselena4074 absolutely

[@gigigiooo]

Honestly this is more like what healthy masculinity looks like, men being so comfortable with their identities that they can express their affection for their friends and even make jokes (like girls do) with each other and even expressing themselves with their fashion and their looks. Wouldn't that be great?

[@malyceascarlet9837]

Yes. I joke with my girls all the time that I'd marry them or give them children in a heartbeat. I'm asexual, most of them are straight, but we still joke like that. I mean it's healthy in a way, because you love these people so much you could marry them, and it shows that you're comfortable to do so. I wish boys would feel more comfortable with that.

[@kdfkdf1711]

Yesssss. Except jonghyun...his actions were a lil more than fan service and regular korean skinship between close friends.

[@kdfkdf1711]

@@malyceascarlet9837 depending on the country, they are.

[@MandySam13]

Being affectionate and being vocal about their feelings/how attractive another female is, is normal among women! However with men not so much. I love that these guys just go with it. It’s how it should be. You shouldn’t have to pretend other men are not attractive to conform to some cultural norm!

[@Feelkkari]

It is both a blessing and a curse. Korea is so heteronormative that no matter how touchy guys get, it’s still assumed they are straight. But actual LGBT people who come out are often faced with apprehension and hostility

[@4ry4n44]

as someone on twitter said "shinee has dating scandals only with men"

[@aishas4818]

Please, Minkey wanted a Dispatch article written. They were practically begging for it.

[@sophiec9305]

What’s Dispatch? And why is it important? 😋 (sorry I’m genuinely curious)

[@xenexian]

@@sophiec9305 Dispatch is a Korean news outlet and they're pretty famous for revealing couples within kpop

[@anyaal9248]

@@sophiec9305 its Koreas biggest gossip/ celeb news company they are known for exposing celeb relationships / confirm dating rumors

[@sophiec9305]

@xen creates @Anya Al upon hearing that, HAHAHHA dang! Yeap Minkey was begging for it. I’m an international fan, so if there were to be gay couples in the industry would people feel infuriated with it or are they more accepting now? (I’m not saying Minkey is a romantic couple, and I’m so sorry. I’m genuinely curious about this)

[@taibatahir9704]

@@sophiec9305 I'm curious too so if anyone can answer plz tell

[@samiewamies]

I think SHINee is one of the only groups in Korea were toxic masculinity is practically nonexistent, i love that about them. The fact that i can't even listen to Playboy without having gay thoughts! Also, i approve Prism playing in the back.

[@WhatASillyLady]

I was just thinking this. They’re truly a different class

[@marchymeow4584]

Shinee demolishing toxic masculinity since 2008 💎

[@xxxXKPoPXxxx]

@@marchymeow4584 Taemin has mentioned that because everyone including men saw him very feminine, he wanted to be more manly. But I think being in SHINee where Onew is a sensitive listener, Jjong is a romantic crybaby who encouraged men to cry more, Minho readily showed affection to men, and Key didn't care about gendered clothing really helped him come to terms with being more feminine once he reached solo songs like MOVE. Whereas debuting in EXO, we would never know how he would develop since it's a more traditionally male group.

[@WhatASillyLady]

@@xxxXKPoPXxxx im a fairly new shawol but omg that is so beautiful. O know taemin is friends with jimin from bts and jimin exudes gender neutrality (some people will say feminine, but lack of masculinity is not femininity), so that makes this info that much more precious

[@phoebeyuu4525]

@@xxxXKPoPXxxx Yes, I really enjoyed that particular interview, especially the way the other members validating Taemin's feeling after he said that he wanted to be appeared manlier. "People often said that I was pretty." "But you ARE pretty!" "So I want to be manlier." "But you ARE manly!" Shinee's hyungs says no to toxic masculinity since 2008 indeed!

[@user-ii9mm7ol8d]

1:00 “( _pause_ ) because i like girls ( _pause_ )” is just so funny to me

[@greenasemerald8635]

I wanted key to be there lol 😂😂😂

[@nikkichase4006]

Yes when I read that I was like awwww baby hims so scared to be hims self 🤭

[@NotDaveGahan]

He realized he gave too much away lol. We want to be cryptic bi you know.

[@ninadj1074]

@@nikkichase4006 even if it's a joke it's not funny it's disgusting how you dismiss the fact that he says he's straight

[@nikkichase4006]

@@ninadj1074 when and where did he say that and when did I say that is was a joke because my comment didn’t say any of that

[@lm.1221]

TAEMIN SAYING HE DOESNT HAVE MALE FANS??? IM RIGHT HERE

[@zsarifahnathar344]

^^

[@yourbelovedex6255]

SAME

[@blue70033]

Doesn't he know that he has huge international male fans by now?

[@hermelaahmed2177]

MEANWHILE THE WHOLE KPOP MALE IDOL BEING TAEMINTS TOO!

[@lawrencedance2450]

Taemminie, If you need me I ll be here, right here

[@littlefish5646]

3:57 what historians say when they see gay people

[@abadbuddy]

PLS-

[@marchymeow4584]

LMAOOO 😭😭😭

[@alicewonderland9160]

Can someone tell me where that clip was from?

[@alicewonderland9160]

@frozenbananas ahh thank you!

[@jadajadapatton6374]

Do you know we’re that clip is from

[@VegaEridani]

In a recent episode of Knowing Brothers, Minho goes on a fiery, full blown rant to Key about Key's seeming total disinterest when Minho returned from the military. Minho goes, "What are you going to do about my broken heart??? TELL ME NOW!" Then later on in the show, one of the game challenges was, "Do something dangerous." Key kneels down and "proposes" to Taemin. Taemin smiles slowly, Onew is laughing his head off and Minho just *stares*. Aight, Imma head myself out and look for my missing marbles.🤣🤣🤣 Also on one of their variety shows, Minho "dazzles" their Noona by throwing confetti. Jonghyun grabs Minho by the collar and demands, "You want to steal not just Noona's heart BUT MINE AS WELL??? 😅😅😅

[@marchymeow4584]

Minho sus 😼😼😼

[@marchymeow4584]

Jk jk unless.... 👀👀👀👅👅👅

[@yooseul__]

@@marchymeow4584 unlesss 👀👀👀

[@mooncherrie]

@@marchymeow4584 unless

[@xxchocolat_samaxx3758]

Unless 👀

[@KassWinnie]

"Jonghyun in general" WELL, ISN'T IT THE TRUEST TRUTH

[@cowboyenthusiast1783]

the fact that there's a part two of this says a lot

[@moira86529]

there's a part 3 now lol

[@alyssaschonefeld8590]

Anybody in shinee could say "I'm gay" and there are only 2 possible reactions. 1. Noone believes them because we think it's a joke because it's obvious or 2. Noone would be surprised because it's obvious as well 😂😂

[@taibatahir9704]

Lmao it's so true

[@vidoublex5417]

I'm also laughing because the way Taemin said "I want to hug (hold) him" can also mean wanting to be held in *that* way from what I learned with Japanese media and such, NSWJAKSKSK so them repeating that and Key even quipping with "or is Jonghyun the one hugging you" HDKJASHDA I LOST IT

[@luwenjun2079]

Did Key just say Jonghyun tops 😭✋

[@saturn4rchive]

Jonghyun talking about Gong Yoo on Blue Night Radio and praising him was so common that sometimes guests were like ''don't u talk about this guy a lot'' lmfaoo

[@faentasy]

the “jonghyun in general part” lmaoo

[@gyuniverse0_1]

3:57 "ThEy SeEm To Be VeRy GoOd FrIeNdS" -My mum when seeing my two friends (who are together) cuddle

[@jadajadapatton6374]

Do you happen to know we’re I can watch that video

[@gyuniverse0_1]

@@jadajadapatton6374 I've actually looked for the original video that has "they seem to be very good friends" in it but I think the creators took it down?

[@simaigrek5173]

This five man have all my love

[@baakojernigan7095]

As a lesbian... I'm often doubted and not accepted in my family and the religious environment I grew up in but can I just give Jonghyun some appreciation for this? Aside from the questionable lyrics 😂😂 he's always said such comforting words towards people who are "different" and it really helped me, made me feel validated and not so alone. Jonghyun's words and actions felt like a warm hug and I just really wanna say thank you for that, so THANK YOU!!

[@choco.__.cat8088]

i feel u. when i often feel alone/ different or out of place, his lyrics and words feel like a warm blanket to me aswell. they help validate my emotions and thoughts and i know im not as alone as i feel. i thought you might wanna know theres someone who found ur comment and related to it😅(im also a lesbian too🥰)

[@dashraj8069]

I love Onew's reaction to kisses.

[@elipeace4512]

Minkey is literally our old married couple for a reason! Also... these days they're literally saying it loud~ kkkkkkkk

[@rhiannonedwards9870]

minkey legit being my reason to live

[@MandySam13]

IKR? I love them so much! That love-hate thing they got going....hot!

[@Ca-yr2rz]

Gay or not, i really really love their different ways of healthy masculinity, and i love they can be a role model for new generations

[@layla-8369]

Idk why but i laughed at the "keep kn mind rain is built LIKE THIS" 😂

[@daysjours]

This is such a fun video -- so upbeat and heartwarming. How full of life and sex appeal was Jonghyun?? He was magical. They all are. But Jonghyun had a wattage that was blinding.

[@marchymeow4584]

It's the jonghyun effect 💫💫

[@MandySam13]

He’s not called Bling Bling for nothing!

[@KD-lf5vn]

@@marchymeow4584 For sure

[@kkbisco]

It's really comforting to me that all the members are so confident in their sexuality and show no bias whatsoever. You can't really find a lot of groups like that in kpop. I love them all so much

[@amparobiosca3387]

Eso es lo que me atrapa de ellos, pueden hacer bromas sobre su sexualidad, sin que las personas los juzgen, todos han salido con chicas y han tenido citas con mujeres, pero defienden la homosexualidad de forma abierta Jonhyun desde la radio y con canciones como Payboy, Key Mino con su relación, sus juegos de besos entre ellos ( que me encanta, pk siempre e pensado que esa maculización de macho alfa es una idiotez ¿Por que no pueden darse un beso? ) con un montón de años durmiendo juntos, verse desnudos, y criando a un niño adolescente, cuando ahun eran crios ( yo e criado a dos hijos y en esa edad los hubiese matado en varias ocasiones y en otras los hubiese matado a besos) esa relación con Taemin, y esos besos ..... son como hermanos ya, de hecho creo que estan mas unidos entre ellos que con algunos familiares. Aparte de hacer programas tontos y dar el dinero a obras caritativas. LOS adoro

[@tatlockandfriends]

not “jonghyun in general” LMAOOO 💀

[@gotchujjang6093]

I still cant believe minkey is on the first page of dispatch’s site sjsnwksnksmsks and k-nets r all congratulated minkey

[@pae7672]

I would be shocked if I found out that all 5 of them are straight... Seriously. I would be so confused :D

[@say_woo]

Yeah same lol

[@melonkio3178]

Like Honestly me too but id Taemin is straight, I'll have trust issues

[@MandySam13]

Taemin is looking for a Mum for Koongie! 😂

[@ajaiy]

@@MandySam13 he know he’s her mom haha

[@annw99]

I would not be surprised because I use myself as an example. many people in my life thought I was not straight but turns out I am 🤷🏽‍♀️ 😂

[@m.st.6657]

I'm kinda sure Key can't be straight... But it's his thing, not our business. Just wanted to say what I think 😂

[@kittyelf1485]

I’m pretty sure he’s, “eh, whatever. I like who I like.”

[@m.st.6657]

@@kittyelf1485 Yeah, you're right. None of our business

[@kittyelf1485]

@@m.st.6657 I actually meant I don’t think gender really concerns him all that much, but you’re right. His business, not ours.

[@gwendere]

He’s into boys, he asked one of male friend out...

[@sokyoul]

I think everyone knows, just sadly its still a a taboo for idols in Korea

[@blue.johnstone.z]

taemin: "i don't have an male fans" me: me: HJSHAJKHSAKJDAS YOU HAVE ME

[@cielncore]

I love the fact that SHINee is one of the only groups which has never had a fragile masculinity, it just doesn't exit here, there's NOTHING

[@chuasianghoe563]

Damn... well done guys this is quite the positive comment and respectful section on a potentially controversial topic Even the replies are respectful

[@lostfroggs]

Jonghyun's daily to-do list: -play kazoo -be gay

[@bbbbbbbbbb0]

Minho happily peeping the interaction between jjong and onew @ 0:25 and then quietly minding his own business is a whole mood 😂

[@gds5959]

KEY FEATURED IN THAT YEARS AND YEARS SONG?????????

[@alprince1999]

This?? I had no idea

[@elleshawol7175]

YES. so good

[@phoenixangel13]

he is in a remix of it! if you look for the title + remix + key you'll find it!! it's great

[@phoebeyuu4525]

Yes, and he sounds SO GOOD! =///=

[@repa7046]

Jonghyun: I like girls so I wouldn’t know what is attractive in a man… anyways **goes on to describe every detail he loves in men like a teen girl**

[@kam-ku1sz]

Minho reaction when he caught JongYu flirting 😂😂😂

[@ShirouAtsuya]

for those who don't know, in this part 6:21 the word hug in japanese can also mean hold (as in fucking, which is why taemin laughed and then was corrected by the radio host(?), so that explains the "or is jonghyun the one hugging you?" joke, ofc u know what i mean. (please correct me if i'm wrong lol)

[@kittyelf1485]

Holy penguin I forgot how much I enjoyed watching these guys, and how fun, yet questionable so many of their interactions (with each other and other people) were.

[@ayeshasuliman4540]

Why do I need BLs when a whole SHINee exists

[@phoenixangel13]

big mood

[@taeheechoi6938]

I love this video it's amazing also it's cool to see how different they all are. Like for example Onew and Minho have the most straight vibe but when they go gay, they go gay 😂😂 Key I'd say is somewhere in the middle just like me "I don't have to gotta choose blues~" 😂😂 And Jonghyun with Taemin definitely seem to be swinging the other way 😂😅 Pls no hate I'm not assuming anyone's sexuality it's just for fun I don't care about their sexual preferences but yeah If you ask me I don't believe that all of them are straight.

[@v.6433]

Key is actually the one, who is most rumored to be gay lol. Seeing you put him in the middle is kind of funny 😂😂😂

[@taeheechoi6938]

@@v.6433 Yeah well it's very much influenced by me being bisexual 😅 Sometimes he gives me the same things I would do or say and that's probably why I see him more in the middle 😅 But like I'm fine with whatever sexual orientation they have cuz I love them from the bottom of my heart. I am just very very scared that many kpop idols who are part of the LGBTQ will never be able to come out as it would ruin them in South Korea so much :( Like for example Ten from WayV/NCT who just gives off so many hints about not being straight - for example wherever he is talking about his ideal type or future relationship he never says "The girl I would date..." He says "The person I would love..." It's always person or significant other never girl which is like a big hint that people from LGBTQ community use when they are worried to come out but just don't want to label themselves as straight... I just want all the kpop artists that I love to be happy and live the life they want but I'm worried that they Will not be able to do so.

[@MandySam13]

@@v.6433 I think Key’s in the middle too! One day he’ll up and choose who he ends up with. I hope when that day comes he chooses with his heart & not out of any compulsion. Everyone should be free to be who they want to be, and with whom they want to be! The rest is BS!!

[@ipeace6145]

I always unconsciously notice special treatment towards Key when he is with other males. It's something that I can not help noticing every time he goes on a show. Or with members.... Or I am just a lunatic 😂😂😂😂

[@hazahae]

taem has a tonne of male fans tho

[@myka1659]

3:59 "It seems they are very good friend" How we breath ?🤣😭😭

[@wv757]

Not sorry and everything about SHINee screams extreme LGBTQ to me, and I'm LOVING it! 😌

[@delulu6969]

1:22 Irene's like, he's my ally

[@Julianna_w]

Love the bit with Ming's 2PM interaction. Visuals unite 🤩

[@indigoslife1202]

6:41 Hgmhgm, Taemin, you gay is showing

[@HangryKitsune]

It always baffles me how these guys still have some LGBTq-phobic fans or fans who are in super hetero-protection mode for these guys who literally *insert part 1 and 2 of these videos*... like... that is not all just jokes and fanservice.... And no I am not a real shipper (I actually don't like real shipping), but I am an LGBTq person and love how supportive and open Shinee are.

[@naddd7308]

Lmao dispatch seriously? An article about minkey 😂😂😂😂😂

[@katzukemiyami5284]

Taemin caring for fanboys 🥺.

[@parboninawar5850]

3:20 LITERALLY the entire 4th generation Kpop boygroups are your fanboys Taemin!!! 😑😑😑😑

[@RaginPancakes]

3:12 taemin no need to worry you already have the hearts of many fanboys, mine included

[@zsarifahnathar344]

oh

[@caroand15]

Omg Taemin talking about Jonghyun's back hahahhahahahhahahaha we understand you Taemin hahhahahaha... and we know that's not a joke hahahahhahahah

[@belerinah]

This made my day so much better.

[@brita4587]

The ending clips had me straight up snorting 😂😂

[@katerin_0273]

too much straight vibes, i can't possibly take it jk GIVE ME MORE

[@Shadify100]

''Jonghyun in general'' LMAOOOO yeeeesssss

[@LostFoxMister]

3:11 Like you don't have male fans Taemin, my brother would hug you, I've he ever have the chance

[@shineeroun]

im subscribed with notifications but i didnt get a notification for this masterpiece why are you doing this to me youtube

[@FallSouthWinter]

Everyone: So you want Jonghyun to hug you Taemin: N- no? 😅😳

[@smartie1098]

The way the video starts with If You Over Me - i knew it was going to be good

[@abeearoundapomegranate5333]

I will never not laugh at Key putting Minho on speaker phone at 5:17

[@melaniedey20127]

I will be genuinely surprised if it turns out any of SHINee are actually straight. I love these men so much, and I’m sure there’s enough material like this from across the years for like 15 parts to this series 😂 #SHINee5Ever 💎

[@annakalkman552]

WAIT Key did Years & Years??? omg kings honoring kings

[@daaishifeeling]

the fact that there's an entire section dedicated to "jonghyun in general" plsssssssssss

[@totorohawkeye3109]

Some of them aren't gay moments, it's just hugging, it's actually very healthy for a relationship and everyone should do that. But some of these moments... Well if there's indeed an heterosexual explanation, I'm curious about what it is 😅

[@anonymously_7226]

MINKEY interactions are what I live for

[@moonbbxe]

4:01 well.... cant argue with that

[@marchymeow4584]

Awww onew's part made my heart go boom soo cutee 😭😭

[@springdayisnottoday371]

pls minkey is a rich couple and we all know it

[@amarillaflower9414]

Que alguien de una explicación no gay jajaajajaj. Love them

[@makicabrera]

Jonghyun bby I too have a Gong Yoo fixation it's normal

[@sapphics.4Loona]

Jjong gives huge pansexuel vibes 🥰🥰🥰

[@marchymeow4584]

Jjongie the king 👑👑💅🏻💅🏻

[@isid977]

Thank you for making this video ❤️ I feel happy for them for being so comfortable around each other!

[@oreo_8433]

when people say "kpop is gay" i guess they weren't wrong 🫂

[@DivaQuinzel]

If there's a part 3 I would love to see some Jongkey moments! JongKeyTV is old but gold 💕

[@annw99]

Ikr I think the video creator is a new fan. in the past it was all about jongkey and 2min now babywols don't even know about jongkey that well :/

[@nivedNnethan]

Changmin and kyuhyun 😂😂😂 fallen for minho

[@tatanasagitari3044]

SHINee 🌈

[@Feelkkari]

Pretty sure Onew is the only mostly straight guy in SHINee

[@simplygiselle23]

he got a pretty soft spot for key

[@melmedina2287]

Este video me hizo sonreir como hace mucho no lo hacía! Solo ellos saben hacerlo. Ellos son como un arcoiris.

[@cgd295]

This is so comforting thank you so much, I really need this idk why🥺

[@6v6-c4u]

SHINee is the most gay for each other

[@aebxo6916]

Really want to know the behind story of the Years and Years collab, not sure how famous they are outside of the UK but if there's one thing people will know about them, it's that they're openly gay go on Key that's our boy!! 🔑❤️

[@lexisstevens5903]

Pls does anyone know the song that plays at 0:24. Their vocals were show stopping, fantastic, amazing

[@AnnaWatermelonLovesJonghyun]

Sweet Surprise!

[@harriettholmes539]

They loved playing around on stage with one another like that for their fans. Knowing fans would find it a sense of humor.

[@m.st.6657]

4:06 and Key's princess cake

[@chan-hc4gf]

I think i need someone to make me the song list in jonghyun in general part

[@dollcoric]

AAAAA I ADORE THIS

[@sapphics.4Loona]

me as lesbian shawol is enjoying the view full of rainbows 🍿🥰...

[@m.st.6657]

"Just Jonghyun in general" CAN'T

[@tallier6766]

Jonghyun in general Love it

[@moira86529]

i love how with Jonghyun, its "Jonghyun in general" hahahaha

[@smadhu0576]

Can you tell me the song at 4:46 I'm sorry I am dumb ALSO "Jonghyun in general" LMAO I CANT😂😂😭

[@AnnaWatermelonLovesJonghyun]

you're not dumb for asking a question! that's how people learn ^^ the song name is 2 : 34!

[@smadhu0576]

@@AnnaWatermelonLovesJonghyun ThaNKYOUUU 😭💜

[@smadhu0576]

@@AnnaWatermelonLovesJonghyun also love you 💜

[@gucciguppygangd5328]

Minho was looking at both of them and when Onew was blushing/smiling Minho smirked 😂😂💕 0:24

[@yacobeinauan9533]

Not Tae saying he doesn’t have male fans. Bro i am your fan and I’m sure i ain’t the only guy.

[@kdfkdf1711]

When i first got into kpop, i thought korea was so much more accepting of homosexuals. The idols behavior and anime/manga convinced me japan and korea were more tolerant than the west. Only to be very disappointed. Fanservice and shipping - all fake-sighhhh. But at least skinship was real. Healthy close platonic physical affection between same sex friends.

[@HangryKitsune]

yeah... but not all fanservice is fanservice. I have the feeling some idols are in the closet and hide behind fanservice while using it to still express themselves.