We had a little disagreement... who's RIGHT? THRIFT with us for VINTAGE HALLOWEEN (and Garfield)!

[@soonergirl755]

I agree with Janine. 😺

[@AH-jj9hp]

One of those Garf’s ate more lasagna than the other😂

[@ShinyBriteDoggo]

🤣🤣

[@barb-jm7990]

Best answer yet!!! lol

[@southernmermaid2526]

Yaaassssssssss

[@dlittle7983]

That was my thought, too. The newest Garfield needs to be fed. 😁 Do you keep them both?❣️

[@tracy_222]

Love the brightly colored table cloths👍🏻🎃

[@DMinSFBay]

I have the candy jar that matches that clear HALLOWEEN mug with the trick-or-treaters. My mom had two of them in the 80s and 90s, and she gave one to me. SUPER nostalgic!!!

[@kcs69sign]

I NEED ONE OF THOSE SNOWMEN AND SANTAS THAT HAVE THE LIGHT UP NOSES SO CUTE.

[@southernmermaid2526]

My cousin is a doctor. She also loves to shop. No clothes, shoes, or jewelry gifts make her happy. Find her a vintage Garfield and she will love you forever ! 💙🐱

[@shawntennant9049]

Oh I love Garfield

[@lauriewilliamson8176]

I remember the ghoul with the breaking arm. They had several a white skeleton, purple spider and something else. They shake, eyes light up and make noise ( I think - 1998 Walmart). My son was born in 1995 in October - Loves everything Halloween. I had bought a set of those from Walmart. They are from late 90's. Unfortunately, we had a couple of spook houses that my BFF and I did for our young kids - with their T ball team. Well some of the other kids tore them up trying to play pinata - with them. I just remember, they had a lot of cool stuff in late 90's for Holidays. I just started watching - Love seeing all the vintage finds !!

[@dawnpatterson7005]

I have to say I think Laura is right the Head is bigger the paws are bigger the eyes are bigger and even when you turned them around the whole backside is bigger lol I don’t like taking sides but you did ask and it’s definitely a bigger size🤣🤣🤣🤣🧡

[@louisasmom]

I loved that Cookie Monster marching band plush! So cute! 🎶🍪

[@dwightevans-dy3yk]

i can't choose between them both! They're so adorable! I LOVE Garfield! You guys have excellent taste!

[@piper320]

OG Garf is a bit more pudge, probably because he has different stuffing. Both are super cute!

[@hunnybee1977]

I agree with Laura, the Garfield you already had is chubbier than the new one. Good finds tho!!😊

[@pennyskelly8657]

I agree they are the same size except for the eyes

[@barb-jm7990]

I have to agree with Laura- The recently purchased Garfield looks slightly smaller. They look like twins where one twin is slightly taller and larger. I imagine they were two different runs at the factory and the supplies had changed slightly(the eyes) and the person sewing made slightly smaller seams leading to a slightly bigger Garfield after it was stuffed. The paws even look slightly bigger on the older one. But, they are close- really close.

[@karenmccarty6759]

Have to give this one to Laura. But so close to the same ........love you two so much

[@lisamacleod7552]

The old one looks wider and has wider eyes.Both Garfields are adorable!

[@jessielacy2526]

I would have to say height wise, the Garfield’s are the same but the one that was already at home is slightly more “chonky” 😊 The smaller face on the new one does create the illusion that it’s smaller.

[@carobinsonrobinson3109]

I live in California, we never have any good finds like you guys have not even close!

[@NessieMay]

I think the Garfields are the same height but the one with the bigger eyes is chubbier, but they are both adorable.

[@jennlynnthreewishes3586]

I think Laura is right. Either way, they are cute.

[@maureenhelm1917]

Both adorable one is fluffier

[@shawnawalker2719]

Love the mugs!!! Thanks for sharing them!

[@jensta1000]

The dear head hangs on your doorknob.

[@blugreen123]

I'm so jealous of that Scary Stories book collection! 😍

[@creepyspookyicky]

For items you want to keep in your own personal collection that have a bit of damage, a chip like the ghostie has can be 'fixed' with a swipe of clear nail polish so it's shiny again!! You guys are so much fun! I have three guys like your guy with the 'fur hat' LOL. one of mine shuffles forward, rings a bell attached to his palm& his eyes light up red & it makes creepy noises. The other one is HUGE & hangs from like clear plastic fishing string. His arms are stretched out in front of him like Superman, his eyes light up red & he SHAKES VIOLENTLY. neither of them make any damn sense & I fkn love them. The big one is my 'baby' LOL!! Back when I got them, I found a CASE of the flying ones & bought them all lol. ( It was the mid90s& they were cheap as hell!) I ended up hanging onto them until I started ebaying & sold all but the two I kept. They were sooooo cool! I've never seen the style of the one you found!! So many cool finds!!🌈👻🌈

[@creepyspookyicky]

I had the green skull frog arms guy!!! I got him in the 90s & im almost 99% positive I got him from Big Lots. I canNOT remember if he made any noise tho!! 😿

[@elisaaguirre7578]

😂 I think one Garfield has a potato body with big eyes and the other a bit slender with small eyes. I feel they look very similar lol love the clear Halloween mug. So cute

[@galinag.8386]

that dog plush is really cute. the ears flutter. i have one somewhere

[@VintageTreasures-1]

You two are so funny. I liked the vintage Halloween apron, and the book bundles. Love your mug collection. I have two Snoopy Halloween mugs I use year round. The Garfield that was recently purchased looks a smidgen smaller. You two have a great day, and thanks for sharing.

[@cindytunstall2314]

Idk about the size since the newer one has been squished, but the one you’ve had longer looks fed up with the newer one hahaha and the newer one looks like he has a hang over 😂😂 seriously though I love Garfield myself so they are both a winner

[@tayloralexander7597]

Sharon here... I agree with Laura, the newest Garfield is smaller than the other. Not a bunch, but smaller. 🤔🤐👍

[@nolasdollsandaquatics9386]

After putting the new Garf in the wash he will probably fluff up...🎉 they look the same to me. But all Garfs are created equal...

[@melissariley9268]

love this video the Garfield with the big eyes is a little bigger but the both are so cute lol

[@WaterWhirld]

The Garfields are the same size but yet they're not....

[@christinegreywolf]

I'm still waiting for my local thrift store to put out more than 6 Halloween items!

[@marlenelarsen5766]

Hi! Girls. Love your videos. I have a Rudolf reindeer with a blinking red nose. Made of the same material as your Santa’s and Snowmen. Didn’t realize there were other ones. Would love to find a Santa and snowman.

[@ellier3817]

Could the skull_ frog guy be some sort of boglin it has the same kind of rubbery arms ?,

[@AnnaMills-l3r]

How about taking one of your new tablecloths and making foldable, sizable totes to hold your estate sale finds while you're shopping? You can use it all the time and make other shoppers jealous of the cool design!!

[@ShinyBriteDoggo]

That’s a great idea!!

[@faeriefire78]

Every time Jeannine wears that shirt in the first clip I just go 😍 I absolutely need that shirt!

[@gardenknitter4]

I bet that knock off Pooh bear is a prize from the boardwalk at Seaside Heights.

[@wendyreid9326]

The original garfield does look a little bigger than the new one to me. They're both classically adorable Garf though :)

[@Krystalemm]

You guys cracking me up. One Garfield ate one more slice of lazana then the other. Thats the answer.😂😂😂😂

[@cupcakepinup1]

That bear in the black kitty costume was adorable 🎃

[@becktheanglophile]

The one Garfield has bigger eyes and has more filling than the other. But if you took the filling out, I bet they are the same size. They’re identical twins where 1 twin gained a bit more weight than the other 😋

[@CuriositySavedTheCat68]

The original Garfield is more chubby and the head is bigger. They are both adorable thou.

[@bizzielizzie913]

Yes Laura it does look bigger🐱

[@carmenzermeno7707]

One is slightly bigger😄❤️

[@peggypeter8070]

You can clean the batterie tabs by using baking soda and toothbrush

[@dianametcalf1814]

Another fun video 😊

[@samanthacalciano8211]

Old Garfield that you owned prior is heavier/fatter looking even in his expression. Scratched up Garfield looks more petite in expression. Probably different years or factory. I had a similar one. The Christmas rabbit looks like Velveteen Rabbit?

[@elainebazzy-ek1bf]

The newer gar is smaller ! LOL hope I was a little help

[@mikemc4340]

The original Garfield was based of the fatter version in the early comics, Garfield was slimmed down later comics

[@janeleslie4192]

New to the channel. Where does this store find this stuff? It’s amazing.

[@tataakalulu9450]

Donations...supposedly profits go to Lupus foundation...

[@janeleslie4192]

@@tataakalulu9450 thank you, I never heard of this store before.

[@shannon_w.]

OK so first off I got SOOOOOO many compliments on my 2023 Shiny Brite Doggo Halloween shirt and I told everyone where to get them and second I have a vintage animatronic skeleton and his white robe is kinda stained do either of you or anyone know what I can do to clean the material?

[@ShinyBriteDoggo]

Thank you Shannon! That's so nice to hear! Hmm, I would try using dawn dish soap first scrub it. If it still needs help I would try wiping it down with oxy clean(or soaking if you can remove the robe). I hope that helps! 😊

[@kristicourtney8099]

I would love to buy a snowman and Santa blinkers. Whete do I do that?

[@jannicelockley8424]

Laura... we need to start a drinking game.. take a shot every time you say Janine 😅 You gals are great!!

[@Goldenfinds]

I definitely think the Garfield with the bigger eyes is a tiny taller and wider. Joe and I use to thrift together but now it’s solo trips for me!

[@janiebrossmann1178]

Omg u guys keep hitting the Halloween items jackpot once again 🎃

[@ginadoyle6335]

Laura is right on the Garfield

[@brittanydickinson2205]

The original Garfield has a bigger head and body. They are very similar, but the original looks bigger.🐈

[@leannerumbolt7337]

One size down from it I says on the Garfield

[@dianebecker1419]

love your new haircut

[@ShinyBriteDoggo]

Thank you!

[@Kat-my8xy]

The one you had first is a little chunkier he must have been eating to much lasagna😂

[@cattygirl218]

When are you decorating your apartment?

[@arodriguez819]

One vote for Laura!

[@debsherman9453]

It’s like you have a set of twins and one is heavier than the other. But basically they’re the same size that’s my opinion.

[@jorobinson8835]

I think Laura is right the new one is a wee bit wider. I wanted to say they're the same though just to up the anti 😂

[@triplethreat2226]

Ok. Gonna settle it here: the OG Garf, looks like Bootleg edition lol. I hate to say it, but I’m with Laura. The newbie looks more authentic and, squished aside, if you were to take a piece of yarn and measure their width, in fact, the new one looks larger. Height, they likely stand the same. I think the OG Garf looks larger because he’s so disproportionate 🤪 Overful, fun haul!! Thanks for taking us long 😊

[@jellydontshake]

Am l crazy but did Jeannine have a costume change and get a haircut 💇‍♀️ or was this two separate days? And we would all be hammered with the drinking game for every time Laura says Jeannine! 🍺

[@barbarareed3661]

They appear to be the same height but the older one has more girth. Measure the circumference and height.

[@Rylee.Reichert]

My grandma has that chicken nugget Garfield but its been awhile since I saw it because i haven't been in her toy box for months but i bet it is still there

[@dianerobinson9248]

I think the one Garfield is definitely bigger. 👍

[@capitalstitcher622]

One Garfield had a few extra pans of lasagna for dinner!

[@barbsnyder3579]

Well, the home Garfield is slightly chubbier.😅

[@ErikaAnnSings]

They are the same size, 😂.

[@staceygale3965]

Laura ✅️😺

[@aileenmattas7928]

The older one is chubbier, slightly bigger.

[@wendee1186]

The 1 on the right is Bigger now on the left lol

[@jellydontshake]

Laura wins the “cat fight”

[@christinescreationsespinos8062]

Yes it is a tad bit bigger 😂

[@dawnpatterson7005]

🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃💀👻🍁🍂🌽 I have that exact same parachute pumpkin but mine is faded because I washed it so many times and it was my son‘s first Halloween plush after a couple months of being born. I bought it in 1992 and have had it ever since and recently sent it to him lol great fines today and I’m so glad you guys are doing well with your sales. I do enjoy watching your videos but I don’t buy a lot of stuff because I have so much of it myself but one day when I get to my storage units I will send you something through your PO Box and surprise you.

[@ginacrowley9830]

I have to agree with Laura on this one, sorry Jeannine.

[@kylie78100]

Your one at home has definitely had an extra pan of lasagna!

[@wendy982]

One Garfield looks fatter than the other.

[@gretchendemasi768]

My nose is broke but I’m still valuable

[@sherrykellum7471]

The two Garfields are very different. They are not the same size.

[@shawnawalker2719]

The original is larger. Look at the mouths!😮

[@jenniferwelsh4017]

I tend to agree with Laura! Don't hate me, Jeannine!

[@hummerfan9360]

I vote for Laura.

[@paultotten3740]

I vote Laura

[@courtneydor2vintage632]

Your 1st Garfield is chubbier they are the same height. 😂

[@momokoblue8032]

Bigger eyes is also larger than smaller eye Garfield, smoosh or no smoosh. lol Laura wins this one.

[@ouchiey5684]

It looks as though your original Garfield has been taken apart washed and re-stuffed as you said the stuffing is different so maybe that’s a solution for you

[@deborahbergen3777]

Laura is right!

[@leannerumbolt7337]

I jest still want to apologize for what I did I really didn't try to bid on anything I'm so sorry love's watching you guy and I don't know what I'm doing on whatnot I'm new sorry ladies 😊

[@RuthHendrix-m2r]

Laura is right

[@OriginalAKH]

I’m sorry, Jeannine. I love you both, but I have to agree with Laura on this one.

[@cindythornton5799]

See who is right at home.

[@alisaburgess2890]

Lol yes he's bigger even his eyes yess!! On camera it's bigger lol😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🎉🎉

[@dianajemison105]

🎃