Should We Point our Fore-Finger in Tashahhud or Move it Up & Down? - Dr. Zakir Naik

[@fasafe7194]

Allah give Dr Zakir long life .He is the best Allem and make every thing ease in different cases for the people .

[@fasafe7194]

From UK

[@RitaFernandes-mr1yi]

Zakir is caniving and manpulative. Look for the meaning in the dictonary

[@irshadsayemahmed2135]

He is not an aalim...he is quoting fatwas of scholars...

[@heisenberg2984]

​@@irshadsayemahmed2135everybody does same even aalim does that

[@khinxaw6415]

​@@irshadsayemahmed2135 who can be called aalim according to you then , the mulvi profession that was created in the subcontinent around 200 years ago? Aalim means who has ilm (علم) (knowledge of the Deen).

[@AliAhmad-us9kq]

السلام علیکم I Was Researching the Hadiths About Forefinger in Tashahud. Muslim 1307 to 1011 Sunan Nisai 1269 Mishkaat 911 Dr. Zakir Naik this Video Great for Learning!

[@Brraziqved]

Maashaallaah!

[@muhammadsulaiman_2490]

👉Hadith on Moving index finger while making dua in Tashahhud: 📚Wa'il bin Hujr said: "I am going to watch the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) and see how he prays. So, I watched him." And he described (his prayer): "Then he sat and lay his left foot on the ground, and placed his left hand on his left thigh and knee. He put his right elbow on his right thigh, then he made a circle with two fingers of his (right) hand, then he raised his finger and I saw him moving it, supplicating with it." (Sunan Nasai 890 and 1269)

[@Brraziqved]

Maashaallaah!

[@aibert6893]

Jazzakallah khairan

[@dev_khan]

One thing that we all generally forget that Hazrat Abu Hanifa was Taba Taabayeen means who saw those who saw Sahaba which means he is most closest to the Sunnah of Prophet PBUH

[@LaFromage-i3q]

closest doesn't mean correct. what is correct is authentic evidence. stop blindly following imaams

[@HajiMilad-jv4ke]

May Allah swt grant dr happiness and jannah

[@MustafizulIslam-o9g]

Aameen Summa Aameen ❤

[@MustafizulIslam-o9g]

Jazakallah Khairan Sheikh Dr.❤

[@TariqSalymAziz]

Zakir Naik when he was young he was very extreme on his opinions like most of the ahle hadees but alhamdulillah he have become extremely good as we can see clearly that he understood that we cannot just wipe out off " ikhtilaf " from the ummah. Because even among the sahabas there were ikhtilaf so its natural and its not a big issue. . but sadly there are so many specially ahle hadees people who are very narrow minded I would say. Zakir is still ahle hadees but the 10 years back zakir naik and todays zakir is very different. My only request is to all ahle hadees be like zakir naik. Try to learn how he have spoken. You can have your opinion without insulting the others.

[@Reshi-k7i]

There was no ikhtilaf between suhabs it is lie all these differences were started after the arrival of four imams, remove these four imams you will find very minimal differences

[@akagamishanks7330]

Here we got the fifth imam😂​@@Reshi-k7i

[@zakirhabibmir7137]

I don't think Zakir is Ahle Hadith now, i have seen him clearly stating that one should get above the divisions that we have created(including Ahle Hadith sect) and follow the path of Sahaba RA

[@Adam-w4r5e]

He is a muslim... don't divide him into sects... let him be a muslim only... and we too are Muslims...

[@SohailAh46]

The same can be said about other schools of thoughts and sects within that school of thought. They view others opinions as incorrect and call them names and think that only their way is correct and *the most close* to the prophet ﷺ. Don't drag only ahle Hadith into it. Look into the hanafi ppl as well, they are mocking, making fun of and passing ridiculous judgements for other opinion and other schools of thoughts. Be very careful with your words Br. Aziz. Don't fall into the category of narrow minded people. May Allah guide all the ppl and forgive us for the mistakes.

[@rusithau918]

أَخْبَرَنَا سُوَيْدُ بْنُ نَصْرٍ، قَالَ أَنْبَأَنَا عَبْدُ اللَّهِ بْنُ الْمُبَارَكِ، عَنْ زَائِدَةَ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا عَاصِمُ بْنُ كُلَيْبٍ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنِي أَبِي أَنَّ وَائِلَ بْنَ حُجْرٍ، قَالَ قُلْتُ لأَنْظُرَنَّ إِلَى صَلاَةِ رَسُولِ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم كَيْفَ يُصَلِّي فَنَظَرْتُ إِلَيْهِ فَوَصَفَ قَالَ ثُمَّ قَعَدَ وَافْتَرَشَ رِجْلَهُ الْيُسْرَى وَوَضَعَ كَفَّهُ الْيُسْرَى عَلَى فَخِذِهِ وَرُكْبَتِهِ الْيُسْرَى وَجَعَلَ حَدَّ مِرْفَقِهِ الأَيْمَنِ عَلَى فَخِذِهِ الْيُمْنَى ثُمَّ قَبَضَ اثْنَتَيْنِ مِنْ أَصَابِعِهِ وَحَلَّقَ حَلْقَةً ثُمَّ رَفَعَ أُصْبُعَهُ فَرَأَيْتُهُ يُحَرِّكُهَا يَدْعُو بِهَا ‏.‏ مُخْتَصَرٌ ‏.‏ Wa'il bin Hujr said: "I am going to watch the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) and see how he prays. So, I watched him." And he described (his prayer): "Then he sat and lay his left foot on the ground, and placed his left hand on his left thigh and knee. He put his right elbow on his right thigh, then he made a circle with two fingers of his (right) hand, then he raised his finger and I saw him moving it, supplicating with it." Sunan an-Nasa'i 1268 Chapter 34: Clenching two of the fingers of the right hand and making a circle with the middle finge, Book 13: The Book of Forgetfulness (In Prayer) Grade: Sahih (Darussalam) sunnah.com/nasai:1268

[@johnstanley7874]

I am not sure why the people asking questions have to mention their professions, totally irrelevent. I hope the class system created by the British in India can one day be discarded.

[@sazid1762]

Brother dr zakir naik himself says this to tell your name address and profession while asking any question

[@joshoscar5728]

It's sometimes easy to give examples based on profession and also it give mind understanding of person and his ability to understand based on his qualifications.

[@MohamedMufaris-ev4ce]

Can anyone tell me how to get answered for a question from dr zakir naik

[@RitaFernandes-mr1yi]

​@@sazid1762zakir does this so he can manipulate his answer to his side and brainwash u

[@yasararafatha3139]

Aryans created varna system , it is not British

[@hishamsalim4908]

Imam shafi and imam hanbal view on finger position is same ryt.... Till offering salam it is raised

[@hishamsalim4908]

@@PWMindset18 then y he is saying differently

[@abdulaziz7515]

Allahu Akbar Masallah Alhamdulillah Assalamu Alaikum

[@Mohamedniam-p6v]

Oh my god !!! How long are our people going to discuss and keep fighting on this subject

[@BilalAhmad-uo6vp]

Whos fighting here? Its a research and discussion nothing like fighting.

[@Bgmi_mod_apk_2024]

According to hadith, finger should be raised during dua only and movement of fingers mentioned in hadees which have many riwayats

[@zzz22214]

What' the fingers had to do with faith and prayers to Allah ..? The fingers or the body don't pray but the heart and the mind... Allah knows what's in our heart and mind.... that's what counts..... Some people don't have fingers... The quran doesn't talk about fingers and body making prayers....

[@grrpast5060]

its not wajib just sunnah

[@zzz22214]

@@grrpast5060 thank you brother. Allah ihfadkom.

[@BombadilBeardie]

The Qur'an doesn't talk about how we should offer salaha.. Then should we leave it at that?

[@grrpast5060]

@@BombadilBeardie who told you quran mentioned how to offer salah too don't mislead people

[@BombadilBeardie]

@@grrpast5060 hahaha do you even understand English?

[@sheikhsiddiq911]

Follow only Sahih hadith if imam's thoughts overlaps with sahih Hadith if prophet Mohammad peace be upon him ❤

[@Anas.12067]

We only want to know what prophet Muhammad pbuh told us no shafai no hambali etc.

[@Hardy_12]

Everyone wants to be close to quran n sunna, on one side saying you can follow any school of thought and on ther hand saying if you want to stay close to quran n hadit than raise it during whole dua (by hearing this who fool will not raise it? As it makes sense that not raising it is somehow proof that person is not close to hadit and quran

[@faizulkhan8649]

Now I'm so confused 🤔 what is right or wrong... What i have learnt is the way of hanafi... Dr zakir please make a video on how to pray namaz properly

[@tariquebinyusuf2230]

Allah will not ask u if you do that or not but you will only be asked about if you regularly offered namaz on time or not. Take action and follow those whom you chose rightful than others.

[@Adnan_147]

Follow the sunnah not the school akhi

[@tariquebinyusuf2230]

@@Adnan_147 Sunnah which are mentioned in books of ahadees are not hidden from us. If there would a sunnat act regarding moving your forefinger Zakir Naik would have told us.

[@shahfaisal1382]

Akhi watch the video of Engineer muhammad Ali mirza for the tariqa of nimaz which is closest to sunnah and hadees. There is a full KZbin video on it with hadith reference or you can go through another video of Asim Al hakeem. Both are correct

[@Adnan_147]

@@tariquebinyusuf2230 I recommend you to watch full video first

[@shamsali9903]

In the Name of Allah, Most Gracious and Most Merciful وَالَّذِينَ كَفَرُوا بَعْضُهُمْ أَوْلِيَاءُ بَعْضٍ ۚ إِلَّا تَفْعَلُوهُ تَكُن فِتْنَةٌ فِي الْأَرْضِ وَفَسَادٌ كَبِيرٌ And those who disbelieve are allies of one another, (and) if you (Muslims of the whole world collectively) do not do so [i.e. become allies, as one united block under one Khalifah (a chief Muslim ruler for the whole Muslim world) to make victorious Allah's religion of Islamic Monotheism], there will be Fitnah (wars, battles, polytheism) and oppression on the earth, and a great mischief and corruption (appearance of polytheism). 8: 73 Why are we Muslims not talking about reestablishing the power and control Allah SWT give us from the beginning? The command is to unite under one Khalifah. The number one concern on the minds of the Muslims is the tragedy in Gazza. The destruction in Gazza is worse than that of Hiroshima and Nagasaki combined. The Zionist Israelis are the modern day Amelak as they were a tribe from nation of the Israelites and their brutality in Gazza and West Bank is the evidence. We have to listen to what Allah SWT is saying to us in the above verse and from the beginning. "And Remember when your Lord said to the Angels, I am going place Khalifah on earth".... 2: 30 You see the UN which is controlled by USA, is dead body in the muddy water as every resolution passed by majority, is vetoed by USA. Which means we have to create a balance of power in the world by creating United League of Muslim Nations. Which is to reestablish the Caliphate because we are children of Adam, peace be upon him . "United League of Muslim Nations" under one Khalifah will be a strictly defensive Force with a quick response to any threat to the Ummah of Islam. And it is easy to do it. It will be the Council of Muftis, from which they will choose the Khalifah. Under the Khalifah will be a seat for a Mufti from every country in world with 100,000 plus Muslim population as Islam is for entire World. From every municipality we will choose a representative till we have the Council of Muftis for that country with a Grand Mufti of that country to sit in the Council of Muftis under the Khalifah. All communication can be done remotely with everyone working from home. Most effective and real democratic way of governing where all decisions are made by the Council of Muftis but the Khalifah having the final say. Under the Khalifah, the "ULMN" will have its own army, navy and Air Force under one commander for defending the entire ummah. We already have the hardware from major Muslim countries. They just have to be relabeled "ULMN" when they out to defend any part of the Ummah like removing the Mediterranean Sea blockade by Israelis.The four letters "ULMN" will be enough to deter anyone from doing what is happening in Gazza today. But we have to be the Nation of Al Muttaqun for Allah SWT is saying now: "You are the Best of People ever raised up for Mankind, enjoying what is Good, forbidding what is evil and believing in Allah SWT" .... Quran 3: 110 Then how can we go wrong when the fear of "ULMN" will overwhelm the hearts of our enemies? That is what Islam is and we are Muslims to resolve every matter in a Peaceful manner, Insha Allah. Alhamdu Lillah. If no one is willing to act as the acting Khalifah, I will be the acting Khalifah till one is chosen and sincerely invite all Muslims to join me in this effort, for if we fail but we will never fail, we will still get one Hashanah for our intentions, Insha Allah Jazak Allah Khair Your brother Abu Saad Acting Khalifah (as Son of Adam, AS)

[@Logic_inIslam]

Very good thoughts brother. We should try to help Muslims who are in trouble in almost all parts of the world. Dr. Zakir Naik sir please do something for Palestinian people.

[@syedshafat618]

Is main b ikhtilaf : koi masla nahi jis main ikhtalaf ho :

[@mohammadnematullah9140]

کہاں زندگی ہے کہاں ڈھونڈتا ہے سرابوں میں آب رواں دیکھتا ہے

[@nishutirahman6865]

As Salamu Alaikum Sir , you said raising the four finger during the tashahud , up and down , but I do it to the end of the whole dua . Sometimes I do some extra dua also after Allahumma jolamtu nafsi……. and till the end I keep it moving up and down and then do the Salam , is that ok ? Or only till the Attahiyatu I have to do that ? If you please let me know, I would be very grateful . Thank you sir .

[@shariqueahmadkhan7662]

Brother u raised a very good question which i also want to know ? Same confusion is here .....

[@Adnan_147]

If you do it till the end it will be good and even as attahiyat it will be good as he said, the reason I said u can do it till end by hadith sunan nisai 1269.

[@nishutirahman6865]

@@Adnan_147 Thank you brother , for your information.

[@sap4128]

Four finger should be raised and in dua should moved up and down.....

[@haseeb2615]

Fore*

[@Sheikhh_Ubair]

​@@haseeb2615 ahl e hadees wala hai matlab manual car without gears and clutch 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@abdulhadi-xq9wb]

​@@Sheikhh_Ubairwhat do u mean?

[@Sheikhh_Ubair]

@@abdulhadi-xq9wb watch pogo

[@AbsarHaider-qz5ck]

Sir please tell me the number of Hadees when we move finger up and down

[@mirzadanishbaig3323]

sunan an nisai 1269

[@hamdankhan8258]

Nisai890

[@merrifieldgalos6248]

Check online or go to your local educated sheikh.

[@ahmedr7545]

Why is this finger raising so important and controversial? I don’t understand its significance. I would like a video explaining more in context as to why it’s so important. If we don’t raise the finger at all, in any various way, is the prayer null?

[@rmahmadkhan]

no, as far my knowledge, it will not be null since it is not a fard or wajib. it is a sunnah.

[@SMD3586]

Bruh raising the forefinger in thashahud is a sunnah and if u raise it u will be rewarded some extra good deeds for doing as per the sunnah but if u don't raise it at all your prayer will be accepted and no problem with the prayer inshallah 😍

[@AbsarHaider-qz5ck]

Sir please tell me the number of Hadees

[@najmmussaquib]

An Nisai 890

[@randommiser3310]

beware salfi promotion here .

[@humaidahmedabuzinjal6257]

do we still raise the finger for darood ibrahim?

[@Muslim_5566]

Yes

[@meeranraees3183]

What is Saudi Arabia not arrangement of general scientist

[@IarbilChonwi]

Allahu Akbar

[@pubguc6771]

Without general scientific what is possible? For all policy for there's subject?

[@KazimRaza-k8z]

None of this is Sunnah. You are supposed to keep your hand and fingers still. If this was the obligated part of salaat Prophet would have done it all the time. If someone sneezes or coughs during salat that doesn’t become part of salat. Same applies to hand and finger. That is why different these fiqhs are different.

[@SMD3586]

What is this akhi, what are u even saying?

[@shaiknihal8798]

6.35

[@Biologyplatform]

thnx

[@haseenashaik5571]

Assalamu alaikum How should a lady sit in salah?

[@aatibkhan6823]

Salah of both men and women are same as prophet Muhammad peace be upon him said pray like you saw me pray and it applies for both genders

[@RaziaBeesony]

muftarishan position same like man

[@haseenashaik5571]

I think no, what's proof?

[@haseenashaik5571]

There are different rules for men and women

[@HudaKhizar]

No it's not. That's the proof of ur claim​@@haseenashaik5571

[@mohammedimran9119]

even salatul witr..people argue hanafi pray bit different and others pray different...these small issue we should not get into these..main is to practice quran and give dawah thats the main objective.. secondary is when a muslim is not performing his islamic duties prayering fasting have to give him dawah..foul language lies now muslims speak so again this we have to give dawah to them..

[@anzil_x]

4:45 he expired 2yrs ago 😭

[@pubguc6771]

From there's Arab COUNTRIES related general without support butt for loss general scientific globally peace

[@pubguc6771]

Before general scientific policy for joint group butt before with general scientific final joint group subject.. butt general scientific cut including for general scientific globally peace related. There's person not mental meand ?

[@khadijabenassou8996]

STOP talking. It's enough. It's Time. Allaah ❤❤❤ The Almighty commanded us to follow ONLY THE QORAAN The Perfect and fully detailed Word of Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty. Following pagan ahadith books and your pagan books claiming it's from Allaah❤❤❤The Almighty is SHIRK SHIRK SHIRK. The Time is Near. Allaah ❤❤❤ The Almighty Will INTERVENE. This is a promise from Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty The Creator of all. Woe to the mouchrekeen. Don't believe me...just watch.

[@mohamedasif2523]

Confusing.....🙄🙄🙄 Better to follow Ahle Hadith...

[@pubguc6771]

General scientific not available others issues not controlling and not open energy power technology digital ecosystem research general scientific globally peace

[@MohammedRaza-ru8bk]

This man loves yazid. INSHALLAH they will be together in the hereafter.

[@thetravelline9086]

He loves Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) 100 times more than Yazid.

[@RudyAbdullah-ey1eg]

This one you understand you wanted from malaysia okey this one you going to play station how much you something islam in a while you something this when you going to malaysia this when you going to play station how much islam you know everything islam this one you something impossible

[@CloverAugustus]

Bro what are you saying. Literally not one sentence makes sense. Just type in your own language, Google will translate it.

[@Bafsha]

tru

[@RudyAbdullah-ey1eg]

This one you know muslim disuan you know understanding meaning you know no muslim destination islam disuan you no going to something no going to corruption dah sim iblis connecting this one you understand iblis you know allah from you okey this one you know this one understand in a job junior connecting prom you know belief you the same

[@pubguc6771]

All rights available for general scientific to Pakistan Pakistan controlling green sunken platform energy power technology digital ecosystem research general scientific globally peace without there's subject for propecenda time wasting gap

[@RudyAbdullah-ey1eg]

Why you know why you know wanted why you know blacklist you understanding you islamkan orang islam you understand endos are you understand islam you know understanding dosa you understanding gina you meninggina how many engineer doctor jakir naik this one connecting from allah juice allah this one understand no those allah this one you juice iblis how many in dosa dunia you understand dosa this one you understand you islam you know understand you know islam

[@meeranraees3183]

Health of general scientist in death condition medicine others rights not available for general scientist

[@pubguc6771]

All rights available for general scientific secretary general secretary general of general assembly United nations general in continue in attacks butt not provided to general scientific security forces and others rights

[@RudyAbdullah-ey1eg]

New going to school dunia you rounding dunia di suami no everything dosa indonesia dosa indonesia imbea my husband how many going to in rosak how this one khutbah ni kayu something in beautiful my husband okey hutba ni dekat istanbul subhanallah connecting okey something dosa number one in dunia this one dosa number one this one you fitnah no di ampun allah subhanahuwataala dah saya punya jinak no dah smu understand dog no this one indonesia because you know islam this one understand macro you going to dog this one understand in don't makro from islam outside disuan understand you my beautiful this one understand my sister my all this one going to something because promise something dunia allah subhanahuwataala subhanallah taala berikut indo sayu indonesia this one understanding roman cat even all dosa dunia

[@Bafsha]

tru

[@cryptoprince6544]

Prophet Muhammad never raised or pointed finger in tashaud. This is all created by some random scholars in past.

[@Muslim_5566]

U don't authentic hadith as well ? Bruh do u even know the meaning if authentic ?

[@BeiBe42780]

Just Rules taught by men Sorry God didn't tell you to point finger Christ or God warn Us about this. w dJJl is daJJal

[@akv1989]

When the Wahhabi Salafi next to me shows the index finger up and down action like this, I lose concentration and close my eyes at that time.

[@SouthSideHoodz2005]

So now you are doing bidah in your prayer by closing your eyes. Why you do this? You don’t like Sunnah?

[@akv1989]

@@SouthSideHoodz2005 it was not bidha, why that guy moving his 4th fingure up and down, what he getting from that? Iam concldingnit was bidha

[@SouthSideHoodz2005]

Zakir Naik just quoted authentic Hadith and you don’t accept it. Which means you follow bidah

[@akv1989]

@@SouthSideHoodz2005 kzbin.info/www/bejne/nKSwgKiqgLBgeassi=fInBok8vwA9AyxBz

[@akv1989]

@@SouthSideHoodz2005 kzbin.infoQp-VYPBkkZw?si=6MxVDpJs9k6IxJ-v now you tell is your bidha or

[@Hanya1962]

there is no ALLAHA or GOD!!!!

[@BTCMEMoTanzeem]

There is no God But ALLAH ❤❤❤❤

[@MohammedRaza-ru8bk]

This hanafi and shafi. etc they never even saw the Prophet ( SAW).

[@iluvbutter]

And your point is?

[@MohammedRaza-ru8bk]

SA. The point is how do these people know?. Why don't you follow Ahle Bait (AS) who are his family so they are much better placed to know.

[@randommiser3310]

Albani came last in 20th century..so his the weakest..Hanafi met sahabah

[@mohammadwazir5566]

No point here brother. Every Muslim is trying to be better each day. Right or wrong leave it to Allah and stay United as an Ummah rather than pointing out different opinions on small issues.

[@MohammedRaza-ru8bk]

SALAAM Alaikum. Yes brother Wazir ,you are right. By slagging off each other we only give Satan the upper hand.

[@mohamedabdullah19]

He should keep it by debates between different religious. He should not go into fiqh and especially in the four madaahib. Because Zakir Naik is not a proper Aalim! Every madhab has his own evidence.

[@Adnan_147]

He just said the correct way to do it and how our prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam have done it.

[@isnija3499]

Selam alejkum Dr.Naik,i want to challange u in explaining of the word of ALLAH.And not only u all of our scholars of our Ummah.

[@NINETY9PLUS01]

Ahhh, everyone is waiting for this day bro.. go ahead😅

[@isnija3499]

I dont wait brother,i mean i will in sha ALLAH him explain the Koran,he dont hear this befor. I mean,he dont understand the koran.

[@khanSherKhan]

One thing I don't understand, Dr Saib, when there is Sahee Hadees available in Bukhari Sharif then why did you started your bayan by mentioning four Imams. That what confuse Muslims whose knowledge is limited.

[@ShooterAsu]

Hadees Number plz??

[@iCricketSpeaks]

Because some muslims separate in groups firka ...so for understanding all the exmaple given by dr sahhib for better understandng

[@Reshi-k7i]

Sir kindly leave what these four imams did tell us what prophat Muhammad swa did we are followers of Muhammad swa not these imams

[@noillsmatter9090]

WHY MR. NAIK REFUSE TO DEBATE CHRISTIAN PRINCE? IS HE A POTATO?

[@imrantariq49]

He has debated many christians, all the answers are given to the Christians

[@noillsmatter9090]

@@imrantariq49 Who's that Christian? He only debates a Christian without integrity, why not accepting the invitation to debate Christian Prince, Sam Shamoun, David Wood, why? Because mr naik is afraid that he will be exposed. He knows his weakness.

[@peerzadausmaan]

​@@noillsmatter9090David wood 😂😂 Haven't you seen debate between Muhammad Hijab vs David Wood. That would be sufficient for you.

[@AbsarHaider-qz5ck]

Sir please tell me the number of Hadees when we move finger up and down

[@antagonist6434]

Nasa 890

[@yasararafatha3139]

Wayil bin hujiru