SHUTTER ISLAND (2010) | FIRST TIME WATCHING | MOVIE REACTION

Shutter Island (2010) First Time Watching Movie Reaction, Review, and Commentary for JL. Many moments wondering who we can trust and if we even should, and MANY thoughts about THAT ending were had.
#firsttimewatching #moviereaction #reactionvideo
Opening graphics/theme by Dr. Evo. Check him out at linkr.bio/drevoproducer
Check out the EOM Patreon!: / eomedia
Check out the EOM Store!: www.eomreacts.com
Join the EOM Discord!: / discord
Follow us on Twitter!: / eomediareacts
Follow us on Instagram!: / extraordinarily_ordina...
SPONSOR: Check out bit.ly/3Bkl516 and use code EOM to get 20% off a EWin Gaming Chair!
SPONSOR: Check out MoviePalette.com and use "SCREAM15" for a 15% discount!
SPONSOR: Check out TryTreats.com and use "ExtraordinarilyOrdinaryMedia" for 15% off first box!
SPONSOR: Check out jamielee02.scentsy.us for all your home decor and scented needs!
Want to send something? (First address is the actual post office building, if needed, and the bottom is his actual P O Box number at said building)
3525 Landsdowne Drive
Lexington, KY 40517
Extraordinary Ordinary Media/EOM/JL Phillips (Any of them will work)
PO Box 23119
Lexington, KY 40523
*COPYRIGHT DISCLAIMER: Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act (1976), allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, commentary, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
NO COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT INTENDED. All rights of any included media 100% belong to their respective owners.

[@S_047]

The "Shut the F up" at the end will be legendary

[@BonnietheOutlaw7]

😂😂😂oh yeah

[@DSmith264]

As sure as the sun rises..

[@zoevalk8645]

HERE for it

[@SuburbanSavage]

I cannot wait for it!

[@GhostWatcher2024]

Absolutely...we got an MFer on this one!!

[@jordan_sal413]

The last line of the movie is what makes this such a legendary flick. Its up to interpretation weather u think he is fully there or not. But most would wager he understands, but would rather "die a good man" and be lobotomized, so he doesnt have to live as a "monster" and doesnt have to live with what he did

[@xXSinForLifeXx]

Agreed that's how I saw it aswell

[@Ramblinrabbit24]

I think that’s what makes the most sense. If that was me, I’d feel the same way. I wouldn’t want to live with that knowledge. Kind of how he looks and acts like he feels.

[@bigbe889]

Agreed he definitely knew

[@denisebennettahrentzen8340]

Agreed

[@leogothisoscar271]

I don't believe it can be interpreted any other way. Then he literally gets up and walks away with the with the doctors, warden, and orderlies. When would have done that before?

[@feedmefrenzy.]

"That aint his woman, she's too old" freaking killed me! Hahahaha

[@jakehawke8196]

When the "RUN"-lady is being interviewed and Leonardo asks her to describe Doctor Sheenan, she shyly glances at Chuck-Hulk and says, "Well, he's easy on the eyes." It's a nice touch that you wouldn't really understand unless you already knew that he was actually Sheenan.

[@jacobhall2628]

Chuck-Hulk?...........god i hate Marvel fans

[@Water3Monkey]

@@jacobhall2628 And if you had watched the video you would have heard J call Chuck, Hulk, numerous times.

[@iAmPimmiCue]

@@jacobhall2628 Are you dumb?

[@Heathen9]

Yes, Leo chose to be lobotomized. What Leo saw at Dachau concentration camp screwed him up. That’s why he worked so much & was away from home all the time. His wife had serious mental health issues but he never listened. He felt a duty to save as many people as possible. So when she killed their children, Leo lost it & killed her. In the end, Leo’s character consciously chose to die a good man. To be honest, that’s truly what he was. Honestly, I wouldn’t want to live knowing I never listened to my wife & wasn’t there to protect my kids when they needed it the most. That would screw me up forever. I’d choose a lobotomy too.

[@kenboston8742]

This movie was a total mindf*ck. Now imagine watching this for the first time ever on DVD that was rented, in a DVD player that was malfunctioning and I didn't realize it, as it randomly played movie chapters out of order, and repeated some chapters at the most confusing times. By the time I figured out what was happening I had concluded that perhaps I needed to visit the lighthouse myself.

[@samanthanickson6478]

😆🤗

[@LoveLife-ho3rg]

Oh you really made me laugh with this one 😂and it’s in the middle of the night here and everybody’s asleep..my family will make sure that I’ll meet you at the lighthouse

[@robertopistone1179]

🤣

[@shainewhite2781]

The twist ending was one of the most shocking and unexpected! It made top 10 lists on every KZbin channel.

[@stevefrench4139]

There were two crazy moments at the end. The first was when we all realized he was a patient playing in his fantasy world and the second one was him accepting reality, but pretending to still act like the marshal knowing full well that it would end with him being lobotomized.

[@e.c.1975]

“I was about to say he took them bullets like a champ.” 😂 This twist was amazing. I was so happy when someone created a film on the perspective of a patient who was suffering from a mental illness. As a person who had ppd and has a brother who suffers from schizophrenia most people don’t realize that sometimes people like this have no self control and that their delusions seem so real that you can’t tell the difference. Sadly we can become victims of our own minds and illness. This film was perfection. Loved this reaction.

[@theatre721]

Man, everyone talks about the twist, which was excellent. But this movie has something i like more: atmosphere. It's a tense film from start to finish

[@nickanderson6164]

Having a mental hospitals you're setting helps a lot with that...... It's the exact same reason why the atmosphere in the season 2 of American horror story was so good

[@kellyadams79]

Probably one of Leo Dicraprio's best performance for me, and the supporting cast. Love this movie and that ending😮

[@dannyb9209]

Agreed..I thought this was the one he should've got the Oscar for

[@AlastorsShadowDemon]

“If she can buy her own drinks, he don’t want her…” 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Yooooo!! It took me a minute to remember. I kept asking why you were saying she’s too old. 💀💀💀 The “Harry Potter dementors” comment had me rolling. 🤣🤣🤣

[@kunglaoshat1250]

I didn’t get it at first. I was like “Michelle Williams isn’t old???” But knowing what he actually meant by that comment is hilarious 😂

[@bigredtlc1828]

These movies are unique in that you watch them the first time and you'll never watch it the same way again. It's a moment in your life that will never be experienced again. Kinda cool. Thanks for reacting!

[@timothyhedrick5295]

One of the most underappreciated movies ever. [SPOILER] Shocking how many people miss the choice he made at the end to be lobotomized when he was no longer delusional. I love this movie. Great reaction!

[@BlueTransAm83]

I did the first time to, though.

[@raymondhenderson8230]

I did spot this, but I’ve always wondered why?? He isn’t delusional anymore so why pretend to be to get lobotomised. Why not just continue getting better?

[@-Antagonist]

@@raymondhenderson8230 I took it as he did it out of guilt

[@raymondhenderson8230]

@@-Antagonist I mean, I get it but I wouldn’t feel guilty shooting the person that drowned my 3 kids. Though in saying that, she clearly had mental issues and needed help herself, but nah still, I would feel guilty but not guilty enough to lobotomise myself

[@USMCMachine]

@@raymondhenderson8230he talks about rather dying thinking your a hero. Rather than live with what he will have to live with.

[@howtocookazombie]

Loved your reaction and it was pretty funny to see you brainstorming that the doctor was lying to him. 😁😁 Yes, he played it in the end. His mind didn't reset. He wanted to "die as a good man" (not really die but being lobotomized), than "live as a monster" (with the memories of killing his wife). So he willingly went to the lobotomization.

[@Lestat13]

The man who played the Mandarin is Ben Kingsley. He also won an Oscar for Ghandi.

[@BrokenInBeauty]

I found him exceptional in Schindler’s List as well 😊

[@Lestat13]

@@BrokenInBeauty Oh yes! Definitely Oscar worthy!

[@kanditraxel]

I love Ben's total weirdness in "Tuck Everlasting"!

[@DMitr0]

once he finally came back from his delusion, he understood why he was delusional, and chose to fry his brain, so that he'd just be empty instead. gnarly ending indeed.

[@insanitypepper1740]

"Why'd we get lumped into this!" 😂🤣😂

[@kathleencooper2153]

I thought the doctor's were lying too..What a twist when we really knew what happened..It's good of them to go through all this for one person..Great reaction as always.

[@maurakinney2403]

3:10 “That ain’t his woman, she too old.” Three minutes in and I’m already laughing 😂

[@Georgia_Outlaw_Vinyl]

The original trailer made this out to be horror. I saw it in theaters and while I was disappointed it wasn’t horror it was so much better than I thought it would be.

[@AREA-jp8vb]

The story of his wife is so heartbreaking. There was a women earlier this year who... her kids and then jumped out a window. She had been suffering from ppd and her husband had been desperately trying to get her help. Her husband forgave her and asked the public to forgive her as well. The system failed them, and most women with ppd. Louis Theroux has a great special called Mothers on the Edge. I highly recommend for anyone interested. Great reaction as usual! The "shut the f*ck up" gets me every time 😂

[@nomadman5288]

Did the system legitimately fail them or were the current limitations of understanding and treatments too much to overcome?

[@Luciphell]

PPD is NO excuse for what that woman did.

[@e.c.1975]

@@LuciphellYou really dk anything about PPD if you think that. People with a mental illness are victims as well. It’s hard to live with committing terrible things and having no control over yourself mentally.

[@AREA-jp8vb]

@@Luciphell lol yeah obviously there is no excuse for murder, but ppd can cause hallucinations and delusions so its not like there in their right mind.

[@Luciphell]

@@e.c.1975 KZbin's algorithm keeps censoring, so let me just say this. Protecting people from the mentally deranged should come before making sure the mentally deranged lead a normal life. Fuck them. Fuck her. I care more about the kids she drowned than her issues. If she were permanently locked away or dead those kids would be alive. Yes, I know it's a movie, however, real life corroborates my view. A man that was known to be mentally deranged just last week murdered his kids, then his wife, then killed himself. He was known to be mentally ill and people begged for him to be locked up. His precious rights were more important than the vulnerable being protected from him.

[@monicamaza5843]

Awesome reaction! I liked how J noticed the police weren't putting any effort into searching for Rachel at the beginning. I cracked up when he said he would drop kick "Rachel" when he saw her standing over the dead kids. That flashback to what Leo's wife did is so sad. I teared up in the theater too. J at the end was all of us watching it, mindf@&ked indeed.

[@maximillianosaben]

Shutter Island was released the same year as Inception, and Leonardo DiCaprio plays characters with very similar tragic backstories in both movies.

[@lmcgregoruk]

I always thought Shutter Island was better than Inception, but most critics/audience polls disagree.

[@Angelabout1]

"Bitch I will drop kick you"! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣My favorite line!

[@ThatArabGirl10]

Hey, J, I think that you'd like "Mystic River". It was written by the same author as "Shutter Island". Thank you for the reaction. I love your channel.

[@johnsmith8906]

Great reaction. Happy Birthday for Friday.

[@traceyreid4585]

Leo's pain when he lifts the girl out of the water was visceral... Involuntary tears! Amazing acting! Happy birthday week from a fellow Sagittarius 🍾

[@silverdoeGirl]

Identity is another that was before this with John Cusack and the late, great, Ray Liotta with a mind bender to it as well. This is my kind of movie! Happy birthday week.

[@gerry_atric]

I think this was your best upload yet. You were so deep in it from the beginning and rightfully so, great movie. How the end reveal got you is one continuous classic look throughout- confusion. You got maybe the best week lined up yet as well and this was a great kickoff! Thanks EOM team for the top tier entertainment. Be well 🎬🙂🙂🙂🐶🐶👍✌️

[@jaykanuck1638]

Yep, he was just playing. He did not want to live anymore knowing what his wife did to his children, he has nothing. Everything he loved was taken away from him. So he just decided bye-bye Chuck.

[@_LexiMae]

He's partly responsible for his children dying which is probably why he also had a mental breakdown and made himself forget what happened. She kept telling him something was wrong with her and he didn't get her the help she needed. Had he done it she probably wouldn't have killed their kids.

[@KZ-sg4es]

I happen to live near a creepy Insane Asylum that was shut down years ago bc they did some rlly evil things there. So this film scares tf outta me😂 Happy birthday btw🎉

[@chillinwithchance5976]

I just wanted to say thank you for helping through what I’m going through rn, I just found out my mom has heart failure and ur videos r helping me through it so much! I think ur reaction to ghost of mars with ice cube in it would be great it’s one of my all time favorite movies

[@TheCastaberg]

"Which would be worse, to live as a monster, or die as a good man." Sometimes reality is too hard to handle, to choose a lobotomized existence over a conscious one is a fucked up place to be. Great movie!

[@jessicapazo7718]

Dr. Jeremiah Naehring played by the great Max Von Sydow ... was Father Merrin in THE EXORCIST

[@Arwe321]

Love this channel, love this movie, and CANNOT wait to see your reaction! Blessings to you!

[@reservoirdude92]

Martin Scorsese is the kind of director who can pretty much make any kind of film. When this came out, a lot of critics thought it was a "lesser" film in the grand scheme of Scorsese's legendary filmography, but a film like this showed that he wasn't really interested in being a "prestige" director, but one who can use their inherent talent for a story that aims to ENTERTAIN as well as make you think. Shutter Island is a fantastic piece of work, and is another example of how easy Uncle Marty makes it look ❤

[@patticriss2238]

When you laugh, for real, (“she wanted me to pull my thing out so she could laugh at it”) I laugh too.

[@StacyLym]

Oh this reaction is going to be good!

[@kanditraxel]

"What's his name??".... Not me yelling out, "Ben Kingsley!" to my phone! 😂

[@samanthanickson6478]

“that ain’t his woman, she too old.” 😆 great dicaprio reference.

[@AprilGabrielle]

I love how this is a completely different movie the second time you watch it.

[@jenniferri7735]

i saw this in the theater, completely spoiler-free. my mind was blown the fuck away. it’s definitely one to watch more than once - every single thing lines up, it’s flawless.

[@jaredroberts578]

Such an underrated movie. Before kids, the scene with the wife and kids crushed me, now, with two toddlers, that scene absolutely fuckin' crushes me,...such a great fucked up movie.

[@DJ_Cub]

3:09 the subtle genius comedy of the murder whistle on full display

[@flossy7258]

I love your reactions. Next time you're wanting to watch another Leo/Scorsese movie, try Gangs of New York. It's also got Daniel Day Lewis and tons of action/violence/blood. Smooches to the pooches😊

[@LenOliver-yz6os]

Oh hell yea!!!! i would to see J react to Gangs of New York that would be bad ass funny.

[@karenlackner192]

Another great Scorcese movie !!! And Leo is amazing as usual! If you watch it a 2nd time you’ll catch ‘everything’ related to the plot. He knew at the end. He chose to have the memories permanently gone.

[@King_IVAR868]

Low key one of Leo's best movies

[@fernandobarrera6440]

I love “murder mysteries” and this is up there. I remember people silently losing their shit at the theater during the reveal and at the end. Amazing acting by Leo. I used to hate on that guy because of the praise he got for no reason, but he’s legitimately one of the greatest.

[@stanley2681]

happy birthday week brother! thank you for your content, love, laughs and empathy. wish there were more people like you in the world. may you live long healthy and prosperous. much love!

[@smichelle65]

When you watch it again: "I can't stomach the water" is clue #1

[@flynngames4703]

Watching EOM try to detective this movie is amazing!

[@joshuacoldwater]

Happy Birthday man- I wish you the very best not only this year, but every year. You keep us all sane in this insanity. Know you are truly loved man.

[@luketrottier6677]

Brilliant movie. When he was talking about it's time to get the Ferry back, and then he asks where is partner is, and he says what partner? You don't have a partner. And then 'tell me more about this partner'. It sounds like a professional asking him to speak on his delusions. At this point, I thought they were pretending Teddy wasn't real, for the purpose of being able to frame Daniels as crazy. So it was clever of him to pick up on it, and respond by acknowledging he doesn't have a partner (agreeing with their stated stance). In the Lighthouse, I thought they were still trying to pull the same thing, to essentially trick the world into him becoming a patient there, so that he couldn't expose things/whistle blow on the outside. Once he showed 'the rule of 4', though, and the anagrams, I instantly was 100% convinced the doctor was being honest, and everything clicked. It was just too impossibly good of a coincidence for it to be a ploy. And then in hindsight, all those little hints added up, that initially steered things another way. The duality that works convincingly in both contexts is so good. The withdrawal effects from not taking the pills, mixed with you thinking the pills are responsible for the effects, and add to the pills being used to help with their ulterior, sinister plot, when really it's just his psychiatric meds, which is another hint for the truth... So many cases of that.

[@subtlesraf]

HAPPY BIRTHDAY J!!! 🥹🫶🫶🫶 you make every day less lonely for me, you and the copilots. sending love ❤❤❤

[@joelholland8523]

One thing I never noticed about this movie. The roll playing worked! Rough ending for him yes. But it worked! By far one of Leo's best rolls. His acting in this is awesome.

[@JacobDennisHarris8586]

COOL REACTIONS! I'LL BE HERE!

[@hot50n]

I love this film. It definitely needs a few watches to pick up on all the little clues throughout. Chuck and his inability to handle a firearm, the nervous guards, the search for Rachel where everyone is sitting around not bothering to look. It's a masterpiece.

[@pittsburgh4life83]

What a great reaction! I knew this was gonna be great when you said you were watching this

[@SongJLikes]

‘ Shuddup Island ‘

[@KokoandFooFoo]

I love how there's small, almost unnoticeable clues throughout the movie; like when they're interviewing the patients and Mark Ruffalo hands one of them a glass of water, the patient then drinks from the cup but she isn't drinking from a real glass.

[@OriginalMalcolmPoole]

Well, Not sure what day it is but...Happy Birthday J, wishing you many more with your co-pilots.❤

[@jcs1025]

I remember seeing this in the theater. You sitting there in silence after they walk him away to the surgery is exactly how the entire theater was as the movie ended.

[@lordofthereels6790]

When in doubt about what to watch next a Scorsese flick is never a bad choice. He's the modern Hitchcock in regards to talent with more variety From Shutter, Cape Fear and The Aviator to The King Of Comedy all are gems

[@pamelalee1508]

J definitely needs to watch Cape Fear !!!!! 🌿🌿🌿

[@idiocracylarper]

Definitely seconding The King Of Comedy.

[@Jnf4uk]

Happy Birthday! Love your videos!

[@inater06]

Happy Birthweek! Thanks for all the good content!

[@daver8475]

Great reaction as per usual! Fun fact, max von sydow who played the German doctor in this, was father merrin in the exorcist, in 1973! Think of how old they made him look in 73, he looks very much similar in this movie.

[@thehitman6963]

I love your reactions brother Keep up the good work 🙌🏽

[@LittleSkin18]

Happy Birthday, Jay! 🎉🎉🎉 thank you for sharing your special day(s) with us 🤗

[@kylewestlake982]

He should do a counter for every time he says "Shut the fuck up" XD

[@larry6360]

Have a great Birthday 🎉. You deserve it. We all appreciate how much you care about this community and know that we care just as much for you. You bring happiness to many. Happy Birthday buddy.

[@House0fHoot]

Great reaction! Andrew wilfully ignored his wife’s deteriorating mental health. He avoided her & left his children with her. He was partially responsible for the kids’ death. Definitely responsible for his wife’s death. Great film!

[@davecharlton5812]

We need a tshirt with your face. Saying “shut the fuck up” 😂

[@EOMReacts]

eomreacts.com there is one in there lol - J

[@murrayroodbaard207]

Remember in the beginning on the ferry when he said he couldn't stand the water? It's because the water reminded him of his loss. He just had that loss buried deep inside.

[@TwilightsFire]

Those 2 minutes of silence followed by "Motherfucker!" was just "Chef's Kiss" Had a ball watching this reaction!

[@nicolem376]

I love this movie! Glad to see this reaction!!! And HAPPY BIRTHDAY! 🎉🎉

[@Thane36425]

Lobotomies were once the big thing in psychiatry, that and electro-convulsive therapy. I knew a couple of people who got ECT back in the day. I was a kid and they were adults, but even so I could tell somehing wasn't right with them afterwards. Both procedures were essentially banned, but they do seem to be trying to get ECT back for some cases. Also when I was a kid there was a state mental institution just outside of town. Back then it was full up and had a criminal ward as well. A cousin of mine was studying to be a nurse and to do a rotation in there. It essentially was a prison with guards, bars, buzzing doors, and all. It was so bad in there that I don't think she finished the rotation. Many didn't.

[@WiseJoeGaming]

Loved how this twisted your mind! Haha! Great job!

[@shesemerald2011]

"Pepe Silvia" thats all I think when you are trying to figure the ending out. 😂 respect and love from SoCal.

[@adamdarmstaedter1256]

Your face when the credits start rolling ..... 🤣

[@TardisHorcrux67]

Happy Birthday (week) Jay! 🖤🤘🏼lol can't wait to see what other movies you picked to watch!

[@willowdragonssacredfire6380]

This was a gem, the twist absolutely punched me in the gut and shocked the hell out me. Such a good movie sad but good

[@jonm6891]

Happy birthdays J! Great reaction to a great movie!!

[@sitebstudios]

Glad you got to experience this masterpiece!

[@haleycerchie5121]

The loooong pondering at the end 😂❤

[@TheJuancharlie782]

That mother f comment was epic and an appropriate response to this movie. Keep em coming brother 👍🏽

[@harpergras]

An awesome movie...It don`t get no better than this one.

[@sarahgillmore7322]

Omg I love you! I cannot wait to watch you watch this.

[@Rickolee]

I loved this movie! I'm happy i got to see your reaction!

[@JBW27]

Love this movie. I already know your reaction is going to be hilarious 😂 If you're after a few other mind fuck films to watch, Mirrors and Oculus are 100% worth a go 😁

[@AliceDepaul]

It's a great rewatch knowing the ending, you get to watch it from the perspective of everyone around trying to help him as a patient

[@Xethyl]

Get this man a t-shirt with “Shut the f*ck up” on it 😂

[@Anthony-ss8ob]

The name you're looking for is Ben Kingsley 👌👍🇹🇹

[@mattcrozier9648]

My brain felt like it was melting at the reveal when I first watched this movie.

[@StevenPD]

I only recall bits and pieces of this movie. Looking forward to the reaction.

[@libarax]

This is such a fantastic film and paired with a great reaction as always!

[@MattBayArea]

"WHERE WAS YO ANTENNAS?!" 😂😂😂

[@Raven5150]

You would think Leonardo would never get on another boat after what happend last time

[@OneThousandHomoDJs]

The scene at the lake was brutal. Leo is a G.