Sibelius: 5. Sinfonie ∙ hr-Sinfonieorchester ∙ Dalia Stasevska

[@johannesnicolaas]

My 92 year old father died 4 days ago. This music, especially the last part gives me great comfort and support. Love to you all out there. Life is short!

[@BS-cu2hg]

Die beste 5. die ich je gehört habe. 👏👏👏

[@donincognito189]

Superb performance as always from this marvellous symphony orchestra 👏

[@cergneuxguillermo1681]

Una delicia esta Sinfonía de Sibelius magistralmente dirigida por Dalia, e interpretada por esta orquesta que tanto admiro en su perfección..!! Un placer renovado en cada concierto! Gracias !! Saludos desde Argentina!

[@Christoph-zd9zb]

23.42-25:16 Absolutely wonderful and fantastic to play this passage at this wide tempo. This underlines the unique genius of this passage.

[@jasontiller]

Spectacular! I love Sibelius and I love the hr sinfonie! These performances are a marvelous gift to the world - thank you!

[@artemakin]

It might be the best performance of this symphony on the channel. I like how flexible she is with the tempi. The shining climax of the first movement, rustic and playful energy of the adagio, grandeur of the finale - she feels them with her body naturally and captures everything right. Brava 👏And as always thanks to the first-class musicians of the orchestra.

[@jamsheddelvadavala1972]

A superb performance of this wonderful symphony! Crafted to perfection by this well gifted conductor & the great orchestra as always! Perfect control over tempo & dynamics! Greatly enjoyed! Thanks for the post. Jamshed Delvadavala from Mumbai, India.

[@joedays94]

Agradable sorpresa con este Sibelius de Dalia Stasevska. Atmosférico, épico cuándo la partitura lo requiere, el sonido orquestal impecablemente trabajado para brindar esas dosis de misterio, angustia y expresionismo que el gran compositor finés pide. Y una buena tension interna para seguir el "relato" de principio a fin. Excelente, gran nivel de esta directora.

[@jchristophem4406]

Bravo. A great interpretation and performance.

[@MegaVicar]

Gorgeous!!! Well-played & well-led; she seemed to be flexible in her tempi, especially in the second movement. I think that worked well; I heard detail I've missed in 30 years of listening to this! I also like Maestra Staskeva's 'artists smock': a shock of color to remind us this is a spring symphony.

[@TheStockwell]

This is sensational. This interpretation is genuinely idiosyncratic and "different" - in a good way. ❤️ So many performances of this work are virtually identical, I usually think, "What? Another performance of the Sibelius 5th? Why bother? They're all the same, by now." This conductor removed a lot of dust and convention from a generally predictable work. Thank you to everyone involved in this performance. Best wishes from Vermont 🍁

[@werlydon]

nerd

[@werlydon]

Apologies, in a quick bout of hindsight, I realize spreading hate on the internet is wrong, and admonishing those for their passions is poor behavior.

[@johannesnicolaas]

@@werlydon Thank you for that.

[@김민석-u5d9p]

Great performance great interpretation Perfekt!

[@tarquinmidwinter2056]

Performance full of tension and excitement. Also great recording and camera work. Love it 🥰

[@richard141724]

Great conductor!

[@SilvioNobre]

Great interpretation! Wonderful! ❤️😍🤗

[@xoknight8166]

One of the most majestic symphonies

[@lowe7471]

Likely the best performance on KZbin. Absolutely excellent. Everything clear. Incredible dynamics. And always great audio/video on this channel. Thank you for sharing this.

[@Adeodatus100]

I've never heard Stasevska conduct before. Wow! - I don't think I've ever heard this symphony played with such passion.

[@lucasmallmann3579]

Sensacional .Tocou a minha alma !

[@matzek.9119]

Meine Lieblingssinfonie. Ich liebe Sibelius! Wie zart hier der 2. Satz endet und gleich in den 3. Satz übergeht. Hervorragend. Immer wieder zeigt sich die Genialität finnischer Dirigenten. Ich denke sie saugen Sibelius schon mit der Muttermilch auf. Dalia Stasevska ist mit dem Urenkel von Jean Sibelius verheiratet. Ich werde verrückt!

[@armandogabba2769]

The quality of the orchestra in Germany is awesome

[@paulinarybska119]

Thank you! 👏

[@algo3766]

Pour moi, rien d'entendu d'aussi bien exécuté depuis la version de 1987 de Léonard Bernstein et la Philharmonie de Vienne. Bravo à tous, merci pour ce magnifique moment de musique. Un pensée particulière à la cheffe d'orchestre, née à Kiev, et à son pays martyrisé. Für mich hat seit der Fassung von Leonard Bernstein und den Wiener Philharmonikern aus dem Jahr 1987 nichts so gut umgesetztes gehört. Herzlichen Glückwunsch an alle, vielen Dank für diesen großartigen musikalischen Moment. A special thought to the conductor, born in Kyiv, and to her martyred country.

[@twanswagten]

Wonderful!

[@waqasahmed3422]

A superb performance!

[@caglayanharun]

Dankeschon..

[@steveberry7195]

Exceptional performance of an exceptional symphony. Dalia Stasevska is new to me, but I look forward to more of her work.

[@ГерманУстинов-з1х]

Good day!!! Life!!

[@JamwebMusic]

First! Love Sibelius!!!

[@ВладимирУ-т3ц]

Прекрасный концерт! Спасибо Франкфуртскому оркестру!

[@MrBohuslav]

Majestätische und wunderschöne Aufführung dieser großartigen und perfekt komponierten Sinfonie mit gut phrasierten und perfekt vereinigten Tönen aller Instrumente. Der zweite Satz klingt besonders schön und echt tiefempfunden. Der letzte Satz klingt besonders majestätisch und auch sehnsüchtig. Die intelligente und geniale Dirigentin leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im gut analysierten Tempo und mit künstlerisch kontrollierter Dynamik. Wundervoll vom Anfang bis zum Ende!

[@TheStockwell]

Wonderful! A brand new Notaire1-style account cranking out useless drivel about brilliant and intelligent conductors! 😂

[@matzek.9119]

Der Schluss ist die 2. Fassung. Sibelius hatte erst einen anderen Schluss komponiert und hat ihn später revidiert. Sie finden den ursprünglichen Schluss auch auf Yotube.

[@Itapirkanmaa2]

She's the SO of Lauri Porra, who's a bass guitar player and Janne Sibelius's great grandkid. So now you know.

[@Anonymus-z3z]

Love her jackett.

[@markiz1009]

🤢🤮🤮

[@lucmaitre246]

magnifique superbe de maitrise

[@christianheinen105]

Klasse ❤❤❤!Gruß Christian

[@siriojanicolaev3389]

🙏🙏🙏❤❤❤ !!!

[@백경근-m7z]

Nice

[@craigkowald3055]

Her husband is a great grandson of Sibelius, so this is a family affair.

[@calebhu6383]

23:40

[@notaire2]

Wunderschöne und detaillierte Aufführung dieser spätromantischen und nordisch komponierten Sinfonie mit seidigen Tönen aller Streicher, milden Tönen aller Holzbläser und brillanten Tönen aller Blechbläser. Der zweite Satz klingt besonders schön und echt beruhigend. Im Kontrast klingt der dritte Satz echt lebhaft und auch inspirierend. Die intelligente und geniale Dirigentin leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im gut analysierten Tempo und mit künstlerisch kontrollierter Dynamik. Faszinierend vom Anfang bis zum Ende!

[@TheStockwell]

EVERYONE is an "intelligent and brilliant conductor" when Notaire1, 2, etc. pushes the AI comment button! 😂

[@TapanilaMosabacka3D]

Meaningless bullshit.

[@davidparrish2534]

What is that jacket he's wearing??

[@juhanpalm-peipman680]

Its more cosmopolitan in sound and flavour than it is Finnish in character. The outbursts of sound and tempo changes don't really capture the almost secretive and mystical quality that permates Sibelius' music.

[@sansovino4124]

Sorry to dissent but there is no magic or spontaneity in this - it all sounds forced to me. One of the most wonderful moments in all music, the transition between the old first and second movements, is quite poor, no flow, no rythmic identity. I really don't like this and I love most things on this wonderful channel.

[@TapanilaMosabacka3D]

You're right, but that comment goes down like a fart in church under all the uncritical gushing, fawning fans here.

[@fl1606]

I hate that I’m agreeing with this, but… I’m agreeing with this. The orchestra sounded sloppy and stressed. The phrases didn’t have life. The end of the first movement should be rapturous, but this felt like they were just playing notes. The ending of the finale didn’t have that amazing tension that makes this piece amazing. It was just… tense. I saw Dalia conduct this live with another symphony and it was similar. Both of these orchestras are better than this. This is truly one of my top-5 favorite pieces ever. I wanted to love this so much, but I didn’t.

[@tarquinmidwinter2056]

Uh?

[@Pianisimo1875]

Dawg. ☠️

[@webcafe-tw3qu]

17:45

[@SergejRazinkov]

Aus welchem Grund kommt diese Maestra zu solchen erstklassigen Orchester??? Es ist sehr schwer zu verstehen.

[@TapanilaMosabacka3D]

This symphony falls apart under this conductor. In her attempt to make every note and phrase pregnant with meaning the flow and momentum disappear. And the simian grimaces and posturing don't help either.

[@fl1606]

Agree. There is no motion here. No joy. No flow. No tension, just tense playing. And I know the orchestra plays better than this.

[@Pianisimo1875]

How? The conducter is fire.

[@SupportTheArts-yo8ox]

Okay, either my perfect pitch is no longer perfect...or it seems like the key is different that other versions I've heard (higher?)

[@markiz1009]

💯

[@Mario-w1v5z]

Cara Venezi....impari

[@mekaomata8327]

打点が上なのは弾きにくい…

[@АлександрБуянов-л7в]

Die Ausführung ist zwar sehr gut, aber das gespielte Werk ist von selbst schwach und unbedeutsam.

[@peterwhyte-zl1kv]

May I disagree with you (in German)?

[@TapanilaMosabacka3D]

It's the other way around.

[@papagen00]

I am not used to seeing so many new women conductors that are popping up all over the place after Covid. Are they hired for merit or gender?

[@raempftl]

What a question! Isn't it obvious? For gender of course. As you can see from the comments nobody likes them.

[@belpit66]

I am used to seeing many more men than women conductors. Are they hired for merit or gender?

[@papagen00]

@@belpit66 mostly for merit, whereas these new DEI hires are mostly not.

[@TapanilaMosabacka3D]

This one not exactly for merit IMO.

[@ВладимирУ-т3ц]

Дирижёров нанимают по цвету кожи и разрезу глаз.

[@markiz1009]

Прекрасный костюм попугая 😂