Significator or Karaka V/s Lord of the House in Vedic Astrology Chart Analysis

[@kristiinagenix587]

This was such a great explanation and now I can understand my own relationship with my mother more as well.

[@govindavallabhadevidasi9259]

Very well explained. It's rarely explained so cleary. Thank you

[@ujjwalchetan4907]

Great information. Thank you sir❤. Just wanted one clarification. Which is more important: 1) position wise siginificator planet's placement w.r.t. the significator house or sign wise significator's placement(e.g. exaltation, friendly etc...)?

[@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology]

Placement of significator from house is more important in person's life

[@ujjwalchetan4907]

@@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology Okay, thank you sir

[@santi-gm5zo]

Sir you said her mental health was good,but I have a question as moon is indicator of some ones mind,as her moon is debilitated can make her mind unstable

[@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology]

Yes Moon main significator of mind more in terms of emotional thought. She did have serious emotional vulnerabilities, insecurities and mild anxiety in certain situations. Mars and Moon though both in debilitation but their exchange yoga gives strength to both of them. So she is emotionally vulnerable so long as she is not able to take some action (Mars). Once she does, she is much better 🙂

[@santi-gm5zo]

@@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology thank you ,plese do vedeos regularly,your vedeos are easy to understand

[@rajkumarkommalapati1688]

Sir, In this chart 4th Lord is in 4th house, had Jupiter been elsewhere in the chart, should we see from 4th house or from Jupiter's placement. Thank you.

[@govindavallabhadevidasi9259]

If Venus in the 10th house in Scorpio, that would be 7th from 4th. In this video you mentioned that 6th from 4th is not too favourable. What happens in this case? When the karaka aspects the house it is the karaka for

[@malayddvae]

Nicely explained....Good

[@manaklaltiwari4774]

Astrology nicely explained,thks Pl also inform wether she owns her house or not. Because karka planet is placed in 8 th from 4 th house with Ketu.

[@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology]

Yes, she owns her own house. There is more to that but I shall reserve that for a new video on the same chart.

[@vineetha5953]

Hi sir what if 5 lord Jupiter and as well as significator is in 12 house exalted with ketu. What will be the result .

[@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology]

Ketu with Jupiter is not considered good for childbirth and relationship with child. However every chart has different application so Jupiter as 5th lord in 12th with Ketu is great for spiritual progress. Jupiter is 5th lord in Leo or Scorpio ascendant. Jupiter in 12th for Leo ascendant is still better than Scorpio ascendant charts. Conjunction with Ketu however is not good for kids either way.

[@cjnibirsarker5787]

Mars and Moon are in Neecha vanga Raj yoga in this chart?

[@abhimanyusharma3913]

Very nice...can you please elaborate signs as giver and house as receiver ?

[@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology]

Signs indicate what will come naturally (or much easier) or given by God/almighty but house indicate how much the person will want and make efforts to grab it. For Venus related matters, influences on Taurus/Libra will show the "ease" of such matters in life but 7th and 2nd houses in chart will show how the person will want and handle such matters.

[@abhimanyusharma3913]

@@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology beautiful ...hope i will learn some amazing basics from you...thank you .

[@brucewayne2184]

What about for a planet IN the house? Like venus in the 4th for home, but the lord of the 4th is afflicted. Then what happens?

[@lalmuni9191]

Good evening 😊 Fourth house is karaka of bhumi, vahan , bhawan . Also of mother , mental peace , happiness . My question is bhumi- Mars, vahan- sukr, bhawan-Mars , mother-moon, mental peace- ketu, happiness- ?? So receptor is single planet that placed in 4th house . If receptor is bad ,malafic , cruel, debliterated, or paap drist than all that 4th house signify will ruin. If no than why ? Please explain in detail.? If yes than plz clarify ? Regards

[@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology]

Yes, if lord if a house is weak, it reduces the receiving capacity but that will not be same for ALL the significations of one house equally - like we saw two examples in the video - using the karaka planets Venus and Moon. A lot is also biased towards the nature of hosue lord - for example, in this situation Jupiter in own sign Vs Saturn in own sign will play out very differently in the house. An astute astrologer has to look at these basic facts. Btw Ketu for mental peace? I am not sure about that. I hope you are not mixing moksha with mental peace which in the context of 4th house is entirely conscious element of mind.

[@radhekrishnashivshakti4231]

💟🙏 ॐ ♾️🪔 MAY SRI RADHE KRISHNA BLESS YOU ALWAYS 🍁

[@lolerroaster9487]

Sir amonh house house ruler and karka which represent blood relatives (jeeva)?

[@vinodsenapala7751]

Very clearly articulated. Well done!!

[@thek5197]

So ruler represents your reaction but karaka represents the state of what it significates

[@aditikaushal8166]

So to identify the spouse in a female chart, will I look at venus(karka) nakshatra or can I also understand his traits from 7th lord as well?

[@aditikaushal8166]

Or venus tells what the individual person is and 7th lord is the spouse attitude towards female? Or venus tells the spouse as a person and 7th lord is the female’s attitude to her spouse?

[@santi-gm5zo]

Greate sir,complement from sri Lanka

[@reanimator9]

Thank you Sir. Can you make a video about parivartan/exchange, it would be great

[@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology]

Yes, soon

[@muraliraghavan8057]

Sir i am quoting from BPHS 7th. house.If the lord of the 7th. house goes to a dushtana the spouse has health problems.If the Karaka Venus is afflicted the spouse dies.The above rules are not applicable to the planets in own house or exalted. What happens if lord is afflicted and Karaka goes to a Dustana.?

[@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology]

These are principles in classics but not rules to be applied just by one or two planets positions. Regarding this particular BPHS principle, it's more specific and clearer versions are described in Bhavarth Ratnakar where it specifies what kind of afflictions can indicate death of spouse. If 7th lord is in 6th house it can either delay the marriage or indicate serious problems in marriage including health issues for spouse. In 8th house, shows either weak personal bond or overall unstable marriage. House karaka placed in dusthana shows denial, delay or general obstructions in marriage then marital life and overall lady luck. Afflictions with 7th lord shows the difficult circumstances for anyone who marries the native and also the native's grave mistakes in matters of 7th house.

[@Shri75hyd]

Sir, significator (karaka) Vs houselord vs planet posited in that house. Please add planet posited also and enlighten us. What is the role of the planet sitting in that house as a lord of some other house.

[@bhupendrapurohit1106]

Sir one query, moon being lord of 2 house, Mercury n rahu placed in same. U told rashi give to bhava . In this case moon is giving to bhava , but rahu is there , so rahu afflicts moon? Or rahu converts converts amrit of moon in poison. Thanking you in anticipation Regards Bhupendra Purohi

[@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology]

Moon in 2nd house own sign Cancer but conjuct Rahu and Mercury will create issues as Rahu afflicts both the planets ie Moon and Mercury in your example however I don't see it as poinson but it can be highly creative and innovative if Venus or Jupiter aspect this combination. Regards.

[@bhupendrapurohit1106]

@@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology ji ,moon is lord of 2 house and not conjucting. In that case? Thanks

[@basantjayant9932]

dear partho, i am following your videos, many of my doubts were cleared. your exploration of natural and functional malefic/benefic was very logical. though your saying that functional are only event based, kept few of my doubts intact.but i am a new student, so fault has to be mine.Thanks . i request if you could suggest a good book, not very elementary, as few things i have already learned, which could systematically, logically,scientifically, sequentially could help me in learning. thanks

[@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology]

Hello Basant, functional nature of planet is not ONLY event based. That is its predominant role in dynamic side eg predicting events or good/bad experiences in dasha. Functional role does have some important part in static analysis too for example yogas between Kendra and trine houses is considered good - this is obviously functional role of planets.

[@vincentmulder]

couldn't it be Venus conjunct Saturn giving the "normal" car?

[@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology]

Yes, Venus + Saturn conjuction keeps her car very modest and practical but not very old or poor condition car because 4th house lord jupiter is strong in own sign and a natural benefic in 4th house keeps her wise in the 4th house matters including car.

[@2347162]

Very good

[@venkybly]

Tq

[@ravipatel5922]

In my case I have a moon and venus in my 3rd house in libra and mars in 4th house, but the result is different from the sir you explained.

[@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology]

Thanks for your comment. Pls also mention different in what signification of 4th house. Venus at 12th from ANY house is great for the house. In this case the vehicles, aesthetics related matters of 4th house is strengthened by a strong Venus being 12th from it. Moon in 3rd creates some mismatch with mother's individual nature though moon's conjunction with dispositor Venus makes it workable. Mars in 4th house Scorpio absolutely makes your 4th house perspectives very sharp, territorial, uncompromising, extremely prioritised and strong.

[@ravipatel5922]

@@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology Sir as you said in video planet from 6,8,12 from their significant houses is not good, if venus is exceptional then it is not contradicting. Being the smallest child in my family, my mother's bond is stronger with me than my elder sister and brother. So the moon in the 12th from the 4th house is contradictory. By the way sir, thank you for the reply.

[@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology]

​@@ravipatel5922 mismatch is in basic nature between you and mother. You two are vastly different as individuals. That does not mean relationship with mother is hostage to that. Relationship with mother is good because of strong Mars in it's own feminine sign Scorpio in your chart as I mentioned. Venus in 12th from any house is good for indulgence/enjoyment significations of that house - that's mentioned in classical text and practically applicable too. In natural zodiac, Venus is exalted in 12th sign i.e. Pisces.

[@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology]

Just to add, Venus is 9th from 7th house in your chart so for relationship/marriage perspective it's supportive. It's 12th from 4th house of vehicles so it's great for those matters of 4th house too (because Venus in 12th from a house is good for feel good matters).

[@ravipatel5922]

@@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology Yes correct sir, mismatch between nature is there between me and my mother.

[@saibharath8541]

Vedic astrology there is no neptune brother

[@ParthoBanerjee_Astrology]

So I don't remember mentioning Neptune in Vedic astrology in the video

[@brahmajosyulavenkatasubram7401]

𝗧𝗵𝗮𝗻𝗸 𝘆𝗼𝘂 𝗳𝗼𝗿 𝗹𝘂𝗰𝗶𝗱 𝗲𝘅𝗽𝗹𝗮𝗻𝗮𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻 𝗸𝗮𝗿𝗮𝗸𝗮 𝗮𝗻𝗱 𝗵𝗼𝘂𝘀𝗲 𝗹𝗼𝗿𝗱 𝘄𝗵𝗮𝘁 𝗮𝗯𝗼𝘂𝘁 𝗼𝗰𝗰𝘂𝗽𝗮𝗻𝘁 𝗼𝗳 𝘁𝗵𝗲 𝗵𝗼𝘂𝘀𝗲. 𝗼𝘁𝗵𝗲𝗿 𝘁𝗵𝗮𝗻 𝗷𝘂𝗽𝗶𝘁𝗲𝗿.