Minecraft Bedrock: Universal TREE FARM! Simple & Fast Tutorial! MCPE Xbox PC PS4

[@silentwisperer]

**UPDATE** You may need to replace the main burnout clock, with a more reliable comparator clock: kzbin.info/www/bejne/n2qyd4mEjbtsgKc I have a newer version of this farm! Its fully afk & playerless! Check it out :D kzbin.info/www/bejne/oJ6Zinx_m5aJq8k Note: Oak trees can sometimes generate a beehive if they are grown in a plains biome! I would recommend avoiding plains biomes for this build:) Thank you so much for watching! I hope you have enjoyed todays tutorial 😊it took me a couple days to design this, but i think it turned out really well for being my first tree farm! A little *note* about acacia mode, there are some very rare tree generations that will have awkward branches, and that could cause them to not be fully harvested. So when using acacia mode, watch out for an extra log here or there:)

[@kid8467]

first

[@Southh]

@@kid8467 bruh

[@charlieprice059]

Thanks for the tutorial! I will definitely be sure to build this! New sub!

[@StepanAsk]

Whats so cool! Thank you!

[@toastroast6484]

Hmm too slow

[@colesmith6874]

The pure quality of this tutorial is very satisfying. No wasted time or rambling, clear overview of farm, explains mechanics simply, gives credit when it’s due, high quality, easy to follow, entertaining, and a good design. Nice.

[@chaseabod3080]

17:03, for the literal 0% of people who see this, I am just tired so I am marking my stopping point for today.

[@toxicice8567]

lol

[@mattbutalt723]

You've done watching?

[@chaseabod3080]

Yeah I have now

[@ved0697]

"For the literal 0% of people who see this" In one of the top comments

[@ianmoore5502]

I built this all at once and honestly had to stop mc for a day because of how intensive it was lol

[@green-o-land]

Heres the Items u need to make those blocks (Pistons Observers etc. etc.) :-:To Craft:-: *16 stacks and 4 Cobblestone* (Pistons,Observer,Lever,Dispenser,Dropper,building blocks,Blocks for Acacia Mode) *One Stack and 58 Slime* (For the Sticky Piston) *3 Stacks And 44 Iron* (Pistons,Observers,Hoppers) *8 Stacks and 63 Redstone* (Almost all Blocks, too lazy) *60 Quartz* (Comparator,Observers) *One Stack and 4 Sticks* (Redstone Torch,Repeater,Comparator,Levers) *9 Stacks and 27* (Any) Wood (Pistons,Hoppers,) *2 Bows* For 2 Dispenser *16 Glowstone Dust* For 2 Redstone Lamp :-:To Smelt:-: *One Stack and 14 Cobblestone* for the Stone (Comparator,Repeater) *Two Stacks and 43 Sand* For the Glass *THE MOST IMPORTANT THING* dirt

[@AfromanRants]

I’m sorry, did you say 64 *stacks* of slime?!

[@pattykat85]

Just have built an 11-layer slime farm for that farm... Hope to collect those fast, cause i wanna start my "Sanctum" soon.... 😎 Edit: Was collecting the slimes, as i realized that it's "only" 2 stacks of sticky pistons... So I guess about 18 stacks of slime balls should bei enough. 😅😎

[@kermicide4202]

@@pattykat85nop i used 2 stacks of slime BALLS and it was enough

[@pattykat85]

​@@kermicide4202​ Yeah, i thought it was slime BLOCKS. 😅 .... Now i have more than enough (made an automatic castle gate and a tree farm and still so much left)

[@creepingaround3714]

This is very helpful!

[@emiliohernandez6005]

Whenever somebody is able to design a tree farm that can handle all trees including acacia, that person would be crowned the Queen/King of redstone

[@Wonder_ing_David]

Out there is a most universal farm. That can handle even big spruce trees.

[@andypleiman7103]

Yes but it doesn’t include dark oak...

[@createyourownfuture5410]

MUMBO JUMBO?

[@vanyakostyanovsky889]

Well there is someone who has made a universal tree farm which runs on I believe a 14 game tick piston cycle, however they haven’t released a video on it yet. They’re called Ninjapigeon

[@abdurrahmanmujahid1577]

There is a guy who made a dark oak tree farm and also a universal without dark oaj

[@GioGio-rx1oo]

I swear to god people that make automatic farms are the smartest humans alive. like how do you ever come up with something as complex for a simple task??????

[@jeffnubskin9164]

Bigg brane

[@NetheriteMinerMicrowavegang]

10000 IQ

[@Deadlyvoltage3]

Honestly it isn’t as difficult as you think. You can mess around for like an hour and get to understand some basic mechanics. Then you can combine some basic mechanics and keep expanding until it’s one complex machine

[@editazilinskyte3681]

Its not that hard. Its all just little bits put together. I think alot of people that dont how to do something have this reaction. Like anytime someone sees me solve a rubiks cube they think its amazing. But its actually easy and you can learn how to do it within and hour most people just give up after a few minutes tho.

[@kgill-_-7042]

But I’m small brain and I always try to design my own farms

[@Meowmeowdhhsjsjgdgdjd]

For anyone wondering this still work like a charm

[@JokerXD-dg5ne]

Thanks I'm about to build it on my realm

[@Meowmeowdhhsjsjgdgdjd]

@@JokerXD-dg5ne np

[@Meowmeowdhhsjsjgdgdjd]

@Cayden Steinebach yea it works good but the only thing is that when there is other redstone farms or anything to do with redstone the machine breaks and dies so now I have to rebuild

[@bigboi5425]

Thanks so much

[@morgan-rq9ir]

doesn’t for me

[@Lazy_Tiger11]

The explanations at the start of this video are exactly why Silent is the best Bedrock farm / red stone KZbinr - how it works, where the floor level is, where the output goes, all the flaws - exactly what we need. Much better than the ones who jump straight into "place this block here etc" You've given me confidence to give it a try

[@greendooars1614]

Yeah most of players doesn't explain how the farm works or something they juat show the totorial and go away.

[@dragonairre9634]

Time to spend 5 hours building it and use it for 30 minutes so I can make some trapdoors for my creeper farm

[@xboxleep6484]

Your giving me flashbacks

[@dragonairre9634]

@@ChrisOBrien1990 Lol that's exactly what I did. I ran out of bonemeal

[@firegodessreiko]

@@dragonairre9634 make a sweetberry farm and never run low again~ Or, yanno.... skeleton sweeper, but since you seem averse to big builds....

[@dragonairre9634]

@@firegodessreiko Already have a large mob farm which I never use nowadays

[@HeplingHandGaming]

@@dragonairre9634 expandable kelp farm produces more than enough bonemeal.

[@outcxzt615]

This was made over a year ago and STILL works perfectly in bedrock 1.19

[@7071DG]

Yippee!

[@mrcubepad4564]

Wow which means I did something wrong,mine's still left some log in oak mode

[@outcxzt615]

@@mrcubepad4564 I had the same issue, go back to the double piston extender and make sure you made that part correctly. That fixed it for me!

[@mrcubepad4564]

@@outcxzt615 Thank you so much it was the glass stacking on my redstone,a cobblestone block a path.Fixed now,its truly is working in 1.19 very well.Tryna build a tnt bomber now cuz I don't like the wither ones.

[@yas9253]

@@mrcubepad4564 ig tnt duper doesn't works in bedrock do they?

[@thonham4986]

Praise be to the Bedrock Edition Mumbo Jumbo

[@aytoad]

YAAASSS

[@MrWestonR]

Hallowed be his name

[@gamemodezero7310]

*more or less ilmango

[@Cranbearry_YouTube]

True that!

[@chrissjskrn]

Nah mumbo doesn’t do any tutorials

[@devonwatts2236]

Just built this on survival bedrock 1.19 and took out the sapling return and instead connected my bonemeal farm to it. I love this thing. Many thanks for the tutorial.

[@claudiaborges986]

Play on pc or móbile?

[@WHYARENOHANDLESAVAILABLE1]

How much bonemeal p/hour did you farm produce and did it ever run out

[@bushbik1787]

Silent, I really liked the description of the video. It was nice that you pointed out that you needed the money from patreon in harsh times to support you and your family. I also liked that even after that, you didn't beg for the patreon like a lot of people do. You were fine if people couldn't support you, and you still stayed happy! You are a really kind youtuber Silent!

[@SeedlingNL]

Replace one of the hoppers in the middle with a grass block with a flower on it. If you then plant birch or oak saplings, you occasionally get beehives :D If you farm trees at night, the bees will stay inside and you can Silkscribe! them without angering them.

[@MechBlaster360z]

Thats quite an effective and efficient way tbh !

[@viqxs4229]

I just built this farm in Minecraft 1.19.2 and it works amazing, this video was made over 2 years ago! One thing you need to do is go to his other channel and find the video where he talks about the fixes for this farm you will need them to use the farm. Thank you silent for making this amazing farm you never disappoint!

[@justinstammberger4898]

Hey can you link the Video where here Talks about the fixes please? I cant find it 😕

[@josecosta5152]

​@@justinstammberger4898 you can find a link to the vídeo on silent coment

[@janrenzendiable5622]

Forget about the tree farm, Im here because of the double piston extender

[@jaysonbunnell8097]

same, my double piston extender so far has been slow and sucky

[@bobbob4173]

What kind do you need? I can design one for you

[@andylines8040]

@LifeLikeLion 2 4 0 ratio for life

[@cowch3916]

@@andylines8040 I don’t think that works on bedrock

[@cristinavilla4918]

U dont know how to build a double piston extender what its so easy

[@jaov2k]

Silent: "...mac n cheese with Ketchup" Me: Pause video. Dry heave uncontrollably. Resume video.

[@skyjack1]

Don't worry, I've heard about worse food.

[@Heisenberg612]

mac and cheese with ketchup isn't nearly as disgusting as it sounds

[@Wonder_ing_David]

My macs are just mac n ketchup lol

[@platinumxyminecraft7457]

Lucky you, you got a like from silent

[@maxlippert7902]

Ok this is similar and sounds weird but trust me... mac and cheese with barbecue sauce. It’s the best with the “blues hog” brand bc it’s a more sweet and I just do a littler drizzle. Definitely the best accomplishment out of my 16 years of living :)

[@keithdeal869]

Dude, I had to build 3 of your other farms just so I could build this farm, so I can build another of your farms😆😉 great job on the tutorial. Doing this in survival took me 4 hours. I must have watched every 10 seconds of the tutorial part atleast 5 times to make sure I got everything positioned right.

[@silentwisperer]

welcome to the rabbit hole of minecraft 😂 gets ya everytime haha keep in mind you can slowdown the video playback speed to make it easier to build:)

[@Nikigun]

Can you make a tutorial of different ways for destroying the wood?

[@kim-jongun7283]

Axe, wither cage, tnt, ghast blaster

[@kim-jongun7283]

It’s not exactly the best but it’s good

[@Wonder_ing_David]

@Med Amine Boudjada wither is the best*

[@angvla_]

Wither and ghast are best, but need mobs that are extremely difficult to get and control, especially ghasts. TNT doesn’t drop all the blocks on bedrock so there would be massive lossage with tnt. Axes are inefficient, but the easiest and most reliable, and can still be pretty efficient with haste 2. Axes are the best option for the average minecrafter, only use ghasts or withers if you need multiple double chests of wood.

[@silentwisperer]

Coming soon:)

[@silverangels3150]

THIS IS HISTORY: EFFICIENT AND EASY TREE FARMS IN BEDROCK EDITION!!!! Note: I know there are other good tree farms in Bedrock Edition, it's a joke, please try and understand that

[@renegangfan5630]

Amazing innovation

[@TheFriendlyFeesh]

agreed

[@jonathanc2311]

Ya but it’s kinda expensive I’m mean a grass block that’s crazy

[@Obi_]

There were already fast and simple tree farms, they just weren’t as accessible as this one.

[@vachellouisbaquiran5006]

Is this only in 1.16?

[@t4c037]

The fact that this man is still replying to comments really does show how much of a good youtuber he is

[@EZ2BCHEEZY36]

2:08 that transition had me like "who tf was standing behind silent that whole time"

[@kaarthiksai1089]

True

[@scuttle9226]

Just built this in my creative test world and it works perfectly. I haven’t played Minecraft very long and this the first big Redstone contraption I have built. Thank you so much for the tutorial.

[@Vinlie]

Y'all haven't experienced true loss until you get halfway done building this thing and two creepers sneak up on you to blow up all the redstone infrastructure.

[@hc_jiymister5577]

It took me hours to build this

[@dmc8129]

A creeper blew me up literally right after I read this

[@RainyGrinch]

This is without a doubt one of the most impressive tree farms I have ever seen - especially for Bedrock! Thank you!

[@valerapirat]

I am a player from Russia and I am very grateful to you for your videos. There are very few such wonderful videos in my language. (I apologize if I made a lot of mistakes)

[@Karrikua]

This is the best farm ever. It took me a long time to build it and I made it on a chunk border first so I had to rebuild it... There was a lot of cursing involved. Love your tutorials! Would love a dark oak wood farm too...

[@SonGoku-wd4mi]

I feel so bad..... I've had similar experiences but not on that scale. Hopefully, this farm makes up for the time loss Jesus

[@Karrikua]

@@SonGoku-wd4mi Hehe, I appreciate that! It is worth it for sure! It’s really, really good and the only proper wood farm for bedrock that I’ve found.

[@SonGoku-wd4mi]

@@Karrikua I'm just starting to build mine right now. any tips other than the obvious? hahaha

[@Karrikua]

@@SonGoku-wd4mi Hehe. As long as you follow all the instructions in the video you should be good 😅 I think I would recommend enclosing the farm with a block that takes a long time to break because I kept destroying the glass/redstone when I first used it. Also make another piston line or two so you can use it for longer before having to harvest the wood.

[@SonGoku-wd4mi]

@@Karrikua I finished the farm and I only had to rebuild the repeater mess for the achacha wood (lol) other then that it’s a wonderful farm

[@araynick8577]

"Scared of tree farms for 12 years" yo Minecraft has been around for XD

[@theguyinthechair]

Thank you so much for dividing the material list into stacks! Now I won't have to do it myself!

[@cizlerable]

This is great. The way you take apart construction and why and how it works is really good. You've made me understand red stone so much more.

[@oddles15]

Just finished this build. I LOVE IT! Thank you for another wonderful farm.

[@Fra-jn4cm]

Aaaah damnit i have everything i need for the farm except that dirt block

[@moopymeebloopy456]

Lol

[@darthdiabeticOG]

Yeah they're really rare

[@DrHusky2749]

@@darthdiabeticOG rarest block in the game if I recall

[@darthdiabeticOG]

@@DrHusky2749 yup

[@phyllisterbrock5193]

Lol

[@mawfbooph1138]

If anyone is wondering, yes this still works. Built it on my survival world today. Anyone who says it isn’t working didn’t do it right

[@GrzegorzLenart-pz3nz]

Thanks

[@perfectbrosstevenskerstete5640]

How much bone meal per hour dose it ues

[@d31t4x3]

Tomorrow silent: this tree farm is broken

[@fatso5573]

classic -bedrock- bugrock

[@sebastianramos5833]

@@fatso5573 it really is tho

[@fatso5573]

@@sebastianramos5833 just built it and it worked perfectly fine, you probably did something wrong

[@austinhilley8205]

@@fatso5573 U do realize that he was talking abt it being bugrock right?

[@ooliver]

@@fatso5573 they literally said it, they didn't build it tomorrow

[@thekingoffiction4977]

I’ve never seen one that works this way. This is kinda awesome!

[@davide6447]

Just chose to build this farm, works great. I even added a cube maker you can also use to create and stack concrete blocks. The only issue i have is with the safety system to block the farm once you reached the max lenght as i still have to properly understand the redstone of this build. Now i'm just making a bell ring, but if someone added this feature on this farm, i would be glad to know to which section i should wire the system. Thanks everybody and of course thanks Silent, always the best :)

[@daelynsky5023]

I do NOT trust tree farms but I trust silentwisperer! Its time I move on from the OG dirt bridge and water collection! xD

[@oliefitzharris27]

Can we get a creeper farm next? Most of them are for Java or really big.

[@darkerebus1398]

I'm not sure but with the current mechanics a simple general mob farm would work... I'll make one soon and I'll update you on the drop rate of gunpowder from there

[@jasonmok8072]

Or witch hut

[@oliefitzharris27]

@@jasonmok8072 yea

[@ooliver]

@@jasonmok8072 why are you commenting this everywhere he already has a tutorial that just needs the new trident killers

[@bobbobberson5371]

They are in the process of changing mechanics that affect them he probably won’t unless he knows it doesn’t have a chance of breaking in a few weeks. Also, they unfortunately need to be big for really good rates, but if you want you can make only part of one if you just need it for rockets or something.

[@ClixUploads.]

its been 3 years and still works!! great vid :)

[@rushil1837]

can you design a wither cage? That would be much appreciated! Great video!

[@kim-jongun7283]

Check out jx67’s with cage design

[@Wonder_ing_David]

@@kim-jongun7283 even though you need to add more Bedrock.

[@desaifamily8239]

The tricky bit would be getting the trees into the required 2x4 or less area

[@desaifamily8239]

I mean the logs

[@Defnetlynotken]

@@desaifamily8239 just build silents tree farm and implent those redstone for the wither cage part

[@jeffbrander7572]

Hey guys not sure if some mechanics have changed or if realms lag is the issue but if your double piston extender isn't retracting the solid block all the way on your oak switch place an observer facing the upper piston and a redstone line into the lower piston. It should review the lower piston and grab the solid block

[@deathtomerryweather8275]

I have a friend who is one of those math guys who plans out his builds. When I say plan, I mean gather enough resources to build the structure to where when he is done, he won’t have blocks/components left. He never crafted red stone based items. So a couple of days ago, I showed him this list and told him to get resources within a week. He said no problem, accepting the challenge. But when I told him the requirements for every block. His jaw dropped

[@kadensummers8183]

Me: stops building to watch tutorial again Creeper: 👀 Me: hears 'tsssssss' Me again: 🙀

[@lordmandy5445]

Kinda wanna make a remix “solid block, solid block, solid block, red stone torch solid block...”

[@supernova5712]

Tested it on my creative world yesterday, works greatly. What can break this farm is spamming saplings , I recommend watching the trees and make sure they are pushed correctly first then plant your next sapling.

[@squallloky]

I built this and love it even tho there is weird piston timings from time to time I'd love a 2x2 tree version for spruce and dark oak :)

[@its_soapy7]

And jungle!

[@desaifamily8239]

Me after seeing this: This is insane! Me after hearing silent say that we gotta chunk align it: Maybe insane’s the wrong word...

[@hyper_g9720]

It's not that big of a deal lol

[@jasonmok8072]

you’re worrying about chunk aligning? LULW

[@mistyarcher802]

I feel it, honestly..

[@ooliver]

that's hardly a problem, he says that because of bedrock edition breaks just about every farm with redstone that isn't chuk alighned

[@desaifamily8239]

@@hyper_g9720 I know it’s just pretty annoying and I can’t download texture packs I’m on xbox

[@johndavidjudeii]

Update Mar 26th, 2022: it works but you must make some changes to the redstone timing. Make sure to switch out the burnout clock with the comparator clock and switch out the pressure plate with a lever ( as seen in Silent's UPDATE video pinned in the comments). Then change the right wall timing to four ticks as shown in the video at 19:25. Next, the pistons of the back wall have two timing repeaters, place the left repeator on 3 ticks and the right on 4 ticks (which will help avoid the problem where the front pistons of the back wall are not retracted). Next, since you adjusted that timing you must now adjust the timings on the back left log extractor which will help the back wall pistons from being sucked out by the log extractor. In the back left corner you will have three repeators in a row which add up to 10 ticks (2+4+4), add one more tick (3+4+4). This will delay your slime pistons of the extractor. Though now we have to delay the normal pistons which then push the logs out of the machine. There is no pretty way to do this. Remove the observer and solide block and branch off the stair step with a repeator on one tick going into the pistion with the glass tower. That should make the machine mechanics work properly. The acacia mode also needs additional ticks. Below Jeeyul says he was able to fix the timing with 20 ticks on the second cycle and 40 ticks on the third cycle. Though, I was able to get good results by adding to repeators on 4 ticks each to the third cycle only. Just extend the length of the third cycle by one block and add two repeators facing the opposite directions. There are some other issues. Oak trees grow gnarly trees even with the piston extender. You must turn on the extender, add one more block to the extender and remove the top sticky piston from the left wall. You only need to do this for oak trees. Then when you want to do other trees, add the sticky piston back and remove the extra block from the piston extender in the roof. Your rates will be low when using oak trees due to this issue. I made a cube maker (which you can find out how to make in Silent's Azalea Tree Farm tutorial) and had issues with the bottom row of my tree columns disappearing some of the time, thus the smart piston wall wouldnt work and it would back up the machine. So instead of using a redstone tourch on the far end of the cube maker, I used an observer column with an observer stabilizer and then led the restone into the wall of pistons. The right (open) side of your cube maker might need multiple redstone tourches in a row, because of the same problem, to read when to stop the bonemeal dispensers and tell you that it is time to harvest the logs. I made Silent's Azalea Tree Farm first but it uses a ton of bonemeal and I didn't think it was worth it, plus the timings weren't working and I couldn't fix it. I am playing on a Realm in Bedrock.

[@jeeeyullee9101]

iOS v1.18.12 Your solution solves the problem that occurs when both pistons simultaneously push two logs placed side by side on the same layer in opposite directions before one is pulled. This was a problem I had been hanging on all night. Thank you very much. I also had to set the repeat circuit for the acacia tree to 20 ticks (5 repeaters) and 40 ticks (10 repeaters) respectively. It's natural because the whole cycle is longer, but I'll mention it for other challengers. Burnout issues do happen occasionally, but I used the original burnout clock as is, because planting seedlings without waiting for full operation saves bone meal. Thanks again.

[@johndavidjudeii]

@@jeeeyullee9101 Great, thanks for sharing! I will add it to my first response just in case others dont see it here.

[@healthyvirus2815]

Hi ! I don't know anything about redstone so I am kind of lost. Around 10:30 one of the redstone torches just turns off for whatever reason. Do you know how to fix it ?

[@johndavidjudeii]

@@healthyvirus2815 that torch is part of the burn out clock. Replace the entire burn out clock with a comparator clock. There is a pinned video above on how to do that.

[@healthyvirus2815]

@@johndavidjudeii Thanks

[@1996Blue]

Anyone else have to watch this at half the speed

[@raffaeleiovine4747]

Half Speed? I watched It at 0.25

[@xboxleep6484]

.75

[@firegodessreiko]

Yes, always.

[@beezalis1574]

Lmao i just pause everytime he places one block

[@slavojdyrdek]

I gotta slow down every build tutorial I watch lol

[@clofreeze1878]

Silent is it possible for you to make a tutorial for creeper farms! Anyway your videos are awesome❤️

[@OmkarNevse]

if you are asking for a creeper farm to use tnt for the trees then im sorry to break it out to you but tnt doesnt have 100% droprate on bedrock so you will lose more than half of the blocks broken by tnt

[@jasonmok8072]

or witch huts

[@ooliver]

@@OmkarNevse I don't think loss is much of a problem if you can afk there fully

[@ooliver]

@@jasonmok8072 he already has an old video, just use common sense for some of it like the normal trident killer design with redstone torches and observers I built it then we needed a backup on the realm for other reasons but it worked fine

[@clofreeze1878]

@@OmkarNevse I know I want rockets

[@nuclearchungus8134]

I built your slime farm and it worked excellent, just got done building this farm and it is another amazing farm, I saw your comment saying acacia mode has an extra log that can come around and I've had it happen but it's a price I'm willing to pay

[@P3njaminCity]

Holy cow... This took a couple of scratches to the head, a couple of brain explosions, and all of my braincells to disappear... But at the end it was totally worth it 😅 Thank you so much lol EDIT: And yes, this still currently works :)

[@baltazar6420]

What do I do if my burnout clock stops out of know where

[@P3njaminCity]

@@baltazar6420 I believe it has to do with the chunks, just like Silent Whisperer mentioned earlier you have to make sure it's all in a single chunk.

[@phillmason9307]

But what if the sticky pistons don't crush the leaves?

[@branntfahrney9274]

It still works but for oak trees, they can occasionally spawn a bees nest which is annoying since they fight you when it is moved,just something to point out!

[@varyandeivaramadhan508]

Wow nice

[@kepritedude15]

Pretty sure only in certain biomes but i dunno

[@sterlingd1984]

@@kepritedude15 only spawns bees if there's a flower within 2blocks of the oak or birch sapling

[@branntfahrney9274]

@@sterlingd1984 do vines count?

[@nickliu6973]

Great tutorial! Built a simplified version for birch in Bedrock 1.18 survival. The comparator detector and the piston layout in the video are amazing. This tree farm is not simple. Took me 2 days to understand everything but the result was satisfying. Thanks for the video!

[@samuellabelle4474]

Did the acacia mode work, what did you changed?

[@nickliu6973]

@@samuellabelle4474 I didn't try acacia. My simplified version did not have the multi-cycling and the height-limiting functions. I reduced the number of dispensers to one, rewired some redstone, rotated the output window by 90 degrees, and added an overflow protector.

[@azucanika5720]

silentwhisperer: ...simple... Me seeing a red stone factory in the background and in the tree farm

[@johnnycashjunky6399]

Love it! Thanks so much Silent! Anyone else have a minor issue where on of the sticky pistons will occasionally get pulled into the log output line

[@kristofernisidis2519]

Yeah did you ever figure that out i just built it

[@leonkrause]

Like at 19:25 in the video but with random pistons? Same here .. Any ideas how to solve it?

[@24voltsdc87]

The area of the farm where a two tick repeater feeds 2 four tick repeaters into a observer, change the two tick to a three tick and that should fix it.

[@rafaelvasallo7892]

@@24voltsdc87 ya me too

[@Nickaliiam]

@@24voltsdc87 you sweet mfer I was hating silent so much

[@Ryan-om2gk]

Thank you for this amazing tutorial. This farm still works today

[@zacherysmith9324]

Made this is 2024, works perfectly added a cuber on the end and gets me tons of wood

[@jenharper1551]

I’m certain if I spend enough time I can figure out a mechanism to make a cube for chopping purposes. However I’m certain you could design one in a tenth of the time it would take me. Any chance you could include some explanation with good pictures if not step by step instructions when you upload ghast blaster video? If not I understand. One last suggestion don’t race through the step by step instructions. I know it’s easy for you but for us newbies I can end up pausing and rewatching a clip multiple times because you went so fast I missed orientation of observers or repeaters or block placement. You are the best with giving great supply lists. I love how you include them in the video comments. So much easier than showing an inventory with all the needed materials which seems to be common in KZbin tutorials. I’ll add more to this novel in another video.

[@jasonmok8072]

Lol it’s just a wall of pistons with a detection system

[@MoonBread_]

Put video at 0.75 if you want; also I agree a 12x12 cube maker is actually really difficult, the observers fire twice if you don’t do any complicated redstone

[@jasonmok8072]

@@MoonBread_ nah you can use a torch on a block to power the redstone lines for the piston wall. Plus, fixing that observer double firing thing is actually pretty easy to fix

[@MoonBread_]

@@jasonmok8072 Thanks for the info

[@grayplaysgaming]

You, my good sir, are nothing short of genius. Thank you so much for sharing this design.

[@rowanmilnor9725]

I am playing on 1.16.201 and my sticky pistons keep getting pulled out of place. i rechecked the timings and couldnt find anything wrong, any advice

[@duaneingrouille1703]

I'm getting the same problem dude did you find a solution yet?

[@firegodessreiko]

Did you flick a lever on or off while the farm was running like he said not to because it would do exactly that? Or is it happening constantly?

[@duaneingrouille1703]

@@firegodessreiko I've solved my issue one of the redstone lines on the first wall of double piston extenders was not connected for some reason. I hooked it up and working fine now.

[@leonkrause]

Like shown in the video at 19:25? I have the same problem. Any ideas how to aproach it?

[@hoodystriker101]

make sure ur NOT building on a chunk border ps; use chunkbase website to find out the chunk borders of ur world

[@JohnnyG919]

I was able to get it working for everything but the acacia. For some reason, when I turn on the acacia circuit, it does cycle multiple times, but not all the wood is moved to the center and often the sticky pistons end up moved instead of the wood. It seems like the timing is not quite right but I've gone over it more times than I can count and it looks like it matches the video exactly. I suppose it's still possible that I missed something but it sure doesn't look like it. I love it for all the other trees, but acacia seems to break the farm. Maybe I need some more ketchup on the mac & cheese. :)

[@krxhzie8300]

WORKS SO GOOD AND it doesnt look ugly!!! it looks impressive and confusing overall making me look like a redstone magician 😂 tysm

[@thiccsnickerrz7388]

I was thinking to myself “I need a tree farm, I’m running low on wood and don’t want to ruin the landscape by my base” the next day, this comes out

[@zzCaptHowdy]

that's absolutely a work of art, brother

[@blueiron270]

Is it supposed to be this satisfying when you make a tree farm? THANK YOU SILENT for this WONDERFUL and easy to understand tutorial, it's so easy to understand what you're saying and doing and I absolutely love it. You're an amazing KZbinr, and thank you again!

[@The_magical_catt]

So, I made this farm in 1.21 and it works excellenty I really recommend building this one because it uses a lot less bonemeal then other tree farms..

[@Tindecasterodeordenezafransisc]

Weird it did not in my world

[@The_magical_catt]

@Tindecasterodeordenezafransisc Check the redstone part again you might have made a mistake in the comparator like I did, check them carefully

[@Tindecasterodeordenezafransisc]

@@The_magical_catt mhh tye i will check again

[@theweirdnessfactor5715]

Do you know about how many observers, pistons, etc etc you need exactly. I see many with how many items you need for the Redstone components but not how many Redstone components you actually need. I dont want to many too much of one and not have enough materials for another :/

[@The_magical_catt]

@@theweirdnessfactor5715 The material uses the exact amount of items but you should still make 2-4 extra items

[@quiblie7369]

How do you stop the pistons from being pulled into the tree line on acacia mode?

[@brendanminto3459]

19:18 may help

[@stefanistylinson3318]

I can't believe I manage to make this farm! I had to do it twice because the first time I messed up just one thing and the rest didn't work. But now it's working great! This is really complex, you have to follow every step carefully. And no mistakes will be made. (Sorry for the bad inglish)

[@MakB546]

8:43 (This is just for myself when I watch this over later)

[@Commando2278]

Does it work with cherry trees if not can u make one that does aswell love the videos thanks

[@jasonmarbach]

This farm is INCREDIBLE. Thanks, amigo.

[@pimpddychkrchz]

Farm works great on the current update except for acacia trees. When I try to farm acacia trees sometimes it doesn't get all the logs which causes pistons to be pushed out of place. Every other tree variant works fine except for this type so I'm trying to figure out what the issue is.

[@radioactivefroggy5276]

Same issue for me.

[@kj.champ.04]

I’m so sad rn. I put the exact amount of items in a shucker box and built this, but when I was done I had one extra red stone dust. My machine is broken and idk where the one piece goes 😭😭

[@ishantkumar5423]

Yaaaay

[@sauerbirnetv-jl7ux]

thank you this farm really helped me,everybody else makes videos with fake tree farms or unefficent ones, this farm is great well explained and helped me alot you defenetly earned an subscriber

[@Gruntalbdg]

So I built this farm in bedrock on the Xbox one, it keeps breaking. Pistons don't always retract and wood doesn't go to the corner. It stays in the block right next to ejection site.

[@Flowthro]

Yeah same but im on windows 10

[@rouvinfung3089]

have you chunk aligned it?

[@Gruntalbdg]

@@rouvinfung3089 Yes, I used the leaf block trick to find the chunk. So I have built it within that one chunk.

[@medericharnois6459]

Had same problem had to add extra repeater on 1 tic next to the repeater at 19.45 in video he has his on 4 tics wasnt enough kept messing up pistons 1 tic worked

[@Killzmantex]

I literally was just thinking I needed this

[@johnnyutah6963]

just finished the farm, works flawlessly 2 years later. well done

[@commanderlego9042]

Yo thanks for saying that, I was wondering if it worked in later times

[@edgarthe2ndd]

Hey silence. I just made this machine on my main world and it works beautifully except for one thing. Whenever the tree grows, it only ends up pulling the bottom log and leaves the other stuff floating. I’m not sure how to fix it so if you can get back to me it would be great! Thanks for this video

[@aryaavicena6594]

I just face the same problem like you and i have no idea what's wrong or what should i fix

[@charitywilliams5881]

I had the same issue due to an error I made - I placed a column of sticky pistons where I should've placed observers. I could also see this issue happening if any of the observers that are placed next to the pistons are facing the wrong way. Hopefully this helps :)

[@Star-du2od]

I'm having a ton of trouble with some of the sticky pistons not retracting the normal pistons and I triple checked all of my timing circuts. I play with no kids and have no other farms nearby. PLEASE HELP

[@Star-du2od]

It is using up my bone meal bc the pistons are in the way of the tree growing and my return rate is slashed as well.

[@mattmonville5301]

Same it only happens on the right side for me tho

[@jacobmathew7652]

Make sure all the rest one are linked up If not you can use glass and add some red stone dust to link everything up

[@Star-du2od]

@@jacobmathew7652 it's all hooked up, I think it's just bedrock

[@augustomado9699]

Same as me

[@gabrielbournival6036]

Amazing tutorial! Easy to follow and it work perfectly on bedrock👍

[@silentwisperer]

:)

[@sukooliscool]

I love how says everything is so easy. (me struggling to wait for glass to smelt)

[@jaxmeteur]

When the redstone is “simple”

[@theogrezwei7082]

Built this chunk aligned and double checked the repeater timings and it works great for every everything but acacia. In acacia mode the multicycle stage of pistons has pistons end up out of place. Can't find where I midbuilt and wondered if anyone else had this happen. Playing on a realm with a not great connection so thought maybe just bedrock jankiness too. Thanks for the video was a fun build.

[@tobiwankanobi9613]

Nope mine dose it to don’t know why

[@theogrezwei7082]

@@tobiwankanobi9613 I added 8 more ticks of delay to the start of the second and third cycle and that seemed to help quite a bit still does it now and then but less often and fewer of them

[@jamiestover6383]

My initial clock that should be active when I step on the pressure plate doesn't work... I have no idea why, i think I followed everything right? The clock seems to turn off by itself when first constructed and never works again after

[@jamiestover6383]

the clock doesn't work for me even when i built it on its own. Maybe im experiencing a new and annoying bug, not sure. Any help would be appreciated

[@jamiestover6383]

Update: logging off for a few min seemed to fix the issue. took a couple of tries, but if anyone else experiences this issue i would try the same thing

[@bouweadriaansen2682]

Maybe it’s because lag.

[@silentwisperer]

Updated the pinned comment regarding burnout clocks

[@jamiestover6383]

@@silentwisperer Thank you! Love your videos

[@andreas.e3172]

My redstone clock turns off after a while, do anyone know why it happens? Cause I've done exactly as in the video.

[@lasi_eisbaer]

If you still have the issue here is the solution: The blocks on top have to be placed very fast

[@alexanderhe646]

also build this away from any other redstone builds, check pinned comment

[@TheValenberry]

it's so satisfying to watch the wood being harvested automatically.

[@vibesss2925]

this farm is still working great of June 25 (1.19.0) and has no problems in a 8 player realm.

[@duckyshitatmc7103]

yo thx for syaing that, needed confirmation it still worked on 1.19

[@vibesss2925]

@@duckyshitatmc7103 i didn’t find anyone who said it still worked so i had to build it in creative to test it… glad to have helped

[@vibesss2925]

@@KiNgSaaBYT check all your repeaters, every tick matters lol

[@onion_ring0024]

Does it work with mangrove trees tho??

[@phillmason9307]

Just made this on MCPE. Testing went fine with single block. Everything fired like it should. Even the burn out clock works perfect. BUT ONLY the bottom wood blocks that have no leaves make it out of the exit. The rest stay on the sticky pistons to the left. The sticky pistons that pull toward the exit do not crush leaves, and they wind up in the way, halting the wood block progress. The exit pistons have leaves to the right 2 blocks wide, and all wood from 3 blocks up stay put. Pls help.

[@grahamblanchet4809]

Any result I have same issue

[@SeedlingNL]

Check your redstone, and especially your repeaters. It sounds like you have a repeater set to the wrong delay.

[@ShadowGhostEm]

Have a similar issue, at 17:54 he tests with a random block, I did it to test it and the block gets pulled to the corner but not completely out the exit, one of the back sticky pistons that pull the block towards the exit get pushed out of line from the other pistons

[@cameronslykerman]

I HAVE SOLVED THIS PROBLEM ON MY OWN RELEM MAKE SURE THE OBSERVERS ARE FACING THE CORRECT WAY ONLY MY BOTTEM 2 WERE FACING THE RIGHT WAY HENSE WHY ONLY 2 LOGS ARE BEING GRABBED SORRY IM A YEAR LATE

[@GreatZodiac]

Best minecraft tutorial KZbinr

[@silentwisperer]

:)

[@ticklover9]

Just a heads up Silent says stuff about chunk borders but you don't have to worry about that, I tested between and on a single chunck border and it always worked fine

[@diamondstingray2990]

17:54 when I did this it acted like a clock and keeps activating the pistons that sends the wood out of the farm do you know what might be wrong with it

[@ticklover9]

@@diamondstingray2990 sometimes the burnout clock doesn't work well, try replacing it

[@diamondstingray2990]

@@ticklover9 I did with the clock he made in his fix video for this farm

[@ticklover9]

@@diamondstingray2990 Besides making sure all the observers are placed the right way I don't know what else

[@TheGauld89]

I can never get the farm to work and take all the trees away, it takes away the bottom two blocks but leaves the rest. Anyone know how to fix? I tried adjusting the bottom tick speed but just the same either way

[@Krutonius32]

Check the back left side and make sure all the redstone is hooked up. One time leaves generated outside and knocked a few redstone loose

[@curtisahlin3615]

Same here but im not sure what im doing wrong

[@TheGauld89]

I figured out why. I didn’t place all the observers correct with the blocks behind them. I had to build it level by level. What I did wrong was just stack up all the blocks like all the observers then all the solid blocks then all the glass etc. If you build it level by level then it will work perfectly.

[@TheGauld89]

@@curtisahlin3615 check my comment.

[@Krutonius32]

@@TheGauld89 nice work!

[@61O_42]

Thanks a lot man, it works pretty well, just talk a little bit slower, cuz sometimes i miss some placements and i have to rewind, but out of that you do a really god job c:

[@javiercastro7843]

When are you going to do a ghast blaster tutorial

[@xmas_doge2047]

When I tested it the pistons were still extended and the other pistons took those pistons with it, what should I do?

[@pvcosmic6244]

Same thing is happening to me

[@keithdeal869]

Mine did something similar. I tested by repositioning the pistons and testing by subsections starting from the top. Break 2 redstone dust(to keep other parts from being activated) and then place down a redstone torch to make sure all the pistons move correctly. Work your way down and back. I found a redstone placement error ×3 and it's been working like a charm since.

[@xmas_doge2047]

@@keithdeal869 oh ok thank you!

[@rayansawly3297]

Great farm! Thank u! Plus, the acacia mode can also farm azalea trees.

[@bobbyglazed1134]

i put it on 4 ticks and the sticky pistons still go out of line I've also tried 3 ticks, what should I do?

[@pvcosmic6244]

Same thing happened with me

[@bobbyglazed1134]

@@pvcosmic6244 I've watched the video again and made sure I've got everything right and it's still happening. I'm not going to touch it any more until I get a reply explaining how to fix it...

[@bobbyglazed1134]

@@pvcosmic6244 I put it on one tick and it seems to work, try that out ;)

[@pvcosmic6244]

Ok because it you put it on 4 ticks and take out a set of observers then that makes it work. Only issue is a couple less leaves get broken

[@bobbyglazed1134]

@@pvcosmic6244 ok what set of observers should I take out?

[@EdvinPhanichjaroen]

is there any way to build the tree farm in more than one Chuck?

[@EdvinPhanichjaroen]

because the output area the pistons didn't want to stay in the same place. and I tested changing the repeaters but it didn't work. i also think i didnt put the tree farm in a chunk:(

[@Texquads]

Not sure if anyone is still looking for an answer on this, but if some of your pistons are hanging, check the repeaters going to the intersecting pistons. I had a repeater on the wrong ticks and it fixed it.

[@joegaming3019]

does it still work

[@r99zy]

im on 1.16.201 and i keep trying to "test" to see if my pistons work when placing a random block. but for some reason it doesnt. i have check the build tutorial many many times.

[@godnation1233]

Same here, found any solution already?

[@r99zy]

@@godnation1233 nope! next time he streams im going to ask him and see if he has possible reason/solution.

[@godnation1233]

@@r99zy I found the issue, since I’m on PS4 I basically ignored the chunk lines at first.... now that it didn’t work I did use the chunkbase site to get my chunks, and built it there again, it now functions perfectly on 4 ticks and can continue the tutorial. Solution: Make sure the entire build is in 1 chunk only.

[@r99zy]

@@godnation1233 im pretty sure mine is chunk aligned tho. and when u bring up the "4ticks" is that something u changed or are u referring to something in the tutorial.

[@hoodystriker101]

@@r99zy he was referring the '4 ticks' to the repeater on the floor/bottom, if ur farm is chunk aligned u have to set that one to 4 ticks