Hey Topher. Onew has been on medical hiatus since the middle of last year. He didn't get to finish the filming of the Hard mv.
@savaspilletta10 ай бұрын
The intro songs was their original recordings which has Onew and Jjong on it.. i feel that they want people to still hear Onew and Jjong voice from their early songs. They didn't even try hard enough to tried to lipsync, like you said, minho didn't even sang along during some parts of View. And they slayed the live vocals especially during Hard❤
@IrmaDamayanti-r9k10 ай бұрын
Exactly what I thought!! Actually for 3 first songs they just mouthing their own part and let other member vocals sounding (hope u got what I mean)... so we all can hear all 5 members of SHINee that I miss so muchh, and for "dont call me" + " harf", yeah, they sang them live😊😊
@avotia10 ай бұрын
No, they didn’t sing the intro live, this is easy to understand, because for the most part it wasn’t even their parts. Their live singing can be heard in the last two songs.
@keriablm10 ай бұрын
You should watch the idol’s reaction to this performance. It is really cute because they got such as excited as we do!
@NyShawol10 ай бұрын
yesss aw gawd the ZB1 babies are so so cuteee
@hirohiwo10 ай бұрын
live vocals, SHINee never disappoints!!!! FOREVER A SHAWOL
@elianamilbia10 ай бұрын
amen!
@Red-he4yk10 ай бұрын
They are the Princes of K-pop… they used the original recordings deliberately to include Jonghyun and Onew…they sang as well but not Live live like for DCM and Hard. The cutest part in the MMA show was the new debuted groups fanning over SHINee in the audience. The the impact they’ve had on K-pop is huge. And yes they looked finnnnee❤
@1234Nanook10 ай бұрын
It was great! I feel bad that Onew has been out for a long time. I can only hope he's doing well! This performance was bomb! I'm pretty sure the first 4 tracks, Sherlock, View, Dream Girl and Everybody were just the recordings, but Don't Call Me and Hard were live live.
@sofeels_10 ай бұрын
DCM was also mostly lip synced sadly but yeah, Hard was 90% live
@田田-h7j10 ай бұрын
They slayed so hard with handheld mics❤🎉they always perform like as if 5 members on stage ❤
@xzxzojkeymtzxzx771210 ай бұрын
they killed it for real -- the little segments it was the backing track because you can hear other members voices more than anything since it was the medley. Don't Call Me and Hard were live
@Lupita31110 ай бұрын
I agree. Just the high notes for everybody were live
@SeleneLedezma10 ай бұрын
Yay SHINee!! This performance was amazing! I love it and I loved seeing other groups who were present standing up during SHINee's full performance!! The respect! Onew has been on a health hiatus since before the release of Hard which happened in June last year, he appears on the album but didn't finish filming the MV so you can only see him briefly in it. He occasionally posts on his insta tho I hope he is doing well ❤ ETA: Just got to the Topher thoughts part and saw you read the comments on why Onew wasn't there lol
@bea_hae_tae939210 ай бұрын
You could hear their vocals better from the fan cameras because I don't think the streaming did it justice
@Catnatti110 ай бұрын
I still have trouble sometimes not seeing them as babies; Taemin going shirtless lately had my brain wracked. Half was like ooh nice somebody's been hitting the GYM and the other part was like aww he's all grown up.
@ciriaespinosa74239 ай бұрын
Sin dos de sus vocalistas principales , cantando solo el rapero y los dos bailarines principales (en shinee todos cantan ) y aún así destruyen a cualquiera de los main vocalistas populares de hoy en día . Icónica presentación dieron cátedra de lo que es ser una leyenda en el kpop 🤴🏻
@sarah-ln5rq10 ай бұрын
Their performance was soo amazing I loved every second. Another great reaction video
@ЕленаСаштова10 ай бұрын
Не хочу обидеть другие группы, но Шайни, самая поющая группа. Даже акапелло они сотворят шедевр.
@koreanconvenience10 ай бұрын
I always love a Shinee review because they never disappoint!
@sofeels_10 ай бұрын
They didn't sing live at all in the meddley (and didn't even really pretend to). They just danced to the first 4 songs. DCM was also mostly lip synced but Hard was 90% live.
@ColdRolledGold10 ай бұрын
oh this was so much fun! i hadn't watched this performance, and it was awesome!!! lol so often i find myself wishing the stylists would put the male and female dancers in the same outfits. stop being cowards and just put the male dancers in the same crop tops and short skirts! i believe in you, stylists, you can do it 😂 15 years and they're still at the top of their game! i remember key and btob's changsub talking about doing music shows now and how most of the groups they debuted with just aren't around anymore... it's lonely at the top! but they're still SLAYING and they absolutely get more beautiful with age! love these outfits too, they look so damn good!!! the highlight of this for me was seeing how much topher was enjoying it! ❤i feel like if topher started only making videos of himself just vibing to music he likes, i'd still be totally here for it 😂 as always, thank you so much! ❤❤❤
@ethelralte102410 ай бұрын
❤❤❤❤
@91vampy10 ай бұрын
I hope Onew will be back with the guys soon ❤❤❤
@sofeels_10 ай бұрын
I've missed you reacting to SHINee Topher 😢 Can you maybe react to some more MVs or live stages of theirs? Oh and you missed Minho's solo comeback with Stay For A Night that was released a couple weeks ago as a digital single and Key's comeback with Good & Great back in September.
@chemiserogers832310 ай бұрын
Onew is still in his hiatus. He seems to be much better but he isn't performing again yet.
@TheHekateris10 ай бұрын
Jinki is still on hiatus for his health. We miss him, too.
@BlueNightShineeWorld2550810 ай бұрын
I hope you took the time to react to taemins guilty & the rizzness and Minho's stay the night.
@91vampy10 ай бұрын
He has reacted to Guilty but not Rizzness yet
@BlueNightShineeWorld2550810 ай бұрын
@@91vampy ah I see. He'll fall in love with the rizzness too.
@leydarachadey46510 ай бұрын
@@91vampyReacciona a la PRESENTAVION DE RIZZNESS en su concierto metamorfosis es maravillosa .Única el la historia de la musica ❤