Sir Vikas Divyakirti & his Ramayan Controversy | Tamasoma

#lallantop #vikasdivyakirtisir #ramayan
Drishti IAS Managing Editor Dr Vikas Divyakirti made a comment on Ramanyana while teaching his UPSC Students. Some people are alleging that it's a controversial remark and that's why he has been receiving flack from netizens since friday morning. #BanDrishtiIAS has been trending on Twitter after his comment went viral. Others on Twitter claim that the professor made the remarks in question while quoting the works of another author during his lecture. They are coming in support with #IsupportVikasDivyakirti. He gave justification on #thelallantop.
Our take on Sir Vikas Divyakirti & his Ramayan Controversy and his justification on #thelallantop . Watch the video to know about it.
“All the videos, songs, images, and graphics used in the video belong to their respective owners and I or this channel does not claim any right over them.
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.”

[@pratyushvaibhav]

काश नूपुर शर्मा को भी एक इंटरव्यू करके दी लल्लनटॉप कुरान-हदीस Quote करने को बोलता, लेकिन ऐसा करने से कुछ लोगों की भावनाओ को चोट पहुचता, हो सकता है पन्तनिर्पेक्षता ख़तरे में आ जाती , शायद इसीलिए उन्होंने ऐसा नहीं किया | मुझे माफ कर दीजिए मैं बीजेपी से नहीं हूं

[@thehappiness55]

कुछ अगर सच बोलो तो पोराणिक पंडित का रोना शुरू जैसे तुम्हारा 😂😂

[@ratnesh063]

😂😂😂

[@TarunGaurangaDas]

thank you... ये फर्क होता है मॉडर्न और वैदिक टीचर्स में ,एक अपनी पॉपुलैरिटी के लिए कुछ भी बक देता है और दूसरा अपने सनातन धर्म की रक्षा के लिए केवल शास्त्रसमत बातें बोलता है, कही से भी किसी भी लोफर ने लिखे हुए तथाकथित ग्रंथो से कुछ भी नहीं बकता। ......

[@Gg-xo1rc]

Aap jara is bat pr vichar karo ki aap dharmik ho ya sampradayik

[@Gg-xo1rc]

Aapka lakshya ishwar ko prapti h ya smpraday vishesh k nam pr ladna lol

[@pravakarmaji8955]

Vikas sir popularity ke liye ei Nehi bol rahe hai......ei sadhu ji apni popularity ke liye pura video na dikhakar kuch kuch clip kat kar deraha hain.........ei apse asa Nehi the....

[@prajaysrivastav701]

Hari bol

[@amitsinghmaurya7269]

षट बिकार जित अनघ अकामा। अचल अकिंचन सुचि सुखधामा॥ अमित बोध अनीह मितभोगी। सत्यसार कबि कोबिद जोगी॥ यही सच्चे संत के गुण है आप लोगो को तो अपनी दुकान की ब्रैंडिंग करनी है न 🙏

[@LifeExperienceOfRK65]

बहुत सुंदर और सही तथा सधे हुए तरीके से आपने बोला। आप का अभिनंदन है। बाकी दुनिया में सभी तरह के लोग हैं, सबको समझाकर एक मत को मानने को बाध्य नहीं किया जा सकता। और तर्क करते करते हुए कुतर्क में फंसने की ज्यादा संभावना रहती है, तब तो बिलकुल भी नहीं।😊

[@praj_yt_funny2268]

Hello bhaiya divyakirti sir ne jo 2 baate kahi jin pr vivad huaa hai vo baate sach hai ya nhi vo toh aapne btaya hi nhi 🥲🥲

[@kshatriyasinghhvikas]

That's the problem with these teachers . They represent someones's facts as they are the eternal truth but in reality it's only a thought developed by their own understanding. Like it's said - Half knowledge is dangerous thing. First explore the oldest. He is a knowledgeable person . So, before teaching or saying anything which is irrelevant to shashtra , they should search and explore all the proofs.

[@Tamasoma108]

Thank you Vikas Singh ji. The world needs more like you.

[@amitsinghmaurya7269]

सारी दुविधा प्रतिशत पर है, सच कितना बोला जाए गूँगे सीखा रहे हैं उनको, मुँह कितना खोला जाए

[@rekhachoudary8756]

Hare Krsna 🙏 prabhu ji 😊 First of all I would like to thank you for this beautiful informational video 😊.....

[@sandleo533]

VD sir is just repeating what is written in some books but not the original Ramayan by Valmiki. So his knowledge is incomplete. He should take help of some authorised guru in disciplic succession of Valmiki then only he can comprehend the Ramayana. As mentioned in Bhagavad Gita..evam parampara praptam imam rajarashayo viduh. Otherwise his incomplete knowledge can become instrument to divide Hindus and spread wrong understanding of Shri Ram.

[@comedyking7709]

Vikas jaise gadhe aate hai aur hamare pujniye sri ram aur mata sita k bare me kuch bhi bol dete hai vikas jaise gadho ka muh kala karke juto ki mala pehna k pure sahar me ghumana chahiye taki koi dusra gadha hamare sri rama aur mata sita k bare me aisi bakwas na kar sake

[@anil19906]

Divya dristi kabhi kuran par baiveel par bhe kuch jankari dedo

[@_India_in_pictures_]

Aapne to un quotation par kuch bola hi nahi...jo sir ne Ramayan me dikhaya aur uttar kand me bataya......aap gyaani baniye isme dikkat nahi h lekin bina tathya wali baat bolke baato ko skip mat kijiye gyaani baba 😂😂

[@atharvayelne5223]

Haa bhai me bhi puri video me vahi dhundh raha tha par inhone uss par bola hi nahi

[@md.hasnainansari1668]

Ek sachchaa teacher exam k perspective se aur apne kitaabi gyaan ko aadhaar banaa k hi padhata h Guruji. I stand with Vikas Divyakirti Sir

[@HarshPathak-ux2zy]

Tb tumko nupur sharma ke sath bhi khda hona pdega kyuki wo bhi toh quran ki line hi quote kr rhi thi,

[@abhishalsharma1628]

Main point se bhtk ke bs aacharyo ki authority ke balbute video bna diya

[@DunammapayaTiwari]

Hari Anant Hari Katha Ananta

[@CR77524]

तुम कैसे Influencer जरा तुम विकास सर की क्लास को देख लो वो बोला नहीं था , वो बोलने से पहले बोला था की मेरी जबान कट जाए मैं बोलना नहीं चाहता परंतु upsc प्रश्न ही ऐसा करता हैं इस क्रम में एक पुस्तक का Reference दे दिए सर की उस पुस्तक में राम - सीता जी के बारे मैं ऐसी बातें हैं।😊😊

[@RahulKumar-hv2mr]

Agar tum mere comment ko padh rahe ho to Dhyan se padhna agar koi Islam ke khilaf bolata hai to Fatwa Jari Ho Jata Hai Uska Sar tan se Judaa karne ke nare lagne Lagte Hain parantu Sanatan Dharm hi hai jismein koi bhi Kuchh Bhi bolkar nikal jata hai yah bhi Hamari hi Galti Hai Ki Ham Logon Ne Itna secular banne ki koshish ki tabhi to Aaj Hamara yah hal hai apne hi Desh Mein ab Dhire Dhire Hamare Itihaas aur Hamare Sanskriti Ko Bhi mitane ki koshish ki Jaati Hai use Sanskriti Ko jisse Na Jaane kitne log hi prerit hue hain Vikas divyakirti sirf Sanatan Dharm ke khilaf hi bolata hoga Meri baten likh Lo usne Na Kabhi Kuran ke bare mein Kuchh bola Hoga Na hi Kisi Aur majhab ke bare mein Kyunki use pata hai ki Vishva ka sabse Sanatan Dharm Duniya ka sabse kamjor na inmein Ekta hai na Kuchh aur Vahi Agar Islam ke khilaf bol diya Jaaye to Unki Khair Nahin Hogi yah Baat Satya hai Kadva bhi hai😢😢😢😢😢😢

[@AryanYadav-g2v]

​@@RahulKumar-hv2mr bharat me 100 crore hindu hai ham bhi hindu dharm hi janme hai to ham hindu dharm ki kuritiyon ki hi na baat karenge muslim isyai se kya lena

[@AryanYadav-g2v]

​@@RahulKumar-hv2mr 5000 saal se purana hamara itihaas hi nhi hai usse pahle ke mile granth jo indus valley ke the wo aaj tak padhe nhi ja chuke hai phir kaise na kare is dharm ki faltu bato ka virodh agar ham islaam me janm liye hote to mohammad aur waha ki kuritiyon ki baat karte Lekin hindu me janm hua hai to kyu bole muslim ke baare me pahla apana ghar saaf karo phir dusro ka

[@jyotipanchal1208]

Par ye jo lines boli hai ye valmik ramayan ki nahi hai And ved vyas ji ne toh ramayan nhi likhi

[@ilapatel7994]

🙏🌸 Jay shree krishna 🌸🙏

[@snehilsahu9051]

Aap complete video ko dekhiye. Kisi ke charitra ka chitran matr kuch second ke video ko dekh kr kardena kisi ke liye bhi bachkani baat hai. Aajkal social media mein yahi chal raha hai

[@deepshikhasingh2994]

👍👍🙏🙏Hare Krishna

[@kumarpk1507]

श्रीमान जी आपने जैसा कि बताया है कि आपने उनका वीडियो देखा है जिसमें से आपने उनकी कुछ बातें लिए हैं लेकिन आपने भी वही गलती कर रहे है जो सब लोग कर रहे हैं कि आप भी पूरा वीडियो नहीं दिखा रहे है आपको इस से ख्याति तो मिल सकती है सर लेकिन हम लोगों को संतुष्टि नहीं आपसे विनम्र निवेदन है 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@Tamasoma108]

comments ke liye dhanyawad. aasha karte hain agle video me aapko santusht kar payenge.

[@prakashchile3482]

तुम सनातनी हो... तुम सच तो अंध हो..

[@VIKASHVERMA-ek6ho]

Also tell about shambook......

[@PappuKumar-l5p]

एक बात मेरा भी महोदय, आपने कहा जो भी रामायण और महाभारत लिखे है वो भगवान् से पेरित हो कर ग्रंथ लिखे थे, तो तुलसीदास जी के बारे मे क्या कहेंगे आप वो भी बहुत बारे रामायण लिखे है, उसमे उन्होंने लिखा है, ढोल, गवार, शुद्र, नारी ऐ सब है तारन की अधिकारी.... ये वाक्य भी भगवान् ने ही कहे थे

[@anil19906]

Kuran ki bhe jankari de do Divya dristi

[@pappudhurvey5406]

Sambhuk vadh ke baare kya kahegen

[@indianyogesh]

Hare Krsna ❤

[@romykashyap4038]

Ooo uska jawab too do jiski baat ho rhi

[@ABC-nb9ks]

Hare Krishna

[@TheHariPutraOfficially]

Boliye mere saath Venkatramana Govindaaaaaaaa

[@devanand5311]

Periyar ki ramayan padha dijiea sar

[@varinderkumar1914]

Osho ko suno

[@ratnesh063]

Pakhand failana band kr

[@DunammapayaTiwari]

Arth ka anarth karte Hain

[@Gg-xo1rc]

Aap dharmik nahi sampradayik ho jo sampraday k nam pr ladte rhte ho kabhi ishawar ki prapti aapka lakshya nahi h

[@Tamasoma108]

Aap koun guru hai. Toh kya aap se dharm sikhe

[@Gg-xo1rc]

Aap bas vichar kijiye hindu dharm k granth hee margdarshan k lie kafi h

[@Gg-xo1rc]

Ishwar ne dharm ni banaya ishwar ne jeewan banaya to jeewan se ishwar ko prapt hona asan h ye mujhe lgta h baki aap vichar karo shayad me galat hun

[@Tamasoma108]

Isliye man ghadat baatein kyon sochte ho. Follow Acharyas who have witness these instructions and passed it on to their followers.

[@DunammapayaTiwari]

Bhagwan ka Leela koi nahin Jaan Sakta

[@Dasanu_Das]

Bahut sundar prabhu ji❤ Dasi ka Dandwat pranam Hari bol❤

[@prajaysrivastav701]

Nice sir

[@Tamasoma108]

thank you prajay

[@YouthAshray]

Really wonderful explanations pr ji... Pranaam

[@MahenderSingh-so6de]

ये कोण है

[@AnjaliKumari-hr1kr]

Ye vikash teacher k name pe kalank h jo ma sita k bare me itni nich bat boli. Uske jibh kat k gir kyu nhi gye bolte waqt

[@pradeeppanday5332]

Jai Sri sitaram Jai Sri Radhakrishnana om Shri ganeshayenamaha Jai Sri sitaram Jai Sri Radhakrishnana Jai Sri shanidev bhagwan ji Jai Sri Parashuram bhagwan ji Jai Jai Sri Radhakrishnana

[@PrasoonTiwari-bd7pf]

Please read periyar e v ramasmami nayakar sacchi ramayan

[@Tamasoma108]

What do you mean read literature by atheist periyar😄

[@mukeshthakkar4092]

Idhar udhar ki bat kyu kare? Gita press dwara published Ramayana and Mahabharat hath me lo. Usme Jo Hindi translation Kiya Gaya hai use ppadh ke dikhao/ sunaao. Dudh ka dudh or Pani ka pano ho jayega.

[@ankissh]

Abe to baat to vhi hui n jb likhi insaan ne to tujhe kaise pta ki sach hi likha h mante bhagwaan ko ho aur likha hua insaan ka mante ho😂😂😂

[@Tamasoma108]

Beta guru parampara bhi kuch hota hai. Apnese badonse baat karne ka sistachaar nahi sikhe..aur aaye yahan tippani karne 😄

[@devanand5311]

Sar hamko aanand ramayan smjha dijiye

[@guideman4776]

यदि समाज में कोई अच्छा कार्य कर रहा है तो उसके प्रति सम्मान,आदर,एवम् समर्थन करना आवश्यक होता हैं,🙏🙏 किन्तु कोई शिक्षक के पद या UPSC😂 ,ya उसके fan following ज्यादा इस वजह से उसको समर्थन करना ही अंधभक्ति🤣 कहलाता है।🙏🚩🕉️🙏🕉️💪

[@vks1984]

Sir JNU me jo slogan lg rahe hai kya unme teachers ki responsbility nahi hai kya....teachers apni vichardhara student pr thop rahe h

[@Tamasoma108]

isiliye hum aapko vedic wisdom se equip kar rahe hain

[@rishabhraj7882]

Sir Vikas Divyakirti❌ Vikas Divyakirti Sir✅

[@jaigrover5441]

Jai bhim

[@pramodkumarujaladeep5707]

Lekhak hi Puran likhte hai 💯 to 💯 right 👍 is line me vikash sir ne sach bola hai isme galat ky hai bhai.khud bhagvan aake nehi likhte hain

[@prakashpmn38]

Those people who write literatures are empowered personalities not an ordinary human being. Speaker is answering your doubt very clearly. Apko bad ek chiz karni hai ki dhyan se video ko bar bar dekho tab aapka doubt nhi rahega.

[@Tamasoma108]

Bhai Pramod Kumar ji, Lekhak keval nimitta hote hain... Lata Mangeshkar ke saamne rakha hua mic aavaj deta hain. lekin mic ki aavaj nahi hoti. Gaati hain lata ji... Similarly, Purano ke hazaro rishi muni lekhak ho sakte hain, lekin puran to sri Bhagvan Krishna ki Vaani hain. BG 15.15 ( vedaiś ca sarvair aham eva vedyo )

[@prakritpandey6459]

We r with vikas sir....He is ri8 with d fact and proof...

[@Tamasoma108]

What values are been taught by such a narration of his?

[@idioticbeatzz]

@@Tamasoma108 the value of reason.

[@Tamasoma108]

And from your comment "the value of absurdity and non contextual"

[@DunammapayaTiwari]

Shri Ram to Leela kiye the

[@SAHILRai-ny9db]

हरे कृष्ण हरे कृष्ण कृष्ण कृष्ण हरे हरे हरे राम हरे राम राम राम हरे हरे

[@prashantnalawade3396]

❤

[@ushanair4225]

Super 🙏🙏

[@Tamasoma108]

thanks Usha ji

[@abhishek-pi8xr]

Well said prabhu

[@Tamasoma108]

thanks Abhishek

[@Gg-xo1rc]

Don't be arrogant that u know everything thing

[@amitseemar6492]

Jai bhim

[@geopoliticalhistory.7928]

Are Jo matter tha wo btao n

[@Tamasoma108]

Aap bataye aapko kya samaj nahi aaya.

[@geopoliticalhistory.7928]

@@Tamasoma108Vikas Divya kirti sahi bol rhe the ya galat, book me likha hua hai ya nhi

[@utsav615]

@@geopoliticalhistory.7928 Ryt ab ye comment nhi krenge 😊

[@ankurkumarmandal1670]

@@geopoliticalhistory.7928 Galat bol rahe the... Bina kisi realisation ke aur bina kisi deep understanding ke ... Aisa kahi. Bhi original Ramayan me nahi likha hua hai... Ki bhagwaan ne aise galat statements bole

[@TeChYViDyA]

@@geopoliticalhistory.7928 ah I think prabhuji is busy so he is not able to reply you back. For your doubt there is another one more video where you can get your doubt cleared. video - kzbin.info/www/bejne/epvRhnuCep2KaLM I hope your doubt gets settled and if it does then don't just forget about this matter but start reading our precious scriptures.." Bhagwat Gita as it is" is a good start And thank you tamsoma channel for this wonderful video.. I really like your way of speaking Hare krishna

[@Gg-xo1rc]

Who are you that itself you will never know if you don't explore just rattu tota grnath ko ratne se kuch nhi hoga jbtk unpr vichar ni krte tab tk uski koi value ni h

[@Tamasoma108]

Aapke logic se aap hi bolenge ki aap swayam God hai... Kisi kitaab mein thode hi na likha hai. Waise mandh logon ke liye adhyatm ko samajhna bada hi difficult hai. Tum se na hopayega.

[@comedyking7709]

Tu to gadha hai

[@jogendramoharana7590]

Tilakdhari bhaiya,app kya dekha nahin,vikas sir ne ohi bat,kitab me likha hua praman dikhae the

[@lifeline2693]

अरे गुरु बात करते करते आप भी भटक गए।।बुरा लग सकता है आपको।।

[@md.hasnainansari1668]

Ek taraf aap kehte h ki Maharshi Vedvyaas aur Vaalmiki jaisa depth me koi nahi samajh sakta aur dusri taraf aap apne aap ko indirectly paramgyaani bataa dete h waah.

[@Gg-xo1rc]

Apko ye bhi ni pta hoga ki dharmik hona or sampradayik hone me kya fark h

[@Tamasoma108]

Video ka subject hain ek famous vyakti dwara janata ko apne opinion se influence karna. Hamara role hain acharyon ka mat ko aap tak pahuchana. Bas.

[@sachitaanand9108]

Reply to diye nhi dhang se... Bhai usme hai ya nhi ye btao na... Kyunki unne to dikhaya na with proof

[@Tamasoma108]

Ramayan toh dikhaya hi nahi

[@yashawantzambare4106]

Hare Krishna..... Pahle to vikas sir jo writer ke baare main bol rahe hai..... O translator ke baare main bol rahe hai

[@Tamasoma108]

Toh Sirji guru paramparagat gyaan sahi se kyon nahi padate..kyon kisi writer or translator ka content padhate hai.

[@raseshwarkrishnadas6370]

Which temple are you stay

[@Tamasoma108]

ISKCON Mumbai

[@raseshwarkrishnadas6370]

@@Tamasoma108 ohh...i am from iskcon mayapur....aap ka lecture bohot acha hai...be continue.

[@saurabh1084]

🙏

[@ganeshkandpal7621]

Ye video dekh kar main keh skta hu ki maine apne 5 min waste kr diye

[@Tamasoma108]

Adhyatm mein sahi guru se na seekhe toh pura life hi waste hojayega. Samjhe

[@comedyking7709]

Teri puri life waste hai

[@TheHariPutraOfficially]

@@Tamasoma108 Venkatramana Govindaa

[@Gg-xo1rc]

Aapke pas rata rataya gyan h aap kbhi explore karo , kabhi aapne doubt hee ni kia ki bhagwan ki existence pr to aap bhagwan ki prapti kabhi kr ni skte

[@comedyking7709]

Tere jaise k pass to wo bhi gyan nahi hai tum jaise log vikas jaise gadho ko chatne me apni puri zindagi nikal dete hai aur dusro ki sahi baat bhi tum jaise logo ko galat lagti hai

[@spcreations7770]

Bhuta pekshya bhat bhari 😂😂

[@amitsinghmaurya7269]

Only publicity stunt by you he is a teacher not religious Saint He only explain what is written in Book why you didn't put question about writer of those book. Close every school and colleges and study in the gurukul and madarasa, become only religious Saint.

[@Tamasoma108]

Your blind following is awesome. Vikas sir is a good teacher for mundane content. Spiritual subject matters require surrender and study under guru parampara. By reading books people don't become doctors.. They need to learn under an experienced doctor. Question to you.. Why can't the teacher consult an expert in the subject matter and then teach.

[@Tamasoma108]

Your blind following is awesome. Vikas sir is a good teacher for mundane content. Spiritual subject matters require surrender and study under guru parampara. By reading books people don't become doctors.. They need to learn under an experienced doctor. Question to you.. Why can't the teacher consult an expert in the subject matter and then teach.

[@amitsinghmaurya7269]

@@Tamasoma108 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@amitsinghmaurya7269]

@@Tamasoma108 teacher don't need any expert to consult about that. Anyway, no matter how well you teach in this country, someone's religious sentiments get hurt.

[@idioticbeatzz]

@@Tamasoma108 its called reader response theory. Barthe has already explained it in his "Death of the Author." Go read it.

[@nkadthekar]

महानुभव आप अपना घडा(मती ) सीधा तो कर लिजिए उलटे घडे मी पानी (ज्ञान ) नही भर सकते । धन्यवाद! जयसियाराम !!!!!

[@Tamasoma108]

Hum toh guru ke ashray mein anushasit hai. Aap apna ghada aur gyaan dekh lijiye seedha hai ya ulta hai

[@rahulpal1277]

Vikas sir is a Gem.

[@Tamasoma108]

Yes we agree.

[@Gg-xo1rc]

He will never know ye sampradayik soch wale humesha ladne ko taiyar rhte h samaj me dharm k nam pr hinsa inka dhandha h

[@comedyking7709]

Vikas sirf gadha hai

[@rahulpal1277]

@@comedyking7709 tera baap hai wo, tameej se nam le , padosi ki nazayaj aulad

[@rahulpal1277]

@@comedyking7709 Abe sale raaandwe ek me to me tera baap hu

[@Dinesh_Karki]

Infact you also did not clear what that means written in the ramayan ??

[@pramodrevankar4871]

Uske liye bro aapko Sahi ramayan padhna hoga

[@Tamasoma108]

Infact the fact is that "this" is not mentioned in Valmiki Ramayan.

[@Gg-xo1rc]

Are dhongi h ,samprdayik h inke pas gyan ni rata hue shabd h jinki inko ratti bhar bhi smjh ni h

[@comedyking7709]

​@@Gg-xo1rctere jaise gadho pe pass gyan rahta hai kya jo vikas jaise c k chatne me lage rahte hai

[@nileshdokhe2061]

Valimiki bonafied the kya phir..?

[@AjayKumar-mw8py]

Bahi ji aapne utar to Diya nahi time pas kar rahe ho

[@heenavaishnav7174]

thank you so much for your awareness videos. this video help us for right knowledge. really appreciate to you. everyone please see this video

[@Tamasoma108]

Thank you Heena ji

[@emilyjohnson194]

Chama kariye ka prabhu par apne bhagwan ke liye kahi gayi batein main is ghatia aadmi se sun bhi nahi sakta jo ki kewal murkha hi nahi maha murkh hain

[@spcreations7770]

Ye kehana kya chahata hai isne kahibhi vikar sir ke point ko galat sabit nahi kiya 😂😂 5min sirf bakchodi Kari bhramian se

[@Tamasoma108]

Kalayla thoda doka pahije pora🙂