U2 - Mothers of the Disappeared - Live Popmart Santiago 1998

[@DamiantxoCebey]

From Argentina. I'm criying, for all the lives.we are live, but not all human are live.

[@Macconator2010]

One of Bono's best written lyrics. "In the wind you hear their laughter, in the rain you see their tears" is my favourite phrase. Serious spine chills.

[@marlenesullivan3113]

I REALLY APRESIATE & TAKE BONO'S WORDS IN THIS SONG TO 💙

[@idicula1979]

I also appreciate a well written song lyric.

[@GreenSangha]

Why would anyone criticize this? They are using their stage to give these mothers and their disappeared/murdered children visibility and a voice. What a great thing to do!

[@j.s.173]

This moment was like a punch in the stomach. How can't you cry watching those mothers talking about the disappearance of their sons? One of the most emotional moments in the entire career of U2 and their live concerts

[@deniboly]

still cryinfg if i'm watching it, after 20+ years.

[@antonboludo8886]

@@deniboly Es muy emocionante.

[@miperrocabezon1984]

La mujer que habla al comienzo es Zola Sierra ella murio sin poder llevar un flor a una tumba.Quienes critiquen esta accion de grandeza y crean que fue desmedida por parte de U2 lean el libro los " los zarpasos del Puma" enteran y si tienen sentimientos sabran cual es el dolor de buscar un hermano padre o hijo y encontrarlo en fosa comun, sin dignidad, sin una flor, leer ese libro te cambia la vida, no tengo ningun familiar desaparecido, pero aun me conmuevo con el dolor ajeno.

[@o0xst]

Still the Best thing on KZbin

[@twonky721]

I had a staffordshire bull terrior put down at the age of 10 coz of a tumor. I laid in my bed alone, and sobbed every night . . . every night. To push me through and past my pain I listened to this song and continued to sob. Some how It helped. Get well soon Bono. and when you get back up on stage, put out the show of you're fucking life. R.I.P Stuart Adamson.

[@Mister.Beagle_8-8]

In Chile, still looking for the disappeared !!! Many mothers are dead, others are very old, to continue fighting ......... the assassins are also dying ....... but as long as there is a Chilean or Chilean who fights for justice and truth .... they will never disappear, they will continue in our hearts and in our memory to never forget us

[@evelynrojas113]

Augusto Pinochet , mando a matar a toda esa gente...

[@jamesdavison2927]

❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ EXIGO JUSTICIA!!!! much love from the USA

[@Mister.Beagle_8-8]

@@jamesdavison2927 ...El Pueblo unido..Jamas sera Vencido!

[@vincentjurg]

I'm not even a big U2 fan but that was fantastic. What is it with U2 that whenever something terrible happens in the world, they can mention it in their shows in such a beautiful way? Wether it's the show in Sarajevo after the war, playing in Santiago a few years after the end of Pinochet's regime singing "El pueblo vencerá" (I'm not sure but I believe that was Salvador Allende's campaign slogan) or giving their stage to the Eagles of Death Metal after the attacks in Paris. You don't have to be a U2 fan to be moved by things like that. They can always get people together to process their anger, sadness and fear in a positive way and that's fantastic.

[@lucashotchkiss2627]

Vincent Jurg don't forget about their Super Bowl performance

[@Paint4U2]

As also the thing that they never canceled the concert at Red Rocks in 1983, despite the dangers... U2 is always there, leaving their message for us to be inspired for the world's rescue. We hear the heartbeat...

[@AngryFart]

I like how you pointed out that you're not a U2 fan without adding some nasty, baseless vitriol like so many people do.

[@jamesdavison2927]

@@AngryFart its amazing that a group that does nothing but promote love can draw so much hate Its a damn shame But its nice that many who arent u2 fans can give credit where credit is due Im a HUGE U2 FAN as you must be (based on your user name) This performance, in my opinion is in their top 5 historically significant performances ever EL PUEBLO VENCERA❤️

[@andydeledge7803]

And there is still people out there that say they take advantage of such tragedies...sad

[@kakazinhu20]

U2 forever!! the best band in the world, and the only band who can give us moments as this.. WONDERFUL!!!

[@רועיברונשטיין-ל8ס]

They're better than The Beatles, aren't they?

[@ronnylit]

Bono,you are the best! south amerika,afrika,you are for all! i am a graet fan since 20 years! You`ll never walk alone!! we see us in 29 of september in Sevilla! U2 is the best band ever and i love you!

[@jsema100]

This song is so touching cuz it was written from a personal story Bono heard in a taxy ride in El Salvador.

[@1untamedwolf]

A few years back my wife & I were visiting family in Argentina. One day I met a "Mother" and as she told me her heartbreaking story of loss I sat there silently, quietly and ultimately feeling helpless. All I could do is reach and hug her. Sometimes when I am having a rough day or see another soul struggling in their's, I just reach out and offer a hug. Sounds cheesy to some I am sure, but nothing lowers our defenses faster than a simple hug. One day... peace.

[@Nigelxman]

I agree. I cannot watch this without crying like a baby.

[@s96822]

The poster holders are saying when their family members was detained/disappeared. the woman that gets much applause adds "I demand justice" It is hard to imagine a more emotionally charged moment.

[@gogely]

Hacia mucho tiempo que no se me saltaban las lágrimas viendo algo. Realmente conmovedor. Mucho valor hacaer lo que hizo en 1998, cuando Pinochet todavía era Comandante en Jefe del Ejercito.

[@kakazinhu20]

all over the world... el pueblo vencera!!! bono is a role model to me.. one of the few who has the courage to give us moments like this...

[@shubhankarnaik6231]

How could you not feel the pain and let the tear roll down your eyes....

[@Dancesbetweenstars]

When we can sing this song and no one have to cry? Never forget this sons and daughters! Thank you for this video.

[@batata01]

I was there. Goosebumps just to remember that night

[@o0xst]

Cannot even imagine.

[@Mister.Beagle_8-8]

En Chile, aún se siguen buscando los desparecidos!!! muchas madres han muerto, otras están muy ancianas, para seguir luchando.........los asesinos tambien se estan muriendo.......pero mientras exista un chileno o chilena que luche por la justicia y la verdad ....ellos nunca desaparecerán , seguirán en nuestros corazones y en nuestra memoria para nunca olvidarnos

[@amydennis4566]

This is a beautiful video. It's so sad that so many mothers have children that have just disappeared. I can't believe how many victims there are that are missing without even knowing if they are dead or alive. I can't even imagine having a child just disappear. That would absolutely destroy me.

[@mauferran]

Esta es por mucho la mejor presentación que he visto en mi vida. Nunca se me habían salido las lágrimas viendo un simple video. Pero esa es la magia de U2, hacen que la música se convierta en el himno de todos. Es increíble la emoción que despierta ver a 70000 gargantas pidiendo juntas justicia. Y la imagen de las madres es imborrable. Grande U2 por este gesto increíble. ¡El pueblo vencerá! ¡Abajo los tiranos!

[@Xiako]

And Chile is again living a moment like this.. so sad! Stay strong Chile!! EL PUEBLO VENCERÁ!!!

[@javierazul8680]

Lo mas triste de este video, es que la mayoría de esas mujeres ya fallecieron, y por como era de esperar, nunca pudieron encontrar a sus seres queridos

[@rocioriquelme4345]

No lo había pensando... claro, esto fue hace casi 20 años, muchas ya estaban muy ancianas. Al menos si es que si existe algún otro lugar, otra dimensión, otro plano estas almas lograron reunirse.

[@edenilson4362]

No importa esta canción siempre estará y existirá y es y seguirá siendo la voz de toda esa gente. y este vídeo un dato para la posteridad de futuras nuevas generaciones.

[@sinnombre-dn5rg]

Nadie puede quitar la vida a otra persona, solamente si por defensa de su propia vida.

[@EngHawJF]

For many people in South America: U2 ARE OUR VOICES! Regrats from Brazil El Pueblo Sudamericano Vencerá!

[@josepgarcia4057]

Asi es y toda latinoamerica temblara y tambien EE:UU.

[@EngHawJF]

Si!

[@jamesdavison2927]

❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@luieu2]

As a teenage U2 fan in the 80s U2 taught me much more about life than any school or teacher could ever teach me . To me one of the greatest U2 songs off all time . I admire U2 how they tell story's in songs and make me aware of what is going on in this world !!

[@jimgindele4526]

So well put. Not 3 weeks ago I was trying to tell a close friend how I have learned more about American Race, life, and spirituality than all our time in school and even my own father were able to teach me. Maybe it's just the delivery? Either way, this video is a perfect representation of what I was alluding to.

[@Nobody6175]

U2coholics I'm a teenager now and feel just the same way about U2.

[@luieu2]

U2 are more than just songs they have a deepness about what they create

[@ibonastor8700]

I always cry when they say "exijo justicia"

[@woodenloonynickel]

Love from Red Rocks. Love from Conscientious Lovers. Please Champion Women. My Uncle Ervin gifted me his Stereo set. Just in time to hear U2 Live from Red Rocks in real time.

[@myflexibility_oo]

Midnight, our sons and daughters Cut down, taken from us Hear their heartbeat We hear their heartbeat In the wind we hear their laughter In the rain we see their tears Hear their heartbeat We hear their heartbeat Night hangs like a prisoner Stretched over black and blue Hear their heartbeat We hear their heartbeat In the trees our sons stand naked Through the walls our daughters cry See their tears in the rainfall

[@DeneyuAdam]

if there ever is a powerful song done by U2 this has got to be the one...I get the bumps just listening to it and my heart breaks, knowing these mothers will never know what happen to their children, so all we can do is hear their laughter in the wind, and see their teardrop in the rain...

[@genesisds]

The best video on youtube. Las pifias que se escuchan a ratos demuestra la fragilidad del chile de 1998. Hoy en dia nadie en nuestro pais medianamente humano se atreveria a pifiar frente al dolor humano. viva chile! viva u2.

[@pecs08]

U2 are truely a band that brings light to the world... I've never met these guys, but I love them.

[@luieu2]

this version moves me everytime SG i dedicate this song to all mothers who have lost children

[@sergiobellotas]

El pueblo vencerá. Saludos hermanos chilenos desde España. Os queremos

[@SatWithJohnnyChan]

I was at the concert. It was surreal...and sent shivers down my spine. When I lived in Santiago I used to work out and run around Estadio Nacional. It gave me chills. Lot of history...not so good history. Although, many Chilenos would argue that Chile would not be where it is today without Pinochet. But at what cost?? I don't know.

[@josepgarcia4057]

Dedicada a mi madre que siempre busca una vida digna mejor para mi........... y asi seguire siendo un guerrero. luchando por mi y por los demas......

[@evelynrojas113]

YO ESTUVE ALLÌ, mi 1er concierto de U2 en Chile!! ya voy en el 4to..🇨🇱👍🙌

[@chefblanc]

there are bands and there are bands, they come and go , the latest craze or whatever. None of them will ever compare to this band.

[@JamesVibe]

Bono has that rare talent to connect with everyone around the world...... music the one great communicator and healer

[@IanBondFlemming]

I love the people of Chile. I lived there a few years and they have much to be proud of. VIVA CHILE!!!

[@tanguyguerin7323]

Super musique très émouvante même la var de la fin confirme

[@guillaumemorel1326]

Je TAIME TANGUY ET AUSSI LES FEMMES

[@glendarr11]

U2. Con sus Letras y melodias sensibles concientizan y llegan hasta los corazones mas duros...Los amoo me hizo llorar al ver a esas Madres y familiares hablar de los suyos aunque desaparecidos, por la injusticia de dictaduras y gobiernos, que todavian quieren alzarce y fijar su poder. Poder que nunca llegara hacer dominio del pueblo!!!

[@voutespancar]

el pueblo vencerá... bono es un genio

[@vivianapaolariveramanrique9124]

De la gira del Pop Mart fue una de las emocionantes.

[@bluebottle08]

Muy Bien Bono. Perdona, mi hablar poco espanyol. I love U2 since 1982. The best group for ever! Muchas Gracias mi amigos.

[@steniemargarita]

De verdad solo un grupo como ellos tienen el verdadero valor y humildad para hacer este tipo de expresión humanitaria. LOS AMO SRES. DE U2

[@fattyjah]

I don't understand most of the words that are said but I understand.... thnks..........

[@imedi]

one of the most moving things i have ever seen at a rock concert tears

[@MatildeAraya]

Grandes !!!! U2, Bono, UNA EXTRAORDINARIA PERSONA!!! hoy una vez más se presentan en nuestro país!!!, BIENVENIDOS NUEVAMENTE!!!

[@ColorsBright]

HANDS DOWN! THE BEST POPMART CONCERT! The mexico show is good but this concert is just bone chilling! The whole concert is mind blowing, I wish there would be more POPMART shows this amazing with Miami,do you feel loved and if god will send his angels... Anyone and everyone should get a copy of this. This show will put those "pop haters" to rest and if it doesent, they clearly have no heart and soul.

[@JayZoop]

I cannot image the pain and worry these mothers went through!

[@Paint4U2]

U2 is always there, leaving their message for us to be inspired for the world's rescue. We hear the heartbeat...

[@xLovelyladies92x]

brilliant absolutely brilliant i feel so much for the mothers wifes husbands children fathers friends of the dissapeard and everyone else who knew someone who was dissapeared my heart truely goes out too you. x

[@wildraptor987]

Absolutely beautiful!! A powerful voice was given to mother's who have lost their children.

[@x3mSK]

I have chills! ...just left Chile couple months ago. Situation has changed. Thanx God.

[@verin1012]

Dedicada a las madres de los normalistas de Ayotzinapa, a las madres de las mujeres desaparecidas en Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua, Mexico, a las madres de todos los desaparecidos por esa guerra sin cuartel contra el narcotrafico, a las madres de todos los inmigrantes que en su paso por Mexico se encontraron con la muerte y que seguramente estarán en alguna fosa con algunos otros cuerpos. Es doloroso que Mexico en la actualidad pase por esto e igualmente que en latinoamerica sucediera

[@davidcarreno9696]

Veronica Lizethe Rascon Martinez Mejor dicho imposible.

[@evelynrojas113]

CHILE🇨🇱 AUN ESTA DIVIDIDO, POR CULPA DE AUGUSTO PINOCHET!!

[@grupoalquimistas00]

Un himno para todas aquellas personas a quienes se les fue arrebata una parte de su vida...se me hace un nudo en la garganta con esta canción.

[@danieldoherty8101]

Say what you like about bono, but as a band, U2 never shied away from the injustices and suffering in the world, remember they were doing Amnesty International's Conspiracy of Hope tour back in the 80's before they had become the juggernaut they now are, also we need justice for Chile, and the Mothers Of The Disappeared, and we also need Justice for the People of Palestine, for to long American foriegn policy has failed the very people it purports to support, but finally the US is getting its dye, with a country divided and no hope of reconciliation, perhaps this is the beginning of the end for the worlds greatest ' democracy '

[@imedi]

can only hope that one day they will be with their loved ones again

[@southsideman4891]

GOD GRANT IT!

[@JLEOMOSQ]

Increible!! ya desde el '98 van a chile y no han venido ni una vez a Colombia :( so sad.

[@andrewgillett5411]

This is such a beautiful version and such an amazing video

[@DejaVu77777]

This is the most simple yet meaningful song U2 has ever written. Just simply amazing. Tears in the Rain???? Wow just picture it........

[@irmarojas88]

con un nudo en la garganta, sinceramente con el pueblo chileno en el sentimiento y verlo en este día de la madre donde muchas mamás no tendran hoy...desde Paraguay un saludo

[@alanbodell2050]

I just watched this again and am in tears for my stupid comment below, god bless these unfortunate mothers and I really hope they get comfort and justice.

[@southsideman4891]

AMEN

[@imedi]

one of the reasons i love u2 so much

[@annabelleboluda8539]

Beautiful.

[@abisail]

very,very emotional...thanks bono.

[@salamanco968]

Love from Scotland

[@djsi38t]

Absolutely INCREDIBLE MAY ALL THE MOTHERS BE REUNITED WITH THEIR LOVED ONES!!!!ONE DAY WE SHALL ALL BE TOGETHER AGAIN!!!

[@PurpleDragonShill]

Thank you very much a wonderful tribute to those with disappeared loved ones. I was very young when the cold war started and our family left Chile when I was 6 so my memories are the heartbreaks and my lifelong hope of the disappeared being found to be laid to rest properly.

[@winger26]

I cried! fabulous!

[@shanemartin325]

I just want to say thank you to the band U2, and to fans who do well and wish well.

[@haneyvey]

Such a very special version of a very beautiful song thank you God bless and may the mothers one day what happened to there loved ones

[@OutSideDeMatrix]

Was at the POPMART tour in Edmonton, Alberta. They did not play this song. Wished they did. This is why U2 are who & what they are. An aweome rock band with a conscience!! I cry everytime I watch this. Humans are capable of such terrible atrocities to each other. Our planet is experiencing this reality & we will all pay dearly - & I ain't talking about money. Can't eat money. Hear their heart beat! U2 fan since the boy album. (blessed to see them twice - no line on the horizon) Namaste

[@benjameslari]

Bono eres un tio grannnnde!!!....

[@ERDaub]

amo ese video. lloro cuando lo veo

[@prisonbreakadictos]

U2 es lo mejor, no hay palabras para describir su música.

[@Macconator2010]

greatest moment of the Popmart Tour, such an emotional song and gathering

[@gaboston]

Hermanos Chilenos salu2 desde México, y si en efecto... el pueblo VENCERÁ !!!!

[@camivargas96]

me emocione 😢😢😢 gran cancion !!!

[@FPKelly]

This is amazing. Tears welling up as I watch......

[@marcelauto]

O engajamento do U2 é realmente algo de tirar o chapéu!!!!! Para que nunca mais na hsitória da AL algo parecido torne a acontecer!!! valeu Bono Vox...

[@luieu2]

this song puts tears in my eyes

[@kilimandjaro26]

Merci BONO, tu es un géant, LE géant.

[@DrToni77]

Thanks for this great live performance. I got tears in my eyes...

[@miriamaguayo9120]

Quien Diciembre/2019??

[@TimStatic]

probably the most surreal moment on the whole entire POPmart tour, after of course the show in Sarajevo. awesome awesome awesome awesome. still words cant describe how awesome this moment is.

[@mauferran]

Y pensar que nunca le había puesto mucha atención a esta canción. Como me ha pasado con muchas canciones de U2, hasta que vivo el sentimiento que tratan de expresar es que las aprecio por completo. La música de U2 no se escucha, se vive.

[@sinnombre-dn5rg]

U2 , haces historia, la música tiene mucha fuerza más que las balas de un revolver.la música dice la verdad,matar a una persona, nadie puede matar a nadie,si no por defender tu vida, nadie, nunca es más un crimen,es el acto , que no debiera de existir, quitar la vida a otra persona por sus ideas.

[@richardyoung6709]

Bono is a great man!

[@JayZoop]

I"m choked up!

[@paliki]

spine chills ..

[@luiscarlosfermanaguilera2633]

Cómo envidio al pueblo chileno, El Salvador todavía vive bajo una ola de violencia y desapariciones a 30 años de la finalización del conflicto de 1980 a 1991, espero que algún día U2 venga a estas tierras centroamericanas, Bono visitó mi país en 1985 en plena guerra civil, y de esa experiencia nació esta canción, espero que vengan para que cantemos juntos "El pueblo vencerá".

[@nizzepower]

One of the few things that still makes me cry, how people can hate Bono is out of my understanding, a man with a bigger heart is hard to find.

[@francispotatohead300]

If I had a fraction of the Grace that these ladies have I would die a happy Woman.

[@peacedistributor5502]

Gracias U2 .

[@sing151]

Another great moment from the greatest band in the world!

[@hyperu2]

Sad how many people don't know this exists.

[@aromatic08]

la musica è lo strumento per la pace e la libertà umana......u2 ne sanno qualcosa..siete fantastici