Girls' Generation 소녀시대 Closer 레코딩 버전 Recording Ver.

[@saviorhyo_5265]

Hyoyeon's vocals really make each Forever1 track more unique

[@주리빈]

소녀시대 노래 중에 최애ㅜㅜㅜ 이 노래는 서현이랑 티파니 음색이 제일 어울리는 것 같음 ㅜㅜㅠㅠ

[@dxxkhauses]

헉 저도 그렇게생각했어요

[@dxxkhauses]

특히 티파니...

[@chaemiya4904]

The way Seohyun sounds exactly the same as the final outcome damn

[@hansanakolonnage2378]

i felt like they all did

[@21jd_]

i swear seohyun and yuri sound perfect right in the recording booth

[@sapbeauty]

I NEED SUNNY SOLO ASAP😭😭😭 HER VOICE IS SOOO BEAUTIFUL 😭😭😭

[@phamnguyenkhanh2438]

You should listen to the song named Goodbye which was collaborated between Sunny and JungWoo,, Renjun. That's so great!

[@sapbeauty]

@@phamnguyenkhanh2438 I've listened to it, of course I need to listen to it cause I'm a sone😭

[@arafadhwang4119]

She has so much potential 😢

[@montyl.8232]

She don’t want to do solo album

[@louise9489]

@@montyl.8232 bro, she does. look up her conversation with boa. i'm tired of seeing comments like this.

[@cileft011]

they will always be THE girl group to me 🥲 i don't think idols these days are trained the same

[@Callmeshin12]

Hyoyeon actually had so many add lips without everyone notice about in every snsd song

[@10veMemory]

ㅇr니..미영쓰 파트 어디갔냑우요 스엠아 ㅜ

[@goodnightLea]

진짜... 이 곡 백미가 파니 브릿지부분인데...

[@ythsieh5286]

maybe she didn't record it in sm

[@Migzter05]

This song deserves a MUSIC VIDEO.

[@sspl-kz7kv]

소녀시대표 시티팝 장르.. 후렴부를 멤버들 돌아가면서 부를것도 너무 좋고 질리지 않고 오래오래 들을 것 같아요

[@seoki12]

이곡으론 음방 활동 안했나요?

[@OYOYoo]

다들 노래를 왤케 잘해... 역시 소녀시대... 최고다

[@dur47tr6dhxdhcv]

역시 소시언니들😊😊

[@끄르릉끄르릉]

멤버들 각자 녹음하느라 서로 어떻게 녹음했는지 모를텐데 이 영상 꼭 봤으면 좋겠다 ㅎㅎㅎㅎ

[@DreamWishx]

they're all amazing but seohyun, sunny and yuri's vocals are seriously underrated!

[@지금앞으로도영원히]

햐...마지막 깔롱부리기까지 완벽햇다...소녀시대 음색머선일이고 소녀시대 왜케 더잘하냐고

[@priscillac3386]

Tiffany at the intro ! It’s just amazing

[@missvanilla2080]

Everyone is really good but Seohyun--- she made it look effortless yet sounded exactly the same on the outcome, even her vocal runs. 🫶 I love GG so much!!! 💖

[@kyungminnam]

써니 음색 너무좋다ㅠㅠ

[@glassheart4121]

Closer and Villain are my fav bsides in this album ❤

[@UtauKukai123]

sunny's voice is so clear and beautiful TT

[@nrld13]

서현 목소리 넘 황홀해~넘 좋다~👍 음색 보물 서주현~💕

[@Sona-np2ju]

I need idol Yuri to comeback honestly!

[@Cam-ss9rb]

I think Yuri's rendition of the chorus is my favorite

[@liz-qu9pk]

sooyoung has really improved so much since the early days of snsd!

[@ADI-lc1de]

Fr

[@yeonjooism]

너무좋다 ㅠ 서현 음색 미쳤음

[@choi_yu_jin]

믿고 듣는 서현🤍소녀시대🤍

[@sophy.k4714]

유리 저음 오진다 자꾸 두근거리고 난리,,,

[@raelee735]

Now this is THE REAL studio live recording version. Not some processed vocals and then labeled "live" ❤️❤️❤️ I really enjoy authentic contents like this. Thank you so muchh!

[@Zenius14]

Merging every scene of snsd's closer recording like this proved that snsd members aren't only have a pretty face but also a good voice.

[@kio9103]

와 서현 막냉이 너무 잘함

[@호잇-t5i]

혹시 레코딩버전으로 편집된건 없을까했는데 제가 원하던걸 딱 올려주셨어요ㅠㅠㅠ 정말 감사합니다ㅠㅠ

[@개두목-l5o]

써니 소리 진짜 좋은데

[@skyking8499]

Don't underestimate Yuri's vocals

[@imchaos4u590]

yuri has a beautiful voice

[@usernumber99345]

Can’t agree more

[@alwaysfindyu]

Seohyun, taeyeon and sunny are so good🥰

[@emperordragon1794]

fany enters. hums once. refuses to elaborate further. leaves.

[@귀족쿠치키]

내가제일좋아하는곡이다ㅜ

[@itgetsworse601]

Thank you for making this, it's such a delight to hear them recording

[@동환님]

티파니 미쵸따

[@andiflores252]

I personally think that sooyoung and seohyun has the best voice.

[@eniddeltacross4410]

Closer is underrated. This is my fave track in the album and in my repeat list whenever I listen to their last album.

[@rocky.487]

Huhuh i love everything esp yuri & hyo's low registers

[@hugo_1120]

레코딩 더 내놔라 스엠아!!

[@neo-if4of]

Seohyuuun 🥺🥺🥺💖💖💖

[@loveautumnbreeze]

묭 파트 내놔 스엠아ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ...

[@ngocbusy4402]

feel like listening live performance, thank you so much for made this video

[@Kap.Vm20]

Seohyun y su pose de diva hasta para cantar. Me encanta..., no deja el glamur ni cuando trabaja ❤😊

[@주또롱]

이 노래 너무 좋아ㅜㅜ 서현이랑 티파니 음색 미쳤음 ㅜㅜ

[@mining6401]

서현 태연은 녹음본이랑 다를게없네 진짜 잘한다❤

[@mayyno1se]

i know tae is a great singer girl be hittin' those high notes but low notes tae got me >//

[@Ban-nq2gy]

Yuri has a wide vocal register❤

[@iszsvnnyknight5688]

Both my favorite vocalists have so little parts shown in all recording clips - Sunny Tiffany

[@dambi117]

어제 소시공계에서 영상보자마자 이 채널에 편집 영상 올라오길 기다렸어요...❤️ 매번 정말 고퀄의 영상 감사합니다

[@ytgirl2590]

What the heck? I need a sub unit with Hyo, Sunny, and Yuri as vocalists, and more solos, why not?!!!

[@karltogonon5570]

this is the og SHY. listen to As Time Goes By cover by them.

[@hugecake4178]

listen to OHGG album, their vocals really shines there

[@simziiii]

클로저 분량 파니가 제일 많은 것 같더만 스엠 카메라 꺼졌는데 꺼진줄도 몰랐나봄... 그럴 것 같은 놈들이어서 더빡치네

[@tiffhappy]

가장 일리있네요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@boy_of_june8480]

이거다 ㄹㅇ

[@이이지-l9h]

와 새벽4시40분에 올려주시다니 ㅜㅜ 밤 새워서 편집하셨나요 영상 뜨고 나서 이 채널에 올라오기만을 기다렸어요 정말 감사합니다!!!!!!!

[@rayskywalker4]

This song is for Yuri she did amazing

[@fuyuyaa]

Hyo's voice🥰🥰🥰

[@user9182-1]

순규 찰떡!

[@jessiechen1323]

Sunny's voice is perfect for this song

[@피치-r9m]

이번 앨범은 써니웅니 유리웅니 음색이 진짜 대박임 세상 사람들 다 알았으면 좋겟다 ㅠㅠㅠ

[@raloyalhilton2658]

태연은 워낙 잘하니 말해모해고...써니님 음색 매력있음.....앨범 내주셨으면

[@Mulgugiable]

Wow. Thanks for you hard work 💪🏻

[@BenchCarreon]

Yuri!!! 😍🥰

[@charmy3021]

Thank you for this! Their voices are so beautiful!🥺💖 #gg4eva

[@taengooss]

Seriously, even the main dancer of SNSD can be a main vocal in other girl groups. 😩❤️

[@rubyrosem9693]

LMAO not at aaaall

[@hyuniversitee]

she can't even support how???

[@fivel9864]

아 왜 눈물이 나지... 진짜 띵곡이다!

[@mobpsycho7813]

their voices are lovely❤

[@haromi4647]

써니 음색 이렇게 좋은지 몰랐는데 파트 왤케 적어용 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@MrPop-fi4uq]

SNSD All the best Vocalist and Clips cut owner, you’re the good too. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@user-ce8pb6qx2u]

편집 너무 잘해주셔서ㅠㅠㅠ 항상 너무 감사합니다!💖💗

[@ueksn96253]

순규 너무 잘해ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 써니솔로내놔ㅜㅜ

[@NhuHuynh-sg5ze]

Giọng của Sunny hay quá huhu

[@박춘삼-f5o]

다들 정말 열심히 하네요. 행복했으면 좋겠어요. 이렇게 각자 열심히 사는 우리들도 그리고 소시도..

[@user-ut5py3md3d]

태연아 팬들만 믿어!!!!! 영원히 💚 사랑해♡♡♡♡Forever love ❤️😍💖

[@TomasAlvarezz]

We got most of the song!!! omgg, this is my fav track ever 😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@herryL03]

🥰so niceee work! thank you

[@nicoadiwijaya5813]

Why do they never show Tiffany's recording proccess??? Unfair

[@kimiaaakk]

My fave song from the latest album! I really love how this song showcase their vocals in a different light. I love snsd so much 🥹💖💖💖

[@fayevinyl4596]

Peeps be talking about sndd vocal but not the editors amazing hard work. Thank you for making thiss!!!

[@monicgarr6686]

es mi canción favorita del album 😍😍😍😍

[@DarkFoncho]

la mía también, aunque claro el title track es buenísimo!!! Paper Plane también.

[@lgiantspurs]

미스 횅누님 파트 내놔

[@paghetti0309]

와 영상 정말 잘 만드셨다 👏🏻 파니파트 부족한거 아쉬워요 ㅠㅠ

[@iamjennie]

It’s very cute of you to edit this 😭😭 thank you so much

[@withstella9172]

Sunny and Hyoyeon voice 😭🤍

[@TheAlexSandwich]

This is the best song from the album let's face it

[@dafihale7139]

BEST TRACK of the album everyone got to shine equakly in this album esp in this track

[@e_a_s_y__]

ㅇ올려주셔서 감사합니다 감사합니다ㅜ ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅠ진짜 빠니부분 왜 더 안줘스엠 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@innerkpop4471]

Thank you very much for this version.

[@ceshee]

oh boy don't be silly🤧 I was waiting for this video, thank you!!!! I love closer so much

[@HOTKNY]

급 이노래에 빠졌어요 좋당❤

[@supermayora]

queens of raw vocals

[@phucduy4606]

giọng Sunny hay vậy trời

[@girlsgeneration3169]

As expected from my Soshi ❤️

[@xxgxxnismilan6374]

I love it👏💕

[@yenchi8801]

Thank you for this video ❤

[@84stair]

어우 선생님 감사합니다 ㅠㅠ❤

[@djimenez19799]

This is fxckun awesome!!!! About time we see them recording! Thanks!!!!

[@reizadkha]

thank you for your hard work ❤️

[@DIVErKKK]

Thank you so much!! Really like this version you made🥰🥰🥰

[@fwhyeye9512]

Seohyun

[@alejaamortegui3004]

Loveeeee it!!!

[@pablo.frodriguez9853]

Esta canción debería tener su videoclip