SMNGG (

follow my social media for SMNGG
Instagram
/ hallyu.smngg
twitter
/ smnggloops
#SMROOKIE #SR20G #SMNGG #SR20G #SR19G #lami #koeun #hina #ningning #jimin #helen
Yang SM Rookie Girl
1. Hina
2. Ningnig
Yang Trainee
1. Jimin
2. Helen
ex Smrookies
1. Junyeon (udah debut sebagai aktris di keyst Entertaiment (salah satu perusahaan SM entertaiment juga)
2. Koeun
3. Lami

[@Max-my6rk]

congrats ningning u made it!

[@azureflute3266]

and jimin aka karina

[@nattynatttyy2998]

@@azureflute3266 why her name is jimin? Isn't karina?

[@juyeonlover405]

@@nattynatttyy2998 karina is her stage name yoo jimin is her real name

[@---xv5jp]

@@nattynatttyy2998 Everyone is aespa actually uses stage names!

[@esobrad9766]

Jimin too

[@Max-my6rk]

Ning Ning's vocal is no joke... a non Korean main vocal yes !

[@wonwoosburger9066]

I’m here because I’m so proud of Karina (Jimin) and Ningning. Yet I can’t move on with the OG SR15G :( I really miss Lami, Koeun, Hina, and Herin....

[@thareqinsans]

Lami & Yiyang could be the visuals of Aespa along with Winter, Karina, & Giselle, but too bad they left :'(

[@ardentthoughts9750]

@@thareqinsans yes herin! i was looking forward to her debut but to no avail :(

[@vanhminglianitochhawng3209]

SM is adding more members maybe koeun and Helen maybe added

[@thareqinsans]

@@vanhminglianitochhawng3209 I hope SM will add Lami & Yiyang as well :'( let's pray together they will be back in SM and join Aespa

[@ardentthoughts9750]

@@vanhminglianitochhawng3209 idk but for me, aespa ot4 will be forever iconic! i don't want a female version of nct :( however, i do wish for the og sm rookies to debut! i am looking forward to that, though herin, my favorite, left sm already :(

[@saaahell]

ningning literally became a main vocalist the moment she stepped SM. they're lucky to have her.

[@markcity6587]

it is sad for koeun hina lami they deserves better

[@evelyngarza3931]

And Giselle trained for less than a year. It’s really sad. I wished they had something like nct but in female version and keep adding members but nope

[@ccsbm208]

Maybe they’re happier now. They’ve been with sm since they were children it’s possible that they grew up and decided that being an idol wasn’t for them.

[@shoottakeapanorama6932]

@@evelyngarza3931 Although Giselle trained shorter, she trained before she joined SM (If that makes sense)

[@evelyngarza3931]

@@shoottakeapanorama6932 where did she trained?

[@llaoniesss1695]

I guess because the girls didn’t fit aespa concept

[@XuLeeKwon_SVT]

They're judging ningning saying she's not a good vocalist in sm Let her sing songs like this and she'll definitely prove her beautiful and super stable voice Their songs as of now is not that challenging for her so she's going easy on it Just wait for their powerful comeback

[@omds259]

wth? she literally number one in gen 4

[@XuLeeKwon_SVT]

@@omds259 yes she's the best main vocalist of 4th gen Haters tried to drag her down saying things like she's the worst main vocal in sm And now she's proving that she deserves to be a main vocal even a main visual and main dancer

[@scarlett9750]

I’m sorry but did they saw ningning singing live without any music/autotune????? Cus if they did then they will know how good ningning is. I’m not MYs but i watch their stuff and aespa went to many variety shows.

[@XuLeeKwon_SVT]

antis just say those stuffs which is obviously wrong cause ningning is a great singer since she was young they're just trying to drag her down but they can't cause Ningning is a talented idol Haters are just envious

[@Wenny_the_WM]

But she managed to hit Taeyeon High note in Into The New World

[@jenlisane]

congratulations to ningning and jimin!! you guys made it!!!

[@cherrymeup1823]

Urri Ningning, u have hardwork and thankyou for survive thru the hard time. And thx SM for debuting ningning on aespa her vocan is not joke😭 i always got goosebumps

[@gujigujimatters3713]

lol ,, can people just accept that smrookies girls might have another path and fate and not arguing these girls should debut as aespa !!? this is disrespectful to aespa members ,, they also work hard and its their fate to be in aespa !! lets just hope the best for smrookies girls 💕

[@maira.azzara]

out of everyone only karina and ningning who made it :( life is hard

[@hhana5190]

only ningning actually, karina wasnt introduced as smrookies

[@azme9355]

why are u sad they made it?-

[@azme9355]

@lola dacutest oh ok

[@유경-d3w]

람고히 목소리도 얼굴도 다 저렇게 이쁜데 놓치냐 진짜.. ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@리동탁]

진짜 안정적임... 음색이랑 안정적인거 보면 고은 뛰어넘는다ㅜㅜ 고은은 약간 슬기느낌이구

[@rheamae8434]

I REALLY LIKE KOEUNS VOICE HDHAJHDA SHE COVER TAEYEON'S WHAT DO I CALL U SHE NAILED IT

[@yasminyousuf]

Karina and NingNing made it :))))

[@jaemsfires4756]

everyone deserved better :( we all know they do. everyone deserved to make it especially that everyone obviously worked so hard. congrats to ning and jimin btw!

[@Max-my6rk]

you can tell ning ning even had the best vocal here lol

[@jkim4729]

히나 고은 라미 데리고와라ㅡ 스엠아 ..

[@ra6262]

Ningning looks so cute!

[@btsismyoxyjin1997]

Exactly 😍

[@pixiejjaem]

I'm soooo proud of Ningning!!!🥺❤️ I really miss the ogs tho 🥺 Lami, Koeun🥺🥺🥺

[@Laylashabye]

fyi. Yoo Jimin, JeongYeon, Helen aren't SMROOKIES (SM didn't introduce them as SMROOKIES)

[@Xilyz]

Wait isnt helen a yg trainee ??i saw her in yg trainee list but idk if she left from yg i think she left sm too..😅

[@Laylashabye]

@@Xilyz idk because so many rumours about her

[@Xilyz]

@@Laylashabye oh ok i have seen her at many ygngg videos so I am really ready for them yg&am Stan here😅

[@anisariasantoso1123]

Yep. They're hidden trainee

[@yolandaferdians9540]

Karina (Jimim) and Ningning made it ❤️❤️❤️

[@tesjackeylove]

ningning&karina

[@jenolevi]

I'M SO PROUD OF NINGNING 😭

[@ceyliinnm]

Our little ningning and jimin they wasso good

[@faza5389]

Ningning high note 😻

[@annejia5382]

0:31 Koeun here sounds so much like Yoona, Tiffany and Sooyoung are singing altogether 😍 anyone else? 🤗

[@ainco-ko7jh]

히나 라미 고은 혜린 돌려놔..

[@erichen713]

I hate the comments talking about BigHit. Please, do not talk it in here, it's not a thing you can talk in here right now.

[@chalimi.fithratu]

What comment?

[@vanhminglianitochhawng3209]

@@chalimi.fithratu all they say is like fOrMeR tRaiNeEs aRe oN biGhiT nOw tHEyrE mOrE sUcCesSfUl tHeRe or something like that,very immature

[@ni-kinotniki]

Why not? lmao

[@shoottakeapanorama6932]

@@ni-kinotniki Read the 2nd comment

[@ni-kinotniki]

@@shoottakeapanorama6932 I didn't ask the reason, dude. I said WHY NOT cuz there's nothing wrong with it, smh

[@heeclvr920]

ningning such a strong girl

[@adhaananda247]

ningning no joke

[@nataliejj1435]

I still think its a pity lami and koeun did not get to debut..

[@btsismyoxyjin1997]

Yess....Lami is my bias from SM rookie while koeun is my bias wrecker. While in Aespa Karina is my bias and Ningning is my bias wrecker. I wonder how would have been my bias list if both Lami and koeun would have debuted in Aespa 🤔🤔.

[@jijizyo]

congratulations jimin and ningning

[@anneb.8258]

lami, koeun and hina is the best trio, i miss my girls :(

[@Naevi-r9p]

Hina’s voice is soooo pretty 😢It isn’t like anything voice that other K-POP idol have.....

[@petarelive5241]

Ningning and karina made it

[@YourNIIZI]

I miss Hina seriously... I think they took giselle after Hina left😭 but I still love Giselle...

[@jere6487]

I think Hina left after Giselle was selected for debut instead of her

[@andre_3578]

Yall there is a huge possibility that Helen might be added to the group as the 5th member. Congrats Ningning and Jimin. We love you. ❤️❤️

[@elise1354]

honestly that's really doubtful. at this point i don't think SM has any plan to add any members

[@SicaRun]

She was rumored to have left in spring 2020 and I think is true, we never heard about her being a trainee since then

[@btsismyoxyjin1997]

@@SicaRun omg 😳

[@SicaRun]

@@mawiya7010 I don't think Helen and Giselle competed over the same spot and highly doubt age had some to do, if Helen was ready, they could debut aespa as 5 members

[@mariafrancesalbano5709]

@@mawiya7010 Fr tho how i wish helen still got to debut :(

[@plmnaa.]

I still can't move on.. Its really hurt to watch this😌 hope that all of them debut in one group but 😭😭

[@insecureraven5777]

Honestly was a fan of Shining Star and I have found out that the singers from all their songs are from SM Entertainment. I already knew about SM Entertainment but I never made the connection between SM Entertainment and Shining Star

[@mary_once3302]

Stan sm artist Not forcing btw hehe

[@sadatulakma]

This song from ost shining star. Only jungyeon,koeun,hina,ning ning sing for that ost. Sadly only ning ning make it. Stop saying other girls doesn't fit aespa concept when they waiting for so many years for only sm keep delayed their debut. Girls are happy. Just support both side without discredit their effort as ex trainees or as aespa members. Both side work hard.

[@siri7478]

I love you Lami😍😍😍

[@JoshuaAlto]

Congrats to Ningning & Karina (Jimin) for your debut Aespa! :D

[@erikamaetobias612]

Ningning

[@saidhanr]

congrats jimin and ningning🎉✨

[@chenjithisandthat7321]

I miss hina herin lami keoun🥺😭❤️

[@endlessnostalgic]

Jimin and Helen didn't even sing, why u put them in this video?

[@---xv5jp]

Because they're part of SM rookies

[@bambuu_]

@@---xv5jp no they were never introduced as sm rookies lol they are only trainees

[@ae-winter9916]

@@---xv5jp they were not

[@aespa9725]

@frozenbananas they weren’t a part of sm rookies 😭

[@Boonies]

I wanna know where all these rumours about members being added to aespa are coming from... cant believe something a stan has made up

[@sadatulakma]

From smnbg fanacc. Before aespa was announced,they already leaked 4 name with now is aespa members. And other 3 girls name.

[@maryfontainefelix5132]

@@sadatulakma may i know what is the names of the 3 other girls?

[@jekrysoohaejung8482]

As to what I know lami, ningning, ko eun,hina and jungyeon is the part of smrookies project The rest are out of the project

[@erichen713]

I miss Herin so much 💗

[@dampcherry]

I'm so sad:((

[@lobna6398]

Why?

[@arian1340]

@@lobna6398 because the other girls were not able to get into aespa, I think

[@yuhenyah1290]

Im really waiting for Koeun's debut. She really trained for a long time...

[@SoshiStars]

*I wish Herin and Koeun made it :(*

[@cio3519]

me too, +Lami and HIna.... i want to see their interaction with nct dream, but sadly they didn't make it😢

[@sadatulakma]

Herin left since 2017. She never part of sm new group

[@arvian_05]

Ning ning,lami and helen...❤️

[@revelkiss8821]

Harika ningning

[@ningbangs4304]

NINGNING BABY

[@moxygamingg]

jimin is karina right??

[@TheKyoung4214]

yes:)

[@ssffdzzz5791]

yAs

[@eirene5794]

Yep

[@asdfghjkl-ny4nm]

She's the one with a scandal before who texted her friend about sm artists?

[@lapisincognito]

@@asdfghjkl-ny4nm yes but it's a FAKE rumour. The person who start the rumour even said she have so much fun by making that fake rumour, she's sick. Karina never said those bad things about bts,exo, and nct! SM already take legal action about it, sadly many people still believe the rumour even tho it's proofed fake

[@busrawkart]

I come here to listen their voices stayed reading comments and couldn't stop listening the song 😅

[@aloha_lax]

Jungyeon, Hina, Koeun and Ningning featuring Jimin and Helen

[@busrawkart]

I hope the girls who haven't debuted will debut soon, I would like to see them with this concept :( there are not many gg who doesn't do girl crush concept recently

[@retenson8596]

I'm pretty sure they all have up on being trainees

[@kwynxx]

The prettiest debuted

[@majdulinmujahed255]

Ehh no lami was literally the visual and sm pushed her so much during sm rookies era but she still didnt make it

[@onlyalexz7631]

@@majdulinmujahed255 i think lami didnt debut bcs kontroversial about redvelvet add new memb,rumor redvelvet was have a sub unit and sm try to add yeri and got any hate speech and sm rookies didnt debut

[@sadatulakma]

@@onlyalexz7631 nothing related with rv. Just sm keep postponed their debut. Too bad final group only have 4 members

[@STANSAT10N]

What could’ve been White Fox / Moonlight Angels

[@poluantiara772]

NINING 🎀

[@eyebrowstj]

I was really looking forward to Koeun and Lami's debuts! A shame they didn't get the chance to debut ☹☹☹

[@vanhminglianitochhawng3209]

Hi again

[@도토리-s4r]

여뤀 내놔...

[@oikawaiitoru1949]

I miss Hina And Lami so much :( I wish all the best from them And also please don't waste Helen potential sm!

[@chiken8801]

Yeah, they could have been the main and lead dancers :’

[@raphaelezra4571]

NingNing ❤

[@aurenstarlight]

I’m still really angry that koleader, hina with cat like eyes and lami mouse didn’t get to debut. SM would’ve debut them if fans didn’t want girl crush so bad. They would’ve fit the innocent concept, however SM wanted them to do girl crush entirely.

[@sadatulakma]

I think koeun, hina,lami can fit with any concept. If they were give a chance to debut with aespa. They totally fit the concept same as aespa members. Even aespa members is cute type but can slay with girl crush concept

[@aurenstarlight]

@@sadatulakma I definitely agree. I started to realize that the main issue is that all of the aespa members have trained for 4 years excluding Giselle. Koeun, Lami and Hina trained for nearly a decade (and Herin although she doesn’t enjoy the entertainment industry and left for good so I’m happy for her)

[@btsismyoxyjin1997]

@@sadatulakma exactly

[@jieun121856]

여기 유지민이랑 핼렌은 왜잇는거야...

[@illll7228]

ㄹㅇ 부르지도 않는데

[@하은-i4v]

ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅌㅌㅋ부르는줄..

[@둥둥이-b8l]

루키즈가 부른건데 루키즈도 아닌 애를 갖다놓음ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@sheesh4918]

ㄹㅇㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@egglayingbunnies]

they still might debut because aespa is highly rumored to be adding members!

[@User-jt8li]

I wish Helen and BBC Girl will

[@omotorera]

Please no

[@---xv5jp]

I will forever miss Koeun and hina:(

[@dproductions7293]

Koeun did all jessica lines, she did a great job

[@a3shyuck]

no but actually the original lineup really could fit the girl crush concept . i mean if aespa debut with a cute concept , people would love it too . same with koeun , hina and lami if they actually debut , they can fit into the concept . but srsly tho doesn't matter what the concept is , they will surely accept aespa even with diff members . they're just saying that they're fine with aespa members now since they already debuted . imagine if the original lineup debut , people would actually love it too lmao . yall didn't know the heartbreak , yall are not there with the smrookies girls

[@daphney2494]

Ikr😢

[@brightesthaesun9335]

This old line up just show how SM GG's before.. They can pass if SM want to do like SNSD SES era.. But to follow this new era.. New generation of idols.. SM just did the best to have different vibes of gg with aespa.. Like how they did with NCT music.. Starting from NCT era.. SM change so much related to music culture.. Aespa just go through with Neo music era too.. And upcoming new group..

[@ganbarinasu]

why yall hoping aespa to use nct's concept? listen, if they use nct's concept its gonna be hard for korean general public to like them, bcs its gonna confuse Korean GP. look how many knetz saying that they glad aespa isn't nct female version, and how they are saying 4-membered girlgroup is enough. SM already said that aespa is a 4-membered girlgroup since start (well its 8-membered girlgroup if its plus their ae). one of aespa's member saying that it was possible for aespa to debut because there are 4 of them. just hope for the OG SRG to live happily and successfully and support aespa as they are now.

[@purecarats2886]

Spain without S😭

[@velvet_5286]

Nah I like aespa's original line up

[@maharanipranodya7478]

I like aespa but feeling sad for our ex-smrookies.

[@lintangcahyan6227]

Ningning medok sekali wkk

[@weareoneexo7252]

I miss koeun and helen 😭💔

[@MisterCee3202]

Hina is debuted with Lightsum I’m happy very much

[@kobe9213]

hina from sm rookies is different from hina from lightsum.

[@thuyduongnguyen148]

love Lami

[@2lstone]

Koeun, Hina

[@lyh121]

I MISS LAMI 😭 LAMI is very talented , why didn't she made it 😢😢😢😢 feel sorry for her, if she were a member of aespa , I'll totally like aespa more 😔😔😔

[@rkperaltaaa]

Ning ning made it Jimin is KARINA !!! 😱

[@user-os4mh8pe1d]

저 오늘 구독했어요 그리고 힘내세요 화이팅 하세요. 그리고 코로나 바이러스 조심하세요 그리고 올해도 건강하게 오래오래 행복하게 사세요! 그리고 올해도 좋은 일만 가득하길 바래요! 그리고 친구가 추천해줬어용.

[@mycakegirls9531]

I Miss Koeun and lami😭

[@ra6262]

I will miss lami 😔

[@chyntiamaycelline9106]

Karina Ningning😍

[@thachsophane2559]

Good

[@체다-e1y]

히나 데려와 스엠!!!!!!ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@jupiter9974]

congrats Ningning and Karina from æspa💜

[@diary_m]

Terjemahan Indonesia, yg komentar English semua 😭😭

[@erina730]

Bener banget

[@고구마-r7d]

여기에 박정연 배우로 빼고 김민정 넣었으면 진짜 진짜 레전드였다 에스엠아

[@user-tm6nl8bg4k]

@김진우 네

[@azr6146]

I miss mmc's girls members....

[@snowflakes6985]

Jimin is not in SRGs !!!

[@imyour_jiee]

Kangen:"(

[@sansint6146]

Only two from here debut with aespa :(

[@meilami3979]

Hani???? Or Jimin/Helen?

[@sansint6146]

@@meilami3979 Jimin and Ning Ning

[@rftownofficial7809]

@@sansint6146 yeah im so sad when lami and koeun left SM

[@Ella-bz5kd]

it was rumored that koeun is gonna debut in rumored new girl group of bighit entertainment

[@Rosevieenla]

@@Ella-bz5kd that's most likely not true. She's already older than Bighit was looking for

[@jisungpark4114]

I'm thinking if Koeun lami and hina debuted

[@matchastrwberry]

HELP I MISS LAMI

[@salasiahmaya1850]

Lamiiiii :( but okay at least ningning and karina did a great job

[@mesmereized]

Justice for Koeun

[@kaguyadesu]

Koeun, Lami,Hina, Jungyeon:(

[@spssr.f]

Lami is like the baby of nayeon and jihyo

[@nailazulfa2807]

Lami cantik banget❤️❤️

[@pome-ru]

Ningning is the only one that survived

[@chiara9224]

Jimin too. Jimin is Karina's real name

[@avocado1635]

@@chiara9224 but jimin wasn't introduced as smrookies tho

[@chiara9224]

@@avocado1635 but she is in this video

[@sadatulakma]

@@chiara9224 she's in this video. But she didn't sing for this song. Only koeun,hina,ning ning was singing