[STATION] 임슬옹 X 조이 '이별을 배웠어 (Always In My Heart)' MV

[@정태환-g2f]

진짜 조이 목소리는 전설이다... 음색도 개쩌는데 감정에따라 확확바뀌네 얼굴도 이쁘고 자신감도 넘치고 조이너무 좋다

[@CalmDain]

가슴도 웅장해짐?

[@나는배신을당했어]

@@lsy2119 ?? 드립인디

[@밍-g2d]

@@lsy2119 찐이네 ㅋㅋㅋ ㅋ ㅋ

[@고성규-c5v]

@@lsy2119 피해의식있음?

[@libcrisgayonoche2618]

@@나는배신을당했어 j8qjqqb1yq7hwqjq7qubqquuwqb1h1yqywbqhuqqhhw6wywh

[@조커-b9y]

조이는 남자들이 딱 좋아할스타일인듯ㅜㅜㅜ 웃는거이쁘고 애교많고 장난잘받아주고ㅜㅜ

[@橋替索]

조커 ㅇㅈ

[@수화이-x6f]

조커 몸매도 예쁘고 얼굴도 예쁘고요!😆

[@힘내세요-k6s]

육성재는 안좋아하던데ㅠ 동료지~

[@히히히히-f1s]

룰루랄라 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ부러우면 부럽다고 말하시죠ㅋㅋㅋㅋ되게 짠해보여요

[@히히히히-f1s]

룰루랄라 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ공감 본인 혼자한거봐ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ그냥 댓글지우지 불쌍해보여

[@ahjoyssi1795]

SM, please let joy have a special stage in smtown concert. let her sing this song. we badly need a live performance of it. or you can just let mark and joy perform their ost together.

[@psy2612]

ahjoyssi 🙌🏻 we all need that mark x joy ost performance 💚

[@inkaprasaptiami3174]

UP!

[@米莎-z2d]

Joy and Yeri yesterday!!

[@zirahmid5306]

Yess

[@liezammm]

YESSSSSSS

[@트위티-f1j]

이때 조이 염색한 것도 잘어울리고 너무 예뻐서 계속 보러오게 된다

[@hanbilee8415]

조윤희씨 여기서 이러시면 곤란합니다

[@國峯顏]

❤

[@JHJung-yb9ow]

진심 조이는 곡 분석을 잘하는 듯 곡에 따라 목소리가 변하는데 다 ㅈㄴ 잘 어울리고 목소리에 감정이 듣는 사람한테 다 느껴짐. 그냥 단순히 노래 잘하는 것도 좋지만 곡을 자기 스타일대로 분석해서 소화하는게 도 좋음

[@ziral3982]

ㅈㄹ

[@btovixxtrash6165]

I'm a simple person.I see joy I click

[@aifos8083]

Katie Zhu Same 😂👌♥

[@dredayeverydayx]

+ Katie Zhu hahaha! exactly..

[@j.3730]

your profile pic though... xD

[@kimmingyubooseungkwan7266]

same

[@lovebear1432]

lol i said the same thing after i clicked on this video

[@정태환-g2f]

와 좋은사람있으면 소개시켜줘 듣고 자동재생으로 왔는데 목소리가 이렇게 달라질 수 있는거임???? ㄹㅇ 조이 개사기네;;

[@itsmeeiam]

조이는 사랑노래도 이별노래도 진짜 장르 안가리고 다 잘 소화한다..좋은사람있으면소개시켜줘,여우야 보고 왔는데 또 다른 매력이야.이건 언제 들어도 몰입도 끝판왕임

[@yahoppa924]

JOY'S VISUAL JOY'S VOCAL JOY'S DANCING SKILL JOY'S RAPPING SKILL JOY'S VARIETY SKILL JOY'S ACTING SKILL HOW TO BE YOU PARK SOOYOUNG?

[@yulitasari4613]

Yess,she is perfect💞💕😙😍

[@fabiolaaguileraguzman1319]

CIERTO :D 💞💕😙

[@lugoche1369]

JOY BODY GOALS

[@navisaramadhany9556]

PERFECT JOY 😭😍

[@putriyantiii]

i hope she can debut on acting or sing an OST

[@hyukri]

JOY'S HONEY VOCALS CURED ME FROM MY FLU 😮 NO KIDDIN GUYS Her voice is that magical. ◼ Edit ◼ This song is slaying charts for the past 48 hours #1 Genie, #1 Soribada, #1 Mnet, #1 Olleh, #5 Naver #11 Melon AND #3 on the overall iChart just under Twice/ Taeyeon. So amazing for a STATION song!!!

[@ajengpuspita4371]

lol seriously? good for you, then.

[@trainheartnet55]

at which part did she hit high note?

[@puterikhalida5663]

trainheartnet55 2:48

[@biaa1511]

김설아 her voice make me cry.. joy's voice is magical 😢😢

[@cuongmanhtran7110]

김설아

[@이해나]

짧은 뮤직비디오지만 영화 한 편을 본 것 같은 기분이다 조이 임슬옹의 눈빛 표정 행동 착장 머리 모든 장면이 다 아름답고 먹먹해

[@paulwilliamtioxon]

If you're watching this video now, you're a legend.

[@MadeTasyaDevi]

yes me

[@kimjoyestrada9805]

Me . 💙💚

[@theresabernardino2700]

Hahaha ...I've watched it almost everyday...

[@notVulture]

:0

[@bilqisfaricha748]

Me in heree

[@krystalynight]

she became more mature now and i'm proud of her so much

[@limitlesstaeyong3039]

her voice improved so much

[@ohqueonda]

Faith Krystal my baby 😭 she isn't my bias but always impressed me in a good way :3 (I love rv so much)

[@fzkkzf2295]

izzatul iman joy always had a good voice..she just never had a chance to shine. My baby 😁

[@my_chemical_kpop9549]

Hydra So what's your point?

[@kamicharakarin]

My_chemical_kpop 9 Her point was how can you tell someone's maturity through a video that contains acting...pretty obvious.

[@터치볼]

조이의 특유한 귀엽고 예쁜 음색이 돋보여서 좋다 임슬옹은 항상 옳습니다 ❤️

[@1423주혜숙]

유주 ㅇㅈ

[@shishiwap]

Joy's deep voice is 💚💚💚💚💚

[@shishiwap]

coz I usually hear her high pitched voice

[@CYTMusic]

For a second I forgot it's Joy's voice lol...

[@dl622]

Taylor Tiffany Her lower register is everything 😍 + surprised to the point this is one of my fav SM Station song and that's saying something

[@박지은-d3c]

Taylor Tiffany who is she in your profile?

[@shishiwap]

박지은 its tzuyuuu

[@kim._868]

노래도 노래지만 저 뮤비속 조이 너무 예쁘고 귀엽고 사랑스러워서 계속보게되네...

[@august_shin2618]

Ok ...now I need to see Joy in dramas and her own album

[@august_shin2618]

and waiting for this mv bts

[@ratihdianut10]

august shin26 what the name of joy's drama?

[@jellybaebi]

she hasn't been in a drama yet, OP just said they want to see her in one

[@velvetyluna5020]

Ratih D U she never debuted as an actress sadly

[@lugoche1369]

AGREE

[@상사화-o4o]

조이 노래 잘하는건 알았는데 이렇게 잘할줄이야..

[@상사화-o4o]

사랑한다 조이야♡

[@채연-l9d]

에핑사랑레벨사랑 ㅇㅈ

[@히히히히-l5l]

갠적으로 조이 이때 미모 레전드같음 ㅠㅠㅠ너무 예뻐

[@서둥-x5f]

히히 히히 ㅇㅈ

[@쿠잉쿠잉쿠-v6e]

진짜 인정 진짜 상큼하고러블리함....

[@zieun4582]

스무살 첫 연애 했던 애랑 둘 다 조이 음색을 너무 좋아해서 이 노래 들으면서 시작했는데 그래서 이 노래 들으면 그때 좋았던 것들과 설렘이 생각나서 슬프기도 하고 그립기도 하고... 그때 기억이 나서 자주 듣지는 못하겠지만 아직도 종종 들으러 올만큼 노래가 좋고 뮤비 속 조이가 너무 예쁘다

[@아기사슴푸두]

진짜 주기적으로 와서 듣는 거 같음 스엠 조이 솔로곡 좀 줘요ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@ainco-ko7jh]

2020년 이 노래 들으시는 분🙋‍♂️

[@김원자-v3z]

저요 ㅋㅋㅋ

[@태리-t2n]

저염🙆🏻

[@xxxx_xxxxxxxxx]

저요 :)

[@gabdol9283]

저여

[@fd6302]

3년만에 다시들으러옴..

[@belletan1038]

SM, 벌써 2020년이 됐는데 저는 아직 박수영 씨가 이 노래를 부르길 바라는데 조이에게 이 노래를 smtown 콘서트에서 부를 수 있는 기회를 주세요. 이 노래의 라이브 공연이 절실히 필요합니다!!

[@덥잇]

진짜 목소리 둘다 너무 잘 어울린다 ㄷㄷ 조이는 조이했고 임슬옹은 슬옹했다

[@mocneeuq]

Joy suits this type of ballads more, her voice sounds so mature here Unlike with RV songs.

[@AmiratikaSalsabila]

Gracie C. try listening to the albums, they have lot of ballads also one of these nights is a ballad song and yes joy rocks those songs

[@yaodevi520]

Gracie C. True, her voice in ballads is just PERFECTION. I actually love Red Velvet ballads more

[@oorumaito]

The velvet side of RV is life

[@ivyreid7]

Gracie C. Yes acoustic ballad is her thing she sounds so good singing ppl need to know that

[@toppr-qt1yl]

agreed

[@tranhuynh9800]

Where Joy's fans ?

[@meghnanepal9877]

hiiii

[@allbeing24]

ayee

[@melypermatasari1274]

Hii😃

[@sooyoung_parkjoyreveluv4518]

🖐💚🥝

[@asnizamnizam4211]

Here

[@joyadvocate2516]

Almost 3 years, and we still never get the live performance of this masterpiece 🤧 who else cry with me?

[@유진-i3m8s]

노래도 노랜데 조이가 너무 예뻐서 자꾸 보러 오게 돼.. 인형같아

[@지예-h1q]

joy looks so cute when she smile!

[@joyismine6668]

I know, shes sooo cuteeee

[@지예-h1q]

Joy is mine Aw your username! u must be a fan of her!:)

[@blurmax]

Joy looks cute while she messes around!

[@honeyyook6648]

she looks awfully ugly yikes you should watch her predebut pic It's horrible I thought she was female shrek LOL

[@blurmax]

ho na You're telling something that does not exist anymore!

[@rookieisabadboy7252]

SM PLEASE GIVE JOY ANOTHER STATION.. she has a great voice, don't waste her talent.

[@jawahirmussad6947]

Park sooyoung slaaaaaaay !!!! Who said she can't sing ??

[@r3my925]

they probably regret saying it now

[@Serenity_01]

Jawahir Mussad of course..ah Park Sooyoung dongsaeng😍😍😍

[@keemrain]

Jawahir Mussad who ever said it needs to listen to 'I hope it'd be that way now' mr removed

[@CottidaeSEA]

I wouldn't go as far as to say she can't sing, but she's not an excellent singer. She can obviously sing, but fairly mediocre. Songs like these suit her better though. She'd probably be able to pull this off really well live as well.

[@eunie102]

Werewolf211 Why downplay Joy's voice on her MV where she obviously freaking kills. no Joy aint no Mariah Carey but her vocal tone is one of my favorites by far

[@hi_katri]

2021년 이 노래 들으시는 분🙋‍♀️

[@다이어리-h5m]

나^__^

[@윤성준-u1d]

저도ㅎ

[@amilliondreams5613]

저요❤️우결보다가 여기까지옴..

[@정하늬-o9m]

저요!!

[@hello_world17]

접미다

[@miyukibokuto3040]

U all see Sungjae but I see Seulong...they look good tgt..my God they're so cute tgt!!! Damn..ahhhhh!!!! 😍

[@ajengpuspita4371]

yeah!!!! such a good chemistry!!!

[@rex8814]

seulong x joy chemistry as a couple is really great... i cant even saw sungjae x joy cuz as a couple cuz i saw them as sibling idk why lmao

[@RielaKOKORO]

+Reffi Eka Wulansari OMGGGGG SAMEEEE I SEE THEM AS SIBLINGS ♥♥♥♥

[@rex8814]

Riela KOKORO maybe cuz how sungjae already drew the friendzone line since the beginning of WGM... lol. they are cute but seriously i saw them as sibling/bestfirend forever lmao

[@RielaKOKORO]

Reffi Eka Wulansari omggg I finally met someone who think the same as me .. Sibling/Best friends that what I'm always writing they're cute . And I really think that Sungjae thinks of Joy as his sister . If you have time pass by my instagram "sungjae_irene" I talked about it

[@luda6040]

너무 고마웠어 너라는 사람 만나 나라는 사람을 항상 웃게 만들었어 우린 사랑을 했었고 우린 사랑을 했었고 고마워 고마워 정말 여기까지 너무 고생했어 부족했던 나를 안아줘서 정말 네가 행복하길 바랄 거 같아 이젠 사랑을 알았고 이젠 사랑을 알았어 너에게 고마워 그저 바라만 보잖아 우린 여기까지잖아 아무 말도 없이 눈물만 한없이 흐르고 있는 널 보면 이젠 사랑을 알았어 이제 이별을 배웠어 Love you Love you Always in my heart Always in my heart 시간이 많이 지나 서로 무뎌질 때쯤 우리 한 번만 생각하기로 해요 정말 사랑했던 나는 네가 있어 행복했어 그저 바라만 보잖아 우린 여기까지잖아 아무 말도 없이 눈물만 한없이 흐르고 있는 널 보면 이젠 사랑을 알았어 이제 이별을 배웠어 Love you Love you Always in my heart Always in my heart 우리 힘들걸 잘 알지만 문득 두려워져서 마지막 인사를 나누면서 두 눈을 꼭 감고 웃어 이별이 내게 왔잖아 이젠 여기까지잖아 잠시 멍하니 나 서있어 혹시나 돌아올 것만 같아서 이젠 사랑을 알았어 이제 이별을 배웠어 Love you Love you 그저 바라만 보잖아 우린 여기까지잖아 아무 말도 없이 눈물만 한없이 흐르고 있는 널 보면 이젠 사랑을 알았어 이제 이별을 배웠어 Love you Love you Always in my heart Always in my heart Always in my heart Always in my heart

[@ronpull5076]

sm please let joy sing this song live

[@eipeituc]

Yeah I agree definitely 💚💚💚

[@이승은1]

처음 이 노래 나왔을땐 연애를 해본적이 없어서 그저 노래 좋다 하고 들었었는데, 시간 지나고나서 연애도하고 이별도 해보고 이 노래 들으니 공감이 아주 많이 되고 좀 더 슬픈느낌

[@alyssamillaine2370]

i love how everyone is surprised to hear joy's voice.Joy's voice is very beautiful but is not show cased in rv title songs.but when you listen to rv ballad songs joy always has this beautiful voice,i think seulgi talked about how surprised she was when she heared joy sing for the first time she said that joy's voice is very clear and very pure. I hope everyone will listen to rv ballad songs because there are many many beautiful songs from rv.i also hope that everyone will appreciate joy and her voice because from what i observed there are many fans who turned back on joy after her drama ended.they said things like she shouldnt have accepted the drama and just focus on rv and that she is selfish and doesnt have a talent for acting.its sad to see when joy gets bashed for her individual activities when other members have done it too.i hope everyone should realize that every individual activity that a member have is for the sake of the group.

[@honeyplums]

yoojung lover nice

[@barbaracirillo2437]

@yoojung lover Thank you I love Joy's voice and she's very talented.

[@deqaahmed2902]

yoojung lover every Word u said is true gurl👏👌🏿joy is so pure and talented

[@exo_velvettt]

we hate ot4

[@Kim-np9qb]

Joy smile like Suzy they have same smile 😘😘😍😍😍😍....it is why they are my biases....

[@karlaeusebio2610]

Kim saia i noticed that too ever since 'Happiness' they kinda resemble each other 😍

[@美夫张]

thought i was the only one who think like that

[@Kim-np9qb]

美夫张 ......no u are not the only one ....in her eyes I can see Suzy ....they are really sweet.....

[@美夫张]

cant agree more^^

[@MuusiicRafael]

Who is Suzy?

[@cupcaketree3963]

Woah Joy‘s lower voice in the beginning is soooo nice. I‘d never thought that her lower register sounds so good. I mean i know that she usually has higher notes in RV songs bc her voice is a bit high. I couldn‘t recognize her at all. I‘m surprised, in a good way ofc. We need more songs like this. Her voice is really sweet and fits songs like that very well. And Seulong‘s voice is amazing as ever. Still one of my favorite SM Stations :)

[@tinnitusxtogether]

I agree. It sounds so mature, colorful and sophisticated, just like how Seulong oppa described her voice in the Vlive session ^___^

[@cupcaketree3963]

Just Joy Things oh, they had a vline? Damn it, i must‘ve missed it

[@tinnitusxtogether]

yessss there was! there's even an eng sub haha before this MV was released, they talked on Vlive :D here's the link

[@tinnitusxtogether]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/nnStapyYhtV8mas

[@cupcaketree3963]

Just Joy Things uhh that‘s so cool. Ok, imma go watch it now. Thanks :)

[@Gowon1231]

조이언니 연기한적 있어서 그런지 뮤비 영화 예고편 같애 연기 짱이다

[@피릿리너스]

조이 너무 완벽한 여자♥

[@연다-h4b]

피릿리너스 한국사람 찾기 힘드네요 조이진짜 이쁘고 노래 잘부르고 부족한게 뭔지..♡♡

[@TV-rd4wb]

진짜진짜 갓조이언닝♡♡

[@피릿리너스]

+연다 음색도 쩌는..

[@피릿리너스]

+분홍신발 ❤박수영 조이❤

[@이준민-f6v]

쀼커플이 생각이 나요ㅜㅜ

[@psy2612]

I want a JOYxJAEHYUNxTAEYEONG collab. i heard they wrote a song together when they were trainees. I hope SM will let it happen 💚

[@fgv3320]

SM STATION you seeing this? We want the holy trinity Joy Taeyong Jaehyun!

[@psy2612]

Velvet PR after hearing their interview at NCT NIGHT NIGHT I didn’t even expected that they really got along well during their trainee days because I can’t see their interaction these days. Only Doyoung Taeil and Johny are very open with Red Vekvet when it comes to their friendship 😅

[@fgv3320]

@@psy2612 that's true. They barely interact which is a bummer. It would be nice to see Joy with male friends too. Anyway Joy (and wendy) is said to have trained at the same time as NCT members that's why they're closer to them than to their seniors unlike Irene, Seulgi, Yeri who trained longer and earlier than them

[@jihancosmetics5401]

me too 😭

[@jasmine_soo8839]

they wrote song together....but somehow they lost the song, they didn't know where the song was saved.

[@caryljill2174]

2020, who's still watching our Joy?

[@xn279]

this sog so gewwwddd

[@caryljill2174]

@@xn279 trueeee

[@neclaajsnsndhdn4827]

Mee

[@zyzee2098]

me

[@lalanotmyname5046]

here.✨

[@Nveevocals]

Can't somebody just give JOY another solo mv instead of just collabs! She's so precious and her voice is just too beautiful. 💖

[@riskaazzahra8108]

She's sing ost of hospital playlist

[@Nveevocals]

I know I just found out last week I am so excited and happy

[@uva8884]

Hello :D

[@tinkeryeol8636]

Joy's voice suit to sing OST. Angelic and very innocent. This is one of the many reasons why I stan Joy.

[@theshinee932]

Joy's voice is beautiful and unique

[@rookieisabadboy7252]

2019 still the best ballad sm station 💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚

[@rookieisabadboy7252]

9,7M

[@SitiAisyah-sf1sx]

I'm sorry but Timeless is better 😅😅

[@exo_velvettt]

Siti Aisyah sorry this ost (this video) is stil the best ballad sm station

[@rcabanosyumul.1888]

Yeah for me it's still the best 💚💚💚

[@crescentmoondriver4343]

a close second to Taeyeon's Rain

[@WntjWkd]

진짜 조이 음색 갑이다...!!!!!!!

[@Hello-zg9ud]

Joy is so successful and so powerful now.She’s a great singer and known as Park Soo Young not just joy of red velvet. -she’s the most followed RV member on all korean streaming platforms🤩 -she’s the only red velvet member to achieve a roofhit on Genie(3times with “always in my heart” and once with “mayday”)😶 -“yeowooya” ost has 17M views(highest views for all RV members’ osts)though the drama wasn’t so popular -she is the longest charting female idol of SM (along with taeyeon) though she hasn’t even debuted solo😌 -She has been nominated for 2 daesangs just for an OST which wasn’t given to her by SM (last song that SM gave joy was “always in my heart” in 2016 and that’s the only station for joy).

[@yeribananarotis7666]

Proud of our SooYoung, finally SM gave her a solo Album. Gosh…. She is so beautiful and talented💚 and her voice can heal anyone. I felt like heaven when i heard Je T 'aime from Hello album

[@beatrizgomes7699]

I hope in the future joy gets her solo debut 💚

[@각형이-k2u]

Beatriz Gomes 인정!!

[@sanjeevmishra408]

I also want that💗💗

[@justme2778]

It would be a great opportunity for you but what would happen to the other red velvet members... Like it would lead them maybe a chance to disband because of their busy schedule 😣😭..... But I would love that as well and more dramas 🎭😍😍😍😍😍

[@barbaracirillo2437]

@@justme2778 wendy has also had a solo

[@christophermanilavlogs3580]

Please

[@아름-h7q]

너무 고마웠어 너라는 사람 만나 나라는 사람을 항상 웃게 만들었어 우린 사랑을 했었고 우린 사랑을 했었고 고마워 고마워 정말 여기까지 너무 고생했어 부족했던 나를 안아줘서 정말 네가 행복하길 바랄 거 같아 이젠 사랑을 알았고 이젠 사랑을 알았어 너에게 고마워 그저 바라만 보잖아 우린 여기까지잖아 아무 말도 없이 눈물만 한없이 흐르고 있는 널 보면 이젠 사랑을 알았어 이제 이별을 배웠어 Love you Love you Always in my heart Always in my heart 시간이 많이 지나 서로 무뎌질 때쯤 우리 한 번만 생각하기로 해요 정말 사랑했던 나는 네가 있어 행복했어 그저 바라만 보잖아 우린 여기까지잖아 아무 말도 없이 눈물만 한없이 흐르고 있는 널 보면 이젠 사랑을 알았어 이제 이별을 배웠어 Love you Love you Always in my heart Always in my heart 우리 힘들걸 잘 알지만 문득 두려워져서 마지막 인사를 나누면서 두 눈을 꼭 감고 웃어 이별이 내게 왔잖아 이젠 여기까지잖아 잠시 멍하니 나 서있어 혹시나 돌아올 것만 같아서 이젠 사랑을 알았어 이제 이별을 배웠어 Love you Love you 그저 바라만 보잖아 우린 여기까지잖아 아무 말도 없이 눈물만 한없이 흐르고 있는 널 보면 이젠 사랑을 알았어 이제 이별을 배웠어 Love you Love you Always in my heart Always in my heart Always in my heart Always in my heart

[@머지꽃송이담]

임아름 감사해여

[@웃빛]

노래 가사 감사해요

[@oo-kl1uh]

수고하셨습니다

[@olivialee2302]

백번째조아효 앙기몯히

[@liveperson3908]

I realized after years how good looking Seulong is especially at 1:26

[@susienk]

Live Person 라이브사람 That is why he was the visual of 2AM .

[@savy9]

Live Person 라이브사람 ikr! I just noticed that too

[@liveperson3908]

Susie nk oh he was visual?? Didnt know that

[@2xtx.x104]

6년이 지났지만 아직도 이 노래를 계속 듣고 있는 박수영 씨는 '거짓말쟁이와 그의 연인' 시리즈 이후 솔로 앨범을 많이 냈고, 다른 드라마에서는 OST를 불렀다. 연기도 잘하고, 노래도 잘하고, 춤도 잘 추고, 랩도 잘하고, 완벽한 사람이에요.

[@nounayunus5439]

💚💚💚💚💚

[@장시현-y9q]

조이 완전 예쁘다.노래도 좋고,너무 예쁨.앞으로도 응원 할게요😍😘😚😙

[@연슬상큼귀욤주의]

장시현 ㅇㅈ여

[@efllvoe2989]

I'm here for Seoulong💞😭 thank you SM for letting me listen to his beautiful voice and watch his beautiful acting💞💞 Joy also has such a great voice, I didn't expect her to be so great but well she did a great job. Seoulong 💞💞💞💞

[@efllvoe2989]

Damn autocorrect. I mean seulong.

[@AmiratikaSalsabila]

Cynthia Ormuseray IKR I missed 2am so much 😭😭😭

[@jenithaayunda]

both of them have their own voice character~~ love it so much >

[@naomizahra5316]

Cynthia Ormuseray thank you!

[@giyuubricks]

Joy is a digital Goddess already!! Still in top of charts!!

[@rex8814]

RV is really good at digital for idols from SM. wendy station with eric nam stays at chart for 20 weeks, one of the succesful smstation song. joy smstation with seulong might ended up like wendy or maybe even better. i mean with big digital competitor it still did great means the public likes the song too :) finger cross

[@2netzkiee]

Reffi Eka Wulansari true, on Ichart joy & seulong is maintaining #2 soot 😍😍😍👍👍💚💚✔😙 i feel so proud hihi

[@redlove8861]

+Reffi Eka Wulansari yes! thats why it is nominated in MAMA! so proud of wendy and eric nam!

[@gelinela8670]

Shoujo Fanboy i bet this song will be nominated next mama 2017 😁

[@gitatiara4432]

Shoujo Fanboy

[@IamJunseo]

아직도 미치도록 떨리면서 듣고있습니다...

[@말랑뽀쨕상큼러블리사]

조이 개 예쁘다, 하얀 니트 찰떡이야..

[@조아-g8x]

노래 너무 좋다..하루에 몇번 듣는건지 ㅎ

[@조아-g8x]

둘다 노래 너무 잘한다 귀에서 꿀떨어진ㄷr

[@학생-t7n7k]

맞아요!

[@sh-gr2qv]

재수없어 깨알 응원도 귀여워욬ㅋ

[@jaimesvanessa10]

동의하다

[@mariB0827]

Been watching this MV since 12am and I still feel like crying everytime the scene gets emotional. wth. I need a drama for this!!!! Joy doesnt look like an amateur actress here. SHE'S TOTALLY BORN FOR THIS! SM!!!! Cast her in a drama!!!!!! SERIOUSLY!!!!

[@violet6507]

+

[@SicaRun]

Secret Stalker I think the RV members said that Joy is the best actress in RV so I'm sure that soon Sm is gonna push her into acting.

[@kwangsoo_]

조이 솔로 갑시다 -!! 조이 음색은 걸그룹안에서도 좋지만 솔로 발라드나 상큼한 노래 부를때 가장 돋보이는듯... 스엠 제발 조이 솔로나 커버 노래 많이많이 해주세요 ㅠㅠ💞🌽😷❣️🍒🍒

[@AmiratikaSalsabila]

Joy should do acting :"""" the mv is so sweet and sad I almost crying.

[@RosedianaEka]

Amiratika Salsabila me too.... i'm tear up

[@jawahirmussad6947]

Amiratika Salsabila she need more solo too

[@dellalovindra4159]

Amiratika Salsabila me too 😢

[@rex8814]

yes for acting! out of RV member joy's acting is really superb especiall in "knowing brther" varshow skit session. she nailed that

[@melliniaabriantisantoso8316]

i'm agree with you, her acting skill is awesome😍

[@melodychen6567]

Where are ma fellow Red Velvet stans at!! Our Joy cutie is flawless!

[@violet6507]

She's a perfection

[@jeralynhablerovlog5023]

Melody Chen she's perfect ❤❤❤❤ love my joy million times

[@tiwitepu9296]

Beautiful voice ✅ Beautiful face ✅ Beautiful smile ✅ Beautiful sleep pose ✅ Everything she always beautiful.. Proud of you sooyoung 💚💚💚

[@margauxannellanes2019]

SM STATION IS BACK AND THIS IS STILL ONE OF THE MOST ICONIC COLLABS. HOW ABOUT WE GET JOY AGAIN?

[@Sam-is8lw]

Margaux Anne Llanes SM be sleeping on our girl 😭

[@sexiangellol]

People love calling celebs "the next Suzy" but honestly when I first saw Joy I thought she could be the next Suzy. Their smiles are so similar, she has this classy vibe to her and she's tall also, and something about her lips are like Sulli.. she's so pretty

[@shqlymqly2668]

wanderlust i love joy because she has the same vibe as sulli

[@shqlymqly2668]

***** I didn't said she's sulli !! She resembles her so much! And has the same vibe as sulli in rv

[@shqlymqly2668]

***** I don't know how i can explain it ! But her being tall , having long hair (befor) , full lips and her cheerful personality .. etc

[@lillian3046]

I think that Joy is Joy, so she can be herself.

[@meisthxrd9781]

I DIDNT RECOGNIZE JOYS VOICE IN THE FIRST PART OH MYGOD I THOUGHT THERE WAS ANOTHER SINGER!!???!? MORE PLEASE

[@eunie102]

hananiah agnas her voice is beautiful 😭😭😭

[@joysdaughter532]

me too, i thought it was taeyeon's voice in the first part. Park Joyii😭💕

[@haidaadlin929]

SAME!!!!!

[@syarifahhumairasalsabeela8173]

I KNOW RIGHT! I thought that someone else sing this song!

[@battie0830]

hananiah agnas I THOUGHT IT WAS SEULGI's!!! 😱

[@midnightriver4021]

OPPA ITS BEEN AWHILE 😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@cancermoon]

2nd generation idols have a special place in my heart 😭

[@hadil0710]

a long while !! rally missed our seulongie a lot !!

[@ayuislamiatisam9436]

ITS BEEN AWHILE😭😭😭😭😭

[@sulkykyungseokfor300dollar7]

yasss let's rejoice 😭😭😭

[@VionyTania]

i got emotional when i heard his voice 😭😭😭

[@nojoynolife6084]

Our tone fairy..

[@babyjoyissleeping]

Someday I'll watch them singing this live. Someday...

[@aprilmendellson1451]

I know a lot of sungjoy couples are going to kill me for this but they actually look really good together

[@2netzkiee]

April Mendellson no im not ilike thiscollaboration. anyone whos with joy partner. isupport him hihi

[@aprilmendellson1451]

ommgg hhiihhi its me mishiro___ on my cousins youtube account! Do you remember me??

[@2netzkiee]

Omg yes i remember you hihi wow lets watch the mv 4ever hihi nice seeing you here hihi

[@alexandrakim6381]

April Mendellson this hurts me too but yeah HAHAHAHA

[@aureliaa740]

for me, they look good together as siblings.

[@grand3y276]

I REALLY WANT TO SEE HER IN A DRAMA!!!!!! SM PLEASEEEEE!!!

[@xxoOpinkOoxx]

Gran d3y omg yasss

[@divya9317]

Gran d3y ur wish is fulfilled😇😇😇

[@CZ1219]

이 노래만 들으면 떠오르는 사람이 있어서 눈물이 주륵주륵 흐른다

[@meenie9687]

this is my favorite song in SM station... i dunno why... there is something in the song that makes me reminisce something.... it feels like i've already heard this song in the past... i dont know really... i just love this song. Joy and Seulong thank you for this song

[@cuetzen712]

i think seulong and joy's voice complement each other very well. and this song has very nice melody too. tbh, i have always have that nostalgic feeling whenever i heard joy sings ballad. or even when she sang ses song in koms. her voice has that quality where i am feeling i should be reminiscing something but i dont know what. her voice sounds pure and clear like coming out from a fairytale song. seulong too has honey voice

[@cashshew2786]

I am Joy's new fan!! here here, love!

[@exorvapinkrevelda-l9322]

Cash Shew welcome although it is too late to say👋👋👋👊

[@bridgetle5832]

It is a bit late but please support Red Velvet too. Thank you

[@Deux04]

Best High what drama?

[@Deux04]

Best High you should also watch We Got Married Yook Sungjae and Joy. Its a must thing to do if you're going to support Joy 😍😍

[@user-cz4tc6ho4m]

Cash Shew YES!!!

[@balqisfaqihah5499]

joy's voice is really angelic i love rv and my fav is joy (actually im not so into girlgroup) i cant recognize her voice at first wow its beautiful srsly!! im looking forward for her solo activities in the future btw im ARMY and hopefully u guys could watch BTS mv Blood Tears and Sweat RedVelvet & Joy Fightingg!!

[@2netzkiee]

qissodingdingdong jjangbongbongggi i like BTS because of redvelvet become a fan of BTS when i saw JHope danced to ICC before.& yes i like their song blood sweat&tears hihi the MV was a masterpiece too.. BTSVELVET fanhere too hihi 😍

[@irenenadonga8228]

I wonder why Joy don't have her solo album yet? She have amazing vocal. SM you gotta give her this.

[@doughnut9019]

Joy solo is coming

[@Hello-zg9ud]

Joy solo album ‘hello’ will be out on May31.Spread the news and tell everyone to stream the MV when it’s out🙏

[@rrrrgg2460]

This is joy's first and last station song.It was one of the most succesful songs of station.AND WE DIDN'T SEE LIVE PERFORMANCE FROM JOY.I WONDER HAVE JOY ANY SPECIAL STAGE FOR NEXT SM CONCERT???THE OTHER THREE MEMBERS HAVE 2 OR 3 SPECIAL STAGE BUT JOYRI ... IT HAS BEEN 4 YEAR BUT THERE IS NOTHING FOR JOY.DO YOU NOW HER NAME IS UNDER THE SM! SHE IS YOUR IDOL.WHY SHE HAS ONLY ONE SONG (AND IT WAS SUCCESFUL).IF PDS DON'T CHOOSE HER FOR HER CHARMS AND TALENT WE CAN'T SEE HER ABILITY (FOR VARIETY, ACT, SING ...)I HOPE YOU CAN GIVE HER MORE OPPORTUNITY

[@kisha5097]

이노래 거리에서 처음들었을때부터 조이목소리인줄 알았던 나는 천재였던가..?

[@수화이-x6f]

yoon chol Shin 조이 특유의 청아한 음색 때문아닐까요..ㅎㅎ조이 음색 너무 좋네요!ㅠ

[@재리야밥먹자]

yoon chol Shin 우리 미라클동지 여기저기자주보이네...

[@이원규-u5o]

2019년에도 이 노래 들으러 오신분 있을라나??

[@caldiaa]

쩌요!!

[@최지은-w7l]

저요!

[@최빵-i8m]

이원규 저요!!!✋🏼✋🏼✋🏼

[@지민-z7v]

저요😃

[@호호잇-e9e]

저요!!

[@burban7986]

joy has the best signing voice in kpop in my opinion its so unique and like attention grabbing, I could generally listen to it non-stop for years and not get bored, Iconic.

[@초초-j8r]

둘이잘어울려ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ슬옹쨩도 귀엽고 조이도귀엽고 웃는거 둘다심쿵ㅠㅠ

[@Shishuuu47]

in the first verse it sounds kinda like seulgi ..

[@itzuyu]

TLaHL?

[@imyourfullsun2964]

It feels like a song for bbyu couple 😭😭

[@apayapyup4541]

lorraine gail garabillo omg ikr😢😢😢

[@amalialaili297]

lorraine gail garabillo bbyu couple forever

[@ursinhablacksz]

joy's smile: free therapy

[@pikachan8511]

that guy looks good 👄

[@TV-zt3jk]

pika chan rite?

[@sandra4408]

pika chan that' Seulong of 2AM ;)

[@SuperAnthoinette]

Half of the views are from me. I cant stop watching this since they uploaded it. I even bought the song on iTunes. I am really surprise how beautiful Joy's voice is.

[@jeralynhablerovlog5023]

Marie Anthoinette Diesta me too 😊

[@newspaperpanda]

Marie Anthoinette Diesta then there must be only two of us watching because I swear I'm 50% of the views too lol

[@firstlovev778]

+newspaperpanda lol same i stream this on my school's lab too hoho

[@susienk]

Marie Anthoinette Diesta And me. :) :)

[@yesungeify]

me in office everyday

[@Gretaisworking]

can we just.... this is the SUB SUB VOCAL OF A GROUP. AND SHE'S THIS AMAZINGLY TALENTED. RED VELVET IS A GROUP OF VOCAL QUEENS

[@bobh6602]

라이브 한번만 불러주면 정말 행복할것같은데 ㅠㅠ

[@터치볼]

3분 32초의 노래 뮤비가 마치 한 영화를 본 느낌

[@rookieisabadboy7252]

10M view, SM will make another station for Joy. ...righ? 💪💪💪

[@nicanharu4840]

Rookie is a Bad Boy I’m waiting on that day

[@jjba3571]

Sm doesnt realized how popular is joy, that or they dont care

[@jkillersmile]

As a fan of Seulong for a long time, he always looks awkward with the others, but this one surprises me. They looks so natural and good each other (even different age quite far ^^;) nice song btw ❤️️

[@SicaRun]

lemonatte Joy is a easy person to be friends with, if you watch WGM she's always the one that try to not let the situation awarkad.

[@ajrl268]

Always In My Heart Joy and Lim Seul-ong 너무 고마웠어 너라는 사람 만나 나라는 사람을 항상 웃게 만들었어 우린 사랑을 했었고 우린 사랑을 했었고 고마워 고마워 정말 여기까지 너무 고생했어 부족했던 나를 안아줘서 정말 네가 행복하길 바랄 거 같아 이젠 사랑을 알았고 이젠 사랑을 알았어 너에게 고마워 그저 바라만 보잖아 우린 여기까지잖아 아무 말도 없이 눈물만 한없이 흐르고 있는 널 보면 이젠 사랑을 알았어 이제 이별을 배웠어 Love you Love you Always in my heart Always in my heart 시간이 많이 지나 서로 무뎌질 때쯤 우리 한 번만 생각하기로 해요 정말 사랑했던 나는 네가 있어 행복했어 그저 바라만 보잖아 우린 여기까지잖아 아무 말도 없이 눈물만 한없이 흐르고 있는 널 보면 이젠 사랑을 알았어 이제 이별을 배웠어 Love you Love you Always in my heart Always in my heart 우리 힘들걸 잘 알지만 문득 두려워져서 마지막 인사를 나누면서 두 눈을 꼭 감고 웃어 이별이 내게 왔잖아 이젠 여기까지잖아 잠시 멍하니 나 서있어 혹시나 돌아올 것만 같아서 이젠 사랑을 알았어 이제 이별을 배웠어 Love you Love you 그저 바라만 보잖아 우린 여기까지잖아 아무 말도 없이 눈물만 한없이 흐르고 있는 널 보면 이젠 사랑을 알았어 이제 이별을 배웠어 Love you Love you Always in my heart Always in my heart Always in my heart Always in my heart

[@soopark3277]

I will never get tired of watching this SM Station of JOY....this will turn 3 tomorrow so SMTOWN don't you think she deserves another one? this is one of the best. Joy's voice is great and unique, please don't waste her talent because she could give more and we also deserve to watch and hear her sweet angelic voice again with a new song.

[@lightningjuniorsuper]

Another SM station song that needs at least one performance on stage

[@septiantiwulansari]

Always In My Playlist

[@이별-y9g]

예전에는 멜로디만 들렸는데 지금은 왜 가사가 들리냐,, 이별이 진짜 힘든건지 다시 알게됬다

[@seasilver7324]

End of year I still watch this MV. I watch this at least once a month. I love how Joy and Seulong oppa voice blend in this song. My wish is to see Joy sing this song live. And I NEED ANOTHER JOYSTATION OR SOLO, PLEASE SM. MAKE IT COME TRUE. It's 2 years already and Joy hasnt any solo or something. I think rather drama Joy need music projects more. Because for me Joy need learn more bout acting. But I'll always support our Sooyoungie.. be healthy be happy .

[@JADC-gg9lm]

You know that it's a good music when you cry or as if you're feeling what the characters in the mv portray. I don't understand Korean at all but I clearly understood what it's about. I love it! 😊

[@2netzkiee]

J.A. DC me too 😊

[@syuperseventeen]

OMG Same here, towards the end, I started to cry!

[@dellalovindra4159]

I know what u fell 😂

[@HelloHello-qb6bt]

J.A. DC exactly. naiyak ako sa huli 😍😍

[@AzzamAlfa]

i like this song and chemistry between Joy and Seulong was so cute!!

[@라엘박-q1n]

조이 음색 역사책에 남기자