Snuff, Subversion and Simulacra

[@TheCinemaCartography]

Skip the waitlist and invest in blue-chip art for the very first time by signing up for Masterworks: masterworks.art/cinema Purchase shares in great masterpieces from artists like Pablo Picasso, Banksy, Andy Warhol, and more. 🎨 See important Masterworks disclosures: masterworks.io/cd

[@vintheguy]

For anybody interested in Baudrillards work, you should also check out deluze and guy debord for other interesting views on art (though the later probably wouldn't like being put on a list of post modernists even if he had a lot of overlap with them in terms of philosophy)

[@sachimi_ggz]

mr Cinema Cartography, why are the tarantino essay comments closed? Are you throwing a rock and hiding the hand?

[@sinuos46]

@TheCinemaCartography I've been trying for the past weeks to find one of your videos, which had as the final quote "The greatest art pieces are not always grandiose but always transformative." but it was to no avail. Has it been taken down?

[@phat7711]

What is the song at 4:30 please??

[@MrButlertron12]

Incomplete Film List Snuff Our Hitler / Hitler: A Film from Germany (1977) The Killing of America (1981) Koyaanisqatsi (1982) Begotten (1989) The Act of Seeing with One's Own Eyes (1971) Man with a Movie Camera (1929) The Greatest Love of All Times (1979) Tie Xi Qu: West of the Tracks (2002) Subversion The Pillow Book (1996) Solaris (1972) Millennium Actress (2001) The Blood of a Poet (1930) Cries and Whispers (1972) The Phantom Carriage (1921) Mother Joan of the Angels (1961) Ritual (2000) Simulacra Blade Runner (1982) Lost Highway (1997) Seconds (1966) Fight Club (1999) Hardcore (1979) Holy Motors (2012) Videodrome (1983) Funny Games (2007)

[@hectorlagos8937]

thanx so much!

[@DogcrotchHell]

Im a PhD student who studies literature at an Ivy League school, and I have to say, this video essay could easily be a book better than the majority of whats out there on the academic market. My movie list just got many new additions, and I pride myself on seeking out films of like this. Excellent excellent work, this is what youtube should be for.

[@fviannaval]

Nice self promoting!

[@coltonc7832]

Academia is a sewer flowing into itself.

[@DogcrotchHell]

@@coltonc7832 I could not agree more

[@coltonc7832]

@@DogcrotchHell Regardless, it's nice that you're finishing up a PhD in literature. I hope the classes are good at least.

[@DogcrotchHell]

@@coltonc7832 Thank you! Part of it Is enjoyable really, I like having time to read and think, but I am not even considering a career in the field, it gets worse every year.

[@samuelcarvajal5180]

WE NEED THE FILM LIST... PLEASEEE

[@Apathesis0]

It seriously needs to be added to the description.

[@rightonrightonrighton]

This has been asked so many times and they just dont listen lol

[@liltick102]

The one’s mentioned: Our hitler: a film from Germany The killing of America The act of seeing with one’s eyes Begotton Decaysia Koyaanisqatsi Man with a movie camera Tie Xi Qu: West of the Tracks The pillow book Paprika The blood of a poet A phantom Carriage Mother Joan Of The Angels Ritual (2000) Seconds (Frankenheimer) Harkor Solaris Holy Motors La Jetée Videodrome Funny Games Begotten Most are uploaded to yt Comment a time-stamp for one of the unmentioned films in the intro - There are only 2 or 3 I didn’t know, so I can prob help out w what ur tryna find aside from the stuff after the ad read.. off top I know I know Vivre Sa Vie, and Persona were among them. ✌🏻cheers

[@Luke-637]

@@liltick102 Do you know the films shown at 0:18 and 1:16?

[@liltick102]

@@Luke-637 I really would like to know the one at 0:18 as well - one of the few I didn’t recognize unfortunately.. 1:16 is Vivre Sa Vie by Jean Luc Godard - That frame is of Anna Karina

[@liltick102]

Such a great channel. Seriously, thank you both so much for inspiring me, and overall being a major part of myself suddenly falling absolutely mad in love with cinema from all angles- as well as psychologically with your insight. This is the most valuable channel on yt to me by far. Love you Cinema Cartography🙌🏻

[@whiteydiamond]

This video is important to anyone interested in film study and creation. Absolutely inspiring, love your channel.

[@VM-hl8ms]

more like, important to anyone watching anything.

[@kennynealtube]

Your videos are so informative and make me want to seek out the sources, *please* consider adding identifying information on screen or adding a list in the description so we can be sure we know what films you are referencing.

[@BrianShh]

They add the title of the film in their chapters of the video, you can also find it in their description if you select show more

[@kennynealtube]

@@BrianShh The chapters have titles, but it does not list the names of the films being discussed. Not sure where you are seeing film titles.

[@zrtsgertzogi2394]

I completely agree on adding the film name while playing the clips. The CC doesn't even help...

[@BrianShh]

@@kennynealtube yeah I realized that after I had commented, I’m not one to delete comments so I figured I’ll just look like a fool on this one

[@shakifnadeem]

Wow men u enabled comment section ❤️ , such a great hand picked channel in KZbin which truly very passionately expressing , & spreading the love for cinema & trying deeply exploring its nuances. Helpful for many cinema learners, goers etc .

[@thekingofsting9929]

The greatest cinema channel, always engrossing

[@shawnsatrinarodriguez4429]

💯💯💯

[@no_problem8023]

This channel consistently puts out the greatest video essays on cinema to ever be on this platform.

[@mattjames7386]

I consider myself passionate about cinema, but I'm willing to admit some of the themes, concepts and even the films themselves you discuss are often things I've never even encountered before. Nonetheless, I am never less than fascinated by your videos. Thank you.

[@marblemilk1065]

@@Ninefiftysix 2:17 is meshes of the afternoon, 2:30 is killer of sheep, 1:21 is perfect blue, and 0:25 is Eraserhead. I didn't recognize any of the others, but I hope this helps

[@botbot3698]

@@marblemilk1065 it's Paprika not Perfect Blue

[@marblemilk1065]

@@botbot3698 oh, my bad

[@screentrader2069]

Here's a list of some films from Introduction: On the Silver Globe (1988), To Sleep So as to Dream (1986), Vivre sa vie (1962), Throw Away Your Books, Rally in the Streets ( 1971), Opening Night (1977), The Double Life of Veronique (1991), Branded to Kill (probably, not really sure). Unfortunately, I didn't find the movie with red tunnel. Note: I missed Nosferatu, Eraserhead, Oldboy, Band of Outsiders (1964), La chinoise (1967), Meshes of the Afternoon (1946), Chungking Express (I believe it was it) and Suspiria (1977) since some of them are well known or set after news collage. Also I didn't include some films so you would search them manually. Hope I was of some help

[@NikiWonoto26]

I'm from Indonesia. Thank you very much for such deep, thoughtful, & introspective analysis into the cinema artworks. I myself am a huge cinema lover/fans, especially the artistic & introspective ones. I'm really glad I've finally be able to find your channel.

[@TheKingWhoWins]

Thank you for what you do. This is a fantastic channel. Please keep uploading

[@Chkhitoooo]

It's just me or watching the Cinema Cartography videos feels like meditation? 💫

[@barsdaghan4296]

I love the ''avant-garde'' presentation style of this channel.

[@daenerystargaryen]

Why not include film list?

[@dylanyanes]

gatekeeping tf outta these

[@tiagogarcia50]

No locked comments means i can finally say how much i love this channel, dying on the internet is engraved in my mind

[@Damien-og6sk]

We now truly live in the world Jean Baudrillard warned us about fifty years ago.

[@SOFIA_RETA]

gorgeous essay with excellent citations, ideas, and insight. thank you!

[@ganazby]

Brilliant and perceptive essay. Thank you!

[@pluvio7208]

Thank you for your existence Cinema Cartography❣️much love from Kyrgyzstan ❣️

[@adriannademadriguera4859]

this channel deserves an honorary academy award and an honorary bafta. a must for every cinema lover and admirer. just perfect! thank you to all involved. happy holidays.

[@Athul487]

🤓

[@johnmars5282]

Finally Syberberg is getting the recognition he deserves , that movie is a surreal masterpiece, it really shakes you.

[@Endimione17]

Simulacra theme is embedded in Baudrillard's philosophy... check his work about Saussure's anagrams, last chapter of Symbolic Exchange and Death to really understand that

[@cheesewizz_]

I’m glad we got to discuss West of the Tracks more

[@Jimmy1982Playlists]

Getting a notification of a new video from Cinema Cartography and seeing _Lost Highway_ in the thumbnail... 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰 priceless! One of the greatest channels in all of KZbin history.

[@thadtuiol1717]

One of the most pretentious, more like.

[@hammerhead6179]

This is just beautiful

[@GrandmaRose9000]

Why do you have comments disabled on your older videos?

[@emanuel_soundtrack]

probably a communist?

[@soysos.tuffsound]

I Love Your Works

[@Dondillilochevrolet]

So thankful for you guys who make this channel 💗

[@willefibe]

Great video. 4 reading tips: Philosophy and the Moving Image - Noel Carroll; Postmodernism, or, The Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism - Fredric Jameson; A Poetics of Postmodernism: History, Theory, Fiction - Linda Hutcheon and Simulacra and Simulation - Jean Baudrillard.

[@framemover7462]

Please add subtitles, the auto-generated ones are wayyy off

[@RallyTheTally]

I love your videos, and I love the films you reccomend, really gives you a whole lot of films to try out, some you may like, others maybe not.

[@brayanjose2591]

Beautiful video

[@EndingSimple]

I have these "losing the meaning of meaning" moments in my life. This vid just gave me another one. At least I can point to it and say that's what it is.

[@kent-ud9zu]

for anybody wondering, i believe günter brus’ Self Mutilation (1965) is also mentioned in the “snuff” section.

[@shiponeunus2915]

can someone list all of the films featured in this video, much appreciated 🙏

[@58christiansful]

Superb channel.

[@paxwallace8324]

Well what assisted much new wave cinema as well as those who were directly influenced by it like Hal Hartley was a certain lightness. The dance scene of a Band Apart and again in Hal Hartley's Simple Men.

[@ARYANSHARMA-xm2rn]

Thanks man

[@pluvio7208]

Film list please❣️

[@thefebo8987]

Film list?

[@pasqualerusso6183]

I LOVE THIS CHANNEL SO MUCH YOU ARE DOING GOD'S WORK AND I DON'T EVEN BELIVE I GOD

[@experi-mentalproductions5358]

Why don't you enable the comments on your older videos?

[@eggycat]

Is there any chance you could label the films being shown? It would really help for further exploration. 🙂

[@kinemaaa]

Please, don't turn off comments on earlier videos

[@NikiWonoto26]

agree

[@cunkboy]

do y’all ever plan on releasing a full list of films featured in this?

[@liltick102]

I commented it a month ago

[@BigShippy0]

Dude pls add a movie list, especially for the ones in the intro. Also if anyone knows the one at 0:18, pls do tell.

[@FayAlexGG]

The trifecta of entertainment

[@lennardschneider9838]

Anyone know the movie at 00:18 ?

[@antonioHR23]

what film is at 0:18

[@ShaneFalko]

Thank you for these truly beautifully crafted videos. I’m always exposed to art I would never otherwise see, and admire your impeccable taste.

[@kevindonjuan1996]

somebody reply to this so I get a notification once the film list is posted. thanks!

[@ethanrees9895]

Anybody know the film at 1:16 by any chance, literally screenshotted it and put it in to google lens and still nothing lol

[@phat7711]

What is the song being played at time mark 4:30 please just after the sponsorship.

[@liltick102]

List of films mentioned: Our hitler: a film from Germany The killing of America The act of seeing with one’s eyes Begotton Decaysia Koyaanisqatsi Man with a movie camera Tie Xi Qu: West of the Tracks The pillow book Paprika The blood of a poet A phantom Carriage Mother Joan Of The Angels Ritual (2000) Seconds (Frankenheimer) Harkor Solaris Holy Motors La Jetée Videodrome Funny Games

[@TheSoCalledZoner1]

whats that tall lady walking through what appears to be carnival tents animation called

[@TheLAMPSY]

In what world was the french new wave a push against formalism? As stated in the video, the movement completely revolutionised film form, it's leading auteurs were primarily preoccupied with form, not "stories". How could it then be non-formalist?

[@jeezusbeezus]

I love you

[@joeysands8893]

What was that very first clip from? I wanted to rewatch that film but can’t remember what it is

[@venusejakokluk]

it´s from a movie called On the Silver Globe by Andrzej Zulawski.

[@alishkaBey]

❤❤❤

[@wasowskifilms8843]

Can somebody add subtitles to this, as always its difficult to understand her.

[@tiagogarcia50]

wdym? just turn closed captions on?

[@PoorEdward]

@@tiagogarcia50 half of them are unintelligible, hence the ironic need for captions

[@sorryabouthat]

I thought I was the only one having trouble understanding her

[@tiagogarcia50]

@@PoorEdward rewatched with cc and I can see it gets confusing sometimes, i found i could fill in the blanks but i understand how others might have trouble. on names especially it gets iffy

[@thadtuiol1717]

It's clearly some kind of Chinese woman trying to speak fancy student English with an AMerican acquired twang. It bugs mightily.

[@zodiarkblack]

cool

[@Endimione17]

well this approach is highly driven by Film-Studies perspective. It's quiet interesting but in this way films have lost their plurality, their own inner rhizomatic de-territorialization

[@tomja6909]

What movie is this at 1:11

[@meppeatsch5518]

Dolls from 2002

[@shimmyfix9315]

¿Por qué no Alejandro Jodorowsky?

[@mad_s6035]

do you have a letterboxd i can follow?

[@willefibe]

Hey, do you know Coffin Joe? Please, watch brazilian horror movies. Suggestions: At Midnight I'll Take Your Soul (1964) / Skull: The Mask (2020) / Friendly Beast (2017) / Good Manners (2017) / All The Dead Ones (2020) / The Nightshifter (2018) / The Devil Lives Here (2015) / The Cannibal Club (2018) / The Yellow Night (2019). They are great movies.

[@zazen108]

(I want to quote the woman in this video. What is her name?

[@asdretdghjhfgj]

Ok when are we gonna talk about Deleuze

[@Leakost]

0:18 what movie is it? 0:29 what movie is it?

[@Sherlock9827]

Also, does anyone know what was the first movie shown in the video?

[@k_nimrod]

0:29 is Throw Away Your Books, Rally in The Streets

[@Leakost]

@@Sherlock9827 I also want to know that

[@Leakost]

@@k_nimrod thanks, hero without cape!

[@dhis2527]

@@Sherlock9827 Na srebrnym globie (On the Silver Globe)

[@hmmm4094]

top

[@BrianShh]

It’s nice to see my critique of postmodernism shown on a channel that I respect

[@akhilnair1137]

I wish I was smart enough to understand this video.

[@thefebo8987]

Read some baudrillard

[@thadtuiol1717]

@@thefebo8987 Or, alternatively, don't bother with either Baudrillard or this pretentious YT channel and go outside instead and get some exercise.

[@thefebo8987]

You should do the Same ;)

[@speeksasfada]

Snuff bands ah

[@Max-ru4lp]

This channel is my zenith of cinema, I love it

[@polymorphic59]

The death of the canon and tradition will signal the death of Art and the birth of Creativity

[@speeksasfada]

Such a

[@heysolifehow3359]

Movie 0:58

[@sirondium]

Great video to shave my balls to. Much love.

[@Anicius_]

Put age warnings on your videos

[@whiteydiamond]

Don't be a pussboy

[@Anicius_]

@@whiteydiamond kids can find these shut up

[@thefebo8987]

Can you do a Retrospecive on Carl Theodor Dreyer?

[@burgerbanger420]

Great vid! I’ve seen like 90% of these images, does anyone else feel a bit disturb by there choices in movies?? 😂

[@seravi]

Disliked "The Cinematography That Changed Cinema"

[@gibsonbonifacio]

stop gatekeeping the films and name the titles, geez

[@jamesongogoleczko5932]

they always include the film names so idk how they're gate keeping..

[@daenerystargaryen]

Yeah, but if they tell you the names you would be able to know them and see them so how would she be able to feel superior and special?

[@PrinceF555]

Someone made a list of the films in this video on letterboxd. I tried posting it in the comment section but it gets deleted by them. The list's name is the same as the title of this video.

[@daenerystargaryen]

@@PrinceF555 I've managed to find it! Thank you! The name of the list is The Cinema Cartography: “Snuff, Subversion and Simulacra” But it's not complete.... Many movies are missing

[@anantgopal]

:)

[@generalportkoff4106]

This thumbnail is misleading, I thought I will see a video about David Lynch’s ‘Lost Highway’. So please replace it with something else.

[@whiteydiamond]

Lol it's in the video dummy

[@generalportkoff4106]

@@whiteydiamond yeah but it’s definitely not the main subject

[@gladness7871]

Hello, it would be cool if you made video of Bergman "Persona"

[@mathewhemmens8865]

what movie is 0:21?