~ So Close ~ Lucy/Caspian

[@GuardianOfMusic27855]

My sister is a hardcore Suspian shipper, and I just don't have the heart to tell her how much I love Lucian

[@GuardianOfMusic27855]

+SmithyLovesCreepypasta our dad read them to her when she was really young, but that's it. I've read them over at least three times.

[@allison3852]

@@GuardianOfMusic27855 same / i liked him and susan together / what if ben and anna dating / he marries liliandil

[@SeddieTheRealDeal]

This actually got me crying. Especially the end. OMG I love Lucian. I've loved them from to very first time I read the book when I was young child. There WAS Lucian undertones in the book. But alas they don't get together. I do love & ship Caspian & Ramandu's Daughter also which is Canon, but I can't help still loving Lucian more. It's the whole feeling of what could & I believe should have been that makes my heart hurt about them. I still believe that Old Caspian in TSC wasn't just wanting to get back to the edge of the earth to find Aslan for help finding his son. I think it was also because he was pinning for Lucy (It being the last place he saw her) I mean think about it. When he made it to Aslan after he died he asked Aslan if he could come to this world. It wasn't just because he wanted to see it. I think Aslan knew what his real motive was and because it wasn't Aslan's will, he only let Caspian go there long enough to help Eustace & Jill out with their mean classmates, not to go seek out Lucy. *Sigh* Oh well. I wish they'd hurry up and make The Silver Chair already.

[@LinneaSandqvist-f88]

"Hello, Lucy, here I come, now old and ugly, to you, still young and beautiful. I have to ask you for help to find my son by another woman." Emberassing. Poor Caspian!

[@electricaubry4959]

SeddieTheRealDeal we have been waiting too long

[@hcnxy_dxisy1719]

- claps - couldn't have said it better.

[@hannahkingery7284]

Me the entire time: Ben... Ben Barnes... You're too attractive. Stahp it Ben. Stahp.

[@bugger238]

Frrrrrr

[@Jazilou]

this still makes me cry. i cannot count the times i have watched it, but every single time it brings tears to my eyes. Beautifully done. :)

[@sailormoon615]

I know that Caspian was infatuated with Susan, but I like Lucy/Caspian better. Thank you so much for this video!!!

[@serethsereth4143]

2019 = still crying.

[@Isbluevilla]

2021

[@Lim0ncell0]

@@Isbluevilla yessssssssss

[@_.nahaa_]

2023 + 😭👍

[@Isaalent]

When she close the door 😩😩💪🏻

[@Jazilou]

I discovered this video like a year and a half ago, and it still one of my favorite videos on youtube. I adore the storyline and the way that you set up the video. This is the video that made me join the Lucy X Caspian ship. Thank you so much for making it, please don't ever ever take it down. :)

[@hannahkingery7284]

I have commented this before, but at 1:38 when it's like "And look how far we've come.", I love how you just smack me in the face with how far they HAVE come.

[@ayukanmuri501]

This video is awesome! I really like how you connected every parts and turn it in a beautiful and magnificent vid like this. My favorite part was 1:30-1:42.. "And look how far we've come.." I kinda feel nostalgic at that time. I missed Peter and Susan, and when I remembered Prince Caspian Movie, I realized that that is also the time when Caspian is infatuated to Susan.. Those are the times that I wished that it is Lucy/Caspian instead. And thanks because you made my wish came true! Thumbs up! :D

[@xXSkyCrystalXx]

I didn't even know this was a thing lol. Never did I think about Lucy and Caspian together, but now I kinda see it?

[@courttv89]

I love this so much! Good choice in song too, Lucian is awesome!

[@lidiawojnarowska2338]

Me encanta esta PELÍCULA es tan maravillosa.

[@slytheraine]

i cried at the end :(

[@LadyLirenel]

I'm glad you liked it; I find the song itself very emotional.

[@LadyLirenel]

I'm glad you liked the video! And I agree, watching the Caspian/Susan parts of PC just makes me sad anymore.

[@LucyHelenPevensie]

This is really really sweet. I don't typically ship this, but it was really sweet. :) Nice job!

[@LadyLirenel]

Well, that's kinda what I was going for. Glad you like it!

[@diamondgirl1654]

Wait, how the hell did it change from Susan and caspian from Lucy to caspian?

[@fauvestan5924]

I have no idea.

[@refsmithy]

Love the ship, love the song, love the video! (Love the VoDT movie too...)

[@brittanyshoemaker5225]

I love this song

[@TheDoRoBouNeko]

I kind of ship these two (Lucy and Caspian) through the movies. ^^; And I'm a more of a fanon shipper. XP Some canon couples are just not that interesting for me. XP

[@katilalo3039]

Same here! I prefer non-canon because canon ships are kinda lame lol

[@Jazilou]

OH. MY. GOSH!!! So in my head, Caspian is closer to his book-age, so this ship actually works without pedo problems. AND OH MY HECK DO I FREAKING LOVE IT?? YES I FREAKING DO! Am I going to create a nerd list of videos to watch when I am sad and have this video be the first one? YES I FREAKING AM!!! :D

[@LadyLirenel]

@courttv89 I'm a guilty Lucian shipper, indeed. Glad you liked the vid!

[@fauvestan5924]

THIS MADE ME CRY

[@joshuadesautels]

I'm getting more of a sibling-like vibe from watching this video.

[@LadyLirenel]

@Nanyz7 Glad you liked it! The pairing is my guilty ship, but for some reason I love making vids for it. =D

[@FairyFalls]

Another amazing video- WOW! Goodness, I love your videos so much! And the ending had me tearing up- I feel like a romance movie loser, haha! XD Great job, I love it!

[@Aline_Tesfaye]

My God!!! This is so nice and cute and lovely!!! :3

[@adventureswithkat3884]

Such a beautiful video. Thank you.

[@KimBellaCullen98]

I love how you did the ending.. Q_Q I cried

[@Kashamaire]

I love this ship.

[@lovetolovefairytales]

Not a big fan of the pairing in general, but I still enjoyed this video anyway. You did a good job on it. I liked the song as well. But...you didn't like the VDT movie? Really? I loved it. It's my favorite movie now and I'm stunned that there are quite a number of (sometimes down-right bitter)fans out there who didn't.

[@mindfreak0525]

beautiful

[@LadyLirenel]

I'm glad you liked the vid. Hmm, a nerd list, I may have to do that myself!

[@paramorita100]

oooooo my god this is amazin really really amazin i love ittt

[@instridewith_life]

This song always make me cry

[@refsmithy]

I agree completely except for one thing. Tom Baker played Puddleglum in Silver Chair and he is a brilliant actor (although Im also a Doctor Who fan, so maybe slightly biased

[@salomefonseka9660]

OMG you actually brought me to tears

[@_.nahaa_]

I came here after a very long time to see them and cry again 🥹💔

[@heatherdavis7782]

I loved it was really good you should make one for the voyage of the Dawn Treader

[@cheyennewilliams8489]

I love this movie of narina prince Caspian and Lucy together

[@LadyLirenel]

Well, that's what it's meant to do! Glad you liked the vid!

[@LadyLirenel]

@lovetolovefairytales Same here, the Silver Chair was the only one I watched all the way through, and thought it was pretty good considering. Will Poulter is great as well, I hope he gets to do the Silver Chair.

[@LadyLirenel]

@LillytheValiant I'm glad you liked it; the last scene is actually the one I think turned out the best too. Some of the middle I'm not too keen on. (And I agree, 'So Close' is one of the best romantic songs!) I'm actually a Caspian/Lilliandil fan, but when I was 7 I loved Lucian, and I haven't quite gotten over it. I'm glad you liked the vid anyway!

[@falsedmitry3372]

LadyLirenel please make SpongeBob Narnia Crossover.

[@courttv89]

@LadyLirenel Yeah I'm the same way. Years ago i used to dislike Ramandu's Daughter because I wanted Lucy to be with Caspian. It wasn't until Suspian happened and as I got older and understood how real love and commitment worked I started suppoting Caspian and Ramandu's daughter.

[@LadyLirenel]

Glad you liked it! (Though I can't say I believe the same about the VODT movie...)

[@LadyLirenel]

Thanks!

[@LadyLirenel]

@tessmarie333 Glad you liked it! I'm not as pleased with this vid as some of the others, but it was fun to get back to it.

[@courttv89]

@LadyLirenel Yeah it's very hard not to be lucian, especially seeing how close friends Ben Barnes and Georgie Henley are, they're so cute. And I always knew deep down Caspian cared about Lucy in the books, like the time when they were saying goodbye.

[@cocochanel2013]

Luv it!!

[@LadyLirenel]

I think I did the whole video just for the ending, so I'm glad you liked it!

[@kissmrule]

i so lvoe this vidoe it so cute and swet

[@alexiebrook9202]

Ben is so cute

[@LadyLirenel]

@LucyHelenPevensie I'm technically a Caspian/Ramandu's Daughter shipper myself, but I like to indulge myself in Lucian occasionally. I'm glad you liked the vid!

[@lovetolovefairytales]

@LadyLirenel Well, to be fair, the BBC did plenty of telling (way worse, in my opinon, than VDT's "My healing cordial and dagger!" ever was) and bad acting, and precious few of the fans complained about that, because it was considered "true to the book", but the movie takes a few creative liberties and everyone seems to just freak out. BTW: I loved PC, too, I saw it like six times in theaters, I just thought VDT had an even better story, and I liked how they gave Rhince a daughter.

[@fauvestan5924]

LUCIAN FOR LIFE

[@angelicamuniz467]

Fauve Stan for real

[@aythegiraffe76]

I like Susan and Caspian better to be honest

[@LadyLirenel]

@FairyFalls Considering I'm not much of a romance person, I enjoyed making this so I'm glad you liked it! The end was really what inspired the rest of it, so I'm particularly glad you liked it.

[@LadyLirenel]

@lovetolovefairytales It's the pairing that my seven-year old self fell in love with, and I haven't quite gotten over it yet. I'm glad you still liked the vid, though! I very much disliked the VODT movie. Not only was it a poor adaptation, which I was expected, but it was a badly made movie in general - it was all tell, not show, which is the opposite of what any good writer would tell you to do. I'm afraid I'm one of those bitter fans. =D

[@lovetolovefairytales]

@LadyLirenel I disagree. I think good writers need to do both showing AND telling, and I think VDT did a good job with balancing it out, all the more so as it was shorter than the first two films. I don't actually mind bitter fans per-say because everyone's allowed their own opinon, I just get mad when said bitter fans get upset with me because I love the movie. They act like I'm stupid for enjoying it and seem to just assume I've never read the books (even though I have, many times).

[@LadyLirenel]

@cyndercindy Glad you liked it!

[@LadyLirenel]

@Thistledown17 Glad you liked it!

[@LadyLirenel]

@ConzSis I'm glad you liked the vid!

[@LadyLirenel]

@paramorita100 Thanks, glad you liked it!

[@VeelouC]

I'm such a hardcore Luspian shipper I don't care. Guys it's better Luspian than Lucian because Lucian is aready a shipping name for Lucy and Ian from pll.

[@VeelouC]

***** #otp

[@LadyLirenel]

@courttv89 Yup, that's pretty much exactly what happened, though I started shipping Caspian/Ramandu's daughter slightly earlier just due to principle.

[@LadyLirenel]

@LillytheValiant Thanks, I like you too!

[@LadyLirenel]

@courttv89 Book!Caspian and book!Lucy are what made me a Lucian shipper originally. I always ship canon, so I now ship Caspian/Ramandu's Daughter, But the seven year old in me still loves Lucian.

[@carlosdwellerofalongname8958]

Bro, they have a more brother and sister relationship. Even Caspian makes it clear that he still has feelings for Susan, as well as stating that Lucy and Edmund are “the closest thing to family [he’s] ever had.”

[@LadyLirenel]

@lovetolovefairytales I couldn't watch the BBC version because the giant beavers seriously freaked me out. I will not defend them as good movies. I expected more out of VODT because of how good LWW and PC were - I felt VODT sank below them in script, though the acting was still excellent considering. I don't mind the liberties, either, thought I thought some of the changes could have been written better. Case in point, Gael was a good idea but they didn't do anything with her.

[@cernudaopip]

Lindura

[@LadyLirenel]

@lovetolovefairytales There's telling, and then there's cringe-worthy lines like "Oh look, my healing cordial and dagger!" and "You're being tempted!" If you have to say that instead of just showing it, something's wrong. However, I have no problem with people liking the movie - everyone's taste is different. And I liked the cinematography and Eustace, so there's that. It doesn't make one less of a book fan to like the movies! (I loved PC and a lot of fans hated that as well).

[@vivscanete9727]

caspian is mine period

[@idawik7126]

I konw why lusy been calld in narnia capian thiking all bot lusy when capian tuhtd that warter he missing lusy all it time

[@SeddieTheRealDeal]

I just realized I put "Edge of the Earth" on my last comment I meant "End of the world" They mean the same thing. Or I could put the "Utter east". as Reeps nursery rhyme called it.

[@lovetolovefairytales]

@LadyLirenel Gosh, I hated the giant beavers. The only BBC narnia movie I liked was silver chair. The girl they got to play Jill was actually a good actress unlike the rest of their cast. I hope walden media makes the silver chair someday, it would be nice to see Will Poulter return as Eustace in that.

[@caitlynford3001]

Y’all know Caspian and Susan aren’t even a thing in the books right? Lucy liking Caspian is canon. The whole Susan storyline was just made up for the movies.

[@nolongerselana3837]

This is just wrong

[@cernudaopip]

Me gusta

[@danielpalacios5479]

susan not lucy doom

[@cairatrait1333]

I do mine to share with you merrie together with us

[@mireyabrunamartin9881]

Me gusta quien ero la película 5 de narnia

[@cernudaopip]

Me gusta