So I got access to Minecraft: China Edition...

[@Fundy]

HELLO. VPN. GET HERE: nordvpn.com/fundy DO

[@PlyrNoob2890]

no

[@harold-ib4wd]

Ok

[@anjindinda9767]

im third

[@Carrot_pikmin]

Erm what the sigma

[@francisedwin5899]

Ty bbg

[@RevVoice2]

"How come WE don't have this?" -- because the cost of that is a Gatcha system, Rewarding systems, Predatory Coinage systems, a locked down ecosystem, a game that really doesn't seem to care about a reasonable gameplay loop in lieu of FOMO add-ons. If Minecraft looked like that I would have noped out a lonnnnnng time ago.

[@ugo7395]

yeah but, adding a few new bosses or animals really really wouldn't be unwelcome

[@wolfgunworld]

Yeah its better to have lazy devs who update the game twice a year than this right?

[@nolanbaker2360]

There's definitely some wiggle room between minecraft and chinacraft

[@love_life_leafeon5955]

Also super glitchy and janky

[@bananalegend194]

yeah i agree a lot of the features are weird and honestly just there for money but the built in mods go hard

[@cmlkevin6250]

as a Chinese person, I can confirm that basically everyone wants to escape from NetEase's version lol. there had been a lot of drama when Mojang decided to contract Minecraft China's operation to NetEase, and sure enough, now they created an abomination of pseudo-Minecraft mixed with shit tons of gacha. Many OG players fled to the international version (which can still be purchased and played in China without a VPN - albeit with a few additional steps), and the NetEase version continues to serve its role as a difficult reminder of the full destructive potential that profit-motivated Chinese game companies can do to a game that's not supposed to be monetized like this. With all that said, the player count for Minecraft China is undoubtedly massive, in part due to the addictiveness of daily rewards, events, and other gacha systems.

[@defnotthekgb8362]

I know I have heard from others that there also exists a large amount of people that will all but refuse to play games if they *dont* contain gatcha elements, how true is that?

[@demo2823]

The fact that they steal mods to sell for profit is just too much for me.

[@justseffstuff3308]

@@defnotthekgb8362That's called a "gambling addiction", sonny.

[@LichtL-ni3rl]

only upside is NetEase offers free Minecraft

[@cmlkevin6250]

@@defnotthekgb8362 Yes, this is a pervasive feature of the Chinese casual gaming culture. Gacha, while exploitative and scummy, is sadly extraordinarily fun as a mechanic. I have vivid experiences of sharing my best and worst pulls with friends. It's social gambling, and it's a danger beauty.

[@CRht6q]

Chinese people call the fox "My Burden" instead of "My companion" since it stops you from putting a block on a certain place lol

[@CRht6q]

also Chinese don't contain hardcore so the difficulties are peaceful to hard :D

[@Snuyybagel]

LMAOO

[@Striker427]

“我的祸伴"(My burden) sound extremely similar to the actual name of the fox "我的伙伴“ (My buddy) so yes

[@xiaoniaoawa]

and hit some redstone things so that fox will kill you lol

[@Sebastian-ir4ry]

对辣！

[@BierBart12]

This is such a monument to corporate horror Why do these monuments always have to look so good? I just hope these amazing artists get paid well, proportionally to the insane amount of microtransactions

[@STIMULAT10N]

Paid well? Maybe. Given enough time to rest to live a reasonably lengthed life? Probably not.

[@DccAnh]

@@STIMULAT10N China's average life expectency is pretty high, people who have actually work for Chinese company would know, the pay is very good if you have the skill to provide what they want, not to mention they pay foreign worker less than their own and yet it still higher than most western country pay you for the same amount of work.

[@Somethoughtz]

that does NOT look good

[@xp16b40]

(Translated from Chinese to English using deepL) Most people don't like the netease version of minecraft, so much so that we tend to play the international version of minecraft. The netease version of minecraft has a chat filter that is so harsh that normal greetings become ****, and the overly fancy user interface may be a novelty to you at first, but this causes a lot of performance issues Framerate drops (you even need to use one game launcher to start another game launcher), both in the launcher interface and in-game performance issues resulting in slightly lower framerates for international versions, most of the mods in the market are ported and restored by the creators of the content without the consent of the original authors, some of the fancy skins that you need to get by random draw, vanilla The game lags behind the international version of Minecraft by 1 or 2 years (now is 1.18 minecraft version), Netease does not think too much about the playing experience but rather how to make more money from Minecraft China edition.

[@Grimmatical]

does netease have permission from mojang to do this?

[@xp16b40]

Hey where did my reply just go, I refreshed the page then I couldn't see him it seems to have been deleted, well all I can tell you is yes they can highly customize the ops plan with the game code(e.x MCBEModAPI) and even pay2win game play, raffle trinkets and a very small portion of skins or dressups that are priced at 12USD (DeepL used)

[@hamakaze_1s]

@@Grimmatical actually they has

[@milo7519]

@@hamakaze_1s Goddamn.

[@jasonchiu272]

@@Grimmatical Since copyright laws are very loose between China and most Western countries, Mojang can't do much but allow Netease to gain the rights to Minecraft Chinese edition. So technically yes, Mojang did allow Netease to modify Chinese Minecraft, but also they have no power over what Netease puts in the game.

[@jasonchiu272]

This ain't microtransactions no more, this is macrotransactions.

[@catfwish]

To be fair, "macrotransaction" could apply to a lot of shit here, annoyingly. But yes, this tkes it even further.

[@darshinirawal7072]

🤓​@@catfwish

[@OhnoOhnoOhnoOhn]

​@@darshinirawal7072 🤡

[@Strife-yt]

More like megatransations

[@OhnoOhnoOhnoOhn]

🤡 ​@@darshinirawal7072

[@PhoenixSC]

Lol I can't believe you got it to work.

[@Funfactsguy555]

phoenix here!

[@bananalegend194]

so when you modding the entirety of chinese minecraft into java edition?

[@tyunu]

Hi peenixSC!!r

[@Funfactsguy555]

@@Its.a.me.wavey_ hes 15 now

[@Fundy]

Ironically because of our video on your channel

[@lairdwightman5133]

Seeing an error code that just says ERR_CHINA_NO is so funny and I dont know why

[@TruthKeepersOfficialHD2]

China What did we even expect 😂

[@xX_Berrie_Black_Xx]

timecode?

[@lairdwightman5133]

@ 2:59

[@lightning_11]

Minecraft Java: You can do anything by writing mods in Java Minecraft China: You can do anything by spending money on microtransactions

[@epicminigum]

Old Chinese Minecraft wasn’t like this, but after it added diamond currency I quit it and here Java or bedrock

[@netherwarrior6113]

Bedrock players in the corner: (I play Bedrock)

[@lolliii5477]

correction: You can't do anything other than spending money on macrotransactions yes, i said *macro*transaction.

[@DccAnh]

@@lolliii5477 You can still play vanilla Minecraft, the pay stuff are mostly just mods, custom game mode and cosmetic.

[@limon430]

What a wild experience. Its not Minecraft anymore... its Minecraft-ish game.

[@Binqiling]

Cause it has chinese aspects?

[@durratulaishah3703]

​@@Binqilingno, it's because of gacha system like any world exploration gacha games.

[@JakeEqualzGroove]

The UIs is like Blockman GO

[@a_random_confused_person7703]

@@Binqiling don't try to twist it into racism.

[@TheeSirRandom]

@@Binqiling My guy what? ARE YOU BLIND LOOK AT IT

[@Miya_1218]

As a Chinese person, I can tell you that not many Chinese Minecraft players like these changes, it's really only the little kids that love playing the additional features. Most players are really unhappy with NetEase changing the game, because they are adding too many features that just makes it less ...Minecraft. For most players, like me, they would rather use a VPN to play the java or bedrock version.

[@yanshuomei]

agreeeeeeeee!

[@emioutt5071]

⁠@@troy7467 Bonus Army Riot of 1932

[@FukaiKokoro]

The uyhgur people

[@FukaiKokoro]

Are you in China? How you using the Internet? Alot of people go missing after using vpn

[@enamishalive]

and the actual vanilla mc is always 2+ years behind on updates, i think we're still on 1.17 lol- or maybe not, its been a while since i touched it

[@HdtvDan]

Chinas Minecraft is overwhelming, I prefer the ordinary one tbh

[@kayco9188]

-_- dummy

[@FodaseNaoLigo]

Bot

[@looptypoop]

I haven't played since 2012 and normal Minecraft is overwhelming

[@lolliii5477]

@@looptypoop please never update the game good sir.

[@ForksAreGoated]

@@FodaseNaoLigo im from china and tbh nobody likes chinese minecraft.

[@thepbrit]

I'll be honest, most of this seems like existing mods that were stolen and turned into an uber predatory gatcha, I'm glad the global version isnt like this

[@somerandomgirl6093]

It looks like the bastard baby between bedrock edition and genshin impact 😅

[@Humanoiddecoy]

Yes, and they all require payment

[@zinuo_539]

Though I am a chinese I still want to say,China people's awareness of copyright still has a long way to go.

[@somerandomgirl6093]

@@zinuo_539 The Chinesse's awareness of copyright is a meme 😅

[@giorgospapoutsakis5271]

Don't care

[@SimplyANugget]

This video is a mix of "Why don't we have this" and "I'm glad we don't have this"

[@xiaoniaoawa]

True, we Chinese player also want escape the NetEase version (China version)

[@ScriptSuper-vc9ku]

both benefits and weakness.. aha

[@BasilBeesLair]

Schrödinger's Minecraft

[@lolliii5477]

@@xiaoniaoawa suddenly, the game policy set by karens all the way to government officials. (over half the playerbase disintegrates btw)

[@StellarDrag0n]

Agree Tbh it doesn’t feel like MC,just a cheap copypaste

[@ultrio325]

From what I've heard, Minecraft China Edition is basically Minecraft if it was twice as predatory as Roblox

[@Binqiling]

How?, this "chinacraft" doesnt include having gamepasses, only cosmetics

[@walnutguybutcool]

​@@BinqilingI dunno man, gatcha mechanics are 3x as preditory as a battlepass.

[@ArcticArmy]

things on roblox are controlled by the specific game's creators, but yeah, there are lots of games that are colourful and brain rot-y targetted towards children just to get them to spend as much robux as possible

[@N0AHOfficial]

@@ArcticArmyi agree, not all games are trying to get money from naive kids. and its the developers fault that roblox is seen as predatory.

[@EditorBall_Brother]

Well honestly most Chinese games are like this if you've ever played them 😅

[@OWEN-cb1tq]

Fundy you are a real one for staying so positive through that entire experience and actually wasting money on a version of a game you’re probably never gonna play again.

[@GDColon]

Congrats on getting your hands on this, I've always been told that Chinese Minecraft is crazy but I never knew they took it THIS far. It just feels like an alternate universe version of Bedrock where they kept feature creeping until literally EVERYTHING had a premium skin. You lost me at the cosmetic footsteps

[@suspicioussand]

holy hell geometry dash fox guy watches minecraft fox guy :o

[@Xedronic]

holy crap colon OUTSIDE OF GD CONTENT?!?! IMPOSSIBLE!! ILLEGAL!!!!!

[@fishytheanimator]

I do love Gd Cologne.

[@nextgeneration6898]

GD COLONGE!!

[@CoraCreates]

Oh hi Foxtuber #2

[@DaPopeOfDope101]

How is this simultaneously 10 times better and 10 times worse than our Minecraft

[@pegfingers]

how is this better in any shape or form

[@DaPopeOfDope101]

@@pegfingers did you not pay attention to the plethora of new features it had to offer? I understand the micro transaction aspect is bad but you have to admit some of the features are just plain cool

[@lookitsash5765]

@@DaPopeOfDope101 ever heard of minecraft bedrock marketplace?

[@footl0se]

​@@DaPopeOfDope101All these features look terrible and don't fit the game imo

[@pegfingers]

@@DaPopeOfDope101 the art is awful, it's lazy, it's a money grab, and by the looks of it the gameplay is terrible

[@Syuvinya]

As a chinese person who never plays chinese games, I can confidently say that most chinese gamers hate the chinese version of minecraft. They used to have access to minecraft bedrock on mobile before foreign media became more strictly regulated and netease, one of the biggest entertainment companies in china became minecraft's publishing agent.

[@fungusamongus69420]

Not just Minecraft, other games as well. For example the Chinese actively boycotted the Chinese edition of Warthunder because it was ran by Tencent and sucks ass.

[@LilyPillow]

Yes. We all tend to hate how overly fancy they are and pop-up ads about features all over the game. When you go to the 我的世界 reviews you can see a lot of people saying they wish they had access to the foreign Minecraft

[@FukaiKokoro]

How are you on KZbin? Vpns can get you arrested

[@Syuvinya]

@@FukaiKokoro I'm in hong kong. When I'm in mainland, I use VPN. It's technically illegal but it's barely enforced.

[@NaraSherko]

You have luobu?

[@JesseMinecraftXD]

Stupid mod suggestion: Survival minecraft, but every time a creeper explodes the next one's explosion becomes a bit stronger than the last. Permanently.

[@senkothefox]

5:48 "it is free on java but to get the same mod in China you have to buy it" Have you ever heard of Minecraft bedrock marketplace?

[@Metroid22540]

Remember, damn-near any mod made for Java Edition is free to download and play. A lot of mods for Bedrock (C++) are stuck on the marketplace and that's where it costs money.

[@pom1489]

doesn't seem like the creators are getting any revenue from the chinese version though

[@economy-incorporated]

It's worse there though, at least the minecraft marketplace had UNIQUE mods that weren't on java

[@unaihmg9352]

​Why do you think that@@pom1489

[@WRYYYYYYYY0629]

@@economy-incorporated Minecrafrt marketplace also has mods that are in java. Which forces you to pay for it.

[@Dawncomer_K]

I’ve never thought that fundy would actually play this!! Well I have to say that living in China mainland myself, Chinese version of minecraft is the starting point of many of us because we don’t easily have access to the international version, but once we get to know the game itself the only thing we do is to escape lol And the system of it is quite complex which easily undermines the value of minecraft itself. It still has a large player base for some people actually enjoys the gacha system and rewands and so on, but yes if anyone really wants to play the game itself, old players will just tell them to run.

[@siewmingwong4510]

If anyone is wondering at 11:34 they are actually saying di li xue (geography in mandarin) and not just a butchered "delicious"

[@Garfield_Minecraft]

Lol it does sounded like "delicious" 地理 means land 学 is study study of land is geography. Well what about cookie part? Lol and why the audio is so glitchy. Gege gege geography cookie cookie 地理学

[@Andypsl8]

地理学 dì lǐ xué🗺️

[@Humanoiddecoy]

Yes, it does refer to geography😂,But its pun in English sounds like delicious.

[@SparkySharky]

Seeing all those different in game currencies I just PRAY Hytale doesn’t have that.

[@whateverIwasthinkingatthetime]

Hytale wont exist

[@Knarfy]

I heard about this version ages ago and it fascinated me, but I never knew how actually insane it was 😅 this is wild

[@TheHolyBrick345]

Yo knarfy love your vids you should definitely cover this

[@alicelee4113]

like number 69 (also love ur vids Knarfy see if you can get a hold of it and play on it it might make good content ;) )

[@CrystalFier]

Ayy it's a Knarfy! 💜

[@CrystalFier]

Next on your channel, Breaking Chinese Minecraft With Your Dumb Ideas!

[@TerryAzarja]

Knifers

[@charmer2087]

The reason why there's so many things such as minigames, events, forums, marketplaces, customization, etc. on Chinese Minecraft is because Chinese apps are designed in a way so that you do not need the support of any western apps, Chinese companies want you to use their apps and their apps only, this allows companies in China have massive monopolies over certain areas of the internet.

[@remor698]

So these apps are basically designed to generate a sunk cost effect to keep the money only going to that app's owner? Almost impressive how dystopian that mentality being a standard anywhere sounds.

[@jasonstormsong4940]

So basically Apple, MS, and Google?

[@yomama9390]

@@jasonstormsong4940 how do you say something so incorrect

[@埊]

so basically, a forum, a wikipedia, a game and avatar creation in 1 place?

[@TheSultan1470]

​@@remor698 No?

[@rankii_hats]

For the first time im happy minecraft didnt get reduced to... this.

[@flamingpaxtsc]

There are other times where you HAVEN’T been happy that Minecraft isn’t like this? Have you not seen the bedrock marketplace?

[@atxm1c45]

Compared to bedrock, it is still that bad

[@teddyarden9710]

​@@flamingpaxtsc bro at least the bedrock marketplace has less micro transactions and pay walled content and overall isn't a scummy and shady spyware of an app/service.

[@ThugSheep]

Imagine if EA made chinese minecraft , there would be ads on the pc version , and a 25% slower fps and 50% slower world generation , hidden behind a battle pass 😂

[@MrWhatWhy]

The bedrock marketplace is fine, albeit there is​ a lot of crap content on there @@flamingpaxtsc

[@omegalegend77]

International Minecraft: noooooo, we can only add one mob to each update! Chinese Minecraft: you want godzilla? sure.

[@Monkeymario.]

Modders: Lemme fix that.

[@LightBulb1k]

Wow that’s a lot of information for 30 seconds in.

[@Fundy]

brain learn big

[@Ironyum99]

@@Fundyheart my comment thanks

[@PlyrNoob2890]

​@@Fundy lol

[@francisedwin5899]

​@@Fundy big brain

[@Monarch_memeory134]

Super big brain

[@shiyishunya_testing]

As a Hongkonger, I have been played Minecraft Chinese version when I was 6. I can said that most of the Chinese player hate Minecraft Chinese version. They mentioned that the game is very laggy, single player need WiFi to play it, the pet fox in the game is annoying, the updates always delay. Therefore, they hate it. And I hate it too! As a result, I play Minecraft bedrock when I was 13. And now I'm 14.

[@sazam974]

wait in hong kong ur allowed to have youtube?

[@whatwhat3315]

​@@sazam974apps like yt instagram and such isnt blocked in hong kong, its just mainland china

[@cyruslam0831]

​@@sazam974Yes, at least for now :)

[@Olimarfrompikmin]

Yo do you play PvZ 2 Chinese

[@aegeangaming8280]

​@@sazam974hk from what I hear is like western countries due to being a British colony at one point

[@codiecola3636]

Minecraft Bedrock edition, but somehow even more predatory.

[@great-wyrmII]

Exponentially

[@skylarduckky3389]

Astronomically

[@suspicioussand]

Cosmically

[@daBeanie98]

Universally

[@aryaman5516]

Universally

[@viablue8143]

I feel the need to comment about this despite not having finishes the video yet. Although I haven’t played this version of MC I do play a few games that are heavy on the gacha (mostly hoyoverse games). And let me tell you, while gacha games look vibrant, colourful and attractive at first, they aren’t all that cheerful underneath it all, especially not long-term. They’re based on addiction, FOMO, resource management and a need to “fit in” / be at least equally as cool as others. I don’t know how exactly gacha mc works, but based on my experience with other gacha games, there are probably daily chores to take care of that reward a minimal amount of currency you can use to gamble, but ultimately it isn’t enough to guarantee you get what you want, and there’s probably at least a 50/50 to lose as well as a pity system with non f2p friendly amounts of gold / rare pity. To non-gacha players, this means that you have to log in every single day (whether you want to or not) to get some amount of currency that you can use to roll the gacha and have a chance to get the item you want. A chance, that gradually gets higher and, say, guarantees a gold drop on 90 pulls (that seems to be the magic number), which may or may not be what you wanted with a, say, 50% chance for each outcome. This means that you get to grind the game daily and\or spend a bunch of money with the very realistic chance of not even getting what you wanted, and no refunds given if you lost. You just gotta grind and spend more! (That’s why it’s so essential to do your dailies - even skipping a few days feels like a pretty large hit to your account.) Top that off with time-limited and often time-gates events and you have the perfect recipe to create FOMO = the fear of missing out, and create a playerbase that logs in every day because they’re afraid that they’ll lose out on getting what they want if they take a break. Don’t get me wrong, these games can be wildly entertaining long-term too - I enjoy my gacha games very much. But the thing is, these are dangerous games, because it’s MUCH easier to develop unhealthy tendencies in them than a regular game. It can ruin your experience of playing the game and take it from, well, a game, to a daily chore and something you literally need to budget for, like irl. You need to keep a clear head not to fall into unhealthy, toxic habits in these games. And many do fall there, they provide the basis and constant income so all these new, flashy and inviting things can be added to lure in the next unsuspecting victim, i mean player. So while you look at this game and think “man, why don’t WE have that? :(“ remember the cost of those features, and all the things you get to have (having a relaxing experience in the game, controlling the content in your game and getting exactly what you’ve purchased, not feeling any pressure to play and having the ability to take breaks from the game whenever you feel like it, and log in as frequently or infrequently as you want without any consequence or difference, not having to budget, having access to free mods…) in exchange for having a more “boring” and less colourful version of minecraft.

[@user-bm3it9nm1k]

imagine playing MINECRAFT and saying ''yo hop on the sims mode for the daily missions'' unironically

[@EEEEEEEE]

E

[@NR.gamer241]

​@@EEEEEEEEN

[@missblank3887]

​@@NR.gamer241O

[@rexcap1124]

Hi, Former Hong Kong citizen here, Minecraft is actually available for purchase on microsoft or app store just like other countries, so all this is not needed, however, main land China would have to do all that. Very cool video, ive never gotten the chinese verion.

[@Seagullsfilms.production]

Hi i am also from hk

[@fuxkag3908]

I heard HK got taken over by China now

[@Ponera-Sama]

Wait, do you mean regular Minecraft is available on Microsoft or Chinese Minecraft

[@rexcap1124]

@@Ponera-Sama regular minecraft is available on mincrosoft, however a few years back i purchased miencraft from mojang website.

[@ebc6970]

​@@Ponera-Sama Regular one. They meant that people in Mainland China has to do complicated stuff to get the regular one. They previously lived in HK, so they could purchase the regular minecraft like other countries.

[@Bionic]

the "M" in Chinese Minecraft stands for microtransactions 💀

[@higztv1166]

microtransactionsinecraft

[@ahmedsafar1390]

💀💀

[@Willio20000]

It was an H tho the M is for Minecraft bedrock

[@paws94]

YOO HI BONC

[@AsclepiusorAcekhaos]

it was a H in the chinese minecraft tho?

[@SniperMonkey146]

China has so much that we don’t in games. For example: Pokemon Quest. Remember that, one off random cubical spin off game? Yeah, apparently China has it still updating, with a lot more content including the other regions and more.

[@FadelessDood]

How did we get a new Fundy video this early it's only been like 2 weeks since the last one. Normally it takes 50 million years

[@niroscalfon5219]

Super true

[@Dessemon]

Now as someone who has recently gone to China and is currently in China, I’ve played this at an event and there were hours of content like, i didn’t want to leave cause I was in a boss fight, this game is like Ultrakill but not on steroids in a way.

[@BlockyTheBrickMaster]

Ultrakill mentioned !!!

[@maximo_theDestroyer]

so its watered down ultrakill?

[@parthernnixxart4623]

Ultrakill Minecraft would be so fun

[@waterdragon7934]

@@parthernnixxart4623 There's a mod for that called, Ultracraft.

[@flamollusk420]

@@parthernnixxart4623 theres a mod called ultracraft, its literally minecraft ultrakill

[@Ironyum99]

fundy do be supporting his Chinese audience 2k likes…..

[@Carrot_pikmin]

Fr

[@Planetmango48]

Wow.

[@romancatholicgameing]

the chinese audience of like 37 people because China banned KZbin

[@christinek232]

memememememme thats meeee

[@acetheonecat]

Thaaats me, buuuuut I live in amirika america

[@owenxue1845]

I can explain Chinese culture in gaming in three words: microtransactions, piracy, and COMBINING. From first hand experience, it's hell. It's only cool at first but once you're a few hours in, you start to question yourself and ask yourself how and when you got here. It's just a hell stew made by adding in whatever that is popular, it's like pineapple on pizza except there's a million other ingredients.

[@Greeeyt]

I like the baby chirp 🐣 in your pic

[@mrpiffers]

Wow, I had no idea Chinese Minecraft was like that! Fundy should make a launcher mod for regular Minecraft so we can enjoy launching the launcher launcher launcher!

[@AnnanKamrans]

fr

[@defnotthekgb8362]

Alot of games in china are different, its because the chinese market is so incredibly different. There are huge swaths of people who just will not play a game if you cant buy your way to the top, and because of the hacking issue many games region-lock china(not to mention chinese internet being restricted heavily). All of this leads to some insane gatcha games

[@distendedmist5840]

basically the curseforge launcher

[@camman18]

people dont understand how hard it is to get into this version lol

[@pancakedev6]

hi canman 1 8

[@unknownman7200]

15 likes only lmao 9 hours

[@magi1134]

I assume this is the part where you make some Chinese Minecraft shorts. "I just found the rarest version of Minecraft... In the west. It's Minecraft, China edition." There, start to your script already

[@Iamnotahumanish]

yeah cost you money and a lot of your personal infomations? way too expensive

[@tonalddrump1332]

in china, it's also quite hard to avoid getting into this terrible version we cant even pay for the normal version(aka international version) to microsoft Netease which runs minecraft chinese eddtion trys its best to stop us

[@JustCallMeElGamer]

Minecraft with a gacha system and mods you have to buy is something crazy and scary to think about

[@SomeGaymerNerd]

I mean, bedrock already has mods you have to buy, so…

[@JustCallMeElGamer]

@@SomeGaymerNerd but it is considered “addons”

[@BOOMBoom-tv4kv]

So minecraft bedrock marketplace

[@Rosy_Maple_Moth_Cherry]

​@@SomeGaymerNerd you can buy them, but you can also add your own mods into bedrock

[@ScriptSuper-vc9ku]

gacha to get skins seems special ... but diamonds vs minecoins, addons to buy vs BEmods to buy... microsoft's doing something chinese did😐 And as i know, in China edition, mods needed to buy only refers to the devs that made it as a living💰, while other mods are free of charge in CNJE edition.

[@Amelia_Jade-craft]

My 1.16 vanilla minecraft brain can barely understand whats going on

[@Riv_Falcon]

One of the rarest occasions that the VPN sponsorship segment is totally legit for the video.

[@ishouldntexist8271]

They be having these while we argue over a mob vote 😭

[@tonyjenssen4157]

It’s also filled with bad gacha and recycled stuff from the original.

[@pwwnzo]

​@strawberr3 They're so definitely missing that

[@burn1ngmem0ries]

​@strawberr3 but in china we can play both chinese Minecraft and normal one(most chinese choose latter except kids)

[@ADSadachbia]

1st world problems

[@LHrx23]

It’s just that Mojang Developers are like thinking of what to put in the game and avoiding the way to impact their game dramatically and also was in Microsoft, Chinese developers just go in and out!

[@XStarfallXTvT]

As a Chinese person, I personally don’t like the changes much actually. It’s really cool yeah, but the out of China version is much better (and honestly even though I’m Chinese, my Chinese sucks so I struggle somewhat with reading omg-). It’s just doesn’t feel like Minecraft anymore.

[@ondranovy5242]

i dont get how you can be chinese yet not speak and read chinese

[@HyperfixationWizard]

The gacha hell that is Minecraft China edition is such a fever dream, and I'm glad someone documented it in a language I can understand.

[@AngieTheCatGD]

14:10 like, you can do emotes, in vanilla minecraft! That’s crazy! *Bedrock Edition has left the chat*

[@somerandomgirl6093]

As I said in other comment... this thing is the bastard child between bedrock edition and some shit free-to-play mobile mmorpg.

[@Tyson-r1w]

It’s funny how people get so mad at bedrock edition for adding any sort of micro transaction when Minecraft China is literally 99.999% micro transactions that nobody ever uses

[@Golldenfireball]

Minecraft bedrock isn't real Minecraft

[@therealartorias7168]

@@Golldenfireball look I don't like bedrock version, but your statement is incredibly asinine

[@Angelikaliu1331]

Me a bedrock player: *_*fades into nonexistence*_*

[@cswertwertwert]

The Chinese edition has changed so much since I last looked at. I sure hope the bedrock version doesn't end up tons of microtransactions to pay for already existing mods on java. That would just be crazy...

[@Focaldesert]

Addons: Let me introduce myself

[@Xedronic]

you already have to pay with minecoins for most maps, mods (aka addons), SKINS EVEN! Not even talking about accessories.

[@_kirbmaster_6609]

:(

[@unknowngod8221]

@@Xedronic that say people can just dowload addon from the internet and maps or have free skin so?

[@SugarbirdyOvO]

Haha. yeah. that would be terrible Edit: This and [I'm pretty sure] the original comment are sarcasm.

[@Syuvinya]

13:28 This player (伤感小结节) is just casually sexually harassing another player (黑曜石a基w) in chat. This game has even worse child safety than roblox. (ik it requires ID and shit but kids are just gonna use their parents' ID). This just goes to show that although china claims to have privacy-invading systems like ID verification in place for child safety purposes, children on the chinese internet aren't well-protected at all.

[@Syuvinya]

And at 14:05 this guy is talking about gangbanging

[@hamspillagernetwork9192]

Good lord.

[@Mihailo_Slavutsky]

You don't really thought they where trying to protect children, do you?

[@Syuvinya]

​@@Mihailo_Slavutsky The government does this for deglobalization and more effective propaganda, but do note that the vast majority of Chinese parents don't want their children to play videogames.

[@Mihailo_Slavutsky]

@@Syuvinya With games like these, I'm not surprised.

[@TheImpossibleCube]

Guan Yu at 12:27 is a famous Chinese warrior from Three kingdoms!

[@percypower6876]

Fundy: Trys to play chinese minercaft for entertainment and pleasure The steps to get it: Name, adress, credit card number-

[@Deer_Cracker_lover]

@@LichtL-ni3rl EXCUSEMEWHAT

[@duckwithknife0]

privacy in china is when you take a Shit in the bathroom that's the only time you would get privacy​@@Deer_Cracker_lover

[@Hack--rz1io]

​@@Deer_Cracker_loverThere's like a state level parental control that limits how much you can play per week accross every game available in China

[@LichtL-ni3rl]

@@Deer_Cracker_lover People below 18 have restricted playing time, something like one hour everyday from 6pm to 8pm. And instead of just asking you to type in your age you need ID confirmation. This is enforced on pretty much all mobile games provided by chinese app-markets. Most foreign games (especially the big ones) available in china are distributed through chinese game dev companies (tencent and netease mostly). They are responsible for updates independently from the original company (chinese mincraft for example only had up to 1.12 when Mojang released 1.16, probably because netease was too busy trying to figure out how to make money from a block game) and also host their own servers, which is independent from the international or even asian server.

[@jessy1982]

@@LichtL-ni3rl Oh so does that prevent the inapp purchases from being bought by kids"?

[@Charlie_is_a_potatoe]

As a Hong Kong person who can access both normal Minecraft and china I find this video extremely interesting

[@toast2110]

Out of the two, which do you prefer more?

[@Charlie_is_a_potatoe]

@@toast2110 normal Minecraft

[@shamaunalfred1834]

King kong

[@toast2110]

@@shamaunalfred1834 No, they meant Hong Kong, a region in China.

[@R_r4y]

@@toast2110 hong kong isnt a city, its a region.

[@zeldacrafter4578]

one word to how they can do this *Gacha* i'm glad regular minecraft is how it is now and never had anything like this happen to it

[@JKuroha]

Sounds like genshin

[@cansarinducin5338]

The only thing i wish western minecraft would change is bringing back tutorial worlds, bringing back sound effects, and the mini games.

[@NoahAtlantis]

Never in my fricking life did I think I’d ever see Minecraft as a Gatcha game

[@Jeffery_Bagels]

4:57 the first option ‘和平’ is for peaceful mode

[@INTHEENDITNEVERMATTERED]

I am at a loss for words. When I finished watching this video, I just sort of zoned out for a bit, just trying to process what I had laid my eyes upon, not a single thought crossing my mind for almost ten minutes. When I finally came to my senses, my first words were 'What the fuck?' Thank you, Fundy, for giving me something to put in my brainholes. I will lose much sleep over this video.

[@nonexistent-yt9em]

Guy got FLABBERGASTED

[@charliesmith31]

Even I'm surprised at how my country does this.

[@fullmoonshadow6967]

@@charliesmith31 Oof.

[@udiomoudochi8696]

I would have never expected my day to start with fundy playing a roblox game in Chinese Minecraft

[@TrainedCreeper]

This is an adequate response to people that think mojang makes boring updates and should instead add stuff that modders commonly make.

[@capnbug]

Ikr lmao. It's so funny how much he tries to gas it up when it just looks like brain rot.

[@nomis5764]

Bro that’s like “Temu Minecraft” 💀

[@ScriptSuper-vc9ku]

agree🤣 temu's a also an eBay or Amazon in chinese edition

[@faith5923]

@@ScriptSuper-vc9ku ..most of amazon’s stock is made in china lmao

[@joshuacottenham9149]

This temu gamecube... seems... off... I know, it's video editing Magic. No way my kid would notice the difference. *kid on Christmas* mom? What the fuck is this?

[@ZG-1NIC]

"GEOGRAPHY, GEOGRAPHY, GEOGRAPHY, COOKIE, COOKIE, COOKIE, D E L I C I O U S"

[@des1990]

Of all countries, the CHINESE version is the one with lootboxes and randomized rewards, which are completely illegal in any shape in chinese games

[@Kristall_Fox]

I heard that this works because they dont actually call it gambeling, basically they hide the fact that its gambeling under words like pulling or whishing (like in genshin impact) and instead of money you get pretty anime girls.

[@fungusamongus69420]

It's legal if the drop rates are disclosed though. Only outright gambling is illegal in China, so gacha games don't count.

[@fullmoonshadow6967]

@@fungusamongus69420 That true?

[@insertname1857]

gacha games are def not illegal in china

[@ScriptSuper-vc9ku]

actually this gacha is more like GI or HSR which are all chinese games.

[@Scratchcat2178-ft7ew]

Diamond is like the main currency where you can sort of but other currencies. They have a lot of KZbinr skins and a bunch of (sorta) useless stuff that aren’t part of the main game. There is one mod where its connected to your launcher so you can get different pets in the launcher and it will show in the mod.

[@globallyhatedperson]

Video Idea: Code EVERY SINGLE THING a player does into an achievement. Per se... You go to a new unexplored coordinate! You get an achievement of "Visit Coordinate X:Y:Z for the first time!" or if you jumped, it could say, "You jumped for the X Time!" stuff like that

[@EmjrRockz]

Infinite gamerscore goes brrr

[@ChaosTheSalamander]

This looks fascinating, but the kind of fascinating you’re okay with while looking at it from a distance. Bosses and all the cool partner models look gorgeous, but you could tell all of it is to squeeze money out of you, and there isn’t any of that simple charm that current normal MC has. Cool from a distance, not so cool when you’re steeped in it.

[@jojocat8637]

I love the guy who helped you he sounds really nice

[@HarimauYap]

4:56 Bro really tried hard to understand (they're peaceful, easy, normal, and hard respectively)

[@spaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaace]

i speak chinese and i could understand the text

[@themanbehindthebananas]

​@@spaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaacebrother these are the things you are taught at 10 years old max

[@spaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaace]

@@themanbehindthebananas true if u learn chinese when young

[@wiktoriaebis4176]

Thats actually crazy omg. The storylines sound kinda cool but if Minecraft was like that here too, I doubt I would‘ve played it for basically my entire life. The simplicity really makes it playable. Meanwhile with this version I would feel like its done after playing one or two mods

[@Mario583a]

Fundy at 12:50 : Why does a pig have eyebrows? Me: Have you not played Storymode?

[@fullmoonshadow6967]

Reuben! I remember that pig. I played like four or five eps of the first game before their company servers shut down entirely and I couldn't get any further.

[@aishaza2]

very few people remember it tho

[@xdarksun5072]

"Why doesnt our minecraft have this." Also people when minecraft adds something new : "This doesnt feel minecrafty." or "I miss old minecraft"

[@Cartoon.Cuties]

Well, some people. Not everyone. No matter what you change, someone will not like it. That's always going to happen.

[@maxdavis7722]

Nah, most people are saying now “why is mojang so lazy” and “they need to add more”.

[@CalamityJay-ez2mq]

People are like "Mojang is so lazy why can't they add things like the modders dooooo" but then Mojang completely reworked data packs so that Vanilla Minecraft is now infinitely customisable but it gets ignored cause y'all are too lazy to learn how to use data packs

[@tonyjenssen4157]

@@CalamityJay-ez2mqIf we have to use data packs to make Minecraft feel fleshed out and complete, that’s almost a problem

[@CalamityJay-ez2mq]

@@tonyjenssen4157 Minecrafts overworld is incredibly fleshed out, even the Nether is fairly expansive at this point, the main weak points are just the End, and that there isn't much handholding to give you something to do

[@cyruslam0831]

As a Hongkonger I'm glad that I have access to the *normal* version of Minecraft

[@nvlx2]

5:09 I see a Skibidi Toilet mod. Didn't know the Chinese were Rizzlers

[@cocoaXC]

那个add特别烂 别问我咋知道的😭

[@nvlx2]

@@cocoaXC Hello, my Chinese friend. I love The Supreme Ruler Xi Jinping

[@jacklansdale77]

Emeralds are given to you free but go away at the end of the month to encourage you to buy more diamond to get enough emeralds instead of losing them, cashing in on the sunk cost fallacy. I'm assuming the other currencies are either free funds, your gold you get from playing or daily log ins, or event currency. And while Java edition gets nothing and we love it for that, Bedrock gets these types of things but because they can't steal mods wholesale the marketplace is smaller and shitty. But they do have some things, they have a Ben 10 adventure map like China's divine boss adventure rush whatever, probably not even translated well.

[@xCamiscoolx]

Chinese version and bedrock version are 2 different things Every great bedrock addon is free and almost nobody posts their stuff on the marketplace And stop with the hating on bedrock for the marketplace nobody is using that everybody gets addons for free like java

[@a_random_confused_person7703]

​@@xCamiscoolx right I used to play bedrock too when I was young and last I checked you can get a lot of free add-ons.

[@fullmoonshadow6967]

​@@xCamiscoolx As someone who actively plays bedrock, I can say the marketplace *does* suck to some extent. Yes, there are good mods and creators on there, but a lot of them are ripoffs/reposts of mods you can get free for java. The free mods/maps are mostly limited. They're usually either just a display of something, or are very niche. I've definitely seen a fair number of free, extensive modded maps on there.. Problem is that half of them are tedious, and are free for educational purposes. I tried playing one, where you restore a bayou. It got laggy within the first hour or so, and I couldn't progress any further. With java, you could slap on your own extra mods to help with lag/render issues, like optifine. You can't do that on bedrock. Yes, you can edit the mod content, but there aren't any that improve game processes.. Bedrock is just too limited for that. And as I said earlier, all the good, free maps are niche. One I saw was based in archery. I've been wanting to try it, haven't gotten around to it. I'm good with minecraft archery. But I have a friend with mobility issues, who can't use a bow at all. A map like that would be impossible for her. Other cases are maps aimed at children, or ones that just don't really go anywhere. I tried this disaster themed map once. Thought it'd be minigame like where you and a friend or two just do what you please while trying to survive what the game throws at you. Nope. There was a whole extra story and village you were supposed to deal with. Wasn't what I'd expected/wanted at all, and it ruined half the experience. It was just a stardew valley style game with disasters. (I'm not fond of games like that. Too grindy, and too little freedom. You have to do specific things to progress, and not enough stuff is optional for that) Regardless, point is. Bedrock *does* suck, just not as bad as people make it out to be. I do really like some of the stuff it has compared to java, like the ability to put potions in cauldrons/dye from cauldrons, or the fact bedrock leads have *slack*. Why don't java leads have *slack*? It's so much nicer. Makes it look like you're not constantly choking the poor animal. I'm sure there're plenty of others, mostly on education edition, but I can't remember any more off the top of my head right now.

[@xCamiscoolx]

@@fullmoonshadow6967 well I partially agree with you but what makes bedrock good is the compatibility with other devices like an Xbox or a pc and yes I agree some addons do suck but not all of them there are some creators who actually work hard on their addons the issue with bedrock is how hard it is to make addons and where to find them because there isn't an official website that the creators can post their addons and there are multiple bad websites that includes actual good addons that creators post on because they get paid for it or whatever the reason they have to post it in the specific website which makes it a problem for us bedrock users to find add-on if they aren't posted on KZbin However some addons are still great and highly recommended to use like better on bedrock like poggy and maybe you just downloaded the wrong map to teach archery to your friend And what I hate about bedrock is the lag and bugs in it but in the last few years I haven't came across multiple bugs it's sometimes just blocks not placing when you place them But what makes java great is the mods on it without the mods everybody will play bedrock And what I like about bedrock is the survival mode on it bedrock has alot of cool features that isn't in java like different colour waters and the world generation which makes it interesting and fun to explore the weird world generation But the main point of what I said is to find reasons on why bedrock sucks because some people hate it for minor reasons or for no reason at all I respect your opinion on why bedrock is bad but don't hate on it because of like one thing (And yes I read everything you said lol)

[@ThatStingrayGuy]

13:03 the chinese text translates to "My world (wo de shi jie)" so the whole title would be: Minecraft, My world.

[@deanergie.]

Hi

[@bananalegend194]

pretty sure 我的世界 is just supposed to be the chinese translation of minecraft, like you dont include the minecraft part in the title, so yeah the direct translationg would be my world

[@Wuana]

@@bananalegend194 It is lol

[@MrKiller392]

Chinese are unique people. They can transform every game in Roblox with Loot-boxes

[@NicoleLu-e8d]

is that a insult or a compliment?

[@monsteryulegend5404]

​@@NicoleLu-e8d both

[@七光酱]

no, it's just the few megacorps that has most of the market share

[@scientificthesis]

probably because Tencent basically handles all gaming in China

[@Finalizor]

@@scientificthesis that explains it

[@JgHaverty]

Java players watching : "oh my god! Imagine if regular minecraft had a predatory store where you had to pay to use mods??" Bedrock players : "oh you guys too!"

[@JDSK0ala]

Your not the only one lol. So much so I’ve been making a discord for it to research and talk about it. Private for now with scarse invites scattered publicly, but if anyone looks hard enough, they will find it Haven’t watched the video yet, but I look forward to seeing it in the morning. Being Australian is fun sometimes

[@Ilikememes0]

Wait do you have the minecraft chinese version or not? This is intresting after all :0 If u dont mind sharing, how many ppl are in that server?

[@RapidLog]

Lets thank Fundy for moving to China to make this video.

[@Definitely_Sage]

0:58 that banner with Steve and Alex is giving me flashbacks

[@fullmoonshadow6967]

As someone who played the old console edition, I have to agree. The nostalgia is hard with that one.

[@pixelatedguy]

Fun fact: “我的世界” literally translates to "My World" Btw person that speaks Chinese here, the difficulties are actually Peaceful, Easy, Normal and Hard im pretty sure the easier version to get is called “迷你世界” but it has less features and only 2 currencies so go check that out too

[@dtheall86]

1:38 Not alex casually holding the Zenith 💀

[@yharon-thejungledragon]

just an average day in minecraft literally having the fucking zenith (as a PICKAXE XD)

[@yharon-thejungledragon]

wonder how fast it mines

[@dtheall86]

​@@yharon-thejungledragon it's post-moonlord so probably quite fast

[@yharon-thejungledragon]

@@dtheall86 they need to make a minecraft terraria mod frfr

[@dtheall86]

@@yharon-thejungledragon there is already a few terraria mods on curseforge

[@irExron]

It's absolutely crazy how much stuff is on this version, i seriously hope this isn't what's taking up all of Mojang's resources for the western version

[@thedeepseacat]

I'm pretty sure they have different dev team

[@endcaps1917]

their a different dev team it's a company called netease hearing another comment i hear most people in china hates the netease version I'm pretty sure mojangs actual resource issues are microsofts doing going off of current and ex mojang employees

[@hiteshannamraj6195]

"the minecraft Netflix adaptation"

[@fullmoonshadow6967]

Ngl, that sounds like something they'd do. Or at least get a paid license to host minecraft bedrock alongside their other games.

[@cornbreadbutcringey5723]

@@fullmoonshadow6967 they announced a minecraft netflix show a few days ago

[@maciekw.7923]

The fact that Minecraft is getting an official Netflix adaptation feels weird

[@OfficialForteko]

Minecraft’s hub page in China is exactly the same to how Roblox’s hub page in the USA looks

[@supersigma.furinaenjoyer]

11:14 HOLY CRAP WHY IS ZHONGLI NEXT TO ALEX 😭😭

[@AnekoF90]

Why the hell is he in minecraft to begin with?

[@bestboisoupsoup]

​@@AnekoF90Why the hell is _this_ minecraft to begin with?

[@Iamnotahumanish]

what's amazing that is even Minecraft have china edition, some people inside still try to play in java edition and to play all the mods that cost them real life money (and not even uploaded by the original modder) free

[@evanwirth7881]

The marketplace on Chinese Minecraft is literally just the bedrock marketplace, you were surprised by the rating system, Bedrock has that too

[@unknowngod8221]

at leats bedrock and even minecraft as a whole give you freedom to adds mods/addon from outside the marketplace and free to be modded

[@fullmoonshadow6967]

Yes and no. The bedrock marketplace has *one* currency besides real money, and the bedrock rating system is stars. The shock factor for the chinese version rating system is that it's the damn hunger bar.

[@joshidk-zy9xj]

Most of the features added feel more RPG rather and sandbox which is Minecraft's main identity

[@Brot_b]

Genshin makes you have a gambling addiction if i had this i would be homeless

[@AivyLynnvDxx]

Fundy is in his active era and we live for it

[@PersonThatsLikesClassicalMusic]

2:35 “launcher launcher launcher”

[@xiaoniaoawa]

yes 发烧游戏平台 launch 我的世界启动器 then launch another Launcher

[@golddollar]

😂😂😂😂

[@Chargeboltttt]

I don't want normal minecraft to be like this >_

[@MostmajorofLs]

13:55 Dawg playing Natural Disaster Survival in minecraft no way😭

[@FireyMinecraft]

What differences did you notice compared to the regular version? Looking forward to hearing more!

[@Humanoiddecoy]

more hacker,more ADs,and more recharge content

[@annxu8219]

more technical blocks mod ore etc(i used to analyze how these blocks works in chinese minecaft)

[@2BPasser]

mobile vertion tokes 2GB (while the bedblock tokes 1GB) still in 1.18.30 vertion (since 2023.1......) tons of teenager player (although there is a limit that one who under 18 should not play over than 3h per week(that's why they ask for your information),but obviously it doesn't works at all,since they can provide thier parents' information) low loarding speed and world creating speed(at least in my computer,some how)

[@2BPasser]

and , you can't adding mod by yourself , the market is the only way(so if you want to using a mod,you should uploarding it first)

[@egg-goes-weeee]

when i saw this in my feed I legit just said "WHAT?" out loud i couldn't believe that fundy is still alive

[@rogue123987]

Do you usually assume people are dead when you don't see them for three weeks?

[@fullmoonshadow6967]

@@rogue123987 Considering covid's still floating around, I consider it a fair concern.

[@egg-goes-weeee]

@@rogue123987 no but fundy literally keeps disappearing for months at a time and then casually pops an update

[@Carl-mx4cu]

W FOR THE GUY THAT HELPED FUNDY！

[@zyansheep]

4:09 the reason is because we aren't subject to super predatory microtransactions thus there is not a surplus of money to do cool things with.