Y&R's New Sheila

Michelle Stafford as Sheila

[@MrJuly1990ish]

When I saw this scene, I just kept seeing the "PSYCHO" Phyllis from the early '90s here. When she was saying the names Nick, Lauren and Micheal, it was pretty much Danny, Crickette and Paul all over again, 10 years later.

[@josephclegg3562]

Phyllis not acting like Phyllis. Lol!😁

[@Pinkranger87]

the duel role phyils and sheila was not good idea Michelle stafford could not be as evil and crazy as Kimberlyn Brown she IS the best

[@tiaflies]

Idk... she played Nina REALLY well

[@fanexpo2114]

MS can play evil phyliss and psycho phyliss well. But her trying to play Sheila was a no for me. It looked like MS was trying to hard to be like Sheila and sound convincing.

[@michelemartin4998]

Phyliss is a special kind of nutts

[@pjmoneybags2780]

​@@michelemartin4998 I think Sheila has more evil & dangerous attributes, she really goes after people with a vengance. Phyllis is vindictive & also capable of murder but Sheila is a step beyond in the lengths she will go to & much more creative with her plans for vengeance & she's somewhat of an escape artist. imo.😯

[@Geefuss]

I disagre

[@BabySwearWords]

This was a weird time. The writers were trying to put Phyllis in every story.

[@kershabeaver3312]

And they still doing it

[@hratchsetrakian1692]

Michelle has such insane range in acting. Good thing they got her back.

[@CrooklynKnight]

Did B&B ever address how they got her to look like Kimberlin Brown again after this?

[@andrebaptiste7288]

Apparently she got a surgery to fix her face back to normal 😭

[@CrooklynKnight]

@@andrebaptiste7288 lol sounds about right. Thanks

[@michaelsteele4587]

Actually...yes! Sheila Carter was actually in prison the entire time and when asked about this, it was made clear this was an imposter but it never actually went deep into who they were or why they were there. There was no mention of Sheila's children Daisy and Ryder though and last we knew...Daisy was in the psych ward with Sharon Newman and then she went missing and the person who checked her out was Sheila Carter which is impossible because Sheila was in prison at that time...not dead like Daisy and Ryder assumed which was why they came to town with Sheila's sister Sarah when she looked like Lauren Fenmore. Daisy also had the baby with Daniel, Phyllis's son so the door is open for them to make a return one day if we had decent writers that is.

[@kershabeaver3312]

It was shelia sister that was the one who got plastic surgery to look like Phyliss

[@GaryU24]

It obviously want her

[@GuyWhoConquers]

I’m so glad that bold and beautiful recently retcon this and claim it was sugar pretending to be Shelia as Phyllis.

[@xtinaah3358]

michelle stafford was my favourite actress.-one for being phyllis and two sheila carter..such a talented actress.miss her on the Y&R

[@luerike]

Michelle is my favorite actress too. I am not used to new Phyllis.

[@686JM]

tina Ah it was total overacting. Sheila was never psycho enough to go after more than just Lauren at one time. This was Sugar Sheila's accomplice.

[@frtv577]

I remember was young in 2014 watching this scene

[@usarmybama]

Dreadful doesn’t begin to describe this travesty

[@user-tz7un5rz8x]

She played her role ❤😅

[@zackgoraj6163]

THIS WAS ONE OF THE BEST

[@mergeron1230]

This isn't Sheila. This is Sugar.

[@686JM]

VibesRays Then what happened to Sugar? Why wouldn't Sheila switch places with Sugar? Sheila never had a problem with Phyllis it was clearly Sugar seeking a way out of Sheila's shadow.

[@luerike]

Sheila is still alive on Los Angeles in 2017-2018. Watch out, Lauren. The bitch is going after u again! Lol

[@pammoore4455]

mark mergeron no wrong it isn't Sugar it's Sheila

[@fanexpo2114]

@@686JMSheila was seen at the doctors office requesting surgery the same time sugar was arrested.

[@fanexpo2114]

@@686JMthe same time sugar was arrested, the cops were still looking for Sheila, and she was seen looking in the windows in the doctors office

[@Multifacted_Brotha]

Since Kimberlin Brown had came back on the Bold and The beautiful recently it bothered me they never tried to address this on Y&R. Evidently whoever tried to look like Phyllis wasn't Shelia at all. Possibility someone Shelia brainwashed into thinking she was her to actually go after Lauren is the most logical explanation.

[@soapsplace]

Absolutely! Sheila already convinced Sugar to take her own face, so she could easily repeat it with another crazy...like Sarah (played by Ellen Wheeler on B&B back to late 1995) and that was totally under Sheila's influence. + She had the perfect morphology to take Phyllis' face

[@bwcarter921]

I think they just retconned this out of existence

[@fanexpo2114]

@@bwcarter921B&B doesn’t want to touch anything that has to do with Sheila’s past On Y&R from 2005 onward. That’s why B&B just continues Sheila’s storyline where she left off in L.A. I’m assuming it’s to complicating for Bradley bell to try and use history for Sheila’s character to further her storylines. And that’s probably why we are getting sad material in todays episode from Sheila on B&B.

[@charleskershaw5903]

when the young and restless was good miss those days

[@DeepScreenAnalysis]

It was never good at this time. When they did this story it already started to be crap.

[@Multifacted_Brotha]

Wrong this is actually when Y&R started getting bad.... The 80's through the early 2000's was when Y&R was at it's peak,

[@antoniochapman3986]

Y&R was dead here.

[@antoniochapman3986]

Y&R was falling here.

[@antoniochapman3986]

@@Multifacted_Brotha Right.

[@prestonrcasey]

So since we saw Sheila with her normal face today on B&B, this person who did plastic surgery wasn't Sheila at all apparently. That's the only way they can explain how she's back, alive, and looking normal.

[@DeepScreenAnalysis]

This was one of Sheila's associates. She has many collaborators.

[@MarkSmith-ie1zq]

I hope they explain soon. I have a feeling it will be explained when Sheila returns to Genoa City.

[@prestonrcasey]

I mean this is paying close attention to detail, but at the same time I can't imagine Sheila being the one to have surgery. It's annoying to think that her face would just suddenly be back to normal for B&B.

[@warrenbaumbree9918]

Preston Casey im speculated that it is sugar , sheilas old partner in crime n former prison guard who helped her escape from prison thats the only logical explanation i can think of they should go with that idea

[@pammoore4455]

Preston Casey no it was Sheila did ever accurd to that Sheila survived and a mystery doctor found her and retored back to the way she used to look

[@Tyree101]

Why did they delete all the old videos of Shelia as Phyllis???

[@jaredcooper9111]

Thank god they did.

[@josephclegg3562]

Michelle Stafford was a great actress. She was the best Phyllis.

[@zmanson3940]

EVER SINCE THIS THEY KEEP RE CREATING PEOPLE PHYLLIS JACK THAT DOCTOR LAUREN WHO'S NEXT SHARON?????

[@silverdream80]

+Felton Mann Maybe Jill ;)

[@zmanson3940]

Steve f. Lol. She is so irrelevant now in days. If that's the case then Gloria might be after. :D

[@MrJuly1990ish]

+Felton Mann I let it slide (imposter storyline) with the Kay & Marge back in the early '90s, because they did it in a somewhat realistic way. But now, I just know the late great Bill Bell must be turning over in his damn grave. The writers have really ruined (F-up) this once great show. Hell, why not just do all of Genoa City with this bullshit (imposter storyline,), since that seems to be the theme the past several years for this mess of a show now (SMDH).

[@zmanson3940]

***** LOL

[@zmanson3940]

+MrJuly1990ish It's just so unrealistic that there's been all this plastic surgery look alike's going on in Genuia* city. The writers must've been bored

[@Annefry]

If you watch the show, I think Ryder's mother and the woman Deacon works for is Sheila. It's going to get interesting to see how they make her look if I am right.

[@josephclegg3562]

Ryder and Daisy are Sheila's children.

[@antoniochapman3986]

When Y&R wasn't good anymore.

[@michaeltannerjr3633]

Is actually is Sugar but not Sheila Carter.

[@danaevans3648]

What is exactly wrong with Shelia anyways?

[@warrenbaumbree9918]

Very good point that is a good way 2 explain how sheila carter is alive she survived being shot fell into a coma was jailed n had reverse plastic surgery they need 2 go wit that one

[@bwcarter921]

I think they retconned this period as well as Sheila's sister surgically altered to look like Lauren, out of Y&R....

[@vistaprime]

are they serious. can someone tell me how this storyline ends? I assume at some point Kimberlin will return and say she got surgery to look like herself again. I hope!!!

[@josephclegg3562]

Lauren supposedly shot Sheila, but somehow she survived and showed back up in LA.

[@fashionista27able]

Michelle Stafford deserved an award for this performance. Outstanding!

[@fanmael1]

Michelle Stafford couldn't pull off Sheila. Kimberlin Brown is the only one who can play Sheila.

[@fanexpo2114]

@@fanmael1I have to agree. MS can pull off crazy Phylis’s but not villainess Sheila

[@HnHBlkM]

Why didn't she just have plastic surgery to look like Lauren? That would have made better sense than for her to look like someone she has nothing against nor anything to gain from impersonating? that storyline where her never before mentioned sister made herself look like Lauren made little to no sense whatsoever.

[@josephclegg3562]

The storyline was stupidly written back then.

[@irememberla6460]

I now realize why I stopped watching Y&R years ago... It became absurd!

[@DeepScreenAnalysis]

Sheila Carter was nothing like this woman, so the only explanation is that Sheila had sent one of her collaborators to masquerade as Phyllis. Whoever the woman actually was, we will never know.

[@josephclegg3562]

Sheila was Phyllis trying to act like Phyllis.

[@DeepScreenAnalysis]

Joseph Clegg This wasn’t Sheila though.

[@abenji7474]

The story lines are SO WEAK!!! Omg!!!! Y&R what happen to u???!

[@luerike]

Adam... I'd love it for Isabella to return. The actress isn't doing anything right now.

[@leespike2078]

looks like phyllis

[@mjguz]

i just read that kimberlin may be coming back...curious how they will work this out.

[@DR729er]

I,wanted to see the real Sheila.

[@mjguz]

that sounds interesting...could be good!

[@thenewctc]

Ridiculous..one Phyllis look a like is worse enough!😱😵

[@marymoore5776]

Please tell me what is that mess with Phyllis. TheYand R writers don't know what the heck they are doing. What is it.

[@silverdream80]

true sheila is evil and manipulative , here its total creepy , so its sugar of course!

[@dennisvalverde3909]

I agree Steve f This is Sugar not Sheila. Sheila Carter Came to the B&B Last Year Played by Kimberlin Brown.

[@aprentissdaye]

God this Sheila/Phyllis/Sugar/Lauren storyline was arguably the worst storyline in history of Y&R.

[@n0thing7matters777]

Thanks to KZbin for suggesting a 16yr old video about a show I don't watch.

[@fanmael1]

Too funny! 🤣

[@cyranothecat]

By far the most ridiculous time for Young and Restless history. the producer/ writer at that time Lynn Marie Latham was a joke thank God they got rid of her

[@makeupboss3568]

Didn’t really care for this . I think it just got weird.

[@carlycool4]

Ok. This is confusing.

[@jauquisgomez1075]

Sheila had plastic surgery to look like Phyllis years before Sarah Symthe her sister had surgery to look like her former longtime rival Lauren and Mary Jane impersonate Patti, Paul's sister to pretend to be her.

[@juliansmith6291]

When Sandra Nelson portrayed Phyllis on the Young and the Restless in my opinion she was way more eviler

[@fanexpo2114]

She looked like a villain% 😂😂👏🤣

[@kershabeaver3312]

Bad story

[@JuJuMJFan4life]

Oh Lord this is confusing.....Who in the world is Sugar and how does she know Sheila?

[@josephclegg3562]

Sheila tricked Sugar to get plastic surgery to look like her, so she can switch places with her so she can escape the mental hospital to go after Lauren.

[@susan5048]

Sorry Phyllis but Sheila is better.

[@gianlucamacagnino9941]

Sheil has come back to Beautiful in 2017 so this woman is not Sheila

[@pammoore4455]

Gianluca Macagnino yes it was Sheila had first return in 2006 this was back in 2006 so this was before she returned to the Bold and the beautiful back in 2017 in her true form so that was Sheila did you not forget that Sheila had plastic surgery on her to make herself look exactly like Phyllis

[@AndrewSmith-pn2qc]

@@pammoore4455 but this woman was killed by Lauren. So she could not have been Sheila since Sheila is alive.

[@gianlucamacagnino9941]

​@@AndrewSmith-pn2qcthis woman is not Sheila.Who is?

[@AndrewSmith-pn2qc]

@@gianlucamacagnino9941 I don't understand your statement/question .

[@gianlucamacagnino9941]

@@AndrewSmith-pn2qc this woman is not Sheila Karter according to me

[@briankachor566]

I didn't like the story line

[@silverdream80]

i never loved this shitty storylines , they should use Sugar whit the real sheilas face ( kimberlin brown ) ....

[@josephclegg3562]

I wonder where Sugar is now.

[@michaelwirick1849]

This was a really bad period of writing and producing

[@GaryU24]

This was so stupid. Michelle is amazing not Shelia