Sodor Short: Assumption

Gordon makes an assumption about the "secret ingredient" Eric has used in his chocolate chip cookies. Is he right or wrong?

[@rebel_x13]

Seeing Gordon that angry over an assumption was both understandable and hilarious!😂😂😂

[@cornholio329]

Agreed i was in stitches

[@legomxstudios]

Yeah given Eric's... Less than favorable past with cooking.

[@karenfan010]

@@legomxstudios and the fact that a sperm bank was robbed after he made cookies was just sus.

[@legomxstudios]

@@karenfan010 I guess we fell for the hype just like Gordon did

[@robrice7246]

Well as he put it, 4:09.

[@JohntheLNERP2]

Thank God Eric's cooking wasn't bad this time honestly when Joey told Gordon what had happened I nearly threw up

[@JoeltheSwedishDragon]

Agreed and same here, not the right moment to drink yer cup of tea.

[@titanoven]

I trow up for the beat up moment

[@upstagefeilx]

Same here I had to check the comments for answers

[@JohntheLNERP2]

@Tara Lamb more like a sick green caterpillar with red stripes

[@Jaiden_C.H.R]

@@JoeltheSwedishDragon don't forget the biscuits

[@lyokianhitchhiker]

Eric feels like that 1 friend who’s secretly a genius, but fakes stupidity so others don’t take him seriously enough.

[@joeleboeuf]

I never did understand that trope. Why would someone fake ignorance so that they wouldn't be taken seriously?

[@lyokianhitchhiker]

@@joeleboeuf To trick villains into underestimating them

[@joeleboeuf]

@@lyokianhitchhiker Ah, I see.

[@lyokianhitchhiker]

@@joeleboeuf I mean, think about how many bad guys got screwed by the last guy they expected because the guy that screwed them seemed like they weren’t a threat.

[@joeleboeuf]

@@lyokianhitchhiker 🤨🤔 Makes sense.

[@DanknDerpyGamer]

*Eric:* "I swear on the Fat Controller's imminent grave..." *The Fat Controller:* "HEY!" 😂😂😂😂

[@arenjtumastens]

To Fat man: "STAY OUTTA THIS, Sir!"

[@anneexoskin2287]

At least we should be proud of gordon for helping Eric out with pointers of his hobby, now he learns how to make good food for people to enjoy. That’s all that gordon has done for Eric. Provide support the best he could. Even if it was a rough start

[@jamesgroccia644]

When nutmeg and cinnamon are added to any baked good, I like to call it "hopping the flavor train"

[@thatswhatshesaid2777]

pun intended?

[@nickmohammadi454]

"I swear on the Fat Controller's imminent grave-" "HEY!" " -That it's 1000% all good." Best line in the video. 😆.

[@OptimusPrime2471]

And then he died because of the crate

[@coralproductions6161]

Alright, Nick Mohammadi, I'll trust you on this one, but only because these cookies are absolutely magnificent. However, if I find out *what* your secret ingredient is, and if it's the complete opposite of everything you've promised, I'm going to subject you to a semi-fatal beating. Understood?

[@christianasuncion]

@@coralproductions6161 understood

[@BRYMUSFREAKINPRIME]

0:51

[@jordandorsett3106]

2:37

[@Railman1225]

the scene where Gordon charged the group had me in stitches! i started giggling when James started describing how Gordon was coming at them, and then I burst out laughing when Gordon showed up! the only thing that'd made it better is if you could hear Gordon's puffing as he got closer, plus the change of speed. well done, Eric!

[@itshighnoon7504]

You could’ve said it without that but alright

[@majorkilljoy]

Oi oi 😂😂😂

[@yeetboiwhatyesplease2095]

"Gordon was coming at them" Jeeeeeeeeezzz dude.... out of context am I right?

[@bengray3245]

Talk about seeing red.

[@stuartbarclay7940]

Joey: This might be the day I lose faith in the world. Gordon: Welcome to the club. Me: Agreed.

[@fastoutnotforkids7192]

I agree as well.

[@marybethricci9495]

Zing!

[@inevitableanarchy4203]

Indeed

[@edward002gaming]

same here

[@Sebastian.A_Castro.B_16]

0:33

[@shawlewis6492]

"Search your feelings, you know it's true" that sent chills down my spine

[@jordandorsett3106]

0:03 Here's the time stamp

[@oliverhood1732]

“Noooooooooooooo nooooooooooooo!” 0:07

[@robrice7246]

​@@oliverhood1732Don't you think you're overreacting Gordon?

[@shadowblade2012]

I really like this one. Eric finally improving his cooking skills and then Gordon jumping to conclusions thinking Eric went back to his old ways only he was wrong and Eric's revenge is his past cooking ways. Very clever.

[@joeleboeuf]

Makes you wonder what his Galloping Sausage surprise is.

[@pamfilipinas9102]

my guess is whatever galloping sausage surprise was Eric is about to massacre Gordon☢️☠️

[@rafplayz10]

My favorite part is when eric said that he used nutmeg gordon just fell to bits not literally though

[@TheTJVERSECouncil]

Huh, maybe Eric isn’t so bad at cooking after all. But I have to say, best Sodor Short ever

[@mechamax7919]

Yeeees, quite.

[@nachojjful]

I already had a feeling that Eric had put something non food in the cookies...🍪

[@bluebellsfan8704]

Indeed TJ

[@brentgibson8198]

What you think Eric is going to make next

[@nachojjful]

@@brentgibson8198 Probably food that has any sort of animal name.

[@JoeltheSwedishDragon]

With Eric's history of shady cooking before this, I can't really blame Gordon for his assumption and misunderstanding. I'd be just as disgusted and upset. ... not enough to throw a semi-fatal trashing, but still. XB Also, Gordon's Christopher Nolan's Batman, confirmed. :P

[@the_autism_express]

I'll be honest, I thought it was Eric that robbed the "bank"

[@Zero-Mk1]

I would give him a semi-fatal beating if he stole sperm added them to cookies

[@Unknown457jk]

Oh Thomas fans:how can a train cook and eat Me and others: well they have faces can talk and can move on their own so why not cook and eat

[@codywilliams8251]

Joel the Swedish Dragon More like livid!

[@privateerbouncher9622]

2:19 “TAKE HIM AWAY, AND STOP THAT NOISE!”

[@ultracharizardmaster]

Considering Eric’s cooking history I don’t blame Gordon for jumping the gun. But I think it’s good he’s learning how to be a better cook. Also Percy needs some help or something.

[@Jamersonde]

Well, Railgate didn't help, so idk what will.

[@lukespillman1313]

Me: What's wrong with you Percy?!

[@Daniel_0923.]

Percy :Everything

[@jynxeddraken4176]

This cheered me up whilst I was having a bad day. Thank you victor for all your work.

[@lukechristmas3951]

This is quite refreshing to have a new Sodor Short! And especially one that actually has a well constructed story. Not too long but not too short either and with the expected humor! Honestly, I can relate to Gordon in this one and I love his reaction at the beginning.

[@billybath2140]

Gordon in this one was Sooo FUNNY I can't 😆 hold in my laughter 🤣

[@SubSimpich]

The tone in Joeys voice further confirms how done he is.

[@taylorberry1735]

I must say, Gordon’s Luke impression of the “No, I am your father” scene from The Empire Strikes Back is good

[@Trifosion]

I lost it when i heard secret ingredient 😂 and Gordon’s furry 🤣

[@joeleboeuf]

"Gordon's furry," what?

[@loganhedger3460]

Typo

[@Bunbiichuffn]

I miss TSOS. Having said that, the latter half of this video ... Pure gold

[@Ryder-a-Blaze]

Let’s just say that Percy wanted to have a Kingdom come.

[@robertrowley4929]

Ewww🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@shanewalters4171]

I got the joke

[@Jedi-ge6lr]

Jesus.

[@tencents6]

Bruh.

[@LukeLintula]

🦗🦗🦗

[@comicfan1324]

To answer the question: The last assumption I made was thinking you would release another humorous video. And I was right.

[@prestigex774]

Once again Victor makes a outstanding video for all of us to enjoy! Thank you Victor!

[@safiuddinhanafy2014]

Is it me or I can't stop watching these shorts.

[@ConductorBrenner4768]

This time Eric was honest he finally followed the ingredients he became a great culinary cookies like i am a culinary student and this time he used Nutmeg he should meet alton brown at fox theatre on march 20th 2022

[@ajaxengineco]

Chocolate chip cookies with nutmeg sounds pretty delicious actually...

[@admiralskipper9563]

Can't really blame Gordon for assuming, given Eric's track record. I mean we are talking about the engine who has used everything from minerals, chemicals, human body parts, domesticated and prehistoric animals for his dishes! For Christmas some needs to give Eric a cook book.

[@RiverDoncaster]

yes XD

[@maxm2317]

He’d still cock up the recipes.

[@TheEmeraldMinecart26]

I got chica (from fnaf my au) a cook book after she burnt the kitchen for the 853784326884227885423790754325787543235533 times the kitchen was ok after that really proved her skills but r.i.p older kitchens 😑

[@davinsmith7543]

A few other "ingredients" Eric used were bodily waste, illegal substances, live animals that weren't crustaceans, and I don't even want to know what else.

[@liladoodle]

Joey: *Says that there was a robbery at the sperm bank.* Me, who has watched Shimoneta: "I've got a bad feeling about this.".

[@lukespillman1313]

Eric: I used my secret ingredient. [Echoes secret ingredient] Me: 🤢🤮 AAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@Gordonjamesheneryproductions]

One send me fatal meeting later

[@oldsquarewheelsproductions]

Well nice knowing you Gordon

[@zack6283]

When Gordon say no at the start I thought that he find out about the dislike on KZbin

[@jacobnelson3953]

He got me in the first half not gonna lie XD I didn’t expect that ending tho.

[@robertrowley4929]

Excellent short Victor. Love the story behind it. Percy being a deviant on OnlyFans was just hilarious. The assumption about the sperm bank robbery and tying it in with Eric’s “secret ingredient” was icing on the cake. Great work as always and can’t wait for the new season.

[@tjmfarming9584]

Last time I made an assumption… well lets just say that’s a story for a whole novel And yes we were bang on right, after the culprit mentioned it

[@ayjaythelnerexpressmixtraf5757]

I never once seen gordon so angry before

[@christianasuncion]

2:52 James: that’s not mad, that’s furious, you alright there, Gordon? Gordon: (screams in fury)

[@frazzianimations9027]

Eric: huh?!

[@christianasuncion]

@@frazzianimations9027 (beats the memes outta him) *one semi fatal beating later*

[@frazzianimations9027]

James: Eric? You dead! Eric: I .. don’t know

[@christianasuncion]

@@frazzianimations9027 Henry: Gordon, what gives?

[@kelanjones7281]

@@christianasuncion I WARNED HIM! I WARNED HIM WHAT HIM WHAT WOULD HAPPEN!

[@Lucat_Here]

Top 10 questions science Cant awncer: 1: how Eric Learn to make good food

[@dustywilliams9797]

Wow! Gordon’s brutal curiosity has really gotten to him this time! Now I feel sorry for Eric! He really has changed! Trying to make up for his mistakes!!! But Gordon! I’m sure he’ll really learns his lesson!!!!!!!!!!

[@Ryder-a-Blaze]

Gordon says “nooooo” like Darth Vader.

[@Ryder-a-Blaze]

Joey: this might be the day I lose faith in the world Me: bro, I lost faith in the world a long time ago.

[@alexfaulkner6275]

I never had faith in the world to begin with.

[@fanofeverything30465]

Things will get better

[@fanofeverything30465]

@@alexfaulkner6275 Things are going to get better

[@johnathanedwards9054]

My brother still believes in the power of humanity, no one can shake his beliefs.

[@fanofeverything30465]

@@johnathanedwards9054 Nice

[@jamessmithandgarrettsmith3623]

Three cheers for Eric. 🙂🙂🙂

[@TTTEFan84]

No one will ever know how Eric made good food Not even Einstein

[@t.bfisher5855]

This was a hilarious Sodor short and I don't know why but the fact Eric actually made something edible and is a little bit worrying lol 🤣🤣🤣 I can't wait for season four part two to return hope the idea isn't dead that was a wonderful show but I understand if the drive has been lost and hopefully you are happy with what you have created and I hope something will come along that is on par or surpasses all your expectations Thank for you for years of enjoyment and actually hilarious content and I hope good fortune come to you in future

[@delishahasmoved5372]

Oh don't worry, last I checked he's finishing up the last episode of the season

[@MrRocklover18]

I seriously felt like i was guna die from this one Very well done 🤣🤣🤣

[@JAProductions494]

One of my favourite Sodor Shorts 😂😂😂

[@TotoDG]

I assumed that, when All Engines Go was announced, Mattel would somehow make something _worse_ than BWBA. *And boy lordy, was I right!*

[@BlooMonkiMan]

Gottem lol

[@yeetboiwhatyesplease2095]

Plz dont fight the United Steak. A soviet Onion on a United Steak would taste delicious

[@codywilliams8251]

SovieyOnion I sure had a lot of fun watching its Season 1, I can't wait for the second season to come out soon.

[@robrice7246]

Was 2:19 your reaction and 2:56 - 3:11 your response to it?

[@NetGreen123]

Oh bother. Poor Gordon, I hope he survives. And I hope we are able to get to try Eric's cookie recipe, it actually sounds pretty good!

[@chocsise]

"what? did whiff release his killer roomba again?" i died

[@NintendoNate1theE2TankEngine]

How many times has he done that?

[@Captain-Rex23]

@@NintendoNate1theE2TankEngine100 times

[@NintendoNate1theE2TankEngine]

Maybe he unleashed it on Nintendo this time.

[@Captain-Rex23]

@@NintendoNate1theE2TankEngine or it’s after you

[@todddavis2041]

YES! What a great short! Loved the Star Wars reference!🤣

[@roaropgard8575]

Glad that Eric did something right😅

[@jenncansell3432]

Crime happens Joey:WHO DARES AWAKEN ME

[@ianfortuna9385]

🥇 you win

[@arenjtumastens]

Ooh, the Galloping Sausage surprise! Wonder what it actually is. And Gordon getting trialed by the coppers reminds me of how it happened in "Smuggling" and "Furness." (Which of course, was really annoying, as that shouldn't have happened to him.)

[@benboy8591]

Hell has frozen over, Eric made something good

[@jodywelds5379]

The voice cracks just make it better 😂

[@jimmybianco8234]

That was one hilarious short

[@cheukyinglau8011]

Just asking, would you like to use the Thomas & Friends models from Sodor Workshops or other Trainz websites🤔😅?

[@gameoholic1994]

3:01 - Where’s the “To be Continued…” meme?

[@cm94returns19]

its been awhile since we seen a sodor short other then the snippets

[@MOHAWKL4A3124]

Gordon: Oh bother Henry: Well nice knowing you Gordon. Me: Yep goodbye. Eric is gonna turn you into Gordon stew

[@joeleboeuf]

Not likely, more like he's going to make Gordon eat it.

[@xerxesjacalan1168]

Really Eric.

[@sudrianrailwaystudios676]

Gordon: NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!” Henry: “Don't you think you're overreacting Gordon?”

[@oliverhood1732]

Gordon: No Henry! If anything I am underreacting. After all of these years, I refuse to believe that Eric, has actually made something…. edible?! Not only edible, but also…. delicious! And cookies of all things?! Wholesome, simple, chocolate chip cookies! They’re absolutely scrumptious! How?! I have to know?

[@sudrianrailwaystudios676]

@@oliverhood1732 Henry: “You have to talk to Eric first…”

[@oliverhood1732]

Eric: I used my secret ingredient.

[@sudrianrailwaystudios676]

@@oliverhood1732 Gordon: “What secret ingredient did you use, Eric?”

[@oliverhood1732]

Eric: I just don’t want to share incase someone steals it.

[@xerxesjacalan1168]

Who is that black engine behind with Joey? 4:08

[@cornholio329]

Lenny is the 1 behind Gordon He taught n took Joey under his wing in his early days Idk who the other 1 is

[@sharksman20rocks]

@@cornholio329 the other one was seen in the sodor short: job

[@DaveTheBlueEngine28]

so who is lenny? the b12 or the tank engine?

[@maxm2317]

The last time I made an assumption was that my current job would suck, and I was right. It DOES suck!

[@arenjtumastens]

Gordon should NOT have done that to Eric!!! That was so wrong! What in crap did he assume Eric's secret ingredient was? He should've mentioned that!

[@eganobrien5544]

All for a chocolate chip cookie.

[@theamericane2655]

My assumption is that the new stories of sodor episodes will be released by or on Christmas. Am I right or wrong?

[@gavinbiller9965]

Never laugh that hard for a long time

[@jamessmithandgarrettsmith3623]

Next time can we know about the “Galloping Sausage Surprise”?

[@TheRealUnderCap]

Have fun being at the shadow realm, Gordon.

[@henrybigGreen]

What the heck aric can make good food and Gordon can be a fighter I don't know if that's great or not

[@SodorTrain1225]

So, let's see who's been shunted over the course of this channel; Thomas, Kate, Johnny Cuba, Diesel, Geoffrey, Oliver, Percy, Peter, Gordon, Eric, George, Bertie, and (possibly) Charlie.

[@cornholio329]

Sheffield as well

[@ssarnold19]

Ohhh that China bit oft 😅 got me bit of a shock there 😂... But bad Percy ! Bad bad bad ! 😂

[@T1_Productions]

“I swore on The Fat Controller’s eminent grave.” “HEY!”

[@muhammadfadhiil5992]

A short of Percy's robbery Hmmmm

[@Shellboi-j6n]

Now someone is gonna commit a Plankton to steal Eric's secret formula. Edit: *Oh dear.* Edit 2: *I want some Gordon ravioli!*

[@marybethricci9495]

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL!

[@yeetboiwhatyesplease2095]

I want to experience having my expectations completely thrown off by trying to consume a surprise product known as a sausage that is gallavanting around like a horse. Does anybody else happen to experience the same emotions about this subject as I do?

[@Sebastian.A_Castro.B_16]

0:33

[@Sebastian.A_Castro.B_16]

2:08

[@Sebastian.A_Castro.B_16]

2:09

[@かいじヘンリー]

4:09～ Oh no

[@Fxhound]

Could ya try to make a video about eric's cooking improvements. I wonder what did he actually do, or not the "semi fatal beating"?

[@clintontambunan8201]

Since when was Eric Darth Vader. Actually he did kill a lot of people. And if Eric is Vader and Gordon is Luke, who the hell if Amidala????? XD

[@someasiandude2008]

hey victor, just a question since you've been making alot of snippets and shorts, are you still working on the stories of sodor?

[@carskedenproductions1491]

Rest in busted buffers Gordon....

[@arenjtumastens]

You know, I've just noticed, as of throughout last month, every new Snippet is uploaded here on a Monday. And the Shorts are on any day. And also the episode previews happen on Tuesdays and the episodes themselves happen on Fridays. Coincidental, ain't it? And speaking of such, really hope the first Season 4, Part 2 episode gets uploaded later this month.

[@yoshidinosaur3070]

Rafiki: Lead to conclusions and you lead to confusions.

[@marcusthetenderengine699]

Hahahaha I lost it at 2:19 Vic, great one! Also I believe that Sodor snippet isn't canon to stories of Sodor right?

[@StarNameKev]

Yes correct

[@suerootes9771]

2:19 kayo when she finds out scott told the hole tracy family about her fear of butterflies

[@DarthWill3]

"Galloping Sausage Surprise". ROFL

[@Dragofrey]

Ahhh I’ve missed sodor shorts

[@arenjtumastens]

Seriously, Gordon's attitude at the beginning was really messed up. And whoa, he really got steamed up later on, literally.

[@aviation_2009]

"Search your feelings,you know it's true!" "Noooooooooooooo!

[@GreenbrookValleyLines]

4:40 that was when Gordon lost the right to freak

[@bluebellsfan8704]

This was awesome! Great video (R.I.P Gordon)

[@stephenfarthing1522]

Uh oh! Eric has found out what the secret ingredient! - oh no ! He hasn't!

[@ARTSONICFAN990]

Me: Well. For once, Eric has done something delicious... And without committing murder or any other crime. Not cool assuming that Eric STOLE those cookies without any proof, Gordon. NOT cool.

[@雪者]

Me: Whaaaat?

[@ARTSONICFAN990]

@@雪者 Me: And the worst part is... *I eat some of Eric's cookies.* IT WAS PERCY WHO DID THE ROBBERY!

[@雪者]

@@ARTSONICFAN990 Me: Dang. The unexpectedness. Sephiroth: Hm. May I have one?

[@ARTSONICFAN990]

@@雪者 Dr. Eggman: Me too. Eric: Sure. There's enough for everybody.

[@雪者]

@@ARTSONICFAN990 Sephiroth: Hm. Neat. *he eats one*

[@RWSARTIST_A1]

1:12 when your brother takes something that’s yours and won’t give it back

[@rottenroads1982]

Zane the Br Class D16/2 diesel: “Aw crap. Gordon could of just asked Eric about the secret recipe but instead he though it was something else after he talked to Joey. I would like to try a cookie and so would my friends. Also, I would love to have a discussion with Percy about how Pornography is a Sinful act that should have never existed”.

[@TheEmeraldMinecart26]

1:40 hmm I wander what Eric's secre- OH oh no poor Eric😢😥

[@jameskarg3240]

I make assumptions a lot... and often, the reality is WORSE

[@romanxfire5thepokemondude457]

Next stories of sodor: introduce Bertram.

[@ericconway5525]

This is so hilarious