SOG Ether & Provider FX Defy All Logic!!!

[@MrBoomie00]

I'm glad these companies are moving back to thinner stock. I don't need everything to double as a crowbar.

[@WutangPham]

I completely agree, “survival” influences knives with quarter inch stock with convex edges and low saber or scandi grinds. Makes a “knife” that’s good at batoning, but it sucks at being a knife.

[@gideonstactical]

For real!

[@edanpino-xt1ph]

I’ve always preferred moderately thick stock, maybe .150-.180”, with a full flat or a high saber grind. I like things to be a bit overbuilt because I’m paranoid about my #1 tool being damaged or destroyed

[@MrBoomie00]

@@edanpino-xt1ph I feel ya. But I prefer full flat or high sabers as well. But if had to go with one option, I'd still prefer 0.125-0.15p0 in CPM3V or a high Rockwell Magnacut. Just got a SurviveKnives GSO 4.5 Bushcraft in that's 0.115 in 3V and I'm in love.

[@edanpino-xt1ph]

@@MrBoomie00 I wouldn’t be, and only because I hate a blade length of less than 5”. I don’t know why, I just feel like anything shorter is too little for me. I’ve used plenty of 4.5” and under blades, but they don’t do as much as a 5” can do

[@charlescollier7217]

Thanks for this, Aaron. As a competitive option, I submit for your consideration, the Ruike Hornet. Similarly skeletonized, slim handle, classic, beautiful drop point, better sheath system, thicker, but very efficient 14C28N blade.

[@realbroggo]

Never used these blades but I do have and use a couple of Ruike F815 Hornet blades which are very similar in size and style. I have been very surprised by the size and style - easy to carry and very nimble to use. I've been surprised with how many hiking & camp tasks that they get done. I'll just say don't be put off by the size and give one a go. Sharp blades all.

[@cylentone]

Nice - good steel too 14C28N at only $50. Thanks for the tip.

[@SparkieJ]

As if your channel couldn’t get better, this new music you introduced this year, adds a level of sophistication.

[@gideonstactical]

Glad you enjoy it!! Thank u so much

[@leoshrbek7926]

skvelé představení nožu a ještě dva najednou po Sog Recondo ,Sog Pillar ....bych pořidil jako Edc Provider fx...vypadá dobře hlavně i ocel 154 CM přeji hodně podobnych videíííí

[@Mike-id8gu]

Another strong video. I agree with your summation that SOG seems to be continuing to move in the right direction and keep their brand fresh with new concepts and new Steels. A bit late to the game on these two introductions as I picked up a Buck 630GRS PakLite and really enjoy it as a pocket EDC. It rotates along with an Izula and Candiru, but they are both 1095 so my PakLite always wins the day on rainy or humid weather days.

[@brianbender8752]

What's the od green fixed on the board behind you

[@gideonstactical]

Cold Steel Lynn Thompson Signature Kobun drop point s35vn

[@patrickmulligan3101]

Great review Aaron. I still haven’t seen one that beats my Izula s35vn. Made in USA. Smaller and more versatile. Maybe not something I’d want to go on a 5 day hike with, but certainly an edc perfection for fixed blade. I’m always in the market for others tho! God bless

[@gideonstactical]

That was is a good one!!

[@itywhat6499]

Thanks for the info. I like the thin blades. I also have the MKC Speedgoat. It's my go-to fly fishing knife that I attach to my waders. Another knife I would compare, although heavier, is the Benchmade Happy Canyon Hunter. However, I will check these knives out. I'm always looking for another knife to include in my rotation.

[@gideonstactical]

Nice, like the speed goat so far

[@itywhat6499]

Yes, I have the magnacut version @@gideonstactical

[@brutalbrital]

I am a big fan of small knives, these are tough little knives thanks for that review

[@Jarrych83]

I have to disagree about the buck paklite update. I have the caper and find that the shape and finishing on the handle makes it extremely comfortable and ergonomic in use and the weird little micro scale thing actually works great for variou grips. I've done a mountain of "paring knife" type food prep with and used it as an EDC fixed blade for a couple of months and never felt like the handle was uncomfortable or had strange hot spots. The variety of new skeletonized options is nice and it's good seeing different approaches to it, as you'll never get a single best option with these kinds of knives, but my experience with a moderate term use test was pretty dang good with the buck line.

[@jarvisskooge8602]

Good review... I've always enjoyed your channel.

[@gideonstactical]

I appreciate that!

[@martinerhard8447]

If you want lightweight yet durable blades then check out UG tools those are next level

[@roadkill4572]

When are you reviewing the MKC Speedgoat? If you are able, you should also check out Mission Knives. Especially the MPU or MBK. I would live to hear your opinion.

[@isaacs_knives_and_knowledge]

I'm really liking these knives. I've watched this probably like 6 times since you posted it. Would be nice to see them compared to the Buck Alpha series knives you reviewed too

[@therealfilthyanimal]

Awesome vid!!! Thank you 🙏🏽

[@gideonstactical]

My pleasure!!

[@cylentone]

Benchmade Altitude might also be a larger lightweight option...

[@jasondiddle4226]

Ok!!! Important question! If money was not a factor. Would you get the kizer mini harpoon or the SOG Provider fx?????

[@gideonstactical]

@@jasondiddle4226 harpoon 👍

[@jasondiddle4226]

What steel? The 3v?

[@jasondiddle4226]

What steel? The 3v?

[@claymcbunch1013]

One sweet slicer

[@gideonstactical]

They are fast!!

[@lamarwilliams185]

Great review

[@The4cp]

I wish SOG would remember it's roots. This new stuff is all right but how about a 7 inch Pilar and an upgrade to the Seal Team and other tactical knives. There's more than just camping.

[@gideonstactical]

Totally, I believe they are working on an updated pillar

[@DullAntler]

What's your thoughts on the Swisstech Stahlern?

[@gideonstactical]

Not sure we will see

[@DL-ij7tf]

Ooh I second this suggestion. I got one and it's really nice. The smooth titanium finish isn't durable but that's okay with me.

[@dlrmon1]

Your making me break you’re own rule! “Under 4” Folder...over 4” fixed”. Thankfully I made my own rule. I told myself I’m not going to buy another under 4” fixed blade until my TJ Overland you talked me into gets dull...lol

[@gideonstactical]

Wonderful!

[@charlessalmond7076]

I likey!

[@taylorfishman823]

I like those but I'm not a fan of the price. The whole clip system being so complex looking makes me feel like I'm overpaying for the R&D on that rather than just a nice well-made little knife from Taiwan. And that makes it doubly unfortunate that the screw mounts for the clip can be manually moved like you showed. Nice to see they did a good job on heat treat though, that counts for a lot.

[@morganclairdayii5609]

Really like both of the knives. But the sheaths are the downfall. I do not like how the belt clips will just rotate on you...SOG give us some good sheaths and better prices!

[@randyyeager]

they'd be good for neck knives, but I dislike those pocket clips, handle would be diggin' into your ribs....

[@panagiotissoufliotis6558]

if the Provider was at 80-90 d price , it could be as an option at my buying list, but for me is a bit overpriced.

[@gideonstactical]

Ya price and clip are the two detractors.

[@rtz549]

Get a bk23 for $12 for review.

[@eyeofthetiger4184]

G'day Aaron, ok, light weight, svelte, (good for concealment), and height to width ratio does come into the equation, however ........ they look to be slimmer handled than the vast majority of my folders. Certainly cant complain about the steel choices, though SOG, IMO, is another that need to be more competitive across every facet of a knife/sheath package. Re; "skeletonised" yeah if you must, though to be honest, I'd rather see it internal, ..... i.e not see it at all, ; ) surely full, and a bit beefier scales, wont add too much weight and provide a better experience ergonomically and cleaning wise .......... and furthermore ..... It's bad enough with spydy holes, and various slots, ........... now we've got finely perforated blades ........ and stainless or not, ... I need a good stiff drink ... immediately ; ) Btw; Joker continues to nail it, if I were looking for such a compact fixy, I'd be jumping on that one. Cheers Duke.

[@timjk32]

those knives r worth 100 tops

[@Chrisdolin]

Yo Aaron awesome as ALWAYS…!!! Not sure if I like these knives… but check it out…. Do me a favor and check out Shed Knives…! I and I bet a lot of other knife enthusiasts would dig your thoughts on this dudes knives… I wanna pull the trigger but still waiting on more inventory cause he can’t keep them in stock… ✌️ out homie..! Hope you have a good weekend..!

[@gideonstactical]

I will do just that

[@joemisak7925]

Way too expensive

[@gideonstactical]

Ya they are steep, but that isn’t now!!! 😢