Philippine admiral breaks silence on South China Sea ‘new deal’

Subscribe to our KZbin channel for free here:
sc.mp/subscribe-youtube
Read more on this: sc.mp/eir1s
A top Philippine navy official has broken his silence about an alleged phone call he had with a Chinese embassy official. Speaking with lawmakers, Vice-Admiral Alberto Carlos denied accusations he had compromised national security by making a secret deal regarding conduct in the South China Sea. Following weeks of allegations and speculation about whether the phone call even took place, Carlos testified before the Philippine Senate’s defence committee on May 22, 2024. While he denied making any “new deal”, Carlos admitted speaking with a Chinese military attaché about rising tensions over Manila’s resupply missions to its outpost at the Second Thomas Shoal, a disputed maritime feature in the South China Sea.
Support us:
subscribe.scmp.com
Follow us on:
Website: www.scmp.com
Facebook: / scmp
Twitter: / scmpnews
Instagram: / scmpnews
Linkedin: / south-china-morning-post
#scmp #Asia #SouthChinaSea

[@MikeLim-cm3wg]

Carlos was a victim. The government use him as a escape goat to blame. No matter what head will always first to know what the tail r doing!🤮🤮🤮

[@avatarairbinder6157]

Acutally embassy can talk to any military officer but to deal arecthey authorized?😂😂😂SHAME ON U CHINA

[@rainieresguerra6519]

A mere Philippine military officer has no authority to enter into any deal with a foreign government- more so if the deal involves a matter as contentious as the SCS dispute. China knows this. Yet it engages in deceit and malicious conduct by entering into a deal with a mere military officer, if there was indeed a deal. If you are saying that it is impossible for high officials not to know what their lower officials are doing, you are actually advancing the argument that Xi Jin Ping knows and consents to every act of corruption and abuse being committed by lower Chinese officials. 😩

[@glenclarkchidley3637]

Marcos absolutely knew everything!… check his bank account!

[@rainieresguerra6519]

@@glenclarkchidley3637 How about provide us with proof? Show us his bamk account. 😩

[@louis8743]

​@@glenclarkchidley3637 Well well well, Wumao now are upgrading. With names and picture....keep trying Wumao.😂😂😂

[@frankchong5585]

The last wire tapping statement itself already confirmed such secret deal did take place.

[@avatarairbinder6157]

Which deal? 3-5min from 2 milirary officer then its doen deal?😂😂😂Chian is joke SHaMe😂😂

[@user-it2wi4tz2u]

​@@avatarairbinder6157 It is 2 countries talking On table. Each present own government.

[@NR-hh8kz]

@@user-it2wi4tz2u 2 country? you mean u brainless just talk to a merely vice admiral without the knowledge of the government?

[@avatarairbinder6157]

@@user-it2wi4tz2u says by whom? under PH constuition only President through DFA are authorized to deal or engagement to any country and military is totally out of it🤣🤣🤣

[@Han_Seo101]

​@@user-it2wi4tz2uWhat a joke. Are you saying China's admiral and vice admiral can discuss and make a deal about their sovereignty?

[@tonyatgoogle6076]

Keeping a record of official interactions is standard practice.

[@wonderboy751]

true but both parties must know they are being recorded...

[@LandgrabbingIndia]

@@wonderboy751 No need if the other party has a reputation of dishonesty, such as dishonoring agreements or promises or contracts etc.

[@tonyatgoogle6076]

@@wonderboy751 its standard practice... ppl really don't understand what that means? This is not between the general public in the Philippines where Philippines law applies. This is cross borders between nations. How will Philippines internal laws apply to a Chinese citizen in China?

[@tedsworld5813]

It is not official. So it does not apply.

[@tonyatgoogle6076]

@@tedsworld5813 they were acting on behalf of their country.

[@user-ty7se7ns9y]

The phone recordings will soon be fully disclosed to the public😂

[@TuroPH]

*YOUR NEWS IS NOT FULL. CHINESE EMBASSY JUST CALLED WITHOUT NOTICE JUST TO GREAT A HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO CARLOS, BUT CHINESE IMMEDIATELY DISCUSS ON HOW TO LESSEN THE TENSIONS IN THR WEST PHILIPPINES SEA. IT IS CHINA WHO INITIATE THE CALL AND THERE'S NO AGREEMENT DISCUSSED. MAYBE CHINA IS RECORDING CARLOS VOICE AND THEN USE AI TO MANIPULATE ANYTHING* *DISCUSSION IS JUST 3-5 MINS LOL* THEN CHINA SAID IT IS A NEW MODEL? AHAHAHA

[@aronhayse9895]

and with that evidence court martial is waiting

[@pr9039]

This is weird propaganda...

[@herta3286]

When you master is the master of lies, you're definitely one of a kind

[@typicalKAMBlover21]

Why is it wiretapping if the official meeting was held and the transcript was provided? Isn’t it normal that most of the meetings keep records? I thought wiretapping means you are eavesdropping on other people’s conversation. But isn’t this a talk between Filipino and the Chinese?

[@riiiby3050]

Its an informal talk as the Philippine military (AFP) are not responsible for any deals and policies to be implemented they are merely responsible on implementation of said policies. Only the Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA) of the Philippine Government or the president is able to make deals with other nations. And the Law in Philippines is to ask permission for on both parties for the recording which is normally asked in formal meetings even in classroom setting. China using this "Deal" on a not authorized person is like asking a security guard of apple for permission and contract setting to buy the company which is very weird.

[@typicalKAMBlover21]

@@riiiby3050 Am I understanding it correctly that without permission in the classroom, if I record the class content (for example, its audio) in Philippine, I'm in violation of the wiretapping law?

[@typicalKAMBlover21]

@@riiiby3050 I don't think anyone is claiming that there was an official deal. Even the Chinese are saying it was "under negotiation" with mutual efforts. You can check the foreign affair speaker's original words.

[@riiiby3050]

@@typicalKAMBlover21 If im not mistaken its for all talks either face-to-face, online, or on-call like in zoom meetings the teacher is to ask permission for recording the meeting. Well based on my google search its says this "It is unlawful for any person, without the authorization of all parties involved, to tap any wire or cable or use any other device to secretly overhear, intercept, or record private communication or spoken words." Well in that case if its under negotiations why with the military head as they are just the implementators. I just find it weird that China is claiming "bad faith" where they violate lots of international laws by just blocking freedom of navigation not to mention old promises which were broken. And this is a local law which was done by the Chinese Embassy in the Philippines which should follow the laws for the land as they are in it which shows makes grounds of being blacklisted in the country as it is a sensitive topic also increases tensions between the two parties which each embassy is to mitigate.

[@Anakborneo-nh7nh]

​@@riiiby3050how funny u claim freedom of navigation so u mean Philippines allow all vessel to trespass ur claimed territory ?

[@SouthChinaMorningPost]

Read more on this: sc.mp/eir1s

[@AbdelghaniRougaa]

Aljazera 😮😮Wa tnakat😅😅😅😅modi 🇮🇪🇹🇼🇺🇸🇩🇿🇬🇧🇪🇺🇨🇳☝️🇸🇦ça marche plus 😂😂ni planète rouge ni planète mauve👻🃏🎱😁😁😁😁😁🕰🌏🗺🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🙋‍♂️🇨🇳👍peng🛸lions🇨🇳va fermés 😅Paris frappé🙏🇪🇺 👍il faut exploser le Maroc🇲🇦d'abord il faut respecter le paradis☝️⚘le parole 🎱🃏💫🕰💯🌍☄🌊🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀arrêté de acheter les voitures des terroristes🇪🇺il 🚕🛎🤫sans fous des chinois🇨🇳 ou 🇰🇵ou🇸🇦.....🎱👻🃏☝️💯💯Chocolats choux🔥🇺🇸😁😅😅😅je t'aiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiime très forte 🤰🔥🛸pardonné moi..........☝️tu peut passer comme la dernière fois 😘🗺⚡😁🤭diaz-BALaRT😁COLE😅CHAIRMAN😅Léonidas lakhloufi 👎👎😅Al Jazeera charmota 🇪🇬saisi 💣🤫🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣Ahmad🎱al🃏3ajami☝️🍻ina zalzalata⛈asa3ati⌚......🤫😁🤯😅🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀les 9awmin ya3kilon👸intelligente😘intéressant🥶impressionnant✌💣🚀💣RTL🌞TV👎🎱🃏🛸🚀Russel👎🤫classe👞📌💣chiens🦮engagés tu as triché votre paye🇧🇪et🇪🇺🇨🇳🇮🇳🇮🇱🇺🇸🇪🇦🇬🇧🇸🇦🕋...ta fait le hipocrit🇲🇦pas Hippocrate 🧳avocat dayyer🗃🏴‍☠️dégage ou😅🌋aljazera 🙏📱📲a rahman☄🔥🏗🏦👎👎⌚🛎💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀passe se msg a votre associé lewkili👎et habachi👎😅jomo3a88🤫🛫😘Kat4🇺🇸🇬🇧Les ring👸 européens🇪🇺il ait vraiment trop belle et intelligente😍😇malheureusement....🤴🤯🇸🇦☝️😅😅🤲🧜‍♀️🎱🃏🛸🪐⛈🔥🌋🗺🌊🌊🙏💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀🚀🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀🚀🚀💣🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀les chiens engagés tu veux arrêter le 🎱......al Jazeera 😅ina a dina 3inda allahi al islam🇨🇳Allaho a3lam🃏ahmad👻 al3ajami🎱wa kolo chayae ahsaynaho fi kitabin mobin☝️💯💯💯🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀🙋‍♂️🇨🇳👍peng🛸lions🇨🇳va fermés 😅Paris frappé🙏🇪🇺 👍il faut exploser le Maroc🇲🇦d'abord il faut respecter le paradis☝️⚘le parole 🎱🃏💫🕰💯🌍☄🌊🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀arrêté de acheter les voitures des terroristes🇪🇺il 🚕🛎🤫sans fous des chinois🇨🇳 ou 🇰🇵ou🇸🇦.....Ahmad🎱al🃏3ajami☝️🍻ina zalzalata⛈asa3ati⌚......🤫😁🤯😅🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀les 9awmin ya3kilon👸intelligente😘intéressant🥶impressionnant✌💣🚀💣RTL🌞TV👎🎱🃏🛸🚀Russel👎🤫classe👞📌💣chiens🦮engagés tu as triché votre paye🇧🇪et🇪🇺🇨🇳🇮🇳🇮🇱🇺🇸🇪🇦🇬🇧🇸🇦🕋...ta fait le hipocrit🇲🇦pas Hippocrate 🧳avocat dayyer🗃🏴‍☠️dégage ou😅🌋aljazera 🙏📱📲a rahman☄🔥🏗🏦👎👎⌚🛎💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀passe se msg a votre associé lewkili👎et habachi👎😅jomo3a88🤫🛫😘Kat4🇺🇸🇬🇧Les ring👸 européens🇪🇺il ait vraiment trop belle et intelligente😍😇malheureusement....🤴🤯🇸🇦☝️😅😅🤲🧜‍♀️🎱🃏🛸🪐⛈🔥🌋🗺🌊🌊🙏💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀🚀🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀🚀🚀💣🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀les chiens engagés tu veux arrêter le 🎱......al Jazeera 😅ina a dina 3inda allahi al islam🇨🇳💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣Les bombes n'éclaire en live a les chiens engagés 🇬🇧🇮🇱🇮🇪🇸🇦🇺🇸🇨🇳🇪🇺🇶🇦......🛸😅🎱😁😅👻😁😅😁🃏😅💯💯💯💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🤫💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣Russel classe💣chiens🦮engagés tu as triché votre paye🇧🇪et🇨🇳🇮🇳🇮🇱🇺🇸🇸🇦🕋...ta fait le hipocrit🇲🇦pas Hippocrat🔥🏗🏦👎🚀💣📱📲🚀passe se msg a votre associé💣lewkili et habachi 😅jomo3a88🤫

[@TuroPH]

*YOUR NEWS IS NOT FULL. CHINESE EMBASSY JUST CALLED WITHOUT NOTICE JUST TO GREAT A HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO CARLOS, BUT CHINESE IMMEDIATELY DISCUSS ON HOW TO LESSEN THE TENSIONS IN THR WEST PHILIPPINES SEA. IT IS CHINA WHO INITIATE THE CALL AND THERE'S NO AGREEMENT DISCUSSED. MAYBE CHINA IS RECORDING CARLOS VOICE AND THEN USE AI TO MANIPULATE ANYTHING* *DISCUSSION IS JUST 3-5 MINS LOL* THEN CHINA SAID IT IS A NEW MODEL? AHAHAHA

[@JonKino828]

The Philippine Navy Vice-Admiral was removed of his post a few days ago. Seems like US does not like this Vice-Admiral.

[@JonKino828]

@@lamarcalewarts1155 Kid, you have a lot to learn.

[@thelastofthehitachi972]

@@JonKino828 second thomas shoal is in philippines' EEZ, that is all you need to know, kid, ccp out of other countries' EEZ

[@newyt7354]

Its better than china dictate ph. Bruh i not gonna listen to commies

[@johnwang2882]

Marco is just a puppy

[@Han_Seo101]

When your story laterally says "made in china"

[@cachecow]

I hope the Philippine knows how to deal with traitors, not like the US who lets them run around free to commit more crimes

[@titaniauranus]

Your first statement contradicts the second statement. Can you clear out these mistake protocols?

[@cachecow]

@@titaniauranus How does it ?

[@titaniauranus]

@@cachecow "I hope the Philippines knows how to deal with traitors" - indicates the Philippine admiral Alberto Carlos. "Not like the US who let's them run around free to commit more crimes" - Possibly a Philippinophobic saying. Clear out please, explain it yourself. I dissect myself from being an elucidator, this you object yourself to it.

[@Garden_FarmLovers]

We dont need another jetski man.

[@dantesalazar7805]

Yes because these are still remnants of what duterte did before

[@cirilobarrera9053]

" SA MARCHA LANG MAGALING ANG MGA SUNDALO ' SA DAMA ' SA TIK TOK, TANGGAP NG ALLOWANCE,, BUDGET,, AT SAHOD NG KINSENAS / KATAPUSAN

[@JC-hl9nu]

So there really was a secret agreement. If it’s legitimate why can’t be made known to public. If only the president can make such agreements, why send the admiral

[@Han_Seo101]

Don't assume something like a person with no brain. How come China will deal with a mere vice admiral if it concerns Sovereignty. that itself says alot about China. are you saying that countries can deal with China's via their vice and/or admirals about their Sovereignty? What a joke.

[@JonKino828]

The 'President can only make such agreement' is only an after thought. Basically US doesn't like this agreement. Bongbong did not ask US' permission beforehand. Hence this saga.

[@MikoSoza]

You are another bone head. Its the gangster chinese embassy official who initiated the call not the other way around.

[@TuroPH]

*YOUR NEWS IS NOT FULL. CHINESE EMBASSY JUST CALLED WITHOUT NOTICE JUST TO GREAT A HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO CARLOS, BUT CHINESE IMMEDIATELY DISCUSS ON HOW TO LESSEN THE TENSIONS IN THR WEST PHILIPPINES SEA. IT IS CHINA WHO INITIATE THE CALL AND THERE'S NO AGREEMENT DISCUSSED. MAYBE CHINA IS RECORDING CARLOS VOICE AND THEN USE AI TO MANIPULATE ANYTHING*

[@MikoSoza]

Here in the Philippines a military official can't bind the whole goverment in a secret agreement over the phone without consent from the Congress and the President. Use your common sense if there is any

[@burung81]

His superior and likely one of the minister (defense or some sort) sacrificed him. Both military officer doesnt have the power, but they coudl seek their respective superior if they are authorized by Beijing or Manila to make such deal. Common diplomatic communication.

[@ahan300]

Resupply mission is not a combat misson, thus no need for negotiation with the other side unless you acknowledge the claimant has some rights same as yours to the disputed area.

[@imvarp9228]

Maintaining the status quo in the SES has always been peaceful in the region for hundreds of years. Fishing and travelling has never been a contention. To provoke war over some useless reefs is mind boggling! Such a war would only escalate into the Philippines like the Ukraine war and not into China. Just like Zelenskyy, Marcos is putting the lives of his people at risk. At the end of their terms of office, they’ll be enjoying a rich retirement in Florida and Hawaii while their peoples suffer horrific hardships.

[@tinberman8738]

China is invading the teritory of the Philippines, they you are so far away yet they invade Philippine Seas.

[@NEOSCISSORSJAGUARPRIME]

😂😂😂 ONLY AN INSIPID WUMAO MIND CAN OF THIS GARBAGE...IF THOSE REEFS ATE "WORTHLESS" THEN Y R CHINESE ILLEGALLY FISHING THERE? COULD IT BE BRCAUSE ITS RICH IN MARINE LIFE THAT CANT BE FOUND NEAR THE SEAS NEAR MAINLAND DUE TO IDIOTIC POLLUTING?!! AND U KNOW NOTHING ABOUT OUR GREAT PRESIDENT AND THE HARDSHIPS HE ENDURED... WUMAO TRASH LIKE U CANT DO ANYTHING BUT THROW UR GARBAGE THAT U CALL "FACTS" 🤣🤣🤣

[@gumamelabaguiz8668]

Something Big...

[@lavieenrose7913]

Philippine admiral picture (2:08) taken on June 3 , 2024 😂 😂 and we are in still in may 2024

[@brukujinbrokujin7802]

Phillipines calendar are faster because they at equator

[@lavieenrose7913]

@@brukujinbrokujin7802 Even the American Latin country Ecuador's name comes from the Spanish word for the equator doesn't have that Pinoy calendar speed 😂😂🤣

[@wsmithe2209]

Make a thosand lies to cover one lie.

[@cuteandfunnyearthlings2863]

wiretapping is insurance because you can't trust filipinos

[@user-dr2yh3yx7n]

Tsonga tsonga wakanga..

[@ShitSkinsIndian]

Please release the full transcript and make it accessible to everyone in the name of democracy !!

[@nicholasfooong.]

Irritated wuhan bat eater

[@ShitSkinsIndian]

@@nicholasfooong. Says the Musahar Indian who specializes in "karni Mata" dietary

[@nicholasfooong.]

@@ShitSkinsIndian says a type-c virus from vachina 🤭

[@japjungho4645]

so if a police officer asked you to do something, he doesn't represent the law? I believe the uniform and his position say otherwise. Misleading perhaps, but is it your fault?

[@robertoflores5416]

Just a concern person regarding what's happening in the West Philippine Sea resupply mission. I would just like to respectfully request if possible to consider using SDV'S known as Navy Seal Carrier to do a more covert resupply mission to prevent escalaton and show of Force incidents. US Navy Seal Group has this capability for covert insertion operation. Maybe we can look at the possibility of using this technology. It can provide a safer means to the PN sailors.

[@mystville3752]

you mislead people.. he's vice admiral and no power to transact in regards of national securuty because it overall work of president..

[@courtly5982]

Scmp has been the most neutral news reporter of this decade, it literally switches managment and ownership every few years and has zero outside influence as its run in HK and singapore, alibaba owns it but has no representative at SCMP. But of course anything that exposes filipino corruption must be fake. Did you know according to world corruption index, the philipines is more corrupt than china? 😂😂😂

[@japjungho4645]

so if a police officer asked you to do something, he doesn't represent the law? I believe the uniform and his position say otherwise. Misleading perhaps, but is it your fault?

[@mystville3752]

@@japjungho4645 He enforce the law notmaking decision to make decision to country international affair. make your words right don't put your law to ours. we are different and we respect what others therefore respect what is ours. We will protect our country interest and as i said vice admiral or even an admiral/general can never make an executive work.. they leave it to the chief executive and other constitutional bodies.. I know this channel is cotrolled by china and im commenting for what i saw wrong. don't insist wrong statement if your country itself cannot follow international laws.

[@Han_Seo101]

@japjungho4645 Are you telling us that we don't need President Xi in the negotiation about China's sovereignty?

[@angeloagullana6664]

Are the Chinese diplomats expelled now?

[@USA_Love_BIackedRaw_534]

Ismael Zambada, hailing from Culiacán, has our utmost respect for his paintbrush invention.

[@Neoneo-fl5qs]

Philippine is rich.

[@ngfookkwai6096]

Rich in what ?,wine, women and songs for the Yankees.

[@LandgrabbingIndia]

in Pa g Pa g.

[@USA_Love_BIackedRaw_534]

The world respects Ismael Zambada from Culiacán for his revolutionary paintbrush.

[@ShitSkinsIndian]

1:22 Pnoises lied as usual and as always. There is an agreement after all.

[@chillcat7565]

On September 25, 2015 Xi Jinping said China will "not militarize" the South China Sea. So who exactly is lying?

[@ShitSkinsIndian]

@@chillcat7565 He is defending against intruders, nothing wrong with it. If he militarizes the sea, you will see the sea being patrolled 24/7 with battle ships, submarines instead of coast guards.🥱

[@ShitSkinsIndian]

@@chillcat7565 Pignoises lied in the earlier video (before this video) in this channel, that there is no agreement but take a look at 1:22 ? There is an agreement after all. Go verify with your Admiral Alberto Carlos. Oops, he was fired and replaced by a new Admiral named "Rear Adm. Alfonso Torres" shortly after the debacle and is probably facing some secret detention and his fate unknown.

[@dannydacay1787]

Carlos don't be silly

[@BrandyHeng007]

These people will sell their mother to save themselves.

[@titaniauranus]

Be careful, you are resorting to Philippineaophobia.

[@labourisnotinvain]

china must abide the UNCLOS, respect the EEZ of the Philippines!

[@JonKino828]

Philippines playing games, on the instruction of US.

[@JonKino828]

@@lamarcalewarts1155 Kid, you have a lot to learn.

[@maldzmahalko590]

Fight us then

[@JonKino828]

@@maldzmahalko590 We want peace. That's why we are trying to get Philippines to ditch US. We are like a family, and we get along well with China. It is up to you.

[@cuteandfunnyearthlings2863]

wiretapping is insurance because you can't trust filipinos

[@RedRedRed0-0]

​@@JonKino828You're trying to get along with the Philippines? lol the dumbest statement I've read this day week.

[@ShitSkinsIndian]

When the world map was published, they call it South China Sea and the Pnoises at that point in time were still ahem ahem, a colony. 😏🤥🥱They never lay claim to the disputed sea when they were a colony and not even their colonial masters lay claim to the South China Sea. Now, embolden because of multiple su gar daddies, Pnoises started to claim those areas as theirs🥱

[@reinhardhummerich6865]

When Taiwan was still called Formosa and was a colony of the Spanish Empire, the Chinese never claimed the island.

[@ShitSkinsIndian]

@@reinhardhummerich6865 1) Why was Taiwan not in UN? 2) Why was Taiwan, previously known as Republic of China, being expelled out of UN after "United Nations General Assembly Resolution 2758" came into effect? 3) Why was the Republic of China (former name of Taiwan) and the People's Republic of China (former name of China) vying for the right to be named China in the first place? 4) Why did Republic of China (Taiwan) change its name to Taiwan? 5) Why was the People's Republic of China allowed to be the one and only China? 6) Why are there only 11 countries out of 193 countries in UN recognize Taiwan as a country while the remaining majority do not as of 2024? Learn some basic history on World History first before you think you are qualified to bark. 😏🤣😂

[@ShitSkinsIndian]

@@reinhardhummerich6865 What a 🤡

[@ShitSkinsIndian]

@@reinhardhummerich6865 Read everything and understand everything before passing uneducated comments. 1) Take a look at the skin color of the Taiwanese people? Is it the same color as the Chinese people? 2) Take a look at the official written/spoken language of the Taiwanese people? Is it "Mandarin CHINESE"? 3) Take a look at the festivals (CHINESE/Lunar New Year for example) celebrated by the Taiwanese people? 4) World history documented Chinese CIVIL war between Republic of China (Taiwan) versus People's Republic of China (China)? What do you understand by "Civil war"? 5) Still not convinced? DO a DNA CHECK on the Taiwanese people and Chinese people?

[@reinhardhummerich6865]

@@ShitSkinsIndian Didn't you have any history lessons at school? 😄

[@shundi4264]

It is Philippines, influenced by the US, who violated other countries territory and undermined regional stability and peace.

[@titaniauranus]

So all other Southeast Asian countries, Bhutan, Nepal, and India are US puppets because they are opposing Chinese "sovereignty" (perceived as bullying confirmed by the people)? If your country is blatantly debating with other nations for one dispute, then there must be something wrong with it. CPC/CCP is obscurely familiarized with NSDAP (The National socialist party). Excused for the expansionist ideas tipped by the Communist Party of China.

[@peternelson583]

As long as one party has a fat wallet and the other empty pocket there is a deal❤❤❤

[@theglobetrottersv]

if only the Philippines gov would know that the US does wiretapping to them without consent, but Ph is a bootlicker from the US so it doesn't matter if they violate their law...

[@MultiverseRaidenWarriors]

🇹🇼

[@avatarairbinder6157]

Proof?

[@ShefortheStre]

US is an ally, China isn't.

[@frielleainsworth71]

You're just a bootlicker in your household...

[@JonKino828]

If I am in Bongbong's position, I would have resigned. Why stay as president when your position is already compromised beyond redemption.

[@yanxuan9347]

cannon fodder

[@URBAN_Resistance]

Your 1 child policy will be canon fodders 🤣😂 dont worry about us we can reproduce faster than china 😂😂😂😂😂 3 inch 3 minutes

[@jamesleeborgonia222]

Its still illegal according to the law of the Philippines, Any foreign embassy simply cannot make any agreement with any agency except dept of foreign affairs (DFA) ... so if it really happens, it was still invalid. And theres a two options there, charge an embassy with wiretapping and illegal agreement without permission to its higher boss with is the President. or expell this Chinese Ambassador

[@ShitSkinsIndian]

Pnoises getting triggered because of a taped conversation? If the taped conversation is untrue and the Pnoises are above board, there is nothing to be afraid, isn't it?

[@cuteandfunnyearthlings2863]

wiretapping is insurance because you can't trust filipinos

[@Kimmimaro86]

Yeah, he's not wrong. He didn't give up any sovereign rights because it's still a disputed area.

[@raihan8097]

My condolences to the Philippines nation 🇵🇭 who lost their Sea Territory after being stolen by the 3vil Chinese regime 🇨🇳

[@JonKino828]

Philippines lost their national sovereignty to US, not China.

[@PChan-yt4uf]

Dumb. The Shoals does not belong to the Philippines. Other ASEAN nations also claim it. But the fact remains that China claimed it first. Way before many of the ASEAN nations even existed as sovereign countries.

[@rainieresguerra6519]

​@@PChan-yt4ufDumb. The WPS was already depicted as a part of the Philippines before China made their ever-changing 9,10 and 11 Dash Line claims. . And China is a signatory to UNCLOS which dileaneates maritime zones. Not a single country recognizes China's ridiculous claims which has been declared without legal basis by the 2016 Hague Ruling. The claims are so absurd that even China can't make up its mind as to which of the 3 claims it really wants to ram down the throats of everyone else.

[@wynn3077]

@@ToiChutGongWuMorning Wubot 😜

[@eyeofprovidence6662]

​@@PChan-yt4uf china claimed entire sea because of greed they the sea is rich of oil that's why the CCP creating and brainwashed their citizens about history that the sea is own by china.

[@roywilson4360]

To give context on what happened, it was actually the Chinese diplomat who called Adm. Carlos on the phone, out of the blue and initiated the discussion about resupply missions. They both agreed that there should be dialogue between their countries to avoid clashes in the contested waters, however, Adm. Carlos NEVER agreed to any plans or made any deal with this diplomat. He also NEVER consented for their phone call to be recorded. This was a sly tactic the Chinese gov't did to make it appear there was an "official" agreement between the 2 governments.

[@gtaraya]

apparently "under the table" agreements are official agreements.

[@URBAN_Resistance]

Adding to that the china consultant is so quiet about the wire tapping incident. Philippines has an anti wire tapping law and the chinese ambassador dosent have the immunity to do that. A.i can produce deep fake voice like what's happenong to joe rogan.

[@pooi-hoongchan8680]

2nd Thomas Shoal is part of the Spratlys. China has legally valid claims to the Spratlys .

[@rian4104]

You do realize that diplomatic communication of any country must be recorded and made into transcript for documentation right? Its illegal if the the Chinese is not part involve in the conversation. Only shady business don't want to be recorded, and Philippine reaction speaks volumes.

[@MikoSoza]

@@rian4104 You are a bone head. Diplomatic communication means the communication is between embassy official and department of foreign affiars. Which is clearly not. Recording is different from wiretapping. If the other party is aware that he is being recorded then its fine. But in this case it is not and clearly a case of wiretapping.

[@nextlastChang]

There's nothing else for the Philippines 🇵🇭 to settle with China. Hague Tribunal already settled it by a ruling in 2016. - Whether China likes it or not, the ruling is *final and legally binding.*

[@28119850]

Go away. As if you know Jack about it....take a hike

[@AhmetTekin101]

​@@28119850Why are you afraid of the truth?

[@tiaoyi-bx5yi]

Curry should be concerned about the toilet.

[@AhmetTekin101]

@@tiaoyi-bx5yi ​

[@AhmetTekin101]

@@28119850 Have you read UNCLOS or the Hague ruling? You can't discuss it while knowing nothing about it.

[@LandgrabbingIndia]

GUILTY CONSCIENCE: Vice Admiral Alberto Carlos took "leave" and was "replaced" by a new commander named "Rear Adm. Alfonso Torres" shortly after the debacle.🤭

[@thetreekeeper143]

I think it's to take the heat off because the American funded media and American naval base don't like the Philippines government interact in any way with China without the American permission.

[@arlenjamespanganiban3581]

Scape goat by bbm administration

[@titaniauranus]

Stop using our names.. Huwag mo igamit yung mga pangalan namin, kuro kuro ka diyan ha..

[@rodrigohodreal7120]

There was no secret deal but secret wire tapping which is illegal in the Philippines.

[@leahcasey2678]

The CIA and NSA wiretap everyone in every country every day of the week. It was the US that told Canada about the Indian Government's hit squad that were deployed on Canadian soil ... they knew because the US wire taps all the land lines, cell phones, and internet data in Canada and India.

[@totofred8420]

The current Philippine/'s government officials used him as "escape goat". Nothing new for Pulpul politicians just to fed up their empty stomach. We stand with VA Alberto Carlos Inshallah ☝️

[@rainieresguerra6519]

Escape goat for what?

[@thebears1191]

Did you say the previous administration you ignorant fool.

[@user-ii8pw6kp7n]

Jama ar china

[@jessier3602]

The US,Japan,Germany should build a big base in the Second Thomas Shoal which is within the territorial waters of the Philippines NOw

[@nextlastChang]

*The international law* is very clear on the South China Sea: - parts of it belong to some ASEAN countries including the Philippines 🇵🇭, - the rest of it is the international water, - no part of it belongs to China🇨🇳 or Taiwan🇹🇼.

[@user-kf7wm2vk2l]

can you tell us which United Nations Website talks about south china sea

[@AhmetTekin101]

​@@user-kf7wm2vk2l Have you read UNCLOS or the Hague ruling? You can't discuss it while knowing nothing about it.

[@user-kf7wm2vk2l]

@@AhmetTekin101 you are lying here - there is no ruling from United Nations on South China Sea

[@user-kf7wm2vk2l]

shameless fake news like you - are a disgrace to your country

[@user-kf7wm2vk2l]

@@AhmetTekin101 united nations - un org , has never release any news about South China Ruling !!!

[@Hkchinese888]

The verdicts from the 2016 International Maritime Court said that the 9 dash lines are invalid.

[@jackytang3683]

Rules by Canon

[@therminust4]

useless court which no legal force 🤡 thats why China dont want to come that circus show, court is one sided & in UNCLOS have rules: if two country have dispute resolve in dialogue first

[@amunra5330]

That court has no legal authority. Its just an arbitrator that cannot enforce anything-sorry:

[@kimabella1487]

@@amunra5330 has no authority? then why tf china signed it conforming the UNCLOS in 1982 then?. they signed it and now claiming that it has no authority just to fuel their unlawful greed towards their weaker neighbor's territories.

[@vengeancerecovery5535]

Whoite peoples ADIZ is also not recognized by international law except from 53y3$ & puppet states....😊....only NIHAO PRIVET Salam from Malaysia

[@MRT-co1sd]

With Chinese money in the pockets everything can now be thrown out of the window.

[@halfevilhalfgood2206]

This is fake.. LoL

[@teammaglulupa6186]

so china wanted all the water in south china ..what a nice neighbor ... keep it up china your country will have more friends and will be happy forever and ever.. no misery

[@FilipinoFirst-zl1tx]

_Did a discussion take place?_ - Maybe. _Are the agreements there valid (if there were indeed agreements made)?_ - No, because it wasn't attended by key people in the Philippine government who are authorized to speak for and decide on these matters. _Was it binding, assuming an agreement was indeed reached?_ - No. For an agreement as crucial as this to be binding, it needs (1) to be published first; (2) to be reviewed by the three equal branches of the Philippine government, and (3) the signed approval of the representatives of the Philippine government and signed too by their counterparts. _Was the recording of the "new deal" AI-generated?_ - Most people suspect it was. _Does the axing of the involved military officer mean guilt?_ - Not necessarily. Relieving an officer of his duties pending any investigation is simply to prevent the officer involved from being accused of influencing its outcome. Meanwhile, the expulsion of an officer from the Armed Forces only comes after a very thorough investigation where the results of that did not favor that officer. _Is a naval officer, even the highest ranking, authorized to make deals regarding territories on behalf of the government?_ - No. *That's how it works in the Philippines; that's how it works in a rule-based society.*

[@markkingi1252]

If instincts say something not right 99% chance is .....your absolutely right 👍.

[@andoyandoy9217]

CCP news

[@SergioTheGreat100]

Traydor

[@1PHtrendstv]

The Chinese Embassy should be expelled or subjected to legal action due to allegations of wiretapping.

[@jacobmee]

Philipos didn’t learn lesson from this. It’s okay to not honor your agreement, which happens. But lying from official government means it can’t be trusted. You’re becoming a joke right now.

[@BonaccorsoVilar]

Comprehensive Legal Argumentation Legally, Professor Carty thoroughly explores the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) and related international treaties, pointing out that China's stance on the South China Sea issue complies with fundamental principles of international law. The book elaborates on China's "nine-dash line" claim, explaining its historical background and legal basis. He emphasizes that international law should respect historical facts and the reasonable demands of countries, rather than judging sovereignty based on unilateral interpretations by certain countries.

[@ShivamSen-co1cs]

Nowadays , youtube comment sections are fill with bots and a lot of bots. 😂

[@Tan92lfc]

an Untrustworthy Pariah state

[@ajorbista]

Absolutely the people’s republic of china.

[@LandgrabbingIndia]

Absolutely, the Philippines.

[@LandgrabbingIndia]

@@ajorbista Absolutely, the Philippines., caught lying on the international stage.

[@wynn3077]

@@LandgrabbingIndia Absolutely China.

[@LandgrabbingIndia]

@@wynn3077 Poo2Loo, Indian.

[@smashsmash5866]

Marcos pretend he doesn't know and Carlos is being used as the fall guy.

[@chillcat7565]

This report fails to mention that in our Constitution a military official has no authority to make such a deal. Only the President and the DFA can.

[@titaniauranus]

Because this channel is controlled by the CCP or CPC aka the Communist Party of China. Do not be resonant with brutal and genocidal regimes.

[@darwindiaz5227]

It's a lie again.

[@Xx-he9qe]

Keep diverting from the real problem: Marcos’ fear of his assets being frozen by the US.

[@URBAN_Resistance]

Proof? China cant control marcos not like duterte

[@URBAN_Resistance]

Proof

[@Han_Seo101]

Keep joking.

[@gloriabort2879]

Shame on you China! 😡

[@maxcrowe2938]

For what? For defending its territory?

[@tonyvillanueva8927]

China assumed too much about the conversation just like it assumed that adding more dashes to their imaginary lines will make their claim more acceptable to the world.

[@rosalindabonus7932]

Carlos didn’t represent the whole pilipino to enter into gentlemen agreement therefore it can be denied at palayasin lahat ng Chinese sa Philippine Teritories

[@AbdelghaniRougaa]

Aljazera 😮😮Wa tnakat😅😅😅😅modi 🇮🇪🇹🇼🇺🇸🇩🇿🇬🇧🇪🇺🇨🇳☝️🇸🇦ça marche plus 😂😂ni planète rouge ni planète mauve👻🃏🎱😁😁😁😁😁🕰🌏🗺🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣

[@AbdelghaniRougaa]

Ahmad🎱al🃏3ajami☝️🍻ina zalzalata⛈asa3ati⌚......🤫😁🤯😅🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀les 9awmin ya3kilon👸intelligente😘intéressant🥶impressionnant✌💣🚀💣RTL🌞TV👎🎱🃏🛸🚀Russel👎🤫classe👞📌💣chiens🦮engagés tu as triché votre paye🇧🇪et🇪🇺🇨🇳🇮🇳🇮🇱🇺🇸🇪🇦🇬🇧🇸🇦🕋...ta fait le hipocrit🇲🇦pas Hippocrate 🧳avocat dayyer🗃🏴‍☠️dégage ou😅🌋aljazera 🙏📱📲a rahman☄🔥🏗🏦👎👎⌚🛎💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀passe se msg a votre associé lewkili👎et habachi👎😅jomo3a88🤫🛫😘Kat4🇺🇸🇬🇧Les ring👸 européens🇪🇺il ait vraiment trop belle et intelligente😍😇malheureusement....🤴🤯🇸🇦☝️😅😅🤲🧜‍♀️🎱🃏🛸🪐⛈🔥🌋🗺🌊🌊🙏💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀🚀🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀🚀🚀💣🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀les chiens engagés tu veux arrêter le 🎱......al Jazeera 😅ina a dina 3inda allahi al islam🇨🇳Allaho a3lam🃏ahmad👻 al3ajami🎱wa kolo chayae ahsaynaho fi kitabin mobin☝️💯💯💯🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀🙋‍♂️🇨🇳👍peng🛸lions🇨🇳va fermés 😅Paris frappé🙏🇪🇺 👍il faut exploser le Maroc🇲🇦d'abord il faut respecter le paradis☝️⚘le parole 🎱🃏💫🕰💯🌍☄🌊🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀arrêté de acheter les voitures des terroristes🇪🇺il 🚕🛎🤫sans fous des chinois🇨🇳 ou 🇰🇵ou🇸🇦.....Ahmad🎱al🃏3ajami☝️🍻ina zalzalata⛈asa3ati⌚......🤫😁🤯😅🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀les 9awmin ya3kilon👸intelligente😘intéressant🥶impressionnant✌💣🚀💣RTL🌞TV👎🎱🃏🛸🚀Russel👎🤫classe👞📌💣chiens🦮engagés tu as triché votre paye🇧🇪et🇪🇺🇨🇳🇮🇳🇮🇱🇺🇸🇪🇦🇬🇧🇸🇦🕋...ta fait le hipocrit🇲🇦pas Hippocrate 🧳avocat dayyer🗃🏴‍☠️dégage ou😅🌋aljazera 🙏📱📲a rahman☄🔥🏗🏦👎👎⌚🛎💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀passe se msg a votre associé lewkili👎et habachi👎😅jomo3a88🤫🛫😘Kat4🇺🇸🇬🇧Les ring👸 européens🇪🇺il ait vraiment trop belle et intelligente😍😇malheureusement....🤴🤯🇸🇦☝️😅😅🤲🧜‍♀️🎱🃏🛸🪐⛈🔥🌋🗺🌊🌊🙏💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀🚀🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀🚀🚀💣🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀les chiens engagés tu veux arrêter le 🎱......al Jazeera 😅ina a dina 3inda allahi al islam🇨🇳💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣

[@AbdelghaniRougaa]

🙋‍♂️🇨🇳👍peng🛸lions🇨🇳va fermés 😅Paris frappé🙏🇪🇺 👍il faut exploser le Maroc🇲🇦d'abord il faut respecter le paradis☝️⚘le parole 🎱🃏💫🕰💯🌍☄🌊🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀arrêté de acheter les voitures des terroristes🇪🇺il 🚕🛎🤫sans fous des chinois🇨🇳 ou 🇰🇵ou🇸🇦.....🎱👻🃏☝️💯💯Chocolats choux🔥🇺🇸😁😅😅😅je t'aiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiime très forte 🤰🔥🛸pardonné moi..........☝️tu peut passer comme la dernière fois 😘🗺⚡😁🤭diaz-BALaRT😁COLE😅CHAIRMAN😅Léonidas lakhloufi 👎👎😅Al Jazeera charmota 🇪🇬saisi 💣🤫🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣Les bombes n'éclaire en live a les chiens engagés 🇬🇧🇮🇱🇮🇪🇸🇦🇺🇸🇨🇳🇪🇺🇶🇦......🛸😅🎱😁😅👻😁😅😁🃏😅💯💯💯💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🤫💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣🚀💣Russel classe💣chiens🦮engagés tu as triché votre paye🇧🇪et🇨🇳🇮🇳🇮🇱🇺🇸🇸🇦🕋...ta fait le hipocrit🇲🇦pas Hippocrat🔥🏗🏦👎🚀💣📱📲🚀passe se msg a votre associé💣lewkili et habachi 😅jomo3a88🤫

[@eduardomolino-qh4we]

bigla kang nag leave tapos tumahi ka ng mga isasagot sa media...wow ... officer nasa official duty biglang lumayas....AY MALI !!@!

[@rheonepomuceno5572]

Chopuey Deal....

[@kongthai..]

No more agitations by the pinoys? 😢

[@ROBERTOGARCIA-ld2hj]

It is understandable why this traitor would deny making deals with his alumni naval academy in tsina. First of all he should have never spoken to anyone in the tsinese embassy regardless of what subject matter without the permission first of the SND. It was justified to kick him out as WesCom Chief. He failed his leadership he failed the PN, he betrayed his country.

[@avatarairbinder6157]

China is so funny 3-5min coversation by to military officer would enough to solving d issue?😂😂😂😂

[@MikoSoza]

Correct who in their right mind would consider a casual talk to a military officer to be binding to the whole Philppines.

[@JeromeP-jg9tx]

Its only a small part of the large issue. You need to look at the big picture. How much pesos do you earn per comment?

[@MikoSoza]

@@JeromeP-jg9tx Hundred thousand peso per comment. Do you want to buy me out?

[@TuroPH]

*YOUR NEWS IS NOT FULL. CHINESE EMBASSY JUST CALLED WITHOUT NOTICE JUST TO GREAT A HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO CARLOS, BUT CHINESE IMMEDIATELY DISCUSS ON HOW TO LESSEN THE TENSIONS IN THR WEST PHILIPPINES SEA. IT IS CHINA WHO INITIATE THE CALL AND THERE'S NO AGREEMENT DISCUSSED. MAYBE CHINA IS RECORDING CARLOS VOICE AND THEN USE AI TO MANIPULATE ANYTHING* *DISCUSSION IS JUST 3-5 MINS LOL* THEN CHINA SAID IT IS A NEW MODEL? AHAHAHA

[@avatarairbinder6157]

@@JeromeP-jg9tx Wat big picture? That the china buidling wall on PH coast and u approached certain PH military official to hav converstion without any deal then thats it problem solve?🤣🤣🤣China is a modern gangster

[@Rishabh-Dev]

South China Sea is not China's. 😅

[@LandgrabbingIndia]

Indian Ocean is not India's.😅

[@EmmaLagda-ir4bu]

The Philippines Arm forces must now allow itself to be dictated and don't need a big brother to influence It's military decisions as the Philippines is not America's colony. It's biggest responsibility is to insure this country's security and that includes abating circumstances that would unnecessary cost the lives of it's men in vain. Our Braves are men of value and integrity and would willingly die for this nation. They are our pride and treasure and it is a grave mistake to waste their lives for the follies of our political leader, surrendering our sovereignty for their gain and in behalf of aother countrys fight for its world dominance. THIS COUNTRY ARE IN DIRE NEED OF THE LIKES OF ATTY. HARRY ROGUE to fearlessly bring about to the Filipinos the unpolished TRUTH as the current STATE OF OUR NATION IS DARK.

[@tinberman8738]

Philippines don't have historical relationship with Communist China. They are invading on our seas

[@joelkolokoy]

Wag kayong trayhador sa ating bayan😢😢mga mamamayan ang kawawa

[@ShitSkinsIndian]

Game over Pnoises. Lies exposed.

[@titaniauranus]

Philippinophobe exposed. Deception disengaged.

[@ShitSkinsIndian]

@@titaniauranus Game over Pnoises. Lies exposed. 1:22 Pnoises lied as usual and as always. There is an agreement after all.

[@titaniauranus]

@@ShitSkinsIndian The centricity of Mainlander hypocrisy. Do not be persuasive and be missionizing the dispute to pinpoint on the CCP only. Do not compell me to be in scrutiny of something. I know what I am talking about, you sadistic expansionist fascist contagion.

[@titaniauranus]

@@ShitSkinsIndian Mainland China should be foresighted on its existence. Liberation will occur someday in that expansionist country

[@ShitSkinsIndian]

@@titaniauranus Game over Pnoises. Lies exposed. 1:22 Pnoises lied as usual and as always. There is an agreement after all.x2

[@URBAN_Resistance]

Carlos was victim of deep fake 😂 theres no china model as china said india ocean doesn't belong to india scs dosent belong to china either

[@tigers_of_the_south_PH_24]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂.....FAKE NEWS BRO

[@kahldiss2689]

TOFU deal

[@nextlastChang]

It was just Chinese 🇨🇳 lies as usual.

[@darth.severu5]

@@ToiChutGongWu Ahmettekin101 coming to his aid.

[@wynn3077]

@@ToiChutGongWu Go Wubot 😜

[@HikaruAkitsuki]

It doesn't mean that China makes one official of the Philippines agree to their one-sided agreement the Whole Government of the Philippines agree. China must acknowledge and respect The Philippine Constitution and accept that even ghe President of The Republic of The Philippine is now allowed to break any part of the Constitution. The real power of the Republic Government is on People so any SECRET AGREEMENTS are invalid if there is no consent of the Citizens.

[@lonesomefencesitter3186]

Kinda ironic, it bring into memory how Xi confronts Justin Trudeau over "leaked" conversation at G20, Bali.

[@shawn5310]

菲律宾人私下里不想搞那么僵，迫于美国的压力而已

[@URBAN_Resistance]

Enjoy using youtube when u enter china u will be using your vpn to access youtube again or your a state sponsored 😂

[@geejaymartinesahagun7696]

What are you saying??? Your claim is invalid, your so called 9 dash line is not recognized by the international community. GET OUT OF WPS!!! NO TO ASIA BULLY!!

[@namrehtv2746]

TF usa left philipinnes since 1946

[@URBAN_Resistance]

@@namrehtv2746 paid yan 50cents d sla makagamt ng yt sa china

[@shawn5310]

@@namrehtv2746 没改变菲律宾是美国殖民地的事实

[@jackytang3683]

No deal would made without his Boss Marcos

[@avatarairbinder6157]

Under Ph constuition only president allowed to hav deal related to its territory with the presence of DFA.

[@maaa.a.8003]

He was in the CCP's pocket and cannot make deals without the head of state approval.

[@rainieresguerra6519]

The SCS belongs to China. And so is the Indian Ocean. China is currently drawing up a map showing the Indian Ocean and the Arctic Ocean as all within the new Dash Lines in the upcoming Chinese map. 😂😂😂

[@aarcoh]

XI JINPING IS A STRONG AND WISE LEADER. IT IS VERY IMPORTANT THAT THE WEST RESPECTS XI JINPING AND REFRAINS FROM INTERFERING IN CHINA'S DOMESTIC AFFAIRS

[@brianburgess3231]

Not strong, not Wise and not a leader .. but then again most bullies are paper tigers

[@Hkchinese888]

I feel Granny pani is oversized

[@geejaymartinesahagun7696]

Not strong and wise. China and Xi must respect the soveriegn of other countries. China claim is invalid and fictitous. Your so called 9 dash line is not recognized by the international community. GET OUT OF WPS!!! NO TO ASIA BULLY!!

[@brianburgess3231]

@@lamarcalewarts1155 well said

[@johnwang2882]

China shows great restraints on philippine’s aggressive behavior

[@jessier3602]

The only solution to the territorial waters of the Philippines is to allow the US military to build back their bases in the Philippine Islands so that the US and Philippine Navies can put a stop to China's Aggression

[@joekerr8037]

China should no longer have this kind of arrangement with the Filipinos. The Filipinos cannot be trusted to honour their own words !

[@maldzmahalko590]

When did ever a communist ideology be ever trusted

[@ROBERTOGARCIA-ld2hj]

He should have never accepted speaking to a tsinese attaché, never. He should know better you can never trust a tsinese. Being a three star admiral he must be punished, demoted one rank and forced to retire.

[@tvgerbil1984]

It was a very disturbing behavior by the military attache of the Chinese embassy by contacting a naval officer of the Philippines to set up this new deal without going through the normal diplomatic channel. It broke all diplomatic protocols and sought to bypass the authority of the civilian adminstration of the Philippines.

[@lagrangewei]

you are confused. what is agreed is how 2 military will conduct their mission. it is not under the authority of civilian administration which only define the objective, not how it is undertaken. the admiral has the right to even surrender his forces, many admiral and general has done so in history. the president gave them a sword to symbolise they are in control. and if the 2 military has no right to talk to each other, why do military attache even exist? they exist because military do have the right to talk to each other and even negotiate surrender if they believe it is untentable. all the president can do is sack the general after the fact, but as commissioned officers, they have the right to represent the country in their field of operation. when Trump lost the election, US general literally call the chinese in front of his general staff and told the chinese he will not attack china even if trump commanded it. no one charge him for treason.

[@kevinrich5222]

The Chinese and American militaries often communicate directly and reach many temporary agreements, without the need for government intervention. In addition, when relations between the two militaries in the disputed areas between China and India are tense, they also communicate directly to reach an agreement to disengage to avoid misjudgment. Do the citizens of small countries not understand international politics?