[Special Clip] ATEEZ(에이티즈) 산 '이하이 - 한숨'

[@dkwlr]

와… 산이 보컬 원래도 너무 좋아했지만 고음나오는데 너무 좋아서 소름돋았다 산이는 참 무대도 독보적이고 보컬도 독보적인듯 되게 남들이 할 수 없는 걸 가지고 있는 느낌이다 산이가 고음할 때 되게 벅차네요 너무 좋아요 산이 노래 많이많이 듣고싶어요

[@nikki6030]

He covered a song which is rather a very emotional song if you have been in Kpop for long… it was a song composed by SHINee Jonghyun (RIP my angel) for Lee Hi who suffered from panic disorder and breathing difficulty… Lee Hi sang this song once again after Jonghyun’s departure and made everyone cry… this song is just that special & San’s beautiful vocal reminded me of Jonghyun… and how idols struggle and feel being the public’s entertainment…. Let’s spread Love!! 🖤

[@furuyakeifu]

The reason why it’s making me cry. Miss him a lot.

[@noemax1491]

I miss him so much T.T

[@rattleearth9611]

Sani has chosen a perfect beautiful amazing song that suit his vocal....

[@DollyGuadalupe]

This cover brought me to tears. It was so beautiful. San did an amazing job. RIP, Jonghyun. We miss you so much. ❤

[@JaehyunsHeart]

I became a fam of shinee after jonghyuns passing not knowing he had passed and he was my bias I miss him so much!💔🍑

[@HenryAndYang]

I'M SO PROUD OF SAN! SUCH AN UNDERRATED VOCALIST AND SUCH A GREAT COVER!

[@RenHyuck03]

Yess he deserves lots of loveeeeeeeeee & spot light 😭😭😭😭💞

[@RenHyuck03]

His vocal issss soooooo goodeee 😭😭😭

[@sabrinamlaadissi]

Wich cover is this, if i can ask?

[@hyekpopcov]

​@@sabrinamlaadissi It's Lee Hi Breathe

[@rattleearth9611]

Glad sani chose this song n has so many emotional meaning of human life in its ...

[@aurorawrap]

San won the singing contest in Namhae at 12 years old. You were born a singer and worked super hard to be one of the best dancer in kpop. He is well mannered and is a sweetheart.

[@ierazrn]

He's so precious, so please don't hurt him. Choi San is not a bad person.

[@atinyturbulence57]

birthday msgs from the member on his bday so genuine and touching. esp Yeosangs

[@Mikaela_16]

I love this comment.

[@Yorong-ej2pt]

단단하고 흔들리지않는 미성인 게 너무 좋다...꼭 이름같아 여린 초록잎들이지만 그게 커다란 산을 이루고 있는것처럼

[@snyssym6857]

こんなにもあたたかな歌声で癒してくれるあなたにも“毎日お疲れさま”がどうか届きますように。

[@chloesylloe9877]

Old shawol and new Atiny here, I'm so moved by the way you sing this unique song. Incredible, your voice is so fantastic.

[@amriejaija1117]

Hai my fellow Shawoltiny...im 13 years Shawol here and 3 years as Atiny

[@Jebastia]

Old Shawol and New Atiny here too! keep coming back to his cover...

[@Kaaaayyyy994]

San and Minho’s dad are actually great friends too. ❤❤

[@kami6937]

This is a song written by SHINee's JONGHYUN for Lee Hi. I am a shawol, and I am grateful for this beautiful cover. Thank you San for remembering and honoring Jonghyun the best way: through his beautiful music.

[@EveSullivan]

When I first got into Ateez, I thought San was just an amazing, passionate dancer with a powerful stage presence. Then I learned he was a singer, with an incredible voice that makes my heart skip a beat. This is beautiful.

[@Gardenii0209]

얼굴만 봐도 위로가 되는데 이런 노래를 불러주다니 산아

[@cristinahernandez8517]

Happy birthaday .🎉😊

[@cristinahernandez8517]

san Happy birthaday 🎉😮😊😊

[@픽숑민기]

정말 죄송하지만 프로필사진 민기인가요..? 혹시 이미지 출처좀 알 수 있을까용…🫢🥹

[@Gardenii0209]

@@픽숑민기 네! 민기 맞아요 에이티즈 인스타그램이 출처였던 걸로 기억합니다...

[@픽숑민기]

@@Gardenii0209 ㅠㅠ감사합니다🩶

[@wndudpp]

힘들고 지칠 때마다 산이 한숨 커버 듣고 있어 하루하루 바쁜 날을 보내면서도 그 바쁜 순간에도 산이를 생각하며 버티고 있어 내 삶의 힘이자 원동력이 되어주어서 고마워 산이가 걸어가는 길 믿고 뒤에서 따라갈게 너무 빠르게도 말고 발 맞춰 함께 걸어가자 언제나 응원할게

[@보노보노-x4k]

11시가 넘은 시간. 쉽지 않은 야근 후 택시타고 집 가는 길에 듣는데 울컥하게 만드네요.. 조심조심 신경써서 꾹꾹 눌러 적은 편지를 읽어주듯 노래하는 그 목소리가 너무 애틋하고 눈물나요.. 덕분에 정말 행복해요 이런 가수의 팬인 것에 감사함을 느끼는 밤이에요. 노래 해줘서 고마워요.

[@고려홍삼-j9b]

말을 너무 예쁘게하셔서 글을 읽는내내 저도 왠지 울컥하네요🥹 항상 좋은 일만 있으시길 바랄게요 좋은 하루 보내세요!

[@Karim-bz6zw]

❤❤❤

[@spring_ax23]

좋은 목소리로 좋은 음악 들려준 산아 고맙고 오늘도 행복한 하루 보내요❤❤❤

[@ehyuka1499]

hits hard at these times

[@MelissaGuionBooks]

I know…the timing

[@MultiFandomStayTiny]

Right

[@asdfgh-j-kl]

Tiktok brought me here and San brought me to ATEEZ. He officially made me an ATINY. This cover hits too close to home. Thank you, San and the rest of ATEEZ. ❤

[@kingchoisan]

You know what San is really great at? "Beauty in simplicity". Like this video is so simple yet beautiful. No moving cameras, no extravagant lighting or editing, just us FOCUS ON SAN'S BEAUTIFUL VOICE AND VISUAL. I have never been this proud at stanning someone. CHOI SAN BEST VOCALIST IN THE WORLD 🥺❤️

[@marianamirelabadea3368]

We can say that the two Choi are the best vocalist. Because we can't forget Jongho either, who also calls Choi like San. I mean, they're the best vocalist in the band and who knows maybe the best vocalist in kpop.

[@pandawarolf1336]

exactly everything is said ❤️

[@suchandrimaghosh4085]

Exactly. His voice does all the magic

[@Chensanie]

No because the song is already sad, the lyrics are so deep but his emotions, omg, like the way he delivered his feelings was just so heartbreaking. It’s literally impossible not to cry if you’re not in your best mood

[@VictoriaBudkey]

San is such a physically energetic performer that I think we sometimes gloss over the fact that his vocals are incredibly strong. He has a tonal control and range that is insanely impressive. He could easily handle solo OSTs or branch out to give us a solo EP/album too. Sure, he impresses us with every stage performance with his 110% energy, but today, I'm thankful for the reminder that Choi San is a singer, first and foremost.

[@daughteroftheabyss4476]

He is an ace and he proves it time and again ♥️

[@Moskeyt_]

なんか不意に聴きたくなって来たのだが、がっつり泣いてしまった 元々本家さんの歌詞がすごく響く作品なんだけど、それと同時にサンさんの歌い方が温かくて安心してついつい涙が😂 良い曲だよ本当に

[@maiwwww]

初めてATEEZを見た時、サン君はパフォーマンスが強烈で体も大きくて，すごく怖い人だと勘違いしていました。 私がそうだったように、きっとサン君をよく知らない人は，彼がこんなにも繊細で柔らかく、美しい声と表現力の持ち主ということを知らないのが勿体無いと思いました。 とても優しくて、繊細で美しいサン君を、世界中の人にもっともっと知って欲しいと、このパフォーマンスを見て思いました。

[@parkminae80]

이 노래가 위로가 되길... 저도 마음의 병 때문에 엄청 힘들었거든요. 지금은 약 안 먹고 있습니다.

[@anuv5362]

Hwaiting 🙂

[@fed4945]

Let’s try to reach 1M before his birthday but even if we can’t it’s still fine, this cover gave so much comfort to so many people, many non fans came here as well during a difficult time and I think that is more meaningful than any view count. He’ll be the happiest just by reading comments and seeing how many people he helped with this cover

[@lejae_tiny]

I listen to it daily!! ❤️

[@qusqkddml5xkzn]

유튜브 떠돌다가 오랜만에 들으러 왔는데 새벽감성과 함께 산이 커버 듣기 이거 극락이네... 😇 산이 목소리는 정말 보물인 게 처음 에이티즈 노래 들을때 딱 사니 파트 듣자마자 "어 얘 누구지? 좋네" 라는 생각이 들었었거든. 그리고 특히나 목소리에 감정을 담아내는 능력이 정말 뛰어나다고 생각해. 그래서 산이의 노래를 들을땐 항상 그 노래의 감정에 더 집중해서 들을 수 있었던 거 같아 사니가 불러주는 노래가 너무 좋고 사니의 목소리가 좋아, 그래서 24년에도 사니가 불러주는 노래를 많이 들을 수 있었으면 좋겠다 그런 의미로 최최즈 듀엣 커버도 기대 많이 하고 있어....!! (부담주는 건 아니구우...👀) 항상 따뜻하고 상냥한 위로를 줘서 고마워 산아, 앞으로도 힘들때마다 많이 들으러 올게😊

[@chels8412]

Nobody is talking about how the lyrics are so comforting and how his delivery is so sincere, thank you San, so many of us really needed this especially me🫶🫶

[@pekidaifuku0718]

멋진 목소리 고마워요.종현씨를 생각해서 따뜻해졌어요.

[@blossoming92]

San said in an interview that he wants to hear "thank you for being born". Hopefully we can flood things with this message for him to see. He will be busy on his birthday, but that doesn't mean he won't see it. So here is day 1 of saying thank you for being born San! Atiny love you!

[@user-lu2hh7cf2j]

산 노래 잘하는거 알았고 음색좋은거 알았지만 이렇게까지 너무너무 잘하는줄 몰랐네 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@DGERICAA]

최산은 놀라운 가수이고 KQ는 그의 보컬을 더 많이 보여줘야 합니다. 최산은그럴 자격이 있습니다

[@exo_ateez1020]

Absolutely agree

[@정호정-b6m]

진심을 담아 정성스레 위로의 말을 전하듯 온마음으로 부른 노래...산이 좋은 가수네요^^

[@1117ship]

San also deserves that kind of solid n loyal fans. Hope you will go viral n more successful in the future boy.

[@mminnn-h6n]

이걸 몇번째 듣는지 모르겠다 최산 사랑해

[@Jlee-ll1xt]

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@soshy0179]

항상 곱고 아름다운 목소리로 노래해줘서 고마워. 오늘도 너 덕분에 힘을 얻어가 사랑해 산아

[@BeWithATEEZ619]

와...산아......할 말을 잃었다......😭기다리고 기다리던 첫 커버 영상의 노래가 이하이 님의 한숨이라니...평상시에도 진짜 좋아하는 노래고 힘들었을 때 많이 들었던 노랜데 산이가 많은 티니들을 위해서 감정들을 꾹꾹 가사에 담아서 불러줘서, 괜찮다고 안아주겠다고 말해줘서, 티니들을 다 포용해주는 느낌이라 너무 고맙고 정말 많이 사랑해요💜너무너무 기특하고 엄청 잘했다고 수고했다고 꼬옥 안아서 토닥토닥해주고 싶네요 산아 언제든 기대요 항상 곁에 있을게요

[@Eltyanistah]

I'd love to have this on Spotify on replay for hours.. Such a beautiful song, my lil atiny and shawol's heart is sobbing... thank you San to honor so well Jonghyun's talent. People who doesn't know San career well often forgets how powerful, talented and lovable he is as vocalist since he has that incredible shining stage presence. Please let him sing more and more, let him sing whatever and whenever he wants! I'm still waiting for the Bad Boy by Red Velvet cover he said he wanted to do. Thank you San for being such an amazing and inspiring being!

[@April_Atiny]

Such a beautiful comment!!

[@Eltyanistah]

@@April_Atiny aww thank youuu I felt every word I wrote 💕

[@bronzepistachio]

Same! Where is that RV cover? It has bn almost 2 years since tt hello82 content 😭

[@Bongbong0001]

17살 학생입니다 그저 안아주면서 괜찮다라는 말한마디 듣고싶을뿐인데 힘내라는 말보다도 괜찮다라는 말이 더 힘이되고 그럴때 있잖아요 저는 지금이 딱 그 순간 인거 같아요 따듯한 노래를 선물해준 산 오빠한테 정말 고맙다고 이렇게 댓글에서라도 전해봅니당..

[@zproject4510]

San's vocals never fail to amaze me. The voice quality and versatility. Truly remarkable.

[@Nyzzxy]

The lyrics are just extremely meaningful, they show care, love and support. I’m truly amazed by the sincerity of his vocals. He’s definitely something to treasure. His visuals are soft, angelic and so ethereal, something so extraordinary.

[@KatinkaMaika]

RIP Jonghyun, your legacy lives on, thank you for this song

[@alicek5471]

I always cherished this song. Growing up listening to Shinee, Jonghyun wrote this masterpiece for Lee Hi who really sings it very well and now San covering it is magical. San is someone we appreciate because he has this comfy, homey aura so this cover is the cherry on top. Thank you San for this gift

[@lloverua]

산이가 평소 성격으로 위로 해주는 노래같네요.. 산이가 정말 해주고싶은 말을 꾹꾹 담아 불러주는것같아서 슬프고 아름다워요 🥹

[@onlyforateez403]

😢 really wish San can get more opportunities to showcase his vocal skills, he’s the lead vocalist but we only got to hear him sing properly almost 5 years after his debut and through a cover. Many people didn’t even know he was a vocalist and that says it all honestly

[@misspriss2482]

He's one of the lead vocalists so they try to give everybody a chance to show off their vocals. He has been given more of a chance to sing lately, but to be honest, KQ has leaned more into his sexy performance side (crop tops, etc.) because he draws a lot of people that way. Perhaps he'll do more covers and get more lead singing parts. San really is an incredible all-rounder. Ace dancer, singer, choreographer performer, actor - you name it, he can do it all flawlessly.

[@kingchoisan]

@@misspriss2482 sorry to correct you. HE'S THE ONLY LEAD VOCALIST but he never gets the proper chance to fully showcase his skills. They always only give him that falsetto part. The longest part he gets is 27 seconds with the same repetitive part. And it gets worse every comeback.

[@greenkingdomhk]

He got like 10 seconds to sing solo for every song... The so-called 'lead' is not quite true. Really sad about this.

[@murpbe9086]

@@kingchoisan in a group with 7 other members, I think that's quite a lot. But bear in mind, even Jongho has to sing repetitive parts in some songs too, vocally demanding ones even. Yeosang has about 30s in Limitless, just singing the same lines in the chorus. It's up to the producers to decide who gets to sing which parts in which songs, but you should also consider the structure of songs that Ateez usually does, which can sometimes inhibit their vocal abilities. That said, I think KQ is great to let him showcase his vocals on this cover, which I thoroughly enjoy, and I hope there will be more in the future, preferably on his birthday.

[@greenkingdomhk]

Since there are many members, KQ could arrange like having three of them as main output and change the 'main 3' for each song so as to showcase every member, it's also good to the group in a long term. Finally see this change in Limitless (hopefully not just once), they should have done it years earlier. No one should bear the least lines every single song afterall, they are a group and everyone should take turns to shine.

[@jennwilson1245]

Wow! So beautiful! We hardly get to hear his vocal prowess but I’ve been blown away by his talent and control. The amount of emotion portrayed through his vocals??? Just wow. I’m crying, even not knowing Korean. Thank you, San-ah! Atiny love you 3000!! 🥹❤️

[@heuhe]

누군가의 한숨을 안아줄만큼 단단한 사람으로 자라나 이렇게 보석같은 커버를 선물해준 우리 고마운 산아‥ 2:30 음 올리는 거 전율 미쳤다 한 단어 한 단어 온 마음 담아 부르는 게 영상에 710% 드러나서 이 노래를 얼마나 많이 불렀을까 싶고 기특하고 짱 감동이고 (っ ̯ -｡) ... 모든 말이 다 닿지는 않겠지만 정말 사랑해 산아 더 좋은 말이 생기면 첫 번째로 해줄게

[@Onlyfirstkhao]

❤😭we love him só much😍👑

[@XiaoMw3R]

His cover is always such a comfort. Choi San has beautiful vocals, he’s such a talented man. San give us some original songs, we’re looking forward to them 🔥

[@becca_36]

BRO LITERALLY WHO GAVE HIM THE RIGHT TO BE SO BEAUTIFUL AND SO TALENTED. That was absolutely gorgeous San, I'll be listening to this on repeat.

[@emi.2956]

감동하고 있습니다.저절로 눈물이 흘러요.에이티즈 보컬 산의 노랫소리를 많은 분들이 들어주셨으면 좋겠습니다.

[@exo_ateez1020]

My heart is aching.. I have so many things to say, yet can't find a single word to describe..San's voice is so incredible. I stopped breathing for the entire song. I can't even express how beautiful San's voice is The range, the timbre - I am in love And should I say his incredible, insane, crazy visuals? Look at him, he is unbelieveably handsome

[@トキヤ-v8k]

サン君の素敵な歌声が心に染みます by Besty

[@bronzepistachio]

Thank you for coming, Besty!

[@dreamynochu2149]

눈물이 멈추지 않아요 ㅠㅠ 산이오빠 노래 감사합니다 아주 긴 하루 후에, 나는 정말로 필요했습니다

[@chemistryofhappiness]

Is there anything San cannot do? Singing, dancing, acting, fitness, making jokes, entertaining fans, and just being a lovely human. ❤ I can't wait to see and support what other endeavors he and Ateez have on their journey.

[@jencvxie]

“you did a good job” no one has ever told me this before and hearing it from my favourite person is so heartwarming

[@inekira1117]

You did a good job dear, you do an awesome job every day!! You are not alone!

[@jencvxie]

@@inekira1117 oh you’re so cute thank you

[@miahsalle299]

not only i wish him to act in a kdrama, but i also want him to sing an ost for a kdrama!!! his voice is so soothing to ears and it's full of emotions~ san omg i'm so proud that you're my bias

[@audreybreuls9117]

But, he was in a drama? Together with Seonghwa and Jongho

[@hunnny3860]

Its been an eternity waiting for San’s beautiful golden voice. He’s so versatile and I cant wait to hear more solo work from him.

[@jemsenz]

Yes!!!

[@쪰-o7z]

산아 정말 힘든하루였는데 노래 듣고 위로가 많이되고 울컥했어 항상 응원하고 앞으로도 좋은 노래 많이 들려주는 아티스트가 되길바라💗

[@swagatapal5193]

"It's gonna be alright at the end of the day", the words I like to listen. Thank you San for this amazing cover

[@suchandrimaghosh4085]

This is so comforting na?! 'It's alright', 'it's gonna be alright' is everything that we need to hear sometimes..

[@swagatapal5193]

​@@suchandrimaghosh4085 Bengali Atiny? Omg, I'm so glad that you r here

[@suchandrimaghosh4085]

@@swagatapal5193 hi! Ikr.. bengali atiny r sathe interact korar alada moja..

[@syurippe2225]

BESTYです 去年DUNKで、沢山日本語使ってくれて、「二度付け禁止！」って言ってたのを覚えてます 素敵な歌声ですね

[@Bangteezluvbot]

It's no question that San is an amazing dancer & performer but we often forget to shed light on the fact that he is an amazing vocalist too. This cover was so heartfelt & I love how he conveyed his emotions through his voice the way he does with expression while dancing

[@zenaalzalk]

San's vocals are just soooooo underrated!!!! I LOVE HIS VOICE SOOOOOO MUCH!!!!!! I'm soooooooo happy, I've been waiting for this!!!

[@cotharsis]

san is such a beautiful human, not just his appearance but his voice, his personality, his actions. it shows in every part of him

[@choisan7473]

Exactly

[@구름테이크아웃]

새내기 에이티니로서 언제나 몸이 부숴져라 무대를 채우는 모습에 놀라며 응원하고 있어요. 이 영상이 처음 올라왔을 때를 기억해요. 마음이 따뜻해지며 뭉클한 커버예요. 겸손과 친절을 잊지 않는 산의 생일을 축하해요. 제가 할 수 있는 건 열심히 투표하고 뮤비를 많이 보는 것이지만 언젠가 직접 무대를 볼 수 있길 바라며 투어 중에도 건강 잘 챙기길 바랄게요.

[@April_Atiny]

Hope you do get to see them onstage soon!

[@rattleearth9611]

​​@@April_Atiny.right.. since ateez has their own song cover hopefully to see each member to sing solo in live on stage ...

[@April_Atiny]

@@rattleearth9611 that would be a dream come true!!!😍 I would seriously weep with joy

[@novatiny2941]

this world is so lucky to have someone like our dear San :((

[@HAppygng]

안녕 산아 승선한 지 얼마되지 않은 티니야 아직 에이티즈란그룹도 잘 모르고 개개인 한 명씩도 잘 모르지만 우리 산이는 뭔가 달라서 푹 빠졌어. 단시간에 이렇게 한 사람한테 빠진게 처음인데 그게 우리 산이다. 우리 매력둥이 산아 한숨이란 곡으로 위로해줘서 고마워⛰️ 우리 산이 항상 응원하고 지켜봐줄게 건강하고 아프지말자❣️

[@chanarenko834]

BESTYです。韓国語で和訳を見ないまま聴いたのですが、歌声とサンくんの表情だけで涙が出てきました。優しい方なんでしょうね。また聴きにきます。

[@monicasintes]

Thank you Besty for visiting. San is indeed a kind person

[@kuma8033]

有難うございます

[@martin9592000]

And now I'm crying like an idiot... His voice is so incredibly soulful and beautiful. We love you San! Our beautiful, talented mountain.

[@gabdongipark]

Same like why make us cry pike that

[@teckhengkoh8944]

same

[@vipirayan4922]

all we cry i just wanna ask a question how he can sing like that and how to get a paradise voice you should know evry person we need to sepport ateez because they try so many good things 🤩😍🥰😇☺💔❣💞💓💗🖤🤎💜💙💚💛🧡❤💌👍

[@nanallxx]

San은 정말 아름다운 목소리를 가지고 있습니다! 이 노래는 아름답습니다. 정말 마음에 듭니다. 영혼을 감동시킵니다. 특히 산의 고음... 산의 다음 곡이 정말 기대됩니다

[@이근영-i2r]

당신 한국인이지

[@nanallxx]

​@@이근영-i2r 예, 왜요??

[@SpecialAnimeLover]

​@mabjojlkl Girl quit lying anyone can tell this was translated using a machine 😂

[@nanallxx]

@@SpecialAnimeLover 우선 저는 여자가 아닙니다. 둘째, 통역사를 확인하십시오. 그는 분명히 괜찮지 않습니다.

[@Blue_Pearlz]

​@@SpecialAnimeLover Wth can't a Korean listen to Ateez?? 🤔

[@run2won]

The way I started crying at the chorus, his voice is so beautiful I can't 🥹

[@ure-tano]

BESTYです。DUNKでパワフルなパフォーマンスで一番惹かれたのがSANさんでした。このバラードは印象が全く違ってこの姿もまた素敵すぎますね！すごく優しい歌声☺️。

[@bronzepistachio]

Hi Besty! Thank you for loving Sani ❤

[@oacity]

San is just so good at dancing that I always forgot he's one of the vocalists in ateez 😂

[@ryntiny]

Choi San i am so thankful to have you as my bias!!! Your talent when it comes to expressing yourself whether through your facial expressions, body language, or voice it is always undeniably perfect.

[@resmidrebolledo2073]

🤝

[@fed4945]

No because this man can seriously become the biggest thing in kpop, like I’m so serious when I say he’s the most talented idol out there. Having these kind of vocals while being one of the best dancers and the best performer, excels at acting, athletic, model like body proportions and goes viral for his visuals every other day. Like kq hit the jackpot with him. The amount of requests he would have if kq let him shine, the amount of wasted opportunities by letting the world hear him sing for more than 1 minute straight and in a different range than his usual only 5 years after his debut despite being the lead vocalist. Kq you messed up big with him. I hope from now on things will change and he’ll get his well deserved recognition.

[@thatoneATINYinthecomments]

Right! KQ Been holding him back this whole time!🤦🏻‍♀️

[@chels8412]

Guys as much as I agree Sannie is one of the most talented idols out there Ateez is a team, KQ equally gives all 8 members opportunities to shine. Most times it's up to them to accept.

[@thatoneATINYinthecomments]

@@chels8412 not really, if your an OT8 atiny like me, it’s clear as day that some members are favored in certain areas from KQ, especially creative freedom wise. But I’m not going to name names and no it’s obvious it’s not San. In order for Ateez to gain more fans and get more attention from locals allowing the members to do covers or projects that show off their talent would be the best way to gain that. In general, I just think KQ has really done a terrible job at promoting the members individual talents and potential. I mean they wasted at least 4 years of not allowing Ateez members to drop covers besides hongjoong and jongho for obvious reasons. Ateez are eight members and should be promoted as a group, but it also doesn’t hurt to give the fans what they want and in this case San being so popular is something that even KQ didn’t see it coming. KQ has never given San the proper credits he deserves and even now he seems to be getting less lines in titles tracks than some of the other vocalists considering that San is THE LEAD VOCALIST. This is why we are getting more vocal about this problem because it’s only become more noticeable as the years pass, but who knows maybe this cover is a change in that KQ is actually trying to do better and let the members have more freedom. Time will only tell.

[@chels8412]

@@rainydaysatz this is exactly my thoughts

[@thatoneATINYinthecomments]

@@chels8412 it’s not accusations when there is proof right in front of us. You just choose not to see it and turn a blind eye and victimize other members as an excuse not to see how San has been unfairly treated in showing his potential and talent. And that’s just it, why should San be the main member to consistently sacrifice his lines for two other members, when in fact San is also a more proficient vocalist than said two. You guys are the same type of people that would cry about if Jongho had to sacrifice most of his lines for other members, but it’s not the same when it happens with San. I guess you never saw the live where a fan asked Mingi if he was going to do a cover or if any of the the members were going to and Mingi replied by saying that the company was not allowing it right now. Which I thought was weird. Or I guess you missed the universe pm messages where both hongjoong talked about teaching San how to produce songs, and even San voicing out how he’s been practicing writing lyrics and wants to get more into producing and produce a song for Ateez. Yeosang also stated half a year ago that he wanted to do a vocal cover and lord knows when KQ will actually allow him to do that, cause it took 5 years to let their lead vocalist finally have a proper cover. The boys have been very vocal about their interests and their wants on lives and pm messages, but some fans like you still choose not to see it. Sure timing could also be a main factor here where the boys have had a nonstop schedule for the past year, but it makes wonder why they couldn’t have given us covers of certain members before then like back in 2021 or 2020. And if you think I’m being biased, this applies to actually most of the members. Like when is Yunho gonna have an official full dance cover? He a main dancer but KQ seems to not prioritize this. Or when is Mingi gonna release his first rap cover or 1st fully produced song. We’ve seen glimpses here and there and we know he’s capable of it. There’s just no reason why KQ should be holding back the boys on their individual projects. That’s where my main frustration lies.

[@각채트]

산이의 한숨 목소리가 너무 애절하게 들어온다.. 산아 고마워 그리고 사랑해

[@eviesnot]

My favorite voice ever, it’s just so angelic and full of emotions. He literally sings his heart out every time and you can’t help but get goosebumps. San you’re so talented, the industry already knows you as the best performer ever but I know this cover is just the beginning and from now on you’ll make a name for yourself as one of the best vocalists as well

[@estherbunny]

i was a bit worried cause this song is so important and hard to cover, but Sannie did such a great job, and i think he is the perfect person to cover this song. He really is such a comforting and empathetic person, you can tell he means every word

[@noorwahidd]

GIVE THIS MAN AN OST RIGHT NOW

[@yukimomo8702]

いつも自分のために心から深呼吸しようって思えるよ♡ サンくんありがとう しっかり休んでね〜

[@정유노-n7j]

아름다운 커버 정말 고마워 산아 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 우리 산이도 에이티즈도 정말 수고했어요

[@fenchortu]

His voice is laced so deeply with emotions that it pours directly to your heart. Well done Sannie. I hope you let yourself be held and told you did a good job as well.

[@ying-wc1ex]

힘들고 마음이 부러질 것 같을 때면 항상 이 동영상을 보며 당신의 진심 어린 노랫소리에 위로를 받고 있습니다. 멋진 노래를 가르쳐주고, 멋지게 전해줘서 고마워요

[@Choi_Rania]

Can we make it 2M before San's bday??? Let's go Puddings!!

[@GIRLBOSS-1111]

wowwwww I'm so amazed by his voice. I always knew him for his charisma, visuals, and powerful stage prescence, but he's literally all rounder?!

[@bronzepistachio]

❤ yes he is! Cutest, warmest, most affectionate & most encouraging too

[@nessatrbl]

as a shawol and fairly new atiny this means a lot to me. It’s like this song reincarnated into a new generation and a new part of my life being welcomed into a new fandom 😭

[@JaehyunsHeart]

Jonghyun wrote this song so beautifully! Us shawols are strong! Jonghyun is looking down on us so proudly! I miss him so much!

[@bbaekguy]

This song touched the soul. Choi San's soft voice made it feel like this song was for me... I don't even know what to say but I want to thank Choi San, all of ATEEZ and even KQ entertainment. ATEEZ is the only reason I have to breathe. Without them, I would probably be somewhere far away from here... Thanks to all ATEEZ for all the affirming words and for always making me smile. Thanks also to KQ entertainment for bringing ATEEZ to the public world. I'm really grateful to everyone!! I hope to make Ateez proud 🙁

[@sorahinata9040]

サンさんこんなに優しい歌唱をされる方だったのですね パフォーマンスとギャップがありすぎて溶けます🫠💕…トークも面白いし日本語も上手で好きしかない 辛い時や立ち止まってしまった時に大丈夫だよって抱き抱えられるような包み込むような歌声で私の琴線に触れました。コラボから知りましたがATEEZさんの推しはサンさんになりそう🫶🏻 サンさんの歌声もっと聴きたいです🥹…どこへ行けば聴けますか？

[@EB990]

You can try his duet with Jongho called Dear Name by IU or his unit track Its You with Wooyoung and Yeosang. He also sings randomly on his lives but i dont know how to search for them.

[@sorahinata9040]

@@EB990 ありがとうございます🥹 早速聴いてきました！ サンさんの歌声はとても柔らかくて好きです🥲✨ 高音は優しさと切なさを感じて Dear Nameは特に気に入りました！

[@shannahbanana]

It takes someone special to cover such a special and meaningful song. Thank you for treating it well.

[@W0W..]

우리 사니는 괜찮은지 요즘들어 부쩍 궁금해 소식 못 들어도 좋으니까 그동안 푹 쉴 수 있는 휴가가 주어지길 늘 기도할게 산아 오늘도 사랑해❤️

[@resmidrebolledo2073]

❤️

[@wineandgin812]

今まさにしんどい最中だったから、歌詞をみて涙が止まりませんでした。とっても癒されました。そして、この曲を作った人のことを知って、また歌詞の重さに泣いてしまいます。サンくん、癒しをありがとう。私もサンくんに同じ言葉を返してあげたいです。

[@나-p9y]

定期的に聴きたくなる。心が疲れた時に大好きだった曲だけど、大好きなサンくんが歌ってくれてからさらにこの曲が大好きになったよ

[@christinaaddison3784]

I didn't know the history of this song...only knew that first time I listened to it San's voice brought me to tears. I watched it 10 more times - cried every time. Took a week off and didn't watch it wondering if it was partly my state of mind at the time....watched again today....full flowing tears. San - you are so talented and have the most beautiful voice that literally brings people to tears. You are a beautiful and talented person inside and out. San - you didn't do a good job - you did an AMAZING job and I am so grateful to be able to witness your growth and talent. You are the BEST and I will always support you....always.

[@joyjoyace]

This song was written for Lee Hi by Jonghyun, the idol that we lost back in 2017

[@nevirai2092]

the lyrics hits so hard and San deliver the emotions of the song so well, enough to make me cry ಥ⁠‿⁠ಥ thank you Sanah we love you so much

[@serena5876]

san is always (rightfully) praised for his performance skills but everyone seems to forget that he’s also an amazing vocalist and this cover proves it. i’ve stanned him for over 2 years now and words cannot express how happy and proud that he’s finally sharing his warm and passionate vocals to the fullest extent. i can tell he put so much care into this and it’s nice to see that it came out so well. also apprently he decidated this song to himself during his high school years. san, i am so glad your hard work paid off and that you’ve grown up to be the comforting hill that people can lean on when they’re having a hard time. you’ve truly lived up to your name. thank you for this cover, thank you spreading your kindness and warmth and thank you for never giving up. we love you 💜

[@ureignhere]

The emotion, the power, the Message of the whole song. He did so well putting respect on the Original Singer and Writer's emotions and message. I hope Jonghyun is resting in Peace.

[@ivyhollyfoot4110]

Hi San, I don't know if you will read this but I just wanted to leave this here. I want to tell you how proud of you we are as Atiny. And I want to say that I'm so proud of how well you are doing. You are so talented and you are such a sweet person and honestly, I can't express how much I love you and appreciate you because I don't have the proper words for it. And I want to thank you for doing this beautiful cover. I've done a lot of mistakes in my past, and I'm not proud of them at all. But hearing the words "It's okay" made me start crying because I've been so scared of making a mistake again that I've completely frozen on trying again. Thank you so much San. And I hope you are eating well and staying healthy. From a very thankful Sri Lankan Atiny.

[@Sofieto_]

You're so strong atiny, you've got this ❤

[@ivyhollyfoot4110]

@@Sofieto_ Thank you❤

[@w8oyo]

It’s okay to do mistake everyone makes mistakes sometimes and it’s okay your a good person and you are strong 💪🏼 don’t feel bad you are good atiny❤️‍🩹🫂

[@jmel-nw6pc]

that was so sweet 🥺 i hope he reads it!

[@Cat1088cat]

Ivy, we are given more strength for recognizing our mistakes. As long as we are alive, we have time to change our lives so as not to keep repeating those mistakes. I think by all of us recognizing how wonderful San & the rest of ATEEZ are, the wonderful messages they impart on us when we listen to their songs & appreciate their fantastic dance moves, help us gain in our strength. I get so lost in their chatter with each other or get sooooo impressed with their sports agility, that I don’t have time to concentrate on making mistakes. We are so very lucky to have them in our lives. They…especially San…are so very important to me. But I still can’t figure out how to become an Atiny. It’s way toooooo complicated I hope we get to hear more from them…in ENGLISH❣️❣️❣️❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 our lives

[@mayasprouts]

최산, 이번 커버 정말 감사합니다. 가사, 목소리, 전하는 메시지, 모든 게 완벽하다. 기쁠 때나 나쁠 때나 에이티니 옆에 있어줘서 고맙다. 슬플때마다 이 커버 들으러 갑니다. 감사합니다

[@菅家明美-f7r]

待っていました 素敵な、お声、落ち着きます

[@cooperbear5159]

진짜 고맙다 산아.... 내가 힘들 때마다 네가 힘이 되어 줘서 너무 고마워..

[@user-qw6js4ch2t]

ファンの方のXでお誕生日が近いと知り観にきました！D.U.N.K.で初めてATEEZさんを知りHush-Hushコラボ曲MVを観ています その2つではこんなに切ないサンさんに出逢っていなかったのですごく驚いています 綺麗な歌声ですね また聴きに来ます

[@Sujeongblue]

サンはギャップ王子です✨私もATEEZのがっつり曲のステージ動画見た後とかこの動画見ると胸キュンが止まらないです、、！

[@kingchoisan]

Come here after watch San's Warrior. I'm so proud of him. He is so talented. Amazing all rounder. Choi San you really achieved your dreams to be a singer, an idol for many idols, the comforting for others and the enormous mountain that no one dare to challenge. You really worked hard. ❤ Hope you know you're being loved by so many.

[@Soy.la.Tormenta]

That’s literally what I did. And I Subscribed to this channel only for San. 😊

[@xanthesegovstein6494]

As a shawol. I’m impressed. This song was written by Jonghyun. Thank you San for covering this song well!

[@kingchoisan]

San do you know how many idol fanboys love you?? Today at The Show, even their fans said he only kept looking at you and not their fans until encore. ☹️❤️‍🩹 Those idols always watch and monitor your fancam. You're their role models of these 4th & 5th generation of kpop. The man who raised the kpop performance standard.

[@culpantan645]

🤧🤧🤧🤧 uri Sanie is an whole package gokden hearted best man my baby

[@miiiii-cb1fm]

BESTYです！DUNKでRYUHEIくんと仲良くお話ししてるお顔が優しくて一気にファンになりました。歌声も素敵！

[@bronzepistachio]

Thank you for being here, Besty! San is a beautiful and gentle soul

[@runab750]

I can feel him pouring his heart in every single word in this song, he really meaning it.

[@animegirl1414_random]

me too🥺🤍 I think this is why he is my favorite voice, he’s not only expressive in terms of facial expressions when he’s performing, but also with the way he sings :((

[@VIPShirlee03]

@@animegirl1414_random our king of expression

[@VIPShirlee03]

i read that this particular song was a song he wanted to sing to someone since he was in high school

[@runab750]

@@animegirl1414_random He really is a complete artist ♥️

[@runab750]

@@VIPShirlee03 yes someone said that he used honorific when he said that on fan cafe so I think it's someone that he really care and respect 🥹