Spiritual Authority of the Awliyā’ in the Shi‘i and Sufi Traditions - Dr Rebecca Masterton

[@Serviteur313]

Amazing sister !

[@bajramtahiri1576]

I’m sufi of the Bektashi order and we believe in the 12 imams

[@atanabawi2085]

The Naqshabandi do also

[@alihameed5389]

thank you for this, what reading would you recommend on this subject, the influence and importance of the imams in the formative years of sufism?

[@newcivilisation]

You are welcome. There aren't really many books that specifically deal with the subject. At the moment it needs research, i.e. studying the ahadith in the Shi'i collections and critically comparing those with texts written by Sunni Sufis.

[@ishfaqyatoo3568]

Dear sister watched your many video regarding islam. You r really an inspiration for all of us .i am an advocate by profession from indian occupied kashmir. I want to read more islamic books. Could you suggest me dr sahiba which books i should read. ....bcz u r experienced person first u converted from one religion to another and then learn about another religion understand that in a well manner. ...i have a need of books in english version i tried a lot to get but i couldn't get..here is not available in english version. If u have possible kindly give me. .......waiting eagerly for your reply?

[@newcivilisation]

Dear brother, there are many pdfs of books and articles online. If you have an email address I can send some iA. With du'as

[@ishfaqyatoo3568]

@@newcivilisation [e-mail]

[@moz2010ify]

Any support of these doctrines from the holy Qur'an?

[@majorpremise]

Any support for Wahhabi Takfiri innovations (like lighting Jordanian air force pilots on fire and eating heart and liver of Syrian soldiers) from the Qurʾān??

[@moz2010ify]

@@majorpremise good question as well!

[@ytee8965]

Just mixing every4hing up and making a soup

[@loxmyth1]

😂

[@Aliameem]

I think she makes some very valid points.

[@justahumanbeing.709]

everyone loves soup!

[@newcivilisation]

It is a little difficult to understand for beginners.

[@majorpremise]

Wahhabism assists the British to dismantle the Ottoman Sultanate and makes chicken stew!

Shia doctrine is not Islam Prophet Muhammad pbuh was not a shia.

[@Aliameem]

If the Prophet Ibraheem is referred to as a Shi'a of Nuh, and Moses is referred to as having Shi'a who he helped, then what is The Prophet Mohammad if he says " Ali is to me as Haroon was to Musa" & in light of the fact that you say "God bless Mohammad and his family as you blessed Ibraheem and his family..", and Ibraheem is a Shi'a of Nuh ? And who are The Shi'a of Ali if they are NOT Imam Hassan, Hussein and Lady Fatema (as) ? And. If The Party of Ali includes Mohammad, then why CAN'T Mohammad be a Shi'a, (when the other Prophet are referred to as it).

[@golisports7535]

Prophet Muhammad pbuh was just muslim, during his lifetime there was no Shia or Sunni. Everybody respect the household of prophet the same wether that person is Shia or Sunni. If you think you are much better than others. Then in the eyes of lord you are low life who is in brotherhood of ibles (Shaitan).

[@Aliameem]

@@golisports7535 Sorry. But you just contradicted yourself. Let's talk about something else. See my profile pic. I painted that myself. I think we have something in common . Artistic lifestyle. What exactly is it that makes you artistic ?