[SS/AUT] Cid Kagenou / Shadow Comparison

[@CosmicStars.]

I don't want to see both game's meat rider in the comment section yapping and praising their own favourite game, thank you

[@hw2736]

hundreds of hours vs hundreds of dollars.

[@cernbest]

So true

[@Youraverage_commenter-yi8yf]

Why dollars?

[@hw2736]

@@Youraverage_commenter-yi8yf well you gotta pay money and roll for it

[@levi_rockingthemhips330]

@@Youraverage_commenter-yi8yf becuz u have to p2w to get cid in ss ( u can get lucky too but mostly u have to spend alot)

[@javigamerxiir7107]

cid is just a couple hours in aut (also they have free code for him)

[@HardCoreGammon]

tbh SS cid just feels more like an shadow moveset and looks clean and I mean like AUT did the shadow moveset good but SS made it better

[@ikari2927]

keep gobbling

[@greenflamesubaru]

@@ikari2927 if someone likes SS cid, they're gobbling, but if someone likes AUT cid, they're okay?

[@ikari2927]

@@greenflamesubaru nah they ass,overpricing,SS is horrible gamr doe,in aut i dont spend more than 2 houra just for 1 spec

[@greenflamesubaru]

@@ikari2927 yeah, but before quests came back, people would have to spend questionable amounts of money (i don't know if there's pity or not)

[@Stando-User]

⁠​⁠@@ikari2927aut is also ass and “overpricing”, buggy and some quests don’t even work because of their over reliance on gacha

[@Motiscool]

Everything goes to aut, except the "highest" move

[@greenflamesubaru]

even atomic is crazy

[@matchacorp_youtube]

highest and atomic suck

[@sub0mc49]

Highest startup looks cooler than the move except, and atomic in aut is cheeks. Its better than SS everywhere else tho

[@oversizedlemon]

And whatever that atomic vfx is

[@Youraverage_commenter-yi8yf]

@@Motiscool highest looks pretty fire，the lines are thin and makes the player look fast and swift, animations is clean too but it's your option so sure ig can't argue with that.

[@comentaristachileno8080]

Overdrive also buffs special, making it so your heal move whips out around 30-50 extra healing, good for parties since holding the move also heals party members (There's high chances that Cultivation/Soul Reaping Cultivation also buffs it, and sadly I got the hexed one on a Yuta)

[@Youraverage_commenter-yi8yf]

@@comentaristachileno8080 oh never knew it was aoe thx man

[@crazydudealpha8946]

Does normal cultivation stats reset when u die like the hexed one?

[@comentaristachileno8080]

@@crazydudealpha8946 I got normal Cultivation on Shadow, and at least it does only if you change the spec (I think SRC/Soul Reaping Cultivation has a glitch that transfers 3 of the added stats to other spec but it probably was patched.) Now, the only time I did max the stats with my Cultivation Shadow, I sadly got my mount bugged, had to reset to get unstuck and for some reason all the stats got wiped out, thing I remember the hexed variant NOT doing. Honest to god, if you get normal Cult, change it for any other less time wasting trait since healing 185.5 with what should be 170 special points AND making a barely 1K dmg "I am Atomic" (against NPCs) with 230 attack points is not all that worth it in my opinion, Gluttonous/True/Gambler works just as well. (Side-note: SRC only returns one stat to normal upon death so, for the case I suffered, the Hexed variant is an straight upgrade, go figure why.)

[@AUTRASED_69]

Ss is way better in my opinion.. Because of the highest being a massive aoe instead of a cutscenes that does to one person

[@IRikku]

AUT is good in animations whilst SS is good in graphics

[@siemanko102]

lol aut clears Sakura stand

[@matchacorp_youtube]

@@IRikkuhonestly i dont like both games but after seeing that SS has a new dev team i got a feeling that if they reworked cid he’d be an absolute monster because this comparison here is just aut being compared to an old moveset made by 1 person

[@ikari2927]

zip up their pants

[@Frieschutz]

Cid used it on one person in the series, it's more accurate.

[@toastlov3r375]

WE MOGGED SS WE MOGGED SS WE MOGGED SS WE MOGGED SS WE MOGGED SS WE MOGGED SS WE MOGGED SS WE MOGGED SS WE MOGGED SS WE MOGGED SS WE MOGGED SS

[@CosmicStars.]

what the devils is that a tester

[@harababura2634]

toast you're a loser

[@cadaverousRemains]

doing tricks on it

[@toastlov3r375]

@@CosmicStars. uhhhhh no i'm just a regular player gang.

[@Zephyr_Gaming34]

Aut cooked so much you know already know they won

[@SplittedCorn]

SS I am Atomic feels better tbh

[@EMvolts154]

​@@SplittedCornye only 1 move

[@kimanijoseph4258]

Imma give the win to aut, ss cooked but i feel like aut cid has better animation and other stuff in general

[@xx_sumiafton_xx7131]

AUT cause of the combat and how it feels to play cid

[@1TMG]

Animation and cutscenes go to aut but vfx n accuracy go to SS by a landslide

[@animationmaster305]

I have to disagree with the Vfx it looks sharper and more clean in aut (in my opinion) but I do like SS move concepts better than auts, I also like the *I am atomic* in SS more but I like auts more overall

[@EdwinYap-rp1zo]

Actually the R move in aut is infinity and gives you healing.

[@AlahabarSurik]

Aut cooked, ss not so much but still good

[@matchacorp_youtube]

ss cid was made by 1 person remember that, also the new VFX is also made by 1 person thats very experienced

[@catreloader618]

​@@matchacorp_youtube so?

[@RenzyRanz]

​@@matchacorp_youtube so?

[@strobalicious]

@@catreloader618he means that if they really wanted, ss would absolutely destroy aut cid in terms of vfx

[@roxafeIIa]

​@@matchacorp_youtubeso ?why dont they just ask for more people to work on cid then ?

[@Adam-q7e]

yo what font are you using?

[@ch4rliegaming]

atleast SS does cinematics but AUT wins

[@SpelingNotGoot]

I’m gonna say AUT purely because it doesn’t consist of spending hundred of real life dollars to get Cid.

[@ZENITH.163]

Not a hundred dollars but worse a hundred hours...

[@adriand6561]

@@ZENITH.163 cid quest is not even hard

[@chesterdosentcare1008]

They nerfed getting cid difficulty in Sakura stand it’s so easy to get that it droped to B tier in value

[@francescoassenzaparisi6488]

Lol you can get CID with no Money and Is Easy I get CID in 3 week

[@light3166]

@@francescoassenzaparisi64883 weeks for one spec is crazy and bro is out here saying it like its nothing

[@shino3963]

SS's cid is much more superior but for Aut's it's average not that bad nor too good, i like em both Oh... Cool font i like it and I want it too xd

[@TheRandomestRandomest]

AUT wins in being canon to both anime and manga, both wins in VFX and SFX, SS takes the cake for I am atomic and Highest and also wins in being p2w, AUT wins in being f2p and in making the player suffer

[@MrMarshmallow.]

Aut beats SS in moves, however SS has more accurate presentation, SS takes the win in my opinion

[@aurorareyes9368]

But one thing that is different aut cid doesn't have the teleport ability that you can just fast travel just saying the place that you need to go only SS has the fast travel teleport that you say the place that you need to go

[@EMvolts154]

Just like planet shaper

[@chinounagesuki8118]

When it comes to more accurate, SS Cid, but Cid in SS is very annoying with the highest move cinematic, even tho i am away from the range of it i still get the cinematic of their ugly headless emo avatars and ruins my long start up range attacks, also able to pause my avatar and getting hit from a person im fighting against. When it comes to smooth gameplay and animation, AUT Cid, pretty fun specs tho i hate his dash because of how far it is that i cant predict the distance just to hit an enemy. Atomic in AUT is pretty annoying because of how low the global cooldown is and it lags the whole server when someone is farming in JJK mobs with Cid. I vote for AUT for being simple and clean.

[@sam_noob1136]

Sakura stand for the win plus ss obtainment is just gambling plus there's pity aut obtainment is just pain.

[@Winterseason116]

I like both of them

[@MehIdk.]

ss cid is pretty old, but ex dev Fate nailed how accurate the moves is. i might list all the references Fate made Overdrive, obvious Highest, is when he fights weakened Aurora Y move(for short) is when Cid curbstomp 2 women(true gender equality) Dashes and Z are most likely when Cid fight Beatrix Do i even need to talk about Atomic? and we have admin Cid with All Range Atomic that kills the entire server lmao

[@MehIdk.]

aut cid is a new one, founding references is a pain, 5 obvious references and nothing more(new reference: John Smith using puppet strings to fight) I kinda expect Recovery Atomic to be AOE instant healing but guess not It's hard to find references to add on Cid, but hey the new moves are cool i guess.

[@MehIdk.]

Btw this is my personal Cid moveset that i want them to add Idle is pretty similar to ss, divine unlike aut's cid idle somewhat brutish M1s can be what they wanted ok, just dont add too many flashy spins E, i might take some slashing barrage ending with a giant stab and a spinning hook kick R move would be conjuring a slime crowbar and bonk in the head(ep 1 season 1 reference) T is a grab type move, dashing at the target, low kick the leg(victim fall down to the ground) and get stomped like 2 women(make that shit painful as much as u can) Y using slimes to make 2 crowbars, giving new M1s which have more hits and parry everything for 10 seconds(some certain moves bypass it) G, stops using the slime sword and starts using puppet strings to make anyone within range stuck, like a spider's webbed up prey. H is the highest scene ofc, make it AOE and accurate to the anime as much as you can. J: Atomic. You can either drop a tsar bomba on everyone in the server or drop a instant tsar bomba, but heals every, single, player, as long as they are in range. Teleport dashes that makes no vfx, just a stepping sound. also if you guys make a taunt, make a global taunt that can, and will, NUKE THE ENTIRE SERVER WITH ATOMIC, make it cancellable so people can stop u.

[@TheRobloxian-lc2sr]

holy yapping but true

[@darealgooba]

The people saying ss cid is better are just meatriding (I have 900 hours on aut and 1.8k on ss)

[@shadow-16385]

i personally like aut's better because it's more accurate to cid and has alot more moves, but sakura stand's atomic is WAY better (no i'm not biased i play both games ALOT)

[@aurorareyes9368]

But the atomic version of aut doesn't one shot players but when max damage it almost does same as the SS atomic I'm thinking both can one shot

[@_wonder_0f_u_]

aut cooked fr

[@tonkra2843]

agree

[@jojopage8876]

aut moveset has clearly nothing like cid, while sakura stand made it perfectly

[@kcoolthegamer]

Huh, the SS effects are nothing like the actual anime

[@kcoolthegamer]

Atomic and highest could use some work for aut tho

[@AbsoluteChaos321]

Aut : anubis with steroids Ss : True Anubis (With Many drugs)

[@kyte_real]

waited for this

[@isaiahenzo641]

i like sakura stand atomic more but imo except for atomic, aut cooked

[@TotallyNotAtom]

Why tf is some of aut meat riders here in this comment section bro get out we don’t need you we only want respectful me say me myself a long time fan of ss and aut I play both of them when they first release like the actual first day I still remember when I pay 25 robux for access to ss and the first map ever of aut I like both of the game equally but for me I like both since ss cid just feels a lot more impactful imo with all the range of attack and effect and stuff it’s also seemed more accurate to the original cid and some of the attacks it’s like how can I explain this elegant it just feels like something cid would actually do but aut highest is the best one I have ever in all of the game that have cid that move is crazy and also the first time I see someone added atomic slash same as eidolon tears too and their overdrive animation is absolutely amazing too and the animation is crazy with all the moves and stuff and that’s why I think both of them tied since they both are good in their own ways aut is more like the animation while ss is more like I don’t know how to explain it but anyway always remember it’s just my opinion your opinion can be different than mine just don’t try to project your own opinion in other people just because they don’t like the same thing as you

[@FushiguroTheFushiguro]

ss cid looks way more elegant and canon, tho it lacks unique skills compared to aut cid since it was made by 1 person and the atomic is way better, tho , I'd prefer ss cid over aut cid because ss cid is literally gambling

[@PhatTran-yy3ev]

aut cooked 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@Isnixe1]

All range sound added back?

[@BlankUser.]

comparing a unfinished spec to a completed one yall must be out of ideas for content or something

[@Kensuchi]

Why is everyone fighting in the comments and replies 😂

[@Call_me_liebe]

my cid got flung and i lost 4 days of grindning what do i do

[@Rotlzldi]

Yaaayyyy

[@Cookie-catto]

Honest opinion? SS did him better in terms of effects and sound effects. Other though aut did slightly better

[@ShampticBackup]

Nice roblox skin i sub

[@TheRealThud40]

I gotta say ss version the highest and atomic look better not to mention the actual teleport to places around the map but everything else id say aut did better

[@mathhpk]

How get this custom font?

[@NhatNamTran-nj7ic]

Aut cooked but ss takes W today

[@bilatniagnes2281]

fr aut's atomic is meh

[@Just_A_Tusk]

​@@bilatniagnes2281 I mean its hella dmg and great grind but the sfx... Its lokking like a purple square 😭

[@NhatNamTran-nj7ic]

@@bilatniagnes2281 yeah it is

[@bilatniagnes2281]

@@Just_A_Tusk i agree, gain meter + atomic + die + repeat process

[@bilatniagnes2281]

@@Just_A_Tusk it's clearly a rushed atomic cuz players pushed the devs to release the upd early

[@progamerbr3320]

ss cid: can tp, atomic very easy to run from, stop time even for a little bit, good pose, mid damage, less moves than aut. Aut cid: bad pose, can heal alot,cant stop time, hard to run from atomic, mid/high damage. Aut could add tp for cid and a pose where cid is sitting on a throne with the dark flames on one of his hands.

[@24HoursCinderella]

Ngl, i like aut's pose more And they got tp too

[@light_gryphon2425]

Aut cid has tp too

[@SungJinWoo0308]

I agree with u bro ss cid pose way more better than aut

[@SungJinWoo0308]

@@light_gryphon2425 how?

[@Itz-Nicky]

​@@SungJinWoo0308it's literally the "Atomic: Flash" move.

[@ninjaxxu2.084]

Everyone praise aut but before summer update everyone hated aut

[@SomeoneThatExists-rj5oo]

I mean, while the ope quest was pain, phase one brought back quests and fixed input lag, which is a BIG W Sure, it's not great, but with the direction they're going, I think it'll turn out to be decent in the near future

[@Lofai511]

Both obtainments sucks hard But I’d prefer aut, at least they ain’t got a banner for cid

[@timurzp1204]

reminder: cid was made by 1 person(fate) before quiting from making game and aut had a whole team to make that unbalanced spec

[@EMvolts154]

Yes a whole team 1 person for vfx , 1 person for clean animation , 1 person for the sfx and 1 person for the movesets idea so what?

[@timurzp1204]

@@EMvolts154 fate as over working and rushing while in aut team 1 could do cripting while other one was doing animations and stuff

[@Mr_Rykes]

Besides atomic and maybe highest, aut wins

[@Calleraisofti]

Aut atomic looks kinda small ngl

[@MeowZaChan]

I still love SS Atomic it look more cooler and better

[@MeowZaChan]

I love that AUT CID got more skill than SS but We need more CID sound, So if he got a skin or add more skill sound that would better…

[@roxafeIIa]

yea I do agree aut atomic looks so goofy 💀

[@justanormaldude5182]

uhhh both of them r good 👍

[@tiramisu02]

AUT did it way better, it feels complete. SS feels like a toolbox item.. still nice though.

[@ShindoSB]

i feel like aut is better because i dont have to waste irl money

[@ARCEMISL33]

Honestly, SS has better atomic in terms of VFX but AUT beats SS overall

[@Isnixe1]

only atomic was better😂

[@BlankUser.]

@@Isnixe1 ss had a better concept of cid, aut cid is just mostly grab moves

[@thakid3116]

I feel like people only like aut more because it has more skills to look at but in all honesty Atomic is all that matters and SS won the fight 10 fold

[@thakid3116]

@@Kyuubey0406 Atomic being Cid's signature move makes it infinity more important than everything else. And aut atomic is horrible not only is it small but they try to cover up their failure with a blank screen.

[@thakid3116]

@@Kyuubey0406​​⁠ can’t tell if aut has a bigger one or not because it blanks out your screen😭they prob did that to hide how horrible it looks😭🙏 who cares which feels better SS is older💀

[@thakid3116]

@@Kyuubey0406 nah how you gonna make a point like that and say it looks like it’s from 2015😭 sorry but aut atomic just ain’t right it leaves no destruction and blanks out your screen so you can’t even see it

[@dolordolor9688]

Wait i met you I was red_Grimson

[@Chrono-j5r]

Aut but the only thing I hate about is the white bread spawn

[@ixnostulol3205]

White 🍞

[@face36345]

Aut cooked but they could have had better vfx for i am atomic

[@LilkravZ]

Honestly combat, atomic, highest and movement goes to cid aut didnt cook

[@oofclub6015]

aut wins but ss feels more like cid

[@Anime1999_lol]

Ss is quick shot type shit bro

[@Hasieur]

Sakura stand take the atomic nuke idk abt others cuz all i care abt cid is just the nuke

[@Honovia]

AUT is a bit too scuffed

[@SiIverRaven]

revert new cid m1 ;-; (the vfx is too flashy and didn't even match the game)

[@Baconhair2349]

Aut better animation and the moves relies to anime and its very clean but the obtainment i have to give it to sakura stand nvm aut

[@No_nameTvT]

Sakura stand so cool

[@penguinsdontstarve1572]

SS atomic: looks good, but easy to escape AUT atomic: a column with a bit of vfx, but... TACTICAL NUKE, INCOMING!!!

[@EdwinYap-rp1zo]

Aut Nuke CID is impossible to escape and good for farming.

[@apollov197]

Ss nuke: you gotta wait 10 mimutes pal. Aut nuke: just reset and u have the cd off lol

[@MeowZaChan]

Nah CID SS ever got unescape nuke before but they change it back to this, So I think they’re have some reason or gimmick that we ever use like !ar in SS

[@chesterdosentcare1008]

They buffed atomic in ss it’s impossible to escape unless ur near the edge

[@Electicfull]

ss better :D but aut also cooked well

[@enzogrilo6932]

AUT is like so.. thats not cid that's sid idfk how people consider it better

[@chesterdosentcare1008]

Fr

[@richiekkkk]

its just...very simple. not even the i am atomic explosion has a texture...

[@Myuklol14]

Both are good but aut atomic is bad in my *opinion*

[@orang8834]

C(m)id

[@mrsaiyan4328]

Ss is only better with atomic aut atomic is so ass

[@amRaichiii]

uhh uhhh uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh standless better, yes

[@greenflamesubaru]

I like Sakura Stand's Cid more however, Overdrive in AUT is cool, though I wished it played music like Sakura Stand's, Atomic Recovery also looks cool, Pose looks sick, but all of the other effects feel lackluster and SS has cooler atomic compared to AUT.

[@thanakritkantitarangkul3071]

Sakura stand better atomic vfx Aut better moveset

[@SoulReaper-AK47]

First! Balls. 🗿

[@Goldy_Catto]

pls nerf cid

[@darkplayer2429]

Ss 🔛🔝

[@enzogrilo6932]

Ong

[@fantalbeatz2420]

Ngl aut could've done bettet on atomic explosion vfx but given that they literally worked on multiple stuff at one and they be pushing these update out in literal weeks it's kinda understandable why cid atomic vfx looks like shit

[@genzoo2469]

aut atomic vfx looks awesome, it's not some random effects going nowhere like in ss, some shitty pillar of something, aut atomic looks just awesome from outside, like an actual nuclear explosion

[@fantalbeatz2420]

@@genzoo2469 they could've done better tbh i mean slap some texture on it and it'd looks more clean rather then now it just looks to me like a plain red and purplish pillar

[@darkest.1501]

In my opinion both are ass, i aint play ss before but ik the obtainment method is fucking insane, But auts is prob worse. All the moves arnt that flashy, which i dont think is really the point of cid. But they still lack

[@sieademation3386]

Aut is just better tbh

[@Stella24311]

Ss better

[@Callmesaito]

Ss win

[@fate4768]

Ngl aut is mid. Doesn't feel like cid at all

[@JugglerJulius]

Ss is better effects wise otherwise aut is better

[@Noir_0-1]

tbh aut's atomic is shit bro 😭

[@Spamzforlife]

all these aut players saying “aut cid better” while ss cid was made by one person 🤦🏾

[@Thezahza]

That's an even better reason to say it's worse than the AUT one. Several people working on one thing is better than a single person.

[@IYIisterJacky]

@@Thezahza The pose barrier aura for AUT's Cid is a freaking rectangle while the VFX on the floor is a circle, sh does not make sense at all and even worse multiple ppl worked on it 😭 And the purple strips that goes on the player's limbs in AUT is a literal invisible part with mesh slapped on top which looks disgusting.

[@ahmeterencavdar7388]

No way ur glazing ss 💀​@@IYIisterJacky

[@nfizq]

@@IYIisterJackyyou’re glazing bro 😭🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@light_gryphon2425]

Why are these guys beefing over poses

[@TheArbiter2024]

umm SS shadow Q OVERDRIVE is 0.05X not 0.5X

[@TheArbiter2024]

: 0

[@CosmicStars.]

they grow with hits

[@MrMarshmallow.]

Aut beats SS in moves, however SS has more accurate presentation, SS takes the win in my opinion