Stamp vs Stamp Episode 8: The Ultimate Stamp Debate with That Dad Guy and Snailmail with Smokey

Get ready for another epic showdown as That Dad Guy and Snailmail with Smokey join forces once again in the latest installment of Stamp vs Stamp! In this highly anticipated episode, the dynamic duo goes head-to-head in a debate to determine the must-have and the must-avoid stamp for their collections. Join in on the fun, arguments, and plenty of stamp talk as they bring their unique perspectives and humor to the table. Who will come out on top in this stamp showdown? Watch now to find out! Don’t forget to Like and Subscribe to both our channels plus leave positive comments and Suggestions for future episodes.
#StampVsStamp #StampCollecting #ThatDadGuy
To Contact
That Dad Guy
PO Box 22
Stn Main
Moncton, NB
E1C 8R9
Canada
Instagram ThatDadGuy1974

[@stephenogier7499]

Wow! You liked my suggestion. That's great and I loved the twist you put on it. I really liked your arguments for both sides of the debate and I loved that you chose the British Guiana 1c magenta. When I thought about the question, I thought it was a bit of a difficult one. As you say, when you are an ardent collector of anything, what is there that you wouldn't add to your collection. But I also thought that for me, since I almost only collect mint stamps, I could just say anything that is not a mint stamp, but that's not entirely correct as I have quite a few used stamps in my collection that I just can't bear to part with. So, well done. You did my question proud.

[@thatdadguy1974]

Thank you so much for the suggestion. We both enjoyed trying to think of how it would work for us.

[@SnailmailwithSmokey]

Well done! I enjoyed you take on this challenge and the wardrobe change was great. Thanks again for collaborating with me every month.

[@thatdadguy1974]

Thanks just me being me haha

[@kozzackkelt]

Very interesting topic - "what stamp you wouldn't want in your collection" Good choice and very rational arguments for having it and not having that stamp in your collection. That stamp is necessary if you collect THAT topic - and your topical collection will forever be ..... lacking, without it. ;-) Thanks for another great Philatelic video !

[@thatdadguy1974]

It was my pleasure. Thank you for watching and commenting

[@GreatStampAdventure]

Hi Rob! I enjoyed this video very much! Great choice of stamp and very good arguments against and for. I loved your wardrobe changes to illustrate your arguments. 🙂🙂🙂I love these collaborations between you and Smokey. So creative! I think the suggestion/question of Stephen was excellent. ... Ooooohh! Having 9 odd million dollars "lying around"! That is a wish. ... Take care!🙂

[@thatdadguy1974]

Yes don’t we all wish we had that unlimited money 🤪

[@mailartlover]

Very interesting twist! I didn't catch at the beginning when you explained it, so then I was like "wait... now he wants to get that stamp?" 😅 I like your arguments on both sides 👍 very entertaining video.

[@thatdadguy1974]

Thank you. I can see how that might be confusing haha

[@idamariegiusti3615]

I saw the magenta on display at postal museum in washington

[@thatdadguy1974]

Did you make an offer for it 🤪?

[@inPostcards]

Oh, how interesting you are changing costumes!))))

[@thatdadguy1974]

Yes playing both sides of the debate

[@ptrinch]

The other major downside risk of the 1 cent magenta lies in the fact that there is only one **known** sample in the world. If someday. someone is looking through their great-grandfather's cigar box and finds a couple mint sample of it, then the value of your stamp will plummet. Sure, still worth millions, but many less than what it once was. Now if you'll excuse me... I have a cigar box to look through. ;-)

[@thatdadguy1974]

Hahaha well I suppose that is a problem too

[@wendybilling2417]

well done1

[@thatdadguy1974]

Thanks

[@wendybilling2417]

You could each pick a stamp for each color of the rainbow and why that stamp/

[@thatdadguy1974]

Good suggestion

[@Robertbrown08049]

You did not mention the best part of owning the British Guiana stamp. You get to put your initials on the back for future owners to see. Your name will be a stamp legend. People will mention your name for generations. People are always talking about the most beautiful stamps. If you have not done it already how about turning the tables and do the most ugliest stamp.

[@thatdadguy1974]

That is an interesting suggestion. Thank you