STAR WARS: SC38 REIMAGINED | DARTH VADER V. OBI-WAN | Reaction | FXitinPost | Jaby Koay | Achara

[@FXitinPost]

Hey, thanks for taking the time to react to Scene 38 and spreading the word! You guys rock!

[@venomusbite3461]

Thank u for ur hard work I’ve shared ur video many times and watch 100 reactions , ur channel and “ Seize The Frame “ should work on a project together if possible and if legal

[@imagomonkei]

Your work is amazing! This is how I always imagined that fight should've gone. It's been nearly 20 years since Mustafar, and Vader has been honing his skills by killing Jedi the whole time waiting to get to Obi-Wan.

[@tonyyul703]

Man I would have sent this video to George Lucas personally

[@tonyyul703]

What makes this video so perfect is how you can see Lord Vader's range of motion...

[@mafiosipepperoni7375]

I hope Disney will add this in the new DvD and Blue Ray from Episode 4. That would be awesome!

[@ryan4327]

Consider what compels the fans of a 40 year old story and why they became geeks for life in the first place. One of the several things I like about this piece is the respect and homage to the original story, that they added to it not trampled on it. That is how it should have been respected in the first place and where Disney Lucasfilm fell down.

[@Deedric_Kee]

I agree 'Jabby this one was more moving than the older one. I old 'Star Wars collection on Blu-ray 👏

[@romaugustine729]

The original is great for its time but 2 have this inserted into the movie will & would make A NEW HOPE much better plus loved how U both weren't taking your eyes away bye Jaby Koay & Achara

[@Angyali]

Wrong! The original choreography for this scene was absolutly poor and trashy, even for 1976, even for an 8 million budget!

[@jakehall7763]

@@Angyali well it's rumoured the actors had to guess where the strikes would end up due to the fact that they were only holding a hilt that didn't have a blade on it. That would explain why the fight looked so weird.

[@MrStonk-ps3er]

@@jakehall7763 no it was actually a prop kinda like a toy light Sabre no guessing was involved

[@paulmichaelfreedman8334]

The original props were made of transparent plastic with lights in and were very fragile. They weren't allowed to touch. Hence the fake moves in the original scene. In ESB they used alumini(u)m rods and very more durable and allowed for slighty more aggressive strikes unless they bent the rods. Since the prequels they used glassfibre sabers that were digitally removed afterwards so any bending or warping during strikes didn't matter, hence the fierce fights in the Prequels.

[@tomyoung9049]

the subtle voiceovers just before the finale, puts what would be going thru their minds.

[@kaharakahara]

you know you did good if the scene made Achara go Ayaya

[@Hibernicus1968]

Regarding the comment at 8:14 -- they were limited by the original props, but not really by how they looked on camera if you moved them a certain way, it was by how fragile they were. Originally, Lucas planned to create the glow totally in camera. The lightsaber blades were three sided wooden rods, and the flats were covered with a scotchlite retroreflector tape (same stuff that's on highway road signs). In the handle was an electric motor that would spin the blade along its long axis, and the rotating blade, with the luminescent tape would create a bright shimmer effect under the studio lights. That didn't look good enough on screen. The glow effect only worked if the blades were at just the right angle, and whenever they weren't, they were clearly visible as rods -- the so they ended up rotoscoping the glowing blade in during post production. They realized this right away, and immediately planned for the rotoscoping while filming was still underway, so they could have made the duel use bigger, more sweeping motions of the lightsabers if that had been the only issue. It wasn't; the props used were always those fragile ones with the rotating blades, and they couldn't be swung about or clashed together very vigorously, or the blades would break. Even so David Prowse kept breaking the blade on his and it had to be replaced each time, stalling filming. This is one reason why they got Bob Anderson to wear the Vader costume for TESB (and they still replaced the lightsaber blades with sturdier, non-rotating aluminum ones); the other was that Bob Anderson was an experienced movie sword fight choreographer and could simply do a better job for the lightsaber duel.

[@venomusbite3461]

Darthvader is only 40 years old

[@The_RedVIII]

This came out months ago, can't believe you completely missed it until now. I actually thought you did a reaction back then, since the Rejects definitely did one and I thought you did too, but guess I remember that wrong.

[@quentinroby9378]

Love u guys

[@ddiver7908]

omg, i think i have a crush on Achara 0_0

[@SB992REBORN]

Pyeah

[@mdabuzar1364]

Hey jaby react on good boys trailer... Its too amazing...😂

[@paulcotero5306]

Please react to Hitopfilms I love venom!!!!!

[@drosnelochmir6346]

00:23 Achara looking smoking hot

[@IloveYou-rb1fk]

Acharas fake reactions ruin everything for me

[@zaandarbrow]

imagine the audience seeing this in 1977

[@paulmichaelfreedman8334]

Imagine how we'd be even more spoilt than today. Last jedi wasn't bad, Too many people have raised the bar way above their heads and now nothing is good enough anymore.

[@cvlcek144]

@@paulmichaelfreedman8334 That's because TLJ was bad. If it wasn't we wouldn't have as much hate for the sequels and solo as the fanbase does. If 90%of the fanbase believes TLJ plus solo is a piece of shit(which they are) then they really must be shit😂

[@EmberQuill]

@@paulmichaelfreedman8334 TLJ had great effects and action sequences (for the most part, although the fight choreography was lacking at times) and I can understand what they were trying to do with Finn's storyline and his side trip with Rose, but the plot itself was lacking. The character development was hamfisted. The tone was inconsistent. The pacing was a mess. The overall plot of the trilogy barely advanced. Finn's entire character arc was treated like a joke until the very end of the movie. Rose was a poorly-written stereotype with no depth despite being a major character. Luke's character arc was shaky, but not absolutely terrible, but his abrupt death was an unsatisfying conclusion to that arc, as well as a terrible send-off for one of the main characters of the whole franchise.

[@nathaniel04]

HeyThereVader I don’t see what was wrong with Solo honestly

[@the_grim_gamer3039]

@@paulmichaelfreedman8334 but TLJ was bad I'm a teen which is who people thinks thinks it's good but no it sucked I've seen enough starwars movies to tell the good from the bad just admit it because a true fan is willing to point out a movies flaws

[@hellowhat890]

4:00 Was basically a tribute to when Anakin and Obi-wan fought inside that corridor during the beginning of their duel on Mustafar. The lights changing to a deep shade of red was actually really cool. Also kind of reminds you of the hallway scene at the end of Rogue One with its dark theme too.

[@bhavyakabade]

Rogue one the casting and writing was actually so good idk why the characters in the sequels had to be so dumb and one sided

[@hellowhat890]

@@bhavyakabade in one word? "Disney"

[@cringekiller348]

hellowhat890 Disney made rogue one.

[@deborahlepage1789]

My mind has tucked this into canon. Lucas probably would have used it lol. And considering his penchant for continuing to tinker, it may yet happen. It's amazing to see Vader at his chilling Sith Lord best. I LOVE this scene and since George Lucas likes to tinker, I hope - HOPE that Lucas sees how very much people love his...what...Eastern/Western story of right, wrong and when courage can help people becomes the people they want to be. It might be a "kids' story" because it's the story you tell over the camp fire to remind people of the dangers faced and that people don't enter their journeys with perfect honor, perfect knowledge or wisdom and definitely not with perfect powerful skills. The steps of the journey have to show the failures and lessons to show the triumphs EARNED. I understand wanting to add in some things to appeal to kids humor, like the desert creatures, one eating another and belching, the world is dangerous, something just died. Leaving the "creatures" and the "droids" as the points of humor for the kids and the audience to laugh a little, but keep all the drama, the questionable moments I guess, because Han shot first, an as a original theater presentation maybe 6 year old audience member, i KNEW that Greedo was telling Han that he was going to kill him and Han shooting first was justified and smart, not just LUCKY. ...sorry, babbling. FactFiend reminded me recently that even now, George Lucas still tinker with Star Wars to get it "perfect," to Fix it in Post is not impossible, and I'd buy it again with THOSE type of changes, and not the overly almost cartoon appeals to kids - who don't need things that blatant, don't expect them to be dumb... Sorry. I loved this. Thank you for sharing. I love seeing Vader kick ass, I'm the weirdo who considered him one of my first heroes. Thank you.

[@thedealer777]

"Impressive, ...MOST IMPRESSIVE!" Almost seamless editing, outstanding computer graphics, and dynamically fluid action. Somebody, call Disney and have them re-shoot this fight scene, paying and using these guys "reimagining" as a paradigm. Then re-re-release the movie again, using the new fight scene, on DVD and/or stream. They'll make 10-20X the money their investment. We've been waiting for this kind of Episode IV fight scene for over forty years.

[@virgildantefrazier1]

Jaby... if you wanna see a great emotional "recreation" of a scene you need to watch "Before the Dark Times." It is the scene of Luke finding Ben the first time in "A New Hope" and Ben explaining what happened to his father. But it is done in a way where the add footage from the prequels to piggyback things he tells Luke. And the intercut scenes and accompanying music are absolutely stunning and gut wrenching at the same time. It's really incredible. Please check it out.

[@1938superman]

Redo the entire original trilogy this way with a proper budget while keeping the spirit of the films. Then simply offer both the original trilogy and the enhanced trilogy.

[@mr.ditkovich2708]

But dont recast it, Disney would probably do that if they remake it

[@Captianmex1C0]

@@mr.ditkovich2708 no shit the actors wouldn't be able to properly act out the duels, with all do half of them are dead

[@daanzoomer2997]

Captain Mexico they can basicly put the face of a actor and a actor like they did with this one alec guiness face is put on this actor idk his name

[@ItsButterBean1020]

I mean they’re fine imo

[@betterlatethannever4529]

See Disney?!! This is what real choreography looks like. None of that throne room bullshit from the last Jedi

[@firstdondiego]

you know, I tend watch a lot of reaction videos and a lot of times it's of the same clip from each youtuber one after the other. ANd by the time I'm at the 5th or 6th reaction video I'm pretty much sick of seeing the same clip. lmao. But I keep watching them though. lol

[@SaRENRampaiger]

Also do a reaction to other fan films of Star Wars: Tie Fighter Remastered anime with dialogue, Darth Maul Apprentice, Lost Patrol, Liberation!!!

[@PACKERMAN2077]

Don't forget Thumb Wars The Phantom cuticle

[@SWTobito0702]

Yeah, in ANH the props department managed the glow effect by covering the lightsabers in reflective material which would reflect the light from the cameras back into them. Sadly that also meant moving the blades out of a certain area within a camera's field of view meant it would lose all that glow. Furthermore the material used to create the blades was very fragile meaning any kind of actual fighting choreography was practically impossible. Add to that Alec Guinness' age and the Vader suit being somewhat clunky to move in and anything other than what we saw on screen was not doable.

[@genesis6422]

This could be inserted into the original Star Wars including prequels 💜

[@blubuddha]

@8:10 the original was all like "Samurai Shodown" .. first off, what the heck does that mean? secondly, that chick looks like she was born in like '97.. how does she have any reference for a '93 Neo Geo game?

[@jimhults4916]

Who made the SC38.

[@YovaRodz]

Awesome reaction, it was very well edited and it is canon in the new era, very awesome work, Disney, take notes XD You guys are a gorgeous couple, keep up your great work! 👍😊

[@matvangogh]

they were flourescent lights . and if you hit them, they would have broken in A new Hope, so the choreogrpahy would be limited.

[@TheGuitarpro3]

Bout fucking time Jabs! This scene definitely surpasses the original scene by leaps and bounds in almost every aspect ... in every aspect tbh. The original scene is still admissible given the time period and resources they had at that time, but damn is this way better.

[@Phyrior]

The props back then snapped against a stiff breeze, so the sticks weren't even touching most of the time. Hence the overlarge contact sparks in the original film.

[@MrSkullHead1250]

I love this reimagining. They made that scene more epic, and I love how they cut it with the original scenes. Don't get me wrong, the purist in me loves the original, and I always will, but wow this was really fucking cool. What fans can do blows me away. Hey Disney, start broadening your search for talent farther then just the ''Top dogs'' in your bubble. You might find some true fans who are artists.

[@jimhults4916]

Well, in the 70s, they don't have a fight like that but, it happens when George Lucas shot piece by piece for the whole cut of the movie. The stunt coordinator Bob Anderson was the fencer was made the choreograph the style.

[@notmee2388]

A hot girl with an accent that knows Star Wars BETTER than her boyfriend? I want one!

[@rahulmenon9530]

If they'd only spent more time perfecting this scene than trying to perfect the already perfect han solo scene......

[@thefatman2780]

GOT ANY ZERO CALORIE ORANGEADE? HUHH? MAY THE FORCE BE WITH US ALL.

[@mattkylie6723]

This is worthy to add to episode IV

[@fanartistabhi2786]

Please react to all goku ultra instinct fights or dragon ball super episode 130...🙇🙇🙇

[@AndreyKrichevsky]

I'd love to see you're reaction to the Star Wars Revisited version of this fight. It's a fan edit of the movie, and the creator had the same intention with this scene, only he didn't reshoot anything. Just changed the editing. The difference from the original is amazing. You can find the scene on KZbin. About the original Lightsabres, they were easily breakable, so they had to pretend to fight with swords that they couldn't really bang on each other... Plus, one of the actors is old, and the other is wearing a cumbersome suit.

[@DarthPoleon]

In the Original it was a boring fight but you still have to think about that this was the first lightsaber battle ever

[@40ozmangi]

you were my brother Anakin. i loved you ...hurts me everytime .

[@mkrulez5152]

Go watch vader episode 1 kzbin.info/www/bejne/e6qZaZSDhLtsncU&t= As good as this

[@commandoplayz2192]

Vader really said: it's over Obi wan I have the hallway

[@iganeshvp]

why remake fucking lion king to be horrendos.

[@twilitezn]

Well Done!!! There were some scenes that were held too long or "off" for me, but the choreography was excellent overall!

[@nmkasprkasprowicz4615]

Kiddish my ass. That show has some really brutal deaths.

[@dogu_kaya_]

You should watch corridor crew videos. Fantastic remakes.

[@rengoku47]

love Corridor Crew !

[@doorran]

there were just a few odd moments.. it was very well done otherwise.

[@warrenphilbert6856]

Where the hell have you been?!♥👍

[@tonyyul703]

If they ever decide to update episode IV I hope they include this...

[@dayasagarchourehembrom6092]

React to Corridor crews new video, "Marvel R-Rated".

[@mohammedkaunain5573]

Hey jaby! Make a reaction video on "Ride through the MCU action" volume 1,2,3 by Gugga Leunnam You'll love it! I promise.

[@eggbruh8163]

why do they both look like they've been crying?

[@blueharvest77]

Consider doing reviews for Adywan's Star Wars: Revisited & Empire Strikes Back: Revisited-complete color correction, every lightsaber and laser bolt re-scoped, 100s of mistakes fixed, and seamless new FX. Return of the Jedi: Revisited in the works right now- kzbin.info/www/bejne/mZDVlI2EmdiWaZI kzbin.info/www/bejne/eYnSoaeZn5tnhaM originaltrilogy.com/topic/id/9060

[@brettsalazar1886]

Were anyone else’s eyes sweating towards the end there?

[@rishibhavsar3802]

do you watch animes? if yes have you seen the the trailer of *"weathering with you".* check it out and react to it.

[@imonceagainaskingforyourfi4432]

I came to say this. I would have him review Your Name first.

[@asxulxetesteronsxez538]

There were multiple reasons for why the fight played out like it did in the original film. 1. George based the style of lightsaber combat off of Kendo, a style developed by Samurai after skills with swords in combat became null with the introduction of firearms. It's a popularized sport today where the first person to touch the other scores the point, so nothing fancy is necessary to win. Lightsaber combat would be much the same way, first person to touch the other guy would probably win. 2. The age of Sir Alec Guiness and the cumbersomeness of the Vader suit were factors that restricted motion and speed. (3). What she is referring to in how the lightsabers were made is seen in the scene with Obi-Wan training Luke aboard the Falcon. They were originally sticks with reflectors attached designed to reflect the lights of the set into the camera to create the illusion of the saber generating light. This was abandoned, however, after that scene. All other scenes were just colored in post.

[@jimhults4916]

Wow, are you people know the new version with Obi Wan fighting Darth Vader.

[@BensBrickDesigns]

I consider myself a purist and I agree that as long as you stick with the spirit of the moment or scene, I don't have a problem. Tacking on falling moments at the end of scenes that involve dippy robots and farting creatures just neuters any gravity you've been trying to put in the story.

[@Jeff55369]

One of the coolest things about the fight choreography in this video, is that you can tell they studied obi-wan and Anakin's fighting styles from the prequels and the clone wars. It FEELS familiar, and that's very satisfying.

[@chosenone6323]

She’s Right‼️the dialogue from the prequels made it more believable that The prequel took place before the trilogy and that these very much are the same people we’ve seen in Phantom Menace, Attack of Clones, Revenge of the Sith . most fans can’t seem to accept Prequel but this sorta forced it to connect and it did that in a positive way because all it did was give volume and depth to the characters Which I really liked✅

[@drizztatk]

She’s right, the lightsabers were basically glass( not literally) and they had to be crazy careful with them.

[@RequiemPoete]

Great react video! Just to comment on your question, the original saber props were too fragile for actual hard core combat.

[@silvervibranium2832]

Hi, I'm trying to find the Corridor Crew video that Jaby mentioned he saw this in. But their videos are badly indexed. Can someone help me find it please? :)

[@Daggersong]

She is right.. The Original Light sabers where rotating filaments that would refract the light and they could not clash to hard with them or they would brake. I loved this and the only line i would have added would have been " You should not have come back " . That is one of the issues people had with Vader from Rogue one how bad ass he was with his saber but you look at one week later in the time line he is nothing like he was in Rogue one. That is Tech with the sabers ...

[@lucasmolinari6763]

5:57 who have a hight ground? Good reaction, i love you two (Soory, my inglis is very bad 😂)

[@user-is-ok]

hot Dart Vader

[@kamileon8536]

She’s right, from a certain angle in the first StarWars the light sabre lose there iluminiscence. You can see it in the original.

[@whakjob]

Glad he is not using the Justice league animation on this face anymore.

[@endless013]

The original SC38 fight was so stiff because Alec Guinness was very stiff he was in his 60's at that point and couldn't really get a fast full range of motion so they played it to his strengths and made the fight we know now.

[@gumfireparalax1371]

Also the lightsabers were very hard to do back then.

[@kellybills2987]

Just watched this, then looked at the tv and there you were in a valspar commercial lol I was like IT'S JABY!

[@Ronin-kk4bt]

This looks sick these guys made the scene so much better!

[@CooLin1stPlace]

Can't get enough of this video. So dope

[@perssontm1628]

I bet Vader has a smoke machine up his as for entrances like these!

[@TechnicalJourney]

Watch pravu deva dance abcd

[@lagoonrd4173]

Better when long time fans and nerds react to this

[@alexander-sb1oi]

the fart reaction at the beginning 0:48

[@tonyyul703]

You two look good together

[@Fatherofheroesandheroines]

yup i didnt blink either the first time i saw this

[@punisherjones6795]

Do honest trailer endgame😊

[@fikikamil]

No reaction Titan season 2 trailer?

[@AYANPATHAK69]

i love corridor crew

[@sidd1212]

Wow

[@cpmf2112]

Use more sunscreen girl!

[@aspirantgeo]

Jabymammu I have come to marry achara♥️

[@T.J.S.]

Nicely done video

[@Otterman214]

Hey Jaby How on earth did you miss Martin Scorsese movie "The Irishman" to react? How on earth?? Do you even read your videos comments?

[@nitishpavithran3191]

React to thushar lall's star wars tribute

[@badmoon7695]

I've watched the original trilogy since it's very first release. It has been re-edited 3 times already since then. They can't just keep adding more stuff as it comes along. The scene is awesome and yes this should've been the fight scene we deserve to watch. But to add it now to A New Hope would be blasphemy. Lol.

[@venomusbite3461]

Please ask “ Seize the frame” if u can react to Kylo Ren vs Vader Force of darkness

[@riturajpatel2008]

Jaby married achhara💑💑💑💏💏💏❤💘

[@RoodeMenon]

It went so well until i heard "I hate you!" ...you were the chosen one." I feel the voice over from Revenge of the Sith was a bit cringy and unnecessary.

[@warriorzrisen]

imo I would totally disagree, I thought it really reinforced the hatred Vader has towards Obi now. But to each their own.

[@jacobklein8156]

Yeah, because fight coreography is what makes a duel great.