IVE 아이브 '해야 (HEYA)' MV

[@multiFANNNNN]

YUJIN AND LIZ VOCAL?!! WONYOUNG PRE CHORUS ?!! REI, GAEUL AND LEESEO RAP ?!!! EVERYTHING IS PERFECT !! AGAIN A BOP!!!

[@IrishaineLibre-je7sg]

THEY WILL SLAY AGAIN AS USUAL, THIS CONCEPT IS A HIT🔥 LET'S KEEP STREAMING AS IVE DESERVE IT

[@dawoodyasir]

​@@IrishaineLibre-je7sgYES STREAM IT AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE PLEASE SEVENTEEN IS ALREADY AHEAD OF US

[@eeseoivezs]

FINALLY ONE THAT SPEAKS OF ALL THE MEMBERS AND NOT OF ONE 🫶🏻🤍

[@LiNuoya]

Thanks to ive and Starship for helping China promote traditional Chinese art culture, I didn't realize that the whole MV is full of Chinese culture at a glance, which pays homage to Chinese art movies such as Huluwa and other landscapes and auspicious clouds are more outstanding! The use of Chinese knots is also very nice, when the headdress is very beautiful!

[@quit4everxx]

YESS!!

[@cranberryjuice99]

I love how Starship starts to give Liz more lines, 'coz gurl she literally deserves it! This song really suits her!

[@whydontive]

Most of the times she sings a lot 😭 but agree, this song is perfect for her

[@konny1763]

the producers always gives the part to the member taht suits it the best

[@Himvfxajkb]

Exactly most of the time she sings alot it just her screentime that lacks😢 but finally she has many screentime in heya​@@whydontive

[@-alyissa-3632]

​@noahfan2719 knowing starship unfortunately I feel like they only gave her more lines due to her loosing weight. They have a history of doing it with wjsn. This is not me saying I had a problem with her previous weight (she's adorable no matter what) just starship is known to do these things

[@whydontive]

@@Himvfxajkb THISSS, that's why ppl usually don't realize when she sings (also not forgetting she gets more lines in bsides) I'm glad she's in the spotlight along with leeseo in this comeback, they look gorgeous and their voices 🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈

[@dilxc]

the Korean more than english lyrics More than 3 minute A freaking whole bridge part The dance the mv the vocals????? IVE killed it. I hope this becomes even more success

[@M_kook1]

Ya finally a song with more korean lines

[@takecarebilly_]

ikr!!! so happy IVE keeping the normal standard of kpop songs ❤

[@asyifamiranda1160]

yezzzz

[@unicorn_xxx3424]

frr

[@IrishaineLibre-je7sg]

IVE IS A PERFECTION, LET'S STREAM HEYA SO THAT THIS SONG WILL BE FAMOUS AS IT DESERVE

[@swittak6512]

Who’s here after MAMA2024?

[@violet-s3s3q]

me!!!

[@0._13q5]

Me

[@Hendrowellyeah]

Its only u😃

[@_rosies9]

ME

[@GranturismoB340]

MAMA, Let me hear your- YAAAAAAAAaAAAAaAaAAaAaAAAaAA

[@bloop6266]

REI'S RAP, WONYOUNG AND LIZ'S PRE CHORUS, GAEUL'S CENTER FOCUS IN THE OUTRO, YUJIN'S HIGHNOTE AT THE BRIDGE, LEESEO'S HAIR BIT AND VOCALS. I CANT DO THIS. HEYA SOTY

[@urhypeboy]

"Heya soty" lol no. Stay delulu 😂

[@urhypeboy]

"Heya soty" lol no. Stay delulu 😂

[@roseareforrose909]

yas to the sky

[@edencoleman5270]

​@@urhypeboy hating is pointless. Commenting will do nothing but promote the song and tell your algorithm to give you more IVE music/content. Based off of this comment, I'm sure that's something you don't want. I would recommend simply not watching/listening to the video instead of taking the time out of your day to comment hate. -sincerely, a non-dive.

[@blackpinkislife221]

lol hater haha ​@@edencoleman5270

[@onlywhenneeded8558]

LIZ's voice always melts through my ear

[@keisya9341]

Right!

[@bkJonni]

I third that!!!!!! Couldn’t agree more!

[@snowdropblik]

💫❤I LOVE YOU LIZ IS SO PRETTY ❤💫

[@huyennguyen3034]

right

[@judyanny.darunday7835]

Yeahh

[@mayesharahman1230]

Wonyoung and liz's pre corrus is just beyond amazing. I freakin love this song

[@sherllymisseshim]

frrr

[@theplanewonyoungcrashedon]

They sound majestic 🤧

[@NRam-ke6cs]

Liz ❤

[@IrishaineLibre-je7sg]

THEY ARE JUST THE BEST, PROBABLY HATERS ARE FINDING ANOTHER WAY TO MAKE A HATE TOWARDS THEM AGAIN LOL

[@user-xh2jb5mm2d]

my babies 🥹

[@Blebmon]

HEYA MV OF THE YEAR ☀️🐯❄️ Congratulations to IVE, and to the team of artists who worked on such a beautiful MV🏆

[@lamir17]

리즈의 몽환적인. 보컬이랑. 너무 잘 어울림 도입부의 레이 랩핑이 확 끌리고 올려봐 노려봐 부분의 원영 리즈 목 꺽는 어서와 탐이나 가을 부분. 이번 뮤비는 찢었다

[@imari_ri]

LEESEO ERA IM CALLING IT LIZ VOCALS ARE ON TOP WONYOUNG VISUALS STUNNING AS ALWAYS REI RAP AT THE BEGINNING WAS AMAZING YUJIN SLAYED SO HARD WISH TO SEE MORE GAEUL, BUT HER PARTS WERE KILLING!!!

[@tatakae.shinri9004]

is gaeul doesn't have any lines in this comeback,i keep find it😭🙏🏻

[@Envonc-ub6nu]

@@tatakae.shinri9004 only a few seconds,hardly find her💔

[@OmarTellezCantor]

I don't know why they keep her in the group if she doesn't participate there.

[@pipkir9429]

she's main dancer for reasons ​@@OmarTellezCantor

[@linhngoc7579]

@@tatakae.shinri9004then i am sitting here counting her screentime. I bet you could miss those if you blink…

[@nekosaiio]

leeseo has been revealed as a rapper, wonyoung has a vocal line, and liz is increasingly revealed as the main vocalist. I am in heaven

[@murunash]

guys please watch Kim Woojin's "I like the way" music video. Help reach 200k

[@Itzy_2000]

Ok​@@murunash

[@loelds4817]

Leeseo: “Heya in korea means sun. Our music video concept is based on the traditional korean folklore called the tiger, sun and moon”. It’s so cool IVE always showcase korean traditional cultural elements and art. ❤️

[@Baulsito64]

@@murunashok

[@joyfulnewjive]

wonyoung has always had vocal lines 😭 what are you on?

[@Cloverferns]

So this is THE BEST MV OF THIS YEAR IN MMA 2024. The aesthetics of this mv and transitions are PURE ART✨

[@Vlogvistae]

Its aespa Armageddon broo 😂😂

[@dinto2391]

@@Vlogvistae at MAMA, aespa's "Armageddon" won Best Music Video, and at MMA, IVE's "HEYA" won Best Music Video.

[@theraffypascual]

​@@dinto2391both directed by Rima Yoon (Rigend Film).

[@Rami_frommars]

Best mv oh.... No hate but ive❤ seen better

[@elevenevergarden]

​@@Vlogvistaeyou probably have no idea about the difference of mama and mma😂

[@birthseol]

자기복제 없이 매번 새로운 색깔로 도전하는 거 진짜 호감 ㅋㅋ 그렇다고 아이브만의 정체성을 버리는 것도 아님

[@beatrice9717]

YESSS

[@antonykumar9550]

YESSS

[@Qpksib2usk]

​@@user-kd2pv5qb3d두그룹의 다른 스타일이 듣고보는 입장에선 환영임 ~

[@ThisPL]

@@보타-c4b 너님 같은 부류들이 제일 역겨운 것 같음. 굳이 아이브 뮤비댓에 뉴진스 언급해서 둘 싸움 시키려고? 뉴진스 좋아하는 사람들 중에서도 아이브 좋아하는 사람들 많음. 왜 이간질 시키려고 함? 혹여나 그럴 의도 없었다 라고 한다면 나는 평소에도 그냥 뇌 안거치고 아무 개념없는 소리 내뱉는 사람이라는 걸 인정하는 거임.

[@sup_yur]

@@보타-c4b예? 뉴진스 신곡 완전 국내 알앤비 스타일이던데

[@randomsophia_xxx8097]

Can we please talk about the pre-chorus?… Wonyoung and Liz absolutely nailed that part. It sounds stunningly beautiful! ✨

[@quit4everxx]

it does!!

[@건강행복부자사랑]

이서존예

[@rsingh2001]

Ikrrrr .. I'm also saying thattt .. it's so good

[@Paul-ey2xd]

Yes! I prefer the pre-chorus to the chorus. The pre-chorus is so good!

[@capitulina]

Yessss

[@Chesslover69420]

IVE CONCEPT ARE SO COOL!!!

[@jjzazaz_00]

It’s meew

[@Prettygirlriz]

Me

[@oOohio]

My birthday on 30 of April and THIS IS THE BEST BIRTHDAY GIFT EVERRRR!!!🎁 IVE SLAYEDDD

[@petitifools]

heree

[@kwandoyah]

Heya! 👋🏻

[@Choi1705-p2h]

뮤비 아직도 다시 봄 … 폭발적인 미감 . . . 제작진 셀렉하는 것도 능력이라고 생각함

[@whenu_cyme]

WONYOUNG ATE THAT DAMN PRE-CHORUS!!!!! 0:42

[@i8jwny]

right!! she got the least line but she devoured the pre-chorus!!

[@mixrocosmo4541]

@@i8jwnyreally? I thought gaeul got the least amount of lines

[@iceyyy__]

rightt?? the falsetto gave me chills

[@Ememe246]

Is this a pre-release or a comeback?

[@ClomaclomaCy]

time stamp pls

[@daniellesmith7052]

It’s so refreshing to see a song over 3 minutes long with an actual chorus. The reputation within the song fits perfectly and is not overplayed. This is the quality I want out of K-pop.

[@Jaxqe]

Sorry for interrupting but this is chinese culture korean are stealing our culture and barely anybody knew so pls give me a favor of sharing about this news to the other kpop fan I personally love ive very much but this comeback makes me very upset and frustrated I am Chinese and I saw A LOT of Chinese culture and traditions shown in the mv and a lot of korean are saying that this is their culture so pls pls pls share this to the other ive fan that u know so more and more people can get to know this

[@모찌모찌-i5y]

@@Jaxqe 퓡퓡퓡퓡퓡퓡퓡퓡퓡퓡퓡퓡퓡퓡퓡퓌이~ ㅋ

[@twicebang4556]

@@JaxqeCan I ask which parts are considered Chinese? Due to their history I think that the culture can be similar

[@Jaxqe]

@@twicebang4556 The pipe and round fan at the beginning to the Chinese knot and auspicious cloud pattern throughout, the mountains that appear many times in the picture are also very similar to the mountain formed by the Calabash Brothers at the end, these are all very obvious Chinese cultural elements, but the MV always emphasizes "showing Korean culture" throughout the promotion process. Chinese culture can certainly be used, but at least respect should be shown. The random appropriation without any understanding has led to this MV being piled up with a strange mixture, especially the pipe at the beginning… Thank you for wiling to at least ask about it I really appreciate that

[@noonemin]

@@Jaxqe Do you know about Sinosphere definition?

[@L_L_L463]

1:48 Liz’s voice is so angelic and fairy . It brings the audience above the clouds. It’s too beautiful 🥹

[@huyennguyen3034]

agree

[@石一-c1o]

你肯定不会想到，里面的MV元素大多是抄袭中国的传统文化，他们还会说这是韩国风~

[@Jjjjjjjjj-er6nt]

@@石一-c1o 중국인들이 vpn으로 우회접속까지 하면서 한국을 훔쳐보고, 조직적으로 문화를 훔치고, 왜곡하고 댓글 테러를 자행하고 있습니다. 자칭 대국이라는 나라의 수준이 찻잔보다 작습니다.

[@L_L_L463]

@@石一-c1o？？？我发这留言的时候还没爆出这事。另外我只是想说栗子的声音很好听而已😅

[@石一-c1o]

@@L_L_L463 可能你误会了什么，我就是科普一下 ❤

[@swagatapal5193]

So many say that this is the one of the worst song of 2024 but to me it is one of the best release of this year. Can't wait for their January cb. Hopefully we'll get to see the true and new side of Ive.

[@T_Cup]

Liz dropped the crown and ascended to goddess level, she seriously blessed us with those visuals and vocals, Liz supremacy

[@NRam-ke6cs]

LIZ 💜

[@nothinkokshorts]

@@cc.l7058 It’s Korean culture. :) Stop distorting. Why do you always distort LOL😂

[@__LALISA__WORLDWIDENUMBERONE]

IVE members ❤

[@Touka_]

Hwaiting

[@kevint-bq3sg]

@@nothinkokshorts 非常に明白な中国風....

[@Ibbuny_jowa]

스타쉽이 드디어 아이브 멤버 각각의 보컬을 살리기 시작한 듯, 진짜 딱 본인들한테 맞는 본인들이 살릴 수 있는 파트만 맡았네… 특히 이번에 리즈 음색이 이쁘게 튀어서 듣기 좋다

[@人間成功]

YesYes.The part allocation this time is even better than usual

[@복덩이-r1r]

2절 리즈 음색 정말 좋음

[@Ibbuny_jowa]

@@twoofus7814 괜찮아 그럴 수 있어, 힘 내!

[@오영진-p8s]

ㄹㅇ.. 리즈, 원영, 가을 잘 맞춰준듯 리즈는 음색 돋보일 수 있는 파트 받았고, 원영이도 딱 자기 음역대 맞는거, 가을도 소화할 수 있는 파트 적절하게 받은거 같음. 유진이랑 이서는 워낙 올라운더고, 레이는 항상 자기 킬링파트 챙겨가긴 했어서.. 이번에 분배 진짜 잘 한듯

[@꺾은굴절]

​@@twoofus7814리즈는 거의 똑같음

[@jjkmety7935]

for new IVE fans 0:12 REI - japanese rapper 0:21 LIZ - main vocalist 0:34 Leeseo - all rounder / youngest maknae 0:45 Wonyoung - center of IVE / vocal line 1:38 Yujin - main vocal / leader 2:45 Gaeul - rapper dancer our fandom name is DIVE welcome to DIVEland

[@kimminkookjeon]

THANKKK UUUU!!!!

[@tamar9567]

Ty❤ I've started stanning them right before this comeback, I'm so glad this is my first comeback❤

[@tamar9567]

So they have two main vocalists?

[@jjkmety7935]

@@tamar9567 they don't have official main vocalist actually but Liz & Yujin doing the high notes

[@sheridanvance7426]

❤

[@dharaniwijesinghe2055]

Liz voice is like heaven and wonyoung visuals like heaven and yujin also my favorite I’ve song

[@dharaniwijesinghe2055]

Like me more

[@dharaniwijesinghe2055]

Thank you guys for liking me god bless you and බුදු සරණයි

[@냠냠-b2q]

보는 내내 '너무 예쁘다'가 무의식중 계속 나옴 비주얼아트 누가 하셨어? 멤버 매력까지 완벽하게 다 살렸네

[@captainpuppy]

리전드 필름!!!

[@邵雯-u9p]

中国文化

[@Zh35_Jennifer]

A lot of Chinese elements😍

[@ethanzeng9320]

Thanks for appreciating the traditional Chinese culture. They are genuinely beautiful as you said.

[@noma7940]

비주얼은 아트팀 로하우스 미술감독 @summerskythunderstorm 입니다 ㅋ

[@Liz_ive_love._.1]

아이브가 질리지 않는 이유는 컨셉때문인 것 같다. 일레븐이나 홀리몰리같이 몽환적인 컨셉이였다가도,걸크러쉬 컨셉,나르시즘 컨셉 등 다양하게 소화해내서 컴백할때마다 보는 재미가 있다. 아이브 오래오래 건강하게 잘 활동하자!❤

[@winnieXiong-cd3do]

Ive와 스타쉽이 중국을 도와 중국 전통 미술 문화를 홍보해 주셔서 감사합니다. mv 전체가 중국 문화로 가득 차 있다는 것을 한눈에 알 수 있을 줄은 몰랐습니다. 그 중에서도 후루와 등 중국 미술 영화에 경의를 표하는 산수상운이 비교적 뛰어납니다! 중국 매듭의 운용도 예쁘고 머리 장식이 예쁘네요!

[@류규]

​@@winnieXiong-cd3do중국인들은 문화대혁명 때 마오쩌둥이 다 없애서 문화가 다 사라졌죠ㅠㅠ😢 아름다운 문화가 다 사라져서 안타깝습니다ㅠㅠ한국이 많이 질투나시죠? 우리 문화가 잘 보존되긴 했습니다😊 아름다운 한국 문화 마음껏 감상하시길~조회수 올려줘서 땡큐~👍During the Cultural Revolution, the Chinese people got rid of Mao Zedong, so the culture disappeared. 😢 It's a pity that all beautiful cultures disappeared. Are you jealous of Korea? Our culture is well preserved. 😊 Enjoy beautiful Korean culture as much as you want. Thank you for posting the view count.

[@잇쥬]

@@winnieXiong-cd3do ?

[@aswn52]

매듭 형태를 보기만 하면 중국 매듭이라고 우기고 있지만 매듭은 나라마다 다양한 형태와 용도로 발전해왔고 누구의 것이라고 말할 수 없음 중국은 자신들의 손으로 파괴한 문화를 주변 아시안의 문화를 훔쳐서 메꾸려 하고 있다😂

[@민경훈-m3h]

@@winnieXiong-cd3do 개소리 하고 자빠졌네

[@TheWarny7]

진짜 미쳤다는 말 밖에 안나옴 일레븐 러브다이브 에프터라이크 베디 키치 그리고 이번 해야까지 나올때마다 새로운 다른 컨셉의 노래와 컨셉을 본인들만에 색깔로 다 소화해냄 멤버들 개성도 다 뚜렸하고 렙파트랑 후렴 전에 천천히 솔로로 빌드업해가는 보컬도 너무 좋음 빨리 음방 무대도 올라왔으면

[@user-nr1bh4em9i]

근데 해야가 뭐임

[@코카투의코카콜라]

​@@user-nr1bh4em9i누군가를 부를때 ○○아, ○○야라고 하듯이 해(태양)을 부르는 것 같아요

[@고종숙-y4f]

언니 사랑해요.❤❤❤❤❤

[@newjeansneverdie019]

This has to be one of the most creative songs ever, the lyrics being inspired by a korean tale is just perfect, and the mv is amazing as well. Sad that people forgot about this one so easily😢

[@美女-r9e]

没忘呢，这可是中国元素，是世界顶层的国家，又不像韩国，世界底层

[@unkle.k]

​@@美女-r9eyou might have forgotten this too😂 1-20: Behaviors in Public Spaces 1. Speaking loudly in public spaces. 2. Ignoring the etiquette of standing in line. 3. Spitting in public areas. 4. Damaging property in hotels or tourist sites. 5. Littering in public places. 6. Leaving public restrooms unclean. 7. Eating loudly in restaurants. 8. Defacing or damaging cultural landmarks. 9. Causing disturbances on airplanes by ignoring safety rules. 10. Attempting to catch wildlife in public places. 11. Taking hotel amenities without permission. 12. Ignoring cultural norms in tourist destinations. 13. Violating public transportation rules abroad. 14. Using camera flashes where prohibited. 15. Invading others' personal space. 16. Removing shoes and placing feet on seats in buses or trains. 17. Moving in large groups and disrupting others. 18. Smoking in non-smoking areas. 19. Being disruptive while dining out. 20. Ignoring local customs or sensitivities. --- 21-40: Economic and Political Issues 21. Illegal fishing in foreign waters. 22. Copyright infringement and illegal downloads. 23. Manufacturing and distributing counterfeit goods. 24. Unfair trade practices. 25. Driving up real estate prices through mass investments abroad. 26. Monopolistic practices by Chinese companies in foreign markets. 27. Ignoring international economic regulations. 28. Exploiting resources in developing countries. 29. Economic coercion through the Belt and Road Initiative. 30. Industrial espionage and technology theft. 31. Exploitation of labor and poor working conditions. 32. Engaging in opaque financial transactions. 33. Running illegal businesses abroad. 34. Bullying local vendors at tourist destinations. 35. Smuggling cultural artifacts or endangered species. 36. Igniting trade disputes in international markets. 37. Overconsuming or damaging foreign resources. 38. Illegal mining and environmental degradation. 39. Violating laws in foreign countries. 40. Cases of illegal immigration and overstaying visas. --- 41-60: Diplomacy and International Image 41. Disregard for other nations' cultures. 42. Cultural appropriation of other countries' traditions. 43. Making historical claims that distort facts. 44. Pro-China protests in foreign nations. 45. Aggressive stances on international disputes. 46. South China Sea territorial conflicts. 47. Suppression of issues related to Tibet, Hong Kong, and Taiwan. 48. Diplomatic bullying of smaller nations. 49. Promoting "Sinocentrism" with a superiority complex. 50. Clashes with locals in foreign nations. 51. Lobbying for pro-China sentiment internationally. 52. Suppressing freedom of the press abroad. 53. Ignoring international norms. 54. Interfering in other countries' internal affairs. 55. Responding aggressively to anti-China sentiments. 56. Attempting to dominate UNESCO and other global institutions. 57. Opposing anti-China protests worldwide. 58. Spreading Chinese propaganda in foreign countries. 59. Denying responsibility for international incidents. 60. Exporting censorship policies overseas. --- 61-80: Actions at Tourist Destinations 61. Disrespecting local cultures and traditions. 62. Ignoring public order abroad. 63. Defacing UNESCO world heritage sites. 64. Lacking table manners in foreign restaurants. 65. Taking photos indiscriminately at tourist attractions. 66. Being disrespectful in religious places. 67. Mocking or belittling local traditional clothing. 68. Displaying extreme nationalism in foreign disputes. 69. Copying or plagiarizing foreign cuisines. 70. Excessive haggling in local markets. 71. Disparaging local residents. 72. Disregarding religious symbols and customs. 73. Misusing public facilities. 74. Loud and chaotic group behavior in tourist areas. 75. Conflicts with flight attendants or passengers. 76. Invading personal space. 77. Violating foreign laws. 78. Criticizing local customs without understanding. 79. Mocking or ignoring foreign practices. 80. Leaving shops or restaurants without paying. --- 81-100: Online Behavior and Other Issues 81. Flooding foreign social media with offensive comments. 82. Spreading misinformation online. 83. Leaving negative reviews on foreign cultural content. 84. Justifying Chinese government censorship on global platforms. 85. Cyberattacks targeting foreign individuals or institutions. 86. Engaging in state-sponsored digital espionage. 87. Using banned platforms like KZbin and Twitter illegally. 88. Copying foreign intellectual property for Chinese products. 89. Poor sportsmanship in online gaming. 90. Cyberbullying against foreign content creators. 91. Targeting international creators with fake reviews. 92. Distorting foreign services to fit Chinese interests. 93. Illegally using software or media. 94. Plagiarizing foreign creative works. 95. Overreacting to perceived cultural attacks. 96. Stirring international disputes through social media. 97. Overly nationalistic comments on online forums. 98. Blocking foreign criticism of China. 99. Demanding blind loyalty to pro-China content. 100. Deflecting criticism while remaining overly defensive. --- These points reflect criticisms often raised globally and are not meant to generalize all individuals. They serve to highlight areas where negative perceptions arise and provide a basis for discussion.

[@yin_ft_eren]

​@@unkle.kyea bruh this is so true lmao

[@QwertyYoungtons]

@@美女-r9e kpop is more successful than cpop. saying that South Korea is at the bottom of the world doesn't make any sense. Not just in music but even in acting, Kdrama is more popular than cdrama... proving your statement wrong once again... stay jealous, chinese girl...

[@doughglass]

@@QwertyYoungtons lmao they always so jealous and salty

[@HallelSpitzer]

I feel like Starship finally realized that they can use EVERY SINGLE MEMBER. It wasn't just a two man show this time and they managed to make a masterpiece.

[@crabkiller-n4q]

I love how starship is promoting Chinese traditional art culture in this song! ❤did not expect the entire mv is full of Chinese culture can be seen at a glance, which to gourd baby and other Chinese art film tribute landscape Xiangyun are more excellent! The use of Chinese knot is also very beautiful!

[@peanut.butter.]

​@@crabkiller-n4q it is Korean culture stop being weird and you should go to mental clinic😢

[@Touka_]

Agreed. I love how every members shined in their own.

[@via45]

Saying this when gaeul and wonyoung got barely any lines

[@yoon9521]

​@@via45 ppl always forgot about Gaeul and then they always celebrate it when Wonyoung has less line. Funny how they act like it's fair only when those two got little spotlight

[@rinahwng]

Liz slayed this comeback. The vocal the visual everything's amazing

[@NRam-ke6cs]

Everything about Jiwon screams Perfection 💜

[@cheeseo8418]

She got the screentime she deserves!

[@__LALISA__WORLDWIDENUMBERONE]

The members never disappoints us ❤

[@Cheshire_Neko]

Absolutely agree! I’m so happy to see Liz appreciation after all the hate she got in the past. People mush remember that she is still very young so body changes are completely ok and she is beautiful and extremely hardworking in every single comeback.

[@Strawbbxmoon]

@@NRam-ke6csyeah I’m glad they all got screentime. Even Gaeul even tho she didn’t have a lot of lines this song 💖

[@user-nameisyuki]

この曲のおかげでIVEの沼に無事はまりました。ありかとうございます。韓国モチーフのMVも神々しい感じの曲の雰囲気との相性最高

[@휘핑-o5i]

뮤비 왤케 신선하냐. 전개 날로 먹지 않고 되게 머리쓴 거 같음. 예쁘면서 신비롭네.

[@해수원-o7g]

​@@Fulltheneat중국?

[@yae_mico7702]

​@@Fulltheneat야랄하지말고 제발 꺼져...중국 요소는 너네 나라가서 찾아 제발 ㅠㅠ

[@handle9657]

​@@Fulltheneatobviously kr culture. stop stealing. thanks

[@하늘고래-c4t]

놨두삼 저 새끼 댓글 히스토리보니깐 안티임 대꾸할 가치도 없음

[@지존불주먹]

​@@Fulltheneata rude Chinese nationalist

[@iveloveDive-jd8ki]

wonyoung selalu improve tiap comeback padahal dia selalu sibuk dengan jadwal lain wonyoung selalu kasih yang terbaik setiap comeback sehat-sehat ya woniee

[@kulazakii]

iyaa woi bangga banget ama Wonnie😭😭😭

[@Kim-on8vb]

It seems that Jang Wonyoung is indeed of Chinese descent, promoting Chinese culture in her new song.❤❤❤

[@exosnisso8909]

Liz getting the most lines, fair screen time, prechorus, chorus, many verses, the bridge, purple hair, great style and eating this concept is my ultimate win. Edit: relax guys.😭😭 I didn't even complain about anything. I'm just happy my girl regained her confidence after everything that happened before.

[@kenieherox2625]

as she deserves🥹

[@via45]

​@@charlotte0904even with the most lines they will never be happy

[@Brunson-t3g]

Y'all actin like Liz always doesn't have the most lines (eleven , I am ) their literal TT

[@yejiponytail1897]

@@charlotte0904I’m so glad someone said this

[@JunnySunny]

​@@charlotte0904That's TRUE!!! 👍🏻

[@Casebycase_1968]

매력이 넘치는 영상(전래동화에서 사랑도,춤사위도,패션도...] 기가막힌 작품이예요

[@skaielvs_]

Im in love with the mv visuals and this concept, WONY'S VOICE IN THE PRE CHORU!?!?! SHE ATE

[@Nobody_Owens]

Ikr her voice is always fitting for pre chorus , like in eleven , love dive. It fits perfectly.

[@pr8941]

EXACTLY, SHE SOUNDS HEAVENLY

[@antihysu]

ISTG I ASCENDED??

[@welloschmallow]

​@@safitry_syaddien interesting way to spell Wonyoung

[@yourfav8998]

​@@safitry_syaddien don't worry both killed it. We all know liz will killed it easily but wonyoung? This actually so surprising. Too soothing in my ears

[@gisellecalista9272]

Leeseo and rei rap omg. And liz voice??! Gaeul face expression is on point Yujin highnote?!!!! Wonyoung part is just magical

[@steste4168]

= SOTY

[@justamultifanperson]

The bridge part ascends me to heaven and Yujin's highnote was incredible! Liz owned this era definitely.

[@yesterday-777]

ほんとうにそう！

[@blackpinkislife221]

fighting to the end

[@za_wavbit]

Just the fact that there even is a bridge, in this day and age

[@steste4168]

SOTY

[@石一-c1o]

“IVE （아이브）新歌MV抄袭中国文化视频对比丨IVE's MV plagiarized Chinese cultural history” 搜索词条

[@abcnithint]

Best MV of the year is what I expected from IVE. Congratulations

[@NRam-ke6cs]

The fact that half of this comment section is about Liz shows how much she is loved and appreciated by Dives. Thank you for the lines and screentime. My gf SLAYEDDD

[@nouharezgui2790]

she's my bias from day 1 ...

[@serenearzueles919]

Nope, it's my gf

[@Touka_]

My wrecker tho

[@benji0099]

Liz always had lines....these token stans are out of control. I actually feel bad for Liz. You'd think her individual album version would be 1st in sales based on the comment section.....but these ppl arent really Ive or Liz fans. They just like seeing a certain member put down.

[@NRam-ke6cs]

​@@benji0099Well you're clearly wrong. I'm a Liz stan since Eleven and i'm a Dive who love all the other girls also. So hate somewhere else.

[@lyoco_latte]

이서 별명이 호랑인데 이번 컨셉이 호랑인게 넘 신기하다!! 이번에 이서가 컨셉 잘 소화 해줬으면 좋겠다..이서야 ! 기대할게❤

[@이게말이되니공주들아]

중국의 문화가 아닙니다 한국의 옛문화니 이상한 댓글 쓸거면 한국문화나 제대로 알고 다세요.

[@kid7109]

​@@이게말이되니공주들아 i think you replied to the wrong comment, this comment translated great lol

[@이게말이되니공주들아]

@@kid7109 aha thank you

[@lyoco_latte]

@@이게말이되니공주들아 이상한 댓글? 제가 중국 문화에 대한 말도 안꺼냈는데 무슨 말씀이시죠;;

[@이게말이되니공주들아]

@@lyoco_latte 잘못 단 거 같다고 외국인 분이 말씀하셨어요~ 당신 말고 다른 분 댓글 달다 실수했습니다 죄송해요~

[@riasrra]

WONYOUNGS PRE-CHORUS??? LIZ’S VOICE?? LEESEO, GAEUL, AND REI’S RAP?? YUJIN’S VOCALS? THIS HAS GOT TO BE SOTY. At first I was unsure of this song when listening to the highlight but It’s amazing!!! IVE literally has no skips…they did so well!!!

[@nothinkokshorts]

@@cc.l7058 Stop distorting! Why is your country always distorting everything? Your country is not that great.😂

[@riasrra]

@@cc.l7058 That wasn’t what my comment was about but okay ill keep that in mind 😭

[@Touka_]

Agreeed

[@shapat3758]

ISN'T THISSS THE ''BEST MV AWARD'' IN MMA 2024?????

[@elevenevergarden]

this is

[@djaiak]

리즈 보라머리 미쳤다... 게다가 음색까지 미쳐서 감미로워 ㅠㅠㅠ 리즈파트 진짜 개미치네;;;;감초다 감초 노래랑 뮤비 파트분배 한명한테 안쏠리고 잘했네 랩부분 해야해야 듣고 반복되는멜로디였으면 별로였을텐데 노래 좋다

[@odr_4ooyears]

그러게요 ㅠㅠ 리즈 음색 진짜 개좋음 ㅜㅜㅠㅠ

[@강-h8v]

진짜 뮤비 색감 너무 매력적인듯 한국풍인데 뽕짝없이 힙합으로 채운것도 독특하고 뮤비 색감이 진짜 세련됨

[@__Yes_or_yes__]

​@@sbnxem8059这是韩国文化，不是中国这样的国家可以超越的，所以不要强求，这是可悲的。 😅中国不是有很多文化吗？他们总是窃取其他国家的文化。

[@odr_4ooyears]

@@sbnxem8059 저도 사실 한국풍보단 중국풍 느낌도 난다고 생각했어요..

[@djaiak]

@@odr_4ooyears저도 처음엔 중국풍애매하게 섞은거아니겠지? 했는데 디테일들이 한국풍같고 전체적으로 호랑이 산모양도 한국것 같네요 자개느낌도 그렇고

[@mbcftkmbcftk8951]

와 티져듣고 이번에는 평범하게 후크송으로 가려나보다 했는데 진짜 강렬하네 아이브는 자기복제를 안 함 매 앨범마다 새로운거하는게 진짜 좋다

[@Tina-ng6ou]

Thanks to ive and Starship for helping China promote traditional Chinese art culture, I didn't realize that the whole MV is full of Chinese culture at a glance, which pays homage to Chinese art movies such as Huluwa and other landscapes and auspicious clouds are more outstanding! The use of Chinese knots is also very nice, when the headdress is very beautiful!

[@user-holy99]

@Tina-ng6ou 시진핑이 니 잡아간디 ㅋㅋㅋ

[@nothinkokshorts]

@@Tina-ng6ou PLZ Stop DISTORTING ‼️ Why is your country always distorting everything? Your country is not that great.😂

[@Goose-lee99]

이게 후크여 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@惠惠田]

China is obviously greater than your country

[@olivia9127]

2:20 쥐불놀이를 이렇게 독창적이고 예쁘게 표현하다니.. 감동개커

[@Good_ing]

저는 저게 동아줄을 표현한거라고도 생각했습니다. 해와달에서 오빠 동생이 타고 올라가는 동아줄요 2:22초에 해와 연결되어 있음

[@영남사수달]

​@@Good_ing와 진짜 알고보니 더 좋네

[@KO_HSI]

​@@Good_ing이제 라도 알았으니 당행이네요

[@ssw61461]

해로 올라가는 동아줄을 쥐불놀이로 시각화 시킨거겟쥬 ㅋㅋ둘다 맞을듯~ 저런 디텔한 요소들 하나하나 까지들은 외국인들은 모르겟쥐,,ㅜㅋㅋㅋ우리만 알기 아까벙

[@Koiqi98171]

Zuibulnori is chinese culture 🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳 Hanfu is chinese culture🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳 Don’t makes gong zu to korean Great mao zedong will makes korea to china 🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳

[@hildajimpayan679]

Music Show Win❌ BEST MV OF THE YEAR✔️ HEYA THE MV YOU ARE🎉 🏆

[@eeeeeeeeeee5126]

OMG LIZ'S VISUALS...SHE LITERALLY LOOKS LIKE AN ANGEL AND THE PURPLE HAIR LOOKS SO GOOD ON HER

[@오덕이-w4d]

와 이번 컴백은 유진이랑 리즈가 대박이다 리즈 파트들어오자 마자 음색 진짜 미쳤음 유진 파트 처음 들어올때 안무 미쳤음

[@TAKY-fw8ve]

Thanks to ive and Starship for helping China promote traditional Chinese art culture, I didn't realize that the whole MV is full of Chinese culture at a glance, which pays homage to Chinese art movies such as Huluwa and other landscapes

[@곰돌이푸-d1x]

@@TAKY-fw8ve Why do Chinese people claim Korean culture, Japanese culture, and all Asian cultures as their own? I hope you love your own culture. This song features only Korean culture perfectly.

[@오덕이-w4d]

@@TAKY-fw8ve It's not Chinese culture it's Korean culture

[@Park_Potato119]

@@TAKY-fw8veTaiwan is not china

[@seochanwook]

​@@TAKY-fw8veTaiwan number one

[@indonggoodshin764]

와, 정말정말 미쳤다. 이제까지 없었던 진짜 창의적인 예술작품 같아요. 너무 고급지고 너무 아름답고 너무 명쾌하고 깨끗해요.... 세계적이고 미래적이고 독보적인 작품입니다.

[@착한마음]

민화와 겸재 정선의 금강전도를 참고했다는데 청록파 박두진 시인의 의 감성도 있는 것 같습니다.

[@indonggoodshin764]

@@착한마음 디렉팅한 분이 누군지 모르지만 신의 경지인듯해요. k-pop이 단순히 음악을 넘는 것 같아요. 세상의 모든 것을 담아 내는 것 같습니다. 존경스럽네요. 유튜버중 겸재 정선의 금강전도와 청록파 박두진 신인의 (해)의 감성을 다루는 유튜버도 있었으면 좋겠다. 지식을 위해서^^~~~

[@Jack-oj2wx]

@@착한마음 한국의 그렇게 작은 곳에서 어떻게 이렇게 많은 풍격이 다른 문화가 탄생할 수 있는지, 머리를 써서 생각해 보면 한국인의 지능이 이렇게 낮은지 모르겠다.

[@Jack-oj2wx]

The natural environment in South Korea already determines that it is impossible for South Korea to have so many different styles of culture. Take a look at the map, little bug

[@Jack-oj2wx]

@@착한마음 The natural environment in South Korea already determines that it is impossible for South Korea to have so many different styles of culture. Take a look at the map, little bug

[@MC-Leeseo]

IVE will release new music in January, its agency Starship Entertainment said Sunday, the third anniversary of the group's debut.

[@짱구는목말라-z8u]

드럼소리가 꼭 장구 치는거 같았어요 아이브 색깔이 있는 한국적 음악 만들어 주셔서 너무 감사해요 원영이 보이스 너무 좋아졌네요

[@AyaCaturan]

WONYOUNG’S PRE-CHORUS IS A MASTERPIECE!!!

[@IrishaineLibre-je7sg]

WONYOUNG IS INDEED THE 4TH GEN IT GIRL, LOL IMAGINE THE HATES SHE RECEIVED BECAUSE OF HER VOICE AND NOW LOOK AT HER, LET'S STREAM HEYA DIVESS

[@어음-j7w]

Wonyoung is perfect idol!!!❤❤

[@quit4everxx]

FR

[@jamssnom-xv1mz]

Fr, the stage presence was there and her facial expression

[@nothinkokshorts]

@@cc.l7058 PLZ Stop DISTORTING ‼️ Why is your country always distorting everything? Your country is not that great.😂

[@MJAlwaysbehappy]

애들 스타일 죽인다. 특히 헤어 액세서리를 포인트 잡고 계속 딱딱 때려박아주면서 되게 강조해두는게... '대한민국의 전통 요소'를 바탕으로 모던트레디션적 재해석을 끌어내는걸로 이렇게 네오 로맨티시즘을 이룩할 수가 있구나. 크으....치인다, 치여. p.s. ㅌㅏㅇㅣ오ㅏ ㄴ ㅓㅂㅓ우 ㅓ 이다, 이 크다만 녀석들아~ ㄴ ㅁ ㄴ

[@winnieXiong-cd3do]

Ive와 스타쉽이 중국을 도와 중국 전통 미술 문화를 홍보해 주셔서 감사합니다. mv 전체가 중국 문화로 가득 차 있다는 것을 한눈에 알 수 있을 줄은 몰랐습니다. 그 중에서도 후루와 등 중국 미술 영화에 경의를 표하는 산수상운이 비교적 뛰어납니다! 중국 매듭의 운용도 예쁘고 머리 장식이 예쁘네요!

[@邵雯-u9p]

Thanks to ive and Starship for helping China promote traditional Chinese art culture, I didn't realize that the whole MV is full of Chinese culture at a glance, which pays homage to Chinese art movies such as Huluwa and other landscapes and auspicious clouds are more outstanding! The use of Chinese knots is also very nice, when the headdress is very beautiful!

[@邵雯-u9p]

真的很漂亮呢，全是中国元素

[@邵雯-u9p]

​@@winnieXiong-cd3do无语了家人

[@Ililllillliiill]

@@winnieXiong-cd3do느그 중국문화는 문화대혁명때 다 없앴자나 ㅋㅋㅋ그러더니 이젠 한국껄 지들꺼래 ㅠ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@linus8976]

普通の歌はA、B、サビ、大サビの4パートぐらいなんたけどこの歌は10パート以上ある。一曲としての構成力が神ってる。

[@sablepuff]

THAT BRIDGE!!!! OMG GOOSEBUMPSSSS!!!! AND THIS IS DEFINITELY LIZ'S ERA 😭💖

[@benzmercado1110]

what time stamp??

[@carljayarellano5154]

@@benzmercado1110 2:23 onwards

[@Luv.ive.6]

....

[@Noorylil]

frr

[@NRam-ke6cs]

We calling it LIZ ERA

[@azmaulia8138]

Demi apa baguss bangettt.. Part Liz leeseo asli merinding, highnote yujin juara..

[@syaifulreal8755]

​@@zeanhsiHOKHN itu apa

[@Prettygirlriz]

​@@syaifulreal8755high note

[@Syoohdam]

​@@syaifulreal8755High note

[@aftonconnection]

highnote​@@syaifulreal8755

[@gzardmiese]

​@@syaifulreal8755high note/nada tinggi

[@kkkkurmom5304]

THIS IS LIZ’s ERA, HER VISUALS, VOCALS, AND HER DUALITY?!!!! OH MY GOSH!!!!! Jiwon is pure talent and beauty.!

[@AthenaDelaCruz-qm3ss]

SHE'S SO GORG HUHUH I'M CRYING MY LIZ IS SO COOL!

[@johnsthetic]

KIK ELIZABETH JIWON ✨😌💕

[@NRam-ke6cs]

MY LIZ ❤

[@Touka_]

AGREED

[@石一-c1o]

“IVE （아이브）新歌MV抄袭中国文化视频对比丨IVE's MV plagiarized Chinese cultural history” 不要翻译直接搜索词条 ”ive's heya and the recent appropriation of Chinese culture” 不要翻译直接搜索词条IVE MV抄袭证据

[@tmcznm26]

HEYA is the most underrated song in 2024

[@miuthub7954]

100%, and then Cosmic RV and Supersonic Fromis 9

[@9q-f5q]

冒頭れいちゃんのキレキレのラップからはじまって畳み掛けるようにリズの綺麗で優雅な歌声に繋がるの最高！！

[@ЧайханаСлепушонка]

please don't use emoji it interferes with streaming

[@PrincessDianneManansala]

Don’t use emoji please

[@9q-f5q]

Sorry. I didn't know that.... Thank you for tell me! I deleted the emoji

[@田-s4x]

絵文字が多い、もしくは連投されていると、KZbin側がスパムだと勘違いして、全体の再生回数を大幅に減らす事態が発生します！絵文字１個なら大丈夫だと思います！！ リズの役割がかなり馴染んでて、これは最適解では？生き生きしているのが伝わる（泣）レイからのリズ、、運営分かってる！ ガウルは？って思ったらラストに来て、感動！目に狂気的なミステリアスな独特の雰囲気がありませんか？惹き込まれます イソはKitsch辺りから、RAPセンスあるのでは？と思っていたので、納得のポジションです！！アイブにおいて、虎=イソだと思っていたので、嬉しかった レイ！！！唯一無二の歌声！まろやかだけど、甘くはない感じ？可愛いんだけど、尖ってるみたい。アイデンティティが、自分の中で確立してて、魅せ方が上手い。「自己解像度高い」 アンニョンズ、今まで、そして、これからの、感謝を伝えたい。私が、メンバー皆を好きな気持ち以上に、自分自身を好きでいて欲しい！ 今回も、カムバを作り上げてくれた、多くの方々に感謝します

[@yaakosro2326]

很遗憾，想提醒各位，韩国人在视频中偷窃了中国文化，包括中国结，祥云，山水画，清朝烟斗，他们已经偷窃了太多了中国文化，也偷窃了日本文化，谨防小偷

[@kuimo1367]

아이브 전부 예쁘지만 이번에 리즈 스타일링 진짜 미친거같음 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 헤어컬러 진짜 찰떡임 ㅠㅠ

[@Alejandro-lx6ek]

中国风很漂亮

[@힛-y9m]

@@Alejandro-lx6ek뭐라는겨

[@이서치]

​@@Alejandro-lx6ek스님은 모두 소림사라는 뜻인가?

[@Liz-shine]

​@@이서치ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@Liz-shine]

​@@Alejandro-lx6ek하수구에서 퍼온 물로 훠궈 육수 맛내는 문화가 진정 중국풍이죠^^ 칭다오 공장위에서 직원이 xx 한 거는 자세히 말안할게요 😢

[@imseou]

I'M SHOKED, IT'S WONDERFUL, ESPECIALLY LEESEO'S RAP, WONYOUNG PRE-CHORUS, YUJIN'S HIGH NOTE, SOTY!!

[@nothinkokshorts]

@@cc.l7058 Stop distorting! Why is your country always distorting everything? Your country is not that great.😂

[@cc.l7058]

@@nothinkokshortssearch the internet for the word “团扇” （Chinese round fan）. There are many Chinese relics & products. Korea doesn’t have this type of fan🙃

[@cc.l7058]

⁠@@nothinkokshorts search the difference between Chinese fan and Korean fan & stop distorting.

[@michaeljamesvedeja2602]

@@cc.l7058 Geth out of the West Philippine Sea then. If your country wants to be respected, then respect other countries as well.

[@JonDaCat02]

@@nothinkokshorts may i ask what they said?

[@wonnie_47]

promised dive's that we will support ive next year 2025

[@행이-l5d]

이번컨셉은 진짜 대박이다.. 한복하고 분위기가 미침

[@user-fv3cg3rz5v]

한복하고는 뭔말임

[@Llsx-102]

@@user-fv3cg3rz5v 문맥을 못 읽으시나요... 한복이랑 분위기가 미쳤다고 하는겁니다... 사이에 있는 '고' 가 영어로 and 에요.

[@Dx_a20137]

진짜 스타쉽 일 잘하네👍

[@토토맘-e1r]

​@@user-fv3cg3rz5v'한복' 하고 '분위기'가 좋다는거 같아여

[@kevint-bq3sg]

正しく読むと、ここに中国の馬面スカートがあります。

[@透-y3w]

最近kpopのほとんどは英語パートが半分を占めてたりしてたからほぼ韓国語で歌ってくれるiveちゃん達好き

[@zeroh3049]

Its ksteal music bro😂

[@abcdefg1223]

@@zeroh3049cao ni mao

[@pg1863]

​@@zeroh3049true, korea only know to steal😂😂

[@0208-v5k]

@@zeroh3049 a jealous Chinese😂😂😂😂

[@user-heeyu4heeyu]

​@@0208-v5kthat's right

[@bindhuprasadh4705]

things i am obsessed with in the song: rei's rap at the beginning (it sounds so cool,it is literally on fire) wonyoung's pre-chorus(it sounds very addictive for some reasons,her vocals sounds heavenly in it) Liz's vocals (she is the main vocalist for a reason) gaeul's part(i am obsessed with all of her parts,wish she had more parts) lesseo's cuteness (her visuals are on another level,like c'mon,she is so pretty) yujin's vocals (her vocals are angelic,i am obsessed with it)

[@mirajin415]

Leeseo's rap got me gasped i think best rap parts 1:28

[@LiD0349]

Best girl group when it comes to EVERY. SINGLE. MEMBER being highly vocally strong. Not even some of the most popular groups have this level of al rounders ( Aespa, Girls Gen, Blackpink, 2NE1, twice etc. not hate on any of the groups mentioned. Obviously we have talented vocalists in these groups, but not EVERY single member is gifted vocally)

[@sameage_yujin]

This concept is really crazy!! Let's find the glory of "I AM" and "LOVE DIVE" with HEYA!!

[@oOohio]

IKR I LOVE IT SO MUCH

[@Im_humanxd]

ITS SO GOOD!!

[@Badbadbaddie]

Yes, hope the impact is as good as the MV. This album is dope, and we still have Accendio released, IVE deserved all the good things.

[@theplanewonyoungcrashedon]

Wonyoung said it’s like love dive 2.0 so it’s SOTY for sure

[@Mystical-100]

​​@@theplanewonyoungcrashedon Actually, Wony said accendio reminded her of love dive 😅

[@whkdld]

완전 한국풍 마법소녀느낌이네 ㅠㅠ 갓기들 사랑해

[@재현-l6f]

@@cc.l7058r u chinese?

[@pfmromla]

한국풍 마법소녀... 딱이다

[@김희애-e7h]

근데 컨셉이 완전 중국 문화인데

[@rkim5102]

​@@김희애-e7h Chinese culture? Did you get rid of all of them during the Cultural Revolution?

[@김희애-e7h]

@@rkim5102 너 엄마 없지?

[@Aridivay_0]

High note from Yujin, Liz with purple and pink hair, Rei and Lesseo rap, Wonyoung and Liz in the pre-chorus... THAT'S PERFECT

[@JonDaCat02]

and gaeul....?

[@Aridivay_0]

@@JonDaCat02 she's WONDERFUL

[@nurl____]

​@@JonDaCat02 and Gaeul center for the last chorus 🔥🔥

[@polyavpole_pollen]

this comment shows the essence of the comeback they forgot about Gaeul

[@石一-c1o]

“IVE （아이브）新歌MV抄袭中国文化视频对比丨IVE's MV plagiarized Chinese cultural history” 不要翻译直接搜索词条 ”ive's heya and the recent appropriation of Chinese culture” 不要翻译直接搜索词条IVE MV抄袭证据，IVE说是韩国风

[@なーちま]

まじ日本で1番好きなアイドルグループだよ。最高。

[@엄지윤-n2w]

레이 도입부는 늘 그렇든 걍 개간지고 장원영은 한국어파트가 많아서 좋고ㅣ 리즈는 걍 개레전드로 돌아왔고 유진이는 하이라이트부분을 강조해서 부르는듯한 느낌이 좋고 이서는 자기 보이스랑 잘맞는 파트 줘서 특유의 그 쫀득한 발음이 잘 돋보이는 듯 그리고 가을은 걍 개미침. 가을선배라는 별명이 왜 나왔는지 알것같음. 누워있는데 볼살이 없음..

[@요조요조-h9b]

이 곡이랑 지금보니까 아이브의 컨셉이 제일 잘어울리는 것 같다는 생각이 든다 분위기가 너무 몽환적이고 잔뜩 취해있는느낌이 든다.. 보라색 컨셉 너무 예쁘다 특히 각자 파트분배가 너무 잘되었다 각자 어울리는 가사의 파트만 제공받아서 적절히 조화와 완벽한 하모니가 이루어졌다 그리고 뮤직비디오가 딱 아이브 본모습 그대로가 담긴 것 같아서 너무 예쁘다. 아이브랑 찰떡이다 특히 일레븐 감독님이 비주얼아트하셔서그런가 색조합이 진짜 맛있다 약간 과일청먹는기분이야

[@cynthia9551]

@@美女-r9eFinally somebody who knows that this is CHINESE STYLE not what they call “Korean Style” ！謝謝所有堅持抵制Ive偷文化的人，祝五偷一小偷團早日解散

[@나오미-n5o]

​@@美女-r9e뭐라는 거야

[@ss-vf3mo]

표현력 미쳤다. 어케 이렇게 맛있게 표현하냐

[@junkaywife]

ㄹㅇ과일청

[@홍성호대표]

@@요조요조-h9b 홍성호 도지사

[@emjey724]

WONYOUNG'S PRE-CHORUS CHANGED MY LIFE AAA😭😭💗

[@IrishaineLibre-je7sg]

STREAM HEYA FOR A BETTER LIFE IN MUSIC 🎶

[@yourfuture5307]

​@@선혜365 Up to them, Don't force them lol. Wonyoung just got her attention.

[@sharmithakur4160]

​@@선혜365are you blind most of the comments parise Liz yunjin and lesso or rei

[@markybaby]

@@선혜365if you actually went through the time to read the comments instead of scanning for anything that says wonyoung you would see most of the comments aren’t even about wonyoung

[@sharmithakur4160]

​@@선혜365 you are just a jealous af 😅 When your favs get praised it's fine they deserve it But when wonyoung get praise it's favouritism overrated ....owo what a fair judgment 👏👏

[@noahfan2719]

happy to see they won music video of the year at this year’s MMAs! absolutely deserved, this whole MV is audiovisual bliss. only MVs this year that i could even consider reasonable competition for this one are red velvet’s cosmic, stayc’s gpt, loossemble’s ttyl, and artms’s birth.

[@Melody-bt4wz]

I'm absolutely in LOVE with the song! Wonyoung pre-chorus and rei and gaeul rap is SO GOOD.

[@nvnos]

OKAY WONYOUNG'S PRE-CHORUS IS SO GOOD. I LOVE HER VOCAL TONE

[@cc.l7058]

The fan in 0:13 0:16 0:18 0:19 1:34 1:36 is a traditional Chinese style fan, not Korean fan. Korean fan don’t look like this. Hope everyone won’t be misunderstood. Thx

[@lukaslourd]

​@@cc.l7058But nobody asked

[@류규]

​@@cc.l7058한국이 많이 질투나시죠? 우리 문화가 잘 보존되긴 했습니다😊 조회수 올려줘서 땡큐~🎉❤😢 Are you jealous of Korea? Our culture was well preserved. 😊 Thank you for raising the number of views~I hope you enjoy Korean culture in this music video~🥰

[@반이-w9f]

​@@cc.l7058That fan is in the style of a 15th-century Korean female artist. Her name is Shin In-sun.

[@반이-w9f]

​@@cc.l7058The Chinese claim that all cultures in the world belong to China. The Korean culture of the music video also claims to have come from China. I think these Chinese people have no dignity So I'll write about Korean culture in the music video The pictures of tigers and clouds in the music video have been drawn by commoners in Korea since the 14th century. (Minhwa) Women's accessories have been worn by Korean women since the 15th century. (Norigae) The hat on the head is part of a dance costume made by a Korean dancer in the 19th century. (Seungmu) Chinese people who covet other people's culture!! I'll give you a quiz. Do you know where women's accessories are worn in this music video?? Jewelry patterns have meaning. Do you know the meaning? Chinese people don't know much because many things in this music video are Korean culture Cultural looters Chinese!!! The Chinese claim that all cultures in the world originated in China. But the Chinese don't know the details of the culture. They don't even have a basis for their claims. They just make their own claims. Chinese people!! If you want your culture to be respected, respect the culture of other countries, too

[@_tk2]

와.. 이런 한국풍 노래는 도 처음인 것 같고 진짜 세련된 느낌이 가득합니다 ㅠㅠ...짱이브

[@中国人是大韩民国的奴]

​@@sbnxem8059중국문화자체가 한반도에서 파생된거라 한국풍이라해도됨 ㅋㅋ

[@건너건너집토토로]

​@@sbnxem8059중국인이세요?

[@jaaminiii]

@@sbnxem8059중국인이 한국어도 배우고 기특하네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@jaaminiii]

⁠@@sbnxem8059누가 봐도 한국풍인데???

[@류청이입니다]

이거 중국풍 인대...😅제가 대만사람

[@dzariendm4070]

who is eager waiting January comeback?

[@bbc93510]

아이브 같은 메이저 그룹이 이런 시도를 해줘서 고마울따름

[@소윤-r6w]

맞아요 그리고 연령층이 어린데 아이들이 한국문화에 대해서 더 알게될거고 좋음

[@CHOCONUVO]

걍 안무 좋다 컨셉 좋다 음색 좋다 매력적이다 이러면 그런가 보다 하는데 너무 억빠라 토쏠린다

[@생각없음-m3t]

그냥 망했단소리잖아

[@handle9657]

대댓글들 개한심; 성적 비교적 쉽게 나오는 이지리스닝이 돌판 휩쓸고있는데 거기에서 혼자 3세대 느낌나는 곡 들고오기가 쉬운줄아나... 이게 이해가 안되는거면 걍 안티인거거나 지능부족임ㅋㅋ

[@소윤-r6w]

@@handle9657 ㅇㅈ

[@yeonzonza5737]

단숨에 귀에 꽂히는 '해야 해야 해야' 후크송이군... 난 이게 영어가 아니라서 맘에 든다. 아주 맘에 드는 전통과 현대 음률의 퓨전이야...

[@Ilovehetero]

한국풍 퓨전한 게 너무 멋진 것 같아요!!

[@김혜인-d1z1h]

저도요

[@chechefo]

장원영...리즈... 미쳤는데??? 홀려버림

[@lil-l4f]

개구려

[@clffld]

​@@lil-l4f조선족 ㄷㄷ

[@chaerzyy_]

THE WAY IT STARTED WITH REIS RAP THEN WENT TO LIZS VOCAL LINE IS ABSOLUTE HEAVEN. THEY ATE THIS COMEBACK SO HARD

[@sherllymisseshim]

YESS MAIN RAPPER AND VOCAL

[@chaerzyy_]

@@sherllymisseshim FRFR

[@용띠해통일장]

굿ㆍ❤좋아요😂😂🎉🎉😊

[@石一-c1o]

你肯定不会想到，里面的MV元素大多是抄袭中国的传统文化，他们还会说这是韩国风~

[@user-gdthhrdchr]

​@@石一-c1o 만물 중국 기원설: 타국의 문화를 두고 중국에서 기원했다고 주장하는 것. 만물중국설, 중국기원설이라고도 한다. 중국 공산당과 중국 네티즌 및 미디어가 다른나라의 문화유산을 전부 중국거라고 우기는 국수주의 사이비 역사 현상과 문화적 전유를 의미한다

[@123Jeong]

💟💟💟 Deserves 100M already💟💟💟

[@SolehUdang-r5x]

let's dive to make it happen🤘

[@맥문희주문희용]

멤버 개인별로 다 훅 준게 너무 좋음 ㅜㅜㅜㅜ 얘네는 항상 틀을깨고 진짜 자기방식대로 가는 듯. 아이브만의 고유성이 너무 좋음

[@石一-c1o]

“IVE （아이브）新歌MV抄袭中国文化视频对比丨IVE's MV plagiarized Chinese cultural history” 不要翻译直接搜索词条 ”ive's heya and the recent appropriation of Chinese culture” 不要翻译直接搜索词条IVE MV抄袭证据，IVE说是韩国风

[@Ioi5754-q6m]

​@@石一-c1o 유튜브도 안되는 나라 중국에서 vpn으로 우회접속까지 하면서 한국을 훔쳐보고, 문화를 훔치고, 왜곡하고 댓글 테러를 하고 다니네요. 불쌍한 중귝

[@이재용딸]

​@@石一-c1oThere's no such thing as Chinese culture, lol. Remember the Cultural Revolution.

[@TarotASMRcloud]

WHY IS NO ONE TALKING ABOUT LIZ’S VISUALS?? SHE IS A GODDESS HERE I LOVE HER SO MUCH LAVENDER HAIR MIGHT BE MY FAVORITE 💜🦄👾

[@slay427]

This hair brings out her features even more she is so beautiful

[@Wenas2005]

Berbagi wenas rekaputri @rekaputri

[@Wenas2005]

​@@slay427@wenas2005 , @aqiss and family

[@LelouchXayanokoji14]

who is the girl with short black hair?

[@gjenkn9]

@@LelouchXayanokoji14 yujin

[@닉네임할거없다-p2t]

진짜 개미쳤다...노래도 그렇고 영상미, 모든 스타일 23년 24년 본 뮤비 중에 제일 크리에이티브하다

[@8io1]

@@cc.l7058点了

[@jingyichen3936]

Not creative but stealing Chinese culture

[@shoppinglee]

yes， because concept is steal Chinese stuff, 中国结🪢hanging on their ears😂

[@jjj2-hr7xn]

Ive와 스타쉽이 중국을 도와 중국 전통 미술 문화를 홍보해 주셔서 감사합니다. mv 전체가 중국 문화로 가득 차 있다는 것을 한눈에 알 수 있을 줄은 몰랐습 니다. 그 중에서도 후루와 등 중국 미술 영화에 경의 를 표하는 산수상운이 비교적 뛰어납니다! 중국 매 듭의 운용도 예쁘고 머리 장식이 예쁘네요!

[@옹뇽뇽-j9c]

@@jjj2-hr7xn-찐-

[@llmaoleo]

they definitely deserved to win the award for best music video at mma this year

[@rescene_0326]

내가 아이브를 좋아하는 이유가 이렇게 아이엠처럼 비슷한 멜로디를 조금씩 변형시켜서 후렴까지 끌고 가는데 그걸 너무 맛깔나게 소화해줌 .. 아이브 사랑해 ..

[@그린라잇]

좋아요 수가 365인데 365일 계속 좋아하다는 거죠!ㅋㅋ저도용 !!💬😍⭐️💗🐰

[@rescene_0326]

@@그린라잇 헉 그렇네요 !! 센스 짱ㅇ ㅎㅎ

[@ak_chan5656]

IVEがKpopらしさとIVEらしい高貴さを守ってくれていることを嬉しく思うよ😢

[@DBDLHHLYXPD]

Chinese traditional culture it is

[@kakap7909]

Thanks to ive and Starship for helping China promote traditional Chinese art culture, I didn't realize that the whole MV is full of Chinese culture at a glance, which pays homage to Chinese art movies such as Huluwa and other landscapes and auspicious clouds are more outstanding! The use of Chinese knots is also very nice, when the headdress is very beautiful!

[@陈洛洋]

ive와 Starship이 중국을 도와 중국 전통 예술 문화를 고양하는 데 감사드립니다. 뜻밖에도 전체 뮤직비디오는 보자마자 중국 문화로 가득 차 있습니다. 중국 예술 영화, 예를 들면 후루와 등 산수상운에 더 많은 걸출한 경의를 표합니다!중국 매듭의 운용도 매우 보기 좋고, 머리 장식으로 매우 아름답다!

[@jirued3705]

I love this impact

[@TAKY-fw8ve]

Why don't Koreans dare to include such excellent and beautiful culture when applying for the Expo? Not gonna lose because of 29 votes...Lol

[@찬우박-p8x]

솔직히 이번건 미쳤다는 표현보다 쎈 표현을 찾고싶을 정도다...니들이 짱 먹어라!!! 진짜 근 10년내 뮤비 중 최고이고 노래도 엄청나다...신선하고 충격적이고 미쳤다 그냥

[@셀렉트-z1t]

노래는 모르겠는데 아이브 비주얼은 역대 최고임

[@yaakosro2326]

That's not Korean culture，that's Chinese culture. Watching China and engaging in cultural appropriation is almost every day, either stealing Chinese festivals or elements. Even movies and TV shows have to plagiarize China, abandoning ur own Korean culture and promoting sinicization. Why do you want to become Chinese so much? Do you want to become a cultural dependent country like this?

[@user_34w322djdd]

리즈퍼트 많아서 좋네 노래는 잘하는 애가 해야지

[@xin4586]

That's what we call stealing👍🏻now you got it,congratulations🎉🎉🎉

[@스스마마스스마마]

​@@xin4586중국은 한국문화가 금지되어있습니다. 나가주세요

[@w__9up]

VOTE IVE ON MAMA VOTE IVE ON MAMA VOTE IVE ON MAMA VOTE IVE ON MAMA VOTE IVE ON MAMA VOTE IVE ON MAMA VOTE IVE ON MAMA VOTE IVE ON MAMA

[@Ivedive02]

Yaa

[@wishplaylist79]

리즈 음색에 맞는 파트 많이 가져간 거 같아서 너무 좋음.. 멤버들 비주얼도 더 이뻐진 거 같음

[@당근콜리]

맞아요 ❤

[@kevinlee6439]

레이는 완전 카리스마 넘치고 원영이 음색 미쳤고 압도적 포스 폼 레전드다ㄷㄷㄷ

[@bindhuprasadh4705]

Liz's voice is heavenly,rei's rap is on another level,wonyoung sounds so good in the pre-chorus, yujin's vocals are so good,lesseo is too cute to look at and gaeul's parts are very addictive even though they are very less!

[@Blebmon]

3 Wonderful Years with IVE, I hope to continue with IVE for much longer, please IVE exceed 7 years as a group 💕💎

[@unidentifiable.individual]

The vocal line killed this! Liz, Yujin and Wonyoung always outdo themselves! And not Leeseo officially joining the rap line.

[@steste4168]

SOTY

[@pg1863]

K steal music👏

[@ClubPuguin]

But they didn't steal this hit!

[@Yousofatube]

Do you know what “officially” means It means having an official positions, and Leeseo isn’t an official rapper

[@石一-c1o]

“IVE （아이브）新歌MV抄袭中国文化视频对比丨IVE's MV plagiarized Chinese cultural history” 不要翻译直接搜索词条 ”ive's heya and the recent appropriation of Chinese culture” 不要翻译直接搜索词条IVE MV抄袭证据

[@GOATfox5]

Leeseo turning into a maknace fr. Rap 10/10. She really owned this era!

[@cheeseo8418]

Ikrrr! Our talented maknae, liz and leeseo owned this era so bad, but they all slayed i swear

[@石一-c1o]

“IVE （아이브）新歌MV抄袭中国文化视频对比丨IVE's MV plagiarized Chinese cultural history” 不要翻译直接搜索词条 ”ive's heya and the recent appropriation of Chinese culture” 不要翻译直接搜索词条IVE MV抄袭证据

[@Ioi5754-q6m]

​@@石一-c1o 유튜브도 안되는 나라 중국에서 vpn으로 우회접속까지 하면서 한국을 훔쳐보고, 문화를 훔치고, 왜곡하고 댓글 테러를 하고 다니네요. 불쌍한 중국인들.

[@Jjjjjjjjj-er6nt]

@@石一-c1o 중국인들이 vpn으로 우회접속까지 하면서 한국을 훔쳐보고, 조직적으로 문화를 훔치고, 왜곡하고 댓글 테러를 자행하고 있습니다. 자칭 대국이라는 나라의 수준이 찻잔보다 작습니다.

[@GOATfox5]

@@石一-c1o thank you so much for letting me know! China is a great nation and deserves to be recognized! I am especially thankful for their culture of eating bats and giving the entire world the corona virus! 🙏🙏🙏

[@iBrunoCosta]

WONYOUNG PRE CHORUS, REI RAP, YUJIN BOSS ATITUDE, GAEUL AURA, LESSEO VISUALS, LIZ VOCALS, IVE IS ON ANOTHER LEVEL

[@石一-c1o]

“IVE （아이브）新歌MV抄袭中国文化视频对比丨IVE's MV plagiarized Chinese cultural history” 不要翻译直接搜索词条 ”ive's heya and the recent appropriation of Chinese culture” 不要翻译直接搜索词条IVE MV抄袭证据，IVE说是韩国风1

[@Ioi5754-q6m]

​@@石一-c1o 유튜브도 안되는 나라 중국에서 vpn으로 우회접속까지 하면서 한국을 훔쳐보고, 문화를 훔치고, 왜곡하고 댓글 테러를 하고 다니네요. 불쌍한 중국인들.

[@Jjjjjjjjj-er6nt]

@@石一-c1o 중국인 수준 : 문화 훔치기, 댓글 조작, 테러

[@pgx-q8hsk]

한국 문화를 잘 살린 뮤직비디오 너무 예쁘다❤

[@xyWu-e7q]

？

[@unkle.k]

​@@xyWu-e7qYou look very Chinese.

[@unkle.k]

@zzmy-l3m 아니 중국인 보고 중국인처럼 생겨서 중국인 같다고 하는데 왜 중국인이 물음표를 답니까? 왜 중국인처럼 생겼다는 말이 싫어요?

[@unkle.k]

중국 전통 APT건축은 최소 3000년 이상의 역사를 자랑하며, 중국 전역에서 다양한 형태로 발전해 왔습니다. 그중에서도 Rose 형태가 가장 대표적인 유형으로 꼽히며, 주로 베이징 지역에서 흔히 볼 수 있습니다.

[@ricardo8252]

THIS IS DEFINITELY LIZ'S ERA. They finally know LIZ's vocal worth. Her vocals are EVERYTHING.

[@yougetoutfromhere]

You forget IAM babe

[@石一-c1o]

“IVE （아이브）新歌MV抄袭中国文化视频对比丨IVE's MV plagiarized Chinese cultural history” 不要翻译直接搜索词条 ”ive's heya and the recent appropriation of Chinese culture” 不要翻译直接搜索词条IVE MV抄袭证据

[@Ioi5754-q6m]

​@@石一-c1o 유튜브도 안되는 나라 중국에서 vpn으로 우회접속까지 하면서 한국을 훔쳐보고, 문화를 훔치고, 왜곡하고 댓글 테러를 하고 다니네요. 불쌍한 중국인들.